The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. 1.2024 charge were framed against accused no. 1, 2 & 3 and till now 2(two) PWs have been examined. In the charge sheet, the no. of cited witnesses are only 8(eight) and out of these, 2(two) witnesses have already been examined. Learned counsel for the petitioner cited a series of Hon’ble Supreme Court’s Judgments regarding the delay in trial. But, the fact of the case in hand and the process taken herein with the facts and circumstances in all the cited cases were not at same footing as such not applicable. On perusal of the process taken by the I.O. from the date of registration of the FIR till now, it is evident that there is no lapses on the part of the prosecution. As such, delay of trial as alleged is not applicable in the present case. For point no. 3, this Court is of the view that for the consideration of this issue, perusal of facts as narrated in the case is required for this matter, the narration made by the Trial Court while framing charge against the 3 accused at para no. 14 & 15 are reproduced herein below; Page 4 “14. So far as the three accused persons (accused no.1, 2 and 3) namely i) Md. Ibungo (36), ii) Md. Atao Rahaman (27) iii) Md. Kudus(23) are concerned, they were allegedly found as the occupants of the bus, which is apparently an interstate bus and travelling together as driver, co-driver and helper of the bus and that a commercial quantity of about 416 …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
LUCY
GURUM
AYUM
Digitally signed
by LUCY
GURUMAYUM
Date:
2024.09.23
15:13:45
+05'30'
Item. 35
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Bail Appln. No. 26 of 2024
Taslima
…Petitioner/s
- Versus Officer in Charge, NAB P.S Manipur
…Respondent/s
B E F OR E
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU
19.09.2024
Heard Mr. S. Jibon, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
and Mr. Samarjit Hawaibam, learned PP appearing for the respondent.
The present bail application has been filed by the petitioner u/s
439 read with Section, 167 of the Cr.P.C praying for releasing the accused
no. 3 (Md. Kudus) on bail in connection with Spl. Trial Case No. 36 of 2023
[Ref:- FIR Case No. 5(3)2023 NAB P.S. U/s 21(C)/25/29 & 60(3) NDPS Act.]
with the following prayers;
“i)
to admit this bail petition,
ii)
to call report from the Officer-in-charge, NAB Police station,
Imphal in connection with the FIR No. 5(3)2023 NAB P.S. u/s
21(c)/25/29 & 60(3) NDPS Act.
iii)
to call report from the Special Judge (NDPS), Manipur in
connection with the Spl. Trial (NDPS) Case No. 36 of 2023.
iv)
to peruse the same.
v)
to pass an order for enlarging the accused on bail on Merit or
on Statutory Bail in connection with the Spl. Trial (NDPS) Case No. 36
of 2023 Ref:- FIR No. 5(3)2023 NAB P.S. u/s 21(c)/25/29 & 60(3)
NDPS Act”.
Page 1
The case of the petitioner is that she is the wife of the accused
no. 3 namely, Md. Kudus who is now in Judicial Custody in connection with
FIR No. 5(3)2023 NAB P.S. u/s 21(c)/25/29 & 60(3) NDPS Act. The accused
Md. Kudus was arrested on 14.03.2023 by the police of NAB PS along with 5
other co-accused. The present accused is at Sl. No. 3. Since then the
accused no. 3 is in judicial custody.
Grounds taken herein by the petitioner are that;
1. The charge sheet was filed incomplete against the
charged 3(three) accused persons; and
2. Delay in trial;
3. The accused is innocent of the charges levels against
him as the only allegation made against him is he is
suspected
to
have
knowledge
in
carrying
some
contraband drug items.
In the counter affidavit filed by the respondent by objecting the
bail application of the petitioner by narrating the prosecution story and
narrated thus;
“…. After reaching North AOC, the team of NAB-PS team started
looking for independent witnesses and found two independent
witnesses who were the staffs of inter-state bus counter, North AOC.
In the meantime, SDC (HQ), Lamphel also arrived and joined with
them. The complainant along with her police team of NAB-PS
proceeded to the bus bir No. MNO04P-0844 which was parked on the
road side opposite to Manipur Public Service Commission, Imphal
along with two independent witnesses and the Magistrate. They
(complainant) introduced themselves as officers’ personnel of NABPS, Executive Magistrate and witnesses to the individuals who were
inside the bus. The driver of the bus, co-driver and one helper of the
Page 2
bus were indentified. On verification, the driver, the co-driver and
one helper of the bus were identified themselves as Md. Ibungo (36)
S/o Md. Khamad Ali, r/o Sangaiyumpham Part-I Nungphou Mamang
Leikai, Md. Atao Rahaman (27) s/o Md. Abdul Malik, r/o Yairipok
Tulihal Mayai Leikai, Imphal East and Md. Kudus (23) s/o (L)
Jalaruddin, r/o Sangalyumpham Mairen Khun, PS & Dist.-Thoubal
respectively. On further verification, they stated that the contraband
items were kept inside the chamber of right side body below the
windows of the vehicle and the contraband items were to be handed
to Md. Nawaz Sharif and Md. Zakir Hussain of Lilong Leihoukhong,
the owner of the vehicle. As such, in presence of the Executive
Magistrate and Independent witnesses and at the instance of the
three individuals, the chamber of the right side body below the
windows near seat number 29 and 30 was opened by using screw
driver and found 17 soap cases containing suspected Heroin powder
in transparent polythene pouches and marked as 1, 2, 3, 4...........and
17 for identification. Further, on the checking another chamber of the
right side body below the windows near seat number 21 and 22 and
found 16 soap cases …………………………………………………………………
……… One brown colour wallet containing one Aadhar Card in the
name of Md. Kudus, one HDFC ATM Card b/card No.
