Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Z
[ 3383 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY
WRIT
NO:37768 oF 2022
Between:
T. chinna Narasimha, s/o. Late T. Sunkanna, Age. 49 Yrs, occ. Agriculture,
B{o 5-11, Devendra Nagar, East Doudarpally, Gadwal, Jogulambi Gadwai
District-509125.
2 T.. shantam.ma, wo. Late Nadipi Mastan, Age. 65 yrs, occ. Agricurture,
R/o. Devendra Nagar, East Doudarpally, Gadwil, Jogulamba Gadwil District1
509125.
3. T. Narsimhulu, S/o. Late Bodanna or Thimanna, Age
Occ. Agriculture, R/o. Devendra Nagar, rait oor'oarpitly,
Jogulamba Gadwal District-S09125.
48 Yrs,
Gadwal,
T. chinna venkatramulu, s/o. Late Jamanna, (and Buddamma) Age. 55 yrs,
9.".. Agriculture, R/o. Devendra Nagar, East Doudarpally, Gadwal,
Jogulamba Gadwal District-509125.
5 T. Ramulu, S/o. Late Nadipi Timmanna, Age. 47 Yrs, Occ. Agriculture,
R/o. Devendra Nagar, East Doudarpally, Gadw'al, Jogulamba Gadwal District-
509125.
b
T. Srinivasulu, S/o. Late Chinna Timmanna Age. 45 Yrs, occ. Agriculture,
R/o. Devendra Nagar, East Doudarpally, Gadwal, Jogulamba Gadwal District509125.
S/o. Late Kane Thippanna Age. 36 Yrs, Occ. Agriculture,
IR/o.[avi,
Devendra Nagar, East Doudarpally, Gadwa l,
509125.
Jogulamba Gadwal District-
8. Krishn4 s/o_. Late Papanna, Age. 47 Yrs, occ. Agriculture, R/o. Devendra
Nagar,East Doudarpally, Gadwal, Jogulamba Gadwal District.
9. T. Govindamma, S/o. Late Jamanna, Age. 65 Yrs, Occ. Agriculture,
R/o. Devendra Nagar, East Doudarpally, Gadwal, Jogulamba Gadwal District509125.
S/o. Late Chinna [/astan, Age. 50 Yrs, Occ. Agriculture,
JR/o.Thimanna,
Devendra Nagar, East Doudarpally,
509125.
Gadwral, Jogulamba Gadwil District-
11.T. shakuntalamma, wo. Late Kondanna, Age. 44 Yrs, occ. Agriculture,
R/o. Devendra Nagar, East Doudarpally, Gadwal, Jogulamba Gadwal District509125.
..PETITIONERS
ii
Z
AND
The State of Telangana, Represented by its PringiP-al S^ecretary, Revenue
Department, Telanlana Seiretariat, Hyderabad'500022.
The Telangitna State Wakf Board, RgP, !y its Chief Executive Officer,
Nanipatly St:ation Road, Hyderabad-500001.
The District Collector, Jogulamba-Gadwal district, Gadwal - 509 125.
The Joint Collector, Jogulamba-Gadwal District, Gadwal - 509 125.
The Revenue Divisional Officer, Gadwal, Jogulamba-Gadwal District-S09125.
The Tahsildar, Gadwal tVlandal, Gadwal Jogulamba-Gadwal District-S09125.
The District Collector, Mahabubnagar District, IMahabubnagar
...RESPONDENTS
Petition unCer Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances st:ated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to pass ,a writ order or orders more particularly in the nature of writ of
mandamus declaring the notification published in Supplement to Part-ll of Andhra
Pradesh Gazette No.28-A dated 13.07.2006, pertaining to S1.No.26028 notifying
the Sy.No .734,7!i5 as wakf properties under the repealed Wakf Act, 1954 thereby
not granting Occupation Rights Certificate (ORC) to the Petitioners under the A.P.
(Telangana Area) Abolition of lnams Act, 1955 by not entering their names in the
Dharani Portal as pattedars in the Sy.No.734, 735 to an extent respectively
admeasuring Ac.13.31 gts and Ac.7.39 gts s.ituated at Gadwal, Jogulamba
Gadwal District a,s illegal, arbitrary, unreasonable and violation of the Articles 14,
19,21, 300A of the Constitution of lndia, provisions of The Wakf Act,1995 and the
A.P. (Telangana Area) Abolition of lnams Act, 1955, consequently quash the
notification publisTed in Supplement to Part-ll of Andhra Pradesh Gazette No.28-A
dt.13.07.2006 pertaining to S1.Nc.26028 notifying the Sy.No.734, 735 as wakf
properties under-1:he repealed Wakf Act, 1954 and direct the Respondent Nos. 3 to
6 to grant Occupation Rights Certificate (ORC) to the Petitioners under the A.P.
(Telangana Area) Abolition of lnams Act, 1955 and enter their names in the
Dharani Portal as pattedars in the Sy.No.734, 735 to an extent respectively
admeasuring Ac.'13.31 gts and Ac. 7.39 gts situated at Gadwal.
t
Z
IA NO: 1 0F 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the Respondent No.5 and 6 to consider the case of the Petitioners for granting for
granting of Occupation Rights Certificate to the Petitioners with respect to land
admeasuring Ac.13.3'l gts and Ac. 7.39 gts in the Sy.No.734,735 situated at
Gadwal, Jogulamba Gadwal District by passing orders in the proceedings already
initiated by issuing Notice (Form-ll) dated 31.08.2019, Notice Vide
No.B/127512019 dated 28.02.2020 and Letter No. 8,1247912021 dated 20.11.2021.
lA NO: 2 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the Respondents not to interfere with petitioners occupation and possession of the
property admeasuring Ac.13.31 gts and Ac. 7.39 gts in the Sy.No.734,735
situated at Gadwal, Jogulamba Gadwal District.
