Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRR-3288-2025 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
CRR-3288-2025 (O&M)
Reserved on : 01.05.2026
Pronounced on : 21.05.2026
Tarsem Singh & Ors.
..... Petitioners
VERSUS
State of Punjab
..... Respondent
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SURYA PARTAP SINGH
Argued by : Mr. B.S. Sidhu, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Chandan Singh and Ms. Reema, Advocates
for the petitioners.
Mr. Jasdev Singh Thind, DAG Punjab.
SURYA PARTAP SINGH, J.
*****
This is a revision petition against the order dated 28.08.2025,
hereinafter being referred to as ‘impugned order’ only, passed by the Court
of learned Additional Sessions Judge Sri Muktsar Sahib, hereinafter being
referred to as ‘trial Court’ only.
2.
By virtue of abovementioned order, the learned trial Court has
framed the charges against the petitioners and passed the following order:“Challan received by way of entrustment after commitment. It
be registered. Heard on the question of charge. From the
perusal of report under Section 173 CrPC and documents
attached therewith, prima facie offence punishable under
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.05.21 18:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-3288-2025 (O&M)
Sections 105, 11892), 3(5) of BNS and Section 9(B) of
Explosive Act and Section 92 of Factory Act is found to have
been made out against the accused. Accordingly, accused have
been charge sheeted thereunder and contents thereof have been
read over and explained to them, to which they did not plead
guilty and claimed trial. Now, prosecution witnesses be
summoned for 23.10.2025.”
3.
The abovementioned order has been passed in the backdrop of
the fact that for the commission of offence punishable under Sections 105,
118(2), 3(5) of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, Sections 9, 9B and 12 of the
Explosives Act and Section 92 of the Factories Act, FIR No.129 dated
30.05.2025 was lodged in Police Station Lambi, District Sri Muktsar Sahib.
4.
The petitioner is aggrieved of the abovementioned order, for
framing of charges. The challenge to the abovementioned order is primarily
on the ground that the petitioners have been prosecuted by the Investigating
Agency, and thereafter charge-sheeted by the learned trial Court, without
any legal basis. According to petitioners, as per contents of the charge-sheet
itself, petitioner No.1 has nothing to do with the commission of crime as he
was not running the business/factory, and secondly, because on the basis of
contents of report under Section 193 of ‘Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023’, hereinafter being referred to as ‘BNSS’ only, filed by the
police, the offence under Section 105 of BNS is not made out.
5.
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.05.21 18:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Heard.
CRR-3288-2025 (O&M)
6.
It has been contended by learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners that initially the petitioners No.1 and 2 were arrested in this case,
and thereafter, name of petitioner No.3 was added on the basis of disclosure
statements of his co-accused. According to learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners, the learned trial Court has framed charges against the petitioners
in a routine and mechanical manner. As per learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners, the final report under Section 193 of BNSS clearly shows that
the Investigating Agency has failed to collect any material indicating
intention or knowledge on the part of the petitioners, which are mandatory
ingredients for constituting offences under Sections 105 and 118(2) of BNS.
The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner has further contended that in
the absence of such mens rea, the framing of charges under the abovesaid
provisions is wholly unsustainable in law.
7.
It has also been contended by learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners that as per case of the prosecution, the petitioner No.1 was the
owner of the land underneath the factory and that the petitioner No.2 was
running the factory, whereas the petitioner No.3 was supplying labour & raw
material. According to learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners, the
allegation of the prosecution that the factory was being run without any
licence, permit or safety measures, is factually incorrect and contrary to the
documentary evidence on record.
8.
It has been further contended by learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners that the facts and evidence do not disclose the commission of
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.05.21 18:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-3288-2025 (O&M)
offence of culpable homicide not amounting to murder and that at the most,
the allegations may constitute negligence, but by no stretch of imagination, it
can attract Section 105 of BNS. According to learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners, the impugned order reflects complete non-application of judicial
mind.
9.
In support of his arguments, the learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners has referred to the observations recorded by this Court in the case
of ‘Inderjit Singh V/s State of Punjab’ CRR-4804-2018. In the
abovementioned case, almost identical incident, i.e. fire in the factory, meant
for manufacturing of plastic goods, had taken place and two persons died. In
the abovementioned case, it has been observed that instead of Section 304 of
IPC read with Section 92 of Factories Act, the offence under Section 304A
of IPC read with Section 92 of Factories Act is made out.
10.
The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has also referred
to the principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
the case of ‘Nitinchandra Somnath Raval V/s State of Gujarat & Ors.’
