Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 23.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010409832019
+
FAO(OS) (COMM) 279/2019
NATWEST MARKETS PLC
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Sanjeev Pathak, Adv.
versus
M/S HERO EXPORTS & ANR .
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Shubham Seth, Mr. Nikilesh Ramachandran, Advs. for
R-1.
Mr. M. A. Venkata Subramanian, Adv. for R-2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J. (ORAL)
1.
This appeal is filed assailing the orders dated 22.05.2019 and
30.05.2019 passed by the learned Single Judge whereby the ABN
Amro Bank N.V. later named as Royal Bank of Scotland and now
known as Natwest Markets PLC (hereinafter referred to as ‘the
appellant’) was directed to deposit with the Registrar General of this
Court the amount reflected in the account of respondent no.2M/S Tiffins Barrytes, Asbestos and Paints Limited (hereinafter
‘Tiffins Barrytes’), along with interest accrued thereon.
2.
The brief facts are that a dispute arose between Hero Exports
Signed By:HONEY FAO (OS)(COMM) 279/2019
ARORA
16:48:42
and Tiffins Barrytes. Prior to the commencement of arbitration
proceedings, Hero Exports filed a petition bearing O.M.P. 369/2008
under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (for
short ‘the Act’). This Court vide order dated 18.07.2008 directed that a
sum of Rs.8.5 crores lying in the bank accounts of Tiffins Barrytes be
secured. In bank account with appellant, Tiffins Barrytes was having
credit balance of Rs.5.89 crores. The appellant was directed to retain
the amount till further orders and by order dated 26.11.2008 the
amount was directed to be kept in a fixed deposit yielding maximum
rate of interest (hereinafter ‘ROI’).
2.1
In view of the appointment of the arbitrator and commencement
of the arbitration proceedings, the petition under Section 9 of the Act
was disposed of with liberty to the petitioner to approach the arbitrator
for further relief on 04.03.2009. The orders dated 18.07.2008 and
26.11.2008 were to continue, subject to further orders of the arbitrator
and the parties were at liberty to approach the arbitrator for
modification of the order.
2.2
The appellant in view of the fact that it was in the process of
winding down filed an application dated 19.09.2017 before the
arbitrator seeking modification of the order of this Court to enable
transfer of the deposited amount to another bank. The application is
pending wherein the following prayer was made:
“1) Modify the order of Hon’ble Delhi High Court
dated March 04,2009 (wrongly typed as March
03,2009) to enable the respondent to move the
account to another Bank as per the extant RBI
guidelines and directions that may be issued by the
Signed By:HONEY FAO (OS)(COMM) 279/2019
ARORA
16:48:42
Hon’ble Tribunal.
2) Authorise the applicant to move funds lying in
the Fixed Deposit with the Royal Bank of Scotland
plc to another Bank Account/ Fixed Deposit in the
same name as with the applicant by means of
RTGS/ Electronic Fund Transfer.”
2.3
The Resolution Professional for Tiffins Barrytes filed an
application in this Court in the disposed of O.M.P. 369/2008, seeking
release of the amount lying with the appellant. In this application the
appellant filed an affidavit stating that a sum of Rs.11,22,06,703/- was
in the frozen account of Tiffins Barrytes.
2.4
The Court noted that the interest by appellant on the FDR was
given at the rates of 7.75%, 8.25% and 7.75% until 30.01.2018 but
thereafter interest was paid at the rate of 3.5%. The reliance placed by
learned counsel for the appellant on the Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
circular dated 01.07.2015 (hereinafter ‘the RBI circular’) that the
appellant was free to fix the rate of interest was not accepted and the
following directions were issued by order dated 22.05.2019
(hereinafter ‘directions’):
“2. In view of the order dated 18th July, 2008, the
bank account stood attached. However, since ABN
Amro Bank has thereafter changed to RBS Bank
which is now in the process of winding down its
operations, an application was moved by the Bank
before the Arbitral Tribunal that the amounts be
shifted to some other account. However, there was
no reference in the said application to the fact that
the interest rate would only be 3.5%. It is
accordingly directed that ABN Amro Bank/RBS
Bank shall deposit the entire sum which is shown
in the account statement at page 39. The interest
Signed By:HONEY FAO (OS)(COMM) 279/2019
ARORA
16:48:42
that shall be payable for the period from 30th
January 2018 till date, shall be the average of the
last three years' interest rates i.e., 7.75%, 8.25%
and 7.75%. The amount be remitted to the
Registrar General's account within a week with the
entire interest accrued on the said deposit of
Rs.5.89 crores, as per the present order.”
2.5
Aggrieved of the directions, the appellant is in the present
appeal.
3.
Learned counsel for the appellant contends that in terms of
Clause 3.3 of the RBI circular the bank was at liberty to determine the
ROI. Clause 3.4 of the RBI circular is relied upon to argue that in the
event of non-renewal upon maturity of the fixed deposit receipt (for
short ‘FDR’) the deposit would bear interest at the savings bank rate.
