Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
(2026:JHHC:1723-DB)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P (PIL) No. 5675 of 2018
The Federation of Jharkhand Chamber of Commerce and Industries through its
Secretary General Kunal Ajmani, son of Sri Tilakraj Ajmani, aged about 35
years, Resident of Bansal Plaza, 401 to 504, Block ‘C’, Station Road, near
Baba Ramdev Ashram, P.O.-Doranda, P.S. Chutia, Town and District Ranchi
----Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. The Chief Secretary, Government of Jharkhand, Project Building, P.O.
Dhurwa, P.S. Jagganathpur, District Ranchi
3. The Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi, P.O. G.P.O, Ranchi, P.S. Kotwali,
District Ranchi
4. The State Election Commission, Jharkhand, near New Market, Ratu Road,
P.O and P.S. Sukhdeo Nagar, District Ranchi
5. The State Election Commissioner, State Election Commission, Jharkhand,
near New Market, Ratu Road, P.O and P.S. Sukhdeo Nagar, District Ranchi
6. Agriculture Produce Marketing Committee, Pandra Market, Ratu Road, P.O
& P.S. Ratu Road, Ranchi
7. The Election Commission of India, Nirvachan Sadan, Ashoka Road, New
Delhi
----Respondents
--CORAM:
Hon’ble The Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajesh Shankar
--For the Petitioner:
Mr. Salona Mittal, Advocate
Mrs. Lavanya Gadodia Mittal, Advocate
Mr. Yashdeep Kanhai, Advocate
Mr. Arya Vardhan Singh, Advocate
Ms. Divya Choudhary, Advocate
Mr. Sourav K. Jha, Advocate
For the Resp.-State:
Mr. Mrinal Kanti Roy, G.A-I
Mr. Abhinay Kumar, A.C to G.A-I
For the Resp. No. 4 & 5: Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, Advocate
Mrs. Shilpi Sandil Gadodia, Advocate
Mr. Prakhar Harit, Advocate
For the Resp. No. 6:
Dr. Ashok Kumar Singh, Advocate
Mr. Sharon Toppo, Advocate
For the Resp. No. 7:
Mrs. Richa Sanchita, Advocate
Ms. Rishita Singh, Advocate
--13 / 22.01.2026
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
With the consent of and at the request of the learned counsel for the
parties, we dispose of this PIL after hearing the learned counsel for the parties.
3.
Petitioner complains that despite several orders made by this court from
time to time, the Terminal Market Yard, Pandra, Ranchi is insisted upon being
occupied and used for keeping Electronic Voting Machines (EVM), setting up
counting centres and other election related activities for all central and local
elections, thereby temporarily evicting/dislocating the petitioners’ Members,
who have been carrying on their businesses as shopkeepers or godown keepers
at the yard for last several years.
4.
Petitioner contends that such disruption of their businesses and business
activities is without authority of law, and since this practice is continuing
despite several orders made by this court, it amounts to high-handed action on
the part of the Respondents. The petitioner has pointed out that their members
are primarily small shopkeepers or godown owners, and disruption of their
business activities severely affects them and their livelihood. Learned counsel
pointed out that several people rely upon the business carried out by the
petitioners’ Members through the market yard, and the interests of several
people are also affected on account of such highhanded actions of the
Respondents.
5.
Pursuant to several orders made in this petition itself, Mr Vivek Kumar
Suman, Deputy Election Officer, Ranchi, has filed an affidavit on 06th January,
2026. In paragraph 7 of this affidavit, there is a reference to some
correspondence followed by a statement that only autonomous colleges in the
respective districts are being used for the purposes of counting of votes and
strong rooms. In paragraph-8, there is a statement that answering Respondents
are “well aware and much vigilant to the earlier orders passed by the Hon’ble
Court in the instant matter as well as the order dated 11.12.2018 passed in W.P
(C) No. 6137 of 2018”. This paragraph proceeds to state that the answering
Respondent vide letter no. 587(ii) dated 19.12.2025 constituted a three-member
committee for spot verification of the places selected / recommended for the
construction of strong rooms and for the counting of votes in the upcoming
elections. In paragraph-9 of the affidavit, there is a statement that the answering
Respondents are acting vigilantly and inspecting several premises which have
been pointed out in Annexure-SCA/III and after due verification, one
prominent premises / spot will be selected, and in the upcoming elections, the
selected premises / spot will be used for carrying out the election duties and
works.
6.
To the above affidavit, is annexed the communication SCA/III, which
refers toabout five premises/spots recommended by the committee. These do
not include the market yard at Pandra, Ranchi. Learned counsel for the
petitioner points out that the affidavit of 06th January, 2026, does not contain
any categorical statement that, hereafter, the market yard at Pandra will not be
disrupted and used for election purposes.
7.
Although there is no categorical statement, the tenor of the affidavit
leads us to believe that there is no proposal to utilise the market yard at Pandra
for election purposes. This is more so because the affidavit, in paragraph-8,
categorically states that “the answering Respondents are well aware and much
vigilant of the earlier orders passed by this Court in the instant matter, as well
as the order dated 11.12.2018 passed in W.P (C) No. 6137 of 2018”, to which,
incidentally, one of us (Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajesh Shankar) was a party. In
fact, His Lordship authored the said order.
