Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P (S) No.497 of 2026
with
W.P (S) No.6953 of 2025
----1. The Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited Through Chief Managing Director,
Jan Path, P.O. Jan Path, P.S. Parliament Stret Police Station, District New Delhi-110001.
2. The Chief General Manager, Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited, Jharkhand
Circle, Arttc Building, P.O. Neori (Vikash), P.S. Khel Gaon, District
Ranchi-835217.
3. The General Manager (Hr), Office of The Chief General Manager,
Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited, Jharkhand Circle, Arttc Building, P.O.
Neori (Vikash), P.S. Khel Gaon, District -Ranchi-835217.
4. The General Manager, Telecom District, Bharat Sanchar Nigam
Limited, Dhanbad, P.O. P.S. District - Dhanbad-826101 (Jharkhand).
The petitioners are represented through Sushil Kumar, Son of Late
Ramchandra Prasad, Aged about 50 years, AGM (Establishment) in the
Office of Chief General Manager. Jharkhand Telecom Circle, Arttc
Building. P.O. Neori (Vikash), P.S. Khel Gaon, District -Ranchi-835217.
....... …
Petitioners
(in both the cases)
Versus
1. Shyam Bihari Son of Sri Mahabir Prasad Yadav, Assistant Telecom
Technician Office of Sub Divisional Engineer, Hasdiha, Bharat Sanchar
Nigam Limited, Dumka, Resident of Village - Tiebaris P.O. Munger P.S.
Haveli Kharagpur, District - Munger-811213 (Bihar).
2. Kamlesh Kant Yadav Son of Sri R.P. Yadav, Assistant Telecom
Technician, Sarath, Office of Sub Divisional Engineer, Bharat Sanchar
Nigam Limited, Madhupur, Resident of Village P.O. Pasopur, P.S. Sadar
Police station District - Darbhanga-847306 (Bihar).
3. Indra Deo Yadav Son of Sri Bengali Prasad Yadav, Assistant Telecom
Technician, Amrapara, Office of Sub Divisional Engineer, Pakur, Bharat
Sanchar Nigam Limited, Dumka Resident of Village Dhaba, P.O/P.S. Khesar District - Banka-813207 (Bihar).
4. Radhey Shyam Yadav Son of Late Sukhdeo Yadav, Assistant Telecom
Technician, Office of Sub Divisional Engineer, Bharat Sanchar Nigam
Limited, Jamtara, Resident of Village Pokharia P.O/P.S. Haveli
Kharagpur District-Munger-811213 (Bihar).
5. Raj Kumar Yadav Son of Sri Rameshwar Prasad Yadav, Assistant
Telecom Technician, Pathargaon, Office of Sub Divisional Engineer,
Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited, Godda, Resident of Village P.S. / P.O.
- Harpur, District-Munger-813221 (Bihar).
6. Abhay Shankar Jha Son of Sri Sita Ram Jha, Telecom Technician,
Office of Sub Divisional Engineer, Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited,
Madhupur, Resident of Village / P.O. Pindaruch, P.S. Kamtaul DistrictDarbhanga-847306 (Bihar).
7. Bhola Choudhary Son of Late Arjun Choudhary, Assistant Telecom
Technician, Rajmahal Office of Sub Divisional Engineer, Bharat Sanchar
Nigam Limited, Sahebganj, Resident of Village Dharhar, PO P.S.Laheriasari, District- Darhbhanga-846001 (Bihar).
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
8. Lal Bau Choudhary Son of Sri Bimal Choudhary, Assistant Telecom
Technician, Kathikund, Office of Sub Divisional Engineer, Bharat
Sanchar Nigam Limited, Dumka Resident of Village P.S./P.O. Pindaruch,
P.S. Kamtaul, District-Darbhanga-847306 (Bihar).
9. Mohan Choudhary Son of Late Baleshway Choudhary, Telecom
Technician, Mihijam, Office of Sub Divisional Engineer, Bharat Sanchar
Nigam Limited, Jamtara, Resident of Village - Chahuta, P.S./P.O Bisfi
District - Madhubani-847304 (Bihar).
10. Arun Kumar Son of Late Ganak Rai, Assistant Telecom Technician,
Mahgaon, Office of Sub Divisional Engineer, Bharat Sanchar Nigam
Limited, Godda, Resident of Village GangpurAsthghar,P.O/P.S.
Athmalgola, District Patna-803211 (Bihar).
11. Dilip Kumar Son of Late Kasim Sah, Assistant Telecom Technician,
Office of Sub Divisional Engineer, Bharat Sanchar PO Nigam Limited,
Godda Resident of Village - Dilawarpur, P.O./P.S. Bihta, District - Patna801103 (Bihar).
… …
Respondents
(in both the cases)
------CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUJIT NARAYAN PRASAD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN KUMAR RAI
------For the Petitioners : Mr. Prabhat Kumar Sinha, Advocate
Mr. Mayank Mridul, Advocate
For the Respondents : ………………
-----th
Order No.03/Dated:5 February, 2026
Per, Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.
