Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
%
!
"
&
' !
#
#$
!
#
(
)
+
(
)
"
(
)
*
*
!
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
"
"
!
#$%& '(
)
!
'
"
!
!
!
+
#$*( (('
"
-2-
!
"
#$%& '('
!
# &%
!
"
#$%& '('
&
,
'
-
#$%& '(
$
,
!
"
#$% '(
!
%
*
.
"
# $%& '+/
!
.
!
*%
!
*
%
.
0%
-3-
"
# $%& '+/
)
!
"
"
'
*
%
++*
++
,
!
.
,
!
&('('%
+
( '( +(++
&(/'++
+
+ '( +(++
&('('
+
( '( +(++
&('(''
+
+' (/ +(++
&(/'+&
+
+ '( +(++
!
.
-
!
#
-
!
# '
-
!
# +
-
#
-
!
# &
.
,
!
.
,
!
.
,
!
!
.
,
.
+ .
# (
$
* & .'
"
-
#!
,
($ (
.
!
!
+(+
.! ".
# &% .+(++#
!
''( '*/.' &*
!
#
+/ (' +(+$
,.
.'+$ '+& '+
-4-
'++
'+(.+(+ #+&
-
+*
#
2 3!
"
"
!
#$%& '(
!
'
"
!
!
!
#$*( (('
+
!
"
#$%& '('
!
# &%
!
"
#$%& '('
"
#
-5-
&
,
'
-
#$%& '(
$
.
!
$%
!
.
*#'#+/%'.'+ "
"
"
# $*
" !
!
"
"
'
$
++*
++
,
!
,
.
#
&'$(+%
+
+' '' +(++
!
-
.
#
!
+/ (' +(+$
!
"*
!
,.
#
.'+'.+(+ #+&.
*
-6-
#
2 3!
"
"
!
#$%& '(
!
'
"
!
"
!
!
#$*( (('
+
!
"
#$%& '('
!
# &%
!
"
#$%& '('
&
,
-
'
#$%& '(
$
,
-
-7-
!
"
#$% '(
*
!
.
!
*%
"
# $%& '+/
!
"
"
'
*
++*
++
,
.
!
&'$(+*
+' '' +(++
!
+
-
#
!
,
.
!
+/ (' +(+$
!
'+*.+(+ #+&.
!
,.
.'+'
-
4!
#
-8-
5676 869:9:;<7 =>6 ?:@6A BC 956 869:9:;<6> D5; :7 956
=9:;<=@
:E5D=C7
+
F95;>:9C ;? <A:=
>:9
69:9:;<
; +(&'%'.+(+$
766G:<E 9; HF=75 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 A=96A (
B6=>:<E
(
; &('('%
'( +(++
+
B6=>:<E
'( +(++
B6=>:<E
; &('('
:7
?:@6A
'( +(++
; &(/'++
+' (/ +(++
B6=>:<E
; &('('' =<A +
'( +(++ B6=>:<E
<<6KF>67
& >6786I9:J6@C 8=776A BC >678;<A6<9
; +.956
68F9C
=D=>A
;
' 9;
;LL:77:;<6>
8>;I66A:<E7
.
.! ".
A=96A
HF=75.769
($ (
??:I6> =<A
IHF:7:9:;<
B6=>:<E
J:A6
86I:=@
=<A
F95;>:9C ?;>
=<A
=<A 9; 769 =7:A6 956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A A=96A
+/ (' +(+$
B6=>:<E
;
'++0'+(.+(+ #+&. %/
J:A6
>678;<A6<9
# (
; $.956
;L8696<9
J:A6
=7:A6
+(+
# &% .+(++#+ .
<<6KF>6#! 8=776A BC >678;<A6<9
IHF:7:9:;<
; &(/'+&
;
;LL:77:;<6>
.956
,.
.'+$
'+&
<<6KF>6#
>B:9>=9;> =<A 956
'+
8=776A
AA:9:;<=@
BC
68F9C
-9-
>:9
69:9:;<
; +(&'$/.+(+$
:7
?:@6A
766G:<E 9; HF=75 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6> A=96A +' '' +(++
B6=>:<E
; &'$(+% 8=776A BC >678;<A6<9
;+
J:A6
<<6KF>6#
=<A 9; 769 =7:A6 956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A A=96A
+/ (' +(+$
B6=>:<E
J:A6
;
,.
