Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on
Pronounced on
Uploaded on
#
CNR No. DLHC010414002025
+
FAO 175/2025
TEK CHAND & ANR.
Through:
: 28.07.2026
: 15.09.2026
: 15.09.2026
.....Appellants
Mr. Rajan Sood, Ms. Ashima
Sood and Ms. Megha Sood,
Advocates
versus
UNION OF INDIA
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Ashish K. Dixit, CGSC
with Mr. Umar Hashmi,
Advocate
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
1.
The present appeal has been filed under Section 23 of the
Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 against the judgment dated
15.03.2024 passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal, Principal Bench,
Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the “Tribunal”) in Claim Application
No. OA/II(U)/DLI/194/2023, titled as “Sh. Tek Chand &Anr. vs.
Union of India”.
2.
Briefly stated, the claim application came to be filed in the
context of the death of one Himanshu Sharma (hereinafter referred to
as the “deceased”), who, as per the case set up by the appellants before
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 175/2025
the Tribunal, had left his native village on 19.06.2023 to travel from
Gajraula to Dehradun to look for some employment. According to the
appellants, the deceased telephonically informed his father on
20.06.2023 that no suitable work had been arranged at Dehradun and
that he was returning home. It was pleaded that while travelling back
from Dehradun towards Gajraula by train No.14042 (Mussoorie
Express), he accidentally fell from the running train between Fazalpur
and Muzzampur Railway Stations owing to a sudden jerk and rush
inside the compartment, resulting in fatal injuries.
It was further pleaded that during the inquest proceedings, one
journey ticket bearing No.63987978 for his onward travel from
Gajraula to Dehradun dated 19.06.2023, a mobile phone and cash
were recovered from his person. The appellants asserted that although
the return journey ticket could not be recovered, the deceased was
travelling as a bona fide passenger and his death occurred in an
“untoward incident” within the meaning of the Railways Act, 1989
(hereinafter referred to as the “Act”).
3.
Upon appreciation of the evidence, the Tribunal dismissed the
claim and observed that although an onward journey ticket had been
recovered, no return journey ticket was found from the person of the
deceased. The Tribunal further noticed that there was no eye witness
to establish accidental fall from a train and the DRM report also did
not support the appellants’ version. Consequently, the Tribunal held
that neither the status of the deceased as a bona fide passenger nor the
occurrence of an “untoward incident” stood proved.
4.
Assailing the impugned judgment, learned counsel appearing for
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 175/2025
the appellants submits that the Tribunal has treated the non-recovery
of the return journey ticket as conclusive against the appellants,
overlooking the settled legal position that mere absence of a ticket
does not by itself disprove the status of a bona fide passenger (Ref:
Union of India v. Rina Devi1). Learned counsel submits that the
evidence on record establishes that the deceased had travelled from
Gajraula to Dehradun on 19.06.2023, whereafter he informed his
father that he was returning as no employment had been arranged. It is
argued that the recovery of the onward journey ticket from the person
of the deceased lends assurance to this version, and the surrounding
circumstances support the version that the deceased was returning by
train when the incident occurred.
It is further submitted that the DRM report merely records that
no valid ticket relating to the date of occurrence was recovered and
proceeds to conclude that the journey could not be established. It is
argued that once the appellants discharged their initial burden by
leading
evidence
regarding
the
journey
and
the
attendant
circumstances, the burden shifted upon the Railways to disprove the
claim, which has not been done in the present case.
5.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
contended that the only ticket recovered from the deceased pertained
to the onward journey undertaken on 19.06.2023 and there is no
documentary evidence regarding the alleged return journey on
20.06.2023. It is further submitted that there is no eye witness to the
occurrence, the body was found lying between the railway tracks, and
(2019) 3 SCC 572
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 175/2025
the cause of death could not be linked with any accidental fall from a
train. On these premises, it is urged that the Tribunal rightly dismissed
the claim petition.
6.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record, this Court is of the considered view that the controversy
essentially gives rise to two questions, first, whether the material on
record establishes that the deceased was a bona fide passenger at the
time of the occurrence and second, whether the death of the deceased
occurred on account of an “untoward incident” within the meaning of
the Act.
7.
Since the issue of the deceased’s bona fide travel forms the very
foundation of the claim, it would be appropriate to examine the said
aspect in the first instance.
8.
A careful perusal of the record shows that the evidence available
in the present case extends considerably beyond the mere question of
recovery of a ticket. The recovery memo prepared during the inquest
records that, besides a mobile phone and cash, one railway journey
ticket bearing No.63987978 for travel from Gajraula to Dehradun
dated 19.06.2023 was recovered from the person of the deceased. The
same ticket also finds mention in the jamatalashi proceedings, the
investigation papers and the DRM report. Thus, the fact that the
deceased had undertaken the onward journey from Gajraula to
Dehradun immediately preceding the occurrence is not in dispute.
9.