2020(2) SCC (Cri) 130. In the abovementioned case, while defining the
circumstances, where the offence of culpable homicide not amounting to
murder is made out, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that ‘for the
abovementioned offence, it has to be established that the act done by the
accused by which the death is caused is done with the intention of causing
death, or of causing such bodily injury as is likely to cause death; or in the
alternative, it is done with the knowledge that it is likely to cause death, but
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.05.21 18:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-3288-2025 (O&M)
without any intention to cause death, or to cause such bodily injury as is
likely to cause death. In the second part punishment prescribed is lesser than
the first part’.
11.
During the course of arguments, the learned Senior Counsel for
the petitioners has also relied upon the observations recorded by the
Coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of ‘Dhanpreet Singh & Anr. V/s
State of Punjab’ 2022(3) RCR (Criminal) 718. In the abovementioned case,
due to breaking of nut-bolt studs, a heavy press weighing four quintal fell
down and injured three workers. The owner of the factory got the workers
admitted in hospital, but two of them died as a result of injury sustained by
them. In the abovementioned case, charge for the commission of offence
punishable under Section 304 IPC was framed by the learned trial Court.
However, this Court observed that ‘forcing a person to undergo criminal
prosecution without noticing as to whether any criminal case is made out
against a person on the strength of the material and evidence collected by the
prosecution itself is a perpetuation of injustice. This Court further observed
that a Court of law cannot refuse to examine the existence of prima facie
evidence and as to whether such evidence would support the continuation of
proceedings against the petitioner or not on a pretext that such issue is to be
examined at the stage of trial. A plea of defence cannot be looked into by the
Revisional Court especially when such plea is sought to be established by
any other evidence or document which is yet to be proved in accordance
with law. The said aspect however does not apply to the evidence collected
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.05.21 18:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-3288-2025 (O&M)
by the Investigating Agency and sought to be relied upon by the agency for
proving its case against an accused’.
12.
The observations recorded by the High Court of Karnataka in
the case of ‘Ramdas Narayan Ghoprade & Ors. V/s State of Karnataka &
Anr.’ 2025 SCC OnLine Kar 16657, have also been relied upon by the
learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners. In the abovementioned case, with
regard to an incident of explosion in the factory on 29.08.2018, one
complaint under Section 92 of Factories Act was filed and in addition to
above, the FIR under Section 304 of IPC was also lodged. The High Court
of Karnataka in the abovementioned case quashed the FIR under Section 304
of IPC.
13.
In view of above, while assailing the impugned order, it has
been contended by learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners that firstly, the
petitioner No.1 has nothing to do with the running of factory in the
abovementioned land, as the same was being run by the son of petitioner
No.1, and the petitioner No.1 was only the owner of the land, underneath the
factory and secondly, the act/omission, which resulted into blast, does not
constitute an offence under Section 304 of IPC. In view of above, the
learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has urged that there is immediate
need for interference and indulgence in the finding recorded by the learned
trial Court in the impugned order. Thus, it has been prayed by learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioners that by accepting the present revision petition, the
impugned order be set aside and the petitioners be discharged.
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.05.21 18:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-3288-2025 (O&M)
14.
The abovementioned arguments have been controverted by the
learned State Counsel. The learned State Counsel has contended that in the
present case, very specific and categorical allegations have been levelled
against the petitioner qua the fact that the land underneath the factory
belongs to the petitioner No.1, and that the factory was being run by the
petitioners jointly. As per learned State Counsel, the abovementioned factory
meant for manufacturing fire crackers was being run in an illegal manner,
without any safety measures installed therein and without obtaining requisite
permit or licence. According to learned State Counsel, on account of
abovementioned deliberate omission on the part of petitioners, the explosion
took place in the abovementioned factory, in the night on 30.05.2025,
resulting into injuries on the person of more than 42 workers. As per learned
State Counsel, out of abovesaid 42 workers, five injured workers passed
away due to the injuries suffered by them.
15.
While defending the impugned order, it has been contended by
learned State Counsel that since the factory was being run in an illegal
manner, without any permit or licence and without installation of safety
measures, the offence under Section 304 of IPC is made out in the present
case. In addition to above, the learned State Counsel has also contended that
no ground for interference in the observations recorded by the learned trial
Court is made out, and that the present petition being devoid of merit
deserves dismissal.
16.
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.05.21 18:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
The record has been perused carefully.
CRR-3288-2025 (O&M)
17.
