Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No. 540 of 2026
1. The State of Jharkhand through the Secretary, Department of Food,
Public Distribution and Consumer Affairs, having its office at
Project Bhawan, P.O. Dhurwa, P.S. Dhurwa, District Ranchi,
Jharkhand
2. The Deputy Secretary, Department of Food, Public Distribution and
Consumer Affairs, having its office at Project Bhawan, P.O.
Dhurwa, P.S. Dhurwa, District Ranchi, Jharkhand...
... Appellants
Versus
1. Suresh Chandra Jaiswal, aged about 67 years, son of Sri Lalji
Jaiswal, resident of Nauperwa, P.O. Nauperwa, P.S. Baxa, District
Jaunpur, Uttar Pradesh-222109
2. Union of India through the Secretary, Ministry of Consumer Affairs,
Food, Public Administration, Department of Consumer Affairs,
having its office at Room No.456C, Krishi Bhawan, Dr. Rajendra
Prasad Road, Opp. Rail Bhawan, Rajpath Area, Central Secretariat,
P.O. & P.S. Central Secretariat, District New Delhi
.….. ….. …. Respondents
---------
CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ PRASAD
---------
For the Appellants
:
Mr. Mrinal Kanti Roy, Advocate
Mr. Rishi Ranjan Vats, Advocate
For the Respondent-UOI :
Mrs. Bakshi Vibha, Advocate
---------
03/ Dated: 29.09.2026
I.A. No.14113 of 2026
1. Mr. Mrinal Kanti Roy learned counsel for the applicants, on
instruction, seeks leave to withdraw I.A. No.14113 of 2026.
2. Accordingly, leave is granted and I.A. No.14113 of 2026 is disposed
of as withdrawn.
L.P.A. No. 540 of 2026
3. Heard Mr Mrinal Kanti Roy, who appears with Mr Rishi Ranjan
Vats for the appellants and Mrs. Bakshi Vibha for the Union of
India.
4. This appeal challenges the learned single Judge’s order dated
14.05.2026 in W.P. (S) No. 7374 of 2025 instituted by the 1st
respondent.
5. The operative portion of the learned single Judge’s impugned order,
inter alia, directs the appellant to continue the appointment of the 1st
respondent as the President of the Jamtara District Consumer
Disputes Redressal Commission until the completion of the
recruitment process under the new rules by relying upon the decision
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ganeshkumar
Rajeshwarrao Selukar and Ors. v. Mahendra Bhaskar Limaye and
Ors. [2025 INSC 752].
6. Mr Mrinal Kanti Roy, learned counsel for the appellants-State,
submits that the learned Single Judge has misinterpreted the decision
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ganeshkumar (Supra). He
submitted that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has clarified that this
judgment would apply prospectively. He submitted that this would
mean only the Presidents of the District Fora who were in service as
on 21.05.2025 would be allowed to continue. He submitted that the
1st respondent’s tenure ended on 30.12.2024 and, therefore, there
L.P.A. No. 540 of 2026
was no question of his claiming any benefit of the directions in
Ganeshkumar (Supra).
7. Mr Roy placed on record the communication dated 08 th September
2026 addressed by the Union of India to its Advocate and contended
that even the Union of India supported the construction now
advanced by him. Besides, Mr Roy pointed out that the charge of the
post of President of the Jamtara Consumer Forum had already been
handed over to Sri Vidhan Chandra Choudhary, who was otherwise
a regularly appointed President of the East Singhbhum District
Forum in the State of Jharkhand. Accordingly, he submitted that
there could be no apprehension about the effective functioning of the
District Fora within the State of Jharkhand.
8. Mr Roy submitted that for the above reasons, the learned Single
Judge’s order warranted interference.
9. In Ganeshkumar (Supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court considered
several issues relating to the functioning of the State Commissions
and the District Forum under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
One issue concerned the invariable delays in filling vacancies to the
posts of President and Member, and the impact of the appropriate
Governments' failure to fill such vacancies on the functioning of the
Commissions and the Fora constituted under the said Act.
10. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, inter alia, issued several directions
regarding the status of appointments to the posts of Presidents and
Members of the State and District Commissions. Since in this matter
we are concerned with the position of the President of the District
L.P.A. No. 540 of 2026
Forum, who was appointed and serving prior to the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Secretary, Ministry of
Consumer Affairs Versus Dr Mahindra Bhaskar Limaye and
Others (Limaye-I), reported in [(2025) 9 SCC 624], we transcribe
such directions for the convenience of reference: 3. Presidents and Members of the
State and District Commissions
who have been appointed and
serving prior to Limaye-I
(Supra)
They shall be allowed to
complete their tenure in entirety.
In the event of their tenure
ending before the completion of
the recruitment process under
the new Rules to be notified,
their appointment shall be
allowed to continue until the
completion
of
the
said
recruitment process.
4. Presidents of the State and (a) Those who are appointed and
District Commissions, and the serving shall be allowed to
Judicial Members of the State complete their tenure in entirety.
Commission, in other States,
with/without having given the In the event of their tenure
written examination followed by ending before the completion of
the recruitment process under
a viva voce.
the new Rules to be notified,
their appointment shall be
allowed to continue until the
completion
of
the
said
recruitment process.
(b) Those who have been
selected, but not appointed, on
account of the concerned States
having stayed the appointment
process during the pendency of
these appeals, shall be appointed
to the respective post, and shall
be allowed to continue in office
till the entirety of their tenure.
