Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on
: 11th August 2026
Pronounced on : 05th October 2026
Uploaded on
: 06th October 2026
+
MAC.APP. 263/2017 & CM APPL. 10252/2017
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. A.K. Soni and Mr. Pavan
Kumar, Advs.
versus
DALIP KUMAR GUPTA & ORS
Through:
…..Respondents
Ms. Parul Dutta, Adv. for R-2 & 3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J.
1.
This appeal has been filed by the Insurance Company assailing the
impugned judgment dated 10th January 2017 passed by Motor Accident
Claims
Tribunal,
South
District,
Saket
Courts,
New
Delhi
(‘MACT/Tribunal’) in MACT No. 75478/2016 by which compensation
of Rs. 34,08,200/- along with 8% interest per annum was awarded.
The Incident
2.
The accident occurred on 27 th April 2011 at about 7:30 pm near
Gate No. 2, AIIMS Hospital, in front of bus stand, Ring Road, New
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
Delhi when the door of Honda City Car bearing no. HR-26-M-7364
(hereinafter, ‘offending vehicle’) was suddenly opened by respondent
no.9/driver. The car door hit against the leg of Smt. Chander Prabha
(hereinafter, ‘deceased’) who was riding as a pillion rider on the
motorcycle no. DL-3S-BJ-4679. Due to the accident, the motorcyclist
lost balance and they fell on the road, as a result of which the pillion
rider sustained fatal injuries.
3.
The deceased was 47 years of age and was working as an
Accounts Officer, earning gross salary of Rs. 2,67,000/-. The claim
petition was instituted by her husband, daughter and son (hereinafter,
‘claimants’).
4.
Respondent no.4/Gaurav Sharma was the registered owner of the
offending vehicle and contested the claim petition by stating that the
vehicle had already been sold to respondent no.5/Gaurav Mittal on 11th
October 2010. It was further stated that respondent no.5/Gaurav Mittal
had sold the vehicle to respondent no.6/Gurvinder Singh on 16th
November 2010, who subsequently sold it to respondent no.7/Pankaj
Sapra on 4th January 2011, after which it was transferred to Ravi Kant
Sapra and was sold to respondent no.8/SK Bhatia on 28 th June 2011. The
vehicle was recovered from the possession of respondent no.8/SK
Bhatia, the current owner. The offending vehicle was insured with
appellant/Insurance Company.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
The Impugned Award
5.
Respondents/claimants had examined Jot Prakash, Accounts-
Assistant at EFY Enterprises, as ‘PW-1’, who had brought on record the
salary slip, service record and bank statement of deceased. The husband
of claimant was examined as ‘PW-2’, who tendered his evidence in
affidavit as Ex.PW2/A. During the cross-examination, he had stated that
he was not an eye-witness to the accident. Uma Shanker was examined
as ‘PW-3’ and had stated that he was an eye-witness. Dharmender Gupta
was examined as ‘PW-4’ and tendered his evidence by way of affidavit
as ‘Ex PW4/1’. He claimed to be an eyewitness to the accident stating
that he was present on the spot of accident and had informed about the
details of the accident after coming across a pamphlet. Prem Kumar
Khurmi was examined as ‘PW-5’ and was also an eyewitness to the
accident, however, he had not informed the police about the accident.
6.
Appellant/Insurance Company, on the other hand, had examined
SI Harpal Singh, Investigation Officer (‘IO’) as ‘R6W1’ who stated that
he had filed an ‘untraced report’ on 28 th January 2012 and during the
investigation, no involvement of the offending vehicle was found.
7.
As regards the issue of negligence, the Tribunal relied upon the
testimony of eyewitnesses- PW-3 to PW-5 to hold that the accident had
occurred due to rash and negligent driving of respondent no.9/driver.
MACT observed that the matter had not been contested by the driver and
owner, despite having knowledge of the proceedings and the witnesses
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
had only been cross examined by the Insurance Company on the basis of
which no adverse inference could be drawn.
8.
MACT awarded Rs. 34,08,200/- to respondents/claimants by
assessing the annual income of deceased as Rs. 2,67,000/-, relying upon
the evidence tendered by PW-1 and Form-16 presented for assessment
year 2011-2012. 30% was awarded towards future prospects and 1/3 rd
was deducted towards personal and living expenses, by considering her
husband, daughter and son to be dependants. Multiplier of ‘13’ had been
taken. The compensation was tabulated as under:
Heads of compensation
Amounts
Loss of dependency
Rs. 30,08,200/-
Loss of love and affection
Rs. 1,50,000/-
Loss of consortium
Rs. 1,50,000/-
Funeral expenses
Rs. 50,000/-
Loss of estate
Rs. 50,000/-
Total
Rs. 34,08,200/-
Submissions on behalf of Appellant
9.
