Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
[ 3300 I
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NOS:2236't AND 37950 OF 2025
W.P.NO: 22361 OF 2025
Between:
THE COMMERCIAL TAXES CRICKET CLUB, represented by its General
Secretary B. Susheel Kumar Semwal, Office at 30-27513, Santhoshimaa
Nagar Colony, Neredmet, R.K. Puram, Medchal- Malkajgiri District,
Telangana
..PETrroNER
AND
1. THE STATE OF TELANGANA, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Sports and
Youth Services Depa(ment, Secretariat, Hyderabad, Telangana, lndia
2. THE HYDERABAD CRICKET ASSOCIATION, represented by its Secretary,
Rajiv Gandhi International Cricket Stadium, Uppal, Hyderabad
3. CoIUMERCIAL TAXES CRICKET CLUB, represented by its secretary B.
Venkataiah Assistant Commissioner Commercial Taxes, H. No. 5-8-1 12, First
Floor, 21st Century Complex, Opposite Chenetha Bhavan, Nampally,
Hyderabad-500001
...RES'.NDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to grant Writ, Order or Direction, more particularly in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus, dectaring the action of Respondent No- 2 in not recognizing the
Petitioner Club as the rightful and legitimate affiliated Club of the Respondent No.
2 i.e. Hyderabad Cricket Association based on the Order passed in Case No. 6 of
2025 by the Hon'ble Ethics Officer and Ombudsman Addl. Charge, despite the
Petitioner's co-ntinuous affiliation, participation in league tournaments, payment of
requisite fees, and compliance with all norms since its inception in 1986 as
unreasonable, illegal, unlawful, arbitrary and violative of Articles 14, 19 and 21 of
the constitution of lndia and consequently to recognize the Petitioner as the full
Member of the Hyderabad Cricket Association Respondent No. 2 with all the rights
and privileges to the Petitioner which it is entifled to as affilir ed club of Hyderabad
I
cricket Association by setting aside order in case No. 6 of 2t25 dated 29.11.2024
passed by the Hon'ble Ethics Officer and Ombudsn r
n Addl. Charge of
Respondent No. 2.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 15.1 CpC praying that in
the c r )umstances stated in
the affidavit fired in support of the petition, the High
court mir be preased to direct
the Respondent No. 2 to permit the petitioner to participat€ ,c,Division
n
for the
League Matches for the season 2025_26 conducted
by the Re ;pondent No. 2.
lA NO: 4 oF 2025
Between:
Commercial Taxes Cricket CIub, represented by
its Sec r tary B. Venkataiah
Assistant Commissioner commerc-iii
{rN;.
s_8_1 12, First Ftoor. 21st
Century Comptex, opposite cnenutn" e'iirbn,
r.ii'ririlrv Hi;;;;;j;:;b.00i,i
rJ;;,
AND
...pETrTtONEF/IESpONDENTNo.3
1. The Commercial Taxes Cricket Club, represented
*"'8I by its r ieneral Secretarv B
s usheer Ku ma r Sem war, oni"J ri'ob:I'
E'EiJ.i:
Neredmet, R.K puram, Medchal tuirtk;j;i;di"ffit,"".,i. Jr, "".iJ
,",r,3rnr ^iJnli
...RESPONDEN T WRlT PETITIONER
. The State Of Telanoar
,,i#;: o rts,a d yo u rh
s e, c;; D; p; ;; lj;i E;1,"&"i:j:._?!::jts?,.:
?31
i
n
2 rhe Hyderabad cricket Assogi"tiil,i$;;;;iu'0"f1) it, se rretarv. Raiiv
i
GandhitnternarionatCrickelStiiiiui,,Upi:"i,i"vtIirn"a
...RESPONDEII' S/RESPONDENTS
Petition under section 151 cpc praying that
in the circL nstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High
vacate the interim order dated 13.01 .2O2S in
Court r ray be pleased to
W.p. No. 22361 cf 2025 passed.
Counsel for the petitioner: SRI M.HAREESH
KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: Cp fOn
SpOCiS
counser for the Respondent No.2: snr v.nn.relrb-ii
nno, s( FoR HcA
Counset for the Respondent No.3: Snf f.SAiffnielif,fi
W.P.NO:379 5o oF 2025
Between:
The comerciar raxes cricket crub,. Represented by
its Hon. secretarv sHArK
JALALUDDTN, Offi_ce at
As;[
C;mir:ssione,
(ST), KhairthaUaa
_O/o.
