Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:16573-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No. 557 of 2023
With
I.A. No. 1234 of 2024
The Management of M/s Hindustan Times, Jharkhand unit, having its
office at Kokar Industrial Area, P.S.- Sadar, P.O.- Ranchi Dist.- Ranchi,
represented through its Authorized Representative Shri Sanjeet Kumar
Singh, S/o Late P.N. Singh, R/o - Flat No. 4A, Arihant Apartment, Dipatoli,
P.O.-Kokar, P.S.-Bariatu, Dist - Ranchi (Jharkhand)
…
…
…
Appellant
Versus
Ashok Karan, S/o- Late Jamuna Prasad Karan, Resident of Bhaskar
Complex, Morabadi, PS-Bariatu, P.O. & Dist. Ranchi (Jharkhand)
…
…
… Respondent
--------CORAM: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
--------For the Appellant:
Mr. Ajit Kumar, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Rajeev Kumar Sinha, Advocate
For the Respondent:
Mr. Dhananjay Kumar Dubey, Advocate
Mr. Raju Koiri, Advocate
--------06/Dated: 09.06.2026
I.A. No. 1234 of 2024
1.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
This I.A. seeks condonation of the delay of 15 days in instituting
this Letters Patent Appeal.
3.
Mr Ajit Kumar submits that the respondent has been duly served in
this matter.
4.
We have perused the averments in the I.A., and we are satisfied
that this delay has been sufficiently explained. The delay is also not
inordinate.
5.
Accordingly, we condone the delay and dispose of this I.A.
-1-
2026:JHHC:16573-DB
L.P.A. No. 557 of 2023
6.
This L.P.A. challenges the judgment and order dated 30th June
2023, which dismissed the appellant’s W.P.(L) No. 369 of 2010. The
appellant instituted W.P.(L) No. 369 of 2010 to challenge the following
orders:
(a)
Order dated 27.03.2009 passed by the Labour Court at
Ranchi, holding the enquiry into the charges against the
respondent-workman and leading to the termination of the
respondent-workman’s services, as invalid;
(b)
The Award dated 29.07.2009 in Reference Case No. 8 of
2005, made by the Labour Court, Ranchi, holding that the
termination of the respondent-workman was illegal and
unjustified, and directing the appellant herein to reinstate
the respondent-workman with 50% back wages.
7.
In this Letters Patent Appeal, Mr Ajit Kumar, the learned senior
counsel for the appellant, did not make any submissions regarding the
validity of the order dated 27.03.2009. However, he submitted that the
Labour Court, after holding that the domestic enquiry was not legal and
proper, should have granted the appellant an opportunity to lead evidence
to establish the charges against the respondent-workman. He submitted
that the denial of such an opportunity amounted to the violation of
principles of natural justice and fair play and was contrary to the law laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Karnataka State Road Transport
Corporation Vs. Lakshmidevamma (Smt) and another, (2001) 5 SCC
433 and Divyash Pandit Vs. Management, NCCBM, (2005) 2 SCC 684.
8.
Mr Ajit Kumar further submitted that a settlement was reached
between the appellant (employer) and the respondent-workman before
-2-
2026:JHHC:16573-DB
the Labour Court made its Award on 27.07.2009. Given this settlement,
the Labour Court erred in making the Award and in directing the
reinstatement of the respondent-workman with 50% back wages.
9.
Mr Ajit Kumar submitted that there was no evidence that the
respondent-workman was not gainfully employed after his termination. He
therefore submitted that the Labour Court was not justified in awarding
50% back wages without ascertaining this aspect of the gainful
employment.
10.
Mr Dubey, the learned counsel for the respondent, defended the
impugned judgment and order based on the reasoning reflected therein.
He submitted that the appellant, in its written statement filed before the
Labour Court, never sought any opportunity to lead fresh evidence. He
submitted that the order dated 06.06.2009 by which the Labour Court
dismissed the appellant’s application for leading fresh evidence was also
never challenged. He submitted that from 29.07.2009, the appellant has
neither reinstated the respondent nor paid any back wages.
11.
Mr Dubey submitted that there was no settlement as contemplated
under the I.D. Act. Some of the amounts paid to the respondent were the
dues prior to his illegal and unjustified termination. He submitted that the
reference was made on 08.09.2005 under Section 10(1)(c) of the I.D. Act
was never challenged by the appellant on the ground that the issue was
already settled under any valid settlement under the I.D. Act.
