Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision : 07.01.2026
W.P.(C) 9983/2017 & CM APPL. 69600/2024
LATE TEJPAL SINGH THROUGH LEGAL HEIRs .....Petitioners
Through: Mr. N.S. Dalal, Mr. Aman Mudgal,
Ms. Nidhi Dalal, Mr. Alok Kumar,
Ms. Rachna Dalal, Mr. Karan Mann,
Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Kamal Kant Jha CGSC, Mr.
Avinash Singh, Ms. Aishwarya Deep
Singh and Ms. Aakriti, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J. (ORAL)
1.
This petition has been filed with the following prayers:“(i) Issue an appropriate writ, order or direction thereby
setting aside the illegal and arbitrary order dated
31.01.2016 passed by respondent no.3 vide which
voluntary retirement of the petitioner was ordered to be
cancelled w.e.f 31.01.2016;
(ii) issue an appropriate writ, order or direction thereby
quashing the order dated 20.08.2016 passed by the
respondent no.2 whereby the petitioner was charged with
charge u/s 19(a), 26, 40 and 19(b) of the BSF Act and
ordered to be dismissed from service;
(iii) Issue an appropriate writ, order or direction thereby
setting aside the order dated 09.12.2016 passed by office of
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 9983/2017
the respondent no.1 vide which representation of the
petitioner was rejected;
(iv) Issue an appropriate writ, order or direction thereby
directing the respondents to give Voluntary Retirement to
the petitioner in pursuance to the letter dated 12.01.2016;
(v) Issue an appropriate writ, order or direction thereby
directing the respondents to give all the consequential
benefits to the petitioner in pursuance to the letter dated
12.01.2016 vide which voluntary retirement of the
petitioner was accepted, along with the interest @ 12 %
per annum from 01.02.2016;
(vi) award costs of the present writ petition in favour of the
Petitioner and against the Respondent;
(vii) Pass any such other or further orders as this Hon'ble
Court may deem fit and proper on the facts and in the
circumstances of the case, in favour of the Petitioner and
against the Respondent.”
2.
The original petitioner, Tej Pal Singh who died during the pendency
of this petition, joined BSF as a constable on 15.06.1993. Thereafter, he was
promoted and posted as Head Constable at the Headquarters of 17 Battalion
of the respondents at Alamganj, Dhubri, Assam.
3.
It is the case of original petitioner that in the month of January 2016,
he had suffered from severe pain and swelling in his left knee, went to BSF
Hospital for treatment. During the treatment, it was suggested by the Base
Hospital doctor that, it is a case of left knee effusion with pain & Swelling.
On 08.01.2016, the petitioner was referred to DIG Medical, GHTY, Patgaon
for specialist advice and MRI along with one attendant by the Chief Medical
Officer, SHQ, BSF, Dhubri, Assam. Pursuant to the reference made by the
C.M.O petitioner went to Civil Hospital for his treatment and specialist
advice.
4.
The issue in this petition is with regard to an order dated 31.01.2016
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 9983/2017
passed by the respondents whereby the original petitioner’s voluntary
retirement was cancelled with immediate effect as the he did not resume his
duty after termination of leave on 26.01.2016.
5.
On March, 2016, One Man Court of Inquiry was initiated against the
original petitioner on the charge of overstaying leave. Thereafter, on
21.04.2016, the commandant ordered initiation of disciplinary proceeding.
The original petitioner was issued a show cause notice on 29.05.2016. On
18.08.2016, the original petitioner was issued a charge sheet with the
following charges:“FIRST CHARGE
BSF ACT U/S.19 (a)
ABSENTING HIMSELF WITHOUT LEAVE
in that he;
at Bn HQ Alamganj, on 09.01.2016 at about 1430 hrs at
afternoon fall in time was found absent without leave from
Bn HQ till brought by party of this unit from 125 Bn BSF
Coochbehar to Bn HQ Alamganj on 10.01.2016 (AN).
Total period of AWL 01 days.
SECOND CHARGE
BSF ACT U/S-26 INTOXICATION
In that he, at Coochbehar town, on 09.01.2016 at about
1130 hrs, while absent without leave from this until
consumed liquor and was found intoxicated by party of PS
Kotwali Coochbehar from whom party of 124 Bn BSF took
him to 124 bn HQ at Coochebehar.
