The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. The date of birth of the claimant is admitted to be on 24 th June, 1991 as mentioned in his driving license. Thus his age comes to 32 years 4 months 3 weeks on the date of accident and therefore, the proper factor would be 201.66, as per Schedule-IV of the EC Act. Accordingly, accepting all other computations arrived by the learned Commissioner as it is, the compensation amount is modified to Rs.16,33,446/- (rupees sixteen lakhs thirty-three thousand four hundred forty-six only), i.e. 9000/- X 201.66 X 90%, payable along with interest @ 12% per annum from the date of accident.
14. Accordingly the appeal is disposed of modifying the compensation amount to the tune of Rs.16,33,446/- (rupees sixteen lakhs thirty-three thousand four hundred forty-six only) along with interest @ 12% per annum from the date of accident, i.e. 14th November, 2023 till the date of deposit.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally Signed
Signed by: MANAS KUMAR PANDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, Cuttack
Date: 02-Feb-2026 19:14:40
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
FAO No.530 of 2025
(From the judgment dated 22nd August, 2025 of learned Commissioner
for Employee’s Compensation-cum-Joint Labour Commissioner,
Cuttack passed in E.C. Case No.361/2023/CUTT)
The Divisional Manager, National
Insurance Co. Ltd., Cantonment
Road, Cuttack, represented by its
Manager
….
Appellant
-versus…
Sukanta Ojha and Another
respondents
Advocate(s) appeared in this case:For Appellant
:
Mr. P.K. Mahali, Advocate
For Respondents
:
Mr. P.K. Mishra, Advocate for
Respondent No.1
Mr. G. Girigoswami, Advocate for
Respondent No.2
CORAM: JUSTICE B.P. ROUTRAY
JUDGMENT
28th January, 2026
B.P. Routray, J.
1.
Heard Mr. P.K. Mahali, learned counsel for the insurer –
Appellant, Mr. P.K. Mishra, learned counsel for claimant – Respondent
No.1 and Mr. G. Girigoswami, learned counsel for owner – Respondent
No.2.
FAO No.530 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: MANAS KUMAR PANDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, Cuttack
Date: 02-Feb-2026 19:14:40
2.
Present appeal by the insurer is directed against impugned
judgment dated 22nd August, 2025 of learned Commissioner for
Employee’s Compensation-cum-Joint Labour Commissioner, Cuttack
passed in E.C. Case No.361/2023/CUTT, wherein compensation to the
tune of Rs.20,02,337/- (including interest) has been granted on account
of injury sustained by the claimant arising out of and in course of his
employment as driver of the truck bearing registration number OD-05-U2712.
3.
The case of the claimant is that, he while employed as driver of
truck bearing registration number OD-05-U-2712 and driving from
Gopalpur to Banei loaded with coal, another truck bearing registration
number OD-09-A-4473 dashed it from the front coming from opposite
direction resulting sustenance of injuries to the claimant. Due to such
injuries he sustained multiple fracture injuries as well as other injuries
and was hospitalized for a period of around four months on different
spells. He further sustained permanent disability due to the accident upto
50%.
4.
Mr. Mahali, learned counsel submits on behalf of the Appellant-
insurer that the contention of claimant regarding sustenance of disability
is not supported by any certificate granted by the competent authority.
FAO No.530 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: MANAS KUMAR PANDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, Cuttack
Date: 02-Feb-2026 19:14:40
The disability certificate produced by the claimant has been granted by
his private treating doctor. He further contends that the claimant did not
have proper driving license to drive a heavy transport vehicle on the date
of accident and so the insurer is not liable to indemnify the compensation
amount.
5.
The accident took place on 24th November, 2023 at around
10.30am and no dispute is raised with regard to the accident as well as
sustenance of injuries by the claimant. Further, no dispute is raised with
regard to the status of the claimant as driver of the truck in question at
the time of accident.
6.
The claimant has examined himself as P.W.1 and the treating
doctor as P.W.2. In support of his injuries he has also produced the
copies of medical documents marked under Ext.5, 6 and 7.
7.
On the other hand, the insurer – Appellant did not adduce any
evidence nor did examine any witness on its behalf. The employer has
though appeared but admitted the claim of the injured regarding the
accident, his employment as the driver of the vehicle as well as
remuneration of the injured to the tune of Rs.15,000/- per month
excluding food allowance.
