Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.10970 of 2023
Reserved on:18.09.2026
Date of Decision: 28.09.2026
Date of uploading: 28.09.2026
_______________________________________________________
The Lohara Cooperative Cho Reclamation and Soil Conservator
Society
…….Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors.
… Respondents
_______________________________________________________
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? 1
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Ajay Sharma, Senior Advocate with Mr.
Tarun K. Brakta, Advocate.
For the Respondents: Mr. Rajan Kahol & Mr. Vishal Panwar,
Additional Advocates General with Mr. Ravi
Chauhan & Mr. Anish Banshtu, Deputy
Advocates General, for the respondentState.
Mr. Arun Kaushal, Advocate, for respondent
No.4.
____________________________________________________
Sandeep Sharma, Judge:
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with order dated
18.12.2023 passed by Joint Registrar (Credit), Cooperative Societies,
Himachal Pradesh, whereby aforesaid authority, while allowing the
appeal filed by respondent No.4 under Section 93 of H.P. Cooperative
Societies Act, 1968 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”), laying
1Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
therein challenge to order of arbitration dated 04.02.2023, set aside
the aforesaid order dated 04.02.2023 passed by learned Arbitrator
and remanded the case back to Assistant Registrar, Cooperative
Societies, Una, with a direction to refer the same to some senior
officer to decide the same afresh, petitioner-society has approached
this Court in the instant proceedings filed under Article 226 of
Constitution of India, praying therein for the following main reliefs:“a. That impugned orders dated 18.12.2023, Annexure P-5,
passed by the Joint Registrar (Credit) Cooperative Societies,
Himachal Pradesh i.e. respondent No.3 herein, may very
kindly be quashed and set aside.
b. That the award dated 4th February, 2023 passed by the
learned Arbitrator may very kindly be upheld.”
2.
Precisely, the facts of the case, as emerge from the
pleadings as well as other material adduced on record by the
respective parties are that in terms of judgment passed by this Court
in CWP No. 497 of 2004, society namely Upper Lohara Cho
Reclamation and Soil Conservation Society, came to be amalgamated
with Lower Lohara Cho Reclamation and Soil Conservation Society,
i.e. petitioner herein, on 14.05.2007. As a consequence of
amalgamation, respondent No.4, who was earlier working as
Secretary of erstwhile Upper Lohara Cho Reclamation and Soil
Conservation Society, became Secretary of Lower Lohara Cho
Reclamation and Soil Conservation Society (hereinafter “petitionersociety”.
3.
After amalgamation, petitioner-society asked respondent
No. 4 to make available records of audit and other proceedings of
previous society, but fact remains that needful was not done, as a
result thereof, petitioner-society proceeded to file a civil suit for
recovery of losses to the tune of Rs. 1,00,000/- in the year 2007.
However, aforesaid suit was dismissed in the year 2018 by this Court,
holding that there is a bar of jurisdiction of civil Courts as
contemplated under Section 72 as also under Section 92 of the Act.
4.
After passing of aforesaid order, petitioner-society filed
an application dated 12.01.2019 under Section 72 of the Act before
Assistant Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Una (Annexure P-2),
seeking therein appointment of an Arbitrator as per provisions of the
Act. Arbitrator appointed by the aforesaid authority ultimately passed
a detailed award dated 04.02.2023 (Annexure P-3), thereby affirming
the claim of the society to the tune of Rs. 1,00,000/- with 12% interest.
5.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with aforesaid award,
respondent No.4 filed an appeal under Section 93 of the Act before
Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Himachal Pradesh (respondent No.
2), which was further delegated to be decided by Registrar,
Cooperative Societies, Himachal Pradesh (Annexure P-4). Vide order
dated 18.12.2023, Joint Registrar (Credit), Cooperative Societies,
allowed the appeal of respondent No.4 and set aside the award dated
04.02.2023 passed by learned Arbitrator and remanded the case for
reconsideration by another Arbitrator (Annexure P-5). In aforesaid
background, petitioner-society has approached this Court in the
instant proceedings, praying therein to set aside order dated
18.12.2023 passed by the Joint Registrar (Credit), Cooperative
Societies and restore order dated 04.02.2023 passed by the learned
Arbitrator.
6.
