Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:29153
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P.G. AJITHKUMAR
FRIDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 14TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.REV.PET NO. 292 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 16.11.2023 IN CMP NO.1147 OF 2022
IN CC NO.93 OF 2016 OF THE COURT OF ENQUIRY COMMISSIONER
& SPECIAL JUDGE (VIGILANCE), EKM AT MUVATTUPUZHA
REVISION PETITIONER/ACCUSED NO.5:
T.R. PRASAD
AGED 57 YEARS
S/O. RAMAKRISHNAN NAIR, RESIDING AT TAIPARAMPIL
HOUSE, POOPARA ESTATE , IDUKKI DISTRICT, NOW
RESIDING AT TAIPARAMBIL HOUSE, MARAMPILLY P.O.,
VAZHAKULAM VILLAGE, KUNNATHUNADU TALUK,
ERNAKULAM DIST., PIN – 683105.
BY ADV K.SANDESH RAJA
RESPONDENTS/STATE OF KERALA & COMPLAINANT:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF
KERALA, ERNAKULAM, PIN – 682031.
DEPUTY SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE
VACB, IDUKKI UNIT, THODUPUZHA, IDUKKI DIST.,
PIN – 685587.
2025:KER:29153
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.292 of 2024
SMT REKHA S, SR PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
SRI A RAJESH, SPL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (VIG)
THIS CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION HAVING COME UP FOR
FINAL
HEARING
ON
27.02.2025,
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
04.04.2025
2025:KER:29153
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.292 of 2024
P.G. AJITHKUMAR, J.
----------------------------------------------------------Crl.Rev.Pet.No.292 of 2024
----------------------------------------------------------Dated this the 4th day of April, 2025
ORDER
Accused No.5 in C.C.No.93 of 2016 pending before the
Court of Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge (Vigilance),
Muvattupuzha has filed this revision petition under Section
397 read with Section 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
(Code).
He
filed
C.M.P.No.1147
of
seeking
discharge. The Special Court dismissed that petition as per
the order dated 16.11.2023. That order is under challenge in
this revision petition.
2.
The
petitioner
was
a
Village
Assistant
in
Chinnakanal Village. While working as such, he allegedly had
prepared false sketches and certificates in respect of property
comprised in survey No.20/1 of Chinnakanal Village, which is
situated in Venadu thavalam, as if the said property is in
Chinnakanal thavalam. It is Government land. Disregarding
that fact the certificate was issued describing it as a property
2025:KER:29153
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.292 of 2024
covered by Patta No.LA 24/1968, which is a forged document.
The petitioner did so based on a conspiracy hatched among
the accused persons. Thereby the accused and his co-accused
have allegedly committed offences punishable under Sections
13(1)(c) and (d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988 (PC Act) and Sections 468, 471 and
420 read with Section 120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
(IPC).
3.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
learned Special Public Prosecutor (Vigilance) and the learned
Senior Public Prosecutor.
4.
The essential allegation against the petitioner is
that he being a Village Assistant failed to ascertain whether
the property covered by the sketch and certificate, which he
had prepared for being issued to witness Nos.3 and 22 was a
Government land or not. The sketch and certificate prepared
by him were submitted before the Village Officer, who is
accused No.4 and he in turn issued to the parties. The
property covered by the said sketch and certificate is a
2025:KER:29153
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.292 of 2024
Government land. It is situated in Venadu thavalam; whereas
the petitioner, without verifying that fact, certified in the plan
and the certificate that it was in Chinnakanal thavalam. The
petitioner could well ascertain from the records in the village
office the real state of affairs. Still he prepared such false
documents, which evidences his misconduct with dishonest
intention.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioner would submit
that being a Village Assistant, the petitioner did not have any
independent authority to issue a sketch or certificate. He was
functioning as per the direction of the Village Officer and had
prepared the documents only as instructed by the Village
Officer. When pokkuvaravu was done and tax received for the
property in question much earlier, preparation of the sketch in
accordance with such revenue records and also the title deed
cannot be a mischievous act. At any rate, no conspiracy
involving the petitioner and his obtaining any pecuniary
advantage in relation to the issuance of the sketch and
certificate are substantiated by the materials produced by the
2025:KER:29153
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.292 of 2024
prosecution. It is submitted that the Special Court without
considering such aspects held that there was sufficient
materials to ask the petitioner to stand trial.
6.
The learned Special Public Prosecutor would submit
that a Village Assistant could easily ascertain the Government
lands within the local limits of the village and when a
certificate is issued disregarding that fact, dishonest intention
can certainly be attributed. By mere perusal of the records in
the village office, the petitioner could understand that the
property in question was not in Chinnakanal thavalam, but it
was in Venadu thavalam. The sketch was prepared denoting
that the property was in Chinnakanal thavalam. It was also
easy for the petitioner to ascertain whether the patta in LA
No.24/1968 was genuine or not. That also was overlooked by
the petitioner. When those facts are borne by records, in the
view of the learned Public Prosecutor, the petitioner is
disentitled to claim a discharge.
7.