1. Both the writ petitions are taken up together for hearing as these are
preferred against the common order passed by the learned Central
Administrative Tribunal, Patna Bench, Patna (Circuit Bench at
Ranchi).
2. The common order dated 19.08.2025 passed in O.A No.
OA/050/00151/2021 and O.A No. OA/050/00306/2021 is under
challenge in W.P(S) No.6953 of 2025 and W.P(S) No.497 of 2026
respectively.
3. The following prayers have been made in these writ petitions:
In W.P(S) No.6953 of 2025:
“That by the instant writ petition petitioners pray for issuance
of a writ of or in the nature of certiorari for quashing of
order/Judgment passed in dated 19.08.2025 OA/ 050/ 00151/
2021 by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Patna Bench,
Patna (Circuit Bench at Ranchi); whereby and whereunder
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
Original Application filed by the respondents has been allowed
and learned tribunal has been pleased to quash and set aside
order dated 25.02.2021 by which Petitioners herein have
decided to review the TDM Dumka Order dated 09.03.1998 on
the ground of collusion, forgery, malafides, conspiracy & fraud
etc. and also petitioners herein was directed to grant all
consequential benefits to the respondents herein/applicants to
the OA as per the rules within a period of 3 months from the
date of the order which is absolutely perverse both on law and
facts.
And/Or
Issue such other writ(s) /order(S)/Rule(s)/Direction(S) as your
lordships may deem fit and proper in the facts and
circumstances of the instant case for doing substantial justice to
the Petitioners.”
In W.P(S) No.497 of 2026:
“That by the instant writ petition petitioners pray for issuance
of a writ of or in the nature of certiorari for quashing of
order/Judgment
dated
19.08.2025
passed
in
OA/050/00306/2021 by the Central Administrative Tribunal,
Patna Bench, Patna (Circuit Bench at Ranchi); whereby and
whereunder Original Application filed by the respondents has
been allowed and learned tribunal has been pleased to quash
and set aside order dated 04.09.2021 by which the applicants of
the OA/050/00306/2021 / respondents herein have been
directed to appear before review DPC on 22.09.2021 and also
petitioners herein was directed to grant all consequential
benefits to the respondents herein/applicants to the OA as per
the rules within a period of 3 months from the date of the order
which is absolutely perverse both on law and facts.
And/Or
Issue such other writ(s) /order(S)/Rule(s)/Direction(S) as your
lordships may deem fit and proper in the facts and
circumstances of the instant case for doing substantial justice to
the Petitioners.”
4. Since both these writ petitions have been preferred against the common
order and further similar issue has to be adjudicated in these writ
petitions, therefore, this Court is delving upon the factual aspect of the
W.P(S) No.6953 of 2025 taking it as lead case.
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
5. The brief facts of the case as per the pleadings made in the writ
petitions which are enumerated from the pleadings of the Original
Applications reads as under:
(i)
The applicants (respondents herein) have been initially
appointed a Casual Labour in between 1985 to 1988 and
they were granted Temporary Status with effect from
09.03.1998 as per the directive of Hon'ble Supreme Court
of India as referred in the same Office Order in which the
name of the applicants find place.
(ii)
While the applicants were working under Department, the
Respondents (Petitioner herein) have issued order dated
20.01.1999 whereby the said order dated 09.03.1998
whereby temporary status was granted, has been kept in
abeyance without any rhyme and reason.
(iii)
Thereafter the applicants have filed one Original
Application being Original Application No.144 of 1999
challenging the said order dated 20.01.1999 which was
allowed on 29.11.2001 whereby the said Order dated
20.01.1999 cancelling / keeping in abeyance the temporary
Status granted to the Applicants has been set aside and the
Respondents have been directed to reinstate the Applicants
with liberty to enquire into the allegations of submitting
forged certificates after giving appropriate opportunity to
participate in the Enquiry and to take appropriate action in
the light of Enquiry Report in accordance with law and in
compliance thereof, the Applicants have been reinstated in
service and subsequently the Respondents have issued one
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
Letter dated 07.01.2002 directing the Applicants to submit
their work diary and accordingly the Applicants have
submitted their Work Diary on 16.01.2002 under clear
receipt and thereafter they were reinstated in the service
vide Order
dated
25.01.2002
and
thereafter
the
Respondents have conducted verification with their Work
Diary which were found correct and genuine which can be
seen from their Letter dated 08.07.2002.
(iv)
That it is further relevant to submit and state here that the
Respondents
herein
have
thereafter
constituted
Departmental Screening Committee (DPC) who met on
30.04.2002 and recommended for eventual regularization
and in compliance thereto the Respondents have issued
Office Order dated 11.07.2002 whereby and whereunder
the Applicants have been regularized as Regular Majdoor
i.e. against Group-"D" Post with effect from 06.02.2002
unconditionally in which the name of Applicants finds
place.