The primary contention raised by appellant/Insurance Company
was the involvement of offending vehicle in the accident. Mr. A.K. Soni,
counsel for appellant/Insurance Company, drew the attention of the
Court to the FIR, which noted that the accident had occurred due to a
golden Honda City car, however, the registration number of the vehicle
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
could not be noted. The complaint had been filed by driver of the
motorcycle.
10.
Mr. Soni, also drew the Court’s attention to the chargesheet filed
by the IO, which noted that the driver of offending vehicle could not be
traced during the investigation. After 95 days of the occurrence of the
accident, an eyewitness, namely Dharmendra Gupta (PW-4), among
others had reached out to the husband of deceased by finding their
number on a poster and had informed them about registration number of
the offending vehicle. The chargesheet also noted that the husband of
deceased had received the information from PW-4 regarding the
involvement of offending vehicle 30 days prior to giving this statement.
11.
Mr. Soni, further pointed out the Detailed Accident Report
(‘DAR’) filed before the MACT, which noted that as per the Call Detail
Records (‘CDR’) of PW-4, his location was not found to be at the spot of
the accident contradictory to the statement made by him. The Forensic
Science Laboratory (‘FSL’) Report of the car recorded that there were
no signs of impact or fresh repairing and denting.
12.
Appellant/Insurance Company had examined the IO as R6W1,
who stated that an ‘untraced report’ [‘Ex.R6W1 (colly.)’] had been filed
on 28 th January 2012, along with a final report. No involvement of the
offending vehicle was found during investigation of the accident which
had taken place from 28 th April 2011 to 28 th January 2012.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
13.
In his cross-examination, he had stated that a protest petition had
been filed by the respondents/claimants. He further stated that the
vehicle had been exchanged between 5 people and colour of the
offending vehicle was ‘golden’, as alleged. He denied the suggestion that
he had not investigated the case properly.
14.
Mr. Soni, contended that the MACT had erred by relying upon the
testimonies given by PW-3, PW-4 and PW-5, which were not reliable.
15.
PW-3 was the driver of motorcycle and had stated in his cross-
examination that he did not know the registration number of the
offending vehicle and had not informed the police about it. He denied the
suggestion that he had not informed the police about the description of
offending vehicle and the alleged vehicle in question was not involved in
the accident.
16.
PW-4 was a hawker present at the spot of accident selling
handkerchiefs and combs near Tilak Nagar and Sagar Pur. He stated that
he came across a poster on 6th July 2011 seeking details of the accident
which had occurred on 27 th April 2011 and had thereafter, provided the
information to the husband of deceased. In his cross-examination, he
stated that on the date of accident, he was returning from Kalkaji Mandir
and got down at the AIIMS bus stop. He had noted down the vehicle
number on a visiting card. He stated that he had not reported the accident
to the police and that he did not know the family of deceased prior to the
accident.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
17.
PW-5 was also stated to be an eyewitness and he stated that he did
not inform the police about the accident. He was travelling towards
Uttam Nagar from Faridabad on the day of accident and was present at
the bus stop when the accident took place.
18.
Mr. Soni, stated that while the evidence of PW-3 to PW-5 had
been discussed in the impugned award, however, the evidence of R6W1
had not been discussed by the MACT. Furthermore, name of the driver
had not been invoked in the criminal proceedings.
19.
Mr. Soni, placed reliance on the decision of this Court in Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Naresh Kumar & Ors. 2026:DHC:2876, whereby,
the Court was examining a case where the IO had received information
regarding the number of offending vehicle after 47 days of the accident,
through an alleged informer. In that case, the case diary, as examined by
the Court had recorded a different offending vehicle. The Court had
noted that the sudden appearance of such ‘highly specific’ information
after 47 days from the registration of the FIR remained unexplained.
Therefore, in view of the facts therein, the appeal of Insurance Company
was allowed.
Submissions on behalf of Respondents
20.
As regards the testimony of witnesses, Ms. Parul Dutta, counsel
for respondents/claimants, stated that while PW-3 had not noted down
the registration number of offending vehicle, he had described the make
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
of the vehicle, being, a Honda City in golden colour to the police on the
date of accident. FIR had also been registered one day after the accident.
21.
In response to the issue of the location of PW-4 at the time of the
accident, Ms. Dutta, stated that the CDR location does not provide an
accurate account and only locates the nearest tower. Moreover, no
question had been put to the witness regarding his location not being the
same as the accident spot.
