Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010946342017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3562]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE 16TH DAY OF JULY 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
WRIT PETITION NO: 42378/2017
Between:
1. THE STATE LEVEL POLICE RECRUITMENT BOARD,, STATE OF
ANDHRA PRADESH, REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN, AT HYDERABAD
2. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH,, REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY, HOME DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT, VELAGAPUDI,
GUNTUR DISTRICT.
3. THE SUPERINTENDENT
KRISHNA DISTRICT
OF
POLICE,,
MACHILIPATNAM,
AT
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
1. RATNA SAGAR BANDI, S/o. Venkateswara Rao, aged about 27 years,
Occ: Unemployee, R/o.Door No.39-12-1, Labbipet, T.V.R. Street,
Vijayawada, Krishna District
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate writ order or direction more particularly one in
the nature of “WRIT OF CERTIORARI" call for records relating to and
connected with the orders of the Hon'ble Andhra Pradesh Administrative
Tribunal, Hyderabad dated 27-09-2016 in O.A.No.3773 of 2014 (O.A.No.3770
of 2014 & Batch) and to quash or set aside the same and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2017(WPMP 52538 OF 2017
-2W.P. No.42378 of 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the operation of the orders of the A.P. Administrative Tribunal,
Hyderabad dated 27-09-2016 in O.A.No.3773 of 2014 (O.A.No.3770/14 &
Batch) pending disposal of the W.P. and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
may be pleased to
grant leave for filing the Counter Affidavit of the
Respondent in W.P.No.42378 of 2017 and to pass
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. GP FOR SERVICES I (AP)
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. KARTHIKSIDDARTHA SALADI
The Court made the following:
-3W.P. No.42378 of 2017
Date of reserved for orders
Date of pronouncement
Date of uploading
: 24.06.2026
: 16.07.2026
: 17.07.2026
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
ORDER: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Subhendu Samanta)
1. Instant writ petition is preferred against order, dated 27.09.2016, passed
by the Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal (for short, „tribunal‟),
Hyderabad, in O.A.No.3773 of 2014. The prayer in the writ petition
reads as follows:
“… to issue an appropriate writ order or direction more particularly one
in the nature of “WRIT OF CERTIORARI” call for records relating to
and connected with the orders of the Hon’ble Andhra Pradesh
Administrative Tribunal, Hyderabad, dated 27.09.2016 in O.A. No.3773
of 2014 (O.A. No.3770 of 2014 & Batch) and to quash or set aside the
same and pass such other order….”
2. The factual matrix of the case:
a. Respondent and the other applicants, were provisionally selected
to the posts of SCTPC (Civil) (Men), SCTPC (AR) (Men) and
Firemen pursuant to Notification No.927/R&T/Rect.2/2011 dated
31.10.2011 issued by the Chairman, State Level Police
Recruitment Board, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad. Subsequently,
their provisional selections were cancelled on the ground that
they had suppressed their involvement in criminal cases while
filling up the attestation forms. Challenging the same, respondent
and the other applicants approached the tribunal.
-4W.P. No.42378 of 2017
b. Learned tribunal heard the applicants and passed a common
judgment by issuing specific direction in paragraph 14, which
reads as follows:
“14. For the reasons stated under Point No.(i) O.A. No.3770/2014, O.A.
No.3772/2014, O.A. No.3773/2014, O.A. No.3774/2014, O.A.
No.3775/2014, O.A. No.3776/2014, O.A. No.3778/2014, O.A.
No.3786/2014 and O.A. No.10650/2012 are allowed. The impugned
proceedings in Rc.No.521/R & T/Genl.2/2012, dt.24.05.2013,
Rc.No.522/R & T/Genl.2/2012, dt.20.08.2013, Rc.No.522/R &
T/Genl.2/2012, dt.20.08.2013, Rc.No.522/R & T/Genl.2/2012,
dt.20.08.2013, Rc.No.522/R & T/Genl.2/2012, dt.20.08.2013,
Rc.No.674/R & T/Genl.2/2013, dt.21.04.2014, Show Cause Notice
Rc.No.523/R & T/Genl.2/ 2012, dt.04.01.2013, Rc. No.523/R & T/
Genl.2/2012, dt.13.12.2013 and C.No.A12/8872/Rect.2011/2012-13,
dt.20.08.2013 are set aside, with a direction to the respondents to
send the applicants for training and appoint them to the post to which
they were selected on completion of the training, within a period of two
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.”
c. Challenging the said direction, instant writ petition has been
preferred by the State.
