The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. As a consequence, the order impugned dated December 23, 2019 is found to be exceptionable and same is set aside with a request to the Tribunal to consider the matter afresh uninfluenced by any observations contained in the previous order of this Court or in the present order, but by testing the grounds contained in support of the order-in-original and the challenge thereto as carried by the respondent herein before such Tribunal. It is hoped that since the mater pertains to a seizure made in the year 2017, the Tribunal will dispose of the appeal at its earliest convenience and without affording any adjournment to the parties.
14. Cus. Appeal No.1 of 2020 is allowed as above by setting aside the order impugned dated December 23, 2019 and by remanding the matter to the Tribunal for the respondent’s appeal before it to be considered afresh in accordance with law.
15. There will be no order as to costs. (W. Diengdoh) Judge (Sanjib Banerjee) Chief Justice Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.06
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Cus.Appl.No.1/2020
Date of Order: 09.12.2021
The Commissioner of Customs
(Preventive) N.E.R., Shillong
Coram:
Vs.
Manik Ranjan Paul
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
For the Respondent(s)
: Dr. N Mozika, ASG with
Ms. L Jana, Adv
: Ms. P Sikdar, Adv
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
This is the second round of the matter in this Court and,
unfortunately, may not be the last.
2.
The department questions the propriety of an order of December,
23, 2019 passed by the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate
Tribunal, Kolkata upon the matter being remanded for fresh consideration
by the Tribunal by an order dated May 6, 2019 passed by this Court.
According to the department, the Tribunal has merely gone on the basis of
the observations of the High Court in the order of May 6, 2019 without
appreciating that the High Court had left the entire matter for a de novo
consideration to be undertaken by the Tribunal.
3.
The order impugned runs into five pages and a line beyond. Most
of the first page is taken up by the cause-title and, from the last two lines of
the first page, through the second, third and most of the fourth page,
observations made by the High in the order of May 6, 2019 have been
quoted. The consideration of the matter appears only over a page and a
quarter without reference in any great detail to the order-in-original against
which the appeal before the Tribunal had been carried by the respondent
herein.
4.
It is not as if the order-in-original dated March 29, 2017 is not
referred to at all. There is a reference at paragraph 4 of the order impugned,
to certain findings recorded at paragraphs 10, 13 and 15 of the order-inoriginal without any discussion thereon.
5.
It may do well to appreciate what may have been the issues that
could have fallen for consideration upon appreciating the case that was built
by the department against the respondent. A large haul of betel-nuts was
seized from the respondent’s possession on March 7, 2016 on the
apprehension that those were smuggled from Myanmar and were being
transported through the known route of the illegal transaction of betel-nuts
in this part of the country. It is true that betel-nuts are not covered by
Section 123 of the Customs Act, 1962, but upon the goods being seized by
the department, the respondent herein indicated that they had been obtained
from the four suppliers and such suppliers furnished seven bills of entry
dating between October, 2014 and November, 2015 to show that the goods
had been legally imported into the country from Myanmar.
6.
In course of the Commissioner considering the matter, detailed
reasons were indicated as to why the Commissioner did not believe that the
four suppliers alluded to by the respondent herein had sold the goods to the
respondent. These reasons are found in great detail in the 27 sub-paragraphs
under paragraph 16 of the order of the Commissioner passed on March 29,
2017. If only to appreciate such reasons, it may be noticed that the
Commissioner found as a matter of fact that the respondent herein claimed
to have obtained the huge supplies on credit which, according to the
Commissioner, was unusual since no previous transactions between the
alleged suppliers and the respondent herein was indicated. In addition, the
Commissioner found that the credit memos of suppliers Khuangluaia &
Sons, Thahleikhuaia, Zothanmawii and J.H. Family Enterprise were
fabricated and had been prepared after the goods were seized. The specific
basis for such finding was that the IEC numbers mentioned in the credit
memos of Khuangluaia & Sons dated February 27, 2016 differed and one of
the IEC numbers was that of Zothanmawii. The Commissioner also
discovered that none of the credit memos had any running serial number.
7.
