Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 10.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010430172026
+
CM(M) 2002/2026, CM APPL. 61708/2026 (Ex. From filing
the certified copies of the annexures) & CM APPL. 61709/2026
(Stay)
TARUSHI RATHORE
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Vineet Jain, Advocate.
versus
SANJAY RATHORE
Through:
.....Respondent
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
%
1.
JUDGEMENT (Oral)
The present Petition has been filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India, 1950, seeking to set aside the Order dated
12.08.2026 [“Impugned Order”] passed by the learned Judge,
Family Court-02, Central, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi [“learned Family
Court”], in HMA No. 805/2023, whereby the learned Family Court
has directed that the evidence be recorded before the learned Local
Commissioner.
2.
The learned Family Court has, in the Judgment Impugned, also
set out in detail the manner in which the entire evidence is to be
carried out, which reads as follows:
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
19:30:40
CM(M) 2002/2026
3.1. Assignment of case by court for recording of evidence3.1.1. Schedule of Evidence- Evidence shall be recorded preferably
on the day & time fixed by ld. Commissioner. If it is not possible on
the same day, then on the next day. Evidence shall continue on say to
day basis, till conclusion. Any alteration in schedule or recording of
evidence, if needed, shall be decided by the Ld. Commissioner, after
consulting all concerned.
3.1.2. Judicial File not to be sent- It is clarified that the judicial file
shall not be sent or summoned for recording of evidence by the Ld.
Commissioner.
3.1.3. Production of Documents for Cross-examination- In case
the opposite side is desirous of production of any document by the
witness or any other entity for the purpose of cross examination,
including the documents which is already deposited in this court by a
party, an application requesting the same shall be moved before this
court expeditiously as per law.
3.2. Recording of evidence by the Commissioner3.2.1. Place and Time- Ld. Commissioner, shall record evidence
only in the Tis Hazari Court Complex at the address agreed in
writing by both sides within one week of this order. But in case both
side parties so agree and give in writing to the Ld. Commissioner,
within one week of this order, then such evidence can be recorded at
any other Court complex in Delhi (eg. Patiala House Court complex,
Karkardooma Court complex). But in any case such place shall nat
be other than a court complex in Delhi.
3.2.1.1. In case, both the parties failed to agree/fumish a particular
place within one week, then LC shall be at liberty to decide the exact
place, subject to parameters mentioned above. Id. Commissioner
shall intimate suitably both sides as well as this court in this regard.
3.2.1.2. Evidence shall be generally recorded between 10.00 AM to
5.00 PM. It can carry on beyond 5.00 PM as well in case both parties
agree. It can even be recorded on a holiday if all the stake holder are
comfortable and agreeable.
3.2.2. Chronology of Recording- Ld. Commissioner shall proceed
to record the examination by first recording the deposition of party to
present petition, before examining other witnesses.
3.2.3. Oath to Witnesses- Ld. Commissioner shall give cach to the
witnesses under examination as a delegate of the Court as per Oaths
Act.
3.2.4. Recording of Evidence- The evidence shall be preferably
typed on a computer or in case of non- availability shall be neatly
hand written.
3.2.5. Time Frame:3.2.5.1. Petitioner shall supply advance copy of examination in chief
by way of affidavit of claimant (s) as well as his "non summoned"
witness (s), il any within ten days from today to other parties.
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
19:30:40
CM(M) 2002/2026
3.2.5.2. Likewise, after conclusion of recording of claimants/
petitioner side evidence, thereafter within next two werks,
respondent side shall supply advance cop of examination in chief by
way of affidavit of respondent (s) as well as his "non summoned"
witness (s), if any to other parties.
3.2.5.3. Ld. Commissioner shall conclude-the recording of evidence
preferably on the same day on within shortest time possible, but not
later than within 30 days of assignment of a case, which is
extendable by the order of this count by another 15 days in case the
evidence is not concluded despite best efforts, only if application is
moved before this court by any of the parties or Ld. LC.
3.2.5.4. Both Claiman/Petitioner's evidence and respondent's
evidence shall be conclucied within 15 days each of initiation In case
there are more than two witnesses for each side, one week per
witness may be added to the 7 days period.
3.2.6. Comfortable Sitting Space- All the witnesses and their Ld.
Counsel shall be provided comforable sitting space by coordination
with both side Ld. counsels.
3.2.7. Exhibition of Documents- Ld. Commissioner shall exhibit
all the documents sought to be proved by a party on record. In
case of any objection to exhibition of the documents by the either
side, the objection shall be recorded in some detail and left open
and admissibility of such document shall be decided by the
referral Court at final stage.
3.2.8. Original Documents to be Retained by Parties- Ld.
Commissioner shall make an observation in the record of evidence
of all original documents produced and he shall sign the exhibits
with an endorsement OSR original seen & returned) wherever
necessary ie. if any new documents produced as per law for first time
directly before Ld. L.C.
3.2.9. English Language- On the first date, when all the concerned
parties appear before the Commissioner he shall proceed lo record
the cross-examination and re-examination, if any, of a witness in
English language.
