Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~65 to 70
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 20.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 12775/2019
THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
AND ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC
GNCTD Services with Mr.
Uday Singh Ahlawat, Mrs.
Tania Ahlawat, Mr. Nitesh
Kumar Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam
and Mr Mohnish Sehrawat,
Advs.
versus
B.P. MAHAUR
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. A K Trivedi, Adv.
+
W.P.(C) 12781/2019
THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
AND ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC
GNCTD Services with Mr.
Uday Singh Ahlawat, Mrs.
Tania Ahlawat, Mr. Nitesh
Kumar Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam
and Mr Mohnish Sehrawat,
Advs.
versus
B.P. MAHAUR
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. A K Trivedi, Adv.
+
W.P.(C) 12796/2019
THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
AND ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC
GNCTD Services with Mr.
Uday Singh Ahlawat, Mrs.
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
Tania Ahlawat, Mr. Nitesh
Kumar Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam
and Mr Mohnish Sehrawat,
Advs.
versus
B.P. MAHAUR
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. A K Trivedi, Adv.
+
W.P.(C) 12800/2019
THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
AND ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC
GNCTD Services with Mr.
Uday Singh Ahlawat, Mrs.
Tania Ahlawat, Mr. Nitesh
Kumar Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam
and Mr Mohnish Sehrawat,
Advs.
versus
B.P. MAHAUR
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. A K Trivedi, Adv.
+
W.P.(C) 12801/2019
THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
AND ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC
GNCTD Services with Mr.
Uday Singh Ahlawat, Mrs.
Tania Ahlawat, Mr. Nitesh
Kumar Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam
and Mr Mohnish Sehrawat,
Advs.
versus
B.P. MAHAUR
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. A K Trivedi, Adv.
+
W.P.(C) 12802/2019
THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
AND ORS.
.....Petitioners
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
Through:
Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC
GNCTD Services with Mr.
Uday Singh Ahlawat, Mrs.
Tania Ahlawat, Mr. Nitesh
Kumar Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam
and Mr Mohnish Sehrawat,
Advs.
versus
B.P. MAHAUR
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. A K Trivedi, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
J U D G M E N T (ORAL)
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
1.
The present Petition has been filed assailing the common order
dated 08.05.2019, passed by the learned Central Administrative
Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (‘CAT’) in six O.A.s filed by
the Respondent/Sh. B.P. Mahuar, vide which the six orders of
punishment awarded against the Respondent have been modified and a
consolidated/amalgamated order of punishment has been passed.
2.
Succinctly stated, the Respondent, while in service, was served
as many as six charge memos dated 22.06.2001, 27.06.2001,
12.07.2001, 19.07.2001, 20.08.2001 and 12.11.2001, which are
summarized as under: Date of
Article of Charges Framed
Final Punishment
Issuance
Imposed
WP (C) NO. 12801/2019
22.06.2001
"While working as STO in ward-81, Withholding of 100%
Shri B.P. Mahaur committed
of monthly pension on
misconduct in as much as he had
permanent basis
issued (82) ST- 35 forms, (30) ST-1
otherwise admissible to
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
him.
forms and (05)'C' forms to M/s.
Nikalson India, Parwana Road, Forfeiture of 100%
Jagatpuri, Delhi. Registration was
gratuity otherwise
granted to the dealer by Sh. J.N.
admissible to him.
Sharma at Arya Samaj Gali, Sita
Ram Bazaar, Delhi with liability and
validity with effect from 15.05.97 in
Ward-19. The dealer shifted to the
registration Ward-81 with effect
from 19.05.1998 and the shifting was
confirmed by both the STI's of Ward19 and ward- 81. Immediately after
shifting, the process of issuing of
statutory forms was initiated by Sh.
B.P. Mahaur. He also allowed
diversified items for sale and
manufacturing without obtaining any
report from the lower functionaries.
The forms were issued in quick
succession. Due to nefarious and
dubious activities of the dealer and a
helping hand given by Sh. B.P.
Mabhaur, the dealer caused heavy
loss to the government revenue.