(v)
That it is very relevant to submit here that in spite of the
proper verification of documents and regularization order
as referred to above, the Chief General Manager, BSNL,
Jharkhand Circle has issued one Letter dated 31.12.2001
to TDM, Dumka to constitute one Enquiry Committee to
enquire about the truth with respect to the Genuineness of
the initial appointment of Applicants as casual labour in
compliance to the order dated 29.11.2001 and thereafter
the TDM, Dumka has constituted Three Men Committee
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
who conducted detailed enquiry in the matter and
submitted their Report holding that "Thus it is proved from
the above fact and finding that the appointment of all 12
TSMs cannot be categorized as false appointment.
Followed by the finding of enquiry committee report
Departmental Promotion Committee was constituted on
comprising of Sri R. Sahu, TDM, Dumka cum-Chairman,
Sri M. Singh, DE (P) Deoghar, Member and Sri P.P. Sah,
DE (A&P) 0/0 TDM, Dumka, Member. The DPC
scrutinized the relevant records of all the 12 TSMs and
recommended to be regularized as RM with effect from
06.02.2002. Based on the Enquiry Committee report all the
TSMs were informed vide DE (A&P) 0/0 TDM, Dumka
Letter No. E-71/ CAT Judgment Order / Pat/2001-02/16 to
27 dated 08.07.2002 for record verification. Further Shri
P.P. Sah, DE (A&P)-officials were regularized against
vacant posts w.e.f. 06.02.2002."
(vi)
After a lapse of 03 years, the Respondents have constituted
another Committee for making enquiry on the same issue
as per the said Order passed in the said Original
Application No. 144 of 1999. It is stated that the Chairman
of the new Committee has issued one Letter dated
15.10.2005 directing the Applicants to furnish required
papers and in compliance thereto the Applicants have
appeared before the said Committee on 28.10.2005 with
required papers which can be seen from the proceeding
dated 28.10.2005 signed by the Members. It is stated that
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
thereafter the Competent Authority i.e. CGMT has issued
direction for closing the enquiry and in compliance there
to, the TDM, Dumka has stopped the Enquiry on
02.03.2006.
(vii) The Applicants while working continuously since the date
of their eventual regularization up to 2010, they were
deprived of their due promotions to the post of Telephone
Mechanic whereas their juniors have been granted with the
said promotional benefit which compel them to file various
Original Applications for redressal of their grievances vide
Original Application No. 838 of 2010, Original
Application No. 347 of 2012, Original Application No.
783 of 2013, Original Application No. 157 of 2013,
Original Application No. 158 of 2013, Original
Application No. 71 of 2014 and Original Application No.
226 of 2014 which were allowed on 24.03.2015,
06.05.2015 and 08.01.2015 respectively in which it has
been held that the Temporary Status granted to the
Applicants vide Order dated 09.03.1998, regularization of
applicants against Group-"D" Posts vide Order dated
11.07.2002 are quite legal and the Applicants are entitled
to get the promotion to the post of Telephone Mechanic
from the date of their juniors.
(viii) In spite of the said orders the Respondents on some pretext
or the other, did not implemented the said Orders, then the
Applicants have filed Contempt Case No.31 and 32 of
2015 in which Order of personal appearance was issued.
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
(ix)
Thereafter, respondents have issued order of termination
on 28.05.2015 on the same ground of procuring
employment on the basis of forged casual labour working
certificate against which the Applicants have filed cases
vide Original Application No.424 of 2015 and OA 430 of
2015 in which vide order dated 09.06.2015 the termination
Order was stayed. Thereafter the respondents have filed
Writ Petition before the Hon'ble Patna High Court vide
CWJC No. 11211 of 2015 against the said interim Order
dated 09.06.2015 where their Writ Petition has been
dismissed on 27.08.2015 and thereafter the Respondents
have cancelled the said termination order dated
09.06.2015.
(x)
Thereafter on the same facts and allegation respondents
have issued Charge Memorandum dated 29.12.2016 after
more than 25 years from the date of the appointment then
the Applicants had filed Original Application No.
051/00335 of 2017 and Original Application No.
051/00132 of 2017.
(xi)
After hearing the parties, the Original Application No.
051/00335 of 2017 was allowed on 01.08.2017 and the
said Charge Memorandum dated 29.12.2016 was quashed
against which the Respondents preferred writ petition
before Hon'ble High Court, Jharkhand vide W.P(s).
No.5032 of 2017 wherein Judgement / Order passed by in
said Original Application No.051/00335 of 2017 was
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
upheld as evident from Order paragraph No.20 of the
Order dated 17.01.2018.
(xii) The Respondents being aggrieved with the said order of
High Court of Jharkhand, preferred Special Leave to
petition (Civil) No.29396 of 2018 before the Hon'ble
Supreme Court of India but the same has also been
dismissed on 02.11.2018.
