Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/TAX APPEAL NO. 449 of 2025
==========================================================
THE PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (CENTRAL),
AHMEDABAD
Versus
NK PROTEINS PVT. LTD.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR.VARUN K.PATEL(3802) for the Appellant(s) No. 1
MR DHINAL A SHAH(12077) for the Opponent(s) No. 1
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PRANAV TRIVEDI
Date : 04/08/2026
ORAL ORDER
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA)
1.
Heard learned Senior Standing Counsel Mr.
Varun Patel for the appellant and learned
advocate
Mr.
Dhinal
Shah
for
the
respondent.
2.
This Appeal is filed under section 260A of
the Income Tax Act, 1961 [for short ‘the
Act’]
arising
12.11.2024
out
passed
by
of
the
order
Income
dated
Tax
Appellate Tribunal in ITA No. 339/Ahd/2022
C/TAXAP/449/2025
for
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
A.Y.
2009-10
proposing
following
substantial questions of law:
(a)
Whether
in
the
facts
and
circumstances of the case and in
law, the learned ITAT has erred
in coming to the conclusion that
the
Assessing
Officer
cannot
make
additions
on
which
issues
did not form part of the reasons
recorded
by
him,
when
no
addition is made by him on the
issues
which
are
included
the
reasons recorded?
(b)
Whether
in
the
facts
and
circumstances of the case and in
law, the learned ITAT has erred
in holding that the Explanation
3 to Section 147 which has been
inserted by Finance (No.2) Act,
2009 retrospectively with effect
from
01.04.1989
purpose
of
i.e.
"For
the
assessment
or
reassessment under this section,
the Assessing Officer may assess
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
or
reassess
the
income
in
respect of any issue, which has
escaped
issue
assessment,
comes
subsequently
the
to
in
his
the
proceedings
section,
and
such
notice
course
of
under
this
notwithstanding
that
the reasons for such issue have
not been included in the reasons
recorded
of
under
section
sub-section
148"
cannot
(2)
expand
the scope and sweep of the main
body of Statutory provision?
(c)
Whether
in
the
facts
and
circumstances of the case and in
law, the learned ITAT has erred
in upholding the decision of the
CIT(A)
in
deleting
the
disallowance
of
Rs.
13,89,08,810/
made
r.w.s
40A(2)(b)
and
Income tax Act, 1961?
u/s.
43(5)
of
the
C/TAXAP/449/2025
3.
Brief
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
facts
of
the
assessee-company
manufacturing
of
case
are
that
the
is
engaged
in
edible,
non-edible
oil
products and byproducts thereof.
3.1
The
assessee
filed
return
of
income and assessment order under section
143(3)
of
29.12.2011
the
Act
was
passed
on
assessing
total
income
at
Rs. 22,55,48,605/-.
3.2
Thereafter, a notice under section
was
issued
on
09.03.2015
for
the
following two reasons:
[a] disallowance u/s. 14A r.w.r. 8D was
wrongly worked out at Rs.1,13,521/instead of Rs.2,18,174/- and
[b]
the
amount
received
from
National
Stock Exchange Ltd [NSEL] amounting
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
to Rs.244.98 crores is in the nature
of income brought in the account of
debtors
in
the
guise
of
so-called
paper trade and which needs to be
taxed in the hands of the assessee
company.
3.3
The
Assessing
Officer
completed
reassessment by making disallowance under
section 43(5) read with section 73 and
section
Rs.
40A(2)(b)
13,89,08,810/-
disallowance of
of
and
excess
Rs. 1,04,652/- under
section 14A of the Act.
3.4
The Assessee preferred an appeal
before
the
additional
CIT(Appeals)
ground
of
and
reopening
raised
of
the
assessment as the Assessing Officer did
not
make
any
addition
recorded for reopening.
for
the
reasons
C/TAXAP/449/2025
3.5
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
The
considering
the
challenging
assessment
CIT(Appeals),
after
additional
first
the
held
ground
reopening
that
the
of
the
reassessment
proceedings is bad in law by observing as
under:
“4.8 So far as merits of additional
claim are concerned, it is observed
that
AO
notice
had
on
issued
two
ground for
reassessment
grounds.