.'+'0'+*.+(+ #+&.
<<6KF>6#
8=776A BC >678;<A6<9
&
>:9
69:9:;<
*
;
; +(((% .+(+*
:7
?:@6A
766G:<E 9; HF=75 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6> A=96A +' '' +(++
B6=>:<E
; &'$(+* 8=776A BC >678;<A6<9
;+
J:A6
<<6KF>6#
=<A 9; 769 =7:A6 956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A A=96A
+/ (' +(+$
B6=>:<E
J:A6
<<6KF>6#
$
L9
;
,.
.'+'0'+*.+(+ #+&.
8=776A BC >678;<A6<9
9 :7 956 I;<96<9:;< ;? 956 @6=><6A I;F<76@
>F9:
?;> 956 869:9:;<6> 95=9 956
<A:= 95>;FE5 :97
:<:79>C ;?
;=A
6I9:;<
= ;? 956
=9:;<=@
;J6><L6<9 ;?
>=<78;>9 =<A
:77F6A <;9:?:I=9:;< B6=>:<E <FLB6>
;
:E5D=C7
+(
:E5D=C7
F<A6>
I9 '/$* ?;> 75;>9
I9 ;? '/$*3 ;< (& (' +(++ =88;:<9:<E >678;<A6<9
- 10 -
; & =7 = I;L8696<9 =F95;>:9C ?;> =IHF:7:9:;< ;? @=<A7 ?;>
956 8>;M6I9
56 ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 ;< +
<;9:?:I=9:;< B6=>:<E <FLB6>
=88;:<96A
:<
8@=I6
I;L8696<9 =F95;>:9C
/$&
;?
>:9
>678;<A6<9
>678;<A6<9
;&
; $ D=7
=7
6=><6A I;F<76@ ?F>956> I;<96<A7
95=9 ;< 956 J6>C <6K9 A=C : 6
;7 * 9; % :<
(% +(++ J:A6
;< +& (% +(++ >678;<A6<9
69:9:;<
; +(&'%'.+(+$ =88@:6A ?;>
I;<J6>7:;< ;? 956:> @=<A7 B6=>:<E
C
;7 ''( &* =<A
*
>6786I9:J6@C ?;> I;LL6>I:=@ F76
*
9 :7 ?F>956> I;<96<A6A BC 956 @6=><6A I;F<76@
95=9 ;< +' (/ +(++ D:95:< @677 95=< = L;<95 ;? 956
=88@:I=9:;< L=A6 >678;<A6<9
; + D:95;F9 ?;@@;D:<E 956
8>;86> 8>;I6AF>6 8>67I>:B6A F<A6> 956 @=D
I;<J6>7:;< ;? 956 @=<A :<
F76
F>J6C
;
E>=<96A
* ?;> I;LL6>I:=@
56>6=?96> ;< +% (/ +(++ >678;<A6<9
;7 * =<A
=88@:6A ?;> I;<J6>7:;< ;? 956 @=<A7 B6=>:<E
C
;7 '*/.'
=<A & .' >6786I9:J6@C ?;> I;LL6>I:=@ F76
9 :7 ?F>956>
I;<96<A6A BC 956 @6=><6A I;F<76@ 95=9 =E=:< :< @677 95=< =
L;<95 D:95;F9 ?;@@;D:<E 956 8>;86> 8>;I6AF>6 >678;<A6<9
- 11 -
; + E>=<96A I;<J6>7:;< ;? 956 @=<A7 :<
F>J6C
;7 ''(
=<A &* ?;> I;LL6>I:=@#=E>;#B=76A :<AF79>:67 F76 ;<
(
'( +(++ =<A 956 @=<A7 B6=>:<E
?;> I;LL6>I:=@ F76 ;< +
C
;7 '*/.' =<A & .'
