Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
LUCY Digitally
signed by
GURU LUCY
GURUMAYUM
MAYU Date:
2024.11.20
11:16:26
M
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WA No. 117 of 2023
1. The Sangeet Natak Akademi, represented by its
Secretary, Rabindra Bhawan, Feroze Shah Road,
New Delhi-110001.
2. The Jawaharlal Nehru Manipur Dance Academy,
Imphal through its Director, D.M. College Campus,
P.O & P.S. Imphal-795001.
3. The Director of Jawaharlal Nehru Manipur Dance
Academy, Imphal, D.M. College Campus, P.O &
P.S. Imphal-795001.
…. Appellants
-Versus1. Th. Hemchandra Singh, aged about 53 years, S/o
(L) Th. Thambalngou, of Luwangsangbam Matai,
P.O. Mantripukhri P.S. Heingang, Imphal, West
District, Manipur.
2. N. Surendrajit Singh aged about 50 years S/o (L) N.
Manihar Singh of Wangkhei Ningthem Pukhri
Manpal, P.O & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District,
Manipur.
3. G. Chandan Devi aged about 44 years, D/o G.
Shantikumar Sharma of Khagempalli Ningom Leirak,
P.O & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
4. H. Shannila Devi aged about 53 years D/o (L) H.
Kuno Sharma of Wangkhei Ningthem Pukhri Mapal
P.O & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
…. Respondents
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 1
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SIDDHARTH MRIDUL
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU KABUI
For the appellants
:
Mr. Sarvan Kumar, Advocate
For the respondents :
Mr. HS. Paonam, Sr. Advocate
Date of hearing
:
23.10.2024
Date of order
:
20.11.2024
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
(Golmei Gaiphullshilu, J)
[1]
Heard Mr. Sarvan Kumar, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the appellants and Mr. HS. Paonam, learned sr. counsel
appearing on behalf of the respondents.
[2]
The present writ appeal has been filed by the State
Appellants under Rule 3(2) of Chapter IV-A read with Chapter-VII of the
Manipur High Court Rules, 2019 against the impugned Judgment and
Order dated 07.07.2023 passed in WP(C) No. 372 of 2022 by the
Hon’ble Single Judge with the following prayer:
(i)
to allow this Writ Appeal and set aside, reverse or
revise the impugned judgment dated 07.07.2023;
(ii)
to grant interim stay on the impugned judgment
dated 07.07.2023 in WP(C) No. 372 of 2022.
(iii)
to pass any other or further order or direction as may
be deemed fit and proper on the facts and in the
circumstances of this case in the interest of justice.
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 2
[3]
The above referred to W.P.(C) No. 372 of 2022 was
filed by the respondents/petitioners to quash the impugned order dated
17.05.2022 passed by the second respondent/appellant no. 2 and to
direct the appellants to consider the case of the respondents/petitioners
for regularization against the available vacancy of Dancer in the
Jawaharlal Nehru Manipur Dance Academy (JNMDA).
[4]
The case of the respondents/petitioners is that they were
initially engaged as Artiste/Guru/Dancer in JNMDA on consolidated pay
and thereafter, they were engaged as contract Dancer on the
recommendation of the Selection Committee with the prescribed pay
scale of Dancer. The respondents have been associated with the
JNMDA for more than 20 years. However, without considering the
factual position, the second appellant issued the impugned order
rejecting the claim of the respondents for regularization to the post of
Dancer. Challenging the same, the respondents filed the above referred
WP(C) No. 372 of 2022.
[5]
According to the learned counsel for the respondents,
they have been engaged in JNMDA for the last about more than 20
years as Artiste/Guru/Dancer in the JNMDA without any break and
admittedly possess the requisite qualification for the said post. Even
though the respondents/petitioners were engaged on contract basis,
they were during the entire relevant period rendering service of regular
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 3
Dancers in JNMDA. In recognition of their service, the respondents have
been allowed to enjoy the regular pay scale and not consolidated pay,
on the recommendation of the Selection Committee since February,
2010 with the approval of the competent authority. The respondents
are continuing against the vacant post without any complaint from any
quarter. It is further submitted that when the term of the contract
engagement of the respondents was about to expire and owing to nonavailability of Chairman of the Academy and the Advisory Board which
was not functional at the time and also apprehending that there may be
an issue in the extension of the contract engagement, the respondents
filed WP(C) No. 74 of 2022 before this Court, seeking a direction to
consider their case for regularization against the available vacancy of
Dancer coupled with a prayer not to oust them from service. It would
further be submitted that vide order dated 31.01.2022, this Court
disposed of the said writ petition with a direction to the respondents to
consider upon receipt of the representation the respondents’ case and
further
the appellants
were
directed
to dispose
of the
said
representation by giving personal opportunity. In the said order, it was
also directed not to oust the respondents from service pending
consideration of the representation.