Precisely, the grouse of the petitioner, as has been
highlighted in the petition and further canvassed by Mr. Ajay Sharma,
learned Senior Counsel, duly assisted by Mr. Tarun K. Brakta, learned
Counsel for the petitioner, is that impugned order passed by Joint
Registrar (Credit), Cooperative Societies, is not sustainable in the eye
of law, being totally contrary to the facts as well as law. To
substantiate his aforesaid submission, Mr. Sharma made this Court
peruse order dated 04.02.2023 passed by learned Arbitrator. He
submitted that bare perusal of aforesaid order passed by learned
Arbitrator reveals that number of opportunities came to be afforded to
respondent No.4 to put in appearance and make available documents
as well as other records, if any, in his possession to substantiate his
claim, but in vain. Mr. Sharma stated that if the impugned order
passed by Joint Registrar (Credit), Cooperative Societies, is read visà-vis order passed by learned Arbitrator, it can be safely concluded
that Joint Registrar (Credit), Cooperative Societies, has arrived at a
wrong conclusion that no sufficient opportunity of being heard was
ever afforded to respondent No.4. Mr. Sharma further submitted that
Joint Registrar (Credit), Cooperative Societies, further erred in
returning a finding that an application filed by respondent No.4,
seeking therein permission to engage a lawyer, could not have been
rejected by learned Arbitrator, especially when ample material was
adduced on record suggestive of the fact that respondent No.4 was
unwell, as a result thereof, he was unable to contest the case. While
making this Court peruse order passed by learned Arbitrator as well
as other material adduced on record by respondent No.4 suggestive
of his illness, Mr. Sharma submitted that respondent No.4 submitted
before learned Arbitrator that on account of his having a stone in his
gall bladder, he was not in a position to contest the case. However,
learned Arbitrator, having regard to the nature of disease, coupled
with the fact that record, if any, was to be made available by
respondent No.4, rightly proceeded to reject his application. He
submitted
that otherwise also, appeal prima facie was not
maintainable, as the same was not filed before the appropriate
Court/forum as described in the Act. He specifically referred to
Section 2(12) of the Act, which defines the term "Registrar". He stated
that bare perusal of definition of “Registrar” as given in aforesaid
provision of law suggests that Registrar of Cooperative Societies
appointed under Section 3 includes any person appointed to assist
the Registrar on whom all or any of the powers or duties of Registrar
have been conferred or imposed under this Act. He submitted that
vide notification dated 23.12.1976, His Excellency the Governor of
Himachal Pradesh was pleased to appoint such officer to assist
Registrar under Section of the said Act and has been pleased to
confer upon said officers all powers of Registrar with respect to
particular Section. He submitted that in the case at hand, Assistant
Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Una, was conferred power of
Registrar under Section 93 of the Act. He further referred to Rule
2(xxi) of Himachal Pradesh Cooperative Societies Rules, 1971, which
defines the term “Primary Society”. He stated that primary society
does not enroll societies as its member and as such, petitioner, being
a primary society, falls under the jurisdiction of Assistant Registrar,
Cooperative Societies, Una, who, for all intents and purposes, is the
Registrar as per provisions of the Act. To substantiate his aforesaid
submission, he submitted that when application under Section 72 of
the Act was filed, the same was only maintainable before Registrar.
Assistant Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Una, while acting as
Registrar, instead of entertaining said application himself, assigned
the same to Arbitrator as per provisions of Section 72 of the Act. This
shows that Assistant Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Una, is the
Registrar for the purpose of primary societies. In this regard, he
placed reliance upon communication dated 31.07.2023 (Annexure P6), which reads as under:“I am to enclose herewith a copy of letter No.
CB(R/HQ)Comp.09/2023(SIU)-15928 dated 21st July,
2023 received from the Additional Director General,
SV&ACB, H.P. Shimla -02 along with its enclosures on
the subject cited above, wherein the above authorities
has requested to take necessary action in the matter.
As you must be aware, that being the Registrar of the
primary societies, it is the responsibility/duty of your office
to settle such issues in the provisions of the law within
stipulated period of time. In view of above, you are
directed to look into the matter and to ensure further
necessary action as per law occupying the field. Action
taken report in the matter may be conveyed to this office
at the earliest, enabling this office to proceed further in
the matter.”
7.
While referring to Rule 148 of the Rules, Mr. Sharma
submitted that there is specific bar to contest the case by a legal
practitioner. No doubt, on showing sufficient cause/reason, plea, if
any, to engage a lawyer could have been accepted, but since in the
case at hand no cogent and convincing plea ever came to be made at
the behest of respondent No.4, no illegality otherwise can be said to
have been committed by learned Arbitrator by passing impugned
order.