Sh. B.P. Mahaur had issued
statutory forms to the dealer in
contravention of order no. 7 and 9 of
1995-96. As per this order, the form
issuing authority is required to fill
the forms as for which assessment
year the forms so issued are to be
used, stamp of the assessing
authority, stamp of the dealer,
amount etc. The forms were issued
without
obtaining
advance
requirement from the dealer except
once dated 12.08.98 when (17) ST35 forms were issued. Except issued
forms for more than once for
particular year and also failed to get
the dealer surveyed in terms of
circular no. 7 and 9 of 1995-96.
Sh. B.P. Mahaur allowed diversified
items for resale by way of
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
amendment in the RC with effect
from 04.07.98 without obtaining
report from the lower functionary.
He also ignored the storage facilities
available with the dealer which was
only about 100 sq. ft. He also failed
to consider the economic condition
of the dealer before allowing
amendments in the RCs and issuing
of statutory forms.
Thus, B.P. Mahaur has not only
shown negligence on his part and
dereliction to duty in issuing
statutory forms and allowing good
number of diversified items for
resale and for manufacturing to the
above said dealer which shows his
active connivance with the dealer.
He failed to maintain absolute
integrity and thereby acted in a
manner which is unbecoming of a
government servant and his conduct
was in violation of provisions of rule
3 of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964."
WP (C) NO. 12796/2019
27.06.2001
"While functioning as STO in ward- Withholding of 25% of
81, Shri B.P. Mahaur committed
monthly pension for a
misconduct in as much as he had
period of 2 years.
issued (69) ST- 35 forms and (29) Gratuity may be
ST-1 forms to M/s. Devo Associates,
released if not required
55A, Anarkali Garden, Jagatpuri,
otherwise.
Shahdara, Delhi, who had shifted to
this place from the jurisdiction of
ward-71 after getting registration on
09.06.98. The forms were issued on
2 occasions i.e. on 19.08.98 and
21.09.98 without getting actual
requirement from the dealer. This
caused heavy loss to the Government
revenue and this itself proves the
active connivance and a helping
hand of Shri B.P. Mahaur to the
dealer.
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
Sh. B.P. Mahaur had issued
statutory forms to the dealer in
contravention of provisions of
circular no. 7 and 9 of 1995-96. As
per the circular the form issuing
authority is required to fill the forms
as for which assessment year the
forms so issued are to be used,
stamp of the assessing authority,
stamp of the dealer, amount etc. The
forms were issued without obtaining
detailed requirement from the dealer
before issuing the same. Shri B.P.
Mahaur issued blank forms to the
dealer in each occasion, in addition
to not following the provisions of the
above noted circular.
Sh. B.P. Mahaur has not only shown
negligence on his part and
dereliction to duty in issuing
statutory forms but also has
extended a helping hand in the
dubious and nefarious activities of
the dealer. He failed to maintain
absolute integrity and thereby acted
in manner which is unbecoming of a
Govt. Servant and his conduct was in
violation of Provision of rule 3 of
CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.”
WP (C) NO. 12802/2019
12.07.2001
"While functioning as STO in ward81, Shri B.P. Mahaur committed
misconduct in as much as he had
issued (120) ST-1 forms, (175) ST-35
forms, (58) 'F' and (05) 'C' forms to
M/s. Continental Traders, Jitar
Nagar, Near Parwana Road,
Shahdara, Delhi, who was granted
registration by him with liability and
validity with effect from 10.04.1997
and had also allowed diversified
items for resale and manufacturing
without having check over the
nefarious and dubious activities of
Withholding of entire
pensionary benefits on
permanent basis and
forfeiture of Gratuity
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
the dealer. This caused heavy loss to
the government revenue and this
itself proves the active connivance
and a helping hand of the said Shri
B.P. Mahaur with dealer.
Sh. B.P. Mahaur issued statutory
forms to the dealer in contravention
of order No.7 and 9 of 1995-96. As
per the circular, the forms issuing
authority is required to fill the form
such as for which assessment year
the forms so issued are to be utilized,
stamps of the issuing authority as
well as of the dealer, amount, items
etc. The forms were issued without
obtaining detailed requirement from
the dealer before issuing the same.
