Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
No
Date
Office Notes,
reports, orders or
proceedings or
directions and
Registrar’s order
with Signatures
COURT’S OR JUDGES’S ORDERS
C482 No. 1800 of 2021
Wit h
C482 No. 1702 of 2021
H o n ’ b l e A l o k M a h r a , J.
Mr. Raj at Mit t al, Advocat e for t he
applicant in C482 No. 1800 of 2021 and Mr .
B.M. Pingal, Advocat e for t he applicant in
C482 No. 1702 of 2021.
Mr. Akshay Lat wal,
St at e of Ut t arakhand.
A.G.A.
for
t he
Mr.
Aay ush
Pokhriyal,
Advocat e,
holding brief of Mr. Abhij ay Negi, Advocat e
for respondent no. 2.
2.
Since, com m on quest ion of law and
fact s are involved in t hese t wo crim inal m isc.
applicat ions, hence, t hey are being decided by
t he com m on j udgm ent . However, for t he sake
of brevit y, fact s of C482 No. 1800 of 2021 are
t aken int o considerat ion.
3.
I n t his case, an FI R was lodged by one
Kam al Singh Chauhan in which it w as alleged
t hat one Bhupal Singh Chauhan has t aken
away his sist er - in- law and m inor nephew
alongw it h him . This FI R was lodged in Pat wari
Circle,
Asho,
Dist rict
Bageshwar
on
28.05.2020. Thereaft er, t he applicant , who
was serving on t he post of Revenue I nspect or
( Pat w ari) , Asho Circle, aft er t ak ing due
perm ission from t he aut horit y concerned,
alongw it h Suresh Rat hour and Praveen Takuli,
who were Revenue I nspect ors of Khakar and
Nandi Gaon respect ively, searched for t he
accused and ult im at ely Bhupal Singh was
arrest ed from Village Nyoli, Dist rict Alm ora
alongw it h t he child and t he wom an. They
were brought in t he office of Tehsil Kafilgair,
Kat hpuriya Cheini at night t im e at about
11: 15 PM. Accused was kept in cust ody in t he
first floor of t he Tehsil building, w hich was
guarded by hom e guard. The ot her t wo SubI nspect ors nam ely Suresh Rat hour and
Praveen Takuli left from t here aft er t aking
due perm ission. I n t he m orning at about 6- 7
AM, t ea was served t o t he accused, but , aft er
som e t im e, noise of t he banging of t he door
was com ing from t he room , where, t he
accused was kept in t he cust ody and it w as
found t hat room was locked from t he inside.
Wit h t he help of t he villagers, w indow was
broken and accused was found lying
unconscious alongwit h gam chha around his
neck and blood was com ing out from t he
backside of his head. Doct or w as im m ediat ely
called at t he spot , but , t he doct or declared
him dead. Thereaft er, post - m ort em was
conduct ed in Sushila Tiw ari Hospit al, Haldwani
on 30.05.2020, whereby, doct ors opined t hat
no definit e opinion could be det erm ined and
as per t he FSL report , it w as found t hat t he
cause of deat h was due t o carbam at e
poisoning and t he ligat ure m ark in absence of
any ext ravasat ion indicat es t he deceased had
t ried t o st rangulat e him self. Subsequent ly, an
FI R was lodged by t he son of t he deceased on
29.05.2020, under Sect ion 302 of I PC at
Police St at ion Jhirauli, Dist rict Bageshwar.
During invest igat ion, t he charge of Sect ion
302 w as not found and chargesheet was filed
under Sect ion 306 of I PC. Wit h regard t o t he
cust odial deat h, inquiry was conduct ed by
CJM concerned, who aft er t he inquiry, found
no evidence regarding t he cust odial deat h.
That inquiry report has at t ained finalit y.
4.
Learned counsel for t he applicant s
would subm it t hat wit hout any evidence on
record, no ingredient s of Sect ion 306 of I PC
are m ade out against t he applicant s. To
support his case, learned counsel for t he
applicant s has relied upon a j udgm ent passed
by Hon’ble Suprem e Court in t he case of Geo
Varghese Vs. St at e of Raj ast han and Anot her,
2021 SCC OnLine SC 873. Paragraph 23 of
t he aforesaid j udgm ent is ext ract ed as
hereunder: “ 23. What is required t o const it ut e an alleged
abet m ent of suicide under Sect ion 306 I PC is
t here m ust be an allegat ion of eit her direct or
indirect act of incit em ent of t he com m ission of
offence of suicide and m ere allegat ions of
harassm ent of t he deceased by anot her person
would not be sufficient in it self, unless, t here
are allegat ions of such act ions on t he part of
t he accused which com pelled t he com m ission
of suicide. Furt her, if t he person com m it t ing
suicide is hypersensit ive and t he allegat ions
at t r ibut ed t o t he accused is ot herwise not
ordinar ily expect ed t o induce a sim ilar ly
sit uat ed person t o t ake t he ext rem e st ep of
com m it t ing suicide, it would be unsafe t o hold
t he accused guilt y of abet m ent of suicide.