22.
While the driver and owner had not entered the witness box, Ms.
Dutta, stated that name of the driver had been disclosed by respondent
no.7/Pankaj Sapra, who had sought time file reply, however, had not
filed a reply. It was reiterated that the only witness examined by
appellant/Insurance Company was the IO.
23.
An application had been filed under Order VII Rule 11 of Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (‘CPC’) by the appellant/Insurance Company,
challenging the involvement of vehicle which had been rejected by the
Tribunal. Dismissal of this order had been challenged before this Court
and vide order dated 29 th January 2014, the Tribunal was directed to
frame an additional issue, being, “Whether a Honda City car bearing no.
HR-26-M-7364 was met with an accident on 27.04.2011 at about 7.30
PM with motorcycle bearing no. DL-3S-BJ-4679?”
24.
In response to the query raised by the Court, counsel for
respondents/claimants, stated that no criminal proceedings were
instituted against the driver, considering that an ‘untraced report’ had
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
been filed by the IO, in response to which a protest petition had been
filed by them.
25.
While notice had initially been issued to the driver and owner,
respondent/Gaurav had filed a reply stating that the vehicle had already
been sold by him and after subsequent transactions was recovered from
the possession of respondent/SK Bhatia. Respondent/Pankaj Sapra, who
was the owner at the time of accident had not been examined by
respondents/claimants.
26.
In support of her argument, Ms. Dutta, placed reliance on the
decision of Supreme Court in Anita Sharma v. New India Assurance
Co. Ltd. (2021) 1 SCC 171, whereby, the Court had stated that the
assessment needs to be on the basis of preponderance of probabilities
and not beyond reasonable doubt, as is the case in criminal proceedings.
Fault should not be found merely because the best eyewitnesses have not
been examined.
27.
Further reliance was also placed on the decision of this Court in
Iffco Tokio General Insurance Co Ltd. v. Sunita Rani & Ors.
2023:DHC:6484, where the Court had taken a view that the factum of
involvement of vehicle could not denied, even though he was not an
eyewitness. Further, no doubt can be cast on the involvement of the
vehicle merely because the police did not investigate the accident
properly and identity of the vehicle had been traced out pursuant to
efforts of the family of deceased.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
Analysis
28.
At the outset, Insurance Company has laid a strong challenge as
regards involvement of the vehicle. The accident in question took place
on 27 th April 2011 near gate no. 2, AIIMS Hospital in front of the bus
stand, Ring Road, New Delhi.
29.
The allegation made was that the accident occurred due to opening
of door of the offending vehicle. Respondent no. 4/Gaurav Sharma was
the registered owner, however, the vehicle had undergone multiple
transfers and was recovered from the possession of respondent no. 8/S.
K. Bhatia. Details of the transfer of vehicle have been narrated in
paragraph 4 above. Appellant/Insurance Company was directed to
deposit the compensation amount, since the insurance policy continued
to be in the name of respondent no. 4/Gaurav Sharma.
30.
On an appeal filed by the Insurance Company against the
dismissal of their application under Order VII Rule 11 of Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908, by order dated 29 th January 2014, this Court had
directed MACT to frame the following issue:
“Whether a Honda City car bearing no. HR-26-M7364 was met with an accident on 27.04.2011 at about
7.30 PM with motorcycle bearing no. DL-3S-BJ4679?”
31.
Respondent no.1/husband of deceased examined himself as PW-2,
along with three alleged eyewitnesses, who were examined as PW-3,
PW-4 and PW-5. All three eyewitnesses deposed on the same lines on
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
factum of the accident, by identifying the offending vehicle. While PW-3
and PW-4 were cross-examined by the Insurance Company, PW-5 had
been cross-examined by the owner. As regards the issue of negligence,
MACT had essentially decided the issue in favour of claimants by
relying upon the deposition of eyewitnesses, confirming the involvement
of offending vehicle and factum of the accident.
32.
FIR No. 147/2011 was registered the next day, i.e., 28 th April
2011, on the basis of DD No. 48A registered on the complaint of Uma
Shanker, who was the driver of motorcycle on which the deceased had
been riding as pillion. He stated that he was working as an Accounts
Manager with M/s Atelier Associates Pvt. Ltd., Noida and his
acquaintance, Prabha Mahajan (deceased), had been riding pillion with
him and they had been travelling towards her residence in Hari Nagar.
33.
Uma Shankar stated that when they reached near AIIMS bus stop,
a Honda City car of golden colour was standing in front of the bus stop.