(xiii) Similar to the above on 11.04.2018 in Original Application
No.051/00132 of 2017 order was passed in which direction
was
passed
to
the
Respondents
to
conduct
a
comprehensive Enquiry and initiate action against the
Senior Officials guilty of omission and commission which
has perpetuated the alleged fraud.
(xiv) The Respondents were granted mandatory six months’
time for doing the same and till such action and
punishment imposed against the Senior Officers and in the
meanwhile the said Charge Sheet dated 29.12.2016 has
been kept in abeyance with further direction that if
aforesaid Enquiry and follow-up action is not taken against
Senior
Officials
within
six
months
the
Charge
Memorandum dated 29.12.2016 is deemed to be quashed
and set aside.
(xv) It is stated that the Enquiry against the Senior Officers has
not been concluded within six months against Senior
Officials, but the Respondents after expiry of six months
period, filed one Miscellaneous Application No. 477 of
2018 for extension of time beyond six months to conclude
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
the inquiry against the Senior Officials but since six
months' time has already been expired, the said
Application was dismissed.
(xvi) In the meanwhile, respondents have implemented the order
passed in OA 157 of 2013, OA 158 of 2013 and OA 71 of
2014 on 12.12.2018 whereby applicants have been granted
the benefits of Promotion under NEPP, Presidential Order
and promotion as TM.
(xvii) Thereafter, respondents lodged one First Information
Report on 14.02.2019 registered on 08.03.2019 being
Deoghar P. S. Case No. 94 of 2019 under Sections 409,
420, 467, 468, 471 & 120(B) of the Indian Penal Code for
the same allegation of procuring appointment on forged
Working Certificate in which the Applicants moved before
the learned Sessions Judge, Deoghar wherein they have
been granted protection which was subsequently recalled
on 22.05.2019.
(xviii) Thereafter the Respondents have placed the Applicants
under suspension vide Order dated 24.05.2019 on the basis
of their said First Information Report and recalling of the
protection Order by the learned Sessions Judge, Deoghar.
After
receipt of the suspension Order some of the
Applicants have submitted Representation before the
Respondents for revocation of the suspension Order but
they have been suggested to first get bail and then move
application for revocation of suspension Order and that
being the reason the Applicants moved before the Hon'ble
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
Jharkhand High Court for grant of their anticipatory bail
vide A.B.A. No. 3691 of 2019 and Α.Β.Α. Νο.3690 of
2019 in which after perusal of the Orders so passed by the
Division Bench of this High Court in W.P.(S) No. 5032 of
2017 upheld by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India vide
S.L.P.(C) No. 29396 of 2018, has granted anticipatory bail
to the Applicants vide Orders dated 26.06.2019.
(xix) After
grant of anticipatory bail, the Applicants have
submitted Representation on 29.06.2019, 01.07.2019
09.07.2019 followed by the Reminders before the
Respondents for revocation of suspension Order and only
on 28.10.2020, said suspension Order has been revoked
but no arrears have been paid. Thereafter, respondents
have commenced enquiry proceeding against some of the
applicants on the basis of same charge sheet dated
29.12.2016 against which OA No.58 of 2019 has been filed
and interim order was granted on 16.01.2019 and finally
said OA has been allowed on 22.01.2020.
(xx) Thereafter, the respondents had issued orders dated
03.03.2020 whereby they have decided to administrative
review of the order dated 09.03.1998 and applicants have
submitted their reply and also demanded legible copies but
the same has not been supplied.
(xxi) In the meanwhile, respondents have issued another order
dated 25.02.2021 calling the applicants on 03.03.2021 for
administrative review of the order dated 09.03.1998.
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
(xxii) Hence the Applicants have got no efficacious remedy they
had moved before the learned tribunal for redressal of their
grievances by way of filing Application being O.A. No.
OA/050/00151/2021.
(xxiii) The applicants had taken ground before the learned
tribunal that after conducting Enquiry and verification of
records, the services of the Applicants have been
regularized unconditionally vide said order dated
11.07.2002
hence
any
question
concerning
the
appointment of the Applicants on the same basis cannot be
questioned by the Respondents.
(xxiv) The learned tribunal vide order dated 19.08.2025 after
hearing both the parties has allowed the said application
i.e. O.A. No. OA/050/00151/2021 and has quashed and
set-aside the order dated 25.02.2021 by which the
applicants were called on 03.03.2021 for administrative
review of the order dated 09.03.1998.
(xxv) Against the order dated 19.08.2025 the present writ
petition has been filed.
6.
It is evident from the factual aspect that altogether eleven
employees who had been taken in the service, initially as a daily rated
capacity, but subsequently they were regularized. Subsequent to the order
of regularization, the respondent-authority, the writ petitioners herein, had
decided to initiate a departmental proceeding against the appointees who
have been regularized on the ground of commission of fraud. The memo
of charge was issued against all the eleven employees who have been
regularized. The five applicants, who are the respondents in the W.P(S)
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
No.6953 of 2025 have approached the learned Tribunal challenging the
memorandum of charge by filing Original Application being O.A
No.051/00335/2017.