11. The Hon'ble Supreme Court delivered the decision in Limaye-I
(Supra) on 3rd March 2023. In this case, there is no dispute that the
L.P.A. No. 540 of 2026
1st respondent was appointed prior to 03rd March 2023, i.e. on 03rd
November 2021. The 1st respondent joined as President of the
Jamtara District Forum on 09th November 2021. There is also no
dispute that, in terms of his appointment, his tenure ended on 30th
December, 2024, upon attaining the age of superannuation, i.e. 65
years.
12. Further, admittedly, the 1st respondent’s tenure ended before the
completion of the recruitment process under the new rules to be
notified. Still, the appellants did not permit the 1 st respondent’s
appointment to continue until the completion of the said recruitment
process. Therefore, the 1st respondent instituted the writ petition,
W.P(S) No. 7374 of 2025, in which the learned Single Judge passed
the impugned order.
13. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, after paraphrasing the summary of
reliefs, issued the following clarification: “We make it clear that for all those appointments which
have been allowed to continue vide this judgment, the
tenure shall be a period of 4 years. Such persons shall not
be entitled to claim the benefit of this judgment qua a fiveyear tenure, subject to the directions issued hereinabove.
We also make it clear that this judgment shall apply
prospectively, except to the extent indicated in the
directions hereinabove.”
14. Mr Roy stresses the emboldened lines quoted above, in which the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has clarified that this judgment shall apply
prospectively, “except to the extent indicated in the directions
hereinabove”.
L.P.A. No. 540 of 2026
15. From the above, the learned single Judge has concluded that the
judgment in Ganeshkumar (Supra) shall no doubt apply
prospectively, “except to the extent indicated in the directions
indicated therein”. One of the directions related to the Presidents of
the District Fora who were appointed and serving prior to Limaye-I
(Supra). Admittedly, such direction applied to the 1st respondent
because he was appointed and was serving prior to Limaye-I
(Supra) i.e. 03rd of March 2023.
16. The direction commanded the appellants to allow such Presidents to
complete their tenure in its entirety. Further, if their tenure ends
before the completion of the recruitment process under the new rules
to be notified, their appointment shall continue until the completion
of the said recruitment process.
17. Admittedly, the 1st respondent’s tenure ended before the completion
of the recruitment process under the new rules to be notified.
Accordingly, the appellants were duty-bound to allow his
appointment to continue until the completion of the said recruitment
process. Because this was not done, the learned Single Judge
intervened and directed compliance.
18. This is not a case where the Hon’ble Supreme Court provided some
unconditional
prospective
application
to
its
decision
in
Ganeshkumar (Supra). The Hon’ble Supreme Court clarified that
this judgment was to apply prospectively, except to the extent
indicated in the directions hereinabove. This means that wherever
the circumstances referred to in the directions applied, such
L.P.A. No. 540 of 2026
directions had to be complied with, and such compliance could not
be avoided on the grounds of some unconditional prospectivity
argument now advanced by the appellants herein.
19. In any event, harmonious construction would support the 1st
respondent’s case about conditional prospectivity. The view taken
by the learned Single Judge, in our judgment, therefore, suffers from
no error warranting interference.
20. Mr Roy submitted that the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s clarification
about prospectivity will have to be given due weight. There is no
doubt about such a proposition. In fact, every word reflected in the
Hon’ble Supreme Court’s judgment will have to be given due
weight. However, if Mr Roy’s argument is accepted, then the words
“except to the extent indicated in the directions hereinabove” would
be rendered almost futile. This would run contrary to Mr Roy’s
argument that every word in the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court deserves due weight. In any event, it is well settled that the
decisions of the Courts are not to be read and construed like statutes.
21. The communication dated 8th September 2026 addressed by the
Union of India to its Advocate should, in fact, never have been
produced before this Court, because it is merely an opinion
expressed by the Under Secretary to the Government of India. Such
opinions do not bind Courts of law; besides, they could be regarded
as a privileged communication between the Union of India and its
Advocate.
L.P.A. No. 540 of 2026
22. The contention that the Jamtara District Forum is functioning quite
efficiently even in the absence of the President, or because a charge
has been handed over to Sri Vidhan Chandra Choudhary, can hardly
be a ground to act in defiance of the directions issued by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court. Sri Vidhan Chandra Choudhary is a regularly
appointed President of the East Singhbhum District Forum. He has
now been given the additional charge of working as President of the
Jamtara District Forum. In our view, this will adversely affect the
functioning of both District Fora.
23. Besides, we fail to understand how the State Government can claim
to be aggrieved by a direction that will only promote the effective
functioning of the District Fora in the State. On one hand, the rules
are not being notified and regular appointments made and on the
other hand, the State, which is otherwise duty-bound to ensure the
effective functioning of the State Commission and the District Fora
as constituted under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, challenges
an order which only continues the appointments of the President and
other Members until regular appointments are made, provided, no
doubt, the contingencies referred to in Ganeshkumar (Supra) are
fulfilled.
24. Accordingly, we are satisfied that no case is made out to interfere
with the learned Single Judge’s order. This appeal is liable to be
dismissed and is hereby dismissed without any order for costs.
L.P.A. No. 540 of 2026
25. Despite the learned Single Judge’s rejection of interim relief, the
directions have not been complied with.
26. Accordingly, we direct compliance within a week from the date of
uploading of this order. No costs.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Manoj Prasad, J.)
September 29, 2026
BS/Madhav/-
Uploaded on: 07/10/2026
L.P.A. No. 540 of 2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review