THIRD CHARGE
BSF ACT U/S-40
AN ACT PREJUDICIAL TO GGOD ORDER AND
DISCIPLINE OF THE FORCE
In that he,
Having been granted 08 days Casual Leave w.e.f.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 9983/2017
16.01.2016 to 26.01.2016 (AN) to bring papers/documents
to prepare papers for his voluntary retirement, failed
without sufficient cause to resume his duty at Bn HQ 17 Bn
BSF on expiry of the said leave and voluntarily resumed his
duties at Bn HQ Alamganj, Dhubri (Asssam) on 08.06.2016
(FN), when No. 096668834 CT Jagdev Singh of this Bn
went to personally serve the Show Cause Notice (SCN), at
his home address, for his eventual dismissal.”
6.
On 20.08.2016, he received a letter from the authorities whereby the
he was dismissed from the service.
7.
It is the case of the original petitioner that he had already retired from
the service with effect from 01.02.2016 and the same has been confirmed by
the respondents vide letter dated 12.01.2016. Therefore, the order dated
31.01.2016 is erroneous and the dismissal order dated 20.08.2016 need to be
set aside.
8.
Mr. N.S. Dalal, learned Counsel for the original petitioner (and now
of his LR’s) submits that the original petitioner had sought voluntarily
retirement and was informed vide a letter dated 12.01.2016, about the
acceptance of voluntary retirement. He also submits that the original
petitioner was on sanctioned leave from 16.01.2016 to 26.01.2016, and went
to his native place. In the meanwhile, the petitioner fell ill and could not join
back his duties.
9.
As things stood, the original petitioner was in receipt of letter dated
30.01.2026 from the respondents whereby the respondents have called him
to be present on his duty on 31.01.2026, so that necessary documents with
regard to his voluntary pension can be sent to Head Office.
10.
Mr Dalal submits that, once the respondents have called upon the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 9983/2017
original petitioner to be present on 31.01.2026 to enable them to send the
documents with regard to his pension, the respondents could not have
without justifiable reason cancel the voluntary retirement.
11.
He submits that the respondents have perpetuated the illegality by not
releasing the pensionary benefits and also issuing a Charge-Sheet on
18.08.2016, whereby, they have framed charges relatable to the period even
prior to the acceptance of the voluntary retirement. He also submits that the
original petitioner did inform the authorities about his illness. The same was
along with the medical certificate issued by a Government Hospital. Hence,
the charges were clearly unsustainable.
12.
Mr. Dalal submits that, when the respondents themselves have
accepted the voluntary retirement and the deceased employee being on leave
for justifiable reasons between 27.01.2026 to 31.01.2026, the respondents
could not have issued a Charge-Sheet on the ground that he overstayed leave
and also for certain other misdemeanors which the original petitioner said to
have committed much before the voluntary retirement was accepted. He
states that the issuance of the Charge-Sheet and the subsequent action of the
respondents dismissing the original petitioner from service is totally illegal,
harsh and violative of Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
13.
On the other hand, Mr. Kamal Kant Jha, learned Central Government
Standing Counsel for the respondents has by referring to the counteraffidavit filed by the respondents, contends that the original petitioner had
tendered notice on 05.01.2016 for voluntary retirement from service w.e.f.
31.01.2026 along with an undertaking that the deceased employee would not
withdraw his voluntary retirement notice. The notice for voluntary
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 9983/2017
retirement was accepted w.e.f. 31.01.2016. Though a reference is made with
regard to original petitioner committing certain offences, the respondents
have also stated that the original petitioner proceeded on casual leave upto
26.01.2016 but without sufficient cause he has failed to resume his duty on
expiry of the said leave. Since, he did not report from leave, his voluntary
retirement was cancelled on 31.01.2016 and the original petitioner was
accordingly informed. He also states that, since the original petitioner did
not join his duties at the Battalion Headquarter after overstay of 133 days,
the he was proceeded for committing offence under Section 19(a), 26, 40 &
19B of the BSF Act, 1968. The Record of Evidence (RoE) was ordered
against him after due procedure for the offence committed by him. After the
RoE was submitted, the RoE proceedings were duly scrutinised and after
due application of mind, Summary Security Forces Court Trial was ordered,
which resulted in the penalty of dismissal from service. He states that the
penalty of dismissal has been rightly passed after following the due process.
14.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record, there is no denial of the fact that, despite the past record of the
original petitioner, the respondents did accept the request of the original
petitioner for voluntary retirement w.e.f. 31.01.2016 vide order dated
12.01.2016. The respondents had granted leave to him till 26.01.2026.
Appropriately, the original petitioner should have joined his duties on
27.01.2026.