Operative portion of the order dated 31.01.2022 passed in
WP(C) No. 74 of 2022 reads as follows;
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 4
“[7] …. Therefore, without going into the merits and demerits of
the petitioners’ case, I am inclined to pass the following orders:
(a) This writ petition is disposed of.
(b) The petitioners are directed to give appropriate
representation to the respondents within a period of 2(two)
weeks from the date of receipt of this order and on receipt
of the said representation, within the stipulated period of
time, the respondent Nos. 1 & 2 are directed to dipose of
the representation by giving personal opportunity and to
pass appropriate speaking orders.
(c) The said exercise shall be done within a period of 8 (eight)
weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order
thereafter.
(d) Till such time, the respondents are directed not to oust the
petitioners from their service.”
[6]
The learned senior counsel for the respondents further
submitted that pursuant to the direction of this Court, on 04.03.2022,
the respondents/petitioners have submitted a representation for
affording regularization to the post of Dancer.
While so, without
considering the factual position, the second appellant issued the
impugned order rejecting the claim of the petitioners. Drawing this
Court’s attention to the orders dated 22.06.2028 in respect of some of
the similarly situated persons, the learned senior counsel submitted that
in the case of some similarly situated persons, who entered into service
as Artists on consolidated basis and subsequently engaged on contract
basis with pay scale, were given regularization to the post of Dancer in
the Academy. He further submits that the respondents/petitioners are
in great hope that their services will be regularized as Dancer and the
respondents have rendered half of their prime life in the role of
Artiste/Guru/Dancer in the Academy. Therefore, the case of the
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 5
respondents may be considered for regularization against the post held
by them and such consideration of the respondents would not involve
any extra financial implication as they were already enjoying the
prescribed pay scale for the post. While stating that there is necessity
of service of the respondents in their letter addressed to the Secretary,
Sangeet Natak Akademi, New Delhi, the appellants have not extended
the service of the respondents after 17.05.2022 for the reason of
approaching this Court seeking for regularization of their service in mala
fide exercise of service. He further submits that non-consideration of
the respondents against the existing vacancy of Dancer held by them
while considering the case of other four Dancers would amount to
violation of the rights guaranteed under Article 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India and the non-regularization of the respondents’
service after rendering more than 20 years of service would be
inhuman and the same may amount to exploitation.
[7]
However, the learned counsel for the appellants submitted
that the duty of the Dancer is to perform on the stage and the
performer has to be full of energy so that he/she can give his/her best.
As per the Recruitment Rules, the posts are filled up through
contractual engagement and their engagement is upto the age of 40
years, which can be extended upto 6 years. In the above referred case,
the respondents were engaged according to the provisions of the
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 6
Recruitment Rules and their contractual engagement should have been
discontinued as soon as they attain the age of prescribed in the
Recruitment Rules, but due to ongoing dance/drama productions, their
contractual period extended from time to time. He further submits that
as per the provisions of the Recruitment Rules of Dancers, respondent
authorities cannot appoint a regular incumbent against the posts.
Hence, the prayer of the respondents for regularization of their services
will be in violation of the provisions of the Recruitment Rules and the
judgment of Apex Court in the case of State of Karnataka v.
Umadevi (3) report in (2006) 4 SCC 1. Thus, a prayer to dismiss
the writ petition was made.