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI L. RAVI CHADER, APPEARING FOR
SRI S. GOUTHAM
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1,3 to 7: GP FOR REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI MOHD. lSMAlL, SC FOR WAKF BOARD
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OI. TTLANGANA AT
HYDEABAI)
ITON'BI,E SRI JUSTICE LITXMI NARAYAITA ALISHETTY
WRIT PETITION No.37768 ol2022
DATE: 24.o2.2ot26
Between
T.Chinna N:rrasimha and others.
...Petitioaers
AND
The State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Revenue
Department and others.
...Respondents
:ORDER:
This rvrit petition is hled seeking a declaration that the
notification published in the Supplement to Part-ll of the Andhra
Pradesh Gazette No. 28-A dated 13.O7.2006, publishing a list of Wakf
properties in Gadwal Taluk of Mahabubnagar District surveyed under
Section 4(3) cf Wakf Act, 1957 and published under Section 5(2) of ibid,
pertaining t.o Sl. No. 2602A, notifying Sy. Nos. 734 and Z3S,
admeasurinSg Ac. 13.31 guntas and Ac. 7.39 guntas respectively,
situated at (iadwal, .Iogulamba Gadwal District (for short, the ' subject
propertyJ, as Wakf properties under the repealed Wakf Act, 1954, as
illegal and rtrbitrary. The petitioners also seek a declaration that the
consequentiill denial of Occupation Rights Certificates (ORC) under the
A.P. (Telangrna Area) Abolition of Inams Act, 1955, and the failure to
enter their names as pattadars in the Dharani Portal in respect of the
subject propert5r, as illegal and arbitrary.
2.
Heard Sri L.Ravi chander, learned senior counsel appearing for
the petitioners, sri Mohd.lsmail, learned standing counsel for wakf
Board for respondent No.2 and learned Government pleader for
Revenue
3'
Learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioners would
submit that in similar facts and circumstances a learned Single Judge
of this Court set aside the Gazette Notification dated 1S.1l.2OOL, vide
order dated 22.09.2016 in wp.No.33Lg3/2014, holding that the survey
conducted under Section a(3) of the wakf Act, L9sr, is not saved under
Section ll2 of the Wakf Act 1995. It is further submitted that aggrieved
by the same, the wakf Board preferred. appeal vide wA.N o.1432 of 2oL6
wherein the Division Bench of this court vide Judgment dated
04.12.2023 conlirmed the order of learned Single Judge in
WP-No.33l33l2OL4 to the extent of setting aside the notification dated
15.11.2ooL with regard to the subject property therein. However, the
Division Bench set aside the findings recorded by the learned Single
Judge that survey conducted under section a(3) of the wakf Act, 1954
is not saved under Section LL2 of the Wakf Act, 1995.
4.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners further submitted that
the writ petition may be disposed of in terms of the common order
/)
passed by the Division Bench of this Court in WA.No.l432 of 2OL6,
WP.No.23241) /2OOB and WP.No. 19205 /2019 dated 04.L2.2023.
5.
Learned Standing Counsel for Wakf Board did not dispute the
aforesaid submission of learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners.
6.
Accorc.ingly, recoiding the submissions made by learned Senior
Counsel for the petil.ioners, the writ petition is disposed of in terms of
common onler dated 04.12.2023 passed in WA.No.l432 of 2016,
WP.Nos.232.12l2OO8 and 19205/2019 and the Notification published in
Supplement to Part II of Andhra Pradesh Gazette No.28-A dated
13.07.2006, insofar as it pertains to the subject property, is quashed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Miscel.laneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed.
SD/.P. PONNA KRISHNA
TANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
ECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Principal Secretary, Revenue Department, Telangana Secretariat, The
State of Telangana, Hyderabad-500022.
2. The Chiel'Exeiutive Officer, The Telangana State Wakf Board, Nanipally
Station R,rad, Hyderabad-500001.
3. The District Col6ctor, Jogulamba-Gadwal district, Gadwal - 509 125.
4. The Joint Collector, Jogu-lamba-Gadwal District, Gadwal - 509 125.
5. The Reve,nue Divisiona=l Officer, Gadwal, Jogulamba-Gadwal District-5O9125.
6. The Tahsildar, Gadwal Mandal, Gadwal Jogulamba-Gadwal District-S09125.
7. The District Collector, Mahabubnagar District, Mahabubnagar
8. One CC to Sri S. Goutham, Advocate IOPUC]
9. Two CCs to GP for Revenue, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
\
TJ
Hyderabad [OUT]
10.Ohe CC to Sri Mohd. lsmail, SC for Wakf Board[OPUC]
1 1 . Two CD (lopies
Z
HIGH COURT
DATED i2410212026
ORDER
WP.No.37768 of 2022
t
uO
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
(i->
, laI
i,"iE 5 T4
0 6 liflB 2026
*r
WITHOUT COSTS
!