A careful perusal of record shows that in the present case, the
abovementioned FIR came into being when ‘SI Karamjeet Kaur’ got a tipoff that an illegal factory, for the production of firecracker, was being run at
Malout-Bathinda bypass, by Tarsem Singh, his wife ‘Sukhchain Kaur’ and
son ‘Navraj Singh’. It was also informed that in the abovementioned factory,
numerous migrant labourers were working. According to above-named
police officer, the informer also told him, that in the preceding night of
30.05.2025, a blast had taken place in the abovementioned factory due to
which number of migrant labourers had buried under the debris, and few of
them passed away.
18.
It is also relevant to mention here that after investigation of
case, the final report has been submitted by the police and in the final report,
very specific role has been assigned to the petitioners. According to
prosecution, the petitioner No.1 has a vital role in the entire case, as he was
owner of the land on which the factory meant for manufacturing of
firecrackers was being run without any permit or licence.
19.
It has also been alleged by the prosecution that the requisite
safety measures were not installed in the abovementioned factory and thus,
due to abovementioned deliberate act, vis-à-vis the omission, on the part of
the petitioners, the abovementioned incident had taken place.
20.
A perusal of record shows that there is nothing on record to
show that the petitioner No.1 was not having any responsibility/share in the
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.05.21 18:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-3288-2025 (O&M)
abovementioned factory and if it is so, then it can be the subject matter of
defence evidence only, which has to be led during the course of trial.
21.
As far as the observations recorded by this Court in the case of
‘Inderjit Singh’ (supra) are concerned, the same were recorded with regard
to a factory for which a proper licence was issued by the concerned
authorities and secondly, the abovementioned factory was not meant for
firecrackers. Thus, it is hereby observed that the petitioners are not entitled
to draw any benefit out of the principles of law laid down in the
abovementioned case.
22.
As far as the observations recorded by this Court in the case of
‘Dhanpreet Singh’ (supra) is concerned, the same, too, are not applicable in
the present case, as in the instant case the Investigating Agency has not
collected any evidence, which can lead to a conclusion that all the safety
measures were taken by the petitioner and his co-accused for running a
factory. In addition to above, there is no evidence collected by the
Investigating Agency to show that the petitioner No.1 was not responsible
for running the factory. The instant case is a case, wherein the plea taken by
the petitioners has to be proved by way of defence evidence. Thus, it is
hereby observed that the petitioners are not entitled to draw any benefit from
the abovementioned principles also.
23.
As far as the case of ‘Ramdas Narayan Goprade’ (supra) is
concerned, the factual matrix of the abovementioned case was altogether
different, wherein with regard to one incident two prosecutions were
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.05.21 18:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-3288-2025 (O&M)
launched. Thus, it is hereby observed that the petitioners are not entitled to
draw any benefit of the abovementioned principles also.
24.
If the factual matrix of the present case is analysed in the light
of the principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
the case of ‘Nitinchandra Somnath Raval’ (supra), it transpires that prima
facie it appears that the petitioner and his co-accused, who were running a
factory of firecracker, must be aware of this fact that there were very fair
chances of explosion in such factory, as they were dealing with explosive
substance. Thus, required safety measures along with requisite permit and
licence should have been ensured by the petitioners, but they failed to do so.
Thus, the natural inference that can be drawn in the present case is that the
petitioners knew that their actions were likely to cause death, yet despite
such knowledge, they failed to take the requisite safety measures. In view of
abovementioned observations, it is hereby observed that the principles laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the abovementioned case are
applicable to the present case, but instead of supporting the case of the
petitioners, it supports the prosecution stand, that a prima facie a case for the
commission of offence punishable under Section 304 of IPC is made out.
25.
In the present case, the principles of law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of ‘Bhachandra & Anr. V/s
State of Maharashtra’ AIR 1968 SC 1319 has also been referred. The
principle of law laid down in the abovementioned case squarely covers the
factual matrix of the present case, and if the abovementioned principle is
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.05.21 18:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-3288-2025 (O&M)
applied to the present case, it transpires that the charges have rightly been
framed against the petitioners.
26.
Taking into consideration the cumulative effect of all the
abovementioned factors, it is hereby observed that there is no illegality,
perversity in the findings recorded by the learned trial Court, in the
impugned order, wherein it has been observed that a prima facie case for the
commission of offence punishable under Section 105 of BNS is made out
against the petitioners. Thus, it is hereby observed that there is no scope for
interference or indulgence in the impugned order and the present petition
being devoid of merit deserves dismissal.
27.
As a sequel to abovementioned observations, finding no merit,
the present petition is hereby dismissed, accordingly.
28.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, stand(s) disposed
of, accordingly.
(SURYA PARTAP SINGH)
JUDGE
21.05.2026
Gaurav Thakur
Whether speaking / reasoned
Whether Reportable
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.05.21 18:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review