7.2.10. Adjournments- Once started the cross-examination shall be
continued on day to day basis. In case of any hardship viz. ill health,
either case can be deferred, at the discretion of the Ld.
Commissioner.
3.2.11. Question-Answers- On the request of Id. Counsel crossexamining the witness, portions of deposition may be recorded in
question-answer form, if the l d. Commissioner deem it fit and
necessary.
3.2.12. Recording of Objections- All the objections raised during
cross-examination/re-examination shall be recorded in the deposition
under titled objections and shall be left open for thie decision of the
Coon at the stage of final arguments, Witness shall not refuse to the
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
19:30:40
CM(M) 2002/2026
answer the question raised on this account only3.2.13. Questions to be allowed- In case Ld. Commissioner finds
any question not related to the face and issue, he shall record his
objection, but shall allow the question to be put and witness must
answer.
3.2.14. Assisting the Witness- In case witness is unable to
understand the question put to him, Ld. Commissioner shall
elaborate the same in an easy to understand manner in an impartial
way.
3.2.15. No Third Person Intervention- Ld, Commissioner shall
ensure that the witness is not assisted by his Ld. Counsel or any
other third party while under cross-examination by way of verbal or
non-verbal communication.
3.2.16. Recording of Demeanor of Witness- Id. Commissioner shal
record the demeanor of the witness where ever it is found pertinent
aad necessary for sharing with the Court.
3.2.17. Witness to sign all pages- Ld. Commissioner shall obtain
signatures of both the sides on each and every page of recording of
evidence apart from signing them himself. In case the witness refuse
to sign, the Ld. Commissioner will still himself sign all such pages
after noting that witness refused to sign. Ld. Commissioner shall
record reasons, if any, stated by the witness for refusal to sign.
3.2.18. Copy of Evidence- All interested parties shall be provided
uncertified copy of the evidence recorded, free of cost.
3.2.19. Safe keep of Original Deposition- ld. Commissioner shall
keep the original depositions in his safe custody till such time they
are filed in the Court in original upon completion of each witness
individually.
3.2.20. Miscellaneous Proceedings- Ld. Commissioner shall
maintain a miscellaneous proceeding sheet for each day of work and
shall submit it in the Court with the report.
3.2.21. Hostile Witness- In case a witness is sought to be declared
hostile, than Ld. I.C. shall refer both the parties to Court within three
days for exercising powers U/s. 154 Evidence Act.
3.2.22. Filing of list of witnesses- Both sides shall file list of
witnesses preferably within 7 Days but not later than 2 week of
identification of issues before this court ,while sharing an
advanced copy thereof with the opposite Party/Parties.
3.2.23. If so desired for the purpose of such evidence only, the
original documents on record of Court, be released to the parties in
lieu of photocopies for such purpose, as per the provision of CPC.
3.3. Summoning of Official Witnesses:
3.3.1. Summons from Court- In case a litigating party is desirous of
summoning an official witness, it shall obtain summons from the
Court with an endorsement that witness shall appear before the
address of Ld, Commissioner for recording of evidence on scheduled
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
19:30:40
CM(M) 2002/2026
date, time and place.
3.4. Advisory to Ld. Commissioner3.4.1. Impartial- Ld. Commissioner shall conduct himself in an
impartial way and behave in an indiscriminate manner while
recording of evidence.
3.4.2. Confidentiality- Ld. Commissioner shall maintain
confidentiality during the whole process.
3.4.3. Integrity- Ld. Commissioner shall not except remuneration or
any favour in cash or kind from the parties over and above the
amount fixed by the Court.
3.4.5. Non-judgmental- Ld. Commissioner shall not criticize the
professional conduct of litigating parties, lawyers on their
understanding of law of either of the parties or ridicule them in any
manner.
3.4.6. Coordination- In case of any foreseen circumstances
warranting change of dates of bearing, for his own case or the
request of other side, he shall apprise the other side in advance via
phone call, email, sms etc
3.4.7. No Third Party Sharing-He shall not allow the deposition to
be inspected by any third party and shall not share a copy thereof
with anybody stranger without permission of the Court.
3.4.8 Inspection- He shall not allow any party 10 inspect the
recorded proceedings in his absence.
3.4.9. Recusal - In case either of the parties or Counsel for the
parties are related or closely known to Court Commissioner, he/she
shall recuse self from the case and inform the referral Tribunal.
3.5. Remuneration of Ld. Commissioner
3.5.1. Quantum- The remuneration for the purposes of
Commissioner need to be fixed by the Court. Remuneration of Ld.
L.C, shall be Rs. 10,000/- one sitting per day (maximurn of 3 hours),
if such witness is Petition/Respondent/party to the petition/suit, If
evidence is extended beyond 3 hours, then Rs. 2,500/- per is to be
paid for each additional hour on such sitting on same day.
Remuneration of Ld. LC shall be Rs.5,000/- per witness, for any
other public witness. Remuneration of Ld. LO shall be Rs.2000/-per
witness, for any other /official/Formal witness.
3.5.1.1 It is further made clear that in case the witness is present
but there is a adjournment sought for any reason without advance
intimation to LC and other side or such adjournment is not
accommodated in advance then the cost of burden of that
particular day of the commission shall be borne by respondent's
side.