'( +(++
9 :7 ?F>956> I;<96<A6A 95=9 A678:96 I;<J6>7:;<
;>A6>7 5=J:<E B66< E>=<96A @677 95=< = L;<95 B6?;>6
8>6@:L:<=>C
;9:?:I=9:;< BF9 =?96> 956 8>;M6I9 :976@? 5=A
B66< <;9:?:6A >678;<A6<9
; $ =776776A 956 <=9F>6 ;? 956
@=<A7 =IHF:>6A ?>;L >678;<A6<9
;7 * 9; % =7 F<A6J6@;86A
I;LL6>I:=@ @=<A7 =<A A696>L:<6A 956 L=>G69 J=@F6 ;? 956
7=L6 =7
7 +$&.# 86> 7HF=>6 L696>7 :<
; +(&'%'.+(+$ =<A
69:9:;<
>:9
69:9:;<
7 '&'.# 86> 7HF=>6 L696>7 :<
;7 +(&'$/.+(+$
=<A
+(((% .+(+*
>:9
=<A
=II;>A:<E@C I;L86<7=9:;< D6>6 =D=>A6A ?;> 956 =IHF:>6A
@=<A7
7=:A
I;L86<7=9:;<
A:7BF>76A 9; >678;<A6<9
; +(&'%'.+(+$
=D=>A7
I=L6
;7 * 9; % :<
>:9
69:9:;<
:<
>:9
69:9:;<
; * :<
>:9
69:9:;<
>678;<A6<9
;$
;7 +(&'$/.+(+$ =<A >678;<A6<9
9;
B6
- 12 -
+(((% .+(+* =<A 956 =D=>A 8>;I66A:<E7 I=L6 9; B6
8=776A ;< ($ (
%
+(+
9 :7 ?F>956> I;<96<A6A 95=9 B6:<E =EE>:6J6A BC
956 I;L86<7=9:;< =D=>A6A
956 =B;J6 7=:A >678;<A6<9
8>6?6>>6A I@=:L7 F<A6>
6I9:;<
B6?;>6 >678;<A6<9
< 956 I@=:L 869:9:;<7 7; ?:@6A BC
956 >678;<A6<97
;
#
$ ;? 956
I9 ;? '/$*
:9 D=7 I;<96<A6A 95=9 956 869:9:;<6>
=88@:6A ?;> 7=<I9:;< ;? 956 @=C;F9 ?>;L 956 ;??:I6 ;? 956
77:79=<9
:>6I9;>
;D< =<A
;F<9>C
=:I5F> ;<@C ;< +& '' +(++ : 6
8>6@:L:<=>C
;9:?:I=9:;<
=II;F<9 ;? =IHF:7:9:;<
@=<<:<E
??:I6
=?96> 956 A=96 ;?
9 :7 =@7; I;<96<A6A 95=9 ;<
;9:?:I=9:;< 8@=< 7=<I9:;< D=7 <;9
;B9=:<6A =<A 956 I@=:L=<97 D6>6 F<=B@6 9; A6J6@;8 956
@=<A7
/
6=><6A I;F<76@ ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 =7 86>
956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7
>678;<A6<9
;7 * 9; %
L=A6
=88@:I=9:;<7 ?;> I;<J6>7:;< ;<@C =?96> 956 <;9:?:I=9:;<
:77F6A ;< (& (' +(++ F<A6>
6I9:;<
=
;? 956
I9 ;?