When he tried to go around the car from the right side, suddenly the car
door opened and Prabha Mahajan who was sitting as pillion fell and
sustained fatal injuries.
34.
As per his statement, the offending vehicle fled away and ‘he
could not note the number’. Therefore, there was no indication as to the
identity of offending vehicle.
35.
After investigation, chargesheet had been filed with the remarks
“untraced”. Statement of Uma Shankar was noted yet again, where he
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
stated that he did not note down the number of the offending vehicle.
The chargesheet further revealed that they tried to trace the offending
vehicle, but were unsuccessful.
36.
On 01st August 2011, identity of the offending vehicle first came
to light on the basis of an appeal for identification, which was made
through a poster put up by the family of deceased at the bus stand
requesting for any information regarding the offending vehicle and the
accident. Pursuant to that, some people called up Uma Shankar, amongst
them was one Dharmender Gupta, who gave his phone number and
stated that the car number was HR-26M-7364.
37.
It was found that the number of Dharmender Gupta had been
given to the husband of deceased/Dalip Kumar Gupta, whose statement
had also been recorded. He stated that he had received this information
30 to 35 days prior and had told his friend Uma Shankar about the same.
However, they had no idea about the address of Dharmender Gupta.
38.
Thereafter, summons had been issued to Dharmender Gupta, who
stated that he sells handkerchiefs on a rehdi/cart and on 27 th April 2011,
when he was travelling in front of AIIMS around 07:15 p.m., driver of
the offending vehicle had opened its door, due to which, the pillion rider
travelling on the motorcycle fell down on the road. He had noted down
the number of the offending vehicle and after the incident, driver of the
offending vehicle fled the scene in his car. Driver of the motorcycle had
taken the injured pillion rider to the hospital in an auto.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
39.
He stated that he saw the poster on 05 th July 2011. He stated that
he did not know the husband of deceased/Dalip Kumar Gupta prior and
called the number given on the poster on 6 th July 2011. In the testimony
given by him (PW-4) before the MACT, he stated that he came across a
pamphlet pasted on the bus stand on 6 th July 2011 for notifying, if
anybody had any information regarding the accident. Following that, he
rang the number and told the details of accident.
40.
In his cross-examination, he stated that he had seen the number of
the offending vehicle and had written down the number on a visiting
card. He stated that the telephone numbers on the poster were of “Dalip
uncle” and “Dalip uncle called me to his residence as I had told him on
phone about the accident.”
41.
The other eyewitness, Prem Kumar (PW-5) had stated that on 27th
April 2011, he was waiting for a bus at the bus stand, when he saw the
motorcycle with the deceased sitting as a pillion rider. The accident
occurred when the door of offending vehicle was suddenly opened by its
driver. In his cross-examination, he stated that he had not informed the
police about the accident and his statement had not been recorded and he
was never approached for any statement. On the date of the accident, he
was coming from Faridabad and proceeding towards Uttam Nagar.
42.
Uma Shankar (PW-3) who was the driver of motorcycle, tendered
his evidence by way of affidavit and deposed about the circumstances of
the accident during his cross-examination. He admitted that he had
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
neither disclosed registration number of the offending vehicle to the
police, nor had he noted down the same. He stated that the deceased was
his sister-in-law. He denied the suggestion that he was deposing falsely
to help the LRs of deceased on account of being related to them. He also
stated that the FIR had been registered 30-40 days after the accident.
43.
Yet another fact was brought to the attention of the Court by Mr.
A.K. Soni, counsel for appellant/Insurance Company, with reference to
the DAR which had been filed on 3 rd February 2012, which notes that, as
per the call detail records (‘CDR’) location of the eyewitness was not
found to be near AIIMS Hospital. It was further noted that, as per the
FSL report, there were no signs of impact, fresh repair, or denting
observed on the offending vehicle. As per the investigation conducted, it
was stated that the accident had not occurred because of the said Honda
City car and, therefore, an untraced report had been duly filed.
44.
In the opinion of this Court, the testimony of PW-3, would have
no bearing, except for the factum of the accident, but not in respect of
involvement of the particular offending vehicle, since he clearly stated
that he had not noted down the number of the offending vehicle. Further,
it may also be noted that as per his statement, the FIR had been
registered 30-40 days after the accident, however, the FIR in question
had been registered on 28 th April 2011, i.e. the next day after the
accident on his complaint. Moreover, in his cross examination, he stated
that the deceased was his sister-in-law, however, in the statement given
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
to the police, husband of deceased/Dalip Kumar Gupta has been stated
as a mere friend.
45.