[8]
The grievances of the respondents is that the second
appellant issued the impugned order without considering the fact that
the respondents are continuing in the post and enjoying the prescribed
pay scale for the post and have rendered half of their prime life in the
role of Artiste/Dancer in JNMDA. Therefore, it would be just and proper
to consider the case of the respondents for regularization against the
post held by them at present. On the other hand, the plea of the
appellants is that the engagement of respondents was purely on
contract basis and for a specific period. As per the provisions of the
Recruitment Rules, the appellant authorities cannot appoint a regular
incumbent against the post. Therefore, the prayer of the respondents
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 7
for regularization of their services will be in violation of the provisions of
the Recruitment Rules and the Judgment of the Apex Court in the case
of State of Karnataka vs Umadevi (3) reported in (2006) 4 SCC
1. It is also the say of the appellants that there is no rule to regularize
the services of the respondents and if the respondents are regularized,
then the other employees will also claim the same benefit. Therefore,
the respondents are not entitled to regularization.
[9]
Pursuant to the direction of this Court in W.P. (C) No.74
of 2022, the petitioners have submitted their representation on
4.3.2022 to the Director, JNMDA, Imphal. Thereafter, on 28.3.2022, the
Director, JNMDA, Imphal addressed a letter to the Deputy Secretary,
Sangeet Natak Akademi, New Delhi, requesting to intimate further
action to be taken up for compliance of the order of this Court for
issuance of speaking order and approval for extension of their contract
service from 1.2.2022 till the date of issuance of speaking order. On
17.5.2022, the second appellant issued the impugned order rejecting
the claim of the respondents by referring the decision of the Apex
Court in Umadevi (3), supra, wherein it has been held that when a
person enters a temporary employment or gets engagement as a
contractual or casual worker and the engagement is not based on a
proper selection as recognized by the relevant rules or procedure, he is
aware of the consequences of the appointment being temporary, casual
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 8
or contractual in nature. Such a person cannot invoke the theory of
legitimate expectation for being confirmed in the post.
[10]
The plea of the respondents is that similarly situated
persons, who entered service as Artiste on consolidated basis and
subsequently engaged on contract basis with pay scale, were given
regularization to the post of Dancer in the JNMDA. In support, the
learned senior counsel for the respondents drew the attention of the
Court to the orders dated 22.6.2018 passed by the Director, JNMDA in
respect of O. Debola Devi; P. Bilash Singh; Thounaojam Parul
Devi and Oinam Jiten Singh.
Operative portions of order dated 22.06.2018 are as follows;
“No. 2(1)75-76/JNMDA
OFFICE OF THE JAWAHARLAL NEHRU MANIPUR
DANCE ACADEMY: IMPHAL
OFFICE ORDER
Imphal, the 22nd June, 2018
As per decision of the Advisory Committee meeting, held on
11th December, 2017, the service of Smt. Oinam Debala Devi, Dancer,
Production Unit, JNMDA is regularized w.e.f 10.05.2018 in the pay
scale PB-2 Rs. 9300-34800/- with grade pay of Rs. 4200/- and posted
to the vacant post of Wardrobe Assistant.
This order issues with the approval of the competent
authority.
(L. Upendro Sharma)
Director
Smt. Oinam Debala Devi
Dancer/JNMDA”
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 9
“No. 2(1)75-76/JNMDA
OFFICE OF THE JAWAHARLAL NEHRU MANIPUR
DANCE ACADEMY: IMPHAL
OFFICE ORDER
Imphal, the 22nd June, 2018
As per decision of the Advisory Committee meeting, held on
11th December, 2017, the service of Shri. P. Bilash Singh, Dancer,
Production Unit, JNMDA is regularized w.e.f 10.05.2018 in the pay
scale PB-2 Rs. 9300-34800/- with grade pay of Rs. 4200/-.
This order issues with the approval of the competent
authority.
(L. Upendro Sharma)
Director
Shri. P. Bilash Singh
Dancer/JNMDA”
“No. 2(1)75-76/JNMDA
OFFICE OF THE JAWAHARLAL NEHRU MANIPUR
DANCE ACADEMY: IMPHAL
OFFICE ORDER
Imphal, the 22nd June, 2018
As per decision of the Advisory Committee meeting, held on
11th December, 2017, the service of Smt. Thounaojam Parul Devi,
Dancer, Production Unit, JNMDA is regularized w.e.f 10.05.2018 in the
pay scale PB-2 Rs. 9300-34800/- with grade pay of Rs. 4200/- and
posted/transferred to the vacant post of Junior Production Assistant.
This order issues with the approval of the competent
authority.
