Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No.06 of 2025
----1. The State of Jharkhand.
2. The Principal Secretary, Department of Rural Works,
Government of Jharkhand, Project Bhawan, Dhurwa, Ranchi.
3. The Chief Engineer, Department of Rural Works, Government
of Jharkhand, Project Bhawan, Dhurwa, Ranchi.
4. The Superintending Engineer, Department of Rural Works,
P.O., P.S. & District Dumka.
5. The Executive Engineer, Department of Rural Works, P.O.,
P.S. & District Dumka.
.......... Appellants.
-Versus1. Tarkeshwar Prasad Singh, son of Late Laxman Singh, resident
of Shivpahar, P.O. & P.S. Dumka, District Dumka.
2. The Accountant General (A&E), Jharkhand, Ranchi.
.......... Respondents.
----CORAM :
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
----For the Appellants :
Mr. Ashok Kr. Yadav, Sr. SC-I
Mr. Aditya Kumar, AC to Sr. SC-I
For the Res. No.1 :
Mr. Shrestha Gautam, Advocate
For the Res. No.2 :
Mrs. Richa Sanchita, Advocate
----Reserved on 10.08.2026
Pronounced on 19.08.2026
Per: Rajesh Shankar, J.
1.
The present Letters Patent Appeal is directed against the learned
Single Judge’s judgment/order dated 31.07.2024 passed in
W.P.(S) No. 3005 of 2016, whereby the writ petition filed by the
1st respondent (original writ petitioner) has been allowed by
setting aside the reasoned order as contained in memo no.282
dated 21.04.2016 as well as the office order as contained in
memo
no.283
dated
21.04.2016,
both,
passed
by
the
Superintending Engineer, Rural Development Department (Rural
Works Affairs) Work Circle, Dumka (the appellant no.4 herein),
directing recovery of excess payment made to the 1st respondent
after cancelling all the promotions granted to him. The appellants
have further been directed by the learned single Judge not to
recover any amount from the 1st respondent as well as not to
register FIR against him. It has also been directed to release
entire retiral benefits in favour of the 1st respondent within a
period of six weeks from the date of passing of the order.
2.
The facts of the case as emanating from the writ petition is that
the 1st respondent was appointed on the post of ‘Tracer’ by an
order of the Superintending Engineer, Rural Engineering
Organization, Works Circle, Bhagalpur vide letter no.108 dated
13.01.1975 and, accordingly, he joined the said post on
14.01.1975. Subsequently, he was provisionally promoted on the
vacant post of Junior Accounts Clerk vide order as contained in
memo no.295 dated 11.02.1980 issued by the Superintending
Engineer,
Rural
Engineering
Organization,
Works
Circle,
Bhagalpur.
3.
However, vide order as contained in letter no.6076 dated
16.11.1985, a direction was issued by the Chief Engineer, Rural
Engineering Organization, Department of Road Construction,
Government of Bihar, Patna to the effect that one Radha Harijan,
‘Treasure Keeper’ be promoted to the post of ‘Junior Accounts
Clerk’ and if the said post was already filled up by any person
belonging to the category of non-scheduled caste, then the said
person be reverted or removed for promoting said Radha Harijan.
4.
Thereafter, the 1st respondent was reverted to the post of ‘Tracer’
vide office order as contained in memo no.214 dated 20.01.1986.
However, the Chief Engineer, Department of Rural Works,
Chhotanagpur Sub-division, Ranchi recalled the earlier order
dated 16.11.1985 vide letter no.113 dated 05.05.1987 and,
thereafter, the 1st respondent was restored to the post of ‘Junior
Accounts Clerk’ with effect from 11.02.1980. Subsequently, his
appointment on the said post was made permanent vide office
order as contained in memo no.476 dated 20.05.1987. He was
also granted 1st and 2nd ACP with effect from 09.08.1999 and
11.02.2004, respectively.
5.
The 1st respondent was put to suspension vide letter no.239
dated 04.03.2011 and was issued chargesheet vide memo no.
363 dated 02.04.2011 wherein altogether 14 charges were
framed against him including the charge of illegally holding the
post of Accounts Clerk and drawing salary for the said post.
Thereafter, departmental enquiry was initiated against the 1st
respondent in which some of the charges were proved against
him and vide office order as contained in Memo No.2006 dated
20.10.2011 issued under the signature of the Chief Engineer,
Department of Rural Works, Government of Jharkhand (appellant
no.3 herein) he was imposed punishment of censure and
stoppage of two increments without cumulative effect.
6.