)r
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE ALOK ARADHE
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE N.V.SHRAVAN KUMAR
TIIRIT APPEAL No.1432 of 2o16. W.P.
and 192O5 of2O19
of 2OO8
COMMON ORDER : per iiie Hon'bte tne Cnid|,t*ici el6i eradtel
The intra-court appeal has been filed by Telangana state
Wakf Board (hereinafter referred to as Wakf BoardJ against an
order dated 22.09.2016 passed by the learned Single Judge by
which writ petition preferred by M/s.Solithro Private Limited
(hereinafter referred to as 'companyJ had been allowed and the
notification dated 15.11.2001 notifying the list of properties
situated at Narsapur and Siddipet Taluks of Medak District as
properties belonging to the Wakf has been quashed. In
W.P.No.23242 of 2008, the petitioner therein has assailed the
validity of notification dated 15.11 .2OOL declaring the
properties to be wakf property and has sought relief of
de-notification of the land in survey Nos-33 to 38, 40, 42 lo 70,
72 to 74 and 76 to 87 of Sikindlapur Village, Shivampet
Mandal, Medak District. In W.P.No. 79205 of 2019, the
petitioner seeks a direction to Inam Tribunal cum Revenue
Divisional Officer to decide fi|e No.H/5652/98 by issuing
pattadar f,ass book and title in favour of the petitioner in
respect of the land measuring Acas.11.O0 bearing Surwey
Nos.60 ar.d 65 situated at Sikindlapur village, Shivampet
Mandal, Medak District.
2.
Similar issues arise for consideration in the writ appeal
as well as the writ petitions. Therefore, the writ appeal and the
writ petitic,ns were heard analogously and are being decided by
this comrron order. For the facility of reference, facts from
W.A.No.1432 of 2076 are being referred to.
(i) FACTS:
3.
One Smt. Azeez Bee and others filed applications before
the Revenue Divisional officer seeking Occupancy Rights
Certificate. The aforesaid applications were rejected by an
order dated 18.12.1998. Being aggrieved, an appeal was filed
which war; also dismissed by an order dated 2l.06.200l by
Joint coll:ctor. The orders passed by the Revenue Divisional
officer anrl the Joint collector were challenged by Smt. Azeez
Bee and ot.hers in a writ petition, namely W.P.No.6107 of 2OO3,
which was; dismissed on 28.03.2ao6. The aforesaid order was
upheld in a writ appeal, namely W.A. (SR) No.633O3 of 2026,
which was dismissed for default on appearance on 01.09.2006.
4. It appears that one Axis Engineers and others had
purchased lands under various sale deeds measuring
Acs.23.08 guntas in survey Nos.136, 137,227 and' 228 of
Shabhaspally Village, Shivampet Mandal of Medak District
(hereinafter referred to as 'subject land). The aforesaid lands
were mortgaged to ING Vysya Bank Limited and State Bank of
India. The subject land was sold in auction held on 26.72.2013
and 13.08.2014, which was conducted by ING Vysya Bank.
The company purchased the subject land in the said auction
and on 07.O2.20t4 and 16.O8.2OL4 sale certificates were
issued in their favour.
5.
On the basis of the survey conducted in the year 1963
under the Wakf Act, L954 (hereinafter referred to as the 1954
ActJ, a notification dated 15.11.2OO1 under Section 5 of the
Wakf Act, 1995 (hereinafter referred to as the 1995 Act) was
issued by the State Government by which the subject land was
declared to be wakf property.
(iil ORDEIR OF LEARNTD STNGLE WDGE:
6.
The company thereupon, filed a writ petition in which the
validity of the notification issued under section 5 of the 1995
Act, date<l 15.11.2001 was challenged. The learned Single
Judge by an order dated 22.09.2016 inter alia held that writ
petition drres not suffer from delay and laches and the rule of
exhaustio:r of alternative remedy is a rule of discretion and not
a compuls,ion. It was further held that survey conducted under
section 4 of the 1954 Act is not saved under section ll2(21 of
the 1995 Act. The learned single Judge, therefore, quashed the
notification dated 15.11 .2oo1 and allowed the writ petition. In
the afores;aid factual background, the wakf Board has filed
this appee.l.
(iii) SUBMISSTONS ON BEHALF OF WAKF BOARD:
7.
Learned Senior counsel for the wakf Board has
submitted that the survey carried out under section 4 of the
L954 Act is saved under Section ll2(2) of the 199s Act. It is
further submitted that the rights and obligations accrLled to
the partie{i were not obliterated while repealing the 1954 Act. It
is also submitted that the survey got merged with the
notilication and therefore, the question of delay and laches in
issuing the impugned notification dated 1s.11.2oo1 under
section 5 of the 1995 Act does not arise: It is contended that
notification declaring the property as wakf properl5r was issued
on 15. 1 1 .2001, wheleas the writ petition was filed belatedly on
05.17.2074. Learned. Single Judge, therefore, ought to have
appreciated that the writ petition suffers from delay and laches
and merely because the company purchased the subject land
under the provisions of the Securitisation and Reconstruction
of Financial Assets and Enforcement of security Interest Act,
2oo2 (hereinafter referred to as the SARFAESI Act) in the year
2073 and 2014, the same cannot be a ground to hold that the
writ petitions filed by the company does not suffer from delay
and laches.
8.
It is also urged that the company ought to have
approached the Wakf Tribunal under Section 6(1) of the 1995
Act instead of filing the writ petition, In support of the
aforesaid submissions, reliance has been placed on the
decisions of the Supreme court in Gammon rndia Limited vs.
Special C:hief Secretaryr, Indore Development Authority
vs. Manotrar Lalz, Madanuri Sri Rama Chandra Murthy vs.
Syed Jala.la, Rashid \llali Beg vs. Farid Pindari+, Sayeed Ali
vs. Andh:ra Pradesh lllakf Boards, Telangana State Wakf
Board vs. P.Radha Madhavio and Telangana State Wakf
Board vs. P.Radha Madhaviz.
[iv] SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF COMPANY:
9.
