Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 27th April 2026
%
+
MAC.APP. 357/2018 & CM APPL. 14082/2018
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pankaj Seth, Advocate with Ms.
Shruti Jain, Advocate.
versus
LATA PUNJANI & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Durgesh Gupta, Advocate for
claimant.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed assailing impugned judgment and award
dated 30th November 2017, passed by Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal
(‘MACT/Tribunal’) Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi, in MACT Case No.
357829/2016, awarding compensation of Rs. 32,28,000/- along with interest
at the rate of 9% per annum, with respect to an accident which occurred on
14th August 2005.
2.
Deceased/Vijay Punjani, along with his family members and two
other relatives, was returning to Delhi from Agra in a Santro Car bearing
No. DL 3C XP 7777. At about 6:30 am, when they reached near village
Prithla, the deceased saw a green colour L&T Tractor-trolley (hereinafter,
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
20:13:45
MAC APP 357/2018
1 of 10
‘offending vehicle’) loaded with bricks driving in the middle of the road. In
an attempt to overtake the offending vehicle, which gave way to the
deceased to pass from the right side, the offending vehicle steered towards
the right side diagonally without any warning, horn or signal resulting in
collision with the front portion of the Santro car, which was badly smashed.
Multiple injuries were suffered by various persons and deceased/Vijay
Punjani succumbed to the said injuries.
3.
Appellant/Insurance Company has filed this appeal challenging the
quantum of compensation awarded to respondent no.1/injured claimant-Lata
Punjani (wife of Vijay Pujani) for the injuries sustained by her. As a result of
the accident, she suffered 40% permanent disability in relation to her left
lower and left upper limb.
4.
Mr. Pankaj Seth, counsel for appellant/Insurance Company, has raised
the following issues: Firstly, minimum wages assessed by the Tribunal for
respondent no.1/injured claimant, have been computed on the basis of a
skilled worker, despite the fact that she was a homemaker; secondly, even
otherwise, minimum wages of the year 2008 have been taken, despite the
accident having occurred in 2005; thirdly, minimum wages had been
enhanced by 1.5 times by the Tribunal, considering that minimum wages for
a skilled workers are for the working hours, whereas, a homemaker performs
24 hours without any break; fourthly, loss of income was given at Rs.
3,65,100/- for the period of 5 years from 2005 to 2010, calculated at Rs.
6,085/-, considering that she had multiple surgeries, but while calculating
loss of future income, the Tribunal mistakenly included this amount to form
a part of compensation awarded at Rs.14,60,400/-.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
20:13:45
MAC APP 357/2018
2 of 10
5.
On the other hand, Mr. Durgesh Gupta, counsel for respondent
no.1/injured claimant, contends that future prospects have been granted at
25%, despite respondent no.1/injured claimant being 34 years of age on the
date of the accident, therefore, 40% ought to have been granted.
6.
In order to align the compensation on the basis of these assertions,
after having perused the records, Court is of the opinion that the Tribunal
was not amiss in calculating monthly income on the basis of minimum
wages of a skilled worker for the services of a homemaker. This issue has
already been considered by the Supreme Court in Kirti v. Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd., (2021) 2 SCC 166 wherein, the Supreme Court relied
upon Arun Kumar Agrawal v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., (2010) 9 SCC
218 and observed as under:
“21. In Arun Kumar Agrawal v. National Insurance Co.
Ltd., this Court, while dealing with the grant of
compensation for the death of a housewife due to a motor
vehicle accident, held as follows:
“26. In India the courts have recognised that the
contribution made by the wife to the house is
invaluable and cannot be computed in terms of money.
The gratuitous services rendered by the wife with true
love and affection to the children and her husband and
managing the household affairs cannot be equated with
the services rendered by others. A wife/mother does not
work by the clock. She is in the constant attendance of
the family throughout the day and night unless she is
employed and is required to attend the employer's work
for particular hours. She takes care of all the
requirements of the husband and children including
cooking of food, washing of clothes, etc. She teaches
small children and provides invaluable guidance to
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
20:13:45
MAC APP 357/2018
3 of 10
them for their future life. A housekeeper or
maidservant can do the household work, such as
cooking food, washing clothes and utensils, keeping the
house clean, etc. but she can never be a substitute for a
wife/mother who renders selfless service to her
husband and children.
27. It is not possible to quantify any amount in lieu of
the services rendered by the wife/mother to the family
i.e. the husband and children. However, for the
purpose of award of compensation to the dependants,
some pecuniary estimate has to be made of the services
of the housewife/mother. In that context, the term
“services” is required to be given a broad meaning
and must be construed by taking into account the loss
of personal care and attention given by the deceased to
her children as a mother and to her husband as a wife.
