Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
BA. No. 2 of 2023
Date of Decision: 22.02.2023
Shri Thanglalpaul Khongsai
Vs.
State of Meghalaya
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. M.F. Quereshi, Adv.
Ms. K. Chisa, Adv.
Mr. R. Gurung, GA.
Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl. PP.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
O R D E R (ORAL)
1.
This matter relates to a case under the Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act (NDPS), 1985 which was registered as
Special (NDPS) Case No. 6 of 2022 before the learned Special Judge,
Khliehriat, East Jaintia Hills District.
2.
The prosecution’s story of the case is that on 12.04.2022 on receipt
of credible information from the Additional Superintendent of Police,
Khliehriat, one vehicle being a Mahindra Bolero bearing Registration No.
NL 04 C-3516 was suspected to be carrying contraband. The said vehicle
was proceeding from Silchar Assam side towards Shillong. The police
accordingly intercepted the vehicle at about 7:00 pm at Khliehriat wherein
there were three occupants namely; (1) Shri Francis Lunk Haokip, s/o Shri
Thangkhomang Haokip (2) Shri Chonminlen Touthang, s/o Chongpu
Touthang and (3) Smti Nengboi Haokip, w/o Shri Chonminlen Touthang.
3.
After observing all the legal formalities, the said vehicle was
searched following which the police found about 51(fifty one) Nos. of soap
cases containing yellowish/orange powder suspected to be heroin
concealed inside the chassis of the vehicle. The suspected contraband was
weighed and measured and found to be 411.71 grams. Accordingly, the
vehicle was seized and the three occupants were thereafter detained and
arrested after a formal FIR was filed by the complainant, Sub-Inspector
D.D. Warjri of Ladrymbai, Police Outpost, leading to the registration of
Khliehriat PS Case No. 42(04)2022 under Section 8(c)/22(c)/27A of the
NDPS Act.
4.
As pointed out, the Investigating Officer (I/O) has examined all the
relevant witnesses and in course of questioning, one of the accused person
Shri Chonminlen Touthang revealed that, he along with one Shri
Thangtinlun Khongsai, were involved in the operation when they bought
the consignment from Mohreh after which Shri Thangtinlun Khongsai left
Manipur for Shillong with the arrangement that he will receive the
consignment at Shillong. On the basis of this revelation, the I/O caused
arrest of the Shri Thangtinlun Khongsai.
5.
After the investigation is completed, the I/O filed his Final Form
Report under Section 173 Cr.PC and has returned a finding to the extent
that a prima facie case is found well established against the accused; (1)
Shri Francis Haokip, (2) Shri Chonminlen Touthang and (3) Shri
Thangtinlun Khongsai, under Section 8(c)/22(c)/27A NDPS Act. The other
accused person Smti Nengboi Haokip was discharged on the ground of
insufficient evidence against her.
6.
One of the accused person, Shri Thangtinlun Khongsai has now
approached this Court with an application under Section 37 of the NDPS
Act, r/w Section 439 Cr.PC for grant of bail through the petitioner herein
who is said to be a relative of the accused.
7.
Heard Mr. M.F. Quereshi, learned counsel for the petitioner who has
submitted that the accused person is innocent and not at all involved with
the alleged offence since he was nowhere in the scene when the said vehicle
was intercepted and also when the said alleged contraband goods were
seized from the said vehicle and as such, presumption for possession of
illicit articles as per Section 54 of the NDPS Act cannot be attributed to the
accused person.
8.
The only allegation levelled against the accused person Shri
Thangtinlun Khongsai is that he was involved in financing the illegal
transaction for which he is liable under Section 27A of the said Act,
however, the I/O has come to this conclusion only on the basis of the
alleged confession of the co-accused and also presumably on the basis of
Call Details Report (CDR) of the mobile phone numbers belonging to the
accused Shri Chonminlen Touthang and the accused Shri Francis Lunk
Haokip and that of the abovementioned accused person. Otherwise, there
is no shred of evidence to link the accused person with the case of the
prosecution.
9.
The learned counsel has however submitted that the accused person
does not deny that he is acquainted with the accused Shri Chonminlen
Touthang as they know each other, but the conversation between them over
the mobile phone is only for exchange of pleasantries.
10.
