The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in a recent decision reported in 2023 SCC Online SC 1406 Review Petition(Civil)No.1620 of 2023 in Civil Appeal No.1661 of 2020 (Sanjay Kumar Agarwal Vs. State Tax Officer and another) in paragraph No.16 has laid down the law relating to the entertainment of review application which is extracted as follows: “16. The gist of the afore-stated decisions is that:(i) A judgment is open to review inter alia if there is a mistake or an error apparent on the face of the record. (ii) A judgment pronounced by the Court is final, and departure from that principle is justified only when circumstances of a substantial and compelling character make it necessary to do so. (iii) An error which is not self-evident and has to be detected by a process of reasoning, can hardly be said to be an error apparent on the face of record justifying the Court to exercise its power of review. (iv) In exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47, Rule 1 CPC, it is not permissible for an erroneous decision to be “reheard and corrected.” (v) A Review Petition has a limited purpose and cannot be allowed to be “an appeal in disguise.” (vi) Under the guise of review, the petitioner cannot be permitted to reagitate and reargue the questions which have already been addressed and decided. (vii) An error on the face of record must be such an error which, mere looking at the record should strik…
14. For all the above reasons, we find no merits in the Review Petition and the same deserves to be dismissed.”
4. Review Petition is dismissed as above. (H.S. Thangkhiew) Judge (S. Vaidyanathan) Chief Justice Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Review Pet. No.2/2024
Date of Order: 19.03.2024
The Commissioner of Central Goods & Service Tax (formerly
Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Crescens Building,
Mahatma Gandhi Road, Shillong-793001.
..... Applicant
Vs.
M/s Ishaan Technologies Pvt. Ltd., Amjok, Byrnihat, Ri-Bhoi District,
Meghalaya.
..... Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. Vaidyanathan, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Review Petitioner
: Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. A. Pradhan, Adv
For the Respondent
: Mr. D. Sahu, Adv with
Ms. M. Gogoi, Adv
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
No
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
No
ORDER
(Made by Hon’ble Chief Justice)
The present review petition has been filed against the order
dated 23.09.2021. Aggrieved by the order of this Court dated 23.09.2021
passed in Central Ex.Ap.No.3 of 2020, the petitioner namely, the
Commissioner of Central Goods & Service Tax has approached the
Apex Court and the Apex Court by an order dated 04.09.2023 disposed
of the Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No(s).30097/2023 which
reads as follows:
“Learned panel advocate appearing for the petitioner submitted
that having regard to a three judge bench decision of this
Court passed in the year 2019 [Steel Authority of India Ltd. vs.
CCE, Raipur reported in (2019) 6 SCC 693] permission may
be granted to the petitioner to file a review petition(s) before
the High Court as the aforesaid three judge bench judgment is
contrary to the relied upon judgment in 2021 SCC online
Meghalaya 154 of the High Court.
In view of the aforesaid submission, these special leave
petitions are disposed reserving liberty to the petitioner herein
to file a review petition(s) before the High Court, if so advised.
In view of the aforesaid order, application for seeking
condonation of delay would not survive for consideration and
stands disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.”
2. According to the petitioner, when the Apex Court has
granted permission to approach this Court and the review is maintainable
and that this Court is empowered to decide the issue and correct the
error. Learned counsel appearing for the respondent drew the attention of
this Court and contended that there was a provision for an appeal under
Section 35G which was repealed by the National Tax Tribunal Act, 2005
which exists prior to 2003 and that in terms of Section 35L of the
Central Excise Act, 1944, an appeal shall lie only to the Supreme Court
and the review is not maintainable. Learned counsel for the respondent
submitted that the question of Order 47 Rule 1 of CPC will not be
applicable to the case, more so, when there is a specific provision
contemplated under the Act for filing an appeal to the Supreme Court.
Even assuming that Order 47 Rule 1 is applicable, still the review is not
maintainable as there is no error apparent on the face of the record for
this Court to interfere. Learned counsel further submitted that the
Supreme Court had not directed this Court to entertain the review but
has permitted the petitioner herein to approach the Court by way of
review and only if the review is maintainable, this Court can entertain
and pass appropriate order.
3. In view of the submissions made by the parties, we are of
the view that in the light of Section 35L of the Central Excise Act of
1944, the petitioner statutory right is only before the Supreme Court.