They are entitled to adequate compensation in lieu of
the loss of gratuitous services rendered by the
deceased. The amount payable to the dependants
cannot be diminished on the ground that some close
relation like a grandmother may volunteer to render
some of the services to the family which the deceased
was giving earlier.”
The above pronouncement has been followed by this Court
in its recent judgment in Rajendra Singh v. National
Insurance Co. Ltd. [Rajendra Singh v. National Insurance
Co. Ltd., (2020) 7 SCC 256 : (2020) 4 SCC (Civ) 99 :
(2020) 3 SCC (Cri) 134] , wherein the notional income of a
deceased housewife was calculated for the purposes of
granting compensation in a motor accident case.”
(emphasis added)
7.
As regards calculating the benchmark income of the housewife, the
Court in Kirti (supra), made the following observations:
“31. Returning to the question of how such notional income
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
20:13:45
MAC APP 357/2018
4 of 10
of a homemaker is to be calculated, there can be no fixed
approach. It is to be understood that in such cases the
attempt by the court is to fix an approximate economic value
for all the work that a homemaker does, impossible though
that task may be. Courts must keep in mind the idea of
awarding just compensation in such cases, looking to the
facts and circumstances.
…
34. However, it must be remembered that all the above
methods are merely suggestions. There can be no exact
calculation or formula that can magically ascertain the true
value provided by an individual gratuitously for those that
they are near and dear to. The attempt of the court in such
matters should therefore be towards determining, in the best
manner possible, the truest approximation of the value
added by a homemaker for the purpose of granting
monetary compensation.
35. Whichever method a court ultimately chooses to value
the activities of a homemaker, would ultimately depend on
the facts and circumstances of the case. The court needs to
keep in mind its duty to award just compensation, neither
assessing the same conservatively, nor so liberally as to
make it a bounty to claimants.”
(emphasis added)
8.
On the issue of minimum wages prevalent in Delhi at the time of
accident i.e. in 2005, ought to have been taken, from as rightly contended by
Mr. Pankaj Seth, counsel for appellant/Insurance Company. Therefore,
monthly income of respondent no.1/injured claimant will be considered as
Rs.3468.9/-.
9.
Enhancement of monthly income by 1.5 times on a notional basis,
considering the minimum wages are for working hours and not for 24 hours
services that a homemaker is expected to do, may not be a rational
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
20:13:45
MAC APP 357/2018
5 of 10
assessment,
therefore,
that
aspect
stands
deleted.
It
would
be
disproportionate to introduce an additional factor of 1.5 to the notional
wages.
10.
Loss of future income has been wrongly calculated by including loss
of income assessed by the MACT during the period of treatment, therefore,
that aspect shall stand modified.
11.
Future prospects shall be taken as 40% as per National Insurance
Company Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680.
12.
As
regards
the
compensation
awarded
towards
loss
of
inconvenience/hardship/disappointment/mental stress, in view of the
decision in Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar, (2011) 1 SCC 343, compensation
towards this head cannot be awarded under a separate head as these
elements are already subsumed within the recognised heads of pain and
suffering and loss of amenities of life.
13.
This Court has also perused the compensation awarded towards non-
pecuniary loss, reference may be drawn to the decision of the Supreme
Court in R.D. Hattangadi v. Pest Control (India) (P) Ltd., (1995) 1 SCC
551 where the Court has examined various heads under which pecuniary and
special damages are awarded. The Court noted that no amount of
compensation can restore the physical frame of the injured claimant and
therefore, the object is to compensate such injury “so far as money can
compensate”, since it is impossible to equate money with human sufferings
or personal deprivations. Relevant observations of the Supreme Court are
extracted as under:
“11. In the case Ward v. James [(1965) 1 All ER 563] it was
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
20:13:45
MAC APP 357/2018
6 of 10
said:
“Although you cannot give a man so gravely injured
much for his ‘lost years’, you can, however,
compensate him for his loss during his shortened span,
that is, during his expected ‘years of survival’. You can
compensate him for his loss of earnings during that
time, and for the cost of treatment, nursing and
attendance. But how can you compensate him for being
rendered a helpless invalid? He may, owing to brain
injury, be rendered unconscious for the rest of his
days, or, owing to a back injury, be unable to rise from
his bed. He has lost everything that makes life
worthwhile. Money is no good to him. Yet judges and
juries have to do the best they can and give him what
they think is fair. No wonder they find it well nigh
insoluble. They are being asked to calculate the
incalculable. The figure is bound to be for the most
part a conventional sum. The judges have worked out a
pattern, and they keep it in line with the changes in the
value of money.
