Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:9863-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No. 413 of 2025
1. The State of Jharkhand through the Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Jharkhand, officiating at Project Building, H.E.C
Colony, P.O & P.S. Dhurwa, District Ranchi.
2. The Secretary, Water Resources Department, Govt. of
Jharkhand, officiating at Nepal House, P.O & P.S. Doranda,
District Ranchi.
3. The Special Secretary, Water Resources Department,
Govt. of Jharkhand, officiating at Nepal House, P.O & P.S.
Doranda, District Ranchi.
4. The Engineer-in-Chief, Water Resources Department,
Govt. of Jharkhand, officiating at Nepal House, P.O & P.S.
Doranda, District Ranchi.
5. The Joint Secretary, Water Resources Department, Govt.
of Jharkhand, officiating at Nepal House, P.O & P.S.
Doranda, District Ranchi.
6. The Under Secretary, Water Resources Department, Govt.
of Jharkhand, officiating at Nepal House, P.O & P.S.
Doranda, District Ranchi ... … Respondents/Appellants
Versus
1. Sampad Kumar Mahto, S/o Thakur Das Mahto, R/o
Mahavir Colony, Lowadih, P.O Lowadih, P.S. Chutia, District
Ranchi.
2. Bijay Kumar Nirala, S/o Nand Kishor Thakur, Ward No.
24, Officer Colony, Nilkanthpuri, P.O, P.S & District
Deoghar.
3. Abinash Kumar Mishra, S/o Late Surya Kant Mishra,
R/o Bajrang Colony, Pokhara Tiltia, Pandit B N Jha Road,
P.O, P.S & District Deoghar.
4. Vinod Kumar, S/o Babu Lal Sharma, R/o MI Division,
P.O – Sector 12 P.S. Marafari, District Bokaro.
5. Md. Parwez Akhtar, S/o Md. Farooq, Bathua Bajar, P.O
Bathua Bajar, P.S & District Gopalganj, Bihar.
6. Shashi Kant Keshri, S/o Rambriksh Keshri, R/o Near
Hanuman Mandir, Lakarka Colliery No. 9, Akashkanali P.O
Lakarka, P.S and District-Dhanbad
... … Petitioners/Respondents
………..
CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RONGON MUKHOPADHYAY
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
………..
For the Appellants
: Mr. Ashutosh Anand, A.A.G.-III
For the Respondents
: Mr. Manoj Tandon, Advocate
………..
th
Order No. 06/Dated, the 17 March, 2026
Per Rongon Mukhopadhyay, J.
Heard Mr. Ashutosh Anand, learned A.A.G.-III for
the appellants and Mr. Manoj Tandon, learned counsel appearing
for the respondents.
2.
This appeal is directed against the order dated
03.09.2024 passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.(S) No.
5508 of 2023, whereby and whereunder, the order contained in
Memo No. 4190 dated 27.07.2023, by which, the writ-petitioners
were transferred from the present place of posting to the places
shown in the transfer order has been quashed and the writpetitioners who had already joined in the transferred place of
posting were ordered to be reverted back to the places where they
were working prior to the issuance of the impugned order.
3.
Briefly stated the facts reveal that the writ-
petitioners were appointed as Junior Accounts Clerk in the Water
Resources Department and their respective dates of joining
ranges from 12.04.1993 to 21.11.2007. The post of Junior
Accounts Clerk has been renamed as Senior Accounts Clerk vide
letter no. 2388 dated 08.07.2014 and this was confined to those
Junior Accounts Clerk who had joined service till 08.07.2004.
Based on the said resolution the post of writ-petitioners nos. 1 to
5 has been renamed as Senior Accounts Clerk and all are
presently posted as Senior Accounts Clerk. The Jharkhand
Accounts Clerical Service Cadre (Recruitment, Promotion and
Terms of Service) Rule, 2018 (in short, the Rules of 2018) came
into existence vide notification as contained in Memo No. 1745
dated 24.04.2018 formulating rules to regulate the Promotion
and Service Conditions in the Jharkhand Accounts Cadre by
which the Accounts Clerk Cadre has been given the status of
State Cadre. It has been stated that the Joint Secretary, Drinking
Water & Sanitation Department, Govt. of Jharkhand vide office
order as contained in Memo No. 2418 dated 28.10.2020
communicated to all concerned that the Cadre of the writpetitioners and similarly situated persons is now State Cadre
and, therefore, the decision with respect to the transfer of the
said cadre personnel shall be taken by the Departmental
Establishment Committee under the Chairmanship of the
Secretary of the Department. The Secretary, Drinking Water &
Sanitation Department, Govt. of Jharkhand vide office order as
contained
in
Memo
No.
dated
22.12.2020
had
communicated to all concerned about the constitution of the
Departmental
Establishment
Committee
for
transfer
and
appointment of the cadre of the writ-petitioners and similarly
situated persons in the light of the Rules of 2018. The other
necessary authorities were also communicated to follow the
necessary instructions relating to the Departmental Secretary
being the competent authority in terms of the Rules of 2018. It
was the grievance of the writ-petitioners that the writ-petitioners
and other similarly situated persons have been transferred from
their respective offices to different offices / zones by virtue of
Memo No. 4190 dated 27.07.2023 issued by the Under Secretary,
Water Resources Department, Govt. of Jharkhand and this was
challenged in W.P.(S) No. 5508 of 2023, in which, an order was
passed by the learned Single Judge on 03.09.2024 quashing the
said order with a further direction that the writ-petitioners who
had already joined at the transferred place of posting shall be
reverted back to the places where they were working prior to the
issuance of the impugned memo. The order dated 03.09.2024
passed in W.P.(S) No. 5508 of 2023 has been challenged by the
State in the present appeal.
