Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
CRP No. 11 of 2022
Date of Decision: 09.05.2022
Vs. M/s. BSC – C&C JV
The Chief Engineer (PWD)
(National Highways)
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. S. Sahay, Adv.
Ms. R. Colney, GA.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. U. Hazarika, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. L. Khyriem, Adv.
Ms. G. Mohan, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
in press:
_____________________________________________________________
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The instant petition under Article 227 is a second round of litigation
that is before this Court between the same parties, though in the present
proceedings the erstwhile respondent in the earlier round (CRP No. 2 of 2022)
is now the petitioner. The petitioner is aggrieved with the impugned order
dated 14.02.2022 passed by the Arbitral Tribunal constituted for adjudication
of disputes in relation to Agreement dated 21.02.2011 for the 2-laning Project
for Nongstoin-Shillong Section of NH-44 under the Special Accelerated Road
Development Programme (SARDP-NE) of the Ministry of Road Transport
and Highways.
2.
The brief facts are that the Arbitral Tribunal vide an interim award
dated 27.07.2021 was pleased to award an amount of Rs. 75 Crores to the
respondent by partly allowing an application of the respondent under Section
31(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as
the ‘Act’) which was made, seeking an interim award in respect of Claim No.
1 in the Arbitral proceedings. An application under Section 33 of the Act was
then filed by the respondents before the Arbitral Tribunal seeking certain
modifications in the award which however, came to be rejected by an order
dated 21.12.2021. By order dated 14.02.2022 the Arbitral Tribunal then
framed issues for its determination in the said Arbitration proceedings and the
first issue framed was with regard to the amounts claimed by the respondents
under Claim No. 1.
3.
The grievance of the petitioner centres around the contention that the
Arbitral Tribunal patently lacks inherent jurisdiction to reconsider Claim No.
1, inasmuch as, the same had already been considered and an award had been
passed thereon, dated 27.07.2021. The Arbitral Tribunal by a subsequent
order dated 21.12.2021 passed under a Section 33 application, had also
rejected prayers for modification of the award in respect of Claim No. 1 which
the petitioner asserts had finally decided the Claim No. 1, but by framing issue
No. 1 on Claim No.1, vide the impugned order, the Arbitral Tribunal had
conferred authority on itself to award further amounts on a claim which it had
already decided. The impugned order is assailed on the grounds that the same
had been passed without jurisdiction, against the provisions of the Arbitration
Act and in violation of the doctrine of functus officio and res-judicata.
4.
Mr. S. Sahay, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that Claim No.
1 had been finally determined by the award dated 27.07.2021 passed by the
learned Arbitral Tribunal and as per Section 35, is enforceable as a decree
under the Act, and as such Claim No. 1 being decreed by the award, the
Arbitral Tribunal is therefore functus officio in respect of Claim No. 1.
Learned counsel has referred to IFFCO Ltd. v. Bhadra Products, (2018) 2
SCC 534 and McDermott International Inc. v. Burn Standard Co. Ltd.,
(2006) 11 SCC 181 to emphasize the point that an interim award is not subject
to a final award but is a final award on matters covered thereby, which he
submits is the position in the instant case, as the award dated 27.07.2021
covers Claim No. 1 and therefore, is final as far as Claim No. 1 is concerned.
5.
It is also argued that the respondent’s application under Section 33
before the Arbitral Tribunal is a clear admission of the fact that Claim No. 1
has been finally decided, since an additional award as per Section 33 (4) can
be sought only in respect of Claims already presented in the arbitral
proceedings but omitted from the award; and the rejection of the same by
order 21.12.2021, he contends, clearly reflects that no additional award or
clarification as sought by the claimant, was made out. He submits that the
only remedy against rejection of a Section 33 application is by preferring a
Section 34 petition under the Act. The framing of the first issue by the Arbitral
Tribunal as to the entitlement of the respondent over amounts claimed by it
under Claim No. 1, he submits has given a new lease of life to the said claim
despite the respondent failing to secure relief in the award as also by Section
33 application. The learned counsel has articulated the challenge to the
impugned order in his written arguments as follows: -
(a)
Arbitral Tribunal is patently lacking inherent jurisdiction over
Claim No. 1 as the same already stands finally decreed by Award dated
27.07.2021.
