Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
a32521
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NA}.IDA
O: 38140
Between
. Telangana Small Scale lndustries Steel and Wooden Furniture Manufacturers
Association, A society bearing Regd No. 1066/2004 Rep. by its Secretary,
M.A. Wasay S/o Mohammed Abdul Qhadeer Siddiqi. Aged about 48 years,
Office at Shop No. 4, M3 Block, Manoranjan Complex, M.J. Market,
Hyderabad - 500001 Telangana.
2. M/s Thushal Krishna lndustries, Represented by its Proprietor, Mr. K. Ravi
Kumar S/ o K. Krishna Murthy, aged about 50 years, Office at Flat No. S-3,
Vishal RNR Residency, Kamalnagar, Opposite Kapra Municpal Office,
Rangareddy - 500062
3. M/s Sri Sai lndustries, Represented by its Proprietor, Mr. U. Shiva Shankar S/
o Late U. Visweswara Rao, aged about 49 years, Office at Flat No. 106, Pearl
Block, Sree Vensai Projects, Kompally, K.V. Rangareddy District - 500014
4. M/s Ashritha lndustries, Represented by its Proprietor, Mrs. Lalita Annapurna
Wo Mr. U. Shiva Shankar Aged about 48 years, Office at Pearl Block, Sree
Vensai Projects, Kompally, K.V. Rangareddy District - 500014
5. M/s Amrutha Enterprises, Represented by its Proprietor, Mrs. B. Amrutha Wo
Bussari Babu Rao, aged about 39 years, Office at 3-4-3/p Adarsh Nagar
Colony, Road No. 10, Satya Enclave, Bandlaguda Jagir, Hyderabad - 500086
6. M/s Kawas Furniture, Represented by its proprietor, Mr. Mohammed Abdul
Raoof, S/o Abdul Khader, Aged about 47 years, Office at No. 1and2, Housing
Board Complex, M.J. Market Road, Hyderabad - 500001
.
PETITIONERS
AND
1. State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary, School Education
Department, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad
2. State Project Director Samagra Shiksha, Government of Telangana Office at
1st Floor, Samagra Shiksha, Beside Telephone Bhavan, Hyderabad.
3. Director School Education, Government of Telangana Office at Saifabad,
Hyderabad - 500004
4. Union of lndia, Represented by its Secretary, Ministry of Education, New
Delhi. Dr Rajendra Prasad Rd, Rajpath Area, Central Secretariat, New Delhi 1 100Cr1
5. Depadment of School Education and Literacy, Samagra Shiksha Scheme Ministry of Education, Shastri Bhavan, Dr Rajendra Prasad Rd, Rajpath Area,
Centrirl Secretariat, New Delhi - 1 10001.
6. M/s. 'frufa Enterprise Private Limited, Office at Plot No. 3-898, Sri Swamy
Ayyappa Co-op Society, Road No. 1 Madhapur, Hyderabad, Telangana 5000ti1.
7. M/s. Mafatlal lndustries Limited, Office at Mafatlal House, 5th Floor, HT
Parekh Marg, Backbay Reclamation, Churchgate Mumbai - 40OO2O.
8. Methodex Systems Private Limited, Office at 607-608 Meghdoot g4, Nehru
Place, New Delhi, Delhi, lndia - 110019.
...RESPONDENTS
Petitiorr under ArTicle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a w"it order or direction, more particularly a writ in the nature of a mandamus
declaring the action of the Respondent No. 2 in issuing the letter daled 01.12.2O25
along with entering the agreements dated 29.1 1 .2025 with Respondent No. 6
(Agreement No. 8/2025-6) and Respondent No. 7 (Agreement No. 7 t2O2S-26) in
connection with the Tenderl Bid Document bearing Bid Notice No. (NlT) 06/55/
2024-25 dated 26.04.2025 issued by the Respondent No.2 for Supply
Commissioning and lnstallation of Bunker Beds in KGBVs in Telangana State, as
being illegal arbitrary and unconstitutional and consequenfly set aside the same.
i1ClF2
Petiticn under section 151 cPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay all
further pror:eedings including but not limited supplies made or initiated by the
Respondenl No. 6 and 7 pursuant to the agreements dated 29.11.2025 wilh
Respondent No. 6 (Agreement No. 8/2025-6) and Respondent No. 7 (Agreement No.
712025-261 in connection with the Tender/ Bid Document bearing Bid Notice No.
(NlT) 06/5S;/2024-25 dated 26.04.2025 issued by the Respondent No.2 for ,supply
Commissiorling and lnstallation of Bunker Beds in KGBVs in Telangana State,.
l.A NO: 2 OF 2025
Between:
1 M/s. Trufa Enterprise Private Limited, Office at Plot No. 3-898, Sri Swamy
Ayyappa Co-op Society, Road No.1, Madhapur, Hyderabad, Telangana 500081.
2 M/s. Mafatlal lnduskies Limited, Office at Mafatlal House, sth Floor, HT
Parekh Marg, Backbay Reclamation, Churchgate Mumbai - 400020.
3 Methodex Systems Private Limited, Office at 607-608 Meghdoot 94, Nehru
Place, New Delhi, Delhi, lndia - 1 10019.
...PETITIONERS
AND
1 M/s. Telangana Small Scale lndustries Steel and Wooden Furniture
Manufacturers Association, A society bearing Regd No. 1066/2004 Rep. by its
Secretary, M.A. Wasay S/o Mohammed Abdul Qhadeer Siddiqi. Aged about
48 years, Office at Shop No. 4, M3 Block, Manoranian Complex, M.J. Market,
Hyderabad - 500001 Telangana.
M/s Thushal Krishna lndustries, Represented by its Proprietor, Mr. K. Ravi
Kumar S/o K. Krishna Murthy, aged about 50 years, Office at Flat No. S-3,
Vishal RNR Residency, Kamalnagar, Opposite Kapra Municpal Office,
Rangareddy - 500062
3 M/s Sri Sai lndustries, Represented by its Proprietor, Mr. U. Shiva Shankar S/
o Late U. Visweswara Rao, aged about 49 years, Office at Flat No. 106, Pearl
Block, Sree Vensai Projects, Kompally, K.V. Rangareddy District - 500014
4 M/s Ashritha lndustries, Represented by its Proprietor, Mrs. Lalita Annapurna
Wo Mr. U. Shiva Shankar Aged about 48 years, Office at Pearl Block, Sree
Vensai Projects, Kompally, K.V. Rangareddy District - 500014
5 M/s Amrutha Enterprises, Represented by its Proprietor, Mrs. B. Amrutha W/o
Bussari Babu Rao, aged about 39 years, Office at 3-4-3lp Adarsh Nagar
Colony, Road No. 10, Satya Enclave, Bandlaguda Jagir, Hyderabad - 500086
6 M/s Kawas Furniture, Represented by its proprietor, Mr. Mohammed Abdul
Raoof, S/o Abdul Khader, Aged about 47 yea$, Office at No. 1and2, Housing
Board Complex, M.J. Market Road, Hyderabad - 500001
...RESPONDENTSMRIT PETITIONERS
7. State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary, School Education
Department, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad
8. State Project Director Samagra Shiksha, Government of Telangana Office at
1st Floor, Samagra Shiksha, Beside Telephone Bhavan, Hyderabad.
