Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:41634 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,
SHIMLA
CWP No. 16846/2026
Decided on: 28.09.2026
Tapita Devi
…Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
.…Respondents.
…………………………………………………………………………….
Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? 1
For the petitioners:
Mr.
Sanjeev Bhushan, Sr.
Advocate with Mr. Sohail Khan,
Advocate.
For the respondents:
Ms. Seema Sharma, Deputy
Advocate General, for
respondents No.1 to 3.
Mr. Rajesh Kosh, advocate, for
respondent No.4.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua, J
Notice. Ms. Seema Sharma, learned Deputy Advocate
General, Mr. Rajesh Kosh, learned counsel, accept notice on behalf
of the respective respondents.
Keeping in view the grievance of the petitioner, the
decision relied upon by the petitioner in support of her claim, and the
order being passed hereinafter, there is no necessity to call for reply
from the respondents. The matter has been accordingly heard at this
stage.
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? yes
( 2026:HHC:41634 )
2.
The petitioner feels aggrieved against the rejection of
her claim by the respondents vide order dated 18.05.2026 for grant of
family pension on the ground that she is the second wife of late Shri
Sukh Ram Chauhan, who retired as a regular employee in the
respondent-Police Department during the year 1998 and had been
drawing regular pension.
The case set up by the petitioner is that Shri Sukh Ram
Chauhan solemnized his first marriage with Smt. Satya Devi, who
was the elder sister of the petitioner. No children were born from this
wedlock. During the subsistence of the aforesaid marriage, Shri Sukh
Ram Chauhan solemnized his second marriage with the petitioner,
who was the sister of his first wife. This marriage was solemnized
during the year 1979. The petitioner lived with Shri Sukh Ram
Chauhan as his wife for almost 44 years, discharging all matrimonial
obligations, and the couple was blessed with five children. The
petitioner has also placed on record a legal heir certificate issued by
the competent authority on 24.05.2023, wherein, apart from her name
figuring as the wife of late Shri Sukh Ram Chauhan, the names of
their children also figure. The first wife of Shri Sukh Ram Chauhan
passed away on 08.12.2020. He nominated the present petitioner as
the recipient of pension after his death vide application dated
11.05.2023 (Annexure P-1), submitted to respondent No. 5. Shri Sukh
Ram Chauhan died on 15.05.2023. The petitioner thereafter
( 2026:HHC:41634 )
requested the respondent-Department for release of family pension in
her favour. Her case was deliberated upon by the respondentDepartment and rejected on 18.05.2026, primarily for the reason that
family pension cannot be granted to the second wife under the
existing legal provisions, as the second marriage solemnized during
subsistence of first marriage is not recognized under the Hindu
Marriage Act.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon Urmila
Devi vs State of Uttar Pradesh & Others2 in support of her claim of
family pension. The facts of that case as noticed in the judgment were
as under: “2.
Brief facts necessary for the adjudication of this petition are
that the petitioner is the second wife of late Shri Surat Ram.
According to the petitioner, her marriage took place with late Shri
Surat Ram on 03.04.1987, during the subsistence of the marriage
of Shri Sugat Ram with Smt. Reshmu Devi. Smt. Reshmu Devi is
stated to have died on 18.11.2015. As per the petitioner, there
was no child born out of the wedlock between late Shri Surat
Ram and Smt. Reshmu Devi. However, there are two children
born out of the wedlock of the marriage of the petitioner with Shri
Surat Ram, who are both major and married. Shri Surat Ram is
stated to have died on 06.04.2021. The case of the petitioner for
the grant of family pension has been rejected vide Annexure P12, dated 18.02.2022, on the ground that she is not the first wife
of late Shri Surat Ram and had contacted marriage with him
during the subsistence of his first marriage, hence this petition.
2 CWP No. 6033 of 2022, decided on 30.03.2026
( 2026:HHC:41634 )
3.
The case of the petitioner is that she is the widow of late
employee of the respondent-Department and is entitled to family
pension, as she is eligible to receive the same.”
In the aforesaid case also, pension was denied to the
petitioner on the ground that she had solemnized marriage with the
government employee during the subsistence of his first marriage.
The Court held as under: “5.