Even assuming for the sake of argument that Order 47 Rule 1 is
applicable, the review is not maintainable in the light of the judgment
passed by this Court dated 15.03.2024 in Review Petition No.1 of 2024
and the same is extracted below:“4. It is now fairly well settled by a series of decisions of the
Hon’ble Court as also the Hon’ble Supreme Court that the
scope of review is very minimal and it is circumscribed by the
provisions of the statute. It would be relevant to refer to few
Judgments to understand and appreciate the scope of review
jurisdiction to find out if the petitioner has made out a case for
reviewing the order. The Hon’ble Division Bench of the High
Court of Madras in the case of The Special Officer, Kallal Cooperative Primary Agricultural and Rural Development Bank
Ltd., Karaikudi, Sivagangai District Vs. R.M.Rajarathinam
and Others [Review Application (MD). No.82 of 2013]
decided on 04.02.2015, held as follows:
“10... It is well settled that the scope of review
is very limited. The review applicant cannot reargue and he is not entitled for re-hearing on
merits.”
5. In another decision of the Division Bench of the High Court
of Madras in the case of Dhanalakshmi Vs. M.Shajahan and
others reported in AIR 2004 Madras 512, it was opined that
the power of review is not an appeal in disguise. The relevant
paragraphs of the said order are extracted below:
“11. From the above judgments, it is seen that the
law is well settled inasmuch as the power of
review is available only when there is an error
apparent on the face of the record and not on
erroneous decision. If the parties aggrieved by the
judgment on the ground that it is erroneous,
remedy is only questioning the said order in
appeal. The power of review under Order 47 Rule
1 C.P.C. may be opened inter alia only if there is a
mistake or an error apparent on the face of the
record. The said power cannot be exercised as is
not permissible for an erroneous decision to be
"reheard and corrected". A review application also
cannot be allowed to be "an appeal in disguise".
Similarly, the error apparent on the face of the
record must be such an error, which must strikes
one on mere looking at record and would not
require any long drawn process of reasoning on
points, where there may conceivably be two
opinions.”
6. Furthermore, in R.Mohala Vs. M.Siva and others in Review
Petition No.61 of 2018 and WMP.No.10818 and 10819 of
2018 decided on 25.04.2018, one of us (SVNJ) sitting at the
High Court of Madras elaborately discussed the scope of
review and in Paragraph Nos.7 and 8, held as follows:
“7.The basic principle to entertain the review
under Order 47 Rule 1 C.P.C. is to correct the errors but
not to substitute a view. The judgment under review
cannot be reversed (or) altered taking away the rights
declared and conferred by the Court under the said
judgment; once a judgment is rendered, the Court
becomes functus officio and it cannot set aside its
judgment or the decree; no inherent powers of review
were conferred on the Court; the review Court cannot
look into the trial Court judgment; it can look into its
own judgment for limited purpose to correct any error
or mistake in the judgment pointed out by the review
petitioner without altering or substituting its view in the
judgment under review; the review court cannot
entertain the arguments touching the merits and
demerits of the case and cannot take a different view
disturbing the finality of the judgment; the review
cannot be treated as appeal in disguise, as the object
behind review is ultimately to see that there should not
be miscarriage of justice and shall do justice for the
sake of justice only and review on the ground that the
judgment is erroneous cannot be sustained.
8. It is settled law that even an erroneous
decision cannot be a ground for the Court to undertake
review, as the first and foremost requirement of
entertaining a review petition is that the order under
review of which is sought, suffers from any error
apparent on the face of the order and in absence of any
such error, finality attached to the judgment/order
cannot be disturbed.”
7. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Meera Bhanja
Vs. Nirmala Kumari Choudhury reported in (1995) 1 SCC
170, while considering the scope of the power of review of the
High Court under Order 47, Rule 1, C.P.C., held as follows:
“The review proceedings are not by way of an
appeal and have to be strictly confined to the scope and
ambit of Order 47, Rule 1 C.P.C. The review petition of
error apparent on the face of the record and not on any
other ground. An error apparent on the face of the
record must be such an error which must strike one on
mere looking at the record and would not require any
long drawn process of reasoning on points where there
may conceivably be two opinions. The limitation of
powers on court under Order 47, Rule 1, C.P.C. is
similar to jurisdiction available to the High Court while
seeking review of the orders under Article 226.”