7.
Another set of employees, six in numbers, have preferred another
Original Application being O.A No. OA/051/00132/2017.
8.
The learned Tribunal has disposed of the Original Application
being O.A No.051/00335/2017 by quashing the Charge Memo dated
29.12.2016 issued by the respondent having been instituted against the
applicants of the said case. The said order dated 01.08.2017 passed in O.A
No.051/00335/2017 had been carried by challenging the same by filing
the writ petition being W.P(S) No.5032 of 2017 which was dismissed vide
order dated 17.01.2018 passed by a co-ordinate Division Bench of this
Court declining to interfered with the order dated 01.08.2017.
9.
The writ petitioner-BSNL has challenged the said order dated
17.01.2018 passed in W.P(S) No.5032 of 2017 by filing a Special Leave
to Appeal being Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No(s):29396 of 2018
which has been dismissed by the Hon’ble Apex Court vide order dated
02.11.2018.
10.
Subsequent to the aforesaid Original Application being O.A No.
OA/051/00132/2017 preferred by six identically placed co-employees,
who were the applicants in the said Original Application, the order was
passed on 11.04.2018 and while disposing of the said Original
Application the following order was passed by the learned Tribunal, for
ready reference, the relevant paragraph-23 is being quoted hereunder:
23. Accordingly, the OA is disposed of with the following
directions:
(i) The respondents shall be at liberty to conduct a comprehensive
enquiry and initiate action against the senior officials guilty of
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
omission and commission which has perpetuated this alleged
fraud. They shall do so within six months of receipt of a copy of this
order.
(ii) Till such time as the aforesaid enquiry as mentioned in para 23
of sub-para (i) is completed and action initiated, the charge memo
dated 29.12.2015 (Annexure-A/25 series) shall be kept in
abeyance. If the aforesaid enquiry and follow up action is not taken
within six months of receipt of a copy of this order, the charge
memo dated 29.12.2016 shall be deemed to be quashed and set
aside.
11.
The order dated 11.04.2018 has not been assailed even Higher
Forum as has been submitted by the learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners. It is the case of the writ petitioners that in pursuance to the
liberty so granted by the learned Tribunal vide order dated 11.04.2018
passed in O.A No. OA/051/00132/2017 an inquiry was directed to be
conducted. The fact finding has been arrived and the writ petitioners have
taken a decision to forward the said report to the Central Bureau of
Investigation (in short-CBI) for institution of an FIR but the CBI has
refused to institute the FIR and has returned the entire file to the writ
petitioner for taking action on its end. The writ petitioner has again taken
decision to institute an FIR and accordingly one FIR has been instituted
being Deoghar Town P.S Case No.94 of 2019 which is still pending before
the competent Court of criminal jurisdiction.
12.
The writ petitioners in the meanwhile, has come out with the
impugned notice 25.02.2021 and 04.09.2021 issued to all the applicants
who were the applicants in O.A No. 051/00335/2017 and O.A No. OA/
051/00132 /2017.
13.
The said notices have been challenged by filing two sets of
Original Applications being O.A No. OA/050/00151/2021 and O.A No.
OA/050/00306/2021.
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
14.
The learned Tribunal vide order dated 19.08.2025 has quashed
the impugned notice dated 25.02.2021 and 04.09.2021 with a direction to
grant all consequential benefits to the applicants as per the rule within a
period of three months from the date of the order.
15.
The said order 19.08.2025 is challenged herein.
Submission of the learned counsel appearing for the writ petitionerBSNL:
16.
Mr. Prabhat Kumar Sinha, the learned counsel appearing for the
writ petitioner-BSNL has submitted that the learned Tribunal while
allowing the Original Applications has not been considered the fact that
the element of fraud has been found in course of inquiry which has been
conducted in compliance to the order dated 11.04.2018 passed in O.A
No. OA/051/00132/2017.
17.
It has been contended that in such a serious irregularity which
has been surfaced in course of inquiry, that too, by virtue of the liberty
granted vide order dated 17.01.2018 passed in WP(S) No.5032 of 2017
which cannot be said to be in the garb of administrative review rather
whatever power of the administrative review has been exercised, i.e., in
pursuance to the order passed by the learned Tribunal as per the direction
passed in paragraph-23 passed in O.A No. OA/051/00132/2017.
18.
The ground has been taken that even in the admitted facts and
circumstances, the memorandum of charge, even though common, has
been quashed and set aside by the learned Tribunal in the litigation
preferred by one set of the employees as per the order dated 01.08.2017
passed in O.A No.051/00335/2017 but the learned Tribunal since has
granted such liberty to go for the inquiry and, as such, the writ petitioner
if proceeded by conducting an inquiry, the same cannot be said to be
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
beyond jurisdiction and, hence, the order since has been passed on the
backdrop of the fact that the writ petitioner has issued the notice beyond
its jurisdiction is bad in the eyes of law.