Somaiiouda_ 1 . 8th Ftoor, B Bto;k, M;y* k;;;ili
c".pr *)Idia",.iil.liffi1";
- 500001.
...PETIT|oNER
AND
1. The State Of Telanoan^a, Rep. by its principal Secretary, Sports
and youth
Services Deoartmeit, secreiariai, iiya"rif,al,i"eirng"na,
tndia.
2. The Hyderabad Cricket.Asso"iri".;'R;#;;;tei oy its Secretary.
Raiiv
-- Gandhi tnrernationat Cricket Stidiurir, utpij]'iVj"rib;; -.",,' '.",,,
3 commerciar raxes cricket crub, Rep;;JJ;i;d'dv"its secret"ry B. venkataiah
Assistant commissioner commerciir iJieiiir]'rvl.
s-a-r rz, First Froor, 2nd
-,,"
9Sl1,lry Comptex, opposite ctrenetna aiiiian, r.irrpjrrv, Hvb#;6";:',
500001.
4. The Single Member Committee, Hyderabad
Cricket Association, Rajiv Gandhi
tnternationat Cricket Stadium, Ljppli -nvaeiaU"i"'
(The Respondent No..4 is not a necessary party
to
'- the present proceedings
and has been arrayed as a proforma pirt'vi -
''
petition under Articte 2z6of
rhe Constitution of tndia
circumstances stated in the affidavit fired therewith,
pleased to grant a writ, order or Direction,
,j::j:]::T:
the High court may be
more particurarry in the nature of writ
of Mandamus
(a) declaring the order passed by the Honourable
ombudsman Addl. charge of
Respondent No. 2 dated 2911112024 in case No. 6
of 2024 in refusing to the
exercise lhe jurisdiction as per the Memorandum of
Association and Rules
and
Regulations of Hyderabad cricket Association-201 8
of Respondent No. 2 and
directing the parties to approach the civit court, (which
direction could not have
been passed against the petitioner herein as it was
the Respondent in case No. 6
of 2024) as unreasonabre, ilegar, unrawfur, arbitrary and
viorative of Articres 14, 1g
and 21 0t the constitution of rndia and consequenfly set
aside the order of the
Honourable Ombudsman dated 29111/2O24 by dismissing
Case No. 6 of 2024,
(b) declaring the action of the Respondent No.2 i.e. Hyderabad
Association in noi recognizing the petitioner crub as
cricket
the rightfur and regitimate
affiliated Club of the Respondent No.2, despite the petitioner,s
continuous
affiliation, participation in league tournaments, payment of requisite
fees, and
compliance with arr norms since its inception in 19g6 and consequenfly
direct the
as the full Memt :r of the Hyderabad
Respondent No. 2 to recognl ize the Petitioner
all the rights i nd privileges to the
Cricket Association i.e. Respondent No 2 with
club of Hyderabat lricket Association'
Petitioner which it is entitled to as affiliated
IA NO :1OF 2025
the ci r 'Lmstances stated in
Petltion under Section 151 CPC praying that in
High court may be pleased to
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the
the Honourable Ombudsrr rn Addl Charge of
suspend the Order passed by
6 of 2024 '
Respondent No. 2 dated 2911112024 in Case No'
lA NO: 2 oF 2025
the cir ;umstances stated in
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in
High Court mrt be pleased to direct
the affidavit filed in support of the petition' the
the full Member of the
the Respondent No.2 to recognize the Petitioner as
Respondent No' 2 wil r all the rights and
Hyderabad Cricket Association
ie
privilegestothePetitionerwhichitisentitledtoaSaffilial€jclubofHyderabad
Cricket Association
lA NO: 3 oF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
ci :umstances stated in
theaffidavitfiledinSupportofthepetition,theHighCourtmelbepleasedtodirect
participz:e in all the League'
the Respondent No. 2 to permit the Petitioner to
le conducted by the
knockout and any other match whatsoever conducted/to
Respondent No..2.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI M'HAREESH KUMAR
C.r"."f for the Respondent No'1: GP FOR SPORTS R1o
- sc FoR HcA
ioi in" n""b"naeni t'to.z: sRl v'RAJENDEB
No'3: SRI K'SATHAKARNI
;;;;;i for the Respondent No'4:
Counsel for the Respondent
;;;;;;i
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
)
FOR THE STATE OF
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE
IELANGAUA
HON'BLE SRI WSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI{A
WRIT PETITIO NS No. 2236L ANri 3795
o oF 2()25
()9. o1.2026
B etween:
The Commercial Taxes Cricket Club'
n.p tV i = General Secretary B' Susheel Kumar Semwal
....- Petitioner
And
The State of Telangana,
Reo. bv its PrinciPal Secretary,
Sports and Youth Services Depa rtmenland others
... .. ResPondents
OR DER:
1.