- 13 -
'/$*
9 :7 ?F>956> I;<96<A6A 95=9 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A7 I=L6 9;
B6 8=776A ;< +/ (' +(+$
'(
6=><6A I;F<76@ J656L6<9@C I;<96<A7 95=9 956
I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 =D=>A 8>;I66A:<E7 =<A =>B:9>=@ =D=>A7
=>6
=@@
D:95;F9
MF>:7A:I9:;<
=>B:9>=>C
=L;F<97 9; 7FBJ6>7:;< ;? 956 >F@6 ;? @=D
86>J6>76
=<A
9 :7 ?F>956>
I;<96<A6A 95=9 956 :L8FE<6A I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 8=776A BC
>678;<A6<9
; + =>6 D:95;F9 MF>:7A:I9:;< =7 :9 5=7 B66<
8=776A =?96> 956 :77F=<I6 ;? <;9:?:I=9:;< F<A6>
=
;? 956
I9 ;? '/$*
8>;I677 ;? @=D
6I9:;<
7; =@7; D:95;F9 ?;@@;D:<E AF6
56 @6=><6A I;F<76@ ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9
:9 :7 =88=>6<9@C I@6=> 95=9 956 F>E6<IC :< D5:I5 956
I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 5=J6 B66< 8=776A D:95:< @677 95=< =
L;<95 ;? 956 =88@:I=9:;< 5=J:<E B66< L=A6 D:95;F9
?;@@;D:<E AF6 8>;I677 =<A 8>;I6AF>6 ;? @=D =<A <; 2
5=7 B66< ;B9=:<6A ?>;L
;> ?>;L 956
9=96
6<9:>6 8>;I677 ;? I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 =<A 956 =D=>A7 =>6
@:=B@6 9; B6 769 =7:A6
9 :7 =@7; I;<96<A6A BC 956 I;F<76@
95=9 956 =D=>A7 8=776A ;< 956 B=7:7 ;? 956 7=:A I;<J6>7:;<
- 14 -
;>A6>7 D6>6 :< @677 95=< ;<6 L;<95 8>:;> 9; 956 A=96 ;? 956
8>6@:L:<=>C
;9:?:I=9:;< A696>L:<67 956 ?>=FA 8@=C6A D:95
I;@@F7:;< =<A <6KF7 ;? 956 =F95;>:9:67
>678;<A6<9
;
9 :7 I;<96<A6A 95=9
;FE59 9; 5=J6 <;9:I6A 95=9 956 I@=:L ;?
956 @=<A7 5=J:<E B66< I;<J6>96A ?;> I;LL6>I:=@ F76 :7 <;9
679=B@:756A :< 956 @:E59 ;? 956 I;<J6>7:;< 5=J:<E B66<
E>=<96A 7D:?9@C :< @677 95=< ;<6 L;<95 ?>;L 956 A=96 ;?
8>6@:L:<=>C
;9:?:I=9:;<
''
6=><6A
>678;<A6<9
;
I;F<76@
?F>956>
I;<96<A7
95=9
5=7 ?=:@6A 9; =88@C 5:7 L:<A 9; 956 ?=I97
=<A I:>IFL79=<I67 956 :L8FE<6A I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 B=>7
956 A6J6@;8L6<9 ;? 956 @=<A7 D:95:< &( L696>7 ;? 956
I6<96> ;?
;?
9=96
:E5D=C. =9:;<=@
?F>956> I;<96<A6A 95=9 >678;<A6<9
;
:E5D=C
9 :7
I;F@A <;9 5=J6
9>6=96A 956 @=<A7 =7 A6J6@;86A I;LL6>I:=@ @=<A7 :< 956
=B76<I6
;?
=<C
7=<I9:;<
8@=<
?>;L
I;L8696<9
=F95;>:9C ;> :< 956 =B76<I6 ;? 8>;;? ;? =<C A6J6@;8L6<9 ;?
@=<A7
56>6?;>6
I;<96<A7
95=9
6<9:>6
- 15 -
A696>L:<=9:;< ;? 956 J=@F6 ;? 956 7;#I=@@6A A6J6@;86A
@=<A7 =>6 =>B:9>=>C D:95;F9 =<C B=7:7
'+
6=><6A I;F<76@ ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 L6>6@C
B6I=F76 =>B:9>=@ 869:9:;<7 ?:@6A BC 956 869:9:;<6> =>6
>6M6I96A ;< 956 E>;F<A ;? 956C B6:<E B=>>6A BC @:L:9=9:;<
956 7=L6 D:@@ <;9 A68>:J6 956 869:9:;<6> ?>;L I5=@@6<E:<E
956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 L=A6 :< = 5=79C L=<<6> D:95
A6@:B6>=96 :<96<9 9; L=G6 F<@=D?F@ E=:<
< 7F88;>9 ;? 56>
I=76 756 5=7 8@=I6A >6@:=<I6 ;< 956 ?;@@;D:<E MFAEL6<971
:
::
! "
#
$%
)
* +
.
'
&
,
,
!