The
main
reassessment notice
was
with reference to transactions with
NSEL
for
Rs.244.98
crores.
Appellant
has
claimed
transaction
with
NSEL
that
was
The
no
carried
out in current year, which is also
accepted by the Special Auditor in
his report under Section 142A of the
Act. The figure of Rs.244.98 crores
was
nothing
but
addition
made
in
Appellant's own case for A.Y.2011-12
C/TAXAP/449/2025
in
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
Assessment
21/11/2014.
Order
This
passed
on
contention
of
Appellant was accepted by AO while
passing the Assessment Order and no
addition was made. So far as second
issue
being
Section
14A
disallowance
for
concerned,
it
addition
under
Rs.1,13,521/original
Rs.2,18,174/-
is
observed
that
is
Section
was
also
Assessment
29/12/2011.
under
14A
for
made
in
Order
While
dated
computing
disallowance under Section 14A read
with
Rule
BD,
gross average
AO
had
considered
asset as
denominator
whereas in the reasons recorded for
present
case,
AO
was
of
the
view
that net average asset needs to be
taken. It is pertinent to note that
entire issue
of disallowance
Section
as
original
14A
was
Assessment
under
raised
in
Order
was
deleted by Hon'ble Ahmedabad ITAT in
Appellate
Order
dated
27/07/2016.
The relevant operative part of the
C/TAXAP/449/2025
said
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
decision
is
reproduced
hereunder.-
"29. We have heard the rival
contentions
and
perused
the
material on record. Assessee is
aggrieved with the disallowance
u/s 14A of the Act of Rs.
1,13,521/-confirmed
by
Id.
CIT(A). We further observe that
Id. AR specifically mentioned
that there is no exempt income
earned by the assessee during
the year. We also observe that
in
the
judgment
of
Hon.
Jurisdictional High Court in
the case of CIT vs. Cortech
Energy P. Ltd. (supra) has
confirmed the order of the
Tribunal deleting disallowance
u/s 14A of the Act as the
assessee has not claimed any
exempt income. Similar is the
situation
in
the
case
of
assessee and we respectfully
following the judgment of Hon.
Jurisdictional High Court are
of
the
view
that
no
disallowance is called for u/s
14A as assessee has not claimed
any exempt income in the year
under appeal. We hold that Id.
CIT(A)
was
not
correct
in
upholding the disallowance and
allow the ground of assessee."
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
Considering
the
above
referred
decision in Appellant's own case for
current
year
only,
ground
of
reassessment for alleged escapement
for disallowance under Section 14A
does not survive or addition made in
reassessment order consequently does
survive.
Thus,
the
effective
addition in Appellant's case based
upon
reassessment
order
is
disallowance
under
Section
43(5)
read
with
Section
for
Rs.13,18,08,810/- which is not based
upon
reasons
recorded.
Thus,
additions
effectively
made
in
Assessment Order are not based upon
reasons recorded and the legal pleas
taken by Appellant are discussed
elaborately by various courts and
the courts have taken a view that
when
on
the
ground
on
which
reassessment was based, addition is
not made by AO in reassessment
order, he cannot make additions on
other grounds which do not form part
of reasons recorded by him.
4.9 In view of above discussions and
factual
matrix
of
the
case
and
respectfully following the decisions
of Hon'ble Jurisdictional High Court
of Gujarat in the case of CIT vs.
Mohmed
Junded
[2013]
taxmann.com
1(Gujarat)/[2013]
taxman
(Gujarat)/355
Dadani
ITR
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
(Guj),
Hon'ble
Jurisdictional
Tribunal in Appellant's own case and
other decisions
and
as mentioned
above
also
as
relied
upon
by
the
Appellant
on
similar
issue
to
the
Appellant's case, I find that claim
of Appellant is correct.
4.10
In
addition
to
above
and
on
perusal of reasons recorded by AO,
which is reproduced herein above, it
is
apparent
that
major
issue
for
alleged escapement of income relates
to payment from NSEL for Rs.244.98
crores.