(L. Upendro Sharma)
Director
Smt. Thounaojam Parul Devi
Dancer/JNMDA”
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 10
[11]
The learned senior counsel for the respondents submits
that there are adequate numbers of vacancies in the grade of
Dancer/Artiste in JNMDA, Imphal and, thus, consideration of the
respondents against such vacancies would be an act of fairness which
also would redress the grievances of the respondents. Further, there is
no legal impediment in any manner for excluding the respondents from
such consideration, but rather would be just, proper and considerate
judicious decision where the interest of any third party would not be
prejudiced.
[12]
On 12.06.2024, learned counsel for the respondents
submitted his written argument/brief note of the case contending that
as per the recruitment rules of Dancer, a Dancer may be retained till
the age of 40 years unless with the specific approval of the Advisory
Committee and the term of contract should be maximum for a period of
6 years. However, all the respondents/petitioners were allowed to be
continued beyond 40 years of age and they have been serving as
Dancer for more than 20 years thereby showing that the said
recruitment rules is not strictly enforced in JNMDA. He further
mentioned that it is the stand of the Appellants that there are no
regular sanctioned post of Dancer in JNMDA and all the posts of
Dancers are contractual posts. However, as per the decision of the
Advisory Committee meeting held on 11.12.20217, the service of 1)
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 11
Smt. Oinam Debola Devi, Dancer; Shri P. Bilash Singh, Dancer; 3)
Thounaojam Parul Devi, Dancer; and 4) Oinam Jiten were regularized
w.e.f 10.05.20218 vide order dated 22.06.2018. Thus, it is seen that
Dancers are given regularization in JNMDA with the approval of the
Advisory
Committee.
However,
in
the
case
of
the
respondents/petitioners, Appellants are adopting a different yardstick
which is discriminatory in nature and thus liable to be interfered with
from the ends of justice. This factum is also admitted by the Appellants
at para 27(v) of the Memo of Appeal that “order dated 22.06.2018 was
passed and the employees were regularized against the vacant regular
post not regularized on the post of contractual Dancers”. Thus, it is
very clear that there are sanctioned post of Dancers in JNMDA against
which the case of the respondents/petitioners can be considered for
regularization as have been done in the case of other similarly situation
person vide order dated 22.06.2018.
Further, in reply to a RTI Application dated 05.04.2024
filed by the counsel for the respondents/petitioners, the JNMDA has
given information to the effect that there are 14 no. of sanctioned posts
of Dancer in JNMDA and 13 of the said posts are presently occupied
including by the present 4(four) respondents/petitioners. In response to
the query regarding whether there has been any instance where
Dancer in JNMDA continued till their respective superannuation from
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 12
service, the JNMDA provided the names of A. Lakshmi Devi, S.
Noyonshakhi Devi and K. Binakumari Devi, N. Ajit Singh and R.K.
Jayatisana Devi meaning thereby they have retired as Dancer upon
attaining the age of superannuation and were given retirement benefits
for the post of Dancer.
From the above facts and circumstances, it is clear that
there are Dancers serving in JNMDA beyond 40 years of age and they
are allowed to continue till the age of superannuation. Further, 4(four)
persons who are similarly situated with the respondents/petitioners and
beyond 40 years of age were also regularized as Dancer in JNMDA
against the sanctioned post of Dancer. Therefore, the claim of the
Appellants that there is no sanctioned post of Dancer in JNMDA against
which
the
respondents/petitioners
could
be
considered
for
regularization is not sustainable. Further mentioned that present
petitioners are enjoying pay scale of Dancer even though they are
working on contract basis and upon regularization there may not be any
financial burden on the Appellant.
[13]
On 15.10.2024, the learned counsel for the appellant
submitted affidavit of the Appellant against the brief note/written
submission filed by the respondents/petitioners stating that during the
hearing on 21.08.2024 the Respondent’s Ld. counsel handed over the
brief notes containing the reply to the RTI application furnished by the
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 13
JNMDA which is not on record. The information provided in response to
the RTI request by one of the CPIOs of the appellants has led to some
confusion for the Hon’ble Court. Additionally, it appears to be
inconsistent with the provisions of the appellant department, and it
contradicts the stance taken by the appellant in their arguments.