Sh. B.P. Mahaur issued blank forms
to the dealer on each occassion. He
had issued blank forms for more
than once for a single year. He
failed to get survey of the dealer as
per circular 7 and cross verify the
purchases and sales made by the
dealer against these Sales Tax (ST)
forms.
Sh. B.P. Mahaur allowed diversified
items by way of amendment in the
RC w.e.f 02.07.1997 and 01.04.1998
without obtaining report from the
lower functionary. He also ignored
the storage facilities available with
the dealer which was 10x12 feet. He
also failed to consider the economic
condition of the dealer before
allowing
amendment
in
the
Registration Certificates(RCs).
Sh. B.P. Mahaur has not only shown
negligence on his part and
dereliction to duty in issuing
statutory forms and allowing good
number of diversified items for
resale and manufacturing to the
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
above said dealer which shows his
active connivance with the dealer,
but he failed to maintain absolute
integrity and thereby acted in a
manner which is unbecoming of a
government servant and his conduct
was in violation of provisions of
rule-3 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules,
WP (C) No. 12781/2019
19.07.2001
" While functioning as STO in ward- Withholding of 30% of
81, Shri B.P. Mahaur committed
monthly pension for a
misconduct in as much as he had
period of 5 years.
issued (45) ST- 35 forms and (24) 'C' Gratuity
may
be
forms to M/s. Ankleshwar Suppliers,
released if not required
A- 105, Radhey Shyam Park, Extn.,
otherwise.
Delhi formerly known as Shree
Balaji Trading Company. The dealer
was granted registration by the then
STO, Ward-56 with liability and
validity with effect from 01.09.1997
at Madipur Village, Delhi. The items
allowed were petroleum products,
chemicals,
plastic
and
PVC
material. The dealer shifted to the
jurisdiction of Ward-81 w.e.f.
11.03.98. The shifting enquiry was
confirmed by the STI's of both the
wards viz. 56 and 81. The surety was
prescribed by Shri B.P. Mahaur on
06.05.98 for Rs.15,000/- under the
local Act and Rs. 10,000/- under the
Central Act. One more item ranipal
was allowed by way of amendment
in the RC w.e.f. 28.08.98. Sh. B.P.
Mahaur issued statutory forms
without
obtaining
advance
requirement from the dealerwhich
proves the active connivance and a
helping hand of Shri B.P. Mahaur to
the dealer.
Sh. B.P. Mahaur had issued
statutory forms to the dealer in
contravention of provisions of order
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
no. 7 and 9 of 1995-96. As per the
circular the form issuing authority is
required to fill the forms as for
which assessment year the forms so
issued are to be used by the dealer,
stamps of the issuing authority, as
well as of the dealer and amount,
items etc. The forms were issued
without
obtaining
detailed
requirement from the dealer before
issuing the same, he failed to
prescribe additional surety in
commensurate of the purchases
being made by the dealer against
these statutory forms, failed to cross
verify the purchases and sales from
the lower functionary and also to get
survey of the dealer. Shri Mahaur
issued blank forms to the dealer on
each occasions mentioned above.
Sh. B.P. Mahaur has not only shown
negligence on his part and
dereliction to duty in issuing
statutory forms to the above
circulars before issuing the statutory
forms. He failed to maintain
absolute integrity & thereby acted in
a manner which is unbecoming of a
Govt. servant and his conduct was in
violation of provisions of Rule 3 of
the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964”
WP (C) NO. 12775/2019
20.08.2001
"While functioning as STO in ward- Withholding of 20% of
81, Shri B.P. Mahaur committed
monthly pension for a
misconduct in as much as he had
period of 5 years.
verified (01) ST- 35 forms bearing Gratuity
may
be
No. 04AA901227 for Rs.7,38,440/released if not required
which was issued to M/s. Bawa
otherwise.
Wood Crafts, 9-A, Govind Park,
Jagatpuri, Delhi, for the assessment
year 1995-96. M/s. Bawa Wood
Crafts in turn issued the said form to
M/s. Pawan Industries, 229, Gokul
Puri, Delhi, a registered dealer of
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
the same ward for the item tea. The
item "tea' is not allowed on the RC
of M/s. Bawa Wood Crafts.