8. In the case in Parsion Devi Vs. Sumitri Devi, reported in
1997 (8) SCC 715, the Hon'ble Apex Court held as follows:
“Under Order 47, Rule 1, CPC a judgment may
be open to review inter alia if there is a mistake or an
error apparent on the face of the record. An error
which is not self-evident and has to be detected by a
process of reasoning, can hardly be said to be an error
apparent on the face of the record justifying the Court
to exercise its power of review under Order 47, Rule
1, CPC. In exercise of the jurisdiction under Order
47, Rule 1, CPC, it is not permissible for an
erroneous decision to be "reheard and corrected". A
review petition, it must be remembered has a limited
purpose and cannot be allowed to be "an appeal in
disguise.”
9. From a reading of the above referred Judgments, it can be
fairly discerned that:
1. Review is not an appeal in disguise.
2. The review proceedings are not by way of an
appeal and have to be strictly confined to the
scope and ambit of Order 47, Rule 1 C.P.C.
3. A wrong exposition of the law or a wrong
application of the law and failure to apply the
correct law cannot be a ground for review.
4. The power to review is a restricted power
given through a Court to go through the Judgment
only to correct it or improve it, on the basis of
some material which ought to have been
considered, escaped consideration or failed to be
placed before it for any other reason, but not to
substitute a fresh or a second Judgment.
5. The power of review cannot be invoked to
correct the erroneous Judgment and the finality
attached to a Judgment cannot be disturbed.
6. Only errors which are apparent on the face
of the record in the sense that errors which strike
on mere looking at record can only be corrected
and not those that require long drawn process of
reasoning on point.
10. The above are some of the basic principles on which the
power to review rests. The said principles are not exhaustive
but only illustrative.
11. To review a Judgment / Order, the Applicants need to
satisfy three basic requirements of Order 47 Rule 1 of C.P.C.,
which are as under:
(i) From discovery of new and important matter or
evidence which after exercise of due diligence was not
within his knowledge (or) could not be produced by
him at the time when the decree was passed (or) order
made;
(ii) There is some mistake (or) error apparent on
the face of the record in the judgment under review; and
(iii) or any other sufficient reasons.”
12. In the present case, the core grounds raised on which the
review petition rests, in our considered opinion are beyond the
scope of the provisions of Order 47 Rule 1 CPC and the law
laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and the Hon’ble
High Court. The Review Applicant in the guise of the Review
Petition wants this Bench to rewrite its Judgment, which is not
possible under review jurisdiction. As already stated above
review is not an appeal in disguise and there is no error
apparent on the face of the record. Therefore, the Division
Bench rightly confirmed the order of the learned Single Judge,
which does not warrant any review.
13. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in a recent decision reported
in 2023 SCC Online SC 1406 Review Petition(Civil)No.1620
of 2023 in Civil Appeal No.1661 of 2020 (Sanjay Kumar
Agarwal Vs. State Tax Officer and another) in paragraph
No.16 has laid down the law relating to the entertainment of
review application which is extracted as follows:
“16. The gist of the afore-stated decisions is that:(i) A judgment is open to review inter alia if there
is a mistake or an error apparent on the face of the record.
(ii) A judgment pronounced by the Court is final,
and departure from that principle is justified only when
circumstances of a substantial and compelling character
make it necessary to do so.
(iii) An error which is not self-evident and has to be
detected by a process of reasoning, can hardly be said to
be an error apparent on the face of record justifying the
Court to exercise its power of review.
(iv) In exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47,
Rule 1 CPC, it is not permissible for an erroneous
decision to be “reheard and corrected.”
(v) A Review Petition has a limited purpose and
cannot be allowed to be “an appeal in disguise.”
(vi) Under the guise of review, the petitioner cannot
be permitted to reagitate and reargue the questions which
have already been addressed and decided.
(vii) An error on the face of record must be such an
error which, mere looking at the record should strike and
it should not require any long-drawn process of reasoning
on the points where there may conceivably be two
opinions.
(viii) Even the change in law or subsequent
decision / judgment of a co-ordinate or larger Bench by
itself cannot be regarded as a ground for review.”
14. For all the above reasons, we find no merits in the Review
Petition and the same deserves to be dismissed.”
4. Review Petition is dismissed as above.
(H.S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
(S. Vaidyanathan)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
19.03.2024
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review