3. SUBMISSIONS OF THE PETITIONER/ STATE:
a. Sri R.S.Manidhar Pingali, learned Assistant Government Pleader
for Services-I, submitted that respondent participated in the
recruitment process in pursuance of Notification No.927/R&T/
Rect.2/2011 dated 31.10.2011 with Registration No.179879 and
was provisionally selected to the post of SCTPC (Civil) (Men) to
Vijayawada
City.
Thereafter,
antecedent
verification
of
provisionally selected candidates including respondent was done
as per rules. During antecedent verification, it came to light that
respondent was involved in Crime No.448 of 2012 registered by
Satyanarayanapuram Police Station, Vijayawada City, for an
-5W.P. No.42378 of 2017
offence under Section 337 of I.P.C., wherein he was convicted
and sentenced to pay a fine of Rs.300/- by judgment dated
17.09.2012 for offence of rash and negligent driving.
b. It is further argued that respondent has applied and participated
in the selection process by suppressing the above criminal
antecedent and while submitting the attestation form he has
written
“No”
against
the
relevant
column
seeking
such
information. It is further argued that at the end of the attestation
form it has been verified by respondent that all statements made
in the application are true, complete and correct to the best of his
knowledge and belief. The attestation form specifically stipulated
that in the event of furnishing false information or suppression of
any factual information would render a candidate disqualified for
employment under Government. It has also enumerated therein,
if it comes to notice at any point of time during his service that
false
information
had
been
furnished
or
material
facts
suppressed, the service of the candidate would be liable to be
terminated solely on that ground. It is further argued that
respondent has willfully suppressed about his involvement in
criminal case in the attestation form, hence provisional selection
was justifiably cancelled.
c. It is further argued that learned tribunal has not properly gone
through the relevant rules, particularly rule 3(g)(1) of the Andhra
-6W.P. No.42378 of 2017
Pradesh Police (Stipendiary Cadet Trainee) Rules, 1999 and
passed an erroneous order. Thus, the impugned order is liable to
be quashed.
3. SUBMISSIONS OF THE RESPONDENT:
a. Sri Karthik Siddartha Saladi, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent submits that impugned order passed by learned
tribunal suffers no illegality. The issue has been time and again
dealt with by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court as well as Division
Benches of this Court. In several decisions, it has been
unequivocally directed that appointment of candidates for nondisclosure of criminal antecedents cannot be taken into
consideration if it is not involved any offence involvement of moral
turpitude or of offence of trivial nature.
b. In support of his contention, learned counsel placed reliance upon
the following judgments:
(i) Commissioner of Police v. Sandeep Kumar1;
(ii) Avtar Singh v. Union of India2; and
(iii) Common judgment of this Court in W.P. Nos.33306
of 2012, 17758 of 2013, 24990 of 2013 and 29006
of 2018.
4. OBSERVATION OF THIS COURT:
a. Heard learned Government Pleader for Services-I appearing for
the petitioners and learned counsel appearing for the respondent.
(2011)4 SCC 644
(2016) 8 SCC 471
-7W.P. No.42378 of 2017
Perused the material available on record, including the order
passed by learned Tribunal.
b. The sole issue falls for consideration before this Court is that,
whether non-disclosure of criminal antecedents of a candidate at
the time of filing of attestation form can itself disqualify him for
selection.
c. Admittedly, this issue was time and again considered by the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court as well as by Division Benches of this
Court in several occasions. In Avtar Singh’s case (supra1), the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court laid down specific guidelines in
paragraphs 38.4 to 38.11. The guidelines are depicted as follows:
38.4 In case there is suppression or false information of involvement
in a criminal case where conviction or acquittal had already been
recorded before filling of the application/verification form and
such fact later comes to knowledge of employer, any of the
following recourses appropriate to the case may be adopted:
38.4.1 In a case trivial in nature in which conviction had been
recorded, such as shouting slogans at young age or for a petty
offence which if disclosed would not have rendered an incumbent
unfit for post in question, the employer may, in its discretion,
ignore such suppression of fact or false information by condoning
the lapse.
38.4.2 Where conviction has been recorded in case which is not trivial
in nature, employer may cancel candidature or terminate services
of the employee.
38.4.3 If acquittal had already been recorded in a case involving
moral turpitude or offence of heinous/serious nature, on technical
ground and it is not a case of clean acquittal, or benefit of
reasonable doubt has been given, the employer may consider all
relevant facts available as to antecedents, and may take
appropriate decision as to the continuance of the employee.