In
Appellant
has
transactions
figure
the
of
present
year,
not
carried
with
NSEL
alleged
the
out
and
any
even
escapement
of
income pertains to addition made by
AO
for
A.Y.2011-12.
elaborately
paras
reasons
which
This
discussed
makes
recorded
by
in
it
AO
issue
is
preceding
clear
that
are
based
upon factually incorrect details or
same are non-existing.”
C/TAXAP/449/2025
3.6
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
The CIT(Appeals) relied upon the
following decisions:
1.
Amar
Jewellers
Ltd
vs.
Deputy
Commissioner of Income Tax reported
in [2018] 92 taxmann.com 4;
2.
Narendrakumar Mansukhbhai Patel vs.
Income Tax Officer Ward 1(2)(3)
reported in [2018] 92 taxmann.com
259;
3.
Mahadev Trading Co. vs. Income Tax
Officer,Ward-5(4) reported in 18
taxmann.com 353;
4.
Sunbarg Tradelink (p.) Ltd vs.
Income Tax Officer reported in
[2016] 74 taxmann.com 16;
5. Ambience Business Services Pvt. Ltd
vs. DCIT in Writ Petition NO. 2608
of 2019 dated 28.11.2019;
6.
Shamshad
Khan
vs.
Assistant
Commissioner of Income Tax dated
11.04.2017 82 taxmann.com 35;
7.
M/s. Gujarat Eco Textile Park Ltd
vs. ACIT in SCA No. 4017 of 2016
dated 05.07.2016;
8.
Mitul Gems vs. ACIT reported
[2015] 62 taxmann.com 66 (Guj.);
in
C/TAXAP/449/2025
9.
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
Oriental Insurance Co. vs. CIT
reported in [2015] 63 taxmann.com
171 [Delhi];
10. Asharam
Ashram
vs
Income
Tax
Officer (Exemption) Ward No.1 in
SCA
No.
of
dated
20.07.2016.
Considering
the
reassessment
notice
escapement
alleged
above
decisions,
the
on
the
ground
of
of
income
for
the
transactions made with NSEL was held to be
not justified by CIT(Appeals).
3.7
With regard to the second issue of
alleged
escapement
relating
to
computation of disallowance under Section
14A
of
the
Act
is
concerned,
the
CIT
(Appeals) held as under:
“4.11 So far as second issue of
alleged
escapement
relating
to
computation of disallowance under
Section 14A is concerned, it is
observed that original assessment
under Section 143(3) of the Act was
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
already
passed
on
29/12/2011
wherein after detailed discussion
AO has made disallowance under
Section 14A at Rs.1,13,521/-. The
discussion was made at para 8 of
the order. The reassessment notice
is issued only for re-computation
of disallowance under Section 14A
made in Assessment Order. It is an
undisputed
fact
that
the
reassessment notice was issued on
9th March, 2015 which means that
such notice is issued beyond four
years
from
end
of
relevant
Assessment Year. On perusal of
reasons recorded, it is seen that
AO has not mentioned whether there
was failure on part of assessee to
disclose
truly
and
fully
all
material facts necessary for making
assessment
as
required
by
Provisions of Section 147. No new
material/tangible material has been
brought on record by AO which
justify such reassessment notice
and on the contrary, re-computation
is made based upon facts already on
the record of AO. Thus, issuance of
notice for alleged escapement of
income by making re-computation of
disallowance u/s 14A on same issue
is certainly change of opinion on
part of subsequent AO. Further, it
is important to note that before
passing of the Assessment Order,
Hon'ble Ahmedabad ITAT had already
deleted disallowance under Section
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
14A made
Order.”
3.8
in
original
Assessment
The CIT(Appeals) relied upon the
decision
of
this
Court
in
the
case
of
Sandesh Procon LLP in ITAT vs Assistant
Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 3(3),
Ahmedabad
in
Special
Civil
Application
No. 19990 of 2019, dated 5th February 2021,
on similar facts. In addition to above,
reliance
was
placed
on
the
following
decisions:
(i) Adani Enterprises Ltd. vs.Assistant
Commissioner of Income Tax (ACIT) / Deputy
Commissioner of Income Tax (DCIT) reported
in 101 taxmann.com 91;
(ii) DCIT vs. Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance
Company Ltd. Reported in [2021] 125
taxmann.com 71;
(iii)
M/s. Tech Span India Private Ltd
reported in [2018] 92 taxmann.com 361;
(iv)E-Inforchips
Ltd
vs.