(b)
Exercise of jurisdiction over Claim No. 1 after passing the award
dated 27.07.2021 is also contrary to order dated 21.12.2021 of the
Arbitral Tribunal wherein it has been held that Tribunal has considered
all the claims and passed its award, which calls for no correction.
(c)
Arbitral Tribunal is patently lacking inherent jurisdiction over
Claim No. 1 as the Arbitral Tribunal has become functus officio having
heard and decided the Claim No. 1.
(d)
Impugned order has resulted in failure of justice, inasmuch as,
the respondents, are being permitted to re-litigate decided claims.
(e)
Impugned order is based on a procedure unknown to law which
is liable to be corrected by this Hon’ble Court.
(f)
Re-hearing of the decided matter is also barred by the principle
of res-judicata contained in Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908.
6.
On the question of maintainability of this petition under Article 227,
learned counsel has placed the judgment of this Court between the same
parties dated 11.02.2022 (CRP No. 2 of 2022) and submits that in the earlier
proceedings it was the respondent herein which had argued before this Court
and placed several decisions that jurisdiction under Article 227 is not
curtailed against Arbitral proceedings, but now are seeking to take a contrary
stand. It is further submitted by the learned counsel that even otherwise, the
orders of Arbitral Tribunal which are patently lacking in jurisdiction have
been challenged before writ Courts and have been held to be maintainable.
Reliance is also placed on the decision of the Delhi High Court in the case of
Surender Kumar Singhal & Ors vs. Arun Kumar Bhalotia & Ors. (2021
SCC Online Del. 3708) wherein he submits the entire gamut of the
maintainability and scope and extent of interference has been discussed.
7.
The learned counsel has also contended that alternate remedy under
Section 34 of the Act is also not available to the petitioner in view of the fact
that the award dated 27.07.2021 has already been put to challenge by the
institution of Commercial Arbitration Case and while the matter is pending,
the impugned order came to be passed which renders the remedy of Section
34 illusory and even if the petitioner was to succeed in the pending Section
34 application, by reliance on the impugned order, the respondent can obtain
another award on the same claim which has been decreed and which decree
is already under challenge.
8.
He lastly submits that remedy under the Arbitration Act is not available
in cases where there is patent lack of inherent jurisdiction and the only
recourse is an application such as the present one under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
9.
Mr. U. Hazarika, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. L. Khyriem,
learned counsel for the respondent submits that the only issue in the present
proceedings is whether Issue No. 1, framed by the Arbitral Tribunal on
14.02.2022, could be framed in view of the interim award dated 27.07.2021
and whether any further adjudication in respect of the said claim would be
permissible. He submits that apart from the non-maintainability of the present
petition, framing or non-framing of issues is not mandatory under the Act nor
determinative of the rights of the parties and as such no cause of action has
arisen to warrant the instant proceedings. It is further submitted that remedy
for any grievance lies in the filing of a Section 34 petition, assuming that the
petitioner is aggrieved by the final arbitral award, under Section 16(3) of the
Act on the ground that the Arbitral Tribunal has exceeded the scope of its
authority.
10.
In support of his contention as to non-maintainability, the learned
Senior counsel has placed reliance on the following judgments: (i)
Deep Industries Limited vs. ONGC (2020) 15 SCC 706.
(ii)
Tagus Engineering Pvt. Ltd. vs. Reserve Bank of India (Writ
Petition No. 3957 of 2021, Bombay High Court) order dated
21.02.2022.
(iii)
11.
SBP and Co. vs Patel Engineering Ltd., (2005) 8 SCC 618.
On the necessity or requirement of framing issues the learned Senior
counsel has cited the following judgments: (i)
Prabhakar Nirman vs. TCIL Limited 2019 SCC Online Del
9559 (Para 52(i).
(ii)
Patel Engineering Co. Ltd. vs. B.T.Patil & Sons Belgaum
(Construction) Pvt. Ltd. (Arbitration Petition No. 891 of 2010,
decided on 04.04.2013).
12.
