The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. The learned counsel for the petitioners, by referring to Annexure A8 Medical Records pertaining to the treatment of Swami Sudheendra Theerdha, pointed out that the condition of the said Swamy was such that he would have suffered death, at the same time, as happened, even if he had not been discharged from the hospital, since he was not responding to medicines. According to the learned counsel, the Swamy was discharged from hospital and taken to Haridwar Ashram to fulfil his cherished desire to be there in that Ashram at the time of his last breath. Thus, it is argued that the act of the petitioners and other disciples taking the Swamy to the Haridwar Ashram on 16-01-2016 cannot be termed as culpable homicide within the meaning of Section 299 IPC. Accordingly, it is submitted that the averments in the complaint, even if accepted as such, will not constitute any offence as alleged. With regard to the above submission, it has to be stated at the outset that, in a proceedings under section 482 Cr.P.C., this Court cannot embark upon an enquiry as to the health condition of the deceased Swamy as revealed from Annexure A8 Medical Records, and whether it indicated 2025:KER:26865 that the Swamy would not have survived even if he was retained in that hospital for some more days. It is a matter to be decided after the examination of the doctors who treated the Swamy, with specific referen…
11. As already stated above, the learned Magistrate has already taken cognizance of the offence alleged in this case, and gone a long way in the enquiry conducted under section 202 Cr.P.C. in the earlier complaint filed before him as C.M.P.No.937/2016. He is yet to arrive at the logical conclusions of the above enquiry, and decide whether there are sufficient grounds to proceed against the accused in connection with the offence alleged. At this stage, it is not at all desirable and proper for this Court to embark upon the question whether the allegations in the complaint, filed by the first respondent as C.M.P.No.583/2018, in respect of the same incident, would constitute the offence alleged against the petitioners and others. This is especially so in view of the fact that the decision by this Court on that point would definitely have an impact on the enquiry being conducted by the learned Magistrate in C.M.P.No.937/2016. If this Court finds that the offence alleged against the petitioners are not attracted even if the allegations in C.M.P No.583/2018 are accepted 2025:KER:26865 as such, then the learned Magistrate would be put to the precarious position of winding up the enquiry in C.M.P.No.937/2016 in the midway. Likewise, if this Court finds that the allegations in C.M.P.No.583/2018 would make out the offence alleged, then also the finding in the above regard would affect the in…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE G.GIRISH
ST
TUESDAY, THE 1
DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 11TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.MC NO. 5702 OF 2019
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 09.07.2019 IN CMP NO.583 OF 2018
OF JUDICIAL FIRST CLASS MAGISTRATE COURT, CHOTTANIKKARA
PETITIONERS:
T.G.RAJARAM SHENOY,AGED 50 YEARS
S/O. GOVINDA SHENOY, RADHESHYM,
T. D. EAST SANNIDHI ROAD,
COCHIN 682 035.
K.J. SUDHAKARA KAMATH,S/O. JANARDHANA KAMATH,
M/S. COCHIN SANITARY DURGA TEMPLE, BUILDINGS,
T.D. ROAD, COCHIN 682 035.
BY ADVS.DINESH R.SHENOY
SRI.EBIN MATHEW
SRI.P.ROHIT PREMANANDAN SHENOY
RESPONDENTS:
PROF.K.K.HARI PAI, AGED 62 YEARS
S/O. KRISHNA PAI, 40/5575,
PADMAVILAS BUILDING TD ROAD, FLOWER JUNCTION,
COCHIN 682 035.
STATE OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY
PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,M HIGH COURT OF KERALA,
ON BEHALF OF THE SUB INSPECTOR OF POLICE,
AMBALAMEDU POLICE STATION, KARIMUGHAL.