Further submitted that in the interest of justice, this Hon’ble court
granted an opportunity to the appellant counsel to take instructions and
clarify on the contrary view taken in the appeal with the RTI reply, for
the same matter was adjourned. Thereafter, the learned counsel for the
appellant brought to the attention of the concerned authority of the
appellants the information furnished in RTI reply dated 30.04.2024.
However, the concerned authority was surprised and unaware of this
response. As a result, they have decided to issue a show cause notice
dated 28.08.2024 to the CPIO responsible for providing incomplete and
inaccurate information in the RTI reply dated 20.04.2024. He further
submitted that the Hon’ble Single Judge overlooked the critical
submission made by the appellant that the respondents/petitioners
were engaged on a purely contractual basis or a specified period.
Granting the respondents/petitioners prayer for regularization would
constitute a breach of the Recruitment Rules (RRs) and contravene the
binding precedent established by the Apex court.
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 14
Operative portion of the RTI reply reads as follows;
“OFFICE OF THE JAWAHARLAL NEHRU
MANIPUR DANCE ACADEMY: IMPHAL
No. Admn.48/2015-16/JNMDA
To
Huidrom Malemleima,
Advocate,
Palace Compound
Imphal East
Imphal, the 30th April, 2024
Subject: Furnishing of information relating to your RTI
Application.
Madam,
With reference to above mentioned subject, I am to furnish
the required information sought by you as follows.
Sl.
No.
Queries
Information
No. of sanctioned posts
of Dancer in JNMDA
No.
of
presently
occupied Dancers and
no. of vacant post of
Dancer
14 (fourteen)
Has there been any
instance where Dancer
in JNMDA continued till
their
respective
superannuation
from
service.
No. of Dancers who are
above 40 years at
present in JNMDA
Whether SNA is the
appointing authority in
respect
of
Dancer,
JNMDA, if not who is the
appointing authority
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
No. of presently occupied post of
Dancers
(thirteen):
Th.
Hemchandra
Singh
singh;
N.
Surendrajit Singh; H. Sharmila Devi;
G. Chandan Devi; M. Momocha
Singh; Anantakumar Longjam; Th.
Tolen Meitei; R.K. Nilakanta Singh; S.
Rahul Singh; Nirina Yambem; Roshali
Rajkumari; L. Monika Devi and
Babina Chanam and 1 (one) post is
lying vacant.
A.Lakshmi Devi, S. Noyonshakhi
Devi, K. Binakumar Devi, N. Ajit
Singh, R.K. Jayatisana Devi
Th. Parul Devi, Dancer posted as Jr.
Production Asstt; O. Debela Devi
Dancer posted as Wardrobe Asstt.;
O. Jiten Singh, Dancer posted as
Stage Asstt.
Director, Jawaharlal Nehru Manipur
Dance Academy, Imphal is the
appointing authority for the post of
Dancer, JNMDA.
Page 15
Is there any vacant post
at present in equivalent
post of Dancer in
JNMDA
Guru Grade 1, JNMDA – Vacant post
3 (three)
Sr. Production Asstt., JNMDA –
Vacant post 1 (one)
Assistant Admn., JNMDA – Vacant
post 1 (one)
(Wangkhem Jikendrajit Singh)
Programme Officer, JNMDA”
[14]
After perusal of all the materials on record and after
hearing both the parties, Ld. Single Judge passed the impugned order
dated 07.07.2023 in WP(C) No. 372 of 2022, relevant portion of the
order reads as follows;
“26. In the result,
(a) The writ petition is disposed of.
(b) The impugned order dated 17.5.2022 passed by the
first respondent is set aside.
(c) The respondent authorities are directed to consider
the case of the petitioners for regularization against the
available vacancies of Dancer in the JNMDA in the light
of the orders dated 22.6.2018 issued by the Director,
JNMDA and as per the relevant rules.
(d) The aforesaid exercise is directed to be completed
within a period of twelve weeks from the date of receipt
of a copy of this order.
(e) There will be no order as to costs.”