9. Director School Education, Government of Telangana Office at Saifabad,
Hyderabad - 500004
10. Union of lndia, Represented by its Secretary, Ministry of Education, New
Delhi. Dr Rajendra Prasad Rd, Ralpath Area, Central Secretariat, New Delhi 't 10001
'tl.Depatment of School Education and Literacy, Samagra Shiksha Scheme Minist.ry of Education, Shastri Bhavan, Dr Rajendra prasad Rd, Rajpath Area,
Central Secretariat, New Delhi - 'l 10001.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filecl in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to vacate the
Status Quo orders dt. 11.12.2025 passed in W.p.No.38140 of 2025, by dismissing
the writ petition, pending disposal of the writ petition.
l.A NO: 3 CIF 2025
Between:
1. State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary, School Education
Depe rtment, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad
2. State Project Director Samagra Shiksha, Government of Telangana Office at
1st Floor, Samagra Shiksha, Beside Telephone Bhavan, Hyderabad.
3. Director School Education, Government of Telangana Office at Saifabad,
Hyderabad - 500004
4. Deperrtment of School Education and Literacy, Samagra Shiksha Scheme
_
Minishy of Education, Shastri Bhavan, Dr Raiendra prasad Rd, Rajpath Area,
Cent.al Secretariat, New Delhi - 110001.
...PETITIONERS
AND
,|
Telangana small scale lndustries steel and wooden Furniture Manufacturers
Asscciation, A society bearing Regd No. 1066/2004 Rep. by its Secretary,
M.A. Wasay S/o Mohammed Abdul ehadeer Siddiqi. Aged ibout 4g years,
Office at Shop No.4, M3 Block, Manoranjan Complex, M.J. M'arket,
Hyderrabad - 500001 Telangana.
2 M/s Thushal Krishna lndustries, Represented by its proprietor, Mr. K. Ravi
Kumar S/ o K. Krishna Murthy, aged about 50 years, Office at Flat No. S_3,
Vishal RNR Residency, Kamalnagar, Opposite Kapra Municpal Office,
Rangareddy - 500062
3 M/s Sri Sai lndustries, Represented by its proprietor, Mr. U. Shiva Shankar,
S/o l-ate U. Visweswara Rao, aged about 49 years, Office at Flat No. 106,
Pearl Block, Sree Vensai Projects, Kompally, K.V. Rangareddy District 500cr14
4. M/s Ashritha lndustries, Represented by its Proprietor, Mrs. Lalita Annapurna
Wo Mr. U. Shiva Shankar Aged about 48 years, Office at Pearl Block, Sree
Vensai Projects, Kompally, K.V. Rangareddy District - 500014
5. M/s Amrutha Enterprises, Represented by its Proprietor, Mrs. B. Amrutha Wo
Bussari Babu Rao, aged about 39 years, Office at 3-4-3/p Adarsh Nagar
Colony, Road No. 10, Satya Enclave, Bandlaguda Jagir, Hyderabad - 500086
6. M/s Kawas Furniture, Represented by its proprietor, Mr. Mohammed Abdul
Raoof, S/o Abdul Khader, Aged about 47 yeas, Office at No. 1and2, Housing
Board Complex, M.J. Market Road, Hyderabad - 500001
7. Union of lndia, Represented by its Secretary, Ministry of Education, New
Delhi. Dr Rajendra Prasad Rd, Rajpath Area, Central Secretariat, New Delhi 110001
8. M/s. Trufa Enterprise Private Limited, Office at Plot No. 3-898, Sri Swamy
Ayyappa Co-op Society, Road No. 1 Madhapur, Hyderabad, Telangana 500081.
9. M/s. Mafatlal lndustries Limited, Office at Mafatlal House, sth Floor, HT
Parekh Marg, Backbay Reclamation, Churchgate Mumbai - 4O0020.
10. Methodex Systems Private Limited, Office at 607-608 Meghdoot 94, Nehru
Place, New Delhi, Delhi, lndia - 110019.
RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate the
interim order daled '11 .12.2025 and dismiss the Writ Petition, pending disposal of the
writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI D.PRAKASH REDDY, Sr. COUNSEL, REP.
SRI M.PRANAV
Counsel for the Respondent No.l to 3: SRI T.RATINIKANT REDDY,
ADDL. ADVOCATE GENERAL
Counsel for the Respondent No.4 & 5: SMT B.KAVITA YAOAV,
SC FOR CENTRAL GOW.
Counsel for the Respondent No.6 to 8: SRI B.CHANDRASEN REDDY,
Sr. COUNSEL, REP.
SRI B-VAMSHIDHAR REDDY
The Court made the follouring: ORDER
I
NI'
Betweenr
Telangana Small Scale Industries Steel and Wooden Furniture
Man ufacturrers Association and Others
... Petitioners
And
State of Telangana & Others
Respondents
Heard Sri D.Prakash Reddy, learned Senior
Designated Counsel representing Sri M.pranav, learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners on record
and Sri T.Rajinikant Reddy, tearned Additionat Advocate
General appearing on behalf of the respondent Nos.1 to 3
and Smt. B.Kavita Yadav, learned standing appearing on
behalf of the respondent Nos.4 and 5
Sri B.Cltrandrasen
and
Reddy, learned Senior Designated
Counsel representing Sri B.Vamshidhar Reddy, learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent Nos.6 to g
on record.
SN, J
wp 38 t40 2025
n
a
as und r:-
"to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly a writ
in the nature of a mandamus declaring ihe action of the
Respondent No.2 in issuing the letteidated 01.12.2025
along with entering the agreements dated 29.11.2025 with
Respondent No.6 (Agreement No.g/2025_6) and
Respondent No 7 Agreement No 7/202526 in connection
with the Tender/ Bid Document bearing Bid Notice
No.(NIT) 06/55/ 2024-25 dated 26.04.2025 issued by rhe
Respondent No.2
Supply Commissioning and
Installation of Bunker Beds in KGBVs in Telangana State as
being illegal, arbitrary, and unconstit-utional and
consequently set aside the same...,,
for
of
ave
ents
st-tD
ort of
bri
th
ade in t he affid vit filed bv the etitione sin
e Drese n
tw rit Pet t on s a sun er:-
It is the case of the petitioners that the writ petitioners,
Telangana Small Scale Industries Steel ancl Wooden Furniture
Small Manufacturers Association and others, have filed the
present writ petition challenging the actions of the respondents
with respect to the supply of 45,360 bunker beds along with
maftresses and pillows. The original tender conditions, as per
clause 5 of the tender documents, required the supply to be
completed within 120 days from the initial agreement dated
29.05.2025. No supplies were made by Respondents No. 6 and 7
within this period, and instead of retendering after expiry of the
SN, J
wp_38 I 40_2025
120-day' term, a supplementary agreement dated
29.L'.zozs
was e>recuted, granting an additiona r L2o days, which
contravelned the originar tender conditions and
deprived
petitionerrs of an opportunity to participate.