BY ADVS. SRI.K.J.JOSEPH (ERNAKULAM) FOR R1
SRI.B.DEEPAK FOR R1
SRI.SANGEETHARAJ.N.R, PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
THIS CRIMINAL MISC. CASE HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
25.03.2025, THE COURT ON 01.04.2025 PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
ORDER
The order dated 09.07.2019 in C.M.P.No.583/2018 on the files
of Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Chottanikkara is under
challenge in this petition filed under Section 482 Cr.P.C at the
instance of the person arraigned as accused Nos.11 and 14 in the
aforesaid C.M.P. The learned Magistrate, by the impugned order, had
forwarded the above C.M.P to the S.H.O of Police, Ambalamedu for
the registration of F.I.R and report.
2.
The allegations against the petitioners herein in the
complaint filed as C.M.P.No.583/2018 before the learned Magistrate,
in conspectus, are as follows:
The petitioner/complainant in that C.M.P is a devotee of
late Swami Sudheendra Theertha, the devotional Guru of
Gauda Saraswata Brahmin community, and the supreme
head of Kashi Math.
Accused Nos.1 to 7 and Accused
Nos.10 to 16, who are associated with the above
community, conspired with Accused Nos.8 and 9 who are
respectively the Managing Director of Seven Hills Hospital,
Mumbai and a Doctor of the said hospital who treated
Swami Sudheendra Theertha, to commit murder of the
above said Swami, and got the said Swami discharged
from that hospital on 16.01.2016 at a time when the
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
physical and mental condition of the said Swami were
totally deplorable. Swami Sudheendra Theertha, who was
aged 90, was admitted in that hospital in the month of
December, 2015, and he was undergoing treatment there
for multiple ailments including age related issues.
At
about 06:30 a.m on 16.01.2016, the said Swami was
discharged from that hospital in accordance with the
conspiracy of the accused, and airlifted to Dehradun.
Thereafter, by about 01:30 p.m on the same day, the said
Swami was taken to Kashi Math at Haridwar by road at a
time when his condition was extremely worse.
On
17.01.2016, at about 01:30 a.m, a formal declaration was
made by the second accused that Shrimad Sudheendra
Theertha Swami attained samadhi at 01:30 a.m.
The
accused were fully aware of the fact that the above said
Swami would not survive if he was discharged from the
hospital in that condition and taken to Haridwar where
there was a bitter cold climate of extreme winter. The
accused did not care to take the said Swami to a hospital
at Haridwar with the deliberate intention to ensure his
death.
The conspiracy to execute the murder of
Sudheendra Theertha Swami, was hatched at the Kashi
Math Ashram at Ambalamedu in Ernakulam District. After
the death of the Swami, his body was placed in
‘Padmasana’ and consecrated at the Haridwar Ashram. All
the above acts were pre-planned and executed by the
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
accused to accomplish their vested interests.
Though
complaints were preferred before the police about the
above criminal acts committed by the accused, they did
not take any action due to the influence of the accused.
Hence, a complaint was filed before the Judicial First Class
Magistrate Court, Chottanikkara as C.M.P.No.937/2016,
which
is
pending
enquiry
before
the
said
Court.
Therefore, it is highly necessary that the complaint has to
be forwarded to the Police under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C for
investigation and report.
3. The complaint in the above regard was initially posted along
with C.M.P.No.937/2016 pending enquiry under section 202 Cr.P.C.
before the learned Magistrate in respect of the same incident.
The
learned Magistrate, instead of sending C.M.P.No.937/2016 to the
police under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C, had proceeded with the case in
accordance with Chapter XV of the Code of Criminal Procedure. At
the time of filing of C.M.P.No.583/2018, the complainant in
C.M.P.No.937/2016 and one witness (who is none other than the
complainant in C.M.P.No.583/2018, himself) were already examined
on oath, and the relevant medical records were summoned from
Seven Hills Hospital, Mumbai. It was in the meanwhile that the first
witness in C.M.P.No.937/2016 had filed C.M.P.No.583/2018 in respect
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
of the same incident with a request to direct the police to register a
crime and to commence investigation upon the allegation of murder
of Swami Sudheendra Theertha. After posting the above C.M.P. for
some time along with C.M.P.No.937/2016, the learned Magistrate, on
09.07.2019,
passed
C.M.P.No.583/2018
to
the
the
impugned
S.H.O
of
order
forwarding
Police, Ambalamedu for
registration of F.I.R and report.