15.
The case of the original petitioner was that on 25.01.2026, he had
informed the respondents about his illness along with medical certificate.
16.
We may state here that, this factum has not been contested by the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 9983/2017
respondents in their reply/counter-affidavit. In this regard, we may
reproduce the stand of the respondents in paragraph 9 of the counter
affidavit, which reads as under:“9. That in reply to the contents of para 9 of the writ
petition, it is submitted that the petitioner had proceeded
on 8 days causal leave w.e.f. 16.01.2015 to 26.01.2016 and
was required to report back on 26.01.2016. Copy of the
movement order is annexed hereto as Annexure R-1.
It is further submitted that the petitioner did not report for
duty in time and overstayed the leave granted to him. Since,
the petitioner did not report from leave timely and was
overstaying from leave, therefore, his voluntary retirement
was cancelled and the petitioner was informed accordingly.
Copy of the order dated 31.01.2016 is annexed hereto as
Annexure R-2.
Analysis of the medical documents so sent by the
petitioner reveals that he was to report back on
26.01.2016 to the unit and for that he had to start journey
for the unit from Raj as than on 23.01.2016. The
petitioner went to the doctor for check up on 25.01.2016
which indicates that he feigned illness with intent to
overstay. His medical certificate of sickness issued by
Govt B.D.K Hospital, Jhunjhunu (Rajasthan) reveal that
he needed rest from 10.02.2016 to 05.06.2016 and he
joined on 08.06.2016. The medical documents so
submitted by the petitioner were examined by the Unit
Medical Officer and the documents were found
insufficient to prove his overstayed from leave. The
petitioner was also indulged in hospital hopping and he
reported back from leave after overstaying on 08.06.2016
(FN).”
(emphasis supplied)
17.
It is noted from the aforesaid stand of the respondents, that the
original petitioner has feigned illness with an intent to overstay but the fact
remains that the medical certificate issued by a Government Hospital at
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 9983/2017
Jhunjhunu has not been rejected/discarded except that the medical
documents submitted by the deceased employee were found to be
insufficient to prove his overstay from leave.
18.
Be that as it may, atleast nothing has been stated by the respondents
that the original petitioner was informed about the rejection of his request
for leave beyond 26.01.2016. It is without rejecting the request for leave, the
respondents without any show cause notice have issued the order dated
31.01.2016 cancelling the voluntary retirement, which according to us is
clearly in violation of the Principles of Natural Justice.
19.
Having said that the question would also arise assuming that the
original petitioner has overstayed his leave for a period of four (4) days,
whether the same could have been the basis for initiating the departmental
enquiry, more so, when they have accepted his request for voluntary
retirement to leave the service. The answer has to be in the negative. The
four (4) days absence is not long enough for the respondents to initiate a
departmental enquiry overlooking the medical certificate issued by a
Government hospital.
20.
Interestingly, we note the subject matter of Charge-Sheet is also
misdemeanors alleged to have been committed by the original petitioner
prior to the acceptance of the voluntary retirement. The respondents could
have instead of accepting the request for voluntary retirement, rejected the
same and initiated the departmental action against the deceased employee
for the misdemeanors. The respondents instead of taking action, on such
misdemeanors have accepted the request for voluntary retirement. Hence,
those alleged misdemeanors could not have been made part of the Charge-
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 9983/2017
Sheet on the principle of estoppel/waiver.
21.
In effect, the said Charge-Sheet has resulted in the dismissal of the
original petitioner from the service of the BSF after he has put in almost 23
years of service. The effect thereof is that the period of 23 years of service
has been forfeited without any benefits. As noted above, the original
petitioner has since expired, leaving his wife and three children (as is clear
from the amended memo of parties).
22.
It is pertinent to note that, in the case of overstay of leave, the
Supreme Court in the case of Union of India & Ors. v. Giriraj Sharma,
AIR 1994 SC 215 has held as under:“1. The respondent who was deputed to undergo a
course as an electrician sought leave for 10 days on
10-12-1982, which was granted. While he was on leave
he sent a telegram for extension of leave by 12 days
which request came to be rejected. The respondent,
however, joined duty on 22-12-1982 thereby
overstaying the period of leave by 12 days (sic 2 days).
