The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. In State of Haryana vs. Ved Kaur, referred sura the Hon’ble Supreme Court has also observed in para-8, which reads as under: “8. The instructions dated 26.03.1975 which were relied upon in the present case, had been considered by this Court in Pawan Kumar v. State of Haryana and another and paragraph 12 of the decision is relevant for present purposes. The said paragraph was as under: “12. Moral turpitude” is an expression which is used in legal as also societal parlance to describe conduct which is inherently base, vile, depraved or having any connection showing depravity. The Government of Haryana while considering the question of rehabilitation of ex-convicts took a policy decision on 2-2-1973 (Annexure E in the Paper-book), accepting the recommendations of the Government of India, that ex-convicts who were convicted for offences involving moral turpitude should not however be taken in government service. A list of offences which were considered involving moral turpitude was prepared for information and guidance in that connection. Significantly Section 294 IPC is not found enlisted in the list of offences constituting moral turpitude. Later, on further consideration, the Government ofHaryana on 17/26-3-1975 explained the policy decision of 2-2-1973 and decided to modify the earlier decision by streamlining determination of moral turpitude as follows: “… The following terms …
4. Learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner has submitted a representation dated 02.08.2026 (Annexure P-12) to the respondent-Corporation, seeking retrospective regularization with effect from 15.07.2024, as granted to incumbents appointed along with petitioner, however, the aforesaid representation has not been decided till date. In view of grievance of the petitioner, this writ petition is disposed of with a direction to respondent No.1 to consider and decide the aforesaid representation, keeping in view the law laid down in Rajinder Kumar2, the guidelines issued by the respondent-Corporation vide its office letter dated 22.01.2021 (Annexure P-8), and the fact that the FIR in question, registered against the petitioner under Sections 279 and 337 of the Indian Penal Code, stands closed. The decision be taken within a period of three weeks from today. The order so passed be also communicated to the petitioner. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of. Jyotsna Rewal Dua Judge 21st September, 2026 rohit
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No. 16329 of 2026
Decided on: 21.09.2026
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Tara Chand
…..Petitioner
Versus
HRTC and Ors.
.....Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Whether approved for reporting? 1
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Rajat Kumar, Advocate.
For the Respondents: Mr. Deepak Sharma, Advocate.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
Notice.
Mr.
Deepak
Sharma,
learned
counsel,
accepts notice on behalf of the respondents.
In view of grievance of the petitioner, submissions
made by learned counsel for the petitioner and order being
passed hereinafter, reply to the writ petition is not required to be
called for. The matter has accordingly been heard at this stage.
2.
The case set up is that the petitioner was appointed
as Conductor on contract basis under office order dated
18.11.2021. He completed two years of continuous contractual
service on 18.11.2023 and became eligible for regularization.
Several incumbents appointed along with the petitioner and other
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
similarly situated persons were regularized in service vide office
order dated 15.07.2024. Petitioner’s case for regularization in
service was left out from the purview of the aforesaid order on the
ground of registration of FIR No. 13/2024 dated 22.02.2024 at
Police Station East Shimla under Sections 279 and 337 of the
Indian Penal Code. The concerned police department issued a
clarification on 23.07.2024 in respect of the aforesaid FIR, stating
that the case registered against the petitioner under Sections 279
and 337 of the IPC was not made out and, accordingly, a closure
report had been sent to the competent Court on 27.05.2024. In the
interregnum, the name of the petitioner was also recommended
for regularization vide office letter dated 11.04.2025, and the
respondent-Corporation regularized petitioner’s services with
effect from 16.04.2025 vide office order dated 28.04.2025.
It has further been pleaded on behalf of the petitioner
that learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Court No. 3, District
Shimla, Himachal Pradesh, (Court of competent jurisdiction) after
considering the cancellation report submitted by the police in FIR
No. 13 of 2024, accepted the cancellation report on 27.07.2026
and ordered closure of the FIR.
3.
Petitioner’s grievance in this petition is in relation to
his claim for regularization with effect from 15.07.2024, when
services of those appointed with him were regularized. He
accordingly claims the same relief.
3(i)
In support of relief claimed, reliance has been placed
upon Rajinder Kumar versus Himachal Road Transport
Corporation and others2. In the said case also, the petitioner
therein, a driver appointed on a contract basis in the respondentCorporation, was not regularized upon completion of the requisite
period on the ground of pendency of a criminal case against him
under Sections 341, 323 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code.
Relevant portion from the judgment reads as under: "5. Pre-condition for regularization, as per the Government
instructions is that an employee, who completes three years of
continuous
service
on
contract
basis,
is
entitled
for
regularization. For the purpose of regularization what has to be
looked into is; firstly whether he is a fit person for regularization;
secondly, whether he has completed three years of continuous
service which is mandatory for regularization; and thirdly,
whether his character and conduct is good in order to hold the
post in Government/Corporation. When these are the facts and
requirement for the purpose of regularization then merely on
the ground of registration of a criminal case, a person cannot
be deprived of his right of regularization. Since there are many
offences which are stated in the IPC but, the Head of Office or
the Appointing Authority has to look into the nature of criminal
case involved. From the FIR produced, the offences against the
petitioner are under Sections 341, 323 and 34 IPC. These
offences are common and trivial in nature in respect of a driver,
who has to negotiate his vehicle on public road and it is normal
that whenever a person who has to negotiate a vehicle on a
public road, touches the Government vehicle. This itself may
not be sufficient to register a criminal case. Merely registration
of a case itself should not be a ground to deprive the petitioner
for regularization. The Head of Office is always presumed that
CWP Number 2110 of 2019, decided on 22.10.2019.
he should protect his employees where cases are filed against
its employees. The pendency of a criminal case and
registration of FIR is to be taken into account but it depends
upon the gravity and nature of the offence. Merely registration
of a criminal case itself is not a ground and it shows that the
Appointing Authority or the Head of Office has not applied its
mind in the present case. Getting an employment/regularization
though is not a fundamental right but consideration for
regularization is a fundamental right for the purpose of Article
16 of the Constitution of India. When such is a fundamental
right for consideration then while dealing with such rights, the
respondents should take all care and caution. The respondents
in the present case are dealing with the right to life of an
employee which ultimately affects his dependents as well.