12.
Learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the respondent,
in his written statement, had clearly made a statement that he was not
gainfully employed. Therefore, the onus was on the appellant to prove
that the respondent was gainfully employed. No evidence was laid by the
appellant on this aspect. Therefore, full back wages should have been
awarded, not only 50%.
-3-
2026:JHHC:16573-DB
13.
The rival contentions now fall for determination.
14.
At the outset, we note and record that no argument was raised
regarding the order dated 27.03.2009 made by the Labour Court holding
that the enquiry which led to the termination of the respondent-workman
was invalid or not legal and proper. Similarly, Mr Ajit Kumar admitted that
the Labour Court’s order dated 06.06.2009, dismissing the appellant’s
application dated 11.04.2009 for an opportunity to lead evidence afresh
before the Labour Court to establish the charges against the respondentworkman, was never challenged at any stage. The record shows that
even in W.P.(L) No. 369 of 2010, there was no challenge to this order
dated 06.06.2009.
15.
Admittedly, the Labour Court and the learned Single Judge have
held that the domestic enquiry in this case was invalid and vitiated by
non-compliance with the principles of natural justice and fair play. There
are concurrent findings of fact on this point, and upon perusal of the
same, we are satisfied that the domestic enquiry was indeed invalid and
violated the principles of natural justice and fair play. Therefore, quite
correctly, no arguments were advanced in this appeal regarding the
validity or fairness of the domestic enquiry.
16.
In this case, there is no dispute that the appellant, in its written
statement, never sought any opportunity to lead fresh evidence if the
Labour Court were to conclude that the domestic enquiry was invalid,
unfair and in violation of the principles of natural justice. Belatedly, an
application was filed seeking leave to lead fresh evidence. However, the
Labour Court rejected this application on 06.06.2009. As noted earlier, the
order dated 06.06.2009 was never challenged in W.P.(L) No. 369 of 2010.
-4-
2026:JHHC:16573-DB
17.
Even otherwise, in the facts and circumstances of this case, the
Labour Court has correctly held that the appellant was not entitled to any
fresh opportunity. The learned Single Judge, after considering the matter
in some detail, has also concurred with the view taken by the Labour
Court. The Labour Court relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Shambhu Nath Goyal Vs. Bank of Baroda and
others, 1983 LAB. I.C. 1697.
18.
The learned Single Judge has considered several decisions on the
stage at which an application to lead fresh evidence must be made. This
includes the decision in the Karnataka State Road Transport
Corporation case (supra).
19.
The learned Single Judge, after considering however the facts and
circumstances of this case, and given the law laid down in Shambhu
Nath Goyal (supra), which view, was substantially upheld by the
Constitution Bench in Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation
(supra) held that there was no perversity or illegality in the Labour Court’s
Award and order dated 06.06.2009 in declining the appellant leave to lead
fresh evidence, based upon a belated application seeking such relief.
20.
In Shambhu Nath Goyal (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that where a dispute is referred to the Tribunal/Labour Court, the
management must seek an opportunity to adduce further evidence, if any,
against the workman’s charges (regarding non-compliance with the
principle of natural justice) in its reply statement itself, and not by way of a
belated application. The Hon’ble Supreme Court further held that if it does
not choose to do so at that stage, it cannot be allowed to do so at any
later stage of the proceedings by filing any application for that purpose,
which may result in delay, wreck the morale of the workman, and compel
him to surrender, which he may not otherwise do.
-5-
2026:JHHC:16573-DB
21.
In the Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation (supra), the
majority has specifically approved the decision in the Shambhu Nath
Goyal case (supra). However, it was also observed that, in a given case,
the Labour Court/Tribunal may, at any stage before the closure of the
proceedings, require or direct the parties to lead additional evidence if, on
the facts and circumstances, it is deemed necessary in the interests of
justice. The observations in Divyash Pandit (supra) are to the same
effect.
22.