19.
The learned counsel for the writ petitioner, based upon the
aforesaid grounds, has submitted that the order passed by the learned
Tribunal is, therefore, not sustainable and it is fit to be quashed and set
aside.
Analysis
20.
We have heard the learned counsel for the writ petitioner.
21.
The case has been taken up at this stage and a detailed hearing
has been given to the learned counsel appearing for the writ petitioner on
two dates, i.e., 04.02.2026 and today, i.e., 05.02.2026.
22.
This Court after having heard the learned counsel for the writ
petitioner on merit has proceeded to examine the factual aspects, vis-a vis,
the consequences of the order passed by the learned Tribunal on earlier
occasion.
23.
The learned Tribunal while passing the order impugned in these
two writ petitions, has given a finding on consideration of the issues as to
whether the respondent-BSNL, the writ petitioner herein, is competent to
conduct an administrative review of the matter once the judicial review
has been made over the decision of the administrative officials.
24.
This Court is to examine the consideration of the aforesaid issue
which has been answered against the writ petitioner by the learned
tribunal.
25.
So far power of this Court is concerned to exercise under Article
226 of the Constitution, which is to be exercised by the power of judicial
review, since, this Court is not exercising the original jurisdiction as
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
conferred as an extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, rather the power of judicial review is being
exercised against the order passed by the Court of law being a Court of
first instance as per the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
case of L. Chandra Kumar vs. Union of India and Ors., (1997) 3 SCC
261.
26.
The power which is to be exercised as per the position of law is
to look into the legality and propriety of the order passed by the learned
Tribunal only in a case error apparent on the face of the order or in a case
of perversity of finding in exercise of power conferred under the power of
judicial review as has been held by the Hon’ble Apex Court at paragraph99 in the aforesaid judgment. The said paragraph is being referred as
under:
“99. In view of the reasoning adopted by us, we hold that clause 2(d) of
Article 323-A and clause 3(d) of Article 323-B, to the extent they exclude
the jurisdiction of the High Courts and the Supreme Court under Articles
226/227 and 32 of the Constitution, are unconstitutional. Section 28 of the
Act and the “exclusion of jurisdiction” clauses in all other legislations
enacted under the aegis of Articles 323-A and 323-B would, to the same
extent, be unconstitutional. The jurisdiction conferred upon the High
Courts under Articles 226/227 and upon the Supreme Court under Article
32 of the Constitution is a part of the inviolable basic structure of our
Constitution. While this jurisdiction cannot be ousted, other courts and
Tribunals may perform a supplemental role in discharging the powers
conferred by Articles 226/227 and 32 of the Constitution. The Tribunals
created under Article 323-A and Article 323- B of the Constitution are
possessed of the competence to test the constitutional validity of statutory
provisions and rules. All decisions of these Tribunals will, however, be
subject to scrutiny before a Division Bench of the High Court within whose
jurisdiction the Tribunal concerned falls. The Tribunals will, nevertheless,
continue to act like courts of first instance in respect of the areas of law
for which they have been constituted. It will not, therefore, be open for
litigants to directly approach the High Courts even in cases where they
question the vires of statutory legislations (except where the legislation
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
which creates the particular Tribunal is challenged) by overlooking the
jurisdiction of the Tribunal concerned. Section 5(6) of the Act is valid and
constitutional and is to be interpreted in the manner we have indicated.
27.
The interpretation of the word “Judicial Review” is well settled
which can only be exercised if there is an error apparent on the face of the
order or the element of perversity is found to be there. The error apparent
on the face of the order means that if the order appears on its face having
with error, then only the power of judicial review is to be exercised.
28.
The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of West Bengal Central
School Service Commission vs. Abdul Halim, (2019) 18 SCC 39, has
held at paragraph-30 that the power of judicial review must be exercised
by the Court after determining that the impugned is vitiated by an error
apparent on the face of the record and not the same has been established
by a process of reasoning. Paragraph-30 of the aforesaid judgment is being
referred as under:
"30. In exercise of its power of judicial review, the Court is to see
whether the decision impugned is vitiated by an apparent error of law.
The test to determine whether a decision is vitiated by error apparent
on the face of the record is whether the error is self-evident on the face
of the record or whether the error requires examination or argument to
establish it. If an error has to be established by a process of reasoning,
on points where there may reasonably be two opinions, it cannot be said
to be an error on the face of the record, as held by this Court
in Satyanarayan Laxminarayan Hegde v. Millikarjun Bhavanappa
Tirumale
[Satyanarayan
Laxminarayan
Hegde v.
Millikarjun
Bhavanappa Tirumale, AIR 1960 SC 137] . ---."
29.