Equally significant is the evidence led by the father of the
deceased, Sh. Tek Chand (AW-1). Although AW-1 admittedly was not
an eye witness to the occurrence, he has consistently stated that the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 175/2025
deceased telephonically informed him on 20.06.2023 that no work had
been arranged at Dehradun and that he was returning home. There is
no cogent material put forward by the respondent so as to show why
this statement should be discarded or suggested any alternative
explanation regarding the presence of the deceased near the railway
track between Fazalpur and Muzzampur in the early hours of
21.06.2023. Significantly, the respondent has neither disputed that
the deceased had travelled to Dehradun on 19.06.2023 nor produced
any material to show that he had not commenced his return journey
therefrom.
10.
In this regard, a gainful reference may be made to the decision
of the Supreme Court in Rina Devi (supra)as well as the recent ruling
in “Lata v. Union of India2”, wherein it was reiterated that the claimant
is only required to discharge the initial burden by placing the
foundational facts on record. In the present case, the appellants have
discharged the said burden by producing the recovered onward journey
ticket, the testimony of AW-1 regarding the return journey and the
official records prepared during the inquest. Beyond pointing to the
non-recovery of the return journey ticket, the respondent has not
produced any evidence to rebut the appellants’ case.
Tested on the aforesaid principles, this Court finds that the
Tribunal proceeded on the premise that since the return journey ticket
was not recovered from the person of the deceased, the appellants had
failed to establish that the deceased was a bona fide passenger. Such
an approach overlooks the law laid down in the aforesaid decisions
2026 SCC OnLine 1350
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 175/2025
and ignores the attendant circumstances. The evidence led by the
appellants sufficiently supports that the deceased had undertaken the
return journey from Dehradun and was travelling by train at the
relevant time. The respondent having failed to rebut the said evidence,
this Court is satisfied that the deceased has been established to be a
bona fide passenger.
11.
Having held that the deceased was a bona fide passenger, the
next question which arises for consideration is whether his death
occurred in an “untoward incident” within the meaning of the Act.
12.
According to the Tribunal, while the body of the deceased was
first noticed by the Loco Pilot of Train No.14119 at about 01:35 hours,
Train No.14042 (Mussoorie Express), by which the deceased was
alleged to have been travelling, crossed the said location only at 01:49
hours. Proceeding on the said premise, the Tribunal held that the
version put forth by the appellants was improbable.
13.
Pertinently, while relying upon the TSR, the Tribunal has
overlooked the complete movement of Train No.14042. The TSR
records that the train reached Muzzampur at 00:50 hours and Fazalpur
at 00:53 hours and thereafter proceeded to Najibabad, where it reached
at 01:02 hours. After its scheduled halt, the train departed from
Najibabad at 01:32 hours and commenced its return journey towards
Fazalpur and Muzzampur. It reached Fazalpur at 01:40 hours and
thereafter Muzzampur at 01:51 hours. Thus, the train was undertaking
a “return loop”, an aspect which has not been considered by the
Tribunal while appreciating the TSR.
14.
Notably, the case of the appellants is that the deceased was
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 175/2025
returning from Dehradun. The movement of Train No.14042 as
recorded in the TSR shows that after reaching Najibabad, the train
returned towards Fazalpur and Muzzampur. The Tribunal, however,
has considered only the fact that the train crossed the concerned
location at 01:49 hours, after the dead body had been noticed at about
01:35 hours, without taking into account its earlier movement through
the same stations between 00:50 and 00:53 hours. The TSR, therefore,
could not have been read in isolation to conclude that the deceased
could not have fallen from Train No.14042.It is pertinent to note that
even the respondent, in its affidavit filed before this Court, has
clarified that Train No.14042, after reaching Najibabad, commenced
its return journey at 01:32 hours towards Fazalpur and thereafter
Muzzampur.
15.
The aforesaid aspect assumes significance as the return
movement of Train No.14042 provides the missing link in the
sequence of events relied upon by the Tribunal. The possibility of the
deceased having fallen during the earlier movement of the train
towards Najibabad, followed by the body being noticed at 01:35
hours, was not duly considered and examined. The subsequent passage
of the same train at 01:49 hours, on its return loop, therefore, could not
by itself be treated as disproving the appellants’ case.
16.
It is well settled that the provisions of the Act are part of a
beneficial legislation. In such matters, compensation cannot be denied
merely because the timings reflected in the TSR do not exactly
correspond with the appellants’ version. The movement of trains and
the time at which the body is first noticed may not always coincide
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 175/2025
with the actual time of the occurrence. In the absence of any positive
evidence to the contrary, such discrepancy by itself cannot defeat a
genuine claim.
17.
Accordingly, the impugned judgment is set aside and the matter
is remanded back to the Tribunal, which is requested to assess the
amount of compensation payable to the appellants in accordance with
law and direct the authorities concerned to disburse the same within
two months from the receipt of a copy of this order. For this purpose,
the matter be listed before the Tribunal at the first instance on
08.10.2026.
18.
The appeal is allowed and disposed of in the above terms.
19.
A copy of this judgment be communicated to the learned
Tribunal.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER15, 2026
na
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:47:52
FAO 175/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review