It is further the case of the petitioners that the reasons
cited by the respondents for the deray, incrude pending
codes for the beds, government enquiries regarding
verification of space avairabirity in KGBVS, which
The tencler conditions did not require post-bid
color coc']es. The alreged pricing enquiry was
coror
pricing, and
are unjustified.
determination of
based on irrelevant
comparisons, and the space verification should
have been
completed prior to tendering. No officiar
orders or
communications extended the time under
the first agreement,
making the second agreement arbitrary and
beyond the tender
terms.
It is further the case of the petitioners that, there was
favoritisnr towards Respondent Nos. 6
Respondent No. B participated activery
and its crr:6[sn1i.rs were retied upon
to B, noting that
in the pre-bid meeting,
by Respondent Nos. 6 and 7
to quarify for the tender, thereby enabring
murtipre participation
through the same entity. This arrangement
contravenes clause
13(f) of the tender conditions and effectivery
ensures preferentiar
\
\
t
I
SN, J
wp_38140_2025
treatment for the respondents, undermining fair competition'
Additionally, there were irregularities in pricing. Purchase orders
dated O4.t2.2025 and 05.L2.2025 reflected exorbitant rates'
including transportation. Post-agreement negotiations and
supplemental agreements, including one dated 06.L2.2o25,
conducted without calling for fresh tenders, contrary
Were
to the
central vigilance commission guidelines and General Financial
Rules that allow renegotiation only in exceptional
cases where
few suppliers are available. Prior supply records indicate
significantly lower costs, reinforcing the petitioners'
claim of
inflated Pricing.
In conclusion, the second suPPlementarY agreements
executed on 2g. LL.2025 materially altered the
terms, particularly the 120-day completion
original tender
period' without
properjustificationorfreshcompetitir,ebidding.Theseactions
Were arbitrary, contrary to the tender conditions,
favoritism, and violate established procurement
show
norms, thereby
givingthemsufficientlocustochallengetheproceedings.The
court to ensure
writ petitioners have thus sought relief from this
competition, and proper
adherence to the tender conditions, fair
pricing in Public Procurement'
{
SN, J
wp_38 t40_2025
follows:;
On 26.04.2025, the Respondent No.2 issued tender
notification for supply of Bunker Beds to KGBV schools
acrojis Telangana.
on :1o.o5.2025 after evaruation and finarization of bids
Respondent No. 6 and Respondent No 7 were awarded with
the tender.
on zg.o5.zozst the Respondent No 2 entered into
dgr'€r-rrr1€fit with Respondent No 6 for supply
of the bunker
beds for the varue of works awarded to nlsponaenc
rrro. o
on 1o.06.2025, the Respondent No.2 entered into
agre(lment with Respondent No 7 for suppry of the bunker
beds for the varue of works awarded to RespondenLNo.
7.
on 22.1o-zozst in view of the compraints received by the
state government, the state government cailed for a report
from the Managing Director, Telangana Education Women
Infra:;tructure Deveropment corporation and the same
was
subrr itted.
On 08.1L.ZOZS' Revised letters of acceptance were
issuel to Respondent No 6 and Respondent No.7
on 24.11.2025, the corour codes were communicated to
the Respondent No 6 and Respondent No. 7
9n
?g.lt.ZOZSt the Supplementary Agreements
into
by the Respondent No'2 and Respondent Nos. were
7 and g
separately for their respective value of works awarded.
4.
hereunder:
a
SN, J
wp_38 140_2025
The bidder shall upload online on e-procurement platform, the
following particulars in the formats enclosed, supported by
documentary evidence as specified in the formats'
I) The Bidder/oEM should be a company registered under
lnaian companies Act L956|2OL3 and should be in existence
from last 7 years from the date of bid calling period. The
Bidder should furnish valid Incorporation certification along
with PAN and GST certificates
turnover
II) The Bidder/oEM should have an average annual
(3)
financial
of a minimum of INR 160 crores of last three
years.i.e.2o2L-22,2022-23and2023-24.Copiesofthe
Audited Financial Statements of last three (3) financial years
to be furnished.
three
III) The net worth of the Bidder/oEM in the lastbalance
finincial years, (as per the last published.audited
and
ir..'eet) should be'positive. The bidder should be profitable
per
(as
years
(3)
financial
should not be in ioss in last Three
2022if," turt published audited balance sheet) i.e.,2O2l-22,
23 and 2023-24. Copy of Balance sheet and cA certificate
with 18-digit UDIN number to be furnished'
IV) The Bidder/oEM must have successfully undertaken in any
following
onl financial year (in last 7 years) at least-.theherein:
a)
numbers of Similar issignments of value specified
Two
One proiect value not less than of Rs'128,00,00,000/- b)
proj".tt of each value not less than Rs'80,00'00'000/- c)
projects of each value not less than of
Three
Rs.64,00,00,000/for
(Similar Experience assignments defined as: Supply of furniture
certificate
school hostel as on biJ publish date) and experience
be
ietating to bidders wori< order completion certificate to
furnished.
V)TheBidder/oEMshouldhavesuccessfullyundertaken
any one
rottowing numbers of similar product (Bunker beds in
of the financial years from last 7 years)
a.ShouldhaveexecutedSingleordermorethan20000
or
bunker beds to State/central Movement organizations.
each order
b. Should have executed at least two orders,state/central
should have more than 15000 bunker beds to
government organizations'
c. should have executed at least three or above orders,.each
10000 bunker beds to
oro"i should have more than
state/Centra I govern ment orga nizations'
{
f
SN, J
wp_38 I 40_2025
Experience certificate relating to
Order/Completion Certificate to be furnished.
bidders work
VI) A) The Bidder/OEM must have a valid certificate: Bidder
shou d have Griha council certification for bunker beds &
Greer co certification from cII, Ail certificates should be
visible on online portal.
B) MSME units need to submit valid ZED Gold
certification & for large manufacturers IEM certificate need
to be submitted.
vII) Bidder/oEM should demonstrate: Availability of Liquid
Assets/credit Facility (letter of credit or Solvency certificate
from any Nationalized Bank/scheduled bank) of Rs.64 crore.
The clate of solvency certificate issued by bank should not be
older than 3 months from the date of issue of bid.
VIII) Bidder/oEM must submit the samples as per the scope
of wc,rk as per Annexure - I. samples to be submitted on or
before the last date of bid submission. (Non submission of the
samples is liable for rejection of the bids)
IX) c'EM/their authorized agencies/Authorized dealer can bid
for the tender. In case the bidder is an agency or dealer, the
turnover of oEM and agency/dealer both ihall be considered.
Singllr/multiple dealers may be participated in the tender.
X) Authorization letter from oEM shall be submitted by the
bidder, in case of authorized agencies/Authorized dealer.