-8W.P. No.42378 of 2017
38.5 In a case where the employee has made declaration truthfully of a
concluded criminal case, the employer still has the right to consider
antecedents, and cannot be compelled to appoint the candidate.
38.6 In case when fact has been truthfully declared in character
verification form regarding pendency of a criminal case of trivial
nature, employer, in facts and circumstances of the case, in its
discretion, may appoint the candidate subject to decision of such
case.
38.7 In a case of deliberate suppression of fact with respect to multiple
pending cases such false information by itself will assume
significance and an employer may pass appropriate order cancelling
candidature or terminating services as appointment of a person
against whom multiple criminal cases were pending may not be
proper.
38.8 If criminal case was pending but not known to the candidate at the
time of filling the form, still it may have adverse impact and the
appointing authority would take decision after considering the
seriousness of the crime.
38.9 In case the employee is confirmed in service, holding departmental
enquiry would be necessary before passing order of termination/
removal or dismissal on the ground of suppression or submitting
false information in verification form.
38.10
For
determining
suppression
or
false
information
attestation/verification form has to be specific, not vague. Only
such information which was required to be specifically mentioned
has to be disclosed. If information not asked for but is relevant
comes to knowledge of the employer the same can be considered
in an objective manner while addressing the question of fitness.
However, in such cases action cannot be taken on basis of
suppression or submitting false information as to a fact which was
not even asked for.
38.11 Before a person is held guilty of 8uggestion8 veri or suggestio
falsi, knowledge of the fact must be attributable to him.
c. In the said judgment, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has also dealt
with the law laid down in Sandeep Kumar‟s case (supra1) and
has observed, at paragraph 24 :
-9W.P. No.42378 of 2017
“24. In Commr. Of Police v. Sandeep Kumar this Court considered a
case where Sandeep Kumar‟s candidature for the post of Constable
was cancelled on the ground that he had concealed his involvement in
the criminal case under Sections 325/34 IPC when he was about 20
years. In para 9, this Court took note of the character “Jean Valjean” in
Victor Hugo‟s novel Les Miserables in which for committing a minor
offence of stealing of loaf of bread for his hungry family, Jean Valjean
was branded as a thief for whole life. This Court also referred to the
decision in Morris v. Crown Office 3 Relevant portion is extracted
hereunder: (Sandeep Kumar case, SCC pp.645-47 paras 8-12).
“8. We respectfully agree with the Delhi High Court 4 that the
cancellation of his candidature was illegal, but we wish to give our
own opinion in the matter.
When the incident happened, the
respondent must have been about 20 years of age. At that age
young people often commit indiscretions, and such indiscretions
can often be condoned. After all, youth will be youth. They are not
expected to behave in as mature a manner as older people.
Hence, our approach should be to condone minor indiscretions
made by young people rather than to brand them as criminals for
the rest of their lives.”
d. Similar issue has arisen before a coordinate Bench of this Court in
W.A. No.1364 of 2025, wherein this Court held at paragraphs 8
and 9:
“8. Having heard the submissions of the learned counsel for the
petitioner and the learned Government Pleader appearing for the
respondents and upon careful examination of the material
available on record, the following admitted facts are emerged for
consideration:
(a) The petitioner submitted application for the post of Police
Constable pursuant to the notification, dated 13.12.2008.
(1970) 2 QB 114:(`970) 2 WLR 792 (CA)
Sandeep Kumar v. Commr. Of Police, 2006 SCC OnLine Del 836: (2006) 90 DRJ 707
-10W.P. No.42378 of 2017
(b) The petitioner participated in the selection process and
provisionally selected to the post of Police Constable in Nellore
District.
(c) A case was registered in Crime No.6 of 2010, dated 03.10.2010
of Butchireddypalem Police Station and the petitioner was
implicated as Accused No.13 and the said case was charge
sheeted on 16.02.2010.
(d) The petitioner has submitted the attestation form on 23.12.2010.
(e) The petitioner was acquitted in the said criminal case vide
judgment, dated 13.03.2014 of the Additional Judicial
Magistrate of First Class, Kovur.
(f) The provisional selection of the petitioner as Police Constable
was cancelled by order, dated 29.04.2011.
(g) The petitioner approached the Andhra Pradesh Administrative
Tribunal by filing O.A.No.1381 of 2013.