Heard Sri M' Hareesh Kumar' learned
Petitioner, Sri V. Rajender Rao' learned
No. 2 - Hyderabad Cricket Association
counsel for
counsel for Respondent
(HCA) and K' Sathakarni'
learned counsel for Respondent No 3 -
Commercial Taxes
Cricket CIub.
2.
by
Writ Petition No' 22361 of 2025 is hled aggrieved
in not recognizing Petitioner Club as their
the action of HCA
rightful and legitimate affiliated Club based
29.11.2t]24 in Case No' 6 of 2024 of
on the Order dated
the Hon'ble Ethics Officer
andOmbudsmanAdditionalCharge,despitePetitioner,s
continuousaffrliation,participationinleaguetournaments,
I
payment of requisite fees and compriance
with : lr norms since
its inception in 19g6.
3.
Writ petition No. 37950 of 2025 is lrJr
the Order o[ the Ombudsman Additional
No. 2 dated 29.t7.2O24 in Case No.
1 aggrieved by
Charge rt Respondent
6 of 2024 **t ir;h refused to
exercise the jurisdiction as per the Memorandun
and Rules and Reguiations of Hyderabad
2OI8 of Respondent No. 2 and directing
tf Association
crick: Associa[ion_
the partre; [o approach
the Civil Court, (which direction could not
against the petitioner herein as it was the
hav : Iteen passed
Respcr dent in Case
No' 6 of 2024). They arso sought a decraratio.
rrat action of
Respondent No.2 in not recognizing petitionr:r
rightful and legitimate affiliated Club of
despite Petitioner,s continuous afflrliation,
Ulub as the
Respc r clen
t No. 2,
participr, I ()n rn league
tournaments, payment of requisite fees
and compii urce with a
norms since it s inception in 19g6 and
consequer 1 r, direct the
Respondent No. 2 to recognize them
Hyderabad Cricket Association with
as the fufl IVr mbcr of the
all the rights rLr ul privileges
to the Petitioner which it is entitled to as
affiLe tr:d club of
Hyderabad Cricket Association.
4.
petitioner in both the
Writ Petiti:,rs is the
Commercial Taxcs Cricket Club Writ Petition
was filed by tirc Commercial Taxes
No. 22. ntl ot 2O2S
Cricket Club, rc;; rrsented by
.7
its Secretary B. Susheel Kumar Semwal who was elected as
Secretary for the period 07.I2.2O24 - 06.12.2025. Since the said
period has come to an end, Writ Petition No. 37950 of 2025 was
lrled. Though Writ Petition No. 22361 of 2025 has, in fact,
become infructuous, at the request of the parties, since
Respondent No. 3 filed Counter in Writ Petition No. 22361 of
2025 and requested this Court to treat the same as counter in
Writ Petition No. 22361 of 2025 also, the same are being
disposcd of by a common Order.
5.
The case of Petitioner is that their Club was
founded in 1986-87 by Bhupender Lal and T. Basavaraj with its
registered ofhce as D. No. 349/SRT, Opposite Sarvodaya Mahila
Mandal, Sanjeev Reddy Nagar, Hyderabad. Since its inception,
the entire Annual Subscription and League fees have been paid
by Petitioner through its bank account and receipts have been
issued by HCA to Petitioner and the receipts for the years 1998-
99, 2002-03, 2004-05, 2008-09, 2009-rO, 20t0-tt, 201r-12,
20t2-t3, 20t3 74, 20t4 15, 2015-16, 2076 77, 20t8-19, 201920,2O2O-21 and 2O2l-22 have been filed before this Court.
5.1.