In this respect, the learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that in a number of decisions by the Apex Court as well as High Courts of
this country, it has been held that a confessional statement of a co-accused
cannot be used or relied upon to affect conviction of another co-accused
since under Section 67 of the NDPS Act, placed in juxtaposition with
Section 25 of the Evidence Act, statement made to a police officer is not
admissible in evidence.
11.
In support of his case, the learned counsel has cited the following
decisions: (i) Tofan Singh v. State of Tamil Nadu; (2021) 4 SCC 1, para
155.156 & 157.
(ii) Sujit Tiwari v. State of Gujarat & Anr.; AIR 2020 SC 667, para
11.
(iii) State by (NCB) Bengaluru v. Pallulabid Ahmad Arimutta &
Anr.; Order dated 10.01.2022 of the Supreme Court in Petition for
Special Leave to Appeal (CRL) No. 242 of 2022.
(iv) Amit Ranjan v. Narcotics Control Bureau, Delhi; Order dated
23.05.2022 of the Delhi High Court in Bail Appln. No. 1189/2020.
(v) Jitendra Bhati v. Narcotics Control Bureau; Order dated
18.03.2021 of the Delhi High Court in Bail Appln. No. 4005/2020.
(vi) Phundreimayum Yas Khan v. State (GNCT of Delhi); Order
dated 11.01.2023 of the Delhi High Court in Bail Appln. No.
1383/2022.
12.
Per contra, Mr. R. Gurung, learned GA for the State respondent has
submitted that the I/O in the charge sheet has made a detailed report on the
role of the accused person, who is directly involved in the case inasmuch
as, he had bought the contraband goods from Myanmar together with the
main accused person Shri Chonminlen Touthang and this too is not the first
time that such a transaction took place and has arranged for their meeting
at Shillong for sale or distribution of the said contraband goods. Since the
complicity of the accused person Shri Thangtinlun Khongsai in the case
has been fully established, it is submitted that bail at this juncture may not
be granted.
13.
The learned counsel has also conceded that the impact of the Tofan
Singh case as far as admissibility of confession or statement under Section
67 of the NDPS Act is concerned cannot be refuted. To this extent, the
admission of the co-accused Shri Chonminlen Touthang as regard the
involvement of the accused person Shri Thangtinlun Khongsai in the case
has to be proved during the trial.
14.
However, the learned GA has impressed upon this Court the
importance of the provision of Section 37 of the NDPS Act and has
submitted that the provision provides that bail can be granted to an accused
charged for offences under the NDPS Act only if the court is satisfied that
there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accused is not guilty of
such offence and secondly, that he is not likely to commit any offence
while on bail.
15.
What are reasonable grounds, according to the learned GA has been
the subject matter of a number of decisions passed by the Apex Court as
well as High Courts and in a recent judgment on this issue, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Narcotics Control Bureau v. Mohit
Aggarwal; 2022 SCC Online SC 891, at paras 12, 13 & 14 has held as
follows: “12.The expression “reasonable grounds” has come up for discussion
in several rulings of this Court. In “Collector of Customs, New Delhi v.
Ahmadalieva Nodira”5, a decision rendered by a Three Judges Bench
of this Court, it has been held thus :“7. The limitations on granting of bail come in only when the question
of granting bail arises on merits. Apart from the grant of opportunity to
the Public Prosecutor, the other twin conditions which really have
relevance so far as the present accused-respondent is concerned, are:
the satisfaction of the court that there are reasonable grounds for
believing that the accused is not guilty of the alleged offence and that
he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail. The conditions are
cumulative and not alternative. The satisfaction contemplated
regarding the accused being not guilty has to be based on reasonable
grounds. The expression “reasonable grounds” means something more
than prima facie grounds. It contemplates substantial probable causes
for believing that the accused is not guilty of the alleged offence. The
reasonable belief contemplated in the provision requires existence of
such facts and circumstances as are sufficient in themselves to justify
satisfaction that the accused is not guilty of the alleged offence.”
[emphasis added]
13. The expression “reasonable ground” came up for discussion in
“State of Kerala and others v. Rajesh ” 6 and this Court has observed
as below:
“20. The expression “reasonable grounds” means something
more than prima facie grounds. It contemplates substantial probable
causes for believing that the accused is not guilty of the alleged offence.
