Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~1 & 2
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 04.05.2026
+
ARB.P. 1742/2025
THE ATLAS ELECTRIC INDUSTRIES PVT LTD
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ankit Jain, Senior
Advocate along with Mr. Rahul
Tyagi and Mr. Aaditya Singh,
Advocates.
versus
M/S POLOTRIPS INDIA (P) LTD & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Prakhar Mittal, Advocate
for R-1.
Mr. Inderbir Singh Alag, Senior
Advocate along with Mr.
Rakesh Kumar Yadav,
Advocate for R-2.
+
O.M.P.(I) (COMM.) 271/2025, I.A. 20332/2025 (U/O 39 Rule
4) & I.A. 25532/2025 (On behalf of the R-2 seeking dismissal
of the present matter)
M/S ATLAS ELECTRIC INDUSTRIES PVT. LTD.
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ankit Jain, Senior
Advocate along with Mr. Rahul
Tyagi and Mr. Aaditya Singh,
Advocates.
versus
M/S POLOTRIPS INDIA (P) LTD. & ANR. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Prakhar Mittal, Advocate
for R-1.
Mr. Inderbir Singh Alag, Senior
Advocate along with Mr.
Rakesh Kumar Yadav,
Advocate for R-2.
Digitally Signed
By:NEERU
ARB.P. 1742/2025 & connected matter
20:23:02
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
%
JUDGEMENT (ORAL)
O.M.P.(I) (COMM.) 271/2025
1.
The present Petition has been filed under Section 9 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 [“the Act”], seeking the
following reliefs:
“A
B
C
2.
Pass an interim order restraining the Respondents, their
agents, nominees, or anyone acting on their behalf from
selling, transferring, alienating or creating any third party
interest in the Suit Property, till the time Ld. Arbitrator
enters upon reference; AND/OR
Pass an ad interim order in favour of the Petitioner and
against the Respondent to maintain status quo in the matter
till the time Ld. Arbitrator enters upon reference; AND/OR
Pass such other further order as this Hon’ble Court may
deem fit and proper in the interest of Justice, equity and
good conscience.”
In the present Petition, this Court, by its Order dated 17.07.2025
[“Interim Order”], was pleased to grant the following interim reliefs:
“11.
3.
For the said reasons, subject to the proceedings initiated by
the Karnataka Bank, the respondent No. 2 is restrained from
selling, transferring, alienating, creating any third-party
rights in respect of the suit property bearing No. Industrial
Plot No. 174, Sector - 4, IMT Bawal, Rewari, Haryana till
the next date of hearing.”
Subsequently, Respondent No. 2 preferred an Application,
being I.A. No. 20332/2025, seeking vacation of the aforesaid interim
reliefs, in the following terms:
“(a)
vacate the ad interim injunction order dated 17.07.2025
passed in O.M.P.(I) (Comm) 271 of 2025 against the
respondent no.2 whereby the respondent no.2 was
restrained from selling, transferring, alienating, creating any
third-party rights in respect of the suit property bearing no.
industrial Plot no. 174, Sector -4, IMT Bawal, District
Digitally Signed
By:NEERU
ARB.P. 1742/2025 & connected matter
20:23:02
(b)
4.
Rewari Haryana till the next date of hearing
(i.e.22.09.2025); and
pass such further or other order(s) as this Hon'ble Court
may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of
the case.”
The principal ground, inter alia, urged by the Respondent No. 2
for vacation of the aforesaid Interim Order was that the Petitioner
lacks the requisite locus standi to institute the present Petitions under
Sections 9 and 11 of the Act.
5.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of Respondent No.
2 draws the attention of this Court to Clause 15 [“Arbitration
Clause”] of the Agreement to Sell dated 10.11.2021 [“Agreement”],
which reads as follows:
“15.
6.
That without prejudice to the above mentioned clause, it is
agreed between the Parties that if the SECOND
PARTY/VENDEE/BUYER fails to perform its part of the
agreement, the First Party/Vendor/Seller will be at liberty to
forfeit the advance money paid by the SECOND
PARTY/VENDEE/BUYER and to reclaim possession of
the
said
property.
However,
if
the
FIRST
PARTY/VENDOR/SELLER does not get the Sale Deed
registered in the concerned office of Sub- Registrar, New
Delhi,
even
when
the
SECOND
PARTY/VENDEE/BUYER or its Nominee(s) offers full
and final balance payment within agreed period, the
SECOND PARTY/VENDEE/BUYER shall have the right
either to claim for the entire paid amount with interest @24
per cent per annum, as well as any/all other
advances/intervening deposits paid by the SECOND
PARTY/VENDEE/BUYER to and received by Karnataka
Bank Ltd. or the First Party/Vendor/Seller (as the case may
be) and cancel the deal OR go in for specific performance
of this Agreement to Sell through Court of Law by means
of arbitration through an Arbitrator appointed by the
Hon'ble Court.”
Learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of Respondent No.
2 contends that the Petitioner is merely a Confirming Party and is
neither the First Party nor the Second Party. It is submitted that Clause
Digitally Signed
By:NEERU
ARB.P. 1742/2025 & connected matter
20:23:02
15 of the Agreement, which embodies the arbitration clause, is
capable of being invoked only by either the First Party or the Second
Party to the said Agreement.
7.
Learned senior counsel further places reliance upon the
description of the parties in the Agreement, wherein the First Party is
identified as Respondent No. 2 and the Second Party as Respondent
No. 1, while the Petitioner is described solely as a Confirming Party.
Reliance is also placed upon the recital, which reads as under:
“BETWEEN
Mrs. Kalpana Devi Verma through Registered GPA holder by
virtue of Registered GPA dated 16-08-2019, duly executed at
London and authenticated vide No. GBRLC0475119 by High
Commission of India, London. And further stamped on 04-082020/07-10-2020 by collector of stamps in favour of Mr. Aneel
Safmi, R/o B-10, Rose Apartments, Sector-14 Extension, Rohini,
New Delhi-I 10085. Also at C-753, Second Floor, Sushant Lok,
Part 1, Gurgaon (HRY) hereinafter called the FIRST PARTY/
VENDOR/
SELLER(email:
sawhneyhml@aol.com,
ka13pna@outlook.com)
AND
M/s POLOTRIPS INDIA. (P) LTD. through its Director, Shri Anuj
Goyal, having its Registered Office at B-8/195, 1st Floor, Sector 3,
Rohini, New Delhi-110085, hereinafter called the SECOND
PARTY/VENDEE/BUYER (cmail: anujgoyal1985@gmail.com).
AND
M/s The Atlas Electric Industries Pvt. Ltd. through its Director Mr.
Navin Kumar Harineja, having its Registered Office at AE-16,
Tagore Garden, New Delhi hereinafter called CONFIRMING
PARTY (email: theatlas_electric@yahoo.co.in).
WHEREAS the. FIRST PARTY/VENDOR/SELLER is the true,
absolute and lawful owner in possession of entire built-up property
Land & Building located at Industrial Plot No. 174, measuring
5720.10 sq.mtrs., Sector-4 at Growth Centre, Bawal, Distt. Rewari,
hereinafter called the SAID PROPERTY.
WHEREAS the CONFIRMING PARTY has already executed a
Joint Memorandum of Settlement dated 30-10-2021 related to the
SAID PROPERTY according to which CONFIRMING PARTY or
its Nominee shall purchase the
Digitally Signed
By:NEERU
ARB.P. 1742/2025 & connected matter
20:23:02
SAID PROPERTY for Rs.6,00,50.000/- (Rupees Six Crore Fifty
Thousand only) from the FIRST PARTY/VENDOR/SELLER and
accordingly, the SECOND PARTY/VENDEE/BUYER through
this Agreement to Sell shall become Nominee/Financial Partner of
the CONFRMING PARTY.
AND WHEREAS the FIRST PARTY-VENDOR/SELLER have
mortgaged the said property No. Land "& Building located at
Industrial Plot No. 174, measuring 5720.10 sq.mtrs., Sector-4' at
Growth Centre, Bawal, Distt. Rewari to Karnataka Bank Ltd. and
have deposited the title deed of the SAID PROPERTY with the
said Bank. The FIRST PARTY/VENDOR/SELLER have
mortgaged the said property to Karnataka Bank Ltd. With reference
to loan accounts of M/s Carafor Foam Pvt.
Ltd.
with
the
said
bank
since
the
FIRST
PARTY/VENDOR/SELLER is Director of M/s Carafor Foam Pvt.
Ltd. i.e., Mr. Aneel Sahni.
AND WHÈREAS Karnataka Bank Lid, vide its email dated 18-102021 has in principally agreed for OTS for. Rs.671.00 Lacs and
subsequently, vide OTS proposal dated 10-11-2021, the SAID
PROPERTY shall be released for a sum of Rs.6,00,50,000/
(Rupees Six Crore Filly Thousand Only) as full and final amount in
respect of which the SAID PROPERTY ie., Land & Building
located at Industrial Plot No. 174, measuring 5720.10 sq-mts.
Sector-4 at Growth Centre, Bawal, Distt. Rewari has been
mortgaged to Karnataka Bank Ltd.”