It is stated, from 1986-87 onwards, the names of
the office bearers of Petitioner are shown as having attended all
the Annual General Meetings (AGM) and Special General
Meetings (SGM). The team selected by Petitioner alone has
.,]
participated in various league matches
anc knockout
tournaments conducted by the HCA. petitioner
fiI,: t 6..1ig"r,.
of Registration dated June 20 1O of Club, ts I aws, let[er
addressed to Terangana commercial Taxes NGOs
letter from the Terangana commerciar raxes
\ssociation,
NGOs lssociation,
Ietter addressed by B. Susheel Kumar Semwal
L: nding over
administration of the Crub, Resolution and
minutes of meeting
of Petitioner club, list of members presented
at the i l.d AGM of
HCA, receipts for payments made by petitioner
No. 2 from 1998 to 2022, ID card issued
to . lcspondent
by Respor Cent No. 2
for Special General Meeting, annual list/record o
executive
body from 20 1O to 2025, Master Register marr
tained by
Hyderabad Cricket Association, letters addresr;r
d bv T
Basavaraj (Committee Member) to the President,
{yderabad
Cricket Association, statement of savings bank
Petitioner Club, letter from the then petitioner
Supervisory Committee etcetera before this
e:count of
Secrc: ary to the
Court in rupport of
Petitioner's contention.
5.2.
It is the further case of petitioner thar, rut of the
blue in 2O23, Respondent No. 3 without arry
right, i rterest or
entitlement, based on an alleged letter issued
by the, .dditional
Commissioner, Commercial Taxes Department,
had pr -l.icipated
in the elections of the HCA. Apart from
this so :ary act,
I
)
Respondent No. 3 has no re lation whatsoever with Pe titione r
Club. It is contended, Respondent No.3 i.e. B. Venkataiah
approached HCA for the firrst time in 2023. Prior thereto,
. Respondent No. 3 was not even aware about the exrstence of the
Club. If Respondent No. 3 had a semblance of right, interest or
entitlement in the Club, he would have basic record to show his
election as Secretary, payment of subscription amounts from
the account maintained by him, representation in the meetings
of HCA, participation in the leagues etcetera. In the absence
thereof, it is clear that the claim by Respondent No.3 is nothing
I
more than an arm-twisting device to extract money. It is further
contended that the said Venkataiah has not placed on record a
ll
I
I
single document to establish that he has any semblalce of
I
I
right, interest or entitlement in the Commercial Taxes Cricket
Club or that the said Club is in any way connected to the
Commercial Taxes Department. Petitioner by stating the
aforesaid facts requested this Court to take cognizance of the
illegitimate manner in which Respondent No.3 is holding
Petitioner to ransom, and Respondent No. 3 should face all the
legal consequences for his ill thought of misadventure and must
be brought to book fgr illegally and unlawfully st5rling himself as
Secretary of the Commercial Taxes Cricket Club.
.,.ar
-/
fr
5.3.
Petitioner contends that in this fact_ rl scenario,
Respondent No. 3 filed Case No. 6 of 2024 before
r_
hics Of{icer
and Ombudsman Additional Charge of HyderiL ,ad Cricket
Association (hereinafter referred to as ,Ombudsrr i n') , again st
Petitioner with a prayer to recognizc Respondent Nc 3 :rs a full
member of HCA. In the said case, the Ombudsrr an, despite
categorically recording a hnding that Respondent Irr .3 failed to
hle any documentary evidence establishing its cas :, relcgated
both the Petitioner and Respondent No. 3 to civil ColurL uide
Order dated 29.11.2024 and further directed
CA not to
recognize Petitioner or Respondent No. 3 as its I rll member
pending adjudication by the civii Court.
5.4.
Petitioner challenges the Order of the Crr lbudsman,
on the ground that Ombudsman failed to r ) ercise thc
jurisdiction vcsted in it and despite declining to as ;ume such
jurisdiction, proceeded to pass directions beyond ;t ; authority
by directing Petitioner (Respondent in Case No. 6 c f '2024) and
Respondent No. 3 to approach the civil Court.
6.
Learned counsel for petitioner relies upon the
judgement of the Hon,ble Supreme Court in Conpt 'oller q.nd.
Auditor General oJ India, Gian prq.kasfu Neu D,z 'hi u. K.S.
')
Jagannathanr, wherein it was categorically held that the High
Courts, in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226, can issue a
writ of mandamus or directions even in matters involving
discretion, where the Government or a public authority has
failed to exercise, has wrongly exercised, or has abused such
discretion, including on mala fide or irrelevalt considerations,
so as to compel proper and lawful performance of that
discretion, and in an appropriate case may itself pass the order
which the authority ought to have passed. The relevant
paragraph is reproduced hereunder:
"
20. There is thus no doubt that the High Courts in India
exercising their jurisdiction under Artrcle 226 have the power to issue a
writ of mandamus or a writ in the nature of mandamus or to pass
orders and give necessary directions where the government or a public
authority has failed to exercise or has wrongly exercised the discretion
conferred upon it by a statute or a rule or a policy decision of the
government or has exercised such discretion mala hde or on irrelevant
considerations or by ignoring the relevant considerations and materials
or in such a manner as to frustrate the object of conferring such
discretion or the policy for implementing which such discretion has been
conferred. In all such cases and in any other fit and proper case a High
Court can, in the exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226, issue a
writ of mandamus or a writ in the nature of mandamus or pass orders
and give directions to compel the performance in a proper and lawful
manner of the discretion conferred upon the government or a public
€iuthority, and in a proper case, in order to prevent injustice resulting to
the concerned parties, the court mayitself pass an order or give
directions which the government or the public authority should have
passed or given had it properly and lawfully exercised its discretion."