Sh. B.P. Mahaur has shown
slackness and negligence on his part
and dereliction to duty in verifying
the statutory forms. He had shown
connivance with the dealer and
failed to maintain absolute integrity
and thereby acted in a manner which
is unbecoming of a government
servant and his conduct was in
violation of provision of Rule 3 of
CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.”
WP (C) NO. 12800/2019
12.11.2001
"While functioning as STO in ward- Withholding of 20% of
81, Sh. B.P. Mahaur committed
monthly pension for a
misconduct in as much as he had
period of 5 years
issued (144) ST- 1 forms, (110) STAND
35 forms (05) 'C' forms and (10) 'F'
Penaly should run
forms to M/s. Acharya Enterprises,
Concurrently.
F-86, Jagatpuri, Delhi, who was
granted registration with liability
and validity w.e.f. 20.02.97, and had
also allowed diversified items for
resale and manufacturing without
having any check over the nefarious
and dubious activities of the dealer.
The space of the business premises
was insufficient for storage of the
diversified items. As per registration
survey report, the space was 10X10
ft. The investment made by the
dealer was meagre viz. Rs. 14000/only. This caused heavy revenue loss
to the government and this itself
proves the active connivance and a
helping hand of Sh. B.P. Mahaur to
the dealer.
Sh. B.P. Mahaur had contravened
the provisions of circular no.7 and 9
of 1995-96. As per circular, the form
issuing authority is required to
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
obtain full requirement of the dealer
for a particular year and issue
statutory forms in one go. He is also
required to fill the form such as for
which assessment years the forms so
issued are to be used, stamp of the
dealer, stamp of the issuing
authority. Amount, items etc. He has
also required to get 2 survey
conducted after the issue of
registration within one year. He also
failed to get cross verification of
purchases and sales made against
these statutory forms by the dealer.
Sh. B.P. Mahaur allowed diversified
items by way of amendment on the
RC on many occasions without
obtaining report from the lower
functionary. He also ignored the
storage facilities available with the
dealer and his economic condition
before allowing amendments in the
RC's.
Thus, B.P. Mahaur has shown
negligence on his part and
dereliction to duty in issuing
statutory forms and allowing good
number of diversified items for
resale and for manufacturing to the
above said dealer which shows his
active connivance with the dealer.
He failed to maintain absolute
integrity and thereby acted in a
manner which is unbecoming of a
government servant and his conduct
was in violation of provisions of rule
3 of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964."
3.
Before the disciplinary proceedings could be concluded, the
Respondent, on attaining the age of superannuation, retired on
30.11.2001.
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
4.
After the Reply/Defence brief was submitted by the Respondent
denying the charges proposed against him, the Inquiry Officer was
appointed and the inquiry reports were submitted before the
Disciplinary Authority holding that the allegations as to the
negligence in discharge of the duties are proved but not of
“connivance”.
5.
In respect of four charge memos, the Disciplinary Authority
issued disagreement notes, taking the view that the allegation as to
connivance between the Respondent and the dealers can also be taken
as proved. In the remaining two, no disagreement note was issued, and
imputation of misconduct levelled against the Respondent was proved
and punishment was imposed in the form of withholding of 30% and
20% of the pension respectively, for a period of five years and both
punishments were directed to run concurrently.
6.
The remark to disagreement notes, were filed by the
Respondent before the Disciplinary Authority and not satisfied with
the same, it was concluded that the charge against the Respondent
stand proved. As required under Rule 9 of the CCS (Pension) Rules,
the same was forwarded to the Union Public Service Commission
(hereafter ‘UPSC’), for their advice.
7.
Ultimately, punishment orders were passed after getting advice
from the UPSC, which are part of the articles of charges extracted
above.
8.
Aggrieved, the Respondent filed as many as six OAs
challenging the orders of punishment passed by Disciplinary
Authority in six articles of charges, which were disposed of vide
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
common judgment dated 22.07.2014, on the ground that the
punishment could not have been imposed without communicating the
advice tendered by UPSC to the Respondent and liberty was granted
to the Disciplinary Authority to pass fresh orders vide separate order
dated 03.02.2017.
9.