8.
The order dated 11.12.2018 squarely concerned the market yard at Pandra.
Therefore, if the answering Respondents claim that they are well aware and
much vigilant of the earlier orders, including the order dated 11.12.2018 passed
in W.P(C) No. 6137/2018, it is obvious that they will not, in defiance of the
directions contained in the said order, or the letter and spirit of the said order,
continue to insist upon using the market yard at Pandra for election purposes,
thereby disrupting the business activities of the petitioners’ Members, who are
small shopkeepers and godown keepers in those premises.
9.
Assuming that there is any ambiguity in the affidavit filed by the Deputy
Election Officer, Ranchi, we now clearly direct the Respondents not to utilise
the market yard at Pandra, Ranchi, for any election purposes, thereby disrupting
the business activities. This is because of the previous directions issued by this
court in its several orders, the earliest of which is the order of the Division
Bench of this Court dated 03rd February, 2015, in W.P (PIL) No. 2944/2013.
This order was later followed by the learned single Judge (Hon’ble Mr Justice
Rajesh Shankar) in the order dated 11.12.2018, passed in W.P. (C) No.
6137/2018. This order was reiterated by the Division Bench in other matters,
including those made in the present petition as well.
9.
In the present petition, the State has submitted that a full-fledged
building was constructed for the storage of EVMs. However, thereafter, a
stance was taken that these premisesare insufficient. Coordinate Benches of this
Court, through several orders made in this petition itself, have expressed
surprise as to how such a large building could be insufficient and further, how
such a large building was constructed without a proper assessment of the
present and future requirements.
10.
Be that as it may, the records disclose that despite previous directions,
Respondents have been insisting upon using the market yard premises at
Pandra, Ranchi, for the purposes of storing EVMs and for counting of votes,
thereby completely disrupting the business activities of the petitioners’
Members who are small shopkeepers and godown keepers for several days.
Since the orders made by this court from time to time have not been challenged
by the State Government, their implementation cannot be frustrated, as has
been done over the last seven to eight years, by giving assurances to this Court
that alternate premises are being identified or even constructed.
11.
Now the affidavit states that a Committee has been constituted to scout
for alternate premises, and about five premises have been recommended by the
District Election Officer to the Committee. Thus, it is submitted that the
process of identifying the alternative premises is ongoing. We are sorry to note
that this process has been ongoing for the last five to six years, perhaps only to
avoid compliance with the clear and categorical directions issued by this court
from time to time. Taking the stance that this identification process is ongoing,
there is insistence on utilising the market yard premises at Pandra in Ranchi for
every election.
12.
Considering that this was a matter of elections, which are always
matters of State and National importance, no precipitative orders were passed
by this Court, nor was any contempt action initiated against the officer for
defying the orders of this Court. This, unfortunately, appears to be perceived as
a weakness of this Branch. The indulgence shown was certainly not weakness,
but it was out of regard for practical and pragmatic considerations. This Court
also felt that some reasonable time should be granted to make alternative
arrangements.
13.
Unfortunately, for the last six to seven years, the State has made no
serious efforts to make alternate arrangements, possibly on account of the
impression that no precipitative orders would be made by this Court,once the
elections are announced and a situation of ‘fait accompli’ is presented before
the Court. This time, the petitioner has approached the Court well in advance.
Therefore, we repeat our orders and, without mincing any words, direct the
Respondents not to utilise the market yard premises at Pandra, Ranchi, for
election purposes, thereby disrupting the business activities therein. As it is, the
affidavits filed before us do not identify this market yard at Pandra.
14.
If the State Government’s claim that serious steps are being taken to
identify the alternate premises is correct, then we see no difficulty whatsoever
if this process is taken to its logical conclusion. In any event, this is a matter for
the State Government and the Election Commissioner to sort out. The entire
burden cannot be placed upon the petitioner and its members, who are smalltime shop / godown keepers operating from the yard.
15.
Considering the apparent breaches in the past, we direct that the Chief
Secretary, State of Jharkhand, the State Election Commissioner, and the Chief
Electoral Officer shall be jointly and severally responsible for implementing the
directions we have now issued regarding the non-utilisation of the market yard
premises at Pandra, Ranchi, for election purposes. If there is any breach, these
officers will be held responsible. We are forced to issue this direction because
there is a tendency to pass the buck to junior officers such as Election Officers,
Deputy Election Officers, etc., who, on many occasions, prefer to obey the
directions of their immediate superiors rather than the Courts. This is again
under the misimpression that the Court would not hold them in contempt,
whereas they are answerable to their immediate superiors each day.
16.
We dispose of this petition in accordance with the above directions. We
refrain from imposing any costs on this occasion, with the fond hope that the
petitioner is not forced to approach this Court once again for the
implementation of our earlier orders, which continue to bind the Respondents,
and for the implementation of this order.
(M.S. Sonak, C.J)
(Rajesh Shankar, J)
January 22, 2026
Ranjeet/R. Kr.
Uploaded on
28.01.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review