On the other hand, learned Senior Counsel for the
company has submitted that notification dated 15.11.2001
has been published under Section 5 of the 7954 Act which has
been repe,aled by the 1995 Act. Therefore, the notification
issued un,ler repealed provision of law is void and the question
of its invalidity can be set up at any stage. It is further
submitted that since the notification is null and void, the
doctrine cf delay and laches does not apply. It is contended
that the company is the purchaser of the subject land in the
auction held on 26.12.2O13 and 13.08.2074.|t is also argued
| (2006) 3 SrlC 354
2 (2020) 8 S(lC 129
3 (2Or7) 13 liCC 174
4 12022) 4 S(lC 414
s (1998) 2 St:C 642
e W.A.No.31 I of 2021
7 S.L.P. Nos.4166-4175 of 2022
that the provisions of SARFAESI Act have an overriding effect
over the other provisions of law. It is further contended that
the issue whether or not the survey cond.ucted under the 1954
,,,
J
.,
Act is saved und.er the 1995 Act, may not arise, for
consideration in t] e facts of the case, as'the notification itself
has been issued under the Repealed Act. It is argued that only
upon publication of notification under Section 5(2) of the 1954
Act, the proprietaqr rights of a person are affected. In support
of the aforesaid submissions, learned Senior Counsel has
placed reliance on D.C.Bhatia vs. Union of Indiaa, Tamil
Nadu Wakf Board vs. Hathija Ammalg, Roma Sonkar vs.
Madhya Pradesh State Public Service Commissionlo
Telangana State lllakf Board vs. L.Srinivasa Reddyrr,
Kailash Singh Rajpurohit vs. State of Telangarrat2 and
Maharashtra State Board of Wakfs vs. Shaikh Yusuf Bhai
Chawlare.
8 (1995) 1 SCC 104
e (20o1) 8
ro
17 SCC 106
scc
12018)
2021 SCC Online TS 1449
12 2022 SCC Online TS 7073
13 2022 SCC Online SC 1653
r0
(v) RELEIIANT PROVISIONS:
10. we have considered the submissions made on both sides
and perused the record. Before proceeding further, it is
apposite ':o take note of relevant statutory provisions. The
wakf Act, 1954 was enacted to provide for better
administr:rtion and supervision of wakfs. The lgs4 Act was
repealed lly the wakf Act, 199s which was enacted with an
object to provide for better administration of wakfs and
matters connected therewith.
11. section 4 of the 1954 Act deals with survey, whereas
section 5 provides for publication of list of wakfs. section 6
deals with disputes regarding wakfs. The relevant provisions of
the 1954 Act and the 1995 Act prior to its amendment by Act
No.27 of :2013 dated o1.11.2or3 are extracted below for the
facility of :-eference:-
WakfAct, 1954
Wakf Act, 1995
1. Section
1. Section 4
4. Preliminary
"4.Preliminary survey of sur:vey of Wakfs--(1) The State
wakfs.
(1)The
State Government may, by notification in
Governmerrt ffiay,
by the Official Gazette, appoint for the
notificatior: in the Officiai State a Survey Commissioner
Gazette, appoint for the State of Wakfs and as many Additional
or
ll
a Survey Commissioner of Assistant Survey Commissioners
Wakfs and as many Additional of Wakfs as may be necessary for
or
Assistant
Surwey
the pulpose of making a survey
Commissioners of Wakfs as of Wakfs edsting in the State at the
may be necessary for the date of the commencement of this
purpose of making a survey of Act.
(2) All Additional and Assistant
the Survey Commissioners of Wakfs
wakfs existing in the State at
date
the
of
shall perform their functions under
commencement of this Act.
All Additional and this Act under the general
Survey supervision and control of the
Assistant
(2)
Commissioners of Wakfs shall Survey Commissioner of Wakfs.
perform their functions under
this Act under the general
supervision and control of the
(3) The Survey Commissioner shall,
after making such inquiry as he
Survey Commissioner of may consider necessary, submit his
Wakfs.
(3) The Survey Commissioner
report, in respect of Wakfs existing
at the date of the commencement of
shall, after making such this Act in the State or any Part
to the State Government
inquiry as he may consider thereof,
following
containing the
necessary, submit his report
at
the date of
the
commencement of this Act in
the State or any part thereof,
particulars, namely:--
(a) the number ofWakfs in the
State showing the Shia Wakfs and
to the State Government Sunni Wakfs separately;
and objects of
containing the following (b) the nature
particulars, namely, (a) the each Wakf;
(c) the gross income of the property
number of wakfs in the State,
in each Wakf;
or as the case may be, any comprised
(d) the amount of land revenue,
part thereof, showing the Shia
cesses, rates and taxes paYable in
t2
lwakfs and Sunni wakfs
respect of each Wakf;
separately; (b) the nature and (e) the expenses incurred in the
objects of each wakf; (c) the realisation of the income and the
gross inco:ne of the property pay or other remuneration of the
comprised in each wakf; mutawalli of each Wakf; and
(d) the amount of land (f) such other particulars relating to
reventle, ()esses, rates and each Wakf as may be prescribed.
taxes payable in respect of
(a)
The Survey Commissioner shall,
trrroperty; (e) the
expenses incurrecl in the while making any inquiry, have the
such
realisation of the income and same powers as are vested in a civil
Court under the Code of Civit
of the mutawalli of each wakf; Procedure, 1908 (5 of 190S) in
and (0 such other particulars respect of the following matters,
the pay or other remuneration
relating to each wakf as may namely:-be prescribed.