When such interest is involved, which includes the employee as
well as his family members, dealing always should be with
more care and caution and not in a mechanical and negligent
manner.
6.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in State Bank of India vs P.
Soupramaniane, referred supra in para-7 held as to what is the
meaning of moral turpitude. It is important and beneficial for
Head of the Department to take note of the observations made
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in para-7, which reads as under:
“7. Moral Turpitude’ as defined in the Black’s Law
Dictionary (6th ed.) is as follows:
“The Act of baseness, vileness, or the depravity in the
private and social duties which man owes to his follow
man, or to society in general, contrary to accepted and
customary rule of right and duty between man and
man.”
“implies something immoral in itself regardless of it
being punishable by law”; “restricted to the gravest
offences, consisting of felonies, infamous crimes, and
those that are malum in se and disclose a depraved
mind.”
According to Bouvier’s Law Dictionary, ‘Moral Turpitude’
is :
“An act of baseness, vileness or depravity in the
private and social duties which a man owes to
his fellow men or to society in general, contrary
to the accepted and customary rule of right and
duty between man and man.”
Burton Legal Thesaurus defines ‘Moral Turpitude’ as :
“Bad faith, bad repute, corruption, defilement,
delinquency, discredit, dishonor, shame, guilt,
knavery, misdoing, perversion, shame, ice,
wrong.”
7. In State of Haryana vs. Ved Kaur, referred sura the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has also observed in para-8,
which reads as under:
“8. The instructions dated 26.03.1975 which were
relied upon in the present case, had been
considered by this Court in Pawan Kumar v. State
of Haryana and another and paragraph 12 of the
decision is relevant for present purposes. The
said paragraph was as under:
“12. Moral turpitude” is an expression
which is used in legal as also societal
parlance to describe conduct which is
inherently base, vile, depraved or having
any connection showing depravity. The
Government of Haryana while considering
the question of rehabilitation of ex-convicts
took
a
policy
decision
on
2-2-1973
(Annexure E in the Paper-book), accepting
the recommendations of the Government
of
India,
that
ex-convicts
who
were
convicted for offences involving moral
turpitude should not however be taken in
government service. A list of offences
which were considered involving moral
turpitude was prepared for information and
guidance in that connection. Significantly
Section 294 IPC is not found enlisted in the
list of offences constituting moral turpitude.
Later,
on
further
consideration,
the
Government ofHaryana on 17/26-3-1975
explained the policy decision of 2-2-1973
and decided to modify the earlier decision
by streamlining determination of moral
turpitude as follows:
“… The following terms should ordinarily
be applied in judging whether a certain
offence involves moral turpitude or not;
(1) whether the act leading to a conviction
was such as could shock the moral
conscience of society in general.
(2) whether the motive which led to the act
was a base one.
(3) whether on account of the act having
been committed the perpetrator could be
considered to be of a depraved character
or a person who was to be looked down
upon by the society.
Decision in each case will, however, depend on
the
circumstances
of
the
case
and
the
competent authority has to exercise its discretion
while taking a decision in accordance with the
abovementioned principles. A list of offences
which involve moral turpitude is enclosed for
your
information
and
guidance.
This
list,
however, cannot be said to be exhaustive and
there might be offences which are not included
in it but which in certain situations and
circumstances may involve moral turpitude.”
Section 294 IPC still remains out of the list. Thus
the conviction of the appellant under Section 294
IPC on its own would not involve moral turpitude
depriving him of the opportunity to serve the
State unless the facts and circumstances, which
led to the conviction, met the requirements of the
policy decision above-quoted.”
3(ii)
Learned Counsel for the petitioner also referred to
office letter dated 22.01.2021 (Annexure P-8), issued by the
respondent-Corporation pursuant to Rajinder Kumar², whereby
directions were issued that, for the “minor offenses by way of
lodged FIRs/criminal case contract employee cannot be deprived
of his right of regularization. Since the respondent corporation has
implemented the said judgment and regularized the services of
Shri Rajinder Kumar in view of instructions issued by the State
Government. You are therefore, directed that the Head of Offices
or Appointing Authority to look into the matter and consider all
pending cases for regularization in which criminal cases of FIRs
lodged against them in view of gravity and nature of offence as
well as directions of the Hon’ble Court.”
4.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
petitioner has submitted a representation dated 02.08.2026
(Annexure
P-12)
to
the
respondent-Corporation,
seeking
retrospective regularization with effect from 15.07.2024, as
granted to incumbents appointed along with petitioner, however,
the aforesaid representation has not been decided till date.
In view of grievance of the petitioner, this writ petition
is disposed of with a direction to respondent No.1 to consider and
decide the aforesaid representation, keeping in view the law laid
down in Rajinder Kumar2, the guidelines issued by the
respondent-Corporation vide its office letter dated 22.01.2021
(Annexure P-8), and the fact that the FIR in question, registered
against the petitioner under Sections 279 and 337 of the Indian
Penal Code, stands closed. The decision be taken within a period
of three weeks from today. The order so passed be also
communicated
to
the
petitioner.
Pending
miscellaneous
application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
21st September, 2026
rohit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review