FAO No.530 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: MANAS KUMAR PANDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, Cuttack
Date: 02-Feb-2026 19:14:40
8.
The learned Commissioner while computing the compensation
amount took the income of the injured at Rs.15,000/- per month and
accepted the loss of earning to the extent of 90% taking the disability up
to 50%. He applied the factor of 203.85 taking the age of the claimant as
32 years.
9.
It is true that the claimant could not produce any disability
certificate granted by the medical board in his favour. But nonsubmission of the same would not disentitle his case regarding
sustenance of disability by him due to the injuries in the accident. What
is contended by Mr. Mahali on behalf of the insurer that in absence of
any disability certificate granted by the medical board the claim of
sustenance of disability by the claimant cannot be considered, is not
found to be a conceivable submission. There may be various reasons for
not getting the disability certificate from the competent authority
prescribed under the law, but that does not mean that the person claiming
for disability does not have any disability for the reason that he does not
possess a disability certificate granted by the competent authority. A
person who has sustained disability need not always require to prove his
disability by producing the disability certificate granted by competent
authority, and as in the instant case, where the question is about grant of
FAO No.530 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: MANAS KUMAR PANDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, Cuttack
Date: 02-Feb-2026 19:14:40
compensation under the Employee’s Compensation Act, 1923 is
concerned. Section 4 of the Act prescribes that the loss of earning of an
injured person can be assessed by taking note of the injuries sustained by
the injured in the opinion of a qualified medical practitioner. Further, it is
clarified by the claimant that he could not be able to get a disability
certificate from the medical board as he was unable to remain present on
the date fixed by the Board.
10.
As seen from the evidence of the claimant as well as P.W.2, it is
found that his contentions with regard to sustenance of such injuries of
multiple fractures is not only supported by the evidence of P.W.2 (the
treating doctor) but also supported by the injury report and other medical
certificates produced by him. When the factum of accident and
sustenance of injuries by the claimant due to the accident is not disputed
specifically and no such contrary or rebuttal evidence has been adduced
from the side of the owner or the insurer, there could not be any
impediment to accept such contention of the claimant regarding his
disability based on the medical reports coupled with the evidence of the
treating doctor. P.W.2 has categorically said in his evidence that the
claimant sustained 50% physical disability due to mal-union of the joints.
Thus the computation of learned Commissioner to accept the contention
FAO No.530 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: MANAS KUMAR PANDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, Cuttack
Date: 02-Feb-2026 19:14:40
of the claimant counting his disability up to 50% and taking note of his
profession as a driver drawing the same for loss of earning capacity up to
90%, cannot be opined as unjustified.
11.
The further contention advanced by Mr. Mahali regarding non-
holding of required driving license for driving the vehicle in question at
the time of accident, it needs to be mentioned here that admittedly the
claimant was having a valid driving license on the date of accident for
LMV and transport vehicle. It is explained by Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of M/s. Bajaj Alliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. V. Rambha
Devi and Others, (2025) 3 SCC 95 that, the additional eligibility criteria
for transport vehicle mentioned in the driving license would generally
apply for those vehicles having weight of more than 7500 kilograms. The
relevant paragraphs are reproduced below:―130. Now harking back to the primary issue and noticing that
the core driving skills (as enunciated in the earlier paragraphs),
expected to be mastered by all drivers are universal—
regardless of whether the vehicle falls into ―Transport‖ or
―Non-Transport‖ category, it is the considered opinion of this
Court that if the gross vehicle weight is within 7500 kg—the
quintessential common man's driver Sri, with LMV licence,
can also drive a ―transport vehicle‖. We are able to reach such
a conclusion as none of the parties in this case has produced
any empirical data to demonstrate that the LMV driving
FAO No.530 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: MANAS KUMAR PANDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, Cuttack
Date: 02-Feb-2026 19:14:40
licence-holder, driving a ―transport vehicle‖, is a significant
cause for road accidents in India. The additional eligibility
criteria as specified in the MV Act and the MV Rules as
discussed in this judgment will apply only to such vehicle
(―medium goods vehicle‖, ―medium passenger vehicle‖,
―heavy goods vehicle‖ and ―heavy passenger vehicle‖), whose
gross weight exceeds 7500 kg. Our present interpretation on
how the licensing regime is to operate for drivers under the
statutory scheme is unlikely to compromise the road safety
concerns. This will also effectively address the livelihood
issues for drivers operating transport vehicles (who clock
maximum hours behind the wheels), in legally operating
―transport vehicles‖ (below 7500 kg), with their LMV driving
licence. Perforce Sri must drive responsibly and should have
no occasion to be called either a maniac or an idiot (as
mentioned in the first paragraph), while he is behind the
wheels. Such harmonious interpretation will substantially
address the vexed question of law before this Court.