Thus, what is requir ed is an exam inat ion of
every case on it s own fact s and circum st ances
and keeping in considerat ion t he surrounding
circum st ances as well, which m ay have
bearing on t he alleged act ion of t he accused
and t he psyche of t he deceased.”
5.
Per cont ra, learned counsel for t he
com plainant , on t he ot her hand, w ould subm it
t hat in his st at em ent , hom e guard who was
on dut y in t he Tehsil prem ises on t he fat eful
day has cat egorically st at ed t hat t he
deceased w as brought by t he applicant s
alongw it h four- five unident ified persons.
Heard learned counsel for t he part ies
6.
and perused t he record.
7.
The relevant provisions of t he I PC t hat
fall for considerat ion are as under:
“ 3 0 6 . A b e t m e n t o f su i ci d e .- I f any person
com m it s
suicide,
whoever
abet s
t he
com m ission of such suicide, shall be punished
wit h im pr isonm ent of eit her descript ion for a
t erm which m ay ext end t o t en years, and shall
also be liable t o fine.
1 0 7 . A b e t m e n t o f a t h i n g —A person abet s
t he doing of a t hing, who—
Fi r st l y .— I nst igat es any person t o do t hat
t hing; or
Se co n d l y .— Engages wit h one or m ore ot her
person or persons in any conspiracy for t he
doing of t hat t hing, if an act or illegal om ission
t akes place in pursuance of t hat conspir acy,
and in order t o t he doing of t hat t hing; or
Th i r d l y .— I nt ent ionally aids, by any act or
illegal om ission, t he doing of t hat t hing.
Explanat ion 1.— A person who, by wilful
m isrepresent at ion, or by wilful concealm ent of
a m at erial fact which he is bound t o disclose,
volunt ar ily causes or procures, or at t em pt s t o
cause or procure, a t hing t o be done, is said t o
inst igat e t he doing of t hat t hing. Explanat ion
2.— Whoever, eit her prior t o or at t he t im e of
t he com m ission of an act , does anyt hing in
order t o facilit at e t he com m ission of t hat act ,
and t hereby facilit at es t he com m ission t hereof,
is said t o aid t he doing of t hat act .”
8.
Sect ion 306 of t he I PC has t w o basic
ingredient s- first , an act of suicide by one
person and second, t he abet m ent t o t he said
act by anot her person( s) . I n order t o sust ain
a charge under Sect ion 306 of t he I PC, it
m ust necessarily be proved t hat t he accused
person has cont ribut ed t o t he suicide by t he
deceased by som e direct or indirect act . To
prove such cont ribut ion or involvem ent , one
of t he t hree condit ions out lined in Sect ion 107
of t he I PC has t o be sat isfied.
Sect ion 306 read wit h Sect ion 107 of
9.
I PC, has been int erpret ed, t im e and again,
and it s principles are well est ablished. To
at t ract t he offence of abet m ent t o suicide, it
is im port ant t o est ablish proof of direct or
indirect act s of inst igat ion or incit em ent of
suicide by t he accused, which m ust be in
close proxim it y t o t he com m ission of suicide
by t he deceased. Such inst igat ion or
incit em ent should reveal a clear m ens rea t o
abet t he com m ission of suicide and should put
t he vict im in such a posit ion t hat he/ she
would have no ot her opt ion but t o com m it
suicide.
10. Considering t he subm issions of learned
counsel for t he part ies and perusing t he
m at erial available on record, t his Court is of
t he opinion t hat in t he present case, t here is
no iot a of ev idence t hat t he applicant s were
involved eit her act ively or passively in
inst igat ing or abet t ing t he deceased t o
com m it suicide. The ingredient s of t he offence
punishable under Sect ion 306 I PC rem ained
unproved and t hus t he applicant s deserve t o
be acquit t ed of t he charges for t he said
offence. I n such circum st ances, allowing t he
crim inal proceedings t o cont inue against t he
applicant s w ould be an abuse of t he process
of law. Therefore, t his Court is of t he
considered view t hat it is a fit case t o exercise
it s inherent j urisdict ion under Sect ion 482
Cr.P.C. t o secure t he ends of j ust ice.
11. Accordingly,
t he
present
crim inal
m iscellaneous applicat ion filed under Sect ion
482 of t he Code of Crim inal Procedure, 1973
is allowed and t he ent ire proceedings of
Crim inal Case No. 490 of 2021, St at e Vs. Tara
Dat t Pat hak and Ot hers, under Sect ion 306 of
I PC, pending in t he Court of learned Chief
Judicial Magist rat e, Bageshwar, is hereby
quashed, qua t he applicant s.
( A l o k M a h r a , J.)
20.05.2026
Uj j wal
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review