Assistant
Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 2(1)(1)
reported in [2018] 99 taxmann.com 84;
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
(v) Sun pharmaceutical Industries Ltd vs.
DCIT reported in [2020] 272 taxmann.com
407.
Considering
the
above
decisions,
CIT(Appeals) held that reassessment notice
relating to alleged escapement of income
relating to disallowance under Section 14A
is mere change of opinion on part of the
subsequent
Assessing
reassessment
notice
Officer
issued
by
and
AO
is
nothing but an invalid notice. Therefore,
CIT(Appeals) allowed additional ground of
appeal
filed
by
Appellant
and
quashed
reassessment order.
3.9
Being aggrieved by the order of
the CIT (Appeals), the Revenue preferred
an appeal before the Tribunal, and the
assessee
challenging
preferred
the
cross-objections
directions
of
the
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
Assessing
Officer
to
conduct
a
special
audit under Section 142(2A) of the Act,
as well as on merits.
3.10
The
Tribunal,
after
considering the submissions made by both
sides as well as the order passed by the
CIT
(Appeals),
dismissed
the
appeal
of
the Revenue, upholding the order passed
by
the
CIT
reassessment
(Appeals)
order
quashing
being
the
without
jurisdiction. Consequently, the addition
made
under
Section
43(5)
read
with
Sections 73 and 40A(2)(b) of the Act of
Rs. 13,89,08,810/- was also quashed and
set aside. As a consequence, the crossobjections
filed
by
the
assessee
supporting the order of the CIT (Appeals)
were allowed.
C/TAXAP/449/2025
4.
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
Learned Senior Standing Counsel Mr. Varun
Patel
submitted
that
the
Tribunal
has
committed an error in upholding the order
of the CIT (Appeals) without considering
the
fact
that
once
an
assessment
is
would
be
open
the
reopened,
it
Assessing
Officer
to
examine
for
the
other
issues which arise during the course of
reassessment proceedings.
4.1
It was further submitted that the
Assessing Officer was justified in making
addition
on
disallowance
under
Section
43(5) read with Section 73, as well as
under Section 14A of the Act.
4.2
It
was
submitted
that
the
disallowance under Section 14A of the Act
was
wrongly
amount
worked
received
from
out,
NSEL
whereas,
was
in
the
the
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
nature of income brought into the account
of the debtors in the guise of so-called
paper trade, which was rightly taxed in
the hands of the assessee-company.
5.
On
the
Mr.
other
Dhinal
hand,
Shah
learned
submitted
Advocate
that
the
CIT(Appeals) and the Tribunal have rightly
referred to and relied upon the decision
of this Court in the case of CIT v. Mohmed
Juned
reported
Dadani,
in
(2013)
taxmann.com (1).
5.1
It was further submitted that no
addition
can
be
made
on
account
of
Section 43(5) of the Act, as the assessee
claimed that no transaction was carried
out through the NSEL for the year under
consideration, which was also accepted by
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
the special auditor in the report under
Section
142A
of
the
Act,
whereas,
the
figure of Rs. 244.98 crores was nothing
but an addition made in the assessee's
own case for Assessment Year 2011–12 in
the
regular
assessment
order
passed
on
21.11.2014, and the Tribunal deleted such
addition by an order dated 16.11.2022.
5.2
It was, therefore, submitted that
the income escaped, as mentioned in the
reasons
recorded
Officer,
does
by
not
the
Assessing
relate
to
the
Assessment Year 2009–10. Hence, both the
CIT
(Appeals)
rightly
held
and
that
the
the
Tribunal
reassessment
proceedings are liable to be quashed.
have
C/TAXAP/449/2025
5.3
in
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
Learned advocate Mr. Dhinal Shah,
support
of
his
submissions,
relied
upon the following decisions:
1. Commissioner of Income Tax-II vs.
Mohmed Juned Dadani reported in [2014] 355
ITR 172 (Guj.);
2. Commissioner of Income Tax-5, Mumbai
vs. Jet Airways (I) Ltd reported in [2011]
331 ITR 236 (Bom);
3. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax
vs. Sunlight Tour and Travels (P.) Ltd
reported in [2024] 169 taxmann.com 673
(Delhi);
4. Sipura
Developers
(P.)