The reasonable belief contemplated in the provision requires existence
of such facts and circumstances as are sufficient in themselves to justify
satisfaction that the accused is not guilty of the alleged offence. In the
case on hand, the High Court seems to have completely overlooked the
underlying object of Section 37 that in addition to the limitations
provided under the CrPC, or any other law for the time being in force,
regulating the grant of bail, its liberal approach in the matter of bail
under the NDPS Act is indeed uncalled for.”
14. To sum up, the expression “reasonable grounds” used in clause (b)
of Sub-Section (1) of Section 37 would mean credible, plausible and
grounds for the Court to believe that the accused person is not guilty of
the alleged offence. For arriving at any such conclusion, such facts and
circumstances must exist in a case that can persuade the Court to
believe that the accused person would not have committed such an
offence. Dove-tailed with the aforesaid satisfaction is an additional
consideration that the accused person is unlikely to commit any offence
while on bail.”
16.
On the basis of the CDR of the mobile numbers of the accused and
the co-accused, it has been proved that there is a nexus between the accused
person and the co-accused and the proximity cannot be denied and as such,
this can be a reasonable ground to believe that the accused person is guilty
of the offence alleged.
17.
Mr. Quereshi, in response to the submission made by the learned GA
has submitted that, apart from the concession as regard the applicability of
the ratio of the Tofan Singh judgment in the case of the accused person
herein, in one of the case cited by the petitioner that is, State by (NCB)
Bengaluru v. Pallulabid Ahmad Arimutta & Anr., the Hon’ble Supreme
Court at para 10 has clearly observed that the CDR details of some of the
accused or the allegations of tampering of evidence on the part of one of
the respondents is an aspect that will be examined at the stage of trial, but
that will not affect the bail already granted to the accused person therein.
18.
It is therefore prayed that bail may be granted to the accused person
on any condition that this Court may deem fit and proper to impose.
19.
Having heard the parties, this Court at the outset would observe that
the case involving the aforementioned accused person Shri Thangtinlun
Khongsai and the co-accused Shri Chonminlen Touthang, after
investigation is completed has resulted in the charge sheet being filed with
a prayer to send the said accused persons to stand trial before the court of
competent jurisdiction and accordingly, a regular case being Special
(NDPS) Case No. 6 of 2022 was registered. Therefore, even though there
is no hard and fast rule that prayer for bail cannot be moved after the charge
sheet is filed, the matter however has to be decided looking into the merits
of the charges levelled.
20.
It is also noticed that this instant application was filed seeking grant
of bail under Section 37 of the NDPS Act read with Section 439 Cr.P.C.
Needless to say, it is well settled that the power of the Court to grant bail
to a person accused of having committed an offence under the NDPS Act,
particularly, for offences under sections 19, 24 ,27A and those involving
commercial quantity, sub-clause (ii) of clause (b) of sub-section 1 of
section 37 would circumscribe the twin conditions required to be fulfilled,
Viz; (i) the satisfaction of the court that there are reasonable grounds for
believing that the accused is not guilty of the alleged offence; and (ii) that
he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail. The satisfaction
contemplated regarding the accused being not guilty has to be based on
reasonable grounds based on existence of facts and circumstances of the
case.
21.
The Apex Court while expressing concern on the menace and impact
of narcotic drugs in contemporary society vis-a- vis the issue of grant or
refusal of bail under Section 37 of the Act has vividly observed as such in
the case of State of Kerala & Anr v. Rajesh & Ors ;(2020) 12 SCC 122,
at paras 18 and 19 which reads as follows:“18. This Court has laid down broad parameters to be followed while
considering the application for bail moved by the accused involved in
offences under NDPS Act. In Union of India v. Ram Samujh, it has been
elaborated as under:“7. It is to be borne in mind that the aforesaid legislative mandate is
required to be adhered to and followed. It should be borne in mind that
in a murder case, the accused commits murder of one or two persons,
while those persons who are dealing in narcotic drugs are instrumental
in causing death or in inflicting death-blow to a number of innocent
young victims, who are vulnerable; it causes deleterious effects and a
deadly impact on the society; they are a hazard to the society; even if
they are released temporarily, in all probability, they would continue
their nefarious activities of trafficking and/or dealing in intoxicants
clandestinely. Reason may be large stake and illegal profit involved.
This Court, dealing with the contention with regard to punishment
under the NDPS Act, has succinctly observed about the adverse effect
of such activities in Durand Didier v. State (UT of Goa) as under: (SCC
p. 104, para 24).
