Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Central Ex. Ap. No. 1 of 2020
Date of Decision: 23.09.2021
The Commissioner of Central Goods
& Services Tax, Shillong
Vs. M/s Ishaan Technologies
Pvt. Ltd.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Biswanath Somadder, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s):
Dr. N. Mozika, SC CGST with
Ms. T Sutnga, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. D. Sahu, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
1.
The
instant
appeal
has
Yes/No
Yes/No
been
preferred
by
the
Revenue/Appellant under section 35G of the Central Excise Act
against the judgment and order dated 18th December, 2019 passed by
the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, Kolkata
(CESTAT) in Appeal No. E/76154/2014, whereby the appeal filed by
the respondent against the common adjudication order dated 31st
March, 2014 and corrigendum dated 5th May, 2014 of the
Commissioner of Central Excise, Shillong, was allowed.
2.
The necessary facts, in brief, are that a certain notification,
being notification No. 32/99-CE, dated 8th July, 1999, had been
issued by the Government of India, Ministry of Finance, wherein it
was proposed to exempt goods specified in the First and Second
Schedule of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985, from payment of
Excise duty from units located in North East India, as specified in the
annexure to the said notification. This scheme provided for refund of
the duty of excise or additional duty of excise leviable thereon as
equivalent to the amount of duty paid by the manufacturer, other than
the amount of duty paid by Cenvat credit under the Cenvat Credit
Rules. The respondent, which reportedly manufactured excisable
goods at its factory situated at Byrnihat, Meghalaya, during the period
March, 2002 to November, 2004, was, therefore, found to be eligible
for benefits under the said notification.
3.
It appears that thereafter, pursuant to a search and seizure
operation and subsequent investigation conducted by the Directorate
General of Central Excise Intelligence (DGCEI), it was alleged that
the respondent had misused the exemption notification No. 32/99-CE,
dated 8th July, 1999 and wrongly availed refunds amounting to Rs.
9,45,67,825/- during the period from October, 2002 to December,
2004, for the clearances of finished goods, claimed to have been
manufactured by the respondent Unit during the period March 2002
to November 2004. It was further alleged that the respondent had also
availed of irregular Cenvat credit amounting to Rs. 53,05,582/-. A
show cause notice dated 28th February, 2006, was then issued by the
Additional DG, DGCEI, Kolkata, to the respondent and the charges
levelled were, inter alia, as follows:
i)
That the respondent, M/s. Ishaan Technologies Pvt. Ltd.,
Amjok, Byrnihat, Meghalaya bearing Central Excise
Registration No. AAACI8965RXM001 engaged in
manufacture of excisable goods falling under Chapter 73
and 84 of the First Schedule to the Central Excise Act,
1944 was availing benefit of exemption had misused
exemption Notification No. 32/99-CE dated 08.07.1999
as amended. It was alleged that the respondent misused
the said exemption Notification by availing wrong
refund to the tune of Rs.9,98,73,407/- by fraudulent
claim of manufacture and clearance of goods under the
aforesaid Notification and thus availed refund under
Area based exemption notification on goods shown to
have manufactured and cleared without manufacturing
any excisable goods and thereby availing double benefit
of passing Cenvat Credit to their buyers.
ii)
That M/s. Manaksia Limited (formerly known as M/s.
Hindustan Seals Ltd.) having seventeen numbers of units
spreading across India engaged in the manufacture of
aluminium products, galvanized steel, packing materials
such as crown, caps and closures, metal containers, and
mosquito coil, purchased more than 91% of the products
of M/s. Ishaan Technologies Pvt. Ltd., Byrnihat.
iii)
That in the contrary it appears from the purchase
accounts of M/s. Ishaan Technologies that they have/had
regularly purchased raw material, components from the
M/s. Manaksia Ltd.
iv)
That investigation revealed that both M/s. Manaksia Ltd.
and M/s. Ishaan Technologies Pvt. Ltd. were managed
and controlled by the same group of people.
v)
That it was alleged that M/s. Manaksia Ltd. in its own
business/financial interest, set up a company called M/s.