4.
In the present petition, the petitioner would contend that
the procedure adopted by the learned Magistrate in forwarding
C.M.P.No.583/2018 to the police under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C, is alien
to the known and established procedures of law. It is stated that,
after taking cognizance of the offence in C.M.P.No.937/2016, the
learned Magistrate cannot revert back to pre-cognizance stage and
forward another complaint filed by a witness in C.M.P.No.937/2016, in
respect of the same incident, to the police under Section 156(3)
Cr.P.C.
It is the further contention of the petitioner that the
complaint about the alleged murder of Swami Sudheendra Theertha
is totally baseless and mala fide, and that it is preferred on the basis
of mere speculations. According to the petitioner, the complaint is
the outcome of the ill motivated struggle of one Sivananda Pai @
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
Raghavendra Theertha for grabbing the position of ‘Madathipathi of
Sree Kashi Math Samsthan’.
5.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners, the learned
counsel for the first respondent and the learned Public Prosecutor
representing the State of Kerala.
6.
As stated above, C.M.P.No.937/2016 filed at the instance
of a person by name Anand K Prabhu, was pending enquiry under
Section 202 Cr.P.C before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court,
Chottanikkara at the time when C.M.P.No.583/2018 was filed by the
first respondent herein in connection with the same incident relating
to the death of Swami Sudheendra Theertha.
So also, the
complainant in C.M.P.No.583/2018 is the first witness who had been
examined in the enquiry conducted by the learned Magistrate in
C.M.P.No.937/2016.
C.M.P.No.937/2016
Even
before
tendering
the
sworn
complainant
in
statement,
Crl.M.C.No.7378/2016 was filed by him before this Court to set aside
the order of the learned Magistrate taking cognizance of the offence
in the said C.M.P, and for a direction for police investigation. The
above said Crl.M.C was dismissed as not pressed on 08.03.2017. It is
thereafter that the first respondent filed C.M.P.No.583/2018, which
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
the learned Magistrate posted along with C.M.P.No.937/2016 for
some time.
7.
As
already
stated
above,
the
crime
alleged
in
C.M.P.No.583/2018 and C.M.P.No.937/2016, is one and the same.
The moment when the learned Magistrate decided to record the
sworn statement of the complainant in C.M.P.No.937/2016, the law
envisages cognizance of the offence being taken. It is also pertinent
to note that the learned Magistrate had gone a long way in the
enquiry under Section 202 Cr.P.C in C.M.P.No.937/2016 by even
summoning the medical records pertaining to the treatment of Swami
Sudheendra Theertha at Seven Hills Hospital, Mumbai. According to
the petitioners, after advancing to such an extent pursuant to the
cognizance being taken in respect of the offence involved in this
case,
the
learned
Magistrate
cannot
revert
back
to
the
pre-cognizance stage for the sole reason that another complaint has
been filed by a witness in C.M.P.No.937/2016 in respect of the same
incident. Thus, the legal issue involved in this matter is whether the
Magistrate is justified in reverting back to the pre-cognizance stage,
and directing investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C., upon the
complaint of the first respondent, after cognizance having already
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
been taken upon the crime in the earlier complaint filed as
C.M.P.No.937/2016 by another person.