(a) summoning and examining any
(a) The Survey Cornmissioner
witness;
shall, wh.ile making any (b) requiring the discovery and
inquiry, have the serme powers production of any document;
as are ves ied in a civil court (c) requisitioning any public record
under thr: Code of Civil from any court or office;
Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), (d) issuing, commissions for the
in respect of the following examination of any witness or
matters,
namely:- accounts;
(a) summoning and examining
(e) making any local inspection or
any witness; (b) requiring the local investigation;
discovery and production of (0 such other matters as may be
any
document;
(c) requisitioning arry public
record frcm any court or
prescribed.
(5) E during any such inquiry, any
dispute arises as to whether a
l3
office; (d) issuing commissions particular Wakf is a Shia Wakf or
for the examination of any Sunni Wakf and there are clear
accounts; indications in the deed of Wakf as
witness or
(e) making
any local to its nature, the dispute shall be
local decided on the basis of such deed.
ins-pection or
investigation; {0 any other
matter which may be (6) The State Government may, by
notification in the Officia] Gazette,
prescribed. (5) If, during any
such inquiry, any dispute direct the Survey Commissioner
arises as to whether a make a second or subsequent
to
survey of Wakf properties in the
the provisions of subor Sunni wakf and there are State and
sections {2), (3), (a) and (5) shall
clear indications in the deed of
as theY aPPIY
wakf as to its nature, the apply to such survey
to a survey directed under subdispute shall be decided on
particular wakf is a Shia wakf
the basis of such deed.
section (1):
Provided that no such second or
subsequent survey shall be made
until the expiry of a period of
twenty years from the date on
which the report in relation to the
immediately previous survey was
submitted under sub-section (3):
2. Section 5 - Publication of 2. Section 5 - 5. Publication of list
list of wakfs.- (1) On receipt of Wakfs:.--(1) On receipt of a
of a report under sub-section report under sub-section (3) of
(3) of section 4, the State section 4, the State Government
Government shall forward a shall forward a copy of the same to
copy of the sarne to the Board.
the Board.
t4
(2) The Board shall examine
(21 The Board shall examine the
the reporl. forwarded to it report forwarded to it under subunder su'c-section (1) and section (1) and publish in the
publish in the Official Gazette Official Gazette a list of Sunni
a list of wrtkfs existing in the Wakfs or Shia Wakfs, in the State,
State, or as the case may be, whether in existence at the
the part of the State
commencement of this Act or
1. Subs. by Act 38
coming into existence thereafter, to
of 1969, s.4, for "in the State" which the report released, and
(with retrcspective effect). 2. containing such other particulars
Subs. By S.5, ibid., for
"existing i.r the State" (with
retrospecti.ze effectt. 108 to
as may be prescribed.
which the report relates, and
containing such particulars as
may be prescribed.
3. Section 6 - 6. Disputes 3. Section 6 - 6. Disputes
regarding rvakfs.- (1) If any regarding Wakfs.--(1) If
any
question arises rvhether a question arises whether a
particular propertl, specified particular property specified
as wakf p:-operty in a list of as Wakf property in the list
wakfs published under sub- of Wakfs is Wakf property or not or
section l2l of section 5 is wakf whether a Wakf specified in such
property o:' not or whether a list is a Shia Wakf or Sunni Wakf,
wakf specified in such list is a the Board or the Mutawalli of
Shia wakf or Sunni wakf, the the Wakf or any person interested
Board or the mutawalli of the therein may institute a suit in a
wakf or any person interested Tribunal for the decision of the
therein may institute a suit in question and the decision of the
a civil court of competent Tribunal in respect of such matter
jurisdiction for the decision of shall be final:
Provided that no such suit
the question and the decision
of the civil court in respect of shall be entertained by the Tribunal
such matter shall be final: after the expiry of one year from the
Provided that no such suit date of the publication of the list
shall be entertained by the of Wakfs:
civil court after the expiry of Explanation: For the purposes of
one year from the date of the this Section and Section 7, the
publication of the list of wakfs expression uarty person interested
under sub-section (2) of therein", shall, in relation to any
Section 5:
Provided further propelty specified as Wakf property
that in the case of the list of in the list of Wakfs published after
wakfs relating to any part of the commencement of the Act, shall
the State and published or include also every person who,
purporting to have been though not interested in the Wakf
published before the concerned, is interested in such
commencement of the Wakf property and to whom a reasonable
(Amendment) Act, 1969, (38 of opportunity had been afforded to
1969.1 Such suit may be represent his case by notice served
entertained by the civil court on him in that behalf during the
within the period of one year course of the relevant enquiry
from such commencement.
under Section 4.
(2) Notwithstanding anYthing
contained in sub-section (1), no
contained in sub-section (1),
proceeding under this Act in
no proceeding under this Act
(2)Notwithstanding anything
respect of any Wakf shall be staYed
in respect of any wakf shall be
by reason only of the pendencY of
stayed by reason only of the
any such suit or of any aPPeal or
pendency of any such suit or
other proceeding arising out of
t6
of any appeal or
other such suit.
proceeding arising out of such
suit.
(3) The Survey Commissioner shall
not be made a party to any suit
(3) The Survey Commissioner under sub-section (1) and no suit,
other legal
shall not be made a party to prosecution or
any suit u.:rder sub-section (l) proceeding shall lie against him in
and no sr-rit, prosecution or respect of anything which is in
other legal proceeding shall lie good taith done or intended to be
against him in respect of done in pursuance of this Act or
anything which is in good any rules made thereunder.
faith done or intended to be
(a) The list of Wakfs shall, unless it
done in pu.rsuance of this Act
is modified in pursuance of a
or arty rules made thereunder.