It is contended by the learned Senior counsel that the entire petition is
based on a complete misreading of the award, as though the respondent under
Section 31(6) had sought an amount of Rs. 117,97,18,006/- under Claim No.
1, the Arbitral Tribunal had proceeded on the principle of Order XII Rule 6
CPC by giving a judgment upon admission and awarded a sum of Rs. 75
Crores with the balance due to be paid after detailed calculations. It is
submitted that nowhere does the interim award say that Claim No. 1 has been
adjudicated in its totality, or that quantification of the balance amount has
been decided. With regard to the rejection of the Section 33 application
learned Senior counsel asserts that as the adjudication was final only as far as
Rs. 75 Crores being part of Claim No. 1, the Arbitral Tribunal had reiterated
the findings of the award and had further observed that the figure that had
been arrived at of Rs. 75 Crores need not be confused with the other claims.
13.
The learned Senior counsel while refuting the contention of the
petitioner that the Arbitral Tribunal had become functus officio as far as Claim
No. 1 is concerned, submits that the Arbitral Tribunal had kept the balance of
Claim No. 1 for determination subject to certified calculations and this is
apparent from the award dated 27.07.2021 itself. He therefore submits that
the petition being non-maintainable and which does not disclose any cause of
action, is based on a palpably erroneous reading of the interim award being
an alleged final adjudication of Claim No. 1, is one in a long series of
applications and petitions filed by the petitioner to scuttle/delay the arbitral
proceedings and does not deserve any consideration from this Court.
14.
Having heard the submissions of the learned counsels and after a
careful perusal of the materials on record, it is noted that the only issue that
is to be decided apart from the question of maintainability, is whether the
Arbitral Tribunal lacked inherent jurisdiction in framing the issue on Claim
No. 1 which the petitioner asserts is a closed and decided issue as far as the
proceedings before the Arbitral Tribunal was concerned. The issue on Claim
No. 1 as framed by the Tribunal for the sake of convenience is quoted
hereinbelow:
“i)
Whether the Claimant is entitled to claim Rs.
117,97,18,006/- being the amount of Claim No. 1?
OPC
(Objected to by Ld. Counsel for the Respondent).”
In the context of Claim No.1, the same was subjected to earlier
proceedings which was initiated by an application under Section 31(6)
wherein the respondent/claimant had called upon the Arbitral Tribunal to pass
an interim award of Rs. 117,97,18,006/- on the ground that the said amount
required no finding of fact. This was partly allowed and the Arbitral Tribunal
awarded the respondent/claimant Rs. 75 Crore by the award dated
27.07.2021. This award was subjected to Section 33 proceedings whereby the
respondent/claimant sought an additional award which however was rejected
by the Tribunal by order dated 21.12.2021.
15.
The Arbitral Tribunal after the culmination of the earlier proceedings
as it proceeded to frame issues for trial and evidence had then framed the
above noted issue which encompassed the entire Claim No.1 of the
respondent/claimant which indisputably had already been partly allowed by
way of the interim award dated 27.07.2021. In this backdrop, it would
therefore be necessary to examine the operative portions of the award dated
27.07.2021 and the order dated 21.12.2021 rejecting the Section 33
application, to ascertain as to whether the Arbitral Tribunal was correct in
framing the issue of Claim No.1 as has been done in the impugned order.
Paragraph Nos. 101, 102 and 103 of the award dated 27.07.2021, which are
relevant are quoted hereinbelow:
“101.
Accordingly, we partly allow the present
application under section 31(6) of the Act filed by the
claimant. However before passing order on the amount,
it is noted that DRB 1 decided that the amounts be paid
on calculation of interest on the basis of 12% per
annum. Various calculations made by the claimant are
mainly on simple interest basis (as reflected in its
submissions before DRB 1), though at some places
interest on interest is also calculated. It is strange to note
that during pleadings, Ld. Counsel for the Claimant
tried to justify the monthly compounding. It is not
certified by the claimant that calculations have been
made on the basis of simple interest and at no point there
is interest on interest. It has been observed that the
calculations are not exactly the way, these should have
been done. For example, while calculating simple
interest from a date xyz to the present, in calculations
another date stu has been taken. Interest has been
calculated from xyz to stu and then this amount has been
added to the principal which cannot be done in doing
calculations for simple interest.