12. In its very nature whenever a tribunal or a court is
required to fix the amount of compensation in cases of
accident, it involves some guesswork, some hypothetical
consideration, some amount of sympathy linked with the
nature of the disability caused. But all the aforesaid
elements have to be viewed with objective standards.
…
14. In Halsbury's Laws of England, 4th Edn., Vol. 12
regarding non-pecuniary loss at page 446 it has been said:
“Non-pecuniary loss: the pattern.— Damages awarded for
pain and suffering and loss of amenity constitute a
conventional sum which is taken to be the sum which society
deems fair, fairness being interpreted by the courts in the
light of previous decisions. Thus there has been evolved a
set of conventional principles providing a provisional guide
to the comparative severity of different injuries, and
indicating a bracket of damages into which a particular
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
20:13:45
MAC APP 357/2018
7 of 10
injury will currently fall. The particular circumstances of
the plaintiff, including his age and any unusual deprivation
he may suffer, is reflected in the actual amount of the
award.
The fall in the value of money leads to a continuing
reassessment of these awards and to periodic reassessments
of damages at certain key points in the pattern where the
disability is readily identifiable and not subject to large
variations in individual cases.”
(emphasis added)
14.
In view of this, the Court is inclined to increase compensation
awarded towards loss of amenities of life and mental and physical shock by
Rs. 1,00,000/- each.
15.
Sr.
No.
Therefore, revised computation is as under:
Heads
Awarded by the
Tribunal
Awarded by
this Court
PECUNIARY LOSS
6.
7.
Expenditure on Medical
Expenses (A)
Expenditure on conveyance
(B)
Expenditure on special diet
(C)
Expenditure on attendant
charges (D)
Income of injured (E)
Rs. 10,53,031/-
Rs. 10,53,031/-
Rs. 27,500/-
Rs. 27,500/-
Rs. 60,000/-
Rs. 60,000/-
Rs. 60,000/-
Rs. 60,000/-
Rs. 6,085/-
Rs.3,468.9/-
Add: Future prospects (F)
Multiplier (G)
Functional disability (H)
Loss of income (I)
Loss of future income/future
earnings [(E+F) x 12 x G x
25%
Rs. 3,65,100/Rs. 14,60,400/-
Rs. 1,387.56/16
25%
Rs. 2,08,134/Rs. 2,33,110/-
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
20:13:45
MAC APP 357/2018
8 of 10
H] = (J)
NON-PECUNIARY LOSS
Pain and suffering (K)
Loss of amenities of life (L)
Mental and Physical Shock
(M)
Disfiguration (N)
Loss
of
inconvenience/hardship/
disappointment/mental stress
(O)
Total compensation (A + B +
C + D + I + J+ K + L+M+N)
=P
Interest awarded
Rs. 2,00,000/Rs. 1,00,000/Rs. 1,00,000/-
Rs. 2,00,000/Rs. 2,00,000/Rs. 2,00,000/-
Rs. 1,00,000/Rs. 30,000/-
Rs. 1,00,000/Nil
Rs. 32,27,441/(rounded off to Rs.
32,28,000/-)
Rs. 23,41,775/(rounded off to Rs.
23,42,000/-
9%
9%
Directions
16.
In view of the above computation, the compensation payable to
respondent no.1/claimant has been reduced by Rs. 8,86,000/- along with
interest at the rate of 9% per annum, as awarded by the MACT.
17.
Vide order dated 11th April 2018, this Court had directed the
appellant/Insurance Company to deposit the entire awarded amount with upto-date interest before the Tribunal within 30 days and 40% amount was
directed to be released in favour of respondent no.1/injured claimant. The
balance amount was directed to be kept in an interest-bearing account
initially for a period of one year to be renewed from time to time, thereafter
till further orders from this Court.
18.
In case any excess amount has been deposited by the Insurance
Company, same shall be refunded to the Insurance Company, along with
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
20:13:45
MAC APP 357/2018
9 of 10
accrued interest thereon. The claimants shall be entitled to release of the
balance amount in terms of the directions contained in the impugned award.
19.
Accordingly, the appeal is disposed of. Pending applications (if any)
are rendered infructuous.
20.
Copy of the judgment be sent to the concerned MACT.
21.
Statutory deposit be refunded to appellant/Insurance Company, only if
the order of deposit has been complied with.
22.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL
JUDGE
APRIL 27, 2026/RK/sp
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
20:13:45
MAC APP 357/2018
10 of 10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review