(a) The list of wakfs published
decision of the Tribunal under subsection (1), be final and conclusive.
under strb-section (2) of
Section 5 sha-ll, uniess it is (5)
On and from the
modified in pursuance of a commencement of this Act in a
decision of the civil court State, no suit or other legal
under sub-.section (1), be final proceeding shall be instituted or
and conclusive.
commenced in a court in that State
in relation to any question referred
to in sub-section (1).
12. The Supreme court in Madanuri sri Rama chandra
Murthy (supra) has considered sections 4, 5 and 6 of the lg54
Act as well as the 1995 Act and has held that sections 4 to 6
contained in both the Acts are almo st pai materia with each
I
I
I
i
other. Paras 12, 73 and 76 are extracted below for the facility
of reference:
12. Section 4 of 'the 1954 'Act, empowered the State
Government to appoint a State Commissioner, and as
many Additional and Assistant Survey Commissioners of
Wakf as may be necessary, by a notification in the Official
Gazette for the purpose of making survey of wakf
properties existing within the State. The Survey
Commissioner after making a survey of wakf properties
would submit his report to the State Government
containing various particulars as mentioned in subsections (3) and (a) of Section 4 of the Act. Section 5 of the
1954 Act mandated that on receipt of such report from the
Survey Commissioner made under sub-section (3) of
Section 4, the State Government should forward a copy of
the same to the Wakf Board. The Wakf Board would
examine the report forwarded to it and publish in Official
Gazette, the list of wakfs in the State. For resolving the
disputes regarding wakfs, Section 6 of the 1954 Act,
provided jurisdictional civil court as a forum and decision
of civil court in respect of such matters should be final. It
was also clarified that no such suit should be entertained
by the civil court, after the expiry of one year from the date
of publication of the list of wakfs as per sub-section 12) of
Section 5. Sub.section (4) of Section 6 stated that the list
of wakfs published under sub-section (2) of Section 5 shall
be final and conclusive unless such list is modified on the
direction of the civil court.
13. The provisions found in Sections 5 and 6 of the
Wakf Act, 1995 and the 1954 Act are almost akin to each
other. However, the change brought in by Parliament
l8
undor the 1995 Act is that, in the case of dispute
rega:ding wakfs, the aggrieved party needs to approach
the Wakf Tribunal constituted under Section 83 of the
Wakt Act, 1995 and consequently, the jurisdiction of the
civil court is taken away. Except the aforesaid change, no
other substantial modification is found in those
provisions. Section 7 of the 1995 Act empowers the
Tribunal to determine the disputes, regarding
auqeLf/wakfs, the particulars of which are specified
therr:in.
16. Thus, it is amply clear that the conducting of
survey by the Survey Commissioner and preparing a
report and forwarding the same to the State or the Wakf
Board precedes the final act of notifying such list in the
Official Gazette by the State under the 1995 Act (it was by
the .3oard under the 1954 Act). As mentioned supra, the
list rvould be prepared by the Survey Commissioner after
making due enquiry and after valid surv'ey as well as after
due application of mind. The enquiry contemplated under
sub-section (3) of Section 4 is not merely an informal
enqtriry but a formal enquiry to find out at the grass root
level, as to whether the property is a wakf property or not.
Thereafter the' Wakf Board will once again examine the list
sent to it with due application of its mind and only
therr:after the same will be sent to the Government for
notilying the same in the Gazette. Since the list is
prepared and published in the Official Gazette by following
the aforementioned procedure, there is no scope for the
plaintiff to get the matter reopened by generating some
sort of doubt about Survey Commissioner's Report. Since
the flurveyor's Report was required to be considered by the
Statt: Government as weil as the Wakf Board (as the case
.1
,
:
may be), prior to finalisation of the list of properties to be
published in the Oflicial Gazette, it was not open for the
High Court to conclude that the Surveyor's Report will
have to be reconsidered. On the contrar5r, the Surveyor's
, :
Report merges with, the gazette notification published
,,
under Section 5 of the Wakf Act.
(vil ISSUES:
13. After noticing the provisions of the 7954 Act and the
1995 Act,
we
may advert to the issues which arise for
consideration in this appeal. The following issues arise for
consideration in this appeal and the writ petitions:
(i)
Whether the survey conducted under Section 4 of
the Wakf Act, 7954, is saved under Section ll2(2) of the Wakf
Act, 1995?
(ii) Whether the notification dated 15.11.2001 has
been issued under Section 5(2) of the Wakf Act, 7954 and is
therefore nullity?
(iii) Whether the writ petition filed by the company
suffers from delay and laches? and
(iv) Whether the Wakf Tribunal is the only authority
under Section 6(1) of the Wakf Act, 1995 to examine the
validity of the impugned notification dated 15.11 .2OO7 and the
same canrlot be examined in a proceeding under Article 226 of
the Constitution of lndia?
(vii) ANAL,YSIS:
(t)
Whe'ther the suroeg conducted under Section 4 of the
Waltf Acit, 7954, is squed under Section 112(2) of the
Wakf Act, 7995?
14. The making of survey under Section 4 of the Act is not a
mere administrative act but it is to be informed by a quasi-
judicial inquiry. The surveyor has the power to find out
whether a particular property is a wakf and Commissioner has
to determine the aspects which have been mentioned in
Section 4 of the Act (see Maharashtra State Board of Wakfs
(supra)). llhe effect of repeal of a statute is to destroy all
inchoate rights and all causes of action which may have arisen
under tht: provisions of repealed statute. When repeal is
followed by a fresh legislation on the same subject, the Court
undoubteclly has to look into the provisions of the new Act, but
only for the purpose of determining whether they indicate a
different intention. The line of enquiry would be, not whether
the new Ar:t expressly keeps alive old rights and liabilities, but
:- ,,, ::; , : -,
.