In the facts and circumstances of the present case, the Labour
Court and the learned Single Judge have concurrently held that the
interests of justice do not require any excessive latitude to be extended to
the appellant (employer). This was a case in which the respondent was
terminated on 22.02.2005 following a defective enquiry that failed to
comply with the principles of natural justice and fair play. The reference
was made on 08.09.2005, and in the written statement filed, the
appellant-employer did not even seek leave to lead fresh evidence if the
enquiry was found to be defective or in breach of the principles of natural
justice and fair play.
23.
At the belated stage, after the enquiry was found to be defective
and in violation of principles of natural justice, an application was filed
seeking leave. This could have only prolonged the misery of the
respondent-workman. The grant of such permission would not have
furthered the interest of justice. It is not as if the appellant was unaware of
the legal position that a domestic enquiry must be consistent with the
principle of natural justice and fair play. Therefore, perhaps, quite
correctly, the appellant did not even challenge the order dated
06.06.2009, by which the appellant’s application for leading fresh
evidence was rejected.
-6-
2026:JHHC:16573-DB
24.
The Labour Court and the learned Single Judge have both found
that this was not a suitable case for permitting the appellant to lead fresh
evidence. The concurrent approach of the two Courts can hardly be
described as illegal, let alone perverse or arbitrary.
25.
As for the settlement, nothing was produced on record to show that
any such settlement was reached and duly recorded in accordance with
the provisions of the ID Act. There is nothing on record to indicate that
any settlement as contemplated under the I.D. Act was in fact reached
between the parties. No contention was raised that there was any Section
2(p) or 12(3) settlement, nor was such a settlement produced on record.
Mere payment of some amounts, or even the exchange of letters, can
hardly amount to a binding settlement, thereby preventing the parties to
the settlement from re-agitating the settled issues.
26.
Crucially, on the above ground, even the appellant did not deem it
proper to challenge or question the reference order dated 08.09.2005. If
such a challenge were to be thrown or a preliminary objection raised and
urged with all seriousness, then the Labour Court could have examined
whether there was indeed any binding settlement that covered the dispute
which was the subject matter of the reference. Therefore, based upon
such payment made, there is no good ground to hold that the disputes
between the parties had already been settled and therefore, the Labour
Court should not have made the Award dated 29.07.2009.
27.
On the aspect of back wages, the Tribunal, as well as the learned
Single Judge, have referred to the claim settlement of the respondentworkman wherein the respondent-workman had categorically pleaded that
he was not gainfully employed. Given the statement, which was duly
verified, the onus shifted upon the appellant to plead and thereafter lead
evidence to show that the respondent-workman was indeed gainfully
-7-
2026:JHHC:16573-DB
employed. No such effort was made. In any event, only 50% back wages
have been awarded. The approach of the Labour Court and the learned
Single Judge is entirely consistent with the law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Deepali Gundu Survase v. Kranti Junior Adhyapak,
[Civil Appeal No 6767/2013]
28.
For all the above reasons, we are satisfied that this L.P.A. deserves
to be dismissed. Accordingly, the same is dismissed without any order for
costs.
29.
Before we conclude, we note that the respondent in this case was
terminated on 22.02.2005. The Labour Court, by the impugned Award
dated 29th July 2009, directed his reinstatement with 50% back wages.
The learned Single Judge dismissed the challenge to the Labour Court’s
Award on 30.06.2023. It is unclear whether any interim relief operated in
W.P.(L) No. 369 of 2010 [possibly not]. However, there is no dispute that,
to date, the respondent-workman has neither been reinstated nor paid
back wages. The appellant employer cannot be permitted to wilt the
resistance or wreck the morale of the respondent-workman and frustrate
the Award and the orders passed in his favour.
30.
Accordingly, the appellant is directed to comply with the directions
of the reinstatement within 15 days from the date of uploading of this
order on the website. Similarly, 50% of the back wages must be paid or
deposited in this Court within four weeks from the date of uploading this
judgment and order on this Court's website, without forcing the workman
to seek execution before the labour court or through the executive
mechanism.
31.
If the amount is deposited with this Court, the Registry must
transfer it to the respondent-workman’s bank account. The learned
-8-
2026:JHHC:16573-DB
counsel for the respondent-workman must provide the workman’s identity
and bank details so that the transfer can be made at the earliest.
32.
The Letters Patent Appeal is accordingly dismissed without any
order for costs.
(M.S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
June 09, 2026
A.F.R.
VK
Uploaded on 10.06.2026
-9-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review