Ishaan Technologies Pvt. Ltd. to promote its own
financial/business interest and to avail not only Central
Excise refund, Income Tax and Sales Tax exemptions in
the N.E. Region and Kutch region but also manipulated
the Accounts in such a manner to help M/s. Manaksia
Ltd. to inflate its Balance Sheet and avail excess Cenvat
Credit and exemption. There was mutuality of
financial/business interest of both the companies. Both
the Companies were controlled by one family. M/s.
Ishaan Technologies Pvt. Ltd. was not a separate entity
but a dummy unit of M/s. Manaksia Ltd. All its
operation from purchase of raw materials to receipts of
finished products on papers were organized by the
employees at the direction of management of M/s.
Manaksia Ltd. and were controlled by the Agarwal
family.
4.
That the respondent was also called upon to show cause as to
why: (a) The amount of Rs.9,45,67,825.70/- shall not be demanded
from and paid by the respondent in terms of proviso to
Section 11A (1) of Central Excise Act, 1944.
(b) The amount of Rs.53,05,582/- being the amount of wrong
Cenvat Credit availed be not demanded and paid by the
respondents in terms of Rule 12 of Cenvat Credit Rules,
2002 and/or Rule 14 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 read
with Section 11A of the Central Excise Act, 1944.
(c) Penalties be not imposed in terms of Section 11AC of the
Central Excise Act, 1944 read with Rule 25 of Central
Excise Rules, 2002.
(d)
Penalties be not imposed in terms of Rule 13 of Cenvat
Credit Rule, 2002 and/or Rule 15 of Cenvat Credit Rules,
2004 read with Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act,
1944.
(e) Interest at appropriate rates under Section 11AB on duty
demanded and interest at appropriate rate under Rule 12
of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002 and/or Rule 14 of Cenvat
Credit Rules, 2004 read with Section 11AB of the Central
Excise Act, 1944 on the duty demanded shall not be paid
by the respondents.
(f)
The amount of Rs.1,70,00,000/- already paid by the
respondent voluntarily in admission of the contravention
of the Central Excise Rules notifications, etc. vide TR-6
Challan No. 02/05-06 dated 19.05.2005 and 04/05-06
dated 31.08.2005, should not be appropriated against the
confirmed demand of duties, penalties, interest, etc.
5.
The show cause notices were then adjudicated upon and the
Commissioner, who was appointed as Common Adjudicator, by an
order dated 31st March, 2014, confirmed the duty demand of
Rs.9,45,67,825.70p. against the respondent under section 11A (2) of
the Central Excise Act, 1944 and Rules 12 and 14 of the Cenvat
Credit Rules, 2002 and 2004, read with section 11A of the Act,
respectively, along with interest under section 11AB of the Act and
Rules 12 and 14 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002 and 2004 and
imposed penalties upon the respondent and other co-noticees named
in the show cause dated 28th February, 2006.
6.
The respondent and other co-noticees, being aggrieved by the
adjudication order, thereafter preferred appeals before the Tribunal
[Appeal Nos. E/76154/2014 (Ishaan Technologies Pvt. Ltd. Vs.
CCE&ST), E/76156-76160/2014 & E/76174-76175/2014 (appeals by
co-noticees), E/76094/2014 to E/76099/2014 (CCE&ST, Shillong Vs.
Manaksia Ltd.) and Appeal No. E/76155/2014 (Manaksia Ltd. Vs.
CCE&ST, Shillong)]. The said appeals were disposed of by the
Tribunal by the common impugned judgment and order dated 18th
December, 2019 and the appeals of Ishaan (respondent), the conoticees and Manaksia Ltd., Kutch were allowed, whereas the appeals
filed by the Revenue were rejected.
7.
This judgment and order of the Tribunal dated 18th December,
2019, is now under consideration in the instant appeal.