Ltd
Principal
Commissioner
of
Income
reported in [2024] 168 taxmann.com
(Delhi);
vs.
Tax
5. Yashoda
Shivappa
Naganhoudar
vs.
Income Tax Officer reported in [2022] 138
taxmann.com 296 (Bombay);
6. Principal Commissioenr of Income Tax
vs. Lark Chemicals (P.) Ltd reported in
[2018] 99 taxmann.com 312;
7. Principal Commissioner of Income Tax
(Centra)-3,
New
Delhi
vs.
Jakhotia
Plastics (P.) Ltd reported in
[2018] 94
taxamann.com 89 (Delhi);
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
8. Jakhotia
Plastics
(P.)
Ltd
vs.
Principal
Commissioner
of
Income
Tax
reported in [2018] 94 taxmann.com 96 (SC).
6.
Having heard the learned Advocates for the
parties
and
on
perusal
of
the
reasons
recorded, and on perusal of the assessment
order passed under Section 147 read with
Section 143(3) of the Act, it emerges that
no
addition
Officer
for
is
the
made
by
the
reasons
Assessing
recorded
for
reopening of the assessment and therefore,
there was no failure on the part of the
assessee for true and full disclosure of
the
income
which
can
be
said
to
have
escaped the assessment.
7.
The regular assessment order under Section
143(3)
of
the
Act
was
passed
on
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
29.12.2011, assessing the total income at
Rs.
22,55,48,602/-.
reassessment
Thereafter,
notice
was
the
issued
under
Section 148 of the Act on 09.03.2015, that
is,
beyond
years,
four
years,
recording
the
but
within
six
aforesaid
two
reasons, namely:
(a) Disallowance under Section 14A
read
worked
with
out
Rule
8D
was
at
Rs.
wrongly
1,13,521/-
instead of Rs.2,18,174/- and;
(b) The amount received from NSEL
amounting to Rs.244.98 crores is in
the nature of income brought into
the account of the debtors in the
guise
of
so-called
which
needs
to
be
paper
trade,
taxed
in
the
hands of the assessee company.
8.
The Assessing Officer, while framing the
reassessment order, did not make addition
C/TAXAP/449/2025
in
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
respect
recorded
of
for
any
of
the
reopening.
two
reasons
Therefore,
it
cannot be said that there was any failure
on the part of the assessee in disclosing
such income in the return of income so as
to confer jurisdiction upon the Assessing
Officer to reopen the assessment beyond
four years, in view of the decision of
this Court in the case of Mohmed Juned
Dadani
(supra),
wherein
it
is
held
as
under:
"... 30. We may also approach the
question from a slightly different
angle. It is not in dispute that
once an assessment is reopened by a
valid
exercise
of
jurisdiction
under Section 147 of the Act, it is
open for the Assessing Officer to
assess or reassess any income which
had escaped assessment which comes
to his light during the course of
his assessment proceedings which
was not mentioned in the reason for
issuing notice under Section 148 of
the
Act.
In
a
notice
for
reassessment which has been issued
beyond a period of four years from
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
the end of relevant assessment
year, the condition that income
chargeable
to
tax
has
escaped
assessment for the reason of the
failure on the part of the assessee
to disclose truly and fully all
material facts for the purpose of
assessment must also be established
unless of course some other ground
viz. non-filing of the return at
all etc. is available to the
Assessing Officer. If such nondisclosure of material facts is
established with respect to the
reason recorded for issuing notice
for reopening the assessment, it
would be open for the Assessing
Officer to thereafter even assess
other
income
which
might
have
escaped assessment but which may
not
necessarily
satisfy
the
requirement of non-disclosure of
true and full material facts. If in
such a situation, the stand of the
revenue
is
accepted,
a
very
incongruent situation would come
about if ultimately the Assessing
Officer were to drop the ground on
which notice for reopening had been
issued but to chase some other
grounds
not
so
mentioned
for
issuance of the notice. In such a
situation, even if a case where
notice
for
reopening
has
been
issued beyond a period of four
years,
the
assessment
would
continue even though on all the
grounds on which the additions are
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
being made, there was no failure on
the
part
of
the
assessee
to
disclose true and full material
facts. In such a situation an
important requirement of failure on
part of the
assessee to disclose
truly and fully all material facts
would be totally circumvented.