PW-5 who is also stated to be an eye witness, does not explain in
his affidavit as to how, he came to know about the proceedings before
MACT and how he came to give evidence in favour of the claimants in
identifying the offending vehicle. No detail has been provided by PW-5
in this regard. He simply stated that he was an eyewitness and he was
conversant with the facts and circumstances of the accident.
46.
In his cross examination, he clearly stated that he did not inform
the police about the accident and neither did the police approach him for
recording of his statement. The provenance of this eyewitness cannot be
confirmed, since there is no background as to how he came around to
testify in identifying the offending vehicle.
47.
As regards PW-4, the timeline is a bit suspicious. PW-4 stated he
was a hawker and he saw the accident on 27 th April 2011, but only
informed the husband of deceased on 06 th July 2011 when he saw the
poster on the bus stand, even though he had written down the number of
the offending vehicle on a visiting card. Even if he was a good
Samaritan, it cannot be believed that having seen the accident, the injury
sustained by the pillion rider and having noted down the number of the
offending vehicle, he chose not to share it with the police. Moreover, he
chose to retain the number and only, per chance, on seeing the poster, of
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
which, no evidence has been placed, he reported it to the husband of
deceased.
48.
Even after the information was provided to the husband of
deceased on 06 th July 2011, the said information was only supplied to the
police after 30 to 35 days, when his statement had been recorded. This
aspect is quite incredible.
49.
Therefore, the chain of stated facts does not inspire confidence in
the credibility of this witness. Besides the investigation, the DAR stated
that his CDR showed that he was not present near the AIIMS hospital at
that particular time. Ms. Dutta, counsel for claimant, countered this by
stating that the CDR tower locations may not be accurate. However, the
evidence that has been placed by the investigation team, in this regard,
has to be believed for lack of any other evidence provided by PW-4 in
terms of his whereabouts.
50.
With no evidence in support of his location near AIIMS hospital,
as well as, the existence of the poster which had been put up and the
omission on his part to inform the police, even if he had noted down the
number of the offending vehicle, all these do not justify the MACT
having taken this witness to be a credible witness. Moreover, the MACT
has made a summary assessment in the sense where all three witnesses
were aligned in their testimony, which is not correct, as explained above.
Moreover, apart from denying their liability on account of transfer of
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
ownership, no evidence is available on behalf of the owner and the
driver.
51.
MACT also discounted the clear testimony of SI Harpal Singh
(R6W1), who stated that he had investigated the matter and found no
involvement of this vehicle and an untraced report had been filed. He
admitted that the claimants had filed a protest petition and he did not
know whether it has been decided by the Court. He denied the
suggestion that he had not investigated the case properly.
52.
The Court is inclined to accept Mr. A.K. Soni’s plea, in terms of
reliance placed upon the decision of this Court in Naresh Kumar
(supra). The Court had taken a view that mere filing of a chargesheet
against a vehicle which was ultimately seized, on the basis of a ‘highly
specific’ information after 47 days from the registration of the FIR, not
only in respect of the registration number, but also the name of the
driver, does not warrant a finding of rash and negligent driving of the
alleged offending vehicle.
53.
Accordingly, in this view of the matter, the Court is inclined to
allow the appeal of Insurance Company and set aside the impugned
award with regard to the issue relating to negligence.
54.
By order dated 15th March 2017, the Court had directed the
deposit of entire amount of compensation along with interest @ 8%
before the MACT and had stayed the enforcement of impugned award.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
55.
Considering that no directions for release of compensation were
passed by the Court, the MACT is directed to release the amount of
compensation
deposited
along
with
accrued
interest
to
appellant/Insurance Company.
56.
If any amount has been released to the claimants, the same shall
not be recoverable from the claimants.
57.
Considering that this is a case of ‘hit-and-run’ by an untraceable
vehicle which occurred in 2011, the claimants shall be at liberty to
approach the Claims Enquiry Officer of the Sub-Division or Taluka in
which the accident took place, in view of the procedure provided under
Clause 20 of the Solatium Scheme, 1989, formulated by the Central
Government under Section 163(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
Alternatively, claimants may seek compensation under Compensation to
Victims of Hit and Run Motor Accidents Scheme, 2022, if applicable.
58.
In view of the above, the appeal is allowed and disposed of.
59.
Pending applications (if any) are rendered infructuous.
60.
Statutory deposit, if any, shall be refunded to appellant/Insurance
Company.
61.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
OCTOBER 05, 2026/RK/sp
ANISH DAYAL
(JUDGE)
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:36:01
MAC.APP. 263/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review