XI) The Bidder/oEM should have capability to provide after
sales service for th-e maintenance period of i.e., defect liability
pe_rio<l (warranty for project period) and should
be able to
offer,\nnual maintenance contract thereafter.
xII) Notwithstanding anything stated above, the Tender
Invitirrg Authority reserves the right to assess the Bidders
capabilities, capacity to perform the contract and to offer
warranty and AMc, should circumstances warrant such an
asses:;ment in the overall interest of the tender Inviting
Authority deciding on award.
Note: a. All the participating bidders should mandatorily pay
electronically the transaction fee to TGTS Hydeiabad
thror.rgh "Payment Gateway Service on e-procurement
Platfcrm". The sca.nned copy of payment receipt shall
be
uplo;rded by the bidder.,,
b. Tlre bidder is subjected to be brack risted and the
EMD
forfeited if he is found to have misread or furnished
farse
information in the forms / statements 7 certificates
SN, J
wp 38140_2025
submitted in proof of qualification requirements or record of
performance.
c. Further, the bidder has abandoned works, non-
completion of works properly in time in earlier contracts,
inordinate delays in completion of the works, litigation
history and/or financial failures and/or participated in the
previous bidding for the same work and had quoted
unreasonably shill also blacklisted and EMD forfeited.
d. The bidder should submit signed undertaking of bid
online.
5. clause 25 and 26 ()f the tender document dated
26.O4.2O25 is extracted hefeunder:
*25. DelaYs and Extension of Time
No claim for compensation on account of delays or
hindrances to the work from any cause whatever shall lie, except
as hereafter defined. Reasonable extension of time shall be
allowed by the State project Director, Samagra Shiksha,
Telangana, Hyderabad for any additional number of units that
may .esult from causes, which in the opinion of the State Project
Director, samagra Shiksha, Telangana, Hyderabad, are
undoubtedly beyond the control of the Bidder. The State Project
Director, Samagra Shiksha, Telangana, l-lyderabad shall assess
the period of delay hindrance caused by any written instructions
issued to the bidder.
26. Liquidated Damages
a. Notwithstanding Authority's right to cancel the order
liquidated damages for late delivery dt Lo/o (One percent) of the
undelivered portion of the order value per week shall be charged
for every week's delay in the specified delivery schedule subject
to a maximum of 10% of the value of the order value. E.g' If the
Desktop is delivered but the delivery of the power cord, to be
supplied along with the Desktop, is delayed then LD would be
caiculated on the total cost of the Desktop and not on the cost of
the power cord alone.
b. Liquidated damages for late commissioning dt to/o (one
percent) of the order value per week shall be charged for every
g r'
ll
SN, J
wp_38140 2025
week's delay in commissioning to a maximum of LOo/o of the
value of l:he order value.
c. l>lease note that the above LD for the delay in delivery
and dela'y in commissioning are independent of each other and
shall be levied as the case may be Authority reserves its right to
recover these amounts by any mode such as adjusting from any
payments to be made by Authority to the Bidder. Liquidated
damages shall be calculated on per weekry basis and recovered
from next release bills."
6. Ihr: tearnea Senior Oes
behalf of the petitioners mainly puts-forth the followino
submissions:
i) As per the clause 5 of tender, the scope of completion of
work is 120 days from the date of agreement. If the respondents
could not have executed the contract agreement, a new tender
ought to lrave been floated.
ii) l\s per clause 1 and clause 16(I) the bidder should be a
registered company in existence for more than 7 years from the
date of calling of the bid, but the respondent Nos.6 was
incorporated only in the year 2022, hence, the respondent No.2
ought to lrave rejected the bid pertaining to respondent No.6.
iii) The respondent Nos.6 to B are making exorbitant
profits, the tender ought not to have been awarded
to the
l0
SN, J
wp_18140_2025
respondent Nos.6 and 7 as the OEM for supplying the respondent
Nos.6 & 7 is the respondent No.8 and that the respondent No'6
is not independently qualified for meeting the eligibility criteria
laid down in the tender for participation in the tender'
iv) The time period specified in the tender document and
the agreement dated 29.05.2025 for supply of bunker beds is
120 days and the respondent Nos'6 to B did not supply the
bunker beds in the said period of 120 days' As such'
the action
of entering supplementary agreement extending the time is
impermissible as per the tender document'
7.
ll
SN, J
wp_38140_2025
i)
The petitioners have no locus
challenge the
supplementary agreements or the tender process
ii) The petitioners had not participated in the tender
pursuant to the tender notification, dated
26.O4 .2(,25.
iii) A person who did not participate in tender cannot
challenge the same as they woutd not be
aggrieved with
the action of the tendering authority in view
participation. The petitioners have no
of the non_
locus standa to file
the present writ petition seeking prayer as
sought for in
the present writ petition since petitioners have
participated in the tender, hence
writ petition is not
maintainabte.
iv) The Writ petitioners in the present writ petitaon
challenging the action of the state in
entering into
supplementary agreements with respondent
The petitioners are not party to the
Nos.6 & 7.
said supplementary
agreements and hence, cannot cha
enge the same.
Seeking to set-asade the supplementary
agreements
which is contractual in nature is not permissible
petition.
are
in writ
t2
SN, J
wp 38140_2025
v) The petitioners are only challenging the supplementary
agreements, dated 29.!L.2O25 and not challenging the
initial agreements, dated 29.Q,5.2Q25, 10.06.2025. The
petitioners without laying any challenge to the first
agreement or initial act of awarding the contract to
8 cannot challenge the
respondent Nos.5 to
su pplementary agreements.
vi) As per the tender document, there is a quantity
variation clause along with specific clause of extension of
time and also levy of liquidated damages for delay
supplies, hence, there is no illegality, committed by the
official respondents as alleged by the petitioners herein'
Based on the aforesaid submissions' the learned
Aclclitional Actvocate General contencls that the oresent
writ oetition needs to be dismissed in limine'
g. The learned senior desiqnated counsel aDoearinq on
behalf of the respondent Ngs.6 to 8 mainly Duts-forth the
followino su bmissions: -
i) There is delay of 3 months on the part of respondent
No.2 in approving the colour codes and logo and there is
I
f
l3
SN, J
wp_38 140_2025
no delay on the part of the respondent Nos.6 to g in
manufar:turing or supply of bunker beds.
ii) As per clause 25 and 26 of the Tender Document, if
time for completion can be extended by tendering
authority and if the delay is attributable to the tendering
authority liquidated damages can be revied. Further, as
per point 4 of the bid document the validity of tender
period is 5 years and 45 days. Therefore, it is setfled law
that when there is an extension clause and Iiquidated
damages time will not be the essence of the contract.
iii) That as per clause 16 the "Bidder or oEM,' should be
incorporated lor I years. The respondent No. 6 and 7 are
the authorized suppliers of the Respondent No. g (oEM)
which is established in year 1960, hence they satisfy the
condition.
iv) Thait the delay is not attributable to the answering
respondents as a complaint was filed on 27.c,5.2c,25
alleging exorbitant price to favourabte rnstitutions.
