The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. On examination of the records and the orders passed therein, the same are replete with instances of the errant conduct of the petitioner in the entire proceedings, which had commenced since 2010. No application for setting aside of the ex parte impugned judgment and order was ever filed. Even in the CRP No. 19 of 2018 proceedings with regard to the substitution of the original plaintiff, the petitioner in spite of receipt of notice did not contest the same. On the question of abatement, the original plaintiff had expired when the matter had been reserved for judgment and decree, and as such, by application of Order 22 Rule 6 CPC, there can be no abatement on this ground. The substitution being effected thereafter, therefore, there is no illegality in the judgment and decree as sought to be made out by the petitioner. The only recourse taken by the petitioner after the passing of the final Judgment and Decree, was to somehow frustrate the execution proceedings, on the two grounds raised as aforementioned, i.e abatement of the suit and the question of substitution, which are also the main grounds raised in the instant Revision Petition. In the considered view of this Court, on the facts of this case, these grounds as set up are without any merit. The proceedings before the lower Courts though seeming superfluous, however, no illegality or irregularity, is apparent on the face of …
10. Accordingly, as observed and discussed above, the instant civil revision application stands dismissed and disposed of.
11. No order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
CRP No. 19 of 2018
Date of Decision: 10.10.2023
Smti Taxly Noris Suting
Vs.
Smti Rishalin Mukhim
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. M.F. Qureshi Adv. with
Ms. K. Chisa, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K.S. Kharshiing, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This application under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India has been filed for declaring the Judgment and Order dated
28.08.2015 passed by the Sub-ordinate District Council Court,
Shillong as inexecutable and as a nullity in the eye of law and also
for setting aside the order dated 12.04.2018 passed in MCA No. 17
CRP No. 19 of 2018
of 2012 passed by the Judge, District Council Court and also the
order dated 16.05.2018 passed in Review Misc. Case No. 1 of 2017
by the Additional District Council Court, Shillong. Further prayer
has been made for quashing the entire Execution proceedings being
Execution Case No. 3 of 2015, re-numbered as Execution Case No.
1 of 2018, pending before the Executing Court/Sub-ordinate
District Council Court, Shillong.
2.
The brief background of facts is that the mother of the
respondent since deceased, instituted a Suit being Ejectment Suit
No. 1 of 2010, before the District Council Court against the
petitioner seeking the eviction of the petitioner from the suit
property in question. The Ejectment Suit was not contested by the
petitioner, ostensibly for the reason that the engaged counsel had
withdrawn himself from the case, and as such by order dated
26.09.2011 the same was ordered to proceed ex parte. The plaintiff
and the witnesses then completed their depositions by November
2011, and after filing of written arguments on May 2012, the Suit
was reserved for pronouncement of final Judgment and Decree. It
appears that on the withdrawal of vakalat by the earlier counsel and
on receipt of notice from the Court, the petitioner entered
CRP No. 19 of 2018
appearance and filed a petition for vacating, and for setting aside of
the order for ex parte hearing dated 26.09.2011. The same then
came to be dismissed vide order dated 04.09.2012. It is worthwhile
to note that in the intervening period, while awaiting the
pronouncement of the Judgment and Decree, the original plaintiff
died, and a substitution application was then filed by the
respondent being petition No. 324 of 2012. The petitioner against
the dismissal of the petition for setting aside the order for ex parte
hearing, then preferred a Misc. Civil Appeal being MCA No. 17 of
2012 before the First Appellate Court i.e. the Court of the Judge,
District Council Court, which after hearing the parties, dismissed
the appeal by order dated 03.04.2014, and upheld the order dated
04.09.2012.
3.
The learned Trial Court by Judgment and Decree dated
28.08.2015, then decreed the Ejectment Suit No. 1 of 2010 in
favour of the respondent, whereafter the respondent/decree holder
filed an Execution Case being No. 3 of 2015 before the Trial Court
for Execution of the Judgment and Decree dated 28.08.2015. The
petitioner then preferred a revision petition being CRP No. 6 of
2016, challenging the ex parte judgment on the issues of abatement
CRP No. 19 of 2018
and substitution. Clarification was then sought by this Court, and
on the same being furnished that a substitution had indeed been
filed, this Court then by order dated 13.06.2017, remanded the
matter back to the District Council Court for adjudicating the same.
It appears that the question of substitution, had been re-agitated by
the respondent, which had taken up the matter and the petitioner, in
spite receipt of notice and though given several opportunities, did
not raise any objection against the same, and the substitution was
allowed on 07.02.2017. The order dated 07.02.2017, as it appears
from the records was never challenged by the petitioner. Misc.