31. As already noted, except for
the Punjab and Haryana High Court
in case of Majinder Singh Kang
(supra) all courts have uniformly
taken a view that Explanation 3 to
Section 147 of the Act does not
change the situation insofar as the
present controversy is concerned.
Leading decision of Bombay High
Court in case of Jet Airways (I)
Ltd. (supra) has been followed by
different High Courts. In case of
Jet Airways (I) Ltd. (supra) the
High
Court,
in
its
elaborate
decision considering the statutory
provisions,
different
judicial
pronouncements and the explanatory
memorandum
for
introduction
of
Explanation 3 to Section 147 of the
Act
ruled
in
favour
of
the
assessee."
9.
After
considering
the
scheme
of
the
reassessment under Sections 147 and 148 of
the Act, the Tribunal has rightly upheld
C/TAXAP/449/2025
the
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
order
of
the
CIT
(Appeals)
by
observing as under:
“7.1. On first reason for reopening
being
disallowance
u/s.14A
for
Rs.2,18,174/- is concerned, it is
observed that addition u/s.14A for
Rs.1,13,521/- was made in original
Assessment Order dated 29-12-2011.
On appeal before this Tribunal vide
Appellate Order dated 27-07-2016 in
ITA No.1986 & 2133/Ahd/2012, Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal
deleted the addition on account of
disallowance u/s.14A, since the
assessee
has
not
received
any
dividend income during this Asst.
year following jurisdictional High
Court judgement.
“8. On
second
reason
for
reopening the assessment, the
assessee claimed that it had
no transaction carried out
with NSEL in the present asst
year, which is also accepted
by the Special Auditor in his
report u/s.142A of the Act.
Whereas
the
figure
of
Rs.244.98 crores was nothing
but
addition
made
in
Assessee's own case for the
Asst. Year 2011-12 in the
regular
Assessment
Order
passed
on
21-11-2014.
On
appeal before this Tribunal
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
vide Appellate Order dated 1611-2022
in
ITA
Nos.328
&
329/Ahd/2017 deleted the above
addition also. Therefore the
income escaped as mentioned in
the 'reason recorded' by the
Ld AO is not relating to the
present Asst. year 2009-10 the
same is invalid in the eyes of
law and the reassessment is
liable to be quashed.
9. Now next question that arise
for
our
consideration
is
whether the AO can proceed with
assessing any other escaped
income, when NO addition is
made on account of the reasons
recorded
by
the
AO
for
reassessment. This issue is
also no more res-integra by
judgements
of
various
High
Courts
more
particularly
jurisdictional High Court in
the case of Mohmed Juned Dadani
[cited supra] wherein it was
held that when the ground on
which reopening of assessment
and no addition was made by the
Ld AO, he could not make
additions on some other grounds
which did not form part of
reasons recorded by him by
observing as follows:
"... 23. Section 147 of the
Act, even without the aid of
Explanation 3 thus enabled
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
the Assessing Officer while
framing an assessment under
Section 147 of the Act, to
assess
or
reassess
such
income for which he had
recorded
his
reasons
to
believe
had
escaped
assessment
and
also
any
other income which escaped
assessment which came to his
notice subsequently in the
course
of
the
assessment
proceedings.
24. Sans explanation (3),
Section 147 of the Act,
however, by no stretch of
imagination,
can
be
construed as to provide that
if the reason on which the
assessment
is
reopened
fails, the Assessing Officer
still can proceed to assess
some
other
income
which
according to him had escaped
assessment and which came to
his light during the course
of
the
assessment.