Accordingly a committee was formed and an enquiry was
l4
SN, J
wp_38140_2025
conducted and the report was filed on 22.10.2025 by
observing that the tender process was conducted fairly
and accorclance with the norms and the respondents No' 6
and 7 agreed to execute the work at the modified rate
which resulted in saving ol 7o/o @ Rs. 1O.72 crores' It was
also observed that cancetlation of tenders will lead to
considerable delay in supply of bunker beds' Thereafter,
revised LOI was signed on 08.11.2025 followed by the
subject supplementary agreements dt' 29'L1"2O25' Hence
there is no delaY.
v) As per the tender document, there is a quantity
variation clause along with specific clause of extension of
time and atso levy of liquidated damages for delay
supplies, hence, there is no illegality, committed by the
official respondents as alleged by the petitioners herein'
Se
ior
re oond ent
iq ated
ns
fo
h
oDea ano
Cou nsel
os.6 to8 con
nd
on
r
half of
tha the Writ Petiti on
needs to be dismassed.
9.
This Court opines that there is no material on record
thatindicatesthattheactionoftheofficialrespondents
t5
SN. J
wp_31 40_2025
herein is illegal or perverse or matafide or intended to
favour the unofficial respondents herein as urged by the
learned senior designated counsel appearing on behalf of
the petitioners.
10. The three m ain olea
uroed
vthel
rned s n ior
desionated counsel aooearing on behatf of the oetitioners
are:
i) As per clause 5, the scope of completion of work is 12O
days so supplementary agreement could not have been
executed and new tender ought to have been floated.
ii) Respondent Nos.6 to I are not an exastence for more
than 7 years and respondent No.6 was incorporated onty
in 2022.
iii) Respondent Nos.6 to 8 are being favoured.
af resa id
di
leas ou
ussed and a swer
rth hVt h CD
t (,ne rs are
as un der
11. A bare perusal of the reasons explained in the counter
affidavit r'iled on behalf of respondent Nos.1 to 3 clearly indicate
that the main reason for extending 120 days time period and
entering into supplementary agreements dated 29.Lt.2025
due to ccnduct of enquiry,,calling for report on the subject
are
issue
l6
SN, J
wp_38140_2025
by TGEWIDC and letters from schools for space and colour codes
and duly considering the said reasons, and the averments made
in the counter affidavit filed by the official respondents herein,
this Court opines that the contention of the petitioners that the
extension of time beyond 120 days and entering into
supplementary agreement is not legal is not tenable'
L2. On bare perusal of clause 25 and 26 of the tender
document notification dated 26.04.2l21(referred to and
extracted above) it is evident that the respondent No'2 has a
contractual power and the discretion for extending time and time
is certainly not the essence of the contract' This Court opines
that there is no illegality on the part of the respondent No'2 in
exercising its right under a clause in the agreement which
governs the Parties to
it and the said extension is PurelY
contractual in nature.
13. This Court takes note of the fact as borne on record that
the respondent No.8 on 24.06.2025 had addressed a letter to
the respondent No.3, requesting respondent No'3 to give
approval with regard to the three priority colour codes for bunker
beds and it is only on 25.1t'2O25 the respondent No'3 had
issued proceedings vide Lr.No.634/SS/CW12025-26-2 in favour
/
t7
SN, J
wp_38140 2025
oF respondent No.7 thereby approving the colour codes and logo
on the [runker beds and also has approved the dark brown and
cream r:olour for the bunker beds. A bare perusal of the
aforesaid communication dated 24.06.202s and zs.lL.zo25
clearly indicates that there is a lapse of three (3) months on the
part of respondent No.2 for approving the colour codes and logo
and there is no delay on the part of respondent Nos. 6 to B in
manufacturing or supplying bunker beds.
14. Lthe judoment of the Apex court reoorted in (1994)
6 SCC 651 in Tata Cellular Vs. Union of India, dated
26.07.L'994 and in oarticutar para No.94, it is observed as
under:94. The principles deducible from the above are :
(1) The modem trend points to judicial restraint in administrative
action.
(2) The ccurt does not sit as a court of appeal but merely reviews the
manner irr which the decision was made. (3) The court does not have
the expertise to correct the administrative decision. If a review of the
administr,ative decision is permitted it will be substituting its own
decision, without the necessary expertise which itself may be fallible.
(4) The terms of the invitation to tender cannot be open to judicial
scrutiny because the invitation to tender is in the realm of contrict.
Normally speaking, the decision to accept the tender or award the
contract is reached by process of negotiations through several tiers.
More often than not, such decisions are made qualitatively by experts.
(5) The Government must have freedom of contract. In other words, a
fair play ir the joints is a necessary concomitant for an administrative
body fun<:tioning in an administrative sphere or quasi-administrative
l8
SN, J
wp_38 I 40_2025
sphere. However, tlre decision must not only be tested by the
application of Wednesbury principle of reasonableness (including its
oih"r facts pointed out above) but must be free from arbitrariness not
affected by bias or actuated by mala fides.
(6) Quashing decisions may impose heavy administrative burden on
ine administration and lead to increased and unbudgeted expenditure.
--* /
/
l9
SN, J
wp_38140 2025
hereunder:
*11. The Arbitral Tribunal, on hearing the parties, had
framr:d 17 issues, of which we are concerned only with the
follovuing:
(i) Was time the essence of the Agreement to make supplies
under the four Purchase Orders and was the delivery date to
be reckoned from the date of the supply order?
(ii) \l/as ONGC justified in recovering liquidated damages of
US $;3,07,804.03 and Rs. 7,O5,367 / -?
(iii) lvas the Claimant entltled to extension of delivery dates
withc,ut levy of liquidated damages on account of force
majeure condition as stated in paragraphs 12.D.3 and
L2.D 4 of the Statement of Claim?
(iv) lVas ONGC entitled to impose liquidated damages on the
basis of the entire value of the Purchase Orders?
(v) Is the Claimant entitled to refund of any part of the
amount recovered by ONGC as liquidated damages?
(vi) Is the Claimant entitled to US gZ,44,tZL.O3 and
Rs.5,76,244.2L as interest on delayed payment as in Exhibit
'H' to the Statement of Claim?"
(vii) Whether the Claimant is entitled to any interest? If so,
at wl'rat rate and for what period?
32. In Saw Pipes case (supra), impugned clause for
liquidated damages was considered and upheld by this court
in thr: following manner:
46. From the aforesaid sections, it can be held that
vvhen a contract has been broken, the party who
s,lffers by such breach is entitled to receive
crlrTlpehsartion for any loss which naturally arises in
the usual course of things from such breach. These
sr:ctions further contemplate that if parties knew
when they made the contract that a particular loss is
lil<ely to result from such breach, they can agree for
payment of such compensation. In such a case, there
{
l
SN, J
wp 38140 2025
may not be any necessity of leading evidence for
proving damages, unless the court arrives at the
concluiion that no loss is likely to occur because of
such breach. Further, in case where the court arrives
at the conclusion that the term contemplating
damages is by way of penalty, the court may grant
reasonable compensation not exceeding the amount
so named in the contract on proof of damages.