! $%
@6=><6A I;F<76@
=886=>:<E ?;> >678;<A6<9
95=9 =9 956 ;F9769
'(
! &
!*
'
>:
=5=<9675
=9:@
;7 * 9; % J656L6<9@C I;<96<A7
956 8>676<9 869:9:;<7 D;F@A <;9 B6
L=:<9=:<=B@6 6:956> :< @=D ;> ;< ?=I97 =<A 956 7=L6
A676>J6 9; B6 A:7L:776A D:95;F9 A6@J:<E ?F>956> ;< L6>:97
- 16 -
6 ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 956 869:9:;<6> 7F88>677:<E 956
L=96>:=@ ?=I97 5=7 =88>;=I56A 95:7
;F>9 D:95;F9 I@6=<
5=<A7 956>6BC :9 :7 =< =BF76 ;? 8>;I677 ;? @=D
6=><6A
I;F<76@ ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 956 I5=@@6<E6 :7 L=A6 BC 956
869:9:;<6> 9; 956 ;>A6>7 ;? I;<J6>7:;< =<A 956 I5=@@6<E6 9;
956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A7 :< 95676 869:9:;<7 D5:I5 =E=:< :7 <;9
7F79=:<=B@6
5=J:<E
6 ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 956 869:9:;<6> :7
<;
9;
I5=@@6<E6
;>A6>7
;?
I;<J6>7:;< BC I;<96<A:<E 95=9 956 =?;>67=:A @=<A7 =>6
=AM=I6<9
9;
J:@@=E6
=<A
956>6
A6J6@;8L6<9 7F>>;F<A:<E 956 @=<A7
=>6
I;LL6>I:=@
9 :7 =@7; I;<96<A6A
95=9 956 @=<A7 =>6 5=J:<E
8;96<9:=@:9C 956 7=L6 D6>6
I;<J6>96A ;< +' (/ +(++ (
'( +(++ =<A +
'( +(+(
=@7; A6<:67 95=9 956 ;>A6>7 ;? I;<J6>7:;<7 8=776A D:95;F9
?;@@;D:<E AF6 8>;I677 ;? @=D =<A 9=G67 F8 = I;<96<9:;<
95=9 956 ;>A6>7 8=776A F<A6>
=<A
6J6<F6
>:BF<=@ F<A6>
6I9:;< /$ ;? 956 "=><=9=G=
I9 =>6 =L6<=B@6 9; I5=@@6<E6 B6?;>6 956
6I9:;< &/ I
;? 956 "=><=9=G=
=<A
- 17 -
6J6<F6
I9 ;< 95:7 E>;F<A =@7; 956 8>676<9 869:9:;<7 =>6
@:=B@6 9; B6 A:7L:776A
'&
6=><6A I;F<76@ ?;> 956 >678;<A6<97 ?F>956>
I;<96<A7
95=9
:L8FE<6A
=>B:9>=@
=D=>A7
A=96A
+/ (' +(+$ D6>6 =@>6=AC I5=@@6<E6A BC 956 869:9:;<6> BC
D=C ;?
F<A6>
>B:9>=9:;<
6I9:;<
:79>:I9 FAE6
69:9:;<
;7 +%.+(+$ =<A +/.+(+$
& ;? 956
I9 ;? '//* B6?;>6 956
=:I5F>
>B:9>=9:;<
>:<I:8=@
69:9:;<7 I=L6 9;
B6 A:7L:776A J:A6 ;>A6> A=96A (' '+ +(+$ =7 B=>>6A BC
956 @=D ;? @:L:9=9:;<
56>6?;>6
869:9:;<6> 5=J:<E ?=:@6A F<A6>
'//*
56 I;<96<A7 95=9 956
& ;? 956
I9 ;?
I=<<;9 :<J;G6 956 D>:9 MF>:7A:I9:;< F<A6>
>9:I@67
++* =<A ++
:L86>L:77:B@6
;? 956
6I9:;<
;<79:9F9:;< ;? <A:= =7 956 7=L6 :7
6=><6A I;F<76@ ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9
F8;< A:7L:77=@ ;? 956 =>B:9>=9:;< 869:9:;<7 ?:@6A F<A6>
6I9:;<
& ;? 956
I9 ;? '//*
B;956>6A 9; ?:@6 =< =886=@ F<A6>
'//*
956 869:9:;<6> 5=7 <;9
6I9:;<
;? 956
I9 ;?