It was not based on patta No.LA 24/1968 mutation
was effected in the name of witness Nos.3 and 22. On the
2025:KER:29153
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.292 of 2024
basis of fabricated patta, a document was executed by
accused No.9 in favour of his son, accused No.1. Tracing title
to the property based on that document accused No.1 sold
properties to witness Nos.3 and 22. Going by the case of the
prosecution, mutation was effected based on the assignment
in favour of accused No.1, which was in consequence of the
conspiracy hatched among accused Nos.1, 2 and 6 to 9. Land
tax was also paid. It was much later accused No.1 executed
sale deeds in favour of witness Nos.3 and 22. During the year
2006, pokkuvaravu was effected on the basis of the said
documents. Land tax was also received. After a year the
certificates in question were prepared by the petitioner. The
sketch and certificate were seen prepared on 06.02.2007 and
07.04.2007. One among the two sketches, namely, regarding
the property conveyed in favour of witness No.22, was
prepared by accused No.4, the Village Officer; whereas the
other one was prepared by the petitioner. In the title deeds in
favour of witness Nos.3 and 22, the property has been
described as one situated in Chinnakanal thavalam. Acting
2025:KER:29153
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.292 of 2024
upon the said title deeds, mutation was effected and tax
received. In the light of the said records maintained in the
village, accused No.5, the petitioner, prepared the sketch and
the certificate.
8.
As alleged by the prosecution, the petitioner could
have understood that the property involved was Government
land and the patta No.LA 24/1968 was a fabricated one. But
the patta was an old one and there were subsequent
transactions by way of even conveyance, dishonest intention
in preparing the sketch and the certificate at a later point of
time on the part of the petitioner cannot readily be inferred.
Unless there are materials to show that the petitioner had a
dishonest intention in preparing the sketch and certificate in
question, his criminal prosecution is incorrect. Going through
the materials produced by the prosecution what could be
gathered is the dereliction of duty on the part of the
petitioner. More than that, a mischievous act of preparing the
sketch and certificate with dishonest intention of gaining some
material thing or pecuniary advantage cannot be gathered
2025:KER:29153
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.292 of 2024
from the materials produced by the prosecution. It is
especially so when an year before mutation was effected and
tax received from witness Nos.3 and 22 on the basis of the
title deeds in their favour. In the said circumstances,
accusation against the petitioner is based on inferences. No
tangible evidence to substantiate the charge is proposed by
the prosecution.
9.
In State of Bihar v. Ramesh Singh [AIR 1977
SC 2018] the Apex Court held that at the stage of framing
charge, the court is not to see whether there is sufficient
ground for conviction of the accused or whether the trial is
sure to end in his conviction. At that stage, the truth, veracity
and effect of the evidence, which the prosecution proposes to
adduce, are not to be meticulously judged. It is also
unnecessary to weigh the probable defence of the accused.
The view taken by the Apex Court in Stree Atyachar Virodhi
Parishad v. Dilip Nathumal Chordia and another [(1989)
1 SCC 715] is that the court need not conduct an elaborate
enquiry in sifting and weighing of the evidence at the time of
2025:KER:29153
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.292 of 2024
framing charge. It is also not necessary to delve into various
aspects. All that the court has to consider is whether the
evidentiary material on record, if generally accepted, would
reasonably connect the accused with the crime. In Union of
India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal and another [(1979) 3
SCC 4] the Apex Court held that where the materials
disclosed grave suspicion against the accused, which has not
been properly explained, the court would be justified in
framing a charge against the accused. In Soma Chakravarty
v. State through CBI [(2007) 5 SCC 403] the Apex Court
reiterated the said view by holding that when there exists a
strong suspicion, a charge can be framed. It was also
cautioned that a mere suspicion as distinguished from grave
suspicion is not enough to frame a charge.
10.
In Vijayan P. v. State of Kerala and another
[(2010) 2 SCC 398] the Apex Court held that the judge
who considers a question where a charge is liable to be
framed is not a mere Post office to frame the charge at the
behest of the prosecution. The judge is expected to exercise
2025:KER:29153
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.292 of 2024
his judicial mind to the facts of the case in order to
determine whether a case for trial has been made out by the
prosecution. In State of Gujarat v. Dilipsinh Kishorsinh
Rao [(2023) 17 SCC 688], the Apex Court held that at
the stage of considering an application for discharge, the
court shall proceed on an assumption that the material which
has been brought on record by the prosecution is true and
evaluate such materials in order to determine whether the
facts emerging from the materials taken on its face value
disclosed the existence of the ingredients necessary of the
offences alleged.
11.
In
the
light
of
the
law
laid
down
in
the
aforementioned decisions, the materials produced by the
prosecution are insufficient to presume that the petitioner has
committed the offences alleged in the final report. Therefore,
the charge against him would only be groundless. Hence, the
impugned order declining the plea of discharge of the
petitioner is set aside. The revision petition is allowed and the
petitioner is discharged of the offences alleged against him in
2025:KER:29153
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.292 of 2024
C.C.No.93 of 2016 pending before the Court of Enquiry
Commissioner and Special Judge (Vigilance), Muvattupuzha.
Sd/-
P.G. AJITHKUMAR, JUDGE
dkr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review