However, when the terms of the contract are
clear and unambiguous then its meaning is to be
gathered only from the words used therein. In a case
fuhere agreement is executed by experts in the field,
it would be difficult to hold that the intention of the
parties was different from the language used therein'
in such a case, it is for the party who contends that
stipulated amount is not reasonable compensation,
to prove the same.
64. Under Section 73, when a contract has been
broken, the party who suffers by such breach is
entitled to receive compensation for any loss caused
to him which the parties knew when they made the
contract to be likely to result from the breach of it'
This section is to be read with Section 74, which
deals with penalty stipulated in the contract, inter
alia (relevant for the present case) provides that
whena contract has been broken, if a sum is named
in the contract as the amount to be paid in case of
such breach, the party complaining of breach is
entitled, whether or not actual loss is proved to have
been caused, thereby to receive from the party who
has broken the contract reasonable compensation
not exceeding the amount so named' Section 74
emphasizes that in case of breach of contract, the
party complaining of the breach is entitled to receive
reasonable compLnsation whether or not actual loss
is oroved to have been caused by such breach'
Therefore, the emphasis is on reasonable
compensation. ... But if the compensation named in
the contract for such breach is genuine pre-estimate
of loss which the parties knew when they made the
contract to be likely to result from the breach of it,
there is no question of proving such loss or such
party is not required to lead evidence to prove actual
loss suffered bY him.
2t
SN, J
wp_38 t40_2025
66. In Maula Bux case t(1969) 2 SCC 5541 the Court
has specifically held that it is true that in Lvery case
ol breach of contract the person aggrieved by the
b'e_ach is not required to prove actuai loss or damage
sr.iffered by him before he can claim a decree and the
cr:urt is competent to award reasonable
compensation in a case of breach even if no actual
d;rmage is proved to have been suffered in
consequence of the breach of contract. The Court has
also specifically held that in case of breach of some
contracts it may be impossible for the court to assess
compensation arising from breach.
Although the aforesaid case was cited by the Arbitral
Tribunal, it distinguished the same by observing that the
afore:;aid case was silent on the aspect. We need- to accept
the ;rforesaid distinction based on the different set of
circunrstances this case emanates from. In Saw pipes
(supra), the purchaser therein had extended the time for
supplv of goods subject to the specific condition that
purchaser would recover the agreed stipulated damages
from the contractor. Thus, the aspect of waiver is an
important distinguishing factor, which was not dealt with in
tne eE' rlier judgment.
35. Ttris Court cannot interfere with this award, as the award
is a plausible view for the following reasons:
a
gs
CqEtIasL d. The Hish Court and District Court
str,ryed beyond the limita tion under Section 34
and
37 of the Arbitration Act. e. Other aspects
of the
SN, J
wp_38 140_2025
award also do not require interference of this
Court, in view of the law laid down in the
Project Director, National Hiqhways No.45E and
22O, National Highways Authority of India v. M.
Hakeem."
16.
under:30. It is now settled that 'whether time is of the essence in a contract',
has to be culled out from the reading of the entire contract as well as
the surrounding circumstances. Merely having an explicit clause may
not be sufficient to make time the essence of the contract. As the
contract was Spread over a long tenure, the intention of the parties to
provide for extensions surely reinforces the fact that timely
performance was necessary. The fact that such extensions were
granted indicates ONGC's effort to uphold the integrity of the contract
instead of repudiating the same.
ought to have been floated.
L7. In so far as the second plea of the petitioners is concerned,
that as per clause 1 and 16(I), respondent Nos.6 to B are not in
existence for more than 7 years, this plea is untenable, since as
,
/
**.
SN, J
wp 38140 2025
per clause 16(I) the bidder or OEM should be incorporated for
seven (7) years and it is the specific case of the respondent
Nos.6 and 7 that they are the authorized suppliers of the
respondent No.B (OEM) which is established in the year 1960.
18. A tare perusal of clause 16 of the tender document
(referred to and extracted above) clearly indicates that tender
document dated 26.04.2025 categorically permits the authorized
agencies/'authorized dealers of OEM to bid for tender and in case,
the bidd,-.r is an agency or dealer, the turnover of OEM and
dealer/aglency, both shall be considered and further the aforesaid
clause also explicitly makes clear that the tender document
permits the participation of single or multiple dealers of one OEM
in the tender.
19. A trare perusal of the content of Clause 16 (referred to and
extracted above) above clearly indicates that clause 16
prescribers pre-qua lification criteria for bidders and also in all the
sub-clau:;es of Clause-16 mentions it for ,.Bidders/OEM,, and
hence all the clauses read together clearly indicates that one
OEM car authorize two (2) dealers to participate in the tender
and in s;uch case turnover of OEM and agencies both will be
:
i
I
I
SN. J
wp_38140_2025
considered while evaluating their pre-qualification criteria
as per
clause 16 of tender document.
20.
n
r
c
tn
res
nden t No.5 was rn
roora ted onl yin20 22 and hence the
w
I
ffi
n
h
unsustainable.
2L. This Court opines that the present writ petition is not
maintaanable since the Writ petitioners in the present
Writ Petition are chaltenging the action of the state in
entering into Supplementary Agreements with
Respondents Nos. 6 and 7. The petitioners are not party to
the said supplementary agreements and cannot challenge
the same. Seeking to set aside the supptementary
agreements which is contractuat in nature is not
permissible in a Writ petitaon. The petationers are only
challenging the Supptementary Agreements dated
29.L1.2O25 and not challenging the initial agreements
/
rrrl-'
SN, J
wp 38140_2025
dated 29.05.2Q25 and 10.06.2025. Admittedly the initial
agreements are pursuant to awarding the contract to
Responrlent No. 6
and Respondent No.7 and
supplenrentary agreements are only for extension of time
for supply of bunker beds. This Court opines that the
Petitioners without laying any challenge to the 1st
agreement or initial act of awarding the contract to
ResponrJent Nos. 6
to 8 cannot challenge the
supplementa ry agreements.
22. In the Division Bench iudqment of the Hiqh Court of
Patna in Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.14O3O of 2O25
dated 24.09.2O25. under identical circumstances an issue
framed thereunder was decided as hereunder:-
Issue 1: Whether the present writ petition can be
entertained, particularlv when it has been instituted after
the declaration of the result of the financial bid?
The law is well settled that writ iurisdicti,on under
Article 226 is primarily preventive and not curative in
matters relatinq to tenders. Where the tender process has
already reached its loqical conclusion and contractual
riqhts have crvstallized, courts have consistently
SN, J
wp_3 8 I 40_2025
ex rcas ed restr an tin ente
n
a
h
n
d chal lenoes .It
tn tno bela
n
r
action of the State or its instrumentalities is shown to be
viti ted bv mala
des, ar bitrarin ss, or violatio
of
statutorv/constitutional orovisions.
In the present case, the petitioner has approached
this Court only after the declaration of the financial
results and the contract has already been executed, by
which stage a vested right has accrued in favour of
respondent no. 4 and corresponding obligations have
arisen on the part of the University. Interference at this
juncture would not only unsettte a concluded contract but
also cause administrative chaos and financiat loss to the
public exchequer.