8.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned senior counsel assisted by Ms. L. Jana,
learned counsel for the appellant, submits that the learned Tribunal
(CESTAT) had ignored material and relevant facts and had not
applied the legal principles in appreciating the matter and instead had
dwelt on inconsequential facts, which has given rise to various
substantial questions of law, that are to be adjudicated and examined
by this Court. Learned senior counsel contends that the CESTAT
erred in law in holding that, – since according to the show cause
notice, and impugned order itself, there was no manufacture of
goods, therefore, there can be no levy and hence no requirement to
make payment of any duty of Central Excise payable under the Act
and resultantly, the question of any recovery of duties not levied or
not paid or erroneously refunded in terms of section 11A(1) of the Act
does not arise (emphasis supplied). This observation, he submits, is
patently incorrect, inasmuch as, the exemption notification provided
for refund of duty of excise in respect of goods manufactured in a
specific area of the region and as such, in respect of goods that are
not manufactured in a specific area, there will be no question of any
refund under the said notification. The other points raised by the
learned counsel, in brief, are; the CESTAT had ignored vital
materials such as the fact that the respondent did not have requisite
plant and machinery to manufacture the subject goods and also the
fact that the respondent had resorted to conscious and deliberate misdeclaration and mis-representation by misusing the notification of
exemption with the mala fide intention of passing irregular Cenvat
Credit to various customers. As such, he prays that appeal be allowed
and the impugned order be set aside and quashed.
9.
Mr. D. Sahu, learned counsel for the respondents, while
rebutting the submissions of the appellant submits that the records
and documents produced before the Tribunal (CESTAT) were
examined and verified which showed the respondent as eligible for
exemption under the said notification and that the refund of duty paid
was based on the exemption notification. That apart, he submits, the
Tribunal also observed that during the period of refund, the
department never challenged the said refund orders and as such, the
proceedings under section 11A are unsustainable. Learned counsel
through his written submission has also put forward the point that in a
similar case, that is the case of Commissioner of Central Excise,
Shillong Vs. Jellalpore Tea Estate reported in 2011 (268) E.L.T. 14
(Gau.), it has been held that, the order granting refund could have
been challenged only by resorting to section 35E of the Act and that,
Revenue could not take recourse to section 11A of the Act and that
this judgment being passed by the then jurisdictional High Court is
binding. It is finally submitted that there is no substantial question of
law that has arisen in the instant case.
10.
Having heard the learned counsel and having examined the
materials on record, especially the impugned judgment and order, it is
palpably evident, on the face of the record itself, that there is no
substantial question of law involved in this appeal. A bare reading of
section 11A of the Act (as amended), clearly shows that the
stipulation under this provision, can be exercised only if certain
conditions precedent are present, as spelt out in section 11A, itself.
For the sake of convenience relevant portion is reproduced
hereinbelow to illustrate this fact:“11A. Recovery of duties not levied or not paid or short-levied
or short- paid or erroneously refunded.- (1) Where any duty
of excise has not been levied or paid or has been short-levied
or short-paid or erroneously refunded, for any reason, other
than the reason of fraud or collusion or any willful misstatement or suppression of facts or contravention of any of
the provisions of this Act or of the rules made thereunder
with intent to evade payment of duty,(a)
the Central Excise Officer shall, within two years from
the relevant date, serve notice on the person chargeable with
the duty which has not been so levied or paid or which has
been so short- levied or short- paid or to whom the refund has
erroneously been made, requiring him to show cause why he
should not pay the amount specified in the notice;
(b)
the person chargeable with duty may, before service of
notice under clause (a), pay on the basis of(i)
his own ascertainment of such duty; or
(ii)
duty ascertained by the Central Excise Officer, the
amount of duty along with interest payable thereon under
section 11AA.”
On examination of the above quoted provision of law, it clearly
shows that the case at hand, is not one concerning conditions as given
in section11A, but the issue concerns refunds made purportedly under
the entitlements claimed by the respondent under the exemption
notification, which, the Appellant/Revenue seeks to recover by taking
recourse to section 11A which in our view, is not admissible. The
cited case of Commissioner of Central Excise, Shillong Vs.
Jellalpore Tea Estate (supra) also appears to squarely cover the
instant case.
11.
