Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision:-15th January, 2026.
ITA 4/2026
THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX - INTERNATIONAL
TAXATION -3
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Ruhir Bhatia, Mr. Anant Mann &
Ms. Lopamudra Mahapatra, Advs.
versus
SRI LANKA CRICKET
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Ajay Vohra, Sr. Adv. with Mr.
Saksham Singhal & Mr. Samkth
Chaudhari, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DINESH MEHTA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD KUMAR
JUDGMENT
DINESH MEHTA, J. (Oral)
1.
Mr. Ajay Vohra, learned senior counsel for the respondent, at the
outset submitted that the issue involved in the present case is squarely
covered by the judgment of this Court in the case of CIT (International
Taxation) v. Fox Network Group Singapore Pte. Ltd. reported in [2024]
158 taxmann.com 434 (Delhi), in which the earlier judgment of this Court
rendered in the case of CIT v. Delhi Race Club (1940) Ltd. reported in
(2014) 51 taxmann.com 550 (Delhi) involving an identical fact-situation has
been dealt with and followed.
2.
It will not be out of place to reproduce the relevant part of the
judgment in the case of Fox Network (supra):
“7. Before us, both Mr. Bhatia as well as Mr. Rai have assailed the view
taken by the ITAT contending that the service from which income was
generated would clearly fall within the ambit of Explanation 2 as placed in
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
16:44:02
ITA 4/2026
Section 9(1)(vi) of the Act. 8. We, however note that Delhi Race Club has
clearly ruled on the scope and ambit of the expression “the transfer of all
or any rights (including the granting of a license), in respect of any
copyright, literary, artistic or scientific work including films or video tube
tapes....” as finding place in clause (v) of Explanation 2 to Section
9(1)(vi). 9. On a due consideration of the relevant provisions contained in
the Copyright Act, 1957, the Court in Delhi Race Club observed as
follows:“16. Adverting to the facts of this case we note that the assessee
was engaged in the business of conducting horse races and
derived income from betting, commission, entry fee, etc. and had
made payment to other centres whose races were displayed in
Delhi. It is not known whether such races had any commentary
or analysis of the event simultaneously. It is not the case of the
Revenue that the live broadcast recorded for rebroadcast
purposes. Having held that the broadcast/live telecast is not a
work within the definition of 2(y) of the Copyright Act and also
that broadcast/live telecast does not fall within the ambit of s. 13
of the Copyright Act., it would suffice to state that a live
telecast/broadcast would have no „copyright‟. This issue is wellsettled in view of the position of law as laid down by this Court
in ESPIV Star Sports case (supra), wherein this Court after
analysing the provisions of the Copyright Act was of the view
that legislature itself by terming broadcast rights as those akin
to „copyright‟ clearly brought out the distinction between two
rights in Copyright Act, 1957. According to the Court, it was a
clear manifestation of legislative intent to treat copyright and
broadcasting reproduction rights as distinct and separate rights.
It also held that the amendment of the Act in 1994 not only
extended such rights to all broadcasting organizations but also
clearly crystallized the nature of such rights. The Court did not
accept the contention of the respondent that the two rights are
not mutually exclusive by holding that the two rights though akin
are nevertheless separate and distinct.
17. In view of the aforesaid position of law which brought out a
distinction between a copyright and broadcast right, suffice
would it be to state that the broadcast or the live coverage does
not have a „copyright‟. The aforesaid would meet the submission
of Mr. Sawhney that the word „Copyright‟ would encompass all
categories of work including musical, dramatic, etc. and also his
submission that the Copyright Act acknowledges the broadcast
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
16:44:02
ITA 4/2026
right as a right similar to „copyright‟. In view of the conclusion
of this Court in ESPN Star Sports case (supra), such a
submission need to be rejected.
In this regard we also quote for benefit the judgment of this
Court in the case of Akuate Internet Services (P) Ltd. v. Star
India (P) Ltd. (supra) as relied upon by learned counsel for the
respondent assessee wherein a Division Bench of this Court has
applied the test of „minimum requirement of creativity‟ for
claiming a right under the Copyright Act, which is absent in a
„live telecast of an event‟.
We note for benefit that the United States Court of Appeal
Second Circuit Ruling in National Basket Ball Association &
NBA Properties NIC v. Motorola Inc, 105 F.3d. 841 (1997) held
that a sports event is a performance and not a work. It is not
copyrightable.
18. Insofar as the submission of Mr. Sawhney that the live
telecast of an event is the outcome of „scientific work‟ and
payment thereof would be covered under the definition of
„royalty‟ is concerned, the said submission is also liable to be
rejected; first, it runs contrary to his earlier submission and also
for the simple reason the cl. (v) of explanation 2 to clause (vi) of
sub-section(1) of Section 9 would relate to work which includes
films or video tapes for use in connection with television or tapes
for use in connection with radio broadcasting. It is to be seen
whether consideration for transfer of all or any rights of
„scientific work‟ including films or video tapes would include a
live telecast. The clause is an inclusive provision for films or
video tapes for use in connection with television or tapes for use
in connection with radio broadcasting. We note such a case was
not set up by the appellant-Revenue before the authorities below.