8. In S.A.S.Infratech Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Telangana
[2024 SCC OnLine SC 4046 : 2024 KHC 8245], a two judge
bench of the ApexCourt held that once the Magistrate takes
cognizance of the offence and embarks upon the procedure
embodied in Chapter XV, he is not competent to switch back to the
pre-cognizance stage and avail of Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. It was so
held by following the dictum laid down by the Apex Court in
Devarapalli Lakshminarayana Reddy and Ors. v. V. Narayana
Reddy and Ors. [MANU/SC/0108/1976 : 1976:INSC:136 :
(1976) 3 SCC 252]. However, a three judge bench of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, in Vinubhai Haribhai Malaviya v. State of
Gujarat & Another [(2019) 17 SCC 1], held that the above
dictum in Devarapalli Lakshmi Narayana Reddy (supra) is one
rendered without taking note of the definition of “investigation” under
Section 2(h) of Cr.P.C., and hence not the correct exposition of law. It
has been laid down by the three judge bench of Hon’ble Apex Court
in Vinubhai (supra) that there is no legal embargo in the Magistrate
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
resorting to Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. even after taking cognizance of the
offence. The relevant paragraph in the above judgment is as follows:
“28. Section 2(h) is not noticed by the aforesaid judgment
at all, resulting in the erroneous finding in law that the
power under Section 156(3) can only be exercised at the
pre-cognizance stage. The “investigation” spoken of in
Section 156(3) would embrace the entire process, which
begins with the collection of evidence and continues until
charges are framed by the Court, at which stage the trial
can be said to have begun. For these reasons, the
statement of the law contained in para 17 in Devarapalli
Lakshminarayana
Reddy
[Devarapalli
Lakshminarayana
Reddy v. V. Narayana Reddy, (1976) 3 SCC 252 : 1976 SCC
(Cri) 380] cannot be relied upon.”
9. True that the above verdict has been rendered while dealing
with the powers of the Magistrate in ordering further investigation
under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C., but still the law laid down by the Apex
Court on the legal issue involved in this case, has to be followed by
this Court. Therefore, the mere reason that the learned Magistrate
had already taken cognizance of the offence involved in this case,
cannot be termed as a disqualification in passing the impugned order
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
under section 156(3) Cr.P.C. directing the Police to register a crime
and investigate.
10. The learned counsel for the petitioners, by referring to
Annexure A8 Medical Records pertaining to the treatment of Swami
Sudheendra Theerdha, pointed out that the condition of the said
Swamy was such that he would have suffered death, at the same
time, as happened, even if he had not been discharged from the
hospital, since he was not responding to medicines. According to the
learned counsel, the Swamy was discharged from hospital and taken
to Haridwar Ashram to fulfil his cherished desire to be there in that
Ashram at the time of his last breath. Thus, it is argued that the act
of the petitioners and other disciples taking the Swamy to the
Haridwar Ashram on 16-01-2016 cannot be termed as culpable
homicide within the meaning of Section 299 IPC. Accordingly, it is
submitted that the averments in the complaint, even if accepted as
such, will not constitute any offence as alleged. With regard to the
above submission, it has to be stated at the outset that, in a
proceedings under section 482 Cr.P.C., this Court cannot embark upon
an enquiry as to the health condition of the deceased Swamy as
revealed from Annexure A8 Medical Records, and whether it indicated
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
that the Swamy would not have survived even if he was retained in
that hospital for some more days. It is a matter to be decided after
the examination of the doctors who treated the Swamy, with specific
reference to the contents of the above Medical Records.