In the case of T.C. Basappa vs. T. Nagappa and Anr., (1955) 1
SCR 250, their Lordship have held that the patent error in a decision
can be corrected when it is manifested by the error apparent on the face
of the proceedings. The relevant portion of the aforesaid judgment is
quoted hereunder:
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
"11. ... An error in the decision or determination itself may also be
amenable to a writ of certiorari but it must be a manifest error apparent
on the face of the proceedings e.g. when it is based on clear ignorance or
disregard of the provisions of law. In other words, it is a patent error which
can be corrected by certiorari but not a mere wrong decision. ...."
30.
Thus, on the basis of the aforesaid settled legal position it is
evident that the power of judicial review can be exercised, if error on
the face of the order impugned, challenged under the Article 226 of
Constitution of India, appears to be there.
31.
We, since, are to consider the issue of administrative review and,
as such, thought it proper to refer the position of law in which
circumstances, the administrative authority is to exercise the power of
administrative review. Law is well settled that the power of review by the
administrative authority or the Court of Law except the Court having the
extra ordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
the power of review can only be exercised if provided under the Statute
otherwise the power of review cannot be exercised, particularly, for the
administrative authority such power is not available to be exercised unless
provide specifically in the Statute, reference in this regard is made to the
judgment rendered in the case of “Kalabharati Advertising vs. Hemant
Vimalnath Narichania & Ors”. reported in (2010) 9 SCC 437 wherein
it has been held by laying down the provision at paragraph-12 regarding
the proposition that the review in absence of statutory provision is not
available to be exercised, the relevant paragraph of the said judgment is
being quoted hereunder:
“12. It is settled legal proposition that unless the statute/rules so
permit, the review application is not maintainable in case of
judicial/quasi-judicial orders. In absence of any provision in the
Act granting an express power of review, it is manifest that a
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
review could not be made and the order in review, if passed is
ultra-vires, illegal and without jurisdiction.”
32.
Adverting to the factual aspect of the present case, it is admitted
case as per the material available on record and based upon that the
argument has been advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner-BSNL that the writ petitioner has decided to initiate a
departmental proceeding against the employees who have been
regularized by taking them in regular establishment of the writ petitionerBSNL. As per the writ petitioner, their regularization was nothing but a
fraud. Memorandum of charge has been issued against all the employees
who were the applicants before the learned Tribunal levelling therein the
allegation of fraud in getting the order of their regularization.
33.
The applicants/the employees, have preferred two Original
Applications, five of them have preferred O.A No.051/00335/2017 and
six were the applicants in O.A No.051/00132/2017. The learned Tribunal
has disposed of O.A No.051/00335/2017 by quashing and setting aside
the memorandum of charge, as would be evident from the operative part
which is being quoted hereinabove.
34.
The said order passed by the learned Tribunal in O.A
No.051/00335/2017 has been upheld by this Court vide order dated
17.01.2018 passed in W.P(S) No.5032 of 2017 against which the writ
petitioner-BSNL had preferred a Special Leave to Appeal being Special
Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No(s):29396 of 2018 which has been
dismissed by the Hon’ble Apex Court vide order dated 02.11.2018.
Therefore, the order passed so far as direction of quashing the
memorandum of charge passed in O.A No. 051/00335/2017 has attained
its finality.
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
35.
The learned Tribunal has taken note about the aforesaid fact,
which according to our considered view cannot be said to suffer from an
error, since, the quashing of the memorandum of charge issued against the
five employees who are the applicants in O.A No. 051/00335/2017 has
attained its finality after dismissal of Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary
No(s):29396 of 2018, since, the writ petitioner-BSNL has not chosen to
file review thereafter.
36.
However, in the second Original Application being O.A
No.051/00132/2017 a different direction was passed as available at
paragraph-23 thereof, which has been quoted hereinabove.
37.
It is, thus, evident from the order dated 11.04.2018 that the
learned Tribunal has kept the memorandum of charge in abeyance by
granting liberty to conduct a comprehensive enquiry and initiate action
against the “senior officials” guilty of omission and commission which
has perpetuated this alleged fraud to be completed within six months of
receipt of a copy of the order and till the order of six months the
memorandum of charge dated 29.12.2016 has been kept in abeyance.
38.
The question of conducting a comprehensive inquiry and
initiation of action and during the aforesaid period the memorandum of
charge dated 29.12.2016 was kept in abeyance was ought to have been
acted upon by the writ petitioner herein.
39.
It is admitted case of the writ petitioner that they have conducted
inquiry and certain irregularities have been found and, hence, the entire
inquiry report was forwarded to the CBI for further necessary action. It is
further admitted case of the writ petitioner that the CBI has decided not to
institute an FIR and again relegated the matter to the writ petitioner. The
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
writ petitioner thereafter has instituted FIR being Deoghar Town PS Case
No.94 of 2019.
40.