(h) On 15.09.2014 in M.A.No.2235 of 2014 in O.A.No.1381 of 2013,
the Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal directed the
respondent authorities to consider the request of the petitioner
for sending for training in view of his acquittal in criminal case.
Pursuant to the said order, the request of the petitioner has
been considered and it was rejected vide Memo, dated
22.12.2014.
(i) Thereafter, O.A.No.1381 of 2013 was dismissed for default by
order, dated 24.06.2006 by the Andhra Pradesh Administrative
Tribunal and it was restored to its file pursuant to the order,
dated 03.10.2020 in W.P.No.21470 of 2019 of a Division Bench
by this Court. Subsequently, due to abolition of the Andhra
Pradesh Administrative Tribunal, the said O.A.No.1381 of 2013
was transferred to this High Court and it was renumbered as
W.P.(AT) No.22 of 2021.
(j) The learned single Judge of this Court dismissed the said W.P.
(AT) No.22 of 2021 by order, dated 13.04.2025.
9. In this factual position, the issues that arise for consideration
before this Court are:
(1) Whether the State was justified in cancelling the provisional
selection of the appellant/petitioner as Police Constable vide order,
dated 29.04.2011 and the Memo No.114/R&T/Admn.2/2013, dated
22.12.2014?
-11W.P. No.42378 of 2017
(2) To what relief, is the appellant/petitioner entitled to?
e. In the present case, it appears that after the applicant was
provisionally selected, during verification, it revealed that he was
involved in a criminal case under Section 337 of IPC, in which he
was convicted and sentenced to pay a fine of Rs.300/-.
f.
Obviously, the offence punishable under Section 337 of I.P.C. is
trivial in nature in which conviction has been recorded. The
guidelines laid down in Avtar Singh‟s case has clearly imposed a
duty upon the employer to make necessary enquiry and find as to
whether the candidate who has submitted application form
suppressing his criminal antecedent was actually in a case trivial
in nature or it is a case involved in moral turpitude or offence of
heinous and serious in nature. Mere registration of a criminal
case against any person does not automatically stigmatize a
candidate or disentitle him to employment under government.
g. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Avtar Singh‟s case has made
specific guidelines and directives upon the employer to conduct
an administrative enquiry as to ascertain nature and antecedent
of the candidate prior to cancellation of his candidature. More so,
in paragraph 38.10 of Avtar Singh‟s case (supra1) the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court has also put a duty upon the employer to enquire
regarding the suppression or submission of false information in
-12W.P. No.42378 of 2017
the attestation form. In that score, the enquiry so held by the
employer should not vitiate the principles of natural justice.
h. In this particular case, petitioners have not conducted any enquiry
as per the guidelines laid down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Avthar Singh‟s case before cancelling the candidature, which is
not justified.
i.
Moreover, being a welfare state, petitioners cannot deny
employment opportunity of applicant, who might have involved in
a petty case of rash driving for which he has been punished.
j.
Unemployment of this country has reached to its vulnerable state,
at this time denying employment to youth shall lead him to adopt
unfair or antisocial mode of earnings. Penal jurisdiction in India
for awarding sentence to accused is a corrective measure rather
than punitive. Thus, after serving a sentence a convict is allowed
to enter into society scot free, he must not have compelled to
carry stigma of convict for his entire life.
k. On that score, even if present applicant may be convicted then
also as nature of conviction in offence of trivial nature, he cannot
be denied his employment.
l.
Learned tribunal has correctly gone through the issues pointed
out before it and has categorically decided the issues by
assigning the reasons thereof.
-13W.P. No.42378 of 2017
m. On a thorough observation of the impugned judgment passed by
the learned tribunal, we find no reason to interfere. Accordingly,
there is no merit in the instant writ petition and hence, the writ
petition being devoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed. Thus,
the writ petition is dismissed and disposed of. No order as to
costs.
n. The applicant/ respondent was provisionally selected pursuant to
the recruitment notification issued in the year 2011; nearly 15
years have elapsed since then. Hence, the petitioners/ State is
directed to carry out the direction of learned tribunal in its true
letter and spirit as early as possible, more preferably within a
period of six weeks from the date of receipt of this order.
5. Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this writ petition shall stand
closed.
____________________
RAVI NATH TILHARI, J
______________________
SUBHENDU SAMANTA, J
BV
-14W.P. No.42378 of 2017
Whether the order is :
Speaking Yes/No / Reasoned Yes/No
Reportable Yes/No / Non-Reportable Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review