For this misdemeanour his services came to be
terminated by an order dated 7-5-1983. His
departmental appeal as well as revision were also
rejected, whereupon he filed a writ petition in the High
Court challenging the order of termination which writ
petition came to be allowed by the order of 3-1-1989.
The petitioner was directed to be reinstated with all
monetary and other service benefits. It is against this
order that the present appeal is preferred.
2. Mr Jain, the learned counsel for the appellant-Union
of India contended that the interpretation placed on
Section 11(1) of the Central Reserve Police Force Act,
1949 (hereinafter called ‘the Act’) is not correct and it
is on account of this erroneous understanding of the
provision that the High Court quashed the order of
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 9983/2017
dismissal. In support of his contention he invited our
attention to a decision of the Rajasthan High Court
reported in Shyamsingh v. Dy. Inspector General of
Police, C.R.P. [AIR 1965 Raj 140 : (1965) 1 LLJ 238]
He also relied on certain other decisions but it is
sufficient to state that according to him the learned
Judges of the High Court had committed an error in
interpreting the said sub-section. In our opinion it is
not necessary for us to construe sub-section (1) of
Section 11 of the Act in the backdrop of the facts of the
present case. Assuming Mr Jain is right, we are of the
opinion that so far as the present case is concerned the
allegation is in regard to the incumbent having
overstayed the period of leave by 12 days. The
incumbent while admitting the fact that he had
overstayed the period of leave had explained the
circumstances in which it was inevitable for him to
continue on leave as he was forced to do so on account
of unexpected circumstances. We are of the opinion
that the punishment of dismissal for overstaying the
period of 12 days in the said circumstances which
have not been controverted in the counter is harsh
since the circumstances show that it was not his
intention to wilfully flout the order, but the
circumstances forced him to do so. In that view of the
matter the learned counsel for the respondent has
fairly conceded that it was open to the authorities to
visit him with a minor penalty, if they so desired, but
a major penalty of dismissal from service was not
called for. We agree with this submission.
3. In the result we see no merit in this appeal but we
would modify the order of the High Court by stating
that while we affirm the High Court's order quashing
the order of dismissal and directing reinstatement in
service with monetary benefits, it will be open to the
department, if it so desires, to visit the respondentpetitioner with a minor punishment. The appeal will
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 9983/2017
stand disposed of accordingly with no order as to
costs. If the reinstatement has not taken place thus far
the department should reinstate him latest within two
weeks from today.”
(emphasis supplied)
23.
This Court in the case of cancellation of voluntary retirement has in
Baikuntha Nath Das v. Union of India and Ors., 2024:DHC:9202-DB,
held as under:“15. In the present case, it is not disputed that the
petitioner, due to his medical conditions, had sought
voluntary retirement by an application dated
05.03.2021. The same was accepted by the
respondents, vide its Order dated 10.06.2021, which
was to be effective from 30.06.2021. It is also not
disputed that the petitioner only wanted a one-month
extension to proceed on voluntary retirement from
31.07.2021 instead of 30.06.2021, maybe for the
reason that he would have earned one increment in the
interregnum, which would have become due and
payable on 01.07.2021. However, in our opinion, only
for this reason, the voluntary retirement of the
petitioner which already stood accepted by the
respondents could not have been cancelled. At best,
the request of the petitioner for postponement of his
date of retirement could have been rejected and he
should have been directed to proceed on voluntary
retirement with effect from 30.06.2021.
16. Accordingly, we direct that the petitioner shall be
considered as having proceeded on voluntary
retirement with effect from 30.06.2021, and all
consequential benefits to the petitioner be released
within a period of 12 weeks from the date the petitioner
completes all formalities for the release of his pension
and other retirement benefits due in accordance with
law.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 9983/2017
17. The departmental proceedings that have been
initiated against the petitioner for his alleged nonreporting at the GC Nagpur, consequent to our above
directions, also stand quashed.”
(emphasis supplied)
24.
In view of the above discussion, we set aside the order dated
31.01.2016 so also the orders dated 28.08.2016 and 09.12.2016. The original
petitioner shall be treated as having voluntary retired on 31.01.2016 and
therefore, shall be entitled to all benefits (subject to adjustment of any
amount paid) with interest at 6% per annum, which shall be paid to the LRs
of the original petitioner who have come on record, as per the rules.
25.
The petition and pending application are disposed of.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
JANUARY 07, 2026/sr
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
14:52:34
W.P.(C) 9983/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review