It was held by the AO that when any person pays any amount for
getting rights/licence to telecast any event (Which is a copyright
of particular person i.e., no one can copy it for direct telecast or
deferred telecast) then amount so paid is to be treated as
„royalty‟ and very much covered under s. 9(1)(vi). In other
words, the” ground of the Revenue was limited to the aspect of
copyright. That apart, we find, no such ground has, been taken
by the appellant/Revenue even in this appeal. The „scientific
work‟ has not been defined in the Act nor in the Copyright Act. It
is not necessary that because the live telecast of an event is
being done at a distant place, the same would be a „scientific
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
16:44:02
ITA 4/2026
work‟. Even otherwise, even by stretching this meaning, it is
difficult to include a live broadcast within „scientific work‟.
Clause (v) expressly uses the words „including films or video
tapes for use in connection with television or tapes for use in
connection with radio broadcasting‟. These words become
relevant to understand the scope of this part of the provision.
Suffice to state, when reference is made to films or video tapes,
then the intent of the provision is related to work of visual
recording on any medium or video tape and can be seen on the
television. Surely such a work does not include a live telecast.
This submission is also need to be rejected. Insofar as the
submission of Mr. Sawhney that analysis, commentary and use
of technology to live feed make the broadcast a subject-matter of
distant copyright is concerned, again neither such a case was set
up before the authorities, nor in this appeal. In fact it is not
known nor pleaded that the live telecast, in this case, was
accompanied by commentary, analysis etc. It is an issue of fact,
which cannot be gone into or raised at this stage. In view of our
discussion above, we are of the view that no question of law
arises in the present appeals. We dismiss the appeals filed by the
appellant-Revenue.”
10. In light of the unequivocal conclusions as expressed by the Division
Bench in Delhi Race Club and with which we concur, we find that once the
Court came to the conclusion that a live telecast would not fall within the
ambit of the expression „work‟, it would be wholly erroneous to hold that
the income derived by the assessee in respect of „live feed‟ would fall
within clause (v) of Explanation 2 to S.9(1)(vi) of the Act.
11. Notwithstanding the above, Mr. Rai, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant, additionally sought to place the respondent‟s income in clause
(i) of Explanation 2 to Section 9(1)(vi) of the Act and sought to contend that
the word „process‟ as occurring therein would make revenue earned from
„live feed‟ taxable.
12. The aforesaid submission essentially proceeded on the basis of
Explanation 6 to Section 9(1)(vi) which reads as under:“Explanation 6.—For the removal of doubts, it is hereby
clarified that the expression "process" includes and shall be
deemed to have always included transmission by satellite
(including up-linking, amplification, conversion for downlinking of any signal), cable, optic fibre or by any other similar
technology, whether or not such process is secret;]”
15. In addition to the above, we note that the arguments addressed on the
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
16:44:02
ITA 4/2026
anvil of Explanation 6 to Section 9(1)(vi) of the Act lose sight of the salient
principles which were enunciated by our Court in Director of Income Tax
vs. New Skies Satellite bv4 , and where the Court had recognized the
primacy of provisions contained in the Double Taxation Avoidance
Agreements as opposed to domestic statutes.
17. Accordingly, and for all the aforesaid reasons, we hold that the ITAT
did not commit any error in passing the impugned orders dated 20 March
2020 and 21 February 2023 and that it was completely justified in
arriving at the finding that the fees received by the respondents towards
live transmission could not be classified as royalty income under Section
9(1)(vi) of the Act. Consequently, no substantial question of law arises in
the instant appeals and the appeals stand dismissed on the aforesaid
terms.”
3.
Mr. Ajay Vohra, learned counsel for the respondent further submitted
that the SLP filed against another judgment, wherein identical issue was
involved has been withdrawn by the department from Hon’ble the Supreme
Court on 13.01.2026 in SLP no.028186/2016.
4.
We have perused the judgment of CIT v. Fox Network Group
Singapore Pte. Ltd. and also considered the fact that even the SLP
involving identical question filed by the department had been withdrawn.
5.
That apart, Mr. Ruchir Bhatia, learned counsel for the appellant has
not been able to point out any fact which shows that the rights of exhibition
given by the respondent Sri Lanka Cricket exceeded beyond the ‘live feed’.
6.
Since the right to show cricket matches was confined to live telecast
and the payment made was only for the match(es) held in the series (within
12 months) and not subsequent matches, such amount paid to the respondent
cannot be considered as a royalty. ‘Because, royalty presupposes enduring
benefits’. In case the licensee has a right to record or preserve the feed and
he continues to derive benefit of that recording and has right to re-telecast or
show those matches in future, beyond the period or event(s) other than such
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
16:44:02
ITA 4/2026
event, then only, the payment made to the licensee in appropriate case, can
be treated as royalty. However, it is not the case in the present agreement or
transaction, hence the amount in question cannot be considered as royalty.
7.
The appeal filed by the appellant-department is, therefore, dismissed.
DINESH MEHTA
(JUDGE)
VINOD KUMAR
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 15, 2026/sr
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
16:44:02
ITA 4/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review