6521660249994482 and Rs. 140/- (1x100, 1x20, 2x10) were seized
on production by Md. Kudus at 2.50 pm by observing formalities.
Further the said three individuals were arrested by observing
formalities at 3.00 p.m., 3.05 pm and 3.10 pm respectively. Hence
the arrested persons along with seized items are handed over for
taking necessary legal actions against them."
Perused the application with counter affidavit filed by the
respondent and also perused the charge sheet submitted by the I.O of the
case and on perusal of the contents of the charge sheet, it was mentioned
that “Further the Hon’ble court is prayed to kindly allow me to
submit supplementary charge sheet against the co-accused persons
if any clue/evidence comes in light in future”. On perusal of these
lines it is seen and evident that supplementary charge sheet as mentioned in
these lines is not for the present accused i.e accused no. 1, 2 and 3 but for
the co-accused who were absconding at the moment.
Page 3
In these facts and circumstances, the ground taken by the
learned counsel for the petitioner that the charge sheet filed against the
present accused i.e. 1, 2 & 3 are incomplete, has no merit.
And for the delay in trial, it is an admitted fact that the FIR was
registered on 14.03.2023 and thereafter, arrested the accused involved in
the present case and charge sheet was filed by the I.O of the case before
the Trial Court on 12.07.2023 after completing the investigation. On
16.1.2024 charge were framed against accused no. 1, 2 & 3 and till now
2(two) PWs have been examined. In the charge sheet, the no. of cited
witnesses are only 8(eight) and out of these, 2(two) witnesses have already
been examined.
Learned counsel for the petitioner cited a series of Hon’ble
Supreme Court’s Judgments regarding the delay in trial. But, the fact of the
case in hand and the process taken herein with the facts and circumstances
in all the cited cases were not at same footing as such not applicable. On
perusal of the process taken by the I.O. from the date of registration of the
FIR till now, it is evident that there is no lapses on the part of the
prosecution. As such, delay of trial as alleged is not applicable in the present
case.
For point no. 3, this Court is of the view that for the
consideration of this issue, perusal of facts as narrated in the case is required
for this matter, the narration made by the Trial Court while framing charge
against the 3 accused at para no. 14 & 15 are reproduced herein below;
Page 4
“14. So far as the three accused persons (accused no.1, 2 and 3)
namely i) Md. Ibungo (36), ii) Md. Atao Rahaman (27) iii) Md.
Kudus(23) are concerned, they were allegedly found as the
occupants of the bus, which is apparently an interstate bus and
travelling together as driver, co-driver and helper of the bus and that
a commercial quantity of about 416 gms of suspected heroin powder
was allegedly recovered from secret modified chambers of the said
bus. The alleged fact that the two accused persons No.2 and 3 had
no knowledge about the said contraband cannot be believed at this
stage. There is nothing at this stage to show even on face value that
they might not have the knowledge of the existence of the
contraband drugs inside the bus. If it is the case of the accused
persons that they have no knowledge about the said contraband
drugs, then it is for them to prove the said absence of their
knowledge by adducing evidence during the trial.
15 In my opinion, at this stage, there are sufficient material showing
prima facie case for framing charge for commission of the offences
under Section 21(C) r/w S:29 of the ND&PS Act as against the said
three accused persons (accused no.1, 2 and 3). Hence the prayer
made by Ld. Counsel for accused No.2 and 3 for discharging them
from the case is hereby rejected.”
On perusal of the para 14 & 15 of the order mentioned above,
the Ld. Trial Court, while framing of charge of the accused involved in the
case, considered the facts of the case and elaborated well and after
considering these facts the Trial Court come to the conclusion that a prima
facie for framing charge of offences under Section 21(C) r/w S: 29 of the
ND&PS Act as against the said three accused persons (accused no.1, 2 and
3).
After going through all these facts, this Court is of the
considered view that necessary trial of the present accused no. 1, 2 & 3 is
called for proving the case. Accordingly, it is observed that the plea of the
accused/petitioner as innocent to the charges leveled against him proved
futile at this stage.
Page 5
Taking into consideration of all these facts as discussed above,
the present bail application filed by the petitioner has no merit. Accordingly,
the present application is dismissed.
As requested by the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
petitioner is given liberty to approach this Court, if the Trial Court failed to
conclude the trial expeditiously and accordingly directed the learned Trial
Court to conclude the examination of PWs as well as trial expeditiously as far
as possible.
JUDGE
Lucy
Page 6
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review