8.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of Respondent No.
2 further submits that, in terms of the aforesaid recital, the Confirming
Party no longer remains a party to the transaction, having nominated
the Second Party as the buyer, consequently, any subsisting jural
relationship is confined solely between the First Party and the Second
Party, and the Confirming Party lacks the requisite locus. He further
refers to the subsequent recitals of the Agreement to contend that all
ensuing clauses and recitals pertain exclusively to the First and
Second Parties, with no reference thereafter to the Confirming Party.
9.
Per Contra, Mr. Jain, Learned Senior Counsel appearing on
behalf of the Petitioner submits that the Confirming Party has the right
to participate and invoke the arbitration clause. He refers to and relies
Digitally Signed
By:NEERU
ARB.P. 1742/2025 & connected matter
20:23:02
upon the Judgment in Ansal Properties & Infrastructure Ltd. & Anr.
V. Dowager Maharanis Residential Accommodation Welfare &
Amenities Trust & Anr.1, particularly Paragraph No. 18 thereof,
which reads as under:
“18. The third challenge which has been made is that there is
improper joinder of parties. it is claimed that petitioner No.1 as per
the Joint Venture Agreement, was only a confirming party as is
clearly evident from the definition of “Parties” in the opening
paragraph of JV Agreement which states that "parties shall mean
collectively Prime Maxi Promotion Services Pvt. Ltd., AHMPL
and DOWAGER Trust and party means any one of them as
relevant to the context but does not include the confirming party"
which is the petitioner No.1. It is claimed that since petitioner No.1
was only a confirming party, it was not bound by the terms of the
Contract of the Joint Venture and therefore cannot be termed as a
signatory and cannot claim the benefit of the Arbitration Clause as
contained in Clause 15.12 of the Joint Venture Agreement.”
10.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioner
submits that, in terms of the said judgment, the Petitioner, being a
Confirming Party and a signatory to the Agreement, possesses the
right to invoke the arbitration clause contained therein.
11.
This Court has heard the learned Senior Counsel appearing on
behalf of the parties, and with their able assistance, perused the
material available on record.
12.
As is evident, upon the nomination of the Second Party, the
Confirming Party ceased to retain any substantive role in the
transaction. From a plain reading of the description of the parties, it
emerges that the transaction was structured in such a manner that the
Confirming Party was originally the intended purchaser of the
property and, thereafter, upon identifying another entity, namely, the
Second Party, nominated the latter and effectively assigned and
2022 DHC 4101
Digitally Signed
By:NEERU
ARB.P. 1742/2025 & connected matter
20:23:02
transferred all its rights, title, and interest in respect of the said
transaction to the Second Party.
13.
The parties therefore submit that there is a dispute inter se the
Respondent Nos. 1 & 2 with respect to the conclusion of the
transaction.
14.
In the considered opinion of this Court, the presence of a
dispute between Respondent Nos. 1 & 2 cannot give rise to a locus to
the Petitioner to invoke an Arbitration Clause which it is not expressly
permitted to.
15.
The arbitration clause, in express terms, does not include the
Confirming Party within the category of parties entitled to invoke
arbitral proceedings. Once the explicit stipulations of the Agreement
do not contemplate or confer such a right upon the Confirming Party,
it cannot, by way of imputation or implication, be contended that a
mere signatory status to the Agreement would, in and of itself, suffice
to vest the Confirming Party with the entitlement to invoke the
arbitration clause.
16.
The intention of the parties is to be discerned from a holistic
reading of the Agreement, and the conspicuous non-inclusion of the
Confirming Party within the ambit of the arbitration clause renders it
evident, to the mind of this Court, that the parties consciously
intended to exclude the Confirming Party from invoking the arbitral
mechanism.
17.
In view of the foregoing analysis, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the present Petition, as instituted under Section 9 of the
Act, is not maintainable.
18.
Accordingly, the present Petition, along with pending
Digitally Signed
By:NEERU
ARB.P. 1742/2025 & connected matter
20:23:02
Application(s), stands disposed of in the above terms.
ARB.P. 1742/2025
19.
In light of the aforesaid determination, and having already held
the aforestated Petition under Section 9 of the Act to be nonmaintainable, this Court is of the considered view that the present
Petition instituted under Section 11 of the Act also cannot be sustained
and is, accordingly, dismissed.
20.
Accordingly, the present Petition stands disposed of in the
above terms.
21.
A photocopy of the Order passed today be kept in the connected
matter.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
MAY 04, 2026/tk/DJ
Digitally Signed
By:NEERU
ARB.P. 1742/2025 & connected matter
20:23:02
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review