For
assuming
jurisdiction
to
frame an assessment under
Section 147 of the Act what
is essential is a valid
reopening of a previously
closed assessment. If the
very
foundation
of
the
reopening is knocked out,
any further proceeding in
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
respect to such assessment
naturally would not survive.
25.
A
question
may
therefore,
arise
whether
introduction of Explanation
(3)
would
change
this
position
and
for
that
purpose we need to ascertain
what is true purport of
Explanation
and
the
purpose for which the same
was introduced. Let us have
a
closer
look
to
such
Explanation which provides
that for the purpose of
assessment or reassessment
under the said section, the
Assessing Officer may assess
or reassess the income in
respect of any issue which
escaped assessment and which
comes
to
his
notice
subsequently in the course
of reassessment proceedings.
The
explanation
further
provides that this would be
so notwithstanding that the
reasons for such issue have
not been included in the
reasons
recorded
under
Section 148(2).
26. If the contention of the
assessee
that
even
after
introduction of Explanation
3 to Section 147 of the Act,
the
situation
has
not
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
undergone
any
material
change
is
accepted,
the
question
that
immediately
would come to one's mind is,
what then was the purpose of
introducing
such
an
explanation. An argument may
arise that if before and
after
introduction
of
Explanation 3, the nature of
jurisdiction
exercised
by
the Assessing Officer was
not to undergo any change,
would Explanation 3 not be
rendered
redundant.
Would
such a situation not run
counter to a well known
legal
principle
that
the
Legislature cannot be seen
to have enacted a redundant
legislation and that every
effort should be made to
give
such
interpretation
which
ensures
that
a
provision in a statute is
not rendering otiose. Such
question may have led to
some interesting discussion.
However, the entire issue
has been put beyond any pale
of controversy by virtue of
the explanatory memorandum
for
introducing
such
explanation.
Such
explanatory memorandum reads
as under:
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
"Clarificatory amendment
in
respect
of
reassessment Proceeding
under section 147
The existing provisions
of section 147 provides,
inter alia, that if the
Assessing
officer
has
reason to believe that
any income chargeable to
tax
has
escaped
assessment
for
any
assessment year, he may
assess or reassess such
income after recording
reasons
for
reopening
the assessment. Further,
he may also assess or
reassess
such
other
income which has escaped
assessment
and
which
comes
to
his
notice
subsequently
in
the
course
of
proceedings
under this section.
Some courts have held
that
the
Assessing
Officer has to restrict
the
reassessment
proceedings
only
to
issues in respect of
which the reasons have
been
recorded
for
reopening
the
assessment. He is not
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
empowered to touch upon
any
other
issue
for
which no reasons have
been recorded. The above
interpretation
is
contrary
to
the
legislative intent.
With a view to further
clarifying
the
legislative intent, it
is proposed to insert an
Explanation in section
147 to provide that the
Assessing
Officer
may
assess
or
reassess
income in respect of any
issue which comes to his
notice subsequently in
the
course
of
proceedings under this
section, notwithstanding
that the reason for such
issue
has
not
been
included in the reasons
recorded
under
subsection (2) of section
148.
This amendment will take
effect
retrospectively
from 1st April, 1989 and
will, accordingly, apply
in
relation
to
assessment
year
19891990
and
subsequent
years."
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
27. From the above, it can
be seen that the explanation
was
meant
to
be
clarificatory in nature and
to put the issue beyond any
legal controversy. When the
Legislature found that in
face
of
the
provisions
contained in Section 147 of
the Act post 01.04.1989 some
of the courts had taken a
view
that
the
Assessing
Officer is restricted to the
reassessment
proceedings
only on issues in respect of
which
the
reasons
were
recorded for reopening the
assessment, such explanation
was
introduced
in
the
statute.
Thus,
the
explanation was meant to be
merely
clarificatory
in
nature and was introduced
with the purpose of putting
at
rest
the
legal
controversy
regarding
the
true
interpretation
of
Section 147 of the Act which
had arisen on account of
certain
judicial
pronouncements.
We
have
noticed
that
prior
to
enactment of Explanation 3
to Section 147, Punjab and
Haryana High Court in case
of Commissioner of Income
Tax
v.