131. Our conclusions following the above discussion are as
under:
(1)
A driver holding a licence for light motor vehicle
(LMV) class, under Section 10(2)(d) for vehicles with a
gross vehicle weight under 7500 kg, is permitted to
operate a ―transport vehicle‖ without needing additional
authorisation under Section 10(2)(e) of the MV Act
specifically for the ―transport vehicle‖ class. For
licensing purposes, LMVs and transport vehicles are not
entirely separate classes. An overlap exists between the
two. The special eligibility requirements will however
continue to apply for, inter alia, e-carts, e-rickshaws, and
vehicles carrying hazardous goods.
FAO No.530 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: MANAS KUMAR PANDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, Cuttack
Date: 02-Feb-2026 19:14:40
(2)
The second part of Section 3(1), which emphasises the
necessity of a specific requirement to drive a ―transport
vehicle‖, does not supersede the definition of LMV
provided in Section 2(21) of the MV Act.
(3)
The additional eligibility criteria specified in the MV Act
and the MV Rules generally for driving ―transport
vehicles‖ would apply only to those intending to operate
vehicles with gross vehicle weight exceeding 7500 kg
i.e. ―medium goods vehicle‖, ―medium passenger
vehicle‖, ―heavy goods vehicle‖ and ―heavy passenger
vehicle‖.
(4)
The
decision
in Mukund
Dewangan v. Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd., (2017) 14 SCC 663 is upheld but for
reasons as explained by us in this judgment. In the
absence of any obtrusive omission, the decision is not
per incuriam, even if certain provisions of the MV Act
and the MV Rules were not considered in the said
judgment.‖
12.
In the given facts of the present case which admittedly shows that
the injured – driver had the driving license for a transport vehicle along
with the license for LMV, the contention advanced by Mr. Mahali does
not hold any force. The vehicle in question is a truck and at the time of
accident it was admittedly driven by the claimant. Thus, as per the
principles elaborated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rambha Devi
case (supra) there would be no hesitation to conclude that the claimant
FAO No.530 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: MANAS KUMAR PANDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, Cuttack
Date: 02-Feb-2026 19:14:40
has the required driving license at the time of accident to drive the
vehicle in question.
13.
The date of birth of the claimant is admitted to be on 24 th June,
1991 as mentioned in his driving license. Thus his age comes to 32 years
4 months 3 weeks on the date of accident and therefore, the proper factor
would be 201.66, as per Schedule-IV of the EC Act. Accordingly,
accepting all other computations arrived by the learned Commissioner as
it is, the compensation amount is modified to Rs.16,33,446/- (rupees
sixteen lakhs thirty-three thousand four hundred forty-six only), i.e.
9000/- X 201.66 X 90%, payable along with interest @ 12% per annum
from the date of accident.
14.
Accordingly the appeal is disposed of modifying the compensation
amount to the tune of Rs.16,33,446/- (rupees sixteen lakhs thirty-three
thousand four hundred forty-six only) along with interest @ 12% per
annum from the date of accident, i.e. 14th November, 2023 till the date of
deposit.
15.
Since the compensation amount as per direction of the
Commissioner has already been deposited, the amount due on the part of
the claimant – Respondent No.1 as per this judgment may be disbursed in
FAO No.530 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: MANAS KUMAR PANDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, Cuttack
Date: 02-Feb-2026 19:14:40
his favour without delay along with accrued interest thereof and the
balance amount if any, may be refunded to the insurer – Appellant. In
case any amount fall short, the same shall be deposited by the insurer –
Appellant within a period of eight weeks from today.
16.
The direction for payment of penalty and penal interest is waived.
17.
The copies of depositions and exhibits, as produced in course of
hearing are kept on record.
( B.P. Routray)
Judge
M.K. Panda/P.A
FAO No.530 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review