4.
It has been submitted by Mr. Ashutosh Anand,
learned A.A.G.-III that almost all the writ-petitioners have
remained stationary at the same place for more than a decade. It
has been submitted that the learned Single Judge has failed to
take into consideration that the office order dated 24.09.2019
issued by the Water Resources Department related to the power
of transfer of Class-III and Class-IV employees of the Water
Resources Department by which the power of transfer has been
delegated to the Engineer-in-Chief-II. The order dated 03.09.2024
passed in W.P.(S) No. 5508 of 2023 is erroneous for the reason
that the executive order dated 24.09.2019 has been overruled by
the subsequent notification dated 28.10.2020 issued vide Memo
No. 166 by the Drinking Water & Sanitation Department which
prompted the learned Single Judge to quash the order of transfer
without noticing the fact that the Water Resources Department is
a separate department and any order issued by the Drinking
Water & Sanitation Department will not have any bearing or any
binding force upon the Water Resources Department. Mr.
Ashutosh Anand, learned A.A.G.-III has submitted that the
Engineer-in-Chief is the competent authority under the Public
Works Department Code-2012 even in the matter of transfer and
posting of Class-III and Class-IV employees.
5.
Mr. Manoj Tandon, learned counsel appearing for
the respondents herein (writ-petitioners) has submitted that the
learned Single Judge has appreciated the fact that the order of
transfer was not passed by the Departmental Establishment
Committee
under
the
Chairmanship
of
the
Departmental
Secretary and the Engineer-in-Chief was not authorized as there
was no delegation of power upon him by the Departmental
Secretary and the Rules of 2018 also does not provide for any
delegation of power. Mr. Tandon has submitted that as per Memo
No. 879 dated 15.02.2024 with respect to the Accounts Clerk
Cadre which has become a State Level Cadre the competent
authority is the Departmental Secretary and, therefore, the
learned Single Judge has correctly arrived at a finding that the
order of transfer was not issued by the competent authority.
6.
We have heard the learned counsels for the
respective parties and have also perused the various affidavits on
record.
7.
The Jharkhand Accounts Clerical Service Cadre
(Recruitment, Promotion and terms of service conditions) Rules,
2018 was modified vide notification dated 24.04.2018. The
“controlling authority” has been defined in Rule 2 (xi) and the
same designates authorization / declaration of a controlling
authority by the respective departments. Rule 11 states about
posting / transfer and for that purpose the controlling authority
has been designated with such powers. The learned Single Judge
has taken into consideration Memo No. 2418 dated 28.10.2020
issued by the Joint Secretary, Drinking Water & Sanitation
Department while setting aside the transfer of the writ-petitioners
and this resolution categorizes that for the purposes of posting /
transfer of the Accounts Clerical Cadre, it is the Departmental
Establishment Committee headed by the Departmental Secretary
which is the competent authority. This resolution according to
learned A.A.G.-III will not be applicable to the writ-petitioners
since the same was issued by the Drinking Water & Sanitation
Department and not by the Water Resources Department to
which the writ-petitioners belonged. When we peruse the order of
transfer dated 27.07.2023, we find that the same has been
issued at the behest of the Engineer-in-Chief-II of the concerned
area. Much prior to the issuance of the transfer order dated
27.07.2023 an order as contained in Memo No. 879 dated
15.02.2021 was issued by the Under Secretary, Water Resources
Department, Govt. of Jharkhand, in which, it has been
categorically mentioned that all matters pertaining to the Cadre
of Accounts Clerk shall be dealt with at the departmental level
and the competent authority will be the Departmental Secretary.
This communication issued in terms of the Rules of 2018
convincingly answers the eligibility or otherwise of the Engineerin-Chief-II of the concerned department in the matter of posting
and transfer of persons of Accounts Clerk Cadre which has been
raised by the learned A.A.G.-III. The Memo No. 879 dated
15.02.2020 will be an added feature indicating that the Engineerin-Chief-II of the concerned department was not the competent
authority to transfer the writ-petitioners.
8.
In view of the aforesaid findings, we do not find
any reason to interfere in the order dated 03.09.2024 passed by
the learned Single Judge in W.P.(S) No. 5508 of 2023 and
consequently we dismiss this appeal.
9.
Pending Interlocutory Application(s), if any, stands
closed.
(Rongon Mukhopadhyay, J.)
(Pradeep Kumar Srivastava, J.)
Dated, the 17th day of March, 2026
A. Sanga /Uploaded on 07/04/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review