:',
,,
'j,..:
whether it manifests an intention to destroy them (see state of
Punjab vs. Mohar singhr+1. The aforesaid view was reiterated
in.;Gammon India (supra) and it was held that
the issue
regard to the continuation of pending
,,,:
l:
proceedings under a repealed statute depends either under the
savings contained in the Repeal Act or under Section 6 of the
General Clauses Act. It was further held that question whether
a right was acqtlired or a liability incurred under a statute
before its repeal in each case depends on the construction of a
statute and the facts of a particular case. It was also held that
when there is a repeal of an enactment and simultaneous
re-enactment, the re-enactment has to be considered as
reaffirmation of the old law and the provisions of the repealed
Act which are thus re-enacted continue in
force
uninterruptedly unless the re-enacted enactment manifests an
intention incompatible with or contrary to the provisions of the
repealed Act. The aforesaid view was again reiterated with
approval in State of Haryana vs. Hindustan Construction
Company Limitedts
14 1.955 (1) SCR 893 : AIR 1955 SC 84
ts 1)017) 9 SCC 463
15. Section 772 of the 1995 Act, which deals with repeal and
savings, isi extracted below for the facility of reference:
112. Repeal and savings:- (1) The Wakf Act, 1954 129 of
1954) and the Wakf (Amendment) Act, lg84 (69 of 1984) are
heretry repealed.
(2) Notwithstanding such repeal, an5rthing done or
any ilction taken under the said Acts shall be deemed to
have been done or taken under the corresponding provisions
of this Act.
(3) If, irnmediately before the commencement of this
Act, In any Sl.ate, there is in force in that State, any law
which corresponds to this Act that corresponding law shall
stanc. repealed:
Providecl that such repeal shall not affect the previous
operetion of that corresponding law, and subject thereto,
anything done or any action taken in the exercise of any
power conferred by or under the corresponding law shall be
deemed to have been done or taken in the exercise of the
powe:s conferred by or under this Act as if this Act was in
force on the day on which such things were done or action
was taken.
76. In the instant case, the repeal of an enactment, namely
1954 Act is accompanied with simultaneous re-enactment
namely th: 1995 Act. In Madanuri Sri Rama Chandra Murthy
(supra), the Supreme Court has held that the provisions of
Sections 4, 5 and 6 of the 1954 Act as well as the 1995 Act are
substantizrlly similar. Therefore, the legislative intention can
safely be irrferred as re-affirmation of the old law.
, ,,:,r
I
I
.
17. It is pertinent to note that scope and effect of Section
Ll2(21 of the 1995 Act was considered by the Supreme Court
in T.Kaliamurthi v. Five Gori Thaikkal Wakfre and it was
held that Section 1 12 of the Act is in conformity with Section 6
of the General Clauses Act, which also provides that a repeal
shall not affect arry right, privilege, obligation or liability
acquired or incurred under the repealed enactment unless a
contrary intention appears. Thus, under Section 6 of the
General Clauses Act and Section 712 of the Wakf Act, prior
operation of the repealed enactment or the legal proceedings or
remedies instituted, continued or enforced are saved.
18. On perusal of Section 712(2) of the 7995 Act, the
legislative intent to save anything done or any action taken
under the 1954 Act is manifest. Therefore, an5rthing done or
any action taken under the 1954 Act is saved and shall be
deemed to have been done or taken under the corresponding
provisions of the 1995 Act. The re-enacted enactment i-e., the
1995 Act does not contain any intention incompatible with or
contrary to the provisions of the Repealed Act. Therefore, the
ro
12o08)9 scc 306
survey conducted under Section 4 of the lgs4 Act is saved
under Section 1L2(2) of the 1g9s Act. The first issue is,
therefore, answered in the affirmative.
(ii) whether the notificqtion dqted, rs.ll.zool has been
issued und,er section 5(2) of the wakf Act, rgs4 and. is
therefore nullitg?
17. A survey made in exercise of powers under section ael of
the 1954 lvct can be made the basis for issuing the notification
under Secr-ion 5(2) of the 1995 Act as the s€rme is saved und.er
Section 112(2) of the 1995 Act. Before proceeding further, it is
apposite to take note of the impugned notification dated
15.11 .2OO'.1 which reads as under:
SUPPLEMENT TO PART II
OF
THE ANDHRA PRADESH GAZETTE
PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY
No.46-A HYDERABAD, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 15, 2OOl
NCTIFI CATIONS BY HEADS OF DEPARTMENTS, ETC.
REVENUE NOTIFICATIONS
ANDHRA PRADESH STATE WAKF BOARD
. ii:.;:,
.": r I
LIST OF WAKF PROPERTIES (REGISTERED AI.{D
UNREGISTERED) IN NARSAPUR AND SIDDIPET TALUKS OF
l
MEDAK DISTRICT OT' TBI,ENGANA REGION SURVEYED
. :.:. ..
.
UNDER SECTION 4(3) OF THE WAKF ACT, 1954 AND, ,',j-. .,,,
','- .
,:.,.
':
,,
:::.-
Thus, it is evident that the notification under Section 5(2),1
has been issued under the 1954 Act.