24. With deep concern, we may point out that the organised activities
of the underworld and the clandestine smuggling of narcotic drugs and
psychotropic substances into this country and illegal trafficking in such
drugs and substances have led to drug addiction among a sizeable
section of the public, particularly the adolescents and students of both
sexes and the menace has assumed serious and alarming proportions in
the recent years. Therefore, in order to effectively control and eradicate
this proliferating and booming devastating menace, causing deleterious
effects and deadly impact on the society as a whole, Parliament in its
wisdom, has made effective provisions by introducing this Act 81 of
1985 specifying mandatory minimum imprisonment and fine.
8. To check the menace of dangerous drugs flooding the market,
Parliament has provided that the person accused of offences under the
NDPS Act should not be released on bail during trial unless the
mandatory conditions provided in Section 37, namely,
(i) there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accused is
not guilty of such offence; and
(ii) that he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail are
satisfied. The High Court has not given any justifiable reason for
not abiding by the aforesaid mandate while ordering the release of
the respondent accused on bail. Instead of attempting to take a
holistic view of the harmful socio-economic consequences and
health hazards which would accompany trafficking illegally in
dangerous drugs, the court should implement the law in the spirit
with which Parliament, after due deliberation, has amended.”
19. The scheme of Section 37 reveals that the exercise of power to grant
bail is not only subject to the limitations contained under Section 439 of
the CrPC, but is also subject to the limitation placed by Section 37 which
commences with nonobstante clause. The operative part of the said
section is in the negative form prescribing the enlargement of bail to
any person accused of commission of an offence under the Act, unless
twin conditions are satisfied. The first condition is that the prosecution
must be given an opportunity to oppose the application; and the second,
is that the court must be satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for
believing that he is not guilty of such offence. If either of these two
conditions is not satisfied, the ban for granting bail operates.”
22.
In the opinion of this Court, even if the petitioner is able to
substantiate his stand that the admission of the co-accused cannot be
utilized to implicate or to convict the accused person Shri Thangtinlun
Khongsai, the fact that this accused person has admitted that he knows the
co-accused Shri Chonminlen Touthang and that there used to be contacts
between them through mobile phone, would suffice as a piece of
circumstantial evidence to link the said accused person to the offence
alleged, though that would only come out during the trial. However, a
prima facie apprehension that the accused person is involved in the
commitment of the offence is reasonable ground for this Court to believe
that he is not guilty of such offence, until proven otherwise.
23.
The principle of bail jurisprudence would demand that bail is the
rule and jail an exception, however, it is also equally true that grant or
refusal of bail is a discretionary power vested on the competent courts and
each case will depend on the particular and peculiar facts and
circumstances, upon which the court will eventually decide the issue.
Generally, what is well settled as has been laid down in a catena of
decisions by the Apex Court is that there are certain factors to be
considered relevant to the grant or refusal of bail.
24.
In this regard, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Prasanta
Kumar Sarkar v. Ashis Chatterjee & Anr.; (2010) 14 SCC 496, at para 9
has held as follows:“9. … It is trite that this Court does not, normally, interfere with an
order passed by the High Court granting or rejecting bail to the accused.
However, it is equally incumbent upon the High Court to exercise its
discretion judiciously, cautiously and strictly in compliance with the
basic principles laid down in a plethora of decisions of this Court on the
point. It is well settled that, among other circumstances, the factors to
be borne in mind while considering an application for bail are:
(i)
whether there is any prima facie or reasonable ground to
believe that the accused had committed the offence;
(ii)
nature and gravity of the accusation;
(iii)
severity of the punishment in the event of conviction;
(iv)
danger of the accused absconding or fleeing, if released
on bail;
(v)
character, behaviour, means, position and standing of the
accused;
(vi)
likelihood of the offence being repeated;
(vii)
reasonable
apprehension
of
the
witnesses
being
influenced; and
(viii) danger, of course, of justice being thwarted by grant of
bail…”
25.
In view of the nature and gravity of the accusation, the severity of
the punishment and the likelihood of the offence being repeated which
would be a threat to a large number of innocent lives and society as a whole,
this Court is convinced that a case for grant of bail as prayed for has not
been made out.
26.
On consideration of the observations made above, this Court is of
the firm view that this petition is devoid of merits and the same is
accordingly rejected.
27.
Registry to send back the case record.
28.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
22.02.2023
“ N. Swer, Stenographer”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review