It is a matter of record that the petitioner happens to be the
second wife of late Shri Surat Ram, as has been observed by me
hereinabove also. It is also a matter of record that the first wife of
Shri Surat Ram pre-deceased him. She died in the year 2015,
whereas Shri Surat Ram passed away in the year 2021.
Obviously, herein it is not the case of the respondents that after
the death of Shri Surat Ram, family pension was paid to his first
wife and after the death of his first wife, now another lady is
claiming the same. Here, the family pension has not been paid to
anyone after the death of Shri Surat Ram. It is also not in dispute
that whereas, no child was born out of the wedlock between Shri
Surat Ram and his first wife Smt. Reshmu Devi, there are two
major children born out of the marriage of the petitioner with late
Shri Surat Ram, who are above twenty five years of age, and thus,
not entitled to receive family pension.
6.
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Smt. Shiramabai and
others Versus The Captain Record Officer and another, (Civil
Appeal No. 5262 of 2023), decided on 18.08.2023, has been
pleased to hold under similar circumstances that in case a man
and women cohabited continuously for long term, then one can
draw a presumption in favour of a valid marriage. Hon’ble Apex
Court also held that though this presumption is rebuttable, but
heavy onus is placed on the one who seeks to deprive the
relationship of its legal origin to prove that no marriage had indeed
taken place.
( 2026:HHC:41634 )
7.
In the present case, there is none except the petitioner
who is claiming the family pension after the death of Shri Surat
Ram. Though she is not the first wife of Shri Surat Ram, but the
first wife of Shri Surat Ram, pre-deceased Shri Surat Ram, issueless, and, therefore, in case family pension is ordered to be
granted in favour of the present petitioner, no prejudice is going to
be caused to anyone.
8.
Accordingly, this petition is allowed. The act of the
respondents of denying family pension to the petitioner is held to
be bad in law. Annexure P-12, dated 18.02.2022, is quashed and
set aside and respondents are directed to release family pension
to the petitioner forthwith. Arrears as are due to the petitioner, be
paid within three months from today and if that is done, no interest
shall be paid thereupon. If arrears are not paid within three
months, they shall entail interest 6% as from the date of this
judgment. Regular family pension be paid to the petitioner from the
month of May, 2026.
The aforesaid decision was affirmed by the Hon’ble
Division Bench in State of H.P. & Anr. Vs. Urmila Devi & Anr3 inter
alia, placing reliance upon the decision rendered in Umawati Vs.
HPSEB & Ors. 4 The relevant portion from the decision is as under: 3.
The learned Single Judge had referred to the
judgment in Shiramabai w/o Pundalik Bawa and
others
vs.
Captain Record
Officer for O.I.C.
Records, ASC Centre (South), Gaya, Bihar and
another, (2014) 16 SCC 773, wherein the Apex Court
has held that there is a presumption in favour of the
validity of the marriage if the perties cohabit together
for long. Further, it was noticed that there was no issue
LPA. 418 of 2026, decided on 17.07.2026.
4 LPA No. 545/2025 decided on 25.04.2026
( 2026:HHC:41634 )
from the first wife and, therefore, no prejudice would be
caused to anyone.
4.
The said issue also stands considered by us in
LPA No. 545 of 2025, titled Umawati vs. HPSEB
and others, decided on 25.04.2026, wherein the
appeal filed by Umawati was allowed. It was held that
while dealing with matters relating to pensionary
benefits, the authorities are required to adopt a
sensitive and positive approach consistent with the
constitutional values of empowerment and dignity,
particularly while considering the claims of weaker
sections. The entitlement to family pension was also
considered while interpreting the Rule of the Central
Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972. The relevant
part thereof reads as under…………”
15.
In the case at hand, this Court is dealing with
an appellant who was in a bigamous relation with the
deceased (Sh. Jai Ram) held not to be immoral by the
apex court in Rameshchandra(supra). The appellant
belongs to a marginalized section of society. Hence, it
becomes the bounden duty of this Court to advance
the constitutional vision of social justice. The
approach to be adopted is one of “social justice
adjudication” as opposed to a purely “adversarial
approach”. Therefore, the role of the Court is to
understand the purpose of law in society and to assist
the law in achieving its intended purpose. An
interpretation which reduces the subordinate
legislation to a futility should be avoided, and a view
that the rule making authority made the rule only for
the purpose of bringing about an effective result
should be adopted.