It has been brought to the notice of this Court by the learned
counsel appearing for the writ petitioner that the said criminal case is still
pending before the competent Court of criminal jurisdiction. The writ
petitioner,
thereafter,
has
again
issued
notice
upon
the
employees/applicants to participate in the inquiry which have been
challenged by filing two Original Applications being O.A No.
051/00335/2017 and O.A No.051/00132/2017.
41.
The learned Tribunal has quashed the notices with a direction to
release all consequential benefits, the proprietary of the said order is under
consideration in these two writ petitions.
42.
The fact which is not in dispute rather admitted by the learned
counsel for the writ petitioner also that the learned Tribunal while
quashing the notices has taken note of the fact that no power is conferred
upon the administrative authority to exercise the power of administrative
review. Such reasoning has been recorded on backdrop of the fact that
when the memorandum of charge has already been quashed by the learned
Tribunal which has attained finality after dismissal of the Special Leave
Petition being Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No(s):29396 of 2018
vide order dated 02.11.2018, then it was not available for the writ
petitioner to again call upon the employees by issuing notice to participate
in disciplinary inquiry.
43.
The fact is also not in dispute that memorandum of charge dated
29.12.2016 containing the imputation therein were identical against all the
employees. When one set of memorandum of charge issued against one
set of the employees have already been quashed and set aside which also
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
attained finality but in the second set of litigation, i.e., O.A
No.051/00132/2017 the order has been passed without touching the issue
of imputation as was alleged against the employees, rather liberty only
was granted to conduct an inquiry to consider the illegality which was
committed by the officials who have perpetuated the alleged fraud. The
said
observation
passed
by
the
learned
Tribunal
in
O.A
No.051/00132/2017 is, therefore, clarified the position that the learned
Tribunal while passing the order has not granted liberty to the writ
petitioner to also conduct an inquiry and alleged irregularity said to be
committed by one or the other employees, keeping the fact into
consideration that the memorandum of charge has already been quashed
and set aside by the learned Tribunal which was upheld by the Division
Bench of this Court as also by the Hon’ble Apex Court by dismissing the
Special Leave to Appeal preferred against the said order.
44.
The question of issuance of notice, therefore, has rightly been
taken note of by the learned Tribunal that it is nothing but reviewing the
decision taken by the Court of Law in the administrative side.
45.
We are not concerned with respect to the culpability said to be
committed by the officials as per the liberty granted vide order dated
11.04.2018 passed in O.A No. OA/051/00132/2017, since, the officials
are not before the learned Tribunal, rather the applicants/employees were
before the learned Tribunal and the writ petitioner now has instituted FIR
against the officials based upon the findings surfaced in course of inquiry
said to be preliminary in nature in view of the liberty granted by the
learned Tribunal vide order dated 11.04.2018.
46.
The question of issuance of notice is, therefore, agitated by the
employees/applicants before the learned Tribunal. The memorandum of
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
charge dated 29.12.2016 has already been quashed and set aside as also
attained its finality upto the Hon’ble Apex Court after dismissal of Special
Leave to Appeal, then where is the question and where is the authority
having with the writ petitioner to again issue notice against the employees
to participate in the inquiry.
47.
The decision based upon the same set of charge has already been
quashed and set aside by quashing the memorandum of charge itself and
even in the second set of Original Application being O.A No.
OA/051/00132/2017 no such liberty was granted by the learned Tribunal
to initiate a fresh inquiry against the employees which cannot be, since,
we are living in the era of judicial discipline and if the Forum has passed
an order it is to be given respect for the purpose of following the principle
of judicial discipline and that has been followed by the learned Tribunal
while passing the order dated 11.04.2018 in O.A No. OA/051/00132/2017
and that is the reason the liberty only was granted to look into the element
of fraud, if committed by the officials having no word granting liberty to
again initiate an inquiry against the employees. But even then, the writ
petitioner has issued notice to the employees to participate in the inquiry.
48.
The law is well settled that once the memorandum of charge has
been quashed, the entire departmental proceeding taken by virtue of the
decision is also said to go into the nullity and it is not available for the
disciplinary authority to again call upon the employees to participate in
the inquiry.
49.
The learned Tribunal, in the aforesaid pretext, has formulated the
issues of the administrative review on consideration of the fact that once
the memorandum of charge itself has been quashed and set aside by the
Court of Law, then it cannot be reviewed by the administrative authority
2026:JHHC:3875-DB
by taking decision in administrative side as has been taken by the writ
petitioner by issuing notice to the employees to participate in the inquiry.
50.
This Court, in view of the aforesaid discussion, is of the view that
we are not found any error apparent on the face of the order or even no
element of perversity and as such we decline to interfere with the orders
passed by the learned Tribunal and, accordingly, both the writ petitions
stand dismissed.
51.
Pending I.As, if any, stands disposed of.
(Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.)
(Arun Kumar Rai, J.)
Dated:05.02.2026
Sudhir
A.F.R.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review