The learned Tribunal (CESTAT) in its order has also clearly
come to a finding that the respondents had cleared the goods during
the relevant period, that is October, 2002 to December, 2004, and had
claimed the refund of the duty paid under the said exemption
notification dated 08th July, 1999. It was also found by the learned
Tribunal that during the period of refund, the department never
challenged the refund orders passed by the Revenue. Extract of the
impugned judgment and order wherein the conclusive findings of the
Tribunal are recorded, are reproduced hereinbelow:
“10. As per the impugned order Ishaan, by a letter dated
04.07.2002
informed
the
jurisdictional
Assistant
Commissioner, the prescribed authority under Notification
No. 32/99-CE, that their factory located in the specified area
and had started commercial production with effect from
22.03.2002 and requested sanction of eligibility certificate and
that the Assistant Commissioner by an order dated 27.09.2002
held that Ishaan is eligible for exemption under the said
notification by way of refund of duty paid from account
current on the products allowed to be manufactured and
cleared; accordingly an amount of Rs.10,21,26,696/- was
refunded to Ishaan during the period from October 2002 to
December 2004 for clearances claimed to have been during
March 2002 to November 2004. The said order of refund was
not challenged by the Revenue. By the impugned order the
Revenue has sought to recover an amount of Rs.8,92,62,243/out of the said refunded amount in terms of Section 11A(2) of
the Act, pursuant to a show cause notice issued under the
Proviso to Section11A of the Act, as amount wrongly refunded
under the said Notification No. 32/99-CE. A further sum of
Rs. 53,05,582/- has also been confirmed against Ishaan as
wrong cenvat credit availed and utilized in terms of Rule 12/14
of the Cenvat Credit Rules 2002/2004 read with Section 11A
of the Act.
11.1 Herein also the jurisdictional Assistant Commissioner
of Central Excise, Shillong Division, vide his order dated
September 27, 2002, had held that Ishaan was eligible for
exemption under the said notification “by way of refund of
duty paid from account current on the product allowed to be
manufactured and cleared” and accordingly, an amount of
Rs.10,21,61,696/- (of which the sum of Rs. 9,45,66,825.70 is a
part) was refunded to Ishaan during the period October 2002
to December 2004. The order of the Assistant Commissioner
granting refund could have been challenged by the
Department only by resorting to Section 35E of the Act, which
has not been done in the instant case, and therefore, as held
by the Hon’ble Gauhati High Court, the Revenue cannot
initiate collateral proceedings to set aside the said order by
resorting to Section 11A of the Act.
11.2 ……………………………………
11.3 …………………………………..
11.4 ………………………………….
11.5 In the present case, since according to the show cause
notice and the impugned order themselves there was no
manufacture of the subject goods, there can be no levy and
hence no requirement to make payment of any duty of central
excise payable in respect of subject machineries under the Act.
Consequently, the question of any recovery of “duties of
excise” not levied or not paid or short levied or short paid or
erroneously refunded in terms of Section 11A(1) of the Act
also does not arise.
11.6 ……………………
11.7 ……………………..
11.8 ……………………..
11.9 In so far as the demand of Rs. 53,05,582/- against
Ishaan as wrongly availed and utilised cenvat credit, the said
notification does not allow refund of the cenvat credit utilised.
Therefore, the act of utilization of the subject cenvat credit by
Ishaan for payment of part of the total excise duty paid on the
subject goods effectively reversed the cenvat credit of Rs.
53,05,582/- and hence there is no wrongful or irregular cenvat
credit being availed by Ishaan, as held by this Bench itself in
the case of Manaksia Ltd. & Spark Exports Ltd. Vs. CCE,
Bolpur, Order No. FO/A/75027-75028/2019 dated 07.01.2019
passed in Appeal Nos. E/278/2009 & E/412/2006. As such,
this demand is also unsustainable.
11.10 …………………………..
11.11 In the premises the demands of duty, interest and
penalties against Ishaan and the other appellants in Appeal
Nos. E/76156-76160/2014 imposed by the impugned order are
unsustainable.”
12.
In such circumstances and especially in view of the stated
position of law and facts, we find no infirmity in the impugned
judgment and order and no substantial question of law is involved.
The appeal accordingly stands dismissed along with MC (Central
Excise Ap.) No.4 of 2020.
13.
However, before parting with the records, we hasten to add that
this judgment and order shall not preclude the appellant from taking
any other action, provided of course, it is entitled to do so, in
accordance with law.
14. No order as to costs.
(H.S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
(Biswanath Somadder)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
23.09.2021
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review