8.
Having heard learned counsel representing the parties
and perused material available on record, especially award dated
04.02.2023 (Annexure P-3) passed by learned Arbitrator vis-à-vis
impugned order dated 18.12.2023 passed by Joint Registrar (Credit),
Cooperative Societies, this Court is persuaded to accept the
submission of Mr. Ajay Sharma, learned Senior Counsel representing
the petitioner-society, that Appellate Court, while passing impugned
order, failed to take note of proceedings conducted by learned
Arbitrator.
9.
Order passed by learned Arbitrator (Annexure P-3), if
perused in its entirety, clearly reveals that proceedings in Reference
No. 3102-3105 had commenced on 20.06.2022 and thereafter
number of opportunities came to be afforded to respondent No.4 for
putting up his stance, but on one pretext or other, he not only failed to
come present before learned Arbitrator on many dates, but also failed
to make available relevant documents to refute the claim of the
petitioner-society. Having carefully perused aforesaid order passed by
learned Arbitrator, wherein detail of all dates, upon which respondent
No.4 either remained absent or failed to produce record has been
given, this Court has no hesitation to conclude that Joint Registrar
(Credit), Cooperative Societies, while passing impugned order, has
acted in hot haste manner. It appears that aforesaid authority, before
considering submission made on behalf of respondent No.4 that no
opportunity of being heard was granted to him, did not even bother to
look into the records of the case decided by learned Arbitrator.
10.
After having carefully perused award dated 04.02.2023
passed by learned Arbitrator, it cannot be said that respondent No.4
was not afforded due opportunity of being heard; rather, this Court is
of the view that learned Arbitrator was over-indulgent while granting
repeated adjournments.
11.
It is also not understood that on what basis, Joint
Registrar (Credit), Cooperative Societies, proceeded to record that
learned Arbitrator, while passing award to the tune of Rs. 1,00,000/-,
failed to take note of record, rather order passed by learned Arbitrator
reveals that petitioner-society had made available complete record
with regard to alleged misappropriation of funds of the Lower Lohara
Cho Reclamation and Soil Conservation Society. Joint Registrar
(Credit), while returning finding that award does not only suffer from
technical shortfall, but is also bereft of sound application of statutory
provisions and logical reasoning, has itself failed to point out
shortcomings, if any, in the award.
12.
Leaving everything aside, once it is not in dispute that
respondent No.4 had failed to produce any document to counter the
claim of the petitioner-society, coupled with the fact that he repeatedly
failed to make himself available before learned Arbitrator to get his
statement recorded, no illegality can be said to have been committed
by learned Arbitrator, while accepting the claim of the petitionersociety, which otherwise remained unrebutted.
13.
Registrar, Cooperative Societies, also erred in holding
that respondent No.4 was denied the opportunity to avail the services
of a legal practitioner under Rule 148 of H.P. Cooperative Societies
Rules, 1971 (in short “Rules). Rule 148 of the Rules provides that
legal practitioner is barred except with the permission of Registrar. No
doubt, in the case at hand, an application under aforesaid Rule was
made by respondent No.4, but no cogent and convincing reason for
making available the services of a legal practitioner ever came to be
raised. Merely stating that he was having a stone in his gall bladder
could not be a ground to permit respondent No.4 to avail the services
of a legal practitioner. It was none of the case of respondent No.4 that
on account of his having a stone in his gall bladder, he was unable to
come present and make submissions. Since no plausible explanation
ever came to be rendered on record at the behest of private
respondent for permitting him to avail the services of a legal
practitioner, no illegality can be said to have been committed by
learned Arbitrator, while rejecting the application under Rule 148 of
the Rules.
14.
Though Mr. Sharma also raised question with regard to
maintainability of appeal, as has been recorded in his submissions,
but since impugned order passed by Joint Registrar (Credit),
Cooperative Societies, is not sustainable for the detailed reasons
given hereinabove, this Court sees no occasion to go into that
question, rather the same is left open to be decided in appropriate
proceedings.
15.
Consequently, in view of the above, this Court finds merit
in the present petition and accordingly, the same is allowed.
Impugned order dated 18.12.2023 (Annexure P-5) is quashed and set
aside, as a consequence thereof, award dated 04.02.2023 passed by
learned Arbitrator is restored.
Petition stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms along
with pending application(s), if any.
p
(Sandeep Sharma),
Judge
September 28, 2026
(Sunil)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review