3.1
The submission is that the appellant was in the process of
winding down and had filed an application before the arbitrator
seeking modification of the order of this Court however, it is pending
till date. The grievance is that the impugned order was passed without
considering the pleadings and material placed on record. The affidavit
filed before the learned Single Judge annexing the RBI regulations
and the statement depicting the interest accrued on the deposit in
question were not factored for.
4.
Per contra, pursuant to the order of this Court dated
26.11.2008 the amount was kept in an FDR and the appellant was
directed to keep the amount in a deposit bearing maximum ROI. It is
contended that the appellant neither issued notice to the affected
parties regarding the reduction in the ROI nor informed the Court
thereof. It is submitted that no notice that term of the FDR expired and
Signed By:HONEY FAO (OS)(COMM) 279/2019
ARORA
16:48:42
has to be renewed was served.
4.1
The contention is that in the application filed before the
arbitrator seeking modification of the order and permission to transfer
the amount to another bank there was no reference to the reduction in
the ROI on the deposit. Moreover, no evidence was adduced to
establish that the ROI on the FDR for all similarly placed customers
was reduced to 3.5%.
5.
The amount belonging to Tiffins Barrytes was frozen pursuant
to the orders of this Court to secure the amount during the pendency
of the arbitral proceedings. The appellant was directed to retain the
amount of Rs.5.89 crores in a fixed deposit carrying maximum ROI. It
is an admitted fact that the interest till 30.01.2018 was paid at the rates
of 7.75%, 8.25% and 7.75%. The learned Single Judge noted that after
30.01.2018, the ROI was reduced to 3.5% without any reasons or
basis.
6.
Relevant portion of clauses 3.3 and 3.4 of the RBI circular is
reproduced below:
“3.3 Interest Rates on Term Deposits
With effect from October 22, 1997, RBI has given
the freedom to commercial banks to fix their own
interest rates on domestic term deposits of various
maturities with the prior approval of their
respective Board of Directors/ Asset Liability
Management Committee (ALCO). Banks are,
however, not allowed to discriminate in the matter
of interest paid on deposits, between one deposit
and another, accepted on the same date and for the
same maturity, whether such deposits are accepted
at the same office or at different offices of the
bank. Interest rates paid by the bank should be as
Signed By:HONEY FAO (OS)(COMM) 279/2019
ARORA
16:48:42
per the schedule and should not be subject to
negotiation between the depositor and the bank…”
“3.4 Calculation of Interest on Term Deposits
Bank are free to adopt any methodology for
calculation of interest on deposits. However, they
should provide information to their depositors
about the manner of calculation of interest
appropriately while accepting the deposits and
display the same at their branches. If a Fixed
Deposit Receipt matures and proceeds are unpaid,
the amount left unclaimed with the bank will
attract savings bank rate of interest.”
7.
Clause 3.3 of the RBI circular permits banks to determine their
own ROI in respect of domestic term deposits for various periods. The
discretion is subject to the condition that there is no discrimination
between deposits accepted on the same date whether at the same or
different offices of the bank. The appellant neither before the learned
Single Judge nor in the present appeal has substantiated the fact that
the ROI for all the similar FDR was reduced to 3.5%.
8.
Reliance on clause 3.4 of the RBI circular does not enhance the
case of the appellant for payment of interest at the rate of 3.5% on the
amount kept in the FDR. It is pertinent to note that no period was
specified for which the FDR was to be maintained. There is nothing
on record to establish that the appellant informed the affected parties
i.e. Hero Exports and Tiffins Barrytes about the maturity of the FDR
and that it was required to be renewed. No application was filed either
before the arbitrator or this Court seeking directions for renewal of the
FDR or informing that owing to the winding down of the bank the
ROI on the deposit was reduced to savings bank rate.
Signed By:HONEY FAO (OS)(COMM) 279/2019
ARORA
16:48:42
9.
Albeit, an application seeking modification of the order dated
04.03.2009 of this Court was filed before the arbitrator on 19.09.2017
however, the prayer was confined to permission to transfer of the
deposited amount to another bank. The application was not pursued
and is still pending. The affidavit filed before the learned Single Judge
does not state that ROI on similar FDRs has been reduced to 3.5%
across all branches of the appellant in India. It merely states that thirty
branches of the bank were closed in a phased manner and that the
Gurgaon and Mumbai branches were operational but the rates of
interest offered to customers on deposits at these branches were not
disclosed.
10.
The directions issued by the learned Single Judge suffer from
no factual or legal error calling for interference in the appeal.
11.
The appeal is dismissed.
12.
All pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J
SHAIL JAIN, J
SEPTEMBER 23, 2026
‘JK’
Reportable: Yes
Signed By:HONEY FAO (OS)(COMM) 279/2019
ARORA
16:48:42
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review