The appellant no.2, vide office order no.92 bearing memo
no.1623 dated 11.07.2013 took a decision to lodge an
F.I.R. against the 1st respondent which resulted in institution of
Jamtara P.S. Case No.337 of 2013 and Dumka P.S Case No. 220
of 2014.
7.
The 1st respondent superannuated from service on 31.07.2013
and thereafter a writ petition being W.P.(S) No. 6109 of 2013 was
filed by him, seeking post retiral dues and other arrears of salary
including the benefit of 3rd MACP. The said writ petition was
disposed of vide order dated 11.11.2013 directing the 1st
respondent to file a fresh representation before the appellant
no.3 for redressal of his grievances, who, in turn, was also
directed to take an informed decision on the representation of the
1st respondent in accordance with law after due verification of his
service records.
8.
Thereafter, the 1st respondent filed Contempt Case (Civil) No.152
of 2014, alleging non-compliance of the order dated 11.11.2013
and during pendency of the said case, the appellant no.4 passed
a reasoned order as contained in Memo No.282 dated 21.04.2016
taking decision to revive the order as contained in letter no.214
dated 20.01.1986 issued by the Superintending Engineer, Rural
Engineering
Organization,
Works
Circle,
Bhagalpur
and,
accordingly, to recover excess payment of salary made to the 1st
respondent over and above the salary received with respect to
the original post of ‘Tracer’. On the same date i.e. 21.04.2016,
the appellant no.4 also issued the office order as contained in
memo no.283 whereby all the promotions given to the 1st
respondent were cancelled and the excess payment made to him
over and above the salary received with respect to the original
post of ‘Tracer’ was directed to be recovered.
9.
The 1st respondent then filed another writ petition being W.P.(S)
No.3005 of 2016 which was allowed vide order dated 31.07.2024
(impugned herein), whereby the reasoned order as contained in
memo nos.282 and the office order bearing memo no.283, both,
dated 21.04.2016 passed by the appellant no.4 were set aside,
directing the appellants not to recover any amount from the 1st
respondent. It was further directed that no FIR would be lodged
against the 1st respondent and his entire retiral benefits must be
released in his favour within a period of six weeks from the date
of passing of the order, failing which, the department would be
liable to pay penal interest @ 7% per annum from the date of
receipt of the said order.
10. The learned counsel for the appellants submits that the learned
Single Judge has failed to appreciate the fact that the 1st
respondent was wrongfully promoted on non-cadre post of
Junior Accounts Clerk without following due procedure of law.
The said post was reserved for the candidate belonging to
Scheduled Caste but due to fraud and misrepresentation on the
part of the 1st respondent, he continued on the said post despite
reversion to the post of ‘Tracer’.
11. It is further submitted that illegal promotion of the 1st respondent
from the post of ‘Tracer’ to ‘Junior Accounts Clerk’ was kept in
abeyance vide Order no.257 dated 25.08.1987 issued by the
Reservation Commissioner-Cum-Principal
Secretary,
Cabinet
Secretariat, Government of Bihar, Patna. Despite that the 1st
respondent continued to hold the post of ‘Accounts Clerk’ without
any authority of law and as such the order of recovery regarding
excess payment made to him was legal and justified which has
erroneously been quashed by the learned Single Judge vide
impugned order dated 31.07.2024.
12. It is also submitted that vide letter no.177 dated 26.07.1989 of
the Joint Secretary to the Government, Department of Personnel
and Administrative Reforms, Government of Bihar, the order
dated 25.08.1987 was recalled. The said letter dated 26.07.1989
was, in fact, found to be fake and suspicious by the departmental
committee constituted under the Chairmanship of the Engineerin-Chief. Such fact was mentioned in the office order no.92
bearing memo no.1623 dated 11.07.2013 issued by the appellant
no.2 and, therefore, the promotion given to the 1st respondent
from the post of ‘Tracer’ to ‘Junior Accounts Clerk’ was declared
nullity vide order bearing memo no.283 dated 21.04.2016. The
said crucial aspect of the matter has not been duly appreciated
by the learned single Judge while passing the impugned
judgment/order.
13. It is contended that no prayer was made in the writ petition for
declaring the registration of F.I.R as illegal and as such the
learned Single Judge has exceeded its jurisdiction while issuing
direction not to register F.I.R. against the 1st respondent.
14. It is further argued that the 1st respondent had used forged
and fabricated document to unlawfully get promotion to the post
of Junior Accounts Clerk and had also got salary for the said post.
As such the 1st respondent was rightly reverted to his original post
of ‘Tracer’ and, consequently, the order for recovery of excess
payment of salary made to the 1st respondent was passed vide
memo no.283 dated 21.04.2016.