In view of the above discussion, this Court is of the
opinion that the writ petition, having been instituted after
the declaration of the financial bid and there is a
subsequent execution of agreement dated 30.09.2025,
and thus, cannot be entertaaned at this stage. The
SN, J
wp_38140 2025
challenge is belated, seeks to unsettle a concluded
contract, and does not warrant interference.
23. This Court, applying the principle laid down in the
above Division Bench judgment of High Court of Patna
under identical circumstances opines that since even in
the present case, the tender process has already reached
its logical conclusion and contractual rights have
crystallized, this Court cannot annul the concluded
contracts and agreements.
24. This Court opines that in view of the fact as borne on
record that the petitioners had not participated in the
tender pursuant to the tender notification dated
26.0,4.2O25, It is settled law that the person who did not
participate in tender cannot challenge the same as they
would not be aggrieved with the action of the tendering
authorit'y in view of the non-participation. The Apex Court
in its catena of judsments had very clearly held that the
person who did not participate in the tender cannot
challenoe the tender. The followinq iudqments qiven
below clearlv indicate reiteration of the said view of the
Apex Court :-
t*-
SN, J
wp_38 | 40_2025
(i) Na tiona! Highways Authority of India vs Gwalior
Jhansi
Expressway Limited, (2018) 8 SCC 243- para
(ii) Shikar Swayamrozgar Seva Sahakari Sanstha
Maryadit Nashik vs Commissionerate Social Welfare, W.p
No 9837 ol 2022- para,s 9 and 11.
(iii) Subir Ghosh vs The State of West Bengat, F.M.A No
91O of 2O2O- (Unnumbered paragraph 5,6 & i)
T
res
nden
of
on
th
are favori q resD ondent Nos.6
to8
and
enablino them to make exorbitant orofits is without anv
basi s, since there is no mate rial on
rde dencin the
same as uroed and alleoed by the petitioners.
26. fn view of the fact as borne on record, the tender
notification and also the agreement categoricaily provides
for extension of time by the state, duty considering the
averments made in the counter affidavit filed by the
Respondent Nos.1 to 3, this Court finds that the pleas put
forth by the petitioners pertaining to variation in the price
is baseless, since as per the tender document, the
consequential main agreement and supplementary
agreement in Clause No.1 to "Annexure for Contract
Agreement", the quantaties to be supplied are purely
tentative/provisional and subiect to change. The quantity
variation clause along with specific clause of extension of
SN, J
wp 38140_2025
time and atso levy of liquidated damages for delay of
supplies, ?s reflected in the tender document, and the
consequential main agreement and the supplementary
agreement clearly indicates that the pleas of the
petitionr:rs on the grounds as alleged in the present Writ
Petition against the official respondent herein are in fact
without any basis.
case:-
under:15. We nray add that the owner or the employer of a project, having
authored the tender documents, is the best person to understand and
appreciatr: its requirements and interpret its documents. The
constitutirtnal Courts must defer to this understanding and appreciation
of the terrder documents, unless there is mala fide or perversity in the
understanding or appreciation or in the application of the terms of the
tender conditions. It is possible that the owner or employer of a
project may give an interpretation to the tender documents that is not
acceptable to the constitutional Courts but that by itself is not a reason
for interferring with the interpretation given.
SN, J
wp_38 t40_2025
t
th
CA
t4 scc s TinJa qdish Mandal Vs. S te of Orissa and
tso se
n
an
r
lar
as un er:-
19. Judicial review of administrative action is intended to prevent
arbitrariness, irrationality, unreasonableness, bias and malafides. Its
purpose is to check whether choice or decision is made ,lawfully, and
not to check whether choice or decision is ,sound'. When the power of
judicial review is invoked in matters relating to tenders or award of
contracts, certain special features should be borne in mind. A contract
is a commercial transaction. Evaluating tenders and awarding contracts
are essentially commercial functions. principles of equity and natural
justice stay at a distance. If the decision relating to awaid of contract
is bona fide and is in public interest, courts will not, in exercise of
power of judicial review, interfere even if a procedural aberration or
error in assessment or prejudice to a tenderer, is made out. The power
of judicial review will not be permitted to be invoked to protect private
interest at the cost of public interest, or to decide contractual disputes,
The tenderer or contractor with a grievance can always seek damages
in a civil court. Attempts by unsuccessful tenderers with imagin6ry
grievances, wounded pride and business rivalry, to make mountaini
out of molehills of some tech n ica l/procedu ral violation or some
prejudice to self, and persuade courts to interfere by exercising power
of judicial review, should be resisted. Such interferences, eitheiinterim
or final, may hold up public works for years, or delay relief and succour
to thousands and millions and may increase the project cost manifold.
Therefore, a court before interfering in tender or contractual matters in
exercise of power of judicial review, should pose to itself the following
questions:
i) Whether the process adopted or decision made by the authority is
mala fide or intended to favour someone.
OR Whether the process adopted or decision made is so arbitrary and
irrational that the court can say : 'the decision is such that no
responsible authority acting reasonably and in accordance with
relevant law could have reached.'
ii) Whether public interest is affected.
3l
SN. J
wp_18t40_2025
If the answers are in the negative, there should be no interference
under Arti(:le 226. Cases involving black-listing or imposition of penal
consequences on a tenderer/contractor or distribution of state largesse
(allotment of sites/shops, grant of licences, dealerships and franchises)
stand on a different footing as they may require a higher degree of
fairness in action.
C. In the iudoment of the Apex Court reoorted in (2O18)
e c?f aa ? i6
Nt+
nt
Hirrh r^rrrrc A!.+ h
ri irr af
Tlrrli-
lrc
Gwalior-f hans Exoresswav Limited, dated 13.O7.2O18 and
in oartic Iar at Para No.2
it is observed a under:-
18. While considering the relief claimed by the respondent (claimant),
the same should have been tested on the touchstone of the principle
governing the tender process, especially when the validity of the
tender do,:ument has not been put in issue or challenged before any
competenl: forum. Going by the terms and conditions in the tender
document:;, as already alluded to in paragraph 8 above, there is no
title of doubt that the right of the claimant (respondent) to match the
bid of L-:1, or to exercise ROFR would come into play only if the
respondert was to pafticipate in the tender process pursuant to the
notice inviting tenders from the interested parties. The objective of
tender process is not only to adhere to a transparent mechanism but
to encourilge competition and give equal opportunity to all tenderers
wlth the end result of getting a fair offer or value for money. The plain
wording of the eligibility clause in the tender documents and the
incidental stipulations make it explicit that the respondent was
required to participate in the tender process by submitting its sealed
bid (techrical and financial). The fact that a deeming clause has been
provided in the tender document that if the respondent was to
participato in the bidding process, it shall be deemed to fulfill all the
requirements of the tender clauses 3 to 6 of the RFP, being the
existing concessionaire of the Project, does not exempt the respondent
from participating in the tender process; rather the tenor of the terms
of the do<:uments made it obligatory for the respondent to participate
in the terder process to be considered as a responsive bidder, along
with others. Having failed to participate in the tender process and,
more so, despite the express terms in the tender documents, validity
whereof has not been challenged, the respondent cannot be heard to
contend that it had acquired any rig ht whatsoever. Onlv th entities
who participate in the tender process oursuant to a tender
notice ca be alloriued to ma ke orievances abo the nonfi rlfillrmarrr
a- k
rah
zrf r n r, .rC flia
iar.rrr< .rt'td
ndit 6ric 6f t h
SN, J
wp_38t40_2025
concerned tender documents. The respondent who chose to
n
af
h
consid ered on the basis of th
t
stated ter s and con itions.
n
r
tender document, the respondent has no case whatsoever.