- 18 -
'$
9 :7 =@7; I;<96<A6A 95=9 956 869:9:;<6> ?:@6A 956
8>676<9 869:9:;<7 ;<@C D:95 =
:<96<9 9; =J;:A
A68;7:9 ;? I;L86<7=9:;< :< 956 6K6IF9:;< 869:9:;<7 86<A:<E
B6?;>6 956
>:<I:8=@
:79>:I9 FAE6
=:I5F>
56>6?;>6 56
I;<96<A7 95=9 9; I:>IFLJ6<9 =@@ 95676 79=9F9;>C B=>7 ;?
@:L:9=9:;< =<A 956 I;<76HF6<I67 ;? <;9 5=J:<E B66<
7FII677?F@
956 8>676<9 D>:9 869:9:;<7 =>6 ?:@6A D5:I5 :7
6K8>677@C 8>;5:B:96A BC 7699@6A @=D :< I=96<= ;? MFAEL6<97
;? 956
;<3B@6
86K
;F>9
6=><6A I;F<76@
?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 956>6 :7 <; :@@6E=@:9C :< 956 =>B:9>=@
=D=>A7
7; =@7; :< 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 8=776A BC
>678;<A6<9
;+
? =9 =@@ 956 869:9:;<6> 5=7 =<C E>:6J=<I6
D:95 >6E=>A 9; A:7L:77=@ ;? 956 =>B:9>=@ 869:9:;<7 956 7=L6
D;F@A 5=J6 9; B6 I5=@@6<E6A :< 956 L=<<6> G<;D< 9; @=D
F<A6>
6I9:;<
;? 956
I9 ;? '//*
=J:<E <;9 A;<6 7;
956 8>676<9 869:9:;<7 =>6 <;9 L=:<9=:<=B@6
'*
;<3B@6
2*
6=><6A I;F<76@ ?F>956>
86K
I;<96<A7 95=9 956
;F>9 :< 956 I=76 ;? /
! , -
2*
$%
&
0 #
1!
!
' 5=7
- 19 -
A68>6I=96A 956 :<96>?6>6<I6 F<A6>
>9:I@67 ++* =<A ++
;?
;<79:9F9:;< ;? <A:= ;? 95;76 L=996>7 E;J6><6A F<A6>
I9 ;? '//* =<A 56@A 95=9 956
I:>IFL786I9
:<
6<96>9=:<:<E
;F>9 LF79 B6 6K9>6L6@C
869:9:;<
F<A6>
D>:9
MF>:7A:I9:;< =7 956 7=L6 I=<<;9 B6 F76A =7 = 7FB79:9F96
?;> 79=9F9;>C >6L6A:67
6 =@7; 8@=I6A >6@:=<I6 ;< 956
MFAEL6<9
;?
#
!! 6
! 2*
+
1!
,
!
! $%
!
4 .0
5 !
&
3'7
D56>6:< :9 :7 56@A 95=9 7:<I6 7FI5 =< =88@:I=9:;< D=7 <;9
96<=B@6 D6 ?=:@ 9; F<A6>79=<A 5;D :< = D>:9 869:9:;< ?:@6A
=E=:<79 =< ;>A6> L=A6 BC
=88@:I=9:;< 956
=D=>A
:79>:I9 FAE6 :< =< F<#96<=B@6
:E5 I;F>9 I;F@A 5=J6 769 =7:A6 8=>9:=@
6=><6A I;F<76@ :< 7F88;>9 ;? 5:7 I=76 5=7 =@7;
>6@:6A F8;< 956 ?;@@;D:<E MFAEL6<971
:
$%
::
(
!
&
$%
+ 9
':
! 16
&
2*
! 9; 61
':
- 20 -
:::
!
!
5 <1*
$%
&
&
':
':
:J
= #
!) = 5
* $%
J
9; 61
7<
)1
. $#2
J:
= #
, 2
$
!
=
<
'
56>6?;>6
!
, 2
/
!8
< !