102.
Further it is noticed that in every case the
delay has been taken from the date of submission of bill,
while the initial date shall be one when the claimant has
submitted all the papers and the bill is accepted for
payment. It also needs to be mentioned that the claimant
got some initial amount as advance and therefore effect
of clause 51.3 of the conditions of contract may also be
kept in view.
103.
In the circumstances mentioned above, the
Tribunal decides to award a sum of Rs. 75 Crore to the
claimant pending the detailed certified calculations.
This amount is the one which is mentioned before the
DRB 1 and also gets mentioned in the correspondence
exchanged between the claimant, respondent and the
MoRTH. The Tribunal, however, is not accepting the
calculations as such and wants to give a chance to the
Respondent to come with its own figures if they have
any. For the present, the Tribunal is deciding an amount
less than the amount which is expected to come out of
calculations. The Respondent is directed to make
payment of the aforesaid interim award within 3 months
from today to the claimant. The interest of 12% per
annum will continue to accrue.”
Subsequently, while dismissing the Section 33 application vide order
dated 21.12.2021 the Arbitral Tribunal had held at paras 15 to 21 as follows:
“15. The Arbitral Tribunal observes that section
33(1)(a) of the Act empowers the Tribunal “to correct in
the award any errors of computation, any clerical or
typographical errors or any errors of similar nature”
16. The Arbitral Tribunal also observes that the
Claimant is not talking of any computational, clerical or
typographical error in its application dated 16.08.2021.
17. Thus, the entire case of the Claimant is based on
the stand that the clarifications sought and additional
award requested lies within the four walls of the words
“any errors of similar nature”.
18. The Arbitral Tribunal observes that any
additional award can only be made under Section 33(4)
of the Act and there is no application under this Act.
Further it is erroneous for the Claimant to infer that the
Interim Award is relating to one issue. The Tribunal
observes that this is erroneous reading of the Interim
Award. The plain reading of the Interim Award makes it
clear that the Tribunal has considered all the claims and
has reached a figure which need not be confused with
any other figure. Thus, the Arbitral Tribunal is of the
clear finding that no additional award or clarification as
sought by the Claimant is made out.
19. As regards clarification/modification of paras
101, 103 and 104, the Tribunal is of the considered view
that the reliefs sought cannot be treated as “errors of
similar nature”. Any relief granted here will go into the
realm of substantive review. The Arbitral Tribunal
observes that there is no mistake or error and therefore,
no correction is needed.
20. Further, the Arbitral Tribunal takes note of the
recent decision of the Supreme Court announced on
22.11.2021 in the case Gyan Prakash Arya vs. Titan
Industries, 2021 SCC Online SC 1100. The relevant para
is reproduced as follows:
“The original award was passed
considering the claim made by the claimant as per
its original claim and as per the statement of the
claim made and therefore subsequently allowing
the application under Section 33 of the 1996 Act
to modify the original award in exercise of powers
under Section 33 of the 1996 Act is not
sustainable. Only in a case of arithmetical and/or
clerical error, the award can be modified and such
errors only can be corrected. In the present case,
it cannot be said that there was any arithmetical
and/or clerical error in the original award passed
by the learned arbitrator. What was claimed by the
original claimant in the statement of claim was
awarded. Therefore, the order passed by the
learned arbitrator on an application filed under
Section 33 of the 1996 Act and thereafter
modifying the original award cannot be sustained.
The order passed by the learned arbitrator in the
application under Section 33 of the 1996 Act is
beyond the scope and ambit of Section 33 of the
1996 Act.”
21. In view of the above decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, the Arbitral Tribunal is of the
considered view that the claimant has completely failed
to
make
out
any
case
for
giving
clarifications/modifications/additional award under
Section 33(1)(a) of the Act and the application filed by
them is dismissed.”
16.