18. The Supreme Court in D.C.Bhatia (supra) has held that
the provisions of the repealed statute cannot be relied upon
after it has been repealed. It has further been held that what
has been acquired under the repealed act, cannot be
disturbed, but if any new or further step is needed to be taken
under the Act that cannot be taken even after the Act is
' repealed. The aforesaid view has been reiterated with approval
by a three-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court in Manish
Kumar vs. Union of IndiatT and it has been held that rights
which have accrued are saved unless taken away expressly. It
is well settled legai proposition that except the cases where the
proceedings were commenced, prosecuted and brought to a
finality before the repeal, no proceeding under the repealed
statute can be commenced or continued after the repeal (see
rz (2021) 5 SCC 1
Keshavan Madhava Menon vs. State of Bombayra and
Mohan Raj vs. Dimbeswari Saikiale)
19. The notification in the instant case has notrbeen issued
under Seclion 5(2) of the 1995 Act, but has been issued under
Section 5(2) of the 1954 Act. The 1954 Act has been repealed
and therelbre, in view of well settled legal position referred to
in preceding paragraph, the powers under Section 5(2) of the
1954 Act cannot be invoked to issue the notification
Therefore, the second issue is answered in the affirmative by
stating thztt the notification dated 15.11.2OO1 has been issued
under Section 5(2) of the 1954 Act and the same is, therefore,
nullity
(iii) Whether the writ petition Jiled bg the compang
suffers fr,cl,rt delag and. laches?
20. It is lrite law that extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is discretionary
in nature and question of delay and laches in all kinds of cases
would not disentitle a part5r to invoke the jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. It is well settled legal
AIR 1951 rSC 128
le AIR 2007 i}C 232
_.r,.: i;.
principle that if an order is a nullity, its validity could be set
up whenever and wherever it is sought to be enforcedlor relied
,:
upon. It is equally well settled legal p-ositionlthat test while
,
.
,,,,,,..,,',:,:.r,,,
.....
'ascertaining the delay, is not of physiCatrrunning of time and
when circumstances justiffing the cond.uct exists, the illegality
which is manifest cannot be sustained on the sole ground of
laches (see M/s.Dehri Rohtas Light Railway Company
Limited vs. District Board, Bhojpurzo). In Tukaram Kana
Joshi vs.
Maharashtra Industrial Development
Corporation2l, the Supreme Court dealing with the issue of
delay in approaching the Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India has held as under:
13. The question of condonation of delay is one of
discretion and has to be decided on the basis of the facts
of the case at hand, as the sarne vary from case to case. It
will depend upon what the breach of fundamental right
and the remedy claimed are and when and how the delay
arose. It is not that there is any period of limitation for the
courts to exercise their powers under Article 226, nor is it
that there can never be a case where the courts cannot
interfere in a matter, after the passage of a certain length
of time. There may be a case where the demand for justice
is so compelling, that the High Court would be inclined to
interfere in spite of delay. Ultimately, it would be a matter
zo (199 2 SCC 598
'2)
zt (2Ol 3) I SCC 353
;::- .:'
within the discretion of the Court and such discretion,
must be exercised fairly and justly'so as to promote justice
and not to defeat it. The validity of the party's defence
must be tried upon principles substantially equitable.
[Vid: P.S. Sad.asiuaslt)amgv. State of T.N. [(1975) 1 SCC
t52 : 1975 SCC (L&S) 22 : AIR 1974 SC 22711 , State of
M.P. v. Nandlal Jaisutal t(19S6) 4 SCC 566 : AIR 1987 SC
251 and Trictip Kumar Dingalv. State of W.B. [(2OO9) I
SCC 768 : (20O9) 2 SCC (1,&S) 1191 )
1.4. No hard-and-fast rule can be laid down as to when
the High Court should refuse to exercise its jurisdiction in
favour of a party who moves it after considerable delay
and is otherwise guilty of laches. Discretion must be
exercised judiciously and reasonably. In the event that the
clairn made by the applicant is legally sustainable, delay
shorrld be condoned. In other words, where circumstances
justifying the conduct exist, the illegality which is
manifest, cannot be sustained on the sole ground of
laches. When substantial justice and technical
cons;iderations are pitted against each other, the camse of
sub:rtantial justice deserves to be preferred, for the other
side cannot claim to have a vested right in the injustice
being done, because of a non-deliberate delay. The court
shorrld not harm innocent parties if their rights have in
fact emerged by delay on the part of the petitioners.
lYid,: Durga .Prashadv. Chief Controller of Imports and.
Exports [(1969) 1 SCC 185 : AIR 1970 SC 769] , Collector
(LA)v. Katiji [(1987) 2 SCC 107: 1989 SCC (Tax) 172: AIR
198'7 SC 13531 , Dehri Rohtas Light Railway Co.
Ltd.v. District Board, Bhojpurl\gg2) 2 SCC 598 : AIR
199:] SC BO2l , DagalSinghv.Unionof India [(2003) 2 SCC
593 : AIR 2OO3 SC 114O1 and Shonkara Coop. Housing
Societg Ltd.v. M. Prabhakorl(2Oll) 5 SCC 607 : (2011) 3
SCC (Civ) 56 : AIR 2O11 SC 2161j .l
The principle laid down in Tukaram l(ana Joshi ("upra)
has been quoted with approval in Union of India vsN.Murugesan22. Thus, the issue of delay has to be decided on
the basis of facts and circumstances of each case.
27. In the instant case, in reply to paragraphs 12 and 13 of
the affidavit filed in support of the writ petition, the Wakf
Board has taken an objection with regard to delay and laches.
The relevant extract of the aforesaid reply reads as under:
Since the period of one year has been elapsed it is for
the Wakf Tribunal to adjudicate the suit challenging the
notification on merits. The petitioner instead of
approaching to Wakf Tribunal established under Section
83 of the Wakf Act, 1995 directly approached this Honble
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India after
more