11. As already stated above, the learned Magistrate has already
taken cognizance of the offence alleged in this case, and gone a long
way in the enquiry conducted under section 202 Cr.P.C. in the earlier
complaint filed before him as C.M.P.No.937/2016. He is yet to arrive
at the logical conclusions of the above enquiry, and decide whether
there are sufficient grounds to proceed against the accused in
connection with the offence alleged. At this stage, it is not at all
desirable and proper for this Court to embark upon the question
whether the allegations in the complaint, filed by the first respondent
as C.M.P.No.583/2018, in respect of the same incident, would
constitute the offence alleged against the petitioners and others. This
is especially so in view of the fact that the decision by this Court on
that point would definitely have an impact on the enquiry being
conducted by the learned Magistrate in C.M.P.No.937/2016. If this
Court finds that the offence alleged against the petitioners are not
attracted even if the allegations in C.M.P No.583/2018 are accepted
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
as such, then the learned Magistrate would be put to the precarious
position of winding up the enquiry in C.M.P.No.937/2016 in the
midway. Likewise, if this Court finds that the allegations in
C.M.P.No.583/2018 would make out the offence alleged, then also
the finding in the above regard would affect the independent decision
of the learned Magistrate in the enquiry being conducted
under
section 202 Cr.P.C. in C.M.P.937/2016. Therefore, it may not be
proper for this court to express any opinion as to the mixed question
of facts and law on the point
whether the allegations in
C.M.P.No.583/2018 would bring home the offence of culpable
homicide, or not. Such a course would definitely render the enquiry
in C.M.P.No.937/2016, as well as the procedures which the
Investigating
Agency
is
bound
to
follow
as
per
law
in
C.M.P.No.583/2016, nugatory. Hence the challenge raised by the
learned counsel for the petitioners on the merits of the allegations in
C.M.P.No.583/2018, cannot be looked into at this stage. As a
conclusion to the above discussions, I find that the prayer in this
petition
to
quash
C.M.P.No.583/2018
Annexure
A1
of
Judicial
the
Chottanikkara, cannot be allowed.
order
dated
First
09.07.2019
Class
in
Magistrate,
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
In the result, the petition is hereby dismissed.
(sd/-)
G. GIRISH, JUDGE
jsr
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
APPENDIX
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A1
CERTIFIED COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 9/7/2019
IN CMP. NO. 583/2018, JUDICIAL FIRST CLASS
MAGISTRATE COURT, CHOTTANIKKARA.
ANNEXURE A2
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF CMP NO. 937/2016 JFCM
CHOTTANIKKARA.
ANNEXURE A3
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF CRL.M.C. NO. 7378/2016,
HIGH COURT OF KERALA.
ANNEXURE A3(A)
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF CASE DETAILS OF CRL.M.C.
NO. 7378/2016 HIGH COURT OF KERALA.
ANNEXURE A4
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF REPORT DATED 6/7/2018
SUBMITTED BY SO OF POLICE, AMBALAMEDU
POLICE STATION, IN CMP NO. 937/2016, JFCM
CHOTTANIKKARA.
ANNEXURE A5
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS IN CMP.
NO. 937/2016, JFCM CHOTTANIKKARA.
ANNEXURE A6
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE SWORN STATEMENT OF
THE DEFACTO COMPLAINANT IN CMP. 937/2016,
JFCM CHOTTANIKKARA.
ANNEXURE A7
TRUE
PHOTOCOPY
OF
JUDICIAL FIRST CLASS
CHOTTANIKKARA.
ANNEXURE A8
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF CERTIFIED COPY OF THE
MEDICAL REPORTS DATED17/9/2019 PRODUCED
FROM SEVEN HILLS HEALTH CITY ON SUMMONS.
ANNEXURE A9
4ITRUE PHOTOCOPY OF CERTIFIED COPY OF THE
PETITION FILED BY ANAND K PRABHU IN CRL.MP
NO.937/2016, JFCM,CHOTTANIKKARA, TOGETHER
WITH WITNESS LIST AND DETAILS OF DOCUMENTS
SUMMONED.
ANNEXURE A10
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF CERTIFIED COPY OF THE
DEPOSITION OF K.K.HARI PAI DATED5/8/2017
IN
CRL
.MP
NO.937/2016,
JFCM
I,
CMP
NO.583/2018,
MAGISTRATE COURT,
Crl.M.C.No.5702/2019
2025:KER:26865
CHOTTANIKKARA.
ANNEXURE A11
TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF ORDER DATED 8/3/2017 IN
CRI.MC NO.7378/2016, HIGH COURT OF KERALA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review