3.5.2. Mode of Payment- Such remuneration shall be paid by the
petitioner directly either by way of cash, cheque or draft against due
receipt.
3.5.3. For this purpose, the ld. Local Commissioner shall provide
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
19:30:40
CM(M) 2002/2026
cash receipt/his bank account / online payment details to the
respondent side so that payment through electronic mode can be
made by the respondent side, if so desired.
3.5.4. Cost to Parties - Each side party shall bear the cost of leading
his/her own side evidence through L.C.
3.5.6. The Stenographer, infrastructure and incidental
matters/issues/items con either be arranged by the Party concerned
who is leading the evidence through LC at his/her own cost, or by
the Ld. Commissioner.
In case the same is arranged by Ld. Commissioner, then the cost of
Stenographer, infrastructure and incidental issues/items/matters, if
any, shall be reimbursed by Party concerned who is leading the
evidence through LC to Ld. Commissioner @ Rs.2,000/- Per witness
if witness is petitioner or respondent and Rs.7,500/- per witness for
any other witness.
3.6. Judicial Intervention during recording of evidence3.6.1. Parties to Cooperate- It is expected that both the sides will
cooperate with Ld. Commissioner as well as each other and recond
evidence in a peaceful manner.
3.6.2. Dissolution of stalemate- In case of any conflicting
circumstances they shall resolve issues at their own level with the
active help of Ld. Commissioner.
3.6.3. Court Intervention- However, in case of any unforeseen
situation requiring judicial intervention, Ld. Commissioner shall lix
date and time for joint appearance of both sides before the Court for
removal of any such impediments
3.6.4. Closure of Evidence - In case a Party fails to Examine any
Witness despite opportunity, the Court Commissioner or the opposite
Party can request this Court to close the right of the defaulting party
to lead Evidence.
3.7. Miscellaneous Applications3.7.1. Moving the Application- In case either of the party is
desirous of moving any miscellaneous application viz, amending of
pleadings, interin injunction ete. they shall share an advance copy
with the opposite side and reply thereof, if any, shall be prepared
within seven days.
3.7.2. Date of Hearing- Upon receipt of reply, both the sides shall
get the application fixed for disposal in the Court in with the help of
the Reader of the Court and shall not wait till next date fixed for
hearing. All such miscellaneous applications shall-be separately
registered, numbered and indexed as an extension of main suit
number.
3.7.3. Evidence not to be stalled- It is clarified that, unless Id
Counsel is of the view that the application is such that evidence
cannot be recorded before its disposal, the recording of PE/RE shall
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
19:30:40
CM(M) 2002/2026
continue unabatedly.
3.7.4. Ld. Counsels/or their Parties shall contact the ld.
Commissioner within one week from today. Thereafter, La.
commissioner shall fix the date(s) for recording evidence and
intimate the parties and/or their counsels suitably, apart from
finalizing the place of recording evidence in view of directions
mentioned above. The reader/ahlmad of this court shall send a copy
of this order to Ld LC. Commissioner through email or electronic
mode/WhatsApp etc on the mobile number of the Ld. L.C.”
3.
Learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner, at the outset,
submits that the Petitioner is not seeking to impugn the appointment
of the learned Local Commissioner. He, however, submits that, having
regard to the nature and conduct of the Respondent, it would be
appropriate if the evidence is recorded in the Courtroom, where the
learned Presiding Judge would be available to intervene in the event
any dispute or issue arises during the recording of evidence, and
thereby facilitate the smooth conduct of the proceedings.
4.
This Court is not convinced that such a course of action would
be practicable, particularly when the learned Family Court is required
to function as a regular Court and hear matters on its board. It is quite
possible that repeated interventions may be required during the
recording of evidence, which may, in turn, impede the learned Judge
in discharging the other judicial functions of the Court.
5.
This Court also notes that the Impugned Order, as extracted
hereinabove, is fairly elaborate and takes into account various
eventualities which may arise during the recording of evidence,
including the summoning of documents, if so required.
6.
This Court is, therefore, of the view that, though the submission
advanced by learned counsel is forthright, the suggestion may not be
practical in nature. In any event, the prayer made in the present
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
19:30:40
CM(M) 2002/2026
Petition is for setting aside the Impugned Order in its entirety.
7.
The suggestion articulated before this Court can, however,
always be placed before the learned Family Court in an appropriate
manner, and the learned Family Court may consider the same, if so
warranted, in the course of the proceedings.
8.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner further submits that the
aforesaid suggestion is also in line with the provisions of Order XVIII
Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which, according to him,
contemplate that, where the appeal is allowed, the evidence of
witnesses is to be recorded either in the presence or under the personal
directions and superintendence of the Judge.
9.
Prima facie, this Court is of the view that such an interpretation
would render the provisions of Order XVIII Rule 4(2) of the CPC
otiose and unworkable.
10.
Nonetheless, these are aspects which, if raised before the
learned Family Court, may be considered in appropriate proceedings.
11.
The present Petition, along with all pending application(s), if
any, stands disposed of.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
SEPTEMBER 10, 2026/v/jk
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
19:30:40
CM(M) 2002/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review