A perusal of the award dated 27.07.2021 (relevant portion quoted
above), no doubt alludes to the fact that Claim No. 1 cannot be said to have
been finally and conclusively adjudicated, inasmuch as, the component
regarding the calculation of interest was not accepted and the sum of Rs. 75
Crore was awarded pending other detailed certified calculations. However,
the order dated 21.12.2021 on the Section 33 application, the paragraphs
quoted above indicate otherwise especially para 18. It is also to be noted that
the order dated 27.07.2021 at para 1(a) notes the fact that an interim award
was prayed for payment of Rs. 117,97,18,006/- which is the entire amount of
Claim No.1 in the application under Section 31(6). A perusal of the
respondent/claimant’s application which was made under Section 33 also
reinforces this position since the respondent/claimant at paras 3.1.3, 3.3.5 and
3.3.7 of the said application has firstly acknowledged that the award since it
had been passed under Section 31(6) had become final on a specific issue
adjudicated therein and further was seeking an additional award relating to
the balance of the claims.
17.
Taking into account these circumstances and the other attendant facts,
it is clearly apparent that the proceedings before the Arbitral Tribunal have
become locked in a procedural wrangle between the parties. This observation
is made in view of the following facts. Firstly, an award interim or otherwise,
as per Section 35 and 36 of the Act is final and binding and enforceable as a
decree. Secondly, the said award dated 27.07.2021 has already been put to
challenge by Section 34 proceedings before the Commercial Court by the
petitioner and the same is pending adjudication. A second award on the same
claim on subsequent adjudication would therefore in the event the Section 34
application is allowed, create a situation wherein the respondent/claimant
would be in possession of another decree in its favour on the same claim.
Thirdly, the only remedy against the rejection of the application under Section
33 would necessarily be by preferring a petition under Section 34(3).
Fourthly, if a part of the claim had been admitted, request to make an
additional arbitral award on such claims have to be proceeded with under
Section 33(4) of the Act.
18.
The Arbitral Tribunal by framing the issue on Claim No.1, which
included the entire claim of the respondent/claimant after the rejection of the
Section 33 application has certainly given rise to disputed questions. This is
also evidenced by the fact that the respondent/claimant themselves noticing
this patent defect even after the instant civil revision application had been
filed before this Court, on 08.04.2022 by way of an application, had prayed
for re-casting and re-drafting of the issue No.1 before the Arbitral Tribunal
with the following prayer:
“In the premises as aforesaid, it is prayed that the
Arbitral Tribunal may be pleased to:
a.
b.
c.
Re-cast issue no. (i) in terms of para 103 of
the Interim Award dated 27.07.2021;
Issue an order of clarification with respect
to Issue no.(i) as it was framed vide order
dated 14.02.2022; and
Pass any order as it may deem fit.
It is prayed accordingly.”
19.
Though as contended by the respondents that the framing of issues is
not mandatory, once an Arbitral Tribunal has resorted to the same, it is
expected that the issues framed should be clear and concise as to the claims,
to allow the parties to tender evidence and make submissions on the said
issues which will be of useful assistance in the conduct of the proceedings. It
is not a question of rights or a cause of action being vested on any party, but
can simply be seen as an aid to speedy and efficient arbitral proceedings.
What has been occasioned in the present case it appears is that, the Arbitral
Tribunal seems to have disregarded the earlier proceedings that is the passing
of the interim award dated 27.07.2021 and the rejection of the Section 33
application dated 21.12.2021, and by framing the issue No.1 on the entire
Claim
No.1,
has
effectively
rewound
the
matter
back
to
the
respondent/claimant’s original claim of Rs.117,97,18,006/- which in the view
of this Court is impermissible, as the Arbitral Tribunal has become functus
officio as far as in respect of the issues adjudicated upon in the award dated
27.07.2021.
20.
The issue that therefore has to be determined is whether the Arbitral
Tribunal patently lacked inherent jurisdiction in framing issue No.1 on Claim
No. 1. It is an admitted position that on Claim No.1, Rs.75 Crores had been
awarded to the respondent/claimant which is final on the specific matters
adjudicated upon. Though it has been argued by the respondent/claimant that
the remaining portion of the Claim No.1 is still up for further adjudication,
and conversely by the petitioner that the award covers the entire claim, the
framing of the issue as it stands leaves little room for doubt that the Arbitral
Tribunal in framing the said issue, lacked inherent jurisdiction in law and fact,
since as noted in the preceding paragraph, the issue covers the entire claim of
Rs.117,97,18,006/-. As mentioned earlier, the respondent on seeing this
irregularity, had also sought recasting of Issue No. 1 by a petition dated
08.04.2022, in spite of the fact that the matter was already before this Court,
which only reinforces the stand taken by the petitioners as to the illegality
committed by the Arbitral Tribunal.