' (ts864scc 67s
(emphasis supplied)
7.
The case of Respondent No- 2 HCA rs that a Writ
under Article 226 of the Constitution is not naintainable
against the Orders passed by the Ombudsman of tr: Hyderabad
Cricket Association. The counter conhned only to r Le ground of
maintainability and did not traverse any of I re facts as
mentioned in the writ afhdavit. Respondent No. 2 Iaced heavy
reliance on the judgment rendered by this Court i t Nolgonda
District Cricket Association ,s.
Hgd.erabc d
Cricket
Association and prayed for dismissal of the Writ p: ition on the
ground of maintainability.
8-
Respondent No. 3 contended that Wril ?etition No.
22367 of 2O25 is not maintainable since it wa s filed by its
erstwhile Secretary Susheel Kumar who was not ar :mployee
of
the Commercial Taxes Department. He has no locusi -o maintain
the present Writ Petition. They placed relialce on A: icle 12 and
Preamble of the Bylaws of petitioner Association to rupport
his
contention. Respondent No. 3 did not plead a posi ive case
piace on record any document establishing that t e had
or
any
independent right or claim over the Commercial Trr :es Cricket
Club. Relying upon the bylaws of the Commercial .l.r res
Cricket
Club, it is prayed that Writ petition be dismiss :d as not
ma r n'taina
ble.
\
;
g.
Respondent No. 3 did not hle any independent
counter in Writ Petition No. 37950 of 2025 and adopted the
Counter hled in Writ Petition No. 2236i of 2025. Respondent
No. 3 contended that despite the fact that administration of the
Club was now in the hands of the employees of the Commercial
Taxes Department, its objection as to locus still subsists.
In view of the rival claims, the points that arise for
10.
consideration are:
(i) whether a Writ Petition under Article 226 would be
maintainable against the Order passed by the Ombudsman on
the grounds of non-exercising of jurisdiction and passing of
directions despite refusing to exercise jurisdiction, beyond its
authority as claimed by the Petitioner?
(ii) Whether the Writ Petitions filed by Petitioner are not
maintainable on the ground that they are against the byelaws,
rules and regulations of the Commercial Taxes Cricket Club as
claimed by the ResPondent No. 3?
(iii) Whether the Order passed by the Ombudsman in Case No' 6
of 2024, calls for any interference?
11. POINT lit: Learned counsel for Respondent No' 2
contended that Writ Petition in its present form is not
maintainable as this Court rn Nalgonda Dtstrict Crtcket
Association o. Hgderabad Cricket Association, categorically
/
l0
held that a Writ petition could not lie againsl
ar Order passed
by the Ombudsman of the Hyderabad Cricket Ass
Order passed by the Ombudsman was akin to
which ought to be challenged before a Civil
jurisdiction.
rciation as the
arr rrbitral award
Cour of competent
Learned Counsel for petitione r rebutted the
said argument and contended that Writ petition
inasmuch as Ombudsman in Case No. 6
:s maintainable
of 2r) 14 refused to
exercise the jurisdiction vested. with it, despite
assume such jurisdiction, proceeded to pass
dirr: tions beyond
its authority by directing petitioner and Respor (
approach the civil Court. Therefore, there was
on merits, against which petitioner could
12.
declining to
enL No. 3 to
no I :cision per se
have hle I an Appeal.
Learned counsel for Petitioner furtl- r r argued
on
law, as follovr.s:
(i)
The High Court's power under Article 226
is par[ of the basic structure of the Constitution
(ii)
is 1 lenary and
of ] _rdia.
The p.v'ers of the High court under Articre
fe[ters and the restrain on the power is
)26 have no
a self_impo; :cl restrain.
(iii) Even if there is an alternative remedy, the igh Court
entitled to exercise its jurisdiction under
ends ofjustice.
is
Articre 2,2( to o,eet t,e
(i")
Once the authority IS refusing to exercisr: jurisdiction
vested with it, a Writ petition under
Article 226 wrt rld not only
be maintainable but would be an
appropriate remerl.