16.
In this regard, a reference can be made to
(2014) 1 SCC 188 titled as Badshah vs. Urmila
Badshah Godse and another. Relevant extract
whereof reads as under:14. Of late, in this very direction, it is emphasized that
the Courts have to adopt different approaches in “social
justice adjudication”, which is also known as “social
context adjudication” as mere “adversarial approach”
may not be very appropriate. There are number of
social justice legislations giving special protection and
benefits to vulnerable groups in the society. Prof.
Madhava Menon describes it eloquently:
“It is, therefore, respectfully submitted that “social
context judging” is essentially the application of equality
jurisprudence as evolved by Parliament and the
Supreme Court in myriad situations presented before
courts where unequal parties are pitted in adversarial
( 2026:HHC:41634 )
proceedings and where courts are called upon to
dispense equal justice. Apart from the social- economic
inequalities accentuating the disabilities of the poor in
an unequal fight, the adversarial process itself operates
to the disadvantage of the weaker party. In such a
situation, the judge has to be not only sensitive to the
inequalities of parties involved but also positively
inclined to the weaker party if the imbalance were not to
result in miscarriage of justice. This result is achieved
by what we call social context judging or social justice
adjudication.”[5]
15. Provision of maintenance would definitely fall in this
category which aims at empowering the destitute and
achieving social justice or equality and dignity of the
individual. While dealing with cases under this provision,
drift in the approach from “adversarial” litigation to social
context adjudication is the need of the hour.
16. The law regulates relationships between people. It
prescribes patterns of behavior. It reflects the values of
society. The role of the Court is to understand the
purpose of law in society and to help the law achieve its
purpose. But the law of a society is a living organism. It
is based on a given factual and social reality that is
constantly changing. Sometimes change in law
precedes societal change and is even intended to
stimulate it. In most cases, however, a change in law is
the result of a change in social reality. Indeed, when
social reality changes, the law must change too. Just as
change in social reality is the law of life, responsiveness
to change in social reality is the life of the law. It can be
said that the history of law is the history of adapting the
law to society’s changing needs. In both Constitutional
and statutory interpretation, the Court is supposed to
exercise direction in determining the proper relationship
between the subjective and objective purpose of the
law.
17. Cardozo acknowledges in his classic “….no system
of jus scriptum has been able to escape the need of it”,
and he elaborates: “It is true that Codes and Statutes do
not render the Judge superfluous, nor his work
perfunctory and mechanical. There are gaps to be filled.
There are hardships and wrongs to be mitigated if not
avoided. Interpretation is often spoken of as if it were
nothing but the search and the discovery of a meaning
which, however, obscure and latent, had none the less a
real and ascertainable pre- existence in the legislator’s
mind. The process is, indeed, that at times, but it is
often something more. The ascertainment of intention
may be the least of a judge’s troubles in ascribing
meaning to a stature.” Says Gray in his lecture “The fact
is that the difficulties of so-called interpretation arise
when the legislature has had no meaning at all; when
the question which is raised on the statute never
occurred to it; when what the judges have to do is, not
to determine that the legislature did mean on a point
which was present to its mind, but to guess what is
would have intended on a point not present to its mind,
if the point had been present.”
18. The Court as the interpreter of law is supposed to
supply omissions, correct uncertainties, and harmonize
results with justice through a method of free decision—
“libre recherché sceintifique” i.e. “free Scientific
research”. We are of the opinion that there is a nonrebuttable presumption that the Legislature while
making a provision like Section 125 Cr.P.C., to fulfill its
Constitutional duty in good faith, had always intended to
give relief to the woman becoming “wife” under such
circumstances. This approach is particularly needed
while deciding the issues relating to gender justice. We
already have examples of exemplary efforts in this
regard. Journey from Shah Bano[8] to Shabana Bano[9]
( 2026:HHC:41634 )
guaranteeing maintenance rights to Muslim women is a
classical example.
19 In Rameshchandra Daga v. Rameshwari Daga [10],
the right of another woman in a similar situation was
upheld. Here the Court had accepted that Hindu
marriages have continued to be bigamous despite the
enactment of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. The Court
had commented that though such marriages are illegal
as per the provisions of the Act, they are not ‘immoral’
and hence a financially dependent woman cannot be
denied maintenance on this ground.