':
/
&
8 + >
<
'
$%
J::
J:::
<
/
#
! 16 1
<
+ 0
':
!
!
, 2
<
)1
. 00
3' (
$
56 I;<96<A7 95=9 ;< 956 B=7:7 ;?
95676 MFAEL6<97 =<A 956 ?=I97 =<A I:>IFL79=<I67 ;? 956
I=76 D56< 956 869:9:;<6> 5=J:<E ?=:@6A 9; I5=@@6<E6 956
A:7L:77=@ ;>A6> F<A6>
6I9:;<
& ;? 956
I9 ;? '//* 956
8>676<9 869:9:;<7 D;F@A <;9 7F>J:J6 ?;> I;<7:A6>=9:;< 956
7=L6 =>6 @:=B@6 9; B6 A:7L:776A
- 21 -
'%
8=>9:67
=J:<E 56=>A 956
@6=><6A
I;F<76@ ?;> 956
956 8;:<9 95=9 =>:767 ?;> I;<7:A6>=9:;< :7 =7 9;
D56956> 956 8>676<9 869:9:;<7 =>6 L=:<9=:<=B@6
'/
9 :7 <;9 :< A:78F96 95=9 956 869:9:;<6> :7 <;D
HF679:;<:<E 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 8=776A BC >678;<A6<9
;+
=<A 956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A7
88=>6<9@C
D56< 956
869:9:;<6> D=7 <;9 7FII677?F@ :< I5=@@6<E:<E 956 =>B:9>=@
=D=>A7 B6?;>6 956
>:<I:8=@
:79>:I9
=<A
677:;<7 FAE6
=:I5F> =<A 5=J:<E <;9 ?:@6A =< =886=@ =7 I;<96L8@=96A
F<A6>
6I9:;<
;? 956
I9 ;? '//*
<;D 9>C:<E 9;
I5=@@6<E6 956 =D=>A7 =<A 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 :< LC
5FLB@6 ;8:<:;< D;F@A <;9 B6 7F79=:<=B@6
7; =@7; 956
869:9:;<7 ?:@6A BC 956 869:9:;<6> I5=@@6<E:<E 956 =>B:9>=@
=D=>A7 D;F@A <;9 B6 L=:<9=:<=B@6 B6?;>6 95:7
;F>9 :< D>:9
MF>:7A:I9:;< F<A6>
;<79:9F9:;<
;? <A:=
#
!
1!
F<A6>
>9:I@67 ++* =<A ++
;<3B@6
7F8>=
86K
;? 956
;F>9 :< 956 I=76 ;?
=9 8=>=E>=85
;7 + =<A
+
56@A =7
- 22 -
!
" !
(
#$
&#$
(
+ 9
%
'
!
(
*
'
+
"*
(
)
,
!
-
"#
.
(
/)
(
(
!
!
!
"*
(
!
(
!
!
!
(
- 23 -
(
!
'
+
(
!
(
)
*
'
&
+(
#
< 956 I=76 ;?
!
+ =
? .!
+ 4
'7 956
,
;<3B@6
86K
.
! $%
&
;F>9 =9 8=>=E>=85
;7 '' =<A '+ 56@A =7 F<A6>
// !
!
(
(
)
'
(
!
'
- 24 -
(
'
(
)
!
2(
!
2(
/
+
(
'
(
!
)
+'
.1
+
;<3B@6
2*
=9 8=>=E>=85
86K
;F>9
:<
I=76
*0
.
! 8
+
)
$
, 2
'
;7 & =<A $ 56@A =7 F<A6>
#
$
(
(
(
.
'
(
9 : :; /$
)
*:)
*
(
(
;?
- 25 -
(
,
!
,
$ !
<
,
(
!
):=
,
; =@7; :< 956 I=76 ;? 9+ 6
! "
!!
, ! 7 $%
! 16
&
;F>9 =9 8=>=E>=85
!
+
*0
3 ' 956
;7
*
!
+ =<A
!2*
. 2*
;<3B@6
F8>6L6
56@A =7 F<A6>
>
?
(
@2@
@
@ '
?
?2?
?
?
.
"#
(AB(C ' (
- 26 -
(
?
?2?