[15]
Being aggrieved by the order dated 07.07.2023, the
appellants has preferred the present appeal. The appellants contended
that the impugned decisions of the Single Judge was passed without
proper deliberation and without arguments, without reference to the
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 16
crucial words of the rule and any citation of authority on law applicable
to Autonomous bodies like SNA and JNMDA and the Single Judge has
committed a grave error in allowing the writ petition, quashing the
order dated 17.05.2022 and directed the appellant authorities to
consider the case of the respondents for regularization against the
available vacancies of Dancer in the JNMDA, whereas there is no
regular post are available for the dancer in the light of the orders dated
22.06.2018 issued by the Director, JNMDA and as per the relevant
rules; however, the order dated 22.06.2018 was passed to consider
regularization for another available vacancy instead of regularization for
dancer available post and the aforesaid exercise is directed to be
completed within a period of twelve weeks from the date of receipt of a
copy of the order and there will be no order as to costs.
[16]
The learned counsel for the appellant further submits that
JNMDA is a constituent unit of Sangeet Natak Akademi (SNA), and SNA
is an autonomous body under Ministry of Culture Government of India,
and 100% financed by the GOI through Grant-in-Aid from Public Fund.
Pay & Allowances and terminal/retirement/pensionary benefits to the
staff of SNA and its constituent units who are working against the
regular sanction posts are being paid from the fund released from the
Ministry of Culture. Contractual Posts like contractual post of Dancer in
JNMDA do not come under regular sanctioned posts and no fund is
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 17
released from the Ministry of Culture Government of India for such
posts on account of terminal/retirement/pensioner benefits. Hence, the
directions of the Hon’ble High Court for consideration of their
regularization on contractual basis cannot be acceded.
In support of his case, the appellant relied upon the
following judgment:
1. (2015) 5 SCC 333 - [T.M. Sampath & Ors Vs.
Secretary, M/O Water Resources & Ors]
2. Municipal Corporation of Delhi Vs Gurnam Kaur.
3. A-One Granites Vs State of UP and Ors.
[17]
It is seen and emerged that the initial engagement of the
respondents/petitioners on consolidated pay as Dancer was in the years
of 1998, 2000 and 2002 respectively and thereafter in the year 2010,
they have been appointed as contract Dancer against the vacant post in
the scale of pay of Rs. 9300-34800 with GP Rs. 4200/- and other
admissible allowances. Now the respondents/petitioners are aged 52,
50, 44 and 53 respectively and under the hope that their services will
be regularized as Dancer in JNMDA, the petitioners have been
performing their duties to the satisfaction of all concerned. It is not the
case of the appellants that the respondents/petitioners are irregular and
have not been performing their duties well. The respondents/petitioners
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 18
have rendered half of their prime life in the role of Artiste/Dancer in the
JNMDA.
[18]
Further, it is also seen and emerged that similarly situated
persons, who entered service as Artiste on consolidated basis and
subsequently engaged on contract basis with pay scale, were given
regularization to the post of Dancer in the JNMDA. In support, the
learned senior counsel for the respondents/petitioners drew the
attention of the Court to the orders dated 22.06.2018 passed by the
Director, JNMDA in respect of O. Debola Devi; P. Bilash Singh;
Thounaojam Parul Devi and Oinam Jiten Singh.
[19]
On perusal of the aforesaid four orders, it is seen and
evident that the Director of JNMDA, Imphal, had issued an order
regularizing the services of O. Debola; P. Bilash Singh; Thounaojam
Parul Devi and Oinam Jiten Singh with effect from 10.05.2018 based on
the decisions of the Advisory Committee meeting held on 11.12.2027.
[20]
After going through the pleadings of the parties and after
hearing both the learned counsel for the parties it is seen that the
following are the admitted position of fact and the same is extracted
herein below;
1.
The respondents/petitioners were initially engaged
as Artiste/Guru/Dancer in JNMDA on consolidated
pay in the years 1998, 2000, 2001 and 2002;
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 19
2.
Thereafter in the year 2010 on recommendation of
the
Selection
Committee,
they
have
been
appointed as contract Dancer against the vacant
post in the scale of pay of Rs. 9300-34800 with GP
Rs. 4200/- and other admissible allowances;
3.
The appointment of the respondents/petitioners is
clearly on sanctioned posts with clear vacancy of
which
the
respondents/petitioners
are
still
holding/occupying. Mention is made here that
appellant no. 2 there are 14 nos. of sanctioned
post out of that 13 nos. of the post of dancers
were appointed/filled out of the said 13, the
present respondents/petitioners were also included
and there is still vacancy of 1 post.