D. In the iudoment f the Aoex Co rt reoorted in (20201
15 SCC 489 in Silooi Constructions Contractors Vs . Union
of India nd Another, dated 21.06.2019 and in Da rticula r
Dara No.2O, it as observed as under:-
20. The essence of the law
down in the iudoments referred to
above is the exercise of restraint and caution; the need for
overwhelming public interest to justify judicial intervention in matters
of contract involving the state instru mentalities; the courts should give
way to the opinion of the experts unless the decision is totally arbitrary
or unreasonable; the court does not sit like a court of appeal over
the appropriate authoritv; the court must realise that the
authority floatino the tender is the best iudoe of its
reouirements and, therefore, the court's interference should be
minimal. The authority which floats the contract or tender, and has
authored the tender documents is the best judge as to how the
documents have to be interpreted. If two interpretations are possible
then the interpretation of the author must be accepted. The courts
will onlv interfere to orevent arbitrariness, irrationalitv. bias.
mala fides or perversitv.
E. In the iudoment of the ex Court reDorted in (2O16)
15 SCC 272 in Montecarlo Limited Vs. National Thermal
Power Corooratio n Limited. dated 18.10,2015 and in
Darticula r oara No-26. i is oh s erved as under:-
JJ
SN, J
wp_38140_2025
26. We res;pectfully concur with the aforesaid statement of law. We
have reasors to do so. In the present scenario, tenders are floated and
offers are invited for highly complex technical subjects. It requires
understanding and appreciation of the nature of work and the purpose
it is going to serve. It is common knowledge in the competitive
commercia field that technical bids pursuant to the notice inviting
tenders arr: scrutinized by the technical experts and sometimes third
party assisl:ance from those unconnected with the owner's organization
is taken. -fhis ensures objectivity. Bidder's expertise and technical
capability and capacity must be assessed by the experts. In the
matters o{' financial assessment, consultants are appointed. It is
because to check and ascertain that technical ability and the financial
feasibility have sanguinity and are workable and realistic. There is a
multi-pron{l complex approach; highly technical in nature. The tenders
where public largesse is put to auction stand on a different
compartm(lnt. Tender with which we are concerned, is not comparable
to any scleme for allotment. This arena which we have referred
requires technical expertise. Parameters applied are different. Its aim
is to achie,/e high degree of perfection in execution and adherence to
the time st:hedule. But, that does not mean, these tenders will escape
scrutiny ol' judicial review. Exercise of oower of iudicia! review
would be called for if the aooroach is arbitrarv or malafide or
procedure adopted is meant to favour one. The decasion makino
process should clearly show that the said maladies are kept at
bav. But where a decision is taken that is manifestlv an
consonance with the lanouaoe of the tender document or
subserves the purpose for which the tender is floated, the court
should foltow the orinciote of restraint. Technical evaluation or
comparison by the court would be impermissible. The principle that is
applied to scan and understand an ordinary instrument relatable to
contract in other spheres has to be treated differently than interpreting
and appreciating tender documents relating to technical works and
projects rr:quiring special skills. The owner should be allowed to carry
out the prJrpose and there has to be allowance of free play in the
joints.
F. In the iudoment of the Apex Court reoorted in 2O2O
SCC Online SC 1035 in M/s- Galaxv TransDort Aqencies,
Contractors, Traders, TransDorls ard Suppligrs, dated
SN, J
wp_38140_2025
o
lar ar
tn
N
erv
under:14:. In.-" series of judgments, thas Court has
that the
authority that authors the tender aocument i" tfr.hetd
p..*nb6"i
to- understand and appreciate its requirements, and
its
interpretation should not be .".ond_gu-.."d by a thus,
court
in
judicial review proceedings.
Th e afo
u
obs rvati ons of the Aoex Cou
n
a
Ithet
ndi
un
nab le an
s
o
!
a
of
tn
e
ron
al
hi
bv this Co rt sin ethea ction
s
n
f
war
the
c
tcla
sDond nts
in as borne on re rd is tn con sonan
with the
Ian uaoe
the s ubiect tender do cument.
28. Taki nq into
a)
n
hen ce, re iected. This Cou rt ooin es that
o
he
ln the
nsidera on:-
The aforesaid facts and circumstances of the case.
b) The submissions made by the learned counse!
appearing on behalf of the petitioners, learned Additional
Advocate General appearing on behatf of the respondent
Nos.l to 3, learned standing appearing on behalf of the
SN, J
wp_38140_2025
respondent Nos.4 and 5 and learned Senior Designated
Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent Nos.6 to g
on record.
c) The observations in the various Court judgments
(referrerl to and extracted above) which are enlisted
below:-
i. (2OO7) 14 SCC s17
ii. (2018) 8 SCC 243
iii. (2016) 16 SCC 818
iv. (2020) 15 SCC 489
v. (2016) ts sCC 222
vi. 2022(2) SCC page 382
vii. 1994(6) SCC page G51
viii. 2O2O SCC Ontine SC 1O3S
ix. The Division Bench judgment of the High Court
of Patna reported in Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case
No.14O3O of 2O2S dated 24.O9 .2OZS.
d)
Ther discussion and conclusion as arrived at para
Nos.6 to 27 of the present order.
Thi sCo
rto
rnes that the Detitio ners are not
entitled for qrant of the retief as orayed for in the present
writ pet t io n, and the J udqmen ts rel edu nbv the
learned senior desionated counsel appearinq on behalf of
I
I
SN, J
wp_38 I 40_2025
case and accordinoly, the oleas out-forth olacino reliance
court on 11.12.2o25 stand vacated and the writ oetition
is dismissed since the same is devoid of merits. However
there shall be no order as to costs.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this writ petition,
shall stand closed.
SD/- , , P. PONNA KRISHNA
TANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPYII
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC to SRI M.PRANAV, Advocate [OPUC]
2. One CC to SRI B.VAMSHIDHAR REDDY, Advocate IOPUC]
3. One CC to SMT B.KAVITA YADAV, SC FOR CENTRAL GOW. [OPUC]
4. Two CCs to ADDL. ADVOCATE GENERAL, High Court for the State of
Telangana at Hyderabad [OUT]
5. Two CD Copies
BSR
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED' 22101t2026
lrt STAfe
q-
ORDER
()
WP.No.38140 of 2025
t,
a
)
.b
*
* It*:";;;;*)
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION,
WITHOUT COSTS
o
?uF
11 l|ifift
c)
F. !,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review