(") The ombudsman, while refusing to
exercisc urisdiction,
could not have gone ahead and issued
a dire; ion to the
.
YI
ll
Petitioner, in the case filed by the Respondent No. 3. Such an
action would be perverse and unsustainable.
("i) The Judgment in Nalgonda District Cricket Association
case (supra), is distinguishable on facts as in that case, the
Ombudsman had conclusively decided the issue and this Court
r.l,as of the view that since the Ombudsman had exercised
jurisdiction and passed a detailed Order, the decision of the
Ombudsman would be akin to decision by the arbitrator and a
Writ Petition against the arbitration award would not lie. [n the
present case, there had been a complete failure to exercise the
jurisdiction, and a perverse direction is given despite refusing to
exercise jurisdiction and as such the Writ Petition is not only
maintainable but a proper remedy.
This Court finds considerable force in
13.
the
submissions advanced by learned counsel for Petitioner. ln the
present case, the Ombudsman had refused to exercise the
j urisdiction vested
in him under the Memorandum of
Association and Rules and Regulations-2Ol8 of Hyderabad
Cricket Association. This jurisdiction was not exercised despite
recording a categorical hnding that Respondent No.3
(B.
Venkataiah) faited to produce any documentary evidence. The
relevant portion of the Order is reproduced as under:
3. Both the parties were put on notice in view of the rival
contentions claimed by both the parties in respect of the same club and
to decide who is genuine and real person entitled to rePresent the
'
Commercial Ta-\es Cricket CIub and a notice dated 21 08 2024 was
issued to furnish answers to the questionnaire. The questionnaire lor
t2
which the replies required
documents pertaining to
and date of affijiation,
to be submitted a-re abour .l
the date of filing of the applica j
Registration Certificate, details
e details of the
rn for a{Iiliation
f the execu tive
lear wise list given to HCA, p.rrf ripation
of the
L€ague matches from
the date ot affiliation, det.ri
of the bank
accounls, audited accou
nts of the club' play grounds '
an_v the
bod5', general body,
r
s
has, details of the members
ceneral Meetings, details (of
members of the ctub,
the clubattending the AC
."",."tr, ,'r" il":: il::T
List of the Cricketers who
at
request of the parties, ,n.
club
M and Special
giveD to the
rj; ared b1, HCA,
the parties of the Gercra
bod).. At the
*u" adjourned, posted t 18 10.2024.
-.tt
t'e u.,ttttt could not submit
arr documentary
evidence, and the n-,.r,..
vent several adjournments
ott'ot"t
for amicable
set,ement.
I,.or the questionnaire
t4.
Once the Ombudsman recorded
that no documentary eviclence
Respondent No. 3, the
a s: :cific fincting
was produced refore it
Authority could not have re
by
egated both
the Petitioner and Respondent
to civil Cour and
sir-rce
Respondent No
3 (Petitioner before the Ombudsrr
required under laq, to prove
In such a factual si uation,
an error in ignoring the re:
by Petitioner from 1986 onwards
exercise of full membership
Such a direction
arbitrary and capricious
tttl:,.
This Court therefore, deems
rhat thc power vestecr
to
the
rrds placed
and putting a . Lalt to the
rights of petitioner all r
after more than three decades.
i5.
n) who ,,r.as
his case and miserz I ly failed
discharge the burden of proof.
Ombudsman committed
z
a sudden
iS
ex-facie
it app 1 priate to
in the High courts urr,,er Articrc
ll
226 of dne Constitution is plenary, of the widest amplitude, and
forms an integral part of the basic structure of the Constitution,
as enunciated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in L. Chandra
Kutnar a, tlnion oJ India2. Exercise of such power is controlled
onty by self-imposed restraints and not by any statutory
Iimitation or other external fetter. Mere existence of an
alternative remedy does not, by itself, oust or curtail writ
jurisdiction ol the High Court, as authoritatively held in
Whirlpool Corporation rt. Reglsttor of T'rade Marks3,
whercin it was laid down that the High Court may nonetheless
exercise its j urisdiction where fundamental rights are affected,
principles of natural justice are violated, or the authority has
acted without or in excess of jurisdiction. As rightly contended
by learned counsel for Petitioner, once an authority vested with
j urisdiction reluses
to exercise the same, invocaLion of writ
jurisdiction of this Court not only becomes maintainable but
constitutes the proper and efficacious remedy; such an
authority, having declined to assume jurisdiction, cannot
thercafter proceed to issue directions to the parties, and any
such course of action is clearly ultra uires, perverse, and
unsusta inable in law.