Upon referring to the documents submitted on behalf of the
respondent herein to substantiate his assertion that the seized goods had
been obtained by him from the four sellers, the Commissioner observed that
the bills of entry did not indicate the split variety of betel-nuts having HS
Code 08028020 and concluded that the bills of entry were not relatable to
the seized goods. The Commissioner also noticed that neither the
respondent herein nor the four alleged importers produced any documents
evidencing transportation of betel-nuts through the sales tax gates of
Mizoram or Assam. Though there is a contrary observation in the High
Court order dated May 6, 2019 in respect to the number of bills of entry that
had been relied upon, the Commissioner found that the entire quantum of
seized goods was covered by four bills of entry as the four alleged
importers submitted that they had sold 15,000 kg of betel-nuts to the
respondent herein and there was no corresponding supply effected to the
respondent in respect of the three other bills of entry relied upon before the
Commissioner.
8.
However, in the respondent’s appeal before the Tribunal the
detailed reasons furnished by the Commissioner were glossed over;
possibly since the Tribunal may have agreed with the findings as they were
based on cogent material. In the Tribunal’s order of March 23, 2019, that
runs into two pages and a half, the consideration of the matter is confined to
some 20 lines on the final page. It is such perfunctory treatment of the
matter that may have weighed with this Court in recording the observations
as it did in the order dated May 6, 2019.
9.
The observations of this Court contained in the order of May 6,
2019 have been substantially quoted in the order impugned dated December
23, 2019 and do not call for any repetition. However, such observations
must necessarily be seen only to imply that those factual issues that were
raised by the respondent herein against the findings rendered by the
Commissioner were not considered by the Tribunal in its earlier order of
March 29, 2017. It was this that impelled this Court to send the matter back
to the Tribunal for its fresh consideration.
10.
Ideally, the Tribunal ought to have assessed the reasons furnished
by the Commissioner in the order-in-original and the challenge thrown by
the respondent herein to such findings. Instead, the Tribunal gave much
credence to the observations of this Court in the order of May 6, 2019 to the
effect that when the four suppliers had affirmed affidavits to confirm that
they had supplied the goods to the respondent herein, there was little reason
to question the same.
11.
It is true that the observation is found in the order of May 6, 2019
of this Court. However, such observation of this Court had to be read in the
context of the failure of the Tribunal in course of its original order dated
March 23, 2018 to indicate that the mind of the Tribunal had been applied
to the matters in issue as the limited discussion in the relevant order of the
Tribunal did not refer to the challenges on divers counts that the respondent
herein carried against the findings on facts rendered by the Commissioner
in the order-in-original, particularly the detailed reasons indicated in
paragraph 16 of the order-in-original.
12.
In the order impugned, the Tribunal has also observed that no
mens rea was involved since the goods would attract 5% duty. That appears
to be a matter of conjecture and merely because the goods would have
attracted a nominal duty cannot be a brush to sweep aside the cogent
findings contained in the order-in-original of the Commissioner without
referring to and dealing with the same in the light of the challenge thereto
thrown by the respondent herein. Both the original order rendered by the
Tribunal on March 23, 2018 and the present order of December 23, 2019
leave a lot to be desired. The Tribunal is tasked with the duty of assessing
the grounds made out in support of an order. In this case the Tribunal
appears to have abdicated its authority to decide and dealt with the matter at
a superficial level without referring to either the grounds indicated in the
order-in-original or the grounds of challenge fashioned by the respondent
herein.
13.
As a consequence, the order impugned dated December 23, 2019
is found to be exceptionable and same is set aside with a request to the
Tribunal to consider the matter afresh uninfluenced by any observations
contained in the previous order of this Court or in the present order, but by
testing the grounds contained in support of the order-in-original and the
challenge thereto as carried by the respondent herein before such Tribunal.
It is hoped that since the mater pertains to a seizure made in the year 2017,
the Tribunal will dispose of the appeal at its earliest convenience and
without affording any adjournment to the parties.
14.
Cus. Appeal No.1 of 2020 is allowed as above by setting aside the
order impugned dated December 23, 2019 and by remanding the matter to
the Tribunal for the respondent’s appeal before it to be considered afresh in
accordance with law.
15.
There will be no order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
09.12.2021
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review