20. Thus, while interpreting a statute the court may not
only take into consideration the purpose for which the
statute was enacted, but also the mischief it seeks to
suppress. It is this mischief rule, first propounded in
Heydon’s Case[11] which became the historical source
of purposive interpretation. The court would also invoke
the legal maxim construction ut res magis valeat guam
pereat, in such cases i.e. where alternative
constructions are possible the Court must give effect to
that which will be responsible for the smooth working of
the system for which the statute has been enacted
rather than one which will put a road block in its way. If
the choice is between two interpretations, the narrower
of which would fail to achieve the manifest purpose of
the legislation should be avoided. We should avoid a
construction which would reduce the legislation to futility
and should accept the bolder construction based on the
view that Parliament would legislate only for the
purpose of bringing about an effective result. If this
interpretation is not accepted, it would amount to giving
a premium to the husband for defrauding the wife.
Therefore, at least for the purpose of claiming
maintenance under Section 125, Cr.P.C., such a woman
is to be treated as the legally wedded wife.
21. The principles of Hindu Personal Law have
developed in an evolutionary way out of concern for all
those subject to it so as to make fair provision against
destitution. The manifest purpose is to achieve the
social objectives for making bare minimum provision to
sustain the members of relatively smaller social groups.
Its foundation spring is humanistic. In its operation field
all though, it lays down the permissible categories under
its benefaction, which are so entitled either because of
the tenets supported by clear public policy or because
of the need to subserve the social and individual
morality measured for maintenance.
17.
The sole contention urged on behalf of the
respondent-Corporation is that, in terms of the Central
Civil Services (CCS) Pension Rules, the appellant is
not entitled to grant of family pension. The relevant
Rule 50 (6) of the CCS Pension Rules reads as
follow:(6) The family pension shall be payable to the members
of
the
family
of
the
deceased Government servant or pensioner
in the following order, namely:(i) subject to provisions of sub- rule (8), widow or
widower, (including a post-retiral spouse and judicially
separated wife or husband),
(ii) subject to provisions of sub-rule (9), children
(including adopted children, step children and children
born after retirement of the pensioner),
(iii) subject to provisions of sub-rule (10), dependent
parents (including adoptive parents) of the deceased
Government servant or pensioner,
( 2026:HHC:41634 )
(iv) subject to provisions of sub-rule (11), dependent
siblings (i.e. brother or sister) of the deceased
Government servant or pensioner, suffering from a
mental or physical disability,
Explanation.- For the purposes of this rule, ‘widow’ and
‘widower shall mean a spouse, legally wedded to the
deceased Government servant or the pensioner.
8(c) Where the deceased government servant or
pensioner is survived by more widows than one, the
family pension shall be paid to the widows in equal
shares and on the death or ineligibility of a widow her
share of the family pension shall become payable to her
child or children who fulfil the eligibility conditions in
sub-Rule (9)
(See GID 22 below this Rule).
(22). Settlement of Family Pension between two wives
of a Government servant or Pensioner under Central
Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 2021.-It is directed to
say that Department of Pension, in supersession of the
Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 has
notified the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 2021
and Rule 50 of the Central Civil Services (Pension)
Rules, 2021 deals with payment of family pension on
death of a Government servant / pensioner.
2.
In accordance with Rule 50 (6) of the CCS
(Pension) Rules, 2021. family pension shall be pavable
to the members of the family of the deceased
Government servant or pensioners in the following
order.
(i)
Subject to provisions of sub-rule (8), widow or
widower, (including a post-retiral spouse and judicially
separated wife or husband)
(ii)
subject to provisions of sub-rule (9), children
(including adopted children, step children and
children born after retirement of the
pensioner),
(ii)
subject
dependent
of the deceased
to provisions of sub-rule (10),
parents (including adoptive parents)
Government servant or pensioner,
(iv)
subject
dependent
deceased
suffering from a
to provisions of sub-rule (11),
siblings (i.e. brother or sister) of the
Government servant or pensioner,
mental or physical disability.
whereas the Explanation to Rule 50 (6) (1) of the CCS
(Pension) Rules, 2021 states that - For the purpose of
this rule, 'widow' and 'widower' shall mean a spouse,
legally wedded to the deceased Govemment servant or
the pensioners.