' ( 1997) 3 scc 26 I
' (t gge) 8 scc t
l4
t6
In the present case, once thr
Ombudsman
expressly declined [o exercise
the jurisdiction r,:sted
in it, it
could no[ have simultaneously
directed l) titioner and
Respondent No. 3 to approach
rssued a direction to Hyderabad
civil Court, nor ;ould it have
Cricket Associzr on to curtail
the rights of a fult member that petitioner
for several decades. It is inconceivable
had br:n exercising
that Ombur sman having
found that no case vr.as made
out by Responder I No. 3, went
ahead and issued a direction
to petitioner to zr rproach civil
Court and restricted its rights
in the interregnurr by issuing a
direction to Respondent No. 2. petitioner
made to suffer the consequence
o[ Respondent Nc. 3 not being
able to establish his case. Therefore,
Ombudsman is whol$ arbitrary
could r< t have been
the direction I sued by the
and unsustainable
Reliance placed on the juctgment
lil
Nalgonda
Distrlct Cricket .4ssociation ccrse
(supra)
]S
misplaced,
rnasmuch as that decision
is clearly distinguishtrlr e on facts;
the Ombudsman in that case
rendered a detailed, cogent,
evidence, which was treated
having exercised juri; liction
and
reasoned decision supl orted
with
as analogous to an arl) tral
and, on that footing, held not
con fFadistinction, the instant
award
amenable to writ inter 'erence,
matter involves a conll) ,-te
to cxercise jurisdictio-n,. coupled
in
failure
with the issuance o. Jirections
beyond authority, thereby squarely warranting exercise of this
Court's jurisdiction under Article 226. Therefore, this Court
rejects the ground of maintainability raised by Respondertt No. 2
and holds that Writ Petition is maintainable.
18.
POINT {iil: As can be seen from
the record, the
Commercial Taxes Cricket Club is the club formed by employees
of the Commercial Taxes Department, with its governing body
nominated on a rotational basis amongst employee-players
residing in Hyderabad and Secunderabad, and managed by
non-gazetted ofhcers. Pursuant to Article 12 of its Bylaws,
which governs qualifications for election as office bearers and
stipulates that no person shall be eligible unless an employee of
the Commercial Taxes Department and a member of either the
AP Commercial Taxes Non-Gazetted Ofhcers' Association,
Hyderabad, or the APCT Gazetted Officers' Association. Article
12 is reproduced hereu nder:
"
Article 12. QUALIFICATIOM .FOR ELECTION AS
OFFICE BE,ARER: 1) No person shall be eligible for election for
any of the post of oflice bearer unless he is an employee of
Commercial Tax Department and a member of either in The AP
Commercial Taxes Non-Gazetted Officers' Association,
Hyderabad or APCT Gazetted Officers' Association.
2) Thc office bearers shall be eligible for re-election.
t6
1)
Not withstanding as it contained in Ar.r Lcle 12(1) one
can become office bearer temporarily with the a1; troval pf The
APCTNGOs' Association if it is other than eml) oyce for
the
period specified.
2)
Any office bearer who fails to attend i consecutive
meetings of the Managing Committee sherll forego his
membership unless such absence is due to vali<l reasons and
with the prior approval of the president.,,
19.
It can be further seen from
'ecord that
administration of Commercial Taxes Cricker
Club was
temporarily entrusted to the body led by B. Sr-Lr heel Kumar
Semwal, invoking.the proviso to Article l2(l), uidt letter
dated
30.11.2024 addressed to the Telangana Comnr rcial Taxes
NGOs Association Hyderabad, with formal per.r ission
duly
granted urde Association's reply letter dated OT.1,2., O24, for
the
period from 07.12.2024 to 06.12.2025 or until r :solution
of
legai issues, whichever is earlier. Upon expiry of th,: said period,
the said body duly handed over charge to petitione. s Secretary,
Shaik Jalalud din uide letter dated 06.12_2025, thcr= ry restoring
the erstwhile ofhce bearers in strict conformity with I he
20.