21.
The policy of minimum judicial intervention as provided under Section
5 of the Act is always uppermost in the minds of the Courts while exercising
powers under Article 226 and 227 in matters concerning arbitration
proceedings. However, situations and circumstances that have arisen in the
instant matter where recourse to Section 37 of the Act is unavailable, or for
that matter Section 16(5) also would not yield any remedy to correct the
proceedings, as a decision rejecting a plea under Section 16(5) can only be
challenged with the final award, the petitioner cannot be faulted for seeking
remedy under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
22.
It is noted that the piecemeal adjudication that has been resorted to has
resulted in the arbitration proceedings being delayed which does not augur
well in such proceedings where time is the essence. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of IFFCO vs. Bhadra Products (2018) 2 SCC 534 with
regard to interim awards and piecemeal adjudication had observed in
paragraphs 7 and 8 as follows:
“7. As can be seen from Section 2(c) and
Section 31(6), except for stating that an arbitral award
includes an interim award, the Act is silent and does not
define what an interim award is. We are, therefore, left
with Section 31(6) which delineates the scope of interim
arbitral awards and states that the Arbitral Tribunal may
make an interim arbitral award on any matter with
respect to which it may make a final arbitral award.
8.
The language of Section 31(6) is advisedly
wide in nature. A reading of the said sub-section makes
it clear that the jurisdiction to make an interim arbitral
award is left to the good sense of the Arbitral Tribunal,
and that it extends to “any matter” with respect to which
it may make a final arbitral award. The expression
“matter” is wide in nature, and subsumes issues at
which the parties are in dispute. It is clear, therefore,
that any point of dispute between the parties which has
to be answered by the Arbitral Tribunal can be the
subject-matter of an interim arbitral award. However, it
is important to add a note of caution. In an appropriate
case, the issue of more than one award may be
necessitated on the facts of that case. However, by
dealing with the matter in a piecemeal fashion, what
must be borne in mind is that the resolution of the
dispute as a whole will be delayed and parties will be put
to additional expense. The Arbitral Tribunal should,
therefore, consider whether there is any real advantage
in delivering interim awards or in proceeding with the
matter as a whole and delivering one final award,
bearing in mind the avoidance of delay and additional
expense. Ultimately, a fair means for resolution of all
disputes should be uppermost in the mind of the Arbitral
Tribunal.”
(Emphasis supplied)
23.
Considering the sequence of events, that is the award dated 27.07.2021,
the Section 33 rejection order dated 21.12.2021 and lastly the impugned order
dated 14.02.2022, though intervention of Courts in arbitration proceedings by
invocation of Article 227 is to be limited to exceptional circumstances, the
instant case at hand in the considered view of this Court has given rise to such
circumstances. This Court in the earlier round of litigation [CRP. No. 2 of
2022 M/s. BSC-C AND CJV vs. The Chief Engineer (PWD)] by order dated
11.02.2022, had dwelt at length on the scope of exercise of powers under
Article 227 while granting relief to the Respondent herein. However, it is
constrained to hold that the same considerations of exceptional circumstances
still hold good in the adjudication of the instant matter, which also will
warrant interference in exercise of powers under Article 227 of the
Constitution.
24.
Accordingly, after careful consideration of the entire facts and
circumstances of the case, it is hereby held that the Arbitral Tribunal patently
lacked inherent jurisdiction, in framing issue No.1 on the entire Claim No.1
on which an interim award had already been pronounced on 27.07.2021. As
such, issue No.1 as appearing in the impugned order dated 14.02.2022 is set
aside and quashed. The Arbitral Tribunal is to proceed on the other issues and
claims as indicated in the order dated 14.02.2022.
25. This petition is accordingly allowed and disposed of.
26. No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
09.05.2022
“Samantha-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review