3. Whereas Rule 50(8)(c) of the CCS (Pension) Rules,
2021 states that-Where the deceased Govemment
servant or pensioner is survived by more widow than
one, the family pension shall be paid to the widows in
equal shares and on the death or ineligibility of a widow,
her share of the family pension shall become payable to
her child or children who fulfil the eligibility conditions
mentioned in sub-rule (9).
4. In this regard, references have been received in this
department regarding eligibility of family pension to the
second wife when the first wife is alive. Having second
wife when the first wife is alive is against the provisions
of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and also contradictory to
the provisions of CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021. The
matter has been examined and it has been decided that
such cases need to be processed in accordance with
( 2026:HHC:41634 )
the provisions of CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021 and the
issue of second wife or second marriage being legal or
otherwise, may be decided first in consultation with
Department of Legal Affairs on case-to-case basis for
deciding the eligibility for Family Pension.
5. All Ministries/Departments are requested to follow the
process of consultation with Department of Legal Affairs
before arriving at decision regarding Settlement of
Family Pension between two wives under Central Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 2021. Such cases must be
brought to the notice of the officer dealing with the
pensioners'
benefits
in
the
respective
Ministry/Department by the attached/subordinate
offices.
18.
Rule 50(8) of the CCS (Pension Rules),
2021 provides for family pension to two wives.
Moreover in terms of GID 22 second wife would not
be entitled to family pension when the first wife is
alive .The wife of Jai Ram had died prior to his
marriage with the appellant, as is evident from
Annexure P-1 (page 32 of the paper book). The
marriage inter se late Sh. Jai Ram and the appellant
is illegal in terms of Section 5(i) of the Hindu Marriage
Act; however, in terms of the law laid down by the
Apex Court in Ram Chandra’s case (supra), the
same is not immoral. In Ram Chandra’s case despite
holding the marriage to be illegal, the right to claim
maintenance was up-held. The object of providing
family pension cannot be different from the object of
providing maintenance.
19.
In the case at hand, late Sh. Jai Ram and
the appellant cohabited from 6.5.1994 till immediately
prior to the filing of the petition seeking restitution of
conjugal rights by the present appellant in August
2006. The long cohabitation inter se the parties, the
entry of the name of the appellant in the service
book/pension record of the deceased Sh. Jai Ram
(though subsequently withdrawn), the fact that late
Sh. Jai Ram had two sons and two daughters from his
previous marriage, all of whom have attained majority
and none of whom is claiming any right over the
family pension due to the family of late Sh. Jai Ram,
when considered with relevant factors like economic
empowerment, social justice, dignity of the individual
requires this Court to be sensitive to and positively
inclined towards the weaker party. Thereby, in our
considered view, the appellant, who is financially
weak and economically dependent, would be entitled
to pension.
20.
In taking the aforesaid view, we are also
encouraged by the following observations of the Apex
Court in Capt. Ramesh Chander Kaushal vs. Veena
Kaushal, (1978) 4 SCC 70:
“The brooding presence of the Constitutional
empathy for the weaker sections like women
and children must inform interpretation if it
has to have social relevance. So viewed, it is
possible to be selective in picking out that
( 2026:HHC:41634 )
interpretation out of two alternatives which
advances the cause- the cause of the
derelicts.”
21.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the
present appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment
dated 03.04.2025 passed in CWP No. 7584 of 2023 is
hereby set aside. The appellant is held entitled to the
grant of family pension in respect of late Shri Jai Ram.
5.
In view thereof, there is no plausible reason as such to take
a different view. Resultantly, the present appeal, being devoid of
any merit, is dismissed, so also the pending miscellaneous
applications, if any.”
In view of the above, notwithstanding decision at
Annexure P-7 dated 15.08.2026, this writ petition is disposed of with
a direction to the respondents including respondents No.1 to 3 to
reconsider the case of the petitioner for grant of family pension, in
accordance with law, keeping in view the decisions rendered in
Urmila Devi2 and Umawati4. The case shall be decided afresh within
four weeks from today. The order so passed be also communicated
to the petitioner. In case the petitioner is found eligible for family
pension, the same shall be released to her within a further period of
two weeks thereafter.
The instant petition to stand disposed of in above terms.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall also stand disposed
of.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
28th September, 2026(rohit)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review