Bylaws.
trven though as per Article 12 of Petitioner's
byelaws, non-employees of Commercial Taxes Depz atment
be part of the administration, since the body has
can
n rw reverted
thn* to the Committee headed by Shaik Jal: I rdclin and
t7
presently all the members are employees of the Commercial
Taxes Department, the discussion in this regard would
purely academic. Therefore, since it is brought on record
be
and
not disputed by Respondents that the club is now being
administered and managed by Shaik Ja,laluddin as Secretary
and that all the members are employees of Commercial Taxes
Department working in the twin-cities, the objection raised by
Respondent No. 3 no longer holds good. Therefore, this Court
holds that writ is maintainable and there is no prohibition as
per byelaws, rules and regulations of the Commercial Taxes
Cricket Club to file the present Writ petition.
21.
POINT
liiil:
As
has been held in the preceding
paragraphs, once the Ombudsman expressly declined to
exercise the jurisdiction vested in it, it could not have
simultaneously directed petitioner ald Respondent No. 3 to
approach civil Court nor could it have issued a direction to HCA
to curtaii the rights of a full member that petitioner had been
exercising for several decades. It
is inconceivable that
Ombr.rdsman having found that no case was made out
by
Respondent No.3, went ahead and issued a direction to
Petitioner to approach civil Court and restricted its rights in the
interregnum. Petitioner could not have been made to suffer the
consequence of Respondent No. 3 not being able.to establish his
ii;
l8
case. Therefore, the direction issued by the O:r budsman is
wholly arbitrary and an unsustainable and there I rre, deserves
to be set aside.
22.
Writ Petition No. 3Z9SO of 2O2S i ; therefore,
allowed alld the direction given by the Ethicr; Officer and
Ombudsman Additional Charge in Case No. 6 cf 2024 dated
29.11 .2024, at PaIa No. 7, directing borh the Il titioner and
Respondent No. 3 to approach civil Court is set il ;ide and the
said direction is confined only to RespondenL Nrr. 3 u.ho was
Petitioner before the Ombudsman.
23.
Further, since it is borne out b1. record that
Petitioner has been exercising rights of full membe ' from 1987
onwards till passing of the Order by the Ombucisrr rn and that
Respondent No. 3 failed to produce a single docurr :nt showing
his right, interest or entitlement in the Corrrrrr, rcial Taxes
Cricket Club, the direction of the Ombudsman i.t:. )ending the
settlement of the disputes with regard to the own: 'ship of the
Clubs in the appropriate Court of
Lau,
the
2Dd
Respondent/ HCA cannot entertain lhe claims c - bolh the
parties', is also set aside and Respondent No. 2 is dirccted to
continue to recognize Petitioner as a full member ,f HCA and
extend all the benehts to it till such time Respor Cent No. 3
approaches the competent civil Court and obtains () 'ders to the
l
l9
contra,rjr. In view of ariowing writ petition
No. 37g50 0f 2025,
no orders are required to be passed in writ petitiou
No. 22!,61
of 2025, therefore, the same is closed.
24.
Consequently, the misceilaneous Applications,
if
any shall stand closed.
SdIMOHD. ISMAIL
DEPUry REGISTRAI
//TRUE COPY//
CTION OFFICER
To
'l
. The Princi pal Secreta ry, Sports and youth S ervicas
D
ent, Secretariat,
Hvd erabad, Tela ngana, lndia
The Secreta ry, H yd erabad Cricket
ndhi International
Cricket Stad iuml U ppal, HyderabadAssoci ation, Raji
3. The Secreta ryB Venka taiah Assistant Co
mmr ssioner Commercial Ta XES,
Commercial Tax es Cric ket Club,
H_ No. 5 -8-11 z, First Floor,
2nd Cent ury
Complex, O pposite Ch enetha Bhavan
Nampa lly, Hyderabad-500001.
4 One CC to SRI M.HAR EESH
KUMAR , Advoca te
[OPUC]
5. Two CCs to GP FOR S PORTS,
High Court for the State of Telangana
Hyderaba
,at
UI
b One CC to SRI V.RAJENDER
RAO, SC FOR H cA
7. One CC to SRt K.SATHAKAR Nl,
[OPUC
Advocate [Op UC]
8. Two CD Co pres
PSK/PMK
d[o
l
l
'|
J
i
E
t'
HIGH COURT
t
DATED:0910112026
COMMON ORDER
WP.Nos.22361 AND 37950 of 2025
s
(-
t
:(\ 1F. SIA rs
I
&1
lat
(
D: ., r.-r ;-\'r,( 7
.--.
\-.
ALLOWING THE W.P.No.3795O OF 2025 qND
CLOSING OF THE W.P.No.22361 OF 20i1t
WITHOUT COSTS
\1
:_
JAN zt?E
)l
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review