In compliance with the aforesaid, copy of the advice of UPSC
was tendered to the Respondent and fresh orders dated 19.01.2016,
08.11.2016, 06.09.2016, 28.01.2016, 27.09.2016 and 20.06.2017 were
passed by the Disciplinary Authority, re-affirming the punishment
imposed by the earlier orders.
10.
Hence, again six OAs were filed by the Respondent, which have
been allowed by the learned CAT vide the impugned common order
dated 08.05.2019, while recording following two reasons: (i)
This is a second round of litigation and the Respondent
retired on 30.11.2001.
(ii)
As per Rule 9 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, the
punishment of withholding pension could have only been
imposed if the employee is found guilty of “grave” misconduct
or negligence. However, the word ‘grave’ has been used for the
first time by the UPSC, which was not appropriate.
11.
Ultimately, the learned CAT, while passing the impugned
common order on 08.05.2019, directed as under : “28. We, accordingly, allow the OAs in part, directing that the six
impugned orders of punishment shall stand amalgamated into one,
to the effect that :
a. the pension of the applicant shall be withheld to the extent
of 50% permanently with effect from the date of this order;
b. the deductions already made under various orders at
different stages shall hold good and shall not be liable to
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
c.
12.
be reopened, and
the applicant shall be released the gratuity, if not already
done.”
We have heard the learned counsel for the parties at length and
with their able assistance, have perused the paper book.
13.
It is evident that the Disciplinary Authority, while passing the
final order, has used the word ‘grave’. Moreover, as per Rule 9 of
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, right to withhold or withdraw pension is
available to the Government in case the pensioner is found guilty of
grave misconduct or negligence during the period of service.
14.
It is evident that the Respondent was working as Sales Tax
Officer. It has been alleged that while performing his duties as Sales
Tax Officer in the year 1995-96, he issued several forms to the traders
without proper verification and that in turn resulted in the evasion of
sales tax. It was also alleged that he did not verify the eligibility of the
concerned traders to be issued those forms. Hence, it was alleged that
the Respondent has acted in a negligent manner in issuing the forms
and taking other steps and has connived with the respective traders.
15.
Pertinently, the above allegations of misconduct, have been
found proved and he has been held guilty by the Disciplinary
Authority. In four out of six matters, the Disciplinary Authority has
come to a conclusion that the Respondent has also connived with the
assessees/dealers.
16.
In such circumstances, it was not appropriate for the learned
CAT to dispose of six petitions, by a summary order, without delving
into the matter, particularly when not only UPSC, but even the
Disciplinary Authority has used the word / expression ‘grave’ while
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
recording finding against the Respondent.
17.
Additionally, the learned CAT was required to go into the
substance and not the form, when the charges levelled against the
Respondent were evidently grave and serious in nature, without giving
undue weightage to whether and when the word “grave” has been
used and by observing that the proceedings could have continued only
if there existed the element of gravity of misconduct or negligence.
18.
In such circumstances, the learned CAT was expected to go into
all the six orders passed by the Disciplinary Authority and analyse
each matter independently, instead of summarily disposing of six
matters only on the basis of aforesaid two reasons, as already noted.
19.
In any case, the UPSC has specifically found the offence to be
grave and has mentioned the same in its advice. The proceedings
would not vitiate solely for the absence of the specific word in the
initial charge particularly when the Disciplinary Authority has also
used the same word. Similarly, the petitions could not be disposed of
only on the ground that this was a second round of litigation, when
liberty itself was granted to the Disciplinary Authority to pass fresh
orders.
20.
Consequently, in view of the foregoing, the impugned order is
set-aside and the matter is remanded back to the learned CAT for a
fresh decision.
21.
Since the Respondent retired in the year 2001, therefore, the
learned CAT is requested to make sincere endeavour for final disposal
of the matters expeditiously, preferably within a period of next three
months from the date the parties enter appearance.
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
22.
The parties along with their learned counsel are directed to
appear before the learned CAT on 05.02.2026.
23.
Accordingly, the present petitions are disposed of.
24.
A photocopy of the Order passed today be placed in the
connected matters.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
JANUARY 20, 2026
‘KDK’
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 12775/2019 & connected matters
KAUR
15:21:22
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review