@
@ (
?
?
(
?2?
@
@ '
;
D
%.
&
!
,
) A
#
&
*"
;
- 27 -
9)# '( /#);
C
<
F
?
#
;
@
'
E' A
A
;
++
+1
;<3B@6
!
86K
2*
2*
$
#
;F>9 :< 956 I=76 ;?
!
! / ;
!
+
' =9 8=>=E>=85
;7 '& 9;
'* 56@A =7 F<A6>
/#
(
'
!
:G /:
!
: #
- 28 -
?
@
?
.
A+./
'
(
)2
9 ;
9 ;
!
%.
&9 ;
'
9 ;
; C1
; '
*
(
)2
*
- 29 -
9 1; !
? 1
?
?
?
91;
C
&
/$
'
>
(
)2
*
?
?
(
9 ;
!
/)
+
,
!
+
!
!
(
. 1
!
91;
- 30 -
!
>
>
. 1
!
>
+
=J:<E 56=>A 956 @6=><6A I;F<76@ ?;> B;95 956
8=>9:67 =<A 5=J:<E I;<7:A6>6A 956 MFAEL6<97 >6@:6A BC 956
@6=><6A I;F<76@ ?;> 956 869:9:;<6> @6=><6A I;F<76@ ?;> 956
>678;<A6<97 =<A 956 MFAEL6<97 >6@:6A BC 95:7
;F>9 :9 :7
=88=>6<9@C 766< 95=9 956 8>676<9 869:9:;<7 :< D5=97;6J6>
L=<<6> D;F@A <;9 B6 L=:<9=:<=B@6 =7 956 869:9:;<6> D;F@A
<;9 B6 6<9:9@6A 9; L=:<9=:< 956 D>:9 869:9:;<7 F<A6>
++* =<A ++
;? 956
;<79:9F9:;< ;?
=@>6=AC 7F??6>6A =< ;>A6> F<A6>
'//*
6<I6
8>676<9
<A:= D56< :9 5=7
6I9:;<
D>:9
>9:I@67
& ;? 956
869:9:;<7
L=:<9=:<=B@6 =7 95676 =>6 B=>>6A BC @=D
=>6
I9 ;?
<;9
7; =@7; 956
8>676<9 D>:9 869:9:;<7 I=<<;9 B6 6<96>9=:<6A 9; I;<7:A6>
;956> 8>=C6>7 ;? 956 869:9:;<7 : 6
;>A6>7 ;? I;<J6>7:;<
- 31 -
D5:I5 ;FE59 9; 5=J6 B66< I5=@@6<E6A :< 956 L=<<6> G<;D<
9; @=D
;> 956 =?;>67=:A >6=7;<7
D5=9 F<#L:79=G6<@C
6L6>E67 :7 95=9 :< I=96<= ;? MFAEL6<97
F8>6L6
;<3B@6
;F>9 5=7 I@6=>@C @=:A A;D< 956 @=D D:95 >6E=>A
9; =<C I5=@@6<E6 L=A6 9; 956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A =<A 956
A:7L:77=@ ;? 956 869:9:;< ?:@6A F<A6>
6I9:;<
& ;? 956
I9
;? '//* I=<<;9 B6 6<96>9=:<6A :< 956 D>:9 MF>:7A:I9:;<
F<A6>
>9:I@67 ++* =<A ++
56>6?;>6 95:7
;? 956
;<79:9F9:;< ;? <A:=
;F>9 I=<<;9 E; :<9; 956 ;956> E>:6J=<I67
=7 9; 5;D 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 L=A6 =7 956 >6L6AC :7
=J=:@=B@6 9; 956 869:9:;<6> 9; =88>;=I5 =88>;8>:=96 ?;>FL
:< 956 L=<<6> G<;D< 9; @=D
=II;>A:<E@C
=
56 8;:<9 >=:76A :7 =<7D6>6A
8>;I66A 9; 8=77 956 ?;@@;D:<E
>:9
69:9:;<7 =>6 A6J;:A ;? L6>:9
II;>A:<E@C 79=<A A:7L:776A
B
>A6>6A =II;>A:<E@C
(
'
'
!,*
!
'
#
)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review