4.
Similarly situated persons but who were appointed
on contract basis much after the contractual
appointment
of
the
present
respondents/
petitioners, who entered service as Artiste on
consolidated basis and subsequently engaged on
contract basis with pay scale,
were given
regularization to the post of Dancer in JNMDA vide
order dated 22.06.2018. (Ref: Anx – A/17 to A/20)
The
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
appointment
order
of
the
aforesaid
Page 20
subsequently appointed employee are reproduced
herein above;
5.
There are Dancers serving in JNMDA beyond 40
years of age and they are allowed to continue till
the age of superannuation. Mentioned is made here
that the appellants allowed the respondents/
petitioners to continue their service beyond 40
years and they have been allowed to serve till now
i.e. more than 20 years thereby showing that the
said recruitment rules is not strictly enforced by the
appellant no. 2, they are still employed as dancers
till now inspite of their age crossing much over 40
years of age and they are now aged about 52, 50,
44 and 53 respectively.
[20]
The Apex Court in the case of Umadevi (3) supra,
held as under.
“53. One aspect needs to be clarified. There may be cases
where Irregular appointments (not illegal appointments) as
explained In S.V.Narayanapa [(1967 2 SCR 128 AIR 1967 SC
1071], R.N.Nanjundappa [(1972) 1 SCC 409: (1972) 2 SCR
799] and B.N.Nagarajan ((1979) 4 SCC 507: 1980 SCC (L&S) 4:
(1979) 3 SCR 937) and referred to in para 15 above, of duly
qualified persons in duly sanctioned vacant posts might have
been made and the employees have continued to work for t en
years or more but without the intervention of orders of the
courts or of tribunals. The question of regularization of the
services of such employees may have to be considered on
merits in the light of the principles settled by this Court in the
cases above referred to and in the light of this judgment.
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 21
In that context, the Union of India, the State Governments and
their instrumentalities should take steps to regularise as a onetime measure, the services of such irregularly appointed, who
have worked for ten years or more in duly sanctioned posts but
not under cover of orders of the courts or of tribunals and
should further ensure that regular recruitments are undertaken
to fill those vacant sanctioned posts that require to be filled up,
in cases where temporary employees or daily wagers are being
now employed. The process must be set in motion within six
months from this date. We also clarify that regularization, if any
already made, but not sub judice, need not be reopened based
on this judgment, but there should be no further bypassing of
the constitutional requirement and regularising or making
permanent, those not duly appointed as per the constitutional
scheme."
[21]
In 2018 SCC Online SC 3860 [Ravi Verma & Ors vs
Union of India & Ors]
“13. In view of the aforesaid decision, the circulars and
regularization of the similarly situated employees at other
places and various recommendation that were made the
services of the appellants ought to have been regularized in the
year 2006; discriminatory treatment have been meted out to
them. As per the decision of Uma Devi (Supra), they were
entitled to regularization of services; they did not serve under
the cover of court’s order. Illegality has been committed by not
directing regularization of services.
14. We direct that the services of the appellants be regularized
w.e.f 1st July 2006 they are entitled to consequential benefit
also let the respondents comply with the order in a period of
three months from today.”
[22]
In 92024) SCC Online SC 2277 – [Ushaben Joshi vs
Union of India & Ors]
“17……… Keeping in view the fact that an employee similarly
placed but inducted in service after nearly six years from the
date of employment of the appellant with the respondentDepartment has been conferred the benefits of confirmation in
service by way of appointment to the post of MTS, the
appellant is entitled to claim the same benefits.”
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 22
[23]
With due consideration to the facts and circumstances set
out by the parties and the admitted position of fact and law as has
been highlighted and narrated above and applying the ratio of the Apex
Court as reproduced above, we are of the view that the case of the
appellants’ contentions have no legs to stand on and instead the
appellant authorities ought to take steps to regularize the service of the
respondents/petitioners.
[24]
In the result there is no scope to interfere with the
impugned order of the learned Single Judge and appellants are directed
to comply with the direction given by the learned Single Judge and to
take steps to comply with the direction made by the learned Single
Judge within a period of 6 (six) weeks.
[25]
With the above direction the present appeal is dismissed.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Lucy
Writ Appeal no. 117 of 2023
Page 23
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review