Atlas
Cycle
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
Industries reported in 180
ITR 319 (supra) had taken a
restricted view of the power
of the Assessing Officer to
make any addition on the
grounds not mentioned in the
reasons
recorded
for
reopening the assessment. We
may also notice that Kerela
High
Court
in
case
of
Travencore Cements Ltd. v.
Asstt. CIT [2008] 305 ITR
170/[2009] 179 Taxman 117
had taken somewhat similar
stand.
28. Explanation 3 to Section
147 of the Act thus does not
in any manner, even purport
to expand the powers of the
Assessing
Officer
under
Section 147 of the Act. In
any
case,
an
explanation
cannot expand the scope and
sweep of the main body of
the statutory provision. In
case of S.Sundaram Pillal v.
V.R. Pattabiraman AIR 1985
(SC) 582 the Supreme Court
observed
that,
an
explanation
added
to
a
statutory provision is not a
substantive provision but as
the plain meaning of the
word itself shows it is
merely meant to explain or
clarify certain ambiguities
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
which may have crept in the
statutory provision. It was
observed as under:
"52.
Thus,
from
a
conspectus
of
the
authorities referred to
above, it is manifest
that the object of an
Explanation
to
a
statutory provision is(a) to explain the
meaning and intendment
of the Act itself.
(b) where there is any
obscurity or vagueness
in the main enactment,
to clarify the same so
as to make it consistent
with the dominant object
which
it
seems
to
subserve.
(c)
to
provide
an
additional
support
to
the dominant object of
the Act in order to make
it
meaningful
and
purposeful.
(d)
an
Explanation
cannot
in
any
way
interfere with or change
the enactment or any
part thereof but where
some gap is left which
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
is
relevant
for
the
purpose
of
the
Explanation, in order to
suppress
the
mischief
and advance the object
of the Act it can help
or assist the Court in
interpreting
the
true
purport and intendment
of the enactment.
(e) It cannot, however,
take away a statutory
right with which any
person under a statute
has been clothed or set
at naught the working of
an Act by becoming an
hindrance
in
the
interpretation
of
the
same."
29. Above decision has been
referred to and relied upon
in
several
subsequent
decisions. Above proposition
being well settled, it is
not necessary to refer to
all such decisions."
10. It is pertinent to note that Explanation 3
to Section
(No. 2)
147 was
Act, 2009,
inserted by
Finance
which provides
that
C/TAXAP/449/2025
even
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
though
Section
reopening
the
notice
containing
of
the
issued
the
under
reasons
assessment
does
for
not
contain a reference to a particular issue
with reference to which income has escaped
assessment, yet the Assessing Officer may
assess or reassess the income in respect
of any issue which has escaped assessment,
provided such issue comes to his notice
subsequently in the course of proceedings.
However,
the
Explanation
amendment
would
by
not
insertion
of
override
the
necessity of fulfilling the conditions set
out in the substantive part of Section 147
of the Act that there was a failure on the
part of the assessee to make a true and
full
disclosure
of
the
income
escaping
assessment when there is no income that
has escaped assessment as per the reasons
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
recorded, and when no addition is made on
account
of
the
reasons
for
which
the
reassessment was initiated. The ratio of
the
decision
of
this
reiterated
by
the
Court
the
Delhi
and
decisions relied
assessee.
Court
Hon'ble
High
upon on
has
been
Bombay
High
Court
in
the
behalf of
the
The Hon'ble Supreme Court has
also dismissed the SLP arising out of the
judgment and
order passed
by the
Delhi
High Court in case of Jakhotia Plastics
Private Limited (Supra).
11. In view of the above conspectus of law and
the
settled
legal
position
when
the
Tribunal has followed the decision of
the
jurisdictional High Court, we do not find
any legal infirmity in the impugned order
of the Tribunal. We are of the opinion
that no question of law, much less any
C/TAXAP/449/2025
ORDER DATED: 04/08/2026
substantial question of law, arises from
the impugned order of the Tribunal. The
appeal,
accordingly stands dismissed.
(BHARGAV D. KARIA, J)
(PRANAV TRIVEDI,J)
JYOTI V. JANI
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review