15. It is also urged that the learned Single Judge has not given any
finding with
respect
to
the
fraud
and
misrepresentation
committed by the 1st respondent in getting promotion to the post
of ‘Junior Accounts Clerk’.
16. On the contrary, the learned counsel for the 1st respondent
submits that the action of the appellants in cancelling the
promotion given to the 1st respondent in the year 1980 and
issuing the order for recovery of excess payment of salary
allegedly made to him after more than 35 years of service that
too without any notice, hearing or proceedings, is contrary to law.
As such, the learned Single Judge has rightly passed the
impugned judgment/order order dated 31.07.2016 and the same
needs no interference of this Court.
17. It is further submitted that after retirement of a State
Government employee, recovery of the paid amount can only be
made by following the procedure prescribed under rule 43(b) of
the Jharkhand Pension Rules, 2000, however, no such procedure
was followed while issuing the order for recovery of excess
amount allegedly paid to the 1st respondent.
18. It is also submitted that the departmental proceeding for the
similar charge was initiated against the 1st respondent in which
the punishment of censure and stoppage of two increments
without cumulative effect was imposed upon him. As such, the
second set of penalty for the similar charge is hit by the principle
of double jeopardy.
19. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
materials available on record.
20. The learned counsel for the appellants has put much emphasis to
the argument that the 1st respondent was illegally granted
promotion to the post of ‘Junior Accounts Clerk’ as the said post
was reserved for the Scheduled Caste candidate and also that the
1st respondent continued to hold the said post by committing
fraud and misrepresentation. As such, the same was rightly
cancelled and payment of excess salary made to the 1st
respondent over and above the salary admissible to the post of
‘Tracer’ was directed to be recovered from him.
21. It
transpires
from the
record
that
the
1st
respondent
superannuated from service on 31.07.2013 and on the said date,
no departmental proceeding was pending against him with
respect to the allegation of illegally holding the post of ‘Junior
Accounts Clerk’ and drawing salary attached to the said post.
During his service tenure, a memo of charge in ‘Prapatra-Ka’ was
issued to him by the appellant no. 4 vide letter as contained in
memo no.363 dated 02.04.2011 wherein one of the charges
against him was of illegally holding the post of ‘Junior Accounts
Clerk’ and getting the salary thereof. Moreover, a full-fledged
departmental proceeding with respect to the charges framed
against him was initiated against the 1st respondent wherein one
Tarini
Prasad
Mandal,
Technical
Advisor,
Rural
Works
Department, Works Circle, Dumka was appointed as Conducting
Officer. After inquiry, some of the charges were found proved
against him for which he was imposed punishment of censure
and stoppage of two annual increments without cumulative
effect.
22. Rule 43(b) of the Jharkhand Pension Rules, 2000 provides that
the State Government has the power to withhold or withdraw
pension or any part of it when the pensioner is found to be guilty
of grave misconduct either in a departmental proceeding or a
judicial proceeding. The State Government has also the right to
recover the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused to the
Government from pension of the concerned pensioner, if such
loss is caused to the government by misconduct or negligence
during his service tenure including the service rendered by him
on reemployment after retirement.
23. The proviso of rule 43(b) deals with certain pre-conditions for
initiation of departmental proceedings and the period of limitation
within which such proceedings can be initiated. It provides that if
departmental
proceeding
was
not
instituted
while
the
government servant was on duty either before retirement or
during re-employment, the same shall be instituted only with the
sanction of the State Government that too for an event which
took place not more than four years before the institution of such
proceeding. It further provides that such proceeding shall be
conducted by the enquiry officer in accordance with the
procedure applicable to a proceeding on which an order of
dismissal from service may be made. It also adds that
departmental proceeding shall be deemed to have been instituted
when the charges framed against the pensioner are issued to him
or with effect from an earlier date, if the government servant has
been placed under suspension on such date.
24. Thus, there is a mechanism provided under the Jharkhand
Pension Rules, 2000 for recovery of any amount from the pension
of a retired government servant. The recovery of any amount
from pension is permissible only when a finding is recorded either
in departmental inquiry or judicial proceeding that an employee
had committed grave misconduct in the discharge of his duty
while in his office. However, in the case in hand, there is no
finding either in departmental proceeding or in judicial proceeding
that the 1st respondent was guilty of illegally holding the post of
‘Junior Accounts Clerk’. The appellants, rather straightway issued
the order of recovery of the alleged excess payment made to the
1st respondent. Though, two FIRs. were lodged against the 1st
respondent, however there is no finding of the competent
criminal court as yet that he was illegally holding the post of
‘Junior Accounts Clerk’.
25. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Punjab &
Others Vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) and Others,
reported in (2015)4 SCC 334, has explained the situations
under which the recovery of excess payment made to an
employee is not permissible under the law. It has been observed,
inter alia, as under: Page 10 of 14
“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship
which would govern employees on the issue of recovery,
where payments have mistakenly been made by the
employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may,
based on the decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as
a ready reference, summarise the following few situations,
wherein recoveries by the employers, would be impermissible
in law:
(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III and
Class IV service (or Group C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the employees
who are due to retire within one year, of the order of
recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess payment
has been made for a period in excess of five years, before
the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully
been required to discharge duties of a higher post, and has
been paid accordingly, even though he should have rightfully
been required to work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the
conclusion, that recovery if made from the employee, would
be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an extent, as would
far outweigh the equitable balance of the employer's right to
recover.”
26. In the present case also, the 1st respondent was a Class-III
employee and superannuated from service on 31.07.2013. He
had allegedly been paid excess amount as salary for the post of
Junior Accounts Clerk since 11.02.1980 and the order of recovery
was passed vide office order as contained in memo no.283 dated
21.04.2016. Thus, the order of recovery of excess payment made
to the 1st respondent was passed after more than 36 years. In
view of the aforesaid judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court,
even if it is assumed that certain amount was paid to the 1st
respondent in excess of his entitlement, the same cannot be
recovered from him.
27. The learned counsel for the appellants has assiduously argued
that the law laid down in the case of Rafiq Masih (Supra.) is
applicable only in the cases where the excess amount was
mistakenly paid to an employee, however in the present case,
excess payment of salary was made to the 1st respondent due to
fraud and misrepresentation on his part.
28. We do not find any substance in the said argument. Though the
claim of the appellants is that letter no.177 dated 26.07.1989 said
to have been issued under the signature of the Joint Secretary,
Department
of
Personnel
and
Administrative
Reforms,
Government of Bihar was a forged one, no inquiry was conducted
on factual aspect during the service tenure of the 1st respondent
after providing him due opportunity of hearing. Even after his
retirement, a proceeding under Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 2000 was
not initiated against him. It is a well settled principle of law that
the right to property is a constitutional right under Article 300A
of the Constitution of India and the same cannot be taken away
without due process of law. Thus, a person cannot be deprived
of right to property (salary in this case) for mere allegation of
forgery without any finding of a competent authority/Court of Law
arrived at in a lawful proceeding.
29. Another aspect in the matter is that a full-fledged departmental
enquiry was conducted with respect to the allegation of illegally
holding the post of ‘Junior Accounts Clerk’ and in the said
departmental proceeding, the punishment was already awarded
to the 1st respondent. As such, second punishment for the same
charge certainly attracts the principle of double jeopardy. Article
20(2) of the Constitution of India provides that no person shall
be prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than
once.
30. In the case of Lt. Governor, Delhi & Others Vs. H.C.
Narinder Singh, reported in (2004) 13 SCC 342, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has held that second penalty based on the same
cause of action would amount to double jeopardy.
31. Thus, we do not find any infirmity in the order of the learned
Single Judge whereby the order of recovery of payment made to
the 1st respondent over and above the salary received for the post
of ‘Tracer’ has been quashed and the appellants have been
directed to make payment of entire retiral dues of the 1st
respondent.
32. We, however, wish to observe that the part of impugned order
dated 31.07.2014 whereby the learned Single Judge has directed
not to lodge FIR against the 1st respondent suffers from infirmity
as the same does not precede any reason. There is no law which
precludes the authorities from instituting any FIR against an
employee with respect to any alleged act of criminal culpability
done during his service tenure. Moreover, when an FIR is lodged,
the criminal court provides due opportunity to both the sides to
present evidences. An accused has also the right of hearing
before pronouncement of judgment. As such, by merely lodging
an FIR, no prejudice is caused to an employee. In fact, in the
present case, two FIRs. were already lodged in the year 2013 and
2014 as mentioned in foregoing paragraphs.
33. For the reasons as aforesaid, the direction contained in the
judgment/order dated 31.07.2024 to the extent of not registering
any FIR against the 1st respondent is set aside. Consequently, the
appellants are at liberty to pursue the criminal cases being
Jamtara P.S Case No.337 of 2013 and Dumka P.S Case No.220 of
2014 already lodged against the 1st respondent, if the same are
still pending.
34. This appeal is, accordingly, disposed of in above terms.
35. Pending I.As., if any, are also disposed of.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
19th August, 2026
Sanjay/
A.F.R.
Uploaded on 19.08.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review