Civil Appeal 17 of 2012, filed against the order of ex-parte hearing
was thereafter taken up for consideration by the Judge, District
Council Court and the petitioner despite receipt of notice, failed to
appear and as such by order dated 12.04.2018, MCA No. 17 of
2012 was dismissed, and the records was then endorsed to the SubOrdinate District Court, for execution. The petitioner then filed a
Review being Review Misc Case 1 of 2017, wherein the Court
below affirmed the Judgment and Decree by order dated
16.05.2018. This was again followed by an application which
appears to have been filed sometime in June 2018, in the Execution
CRP No. 19 of 2018
Case, wherein the petitioner sought for dismissal of the Suit, which
however was not entertained.
4.
The petitioner has now preferred this revision under Article
227 of the Constitution of India, seeking interference on the ground
that the Suit should have abated, as substitution was not effected in
the correct procedure.
5.
Heard learned counsels for the parties.
6.
Mr. M.F. Qureshi, learned counsel for the petitioner
has sought to impress upon this Court the factum of procedural
laches by submitting that there has been irregularity in the
proceedings before the Courts below, which has occasioned
miscarriage of justice and has highlighted the orders dated
03.04.2014 passed by the Judge, District Council Court as also the
order dated 12.04.2018 passed by the Additional Judge, District
Council Court, which he contends have effectively taken away the
petitioner’s right under Section 47 CPC.
7.
Mr. K.S. Kharshiing, learned counsel for the
respondent has submitted that the instant case is a classic case of
the deprivation of the fruits of litigation on a judgment and decree
which had been passed as far back as on 28.08.2015, in favour of
CRP No. 19 of 2018
the respondent/plaintiff in Ejectment Suit No. 1 of 2010. On the
question of abatement, it has been submitted that during pendency
of the judgment and order after the proceedings had been
completed, the factum of the death of the original plaintiff had
already been brought on record and was also taken up by the Court
and that the petitioner/judgment debtor in spite of receipt of notice,
never raised any objection to the same. He further submits that the
petitioner by her own conduct has waived whatever right or remedy
she might have possessed, as is evident from the order dated
07.02.2017, passed in Misc. Case No. 18 of 2016, wherein the
petitioner had not appeared and substitution was allowed.
Similarly, it is submitted by order 12.04.2018 passed MCA No. 17
of 2012, on the non-appearance of the petitioner, the Execution
case was then endorsed to the Sub-ordinate District Council Court
for execution. It is finally contended that substantive procedure
having been followed and ample opportunity having been granted
to the petitioner, no case whatsoever has been made out to warrant
any orders, or interference under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India.
CRP No. 19 of 2018
8.
As discussed, and noted in the preceding paragraphs,
the petitioner had not contested the Ejectment Suit and though had
sought for setting aside the ex parte order of hearing dated
20.09.2011, which was also dismissed on appeal, did not take any
other steps to ensure timely action or representation in the matter.
Apart from filing a civil revision before this Court, after the
Execution Case had been filed on the passing of the final judgment
and decree dated 20.08.2015, challenging the ex parte judgment, no
objections on the question of substitution were ever raised, and in
fact, the petitioner neglected to appear before the Courts below as
evident from the records, especially orders dated 07.02.2017 and
12.04.2018. There is therefore no need for this Court to allude to or
to re-examine the judgment and decree, which appears to have been
only reproduced by order dated 16.05. 2018, on a review filed by
the petitioner.
9.
On examination of the records and the orders passed
therein, the same are replete with instances of the errant conduct of
the petitioner in the entire proceedings, which had commenced
since 2010. No application for setting aside of the ex parte
impugned judgment and order was ever filed. Even in the
CRP No. 19 of 2018
proceedings with regard to the substitution of the original plaintiff,
the petitioner in spite of receipt of notice did not contest the same.
On the question of abatement, the original plaintiff had expired
when the matter had been reserved for judgment and decree, and as
such, by application of Order 22 Rule 6 CPC, there can be no
abatement on this ground. The substitution being effected
thereafter, therefore, there is no illegality in the judgment and
decree as sought to be made out by the petitioner. The only
recourse taken by the petitioner after the passing of the final
Judgment and Decree, was to somehow frustrate the execution
proceedings, on the two grounds raised as aforementioned, i.e
abatement of the suit and the question of substitution, which are
also the main grounds raised in the instant Revision Petition. In the
considered view of this Court, on the facts of this case, these
grounds as set up are without any merit. The proceedings before
the lower Courts though seeming superfluous, however, no
illegality or irregularity, is apparent on the face of the records on
these two counts. As such, there being no materials or grounds
present, calling for any interference, the instant revision application
under Article 227, is therefore liable to be rejected.
CRP No. 19 of 2018
10.
Accordingly, as observed and discussed above, the
instant civil revision application stands dismissed and disposed of.
11.
No order as to costs.
12.
Records of the Lower Courts to be transmitted back
immediately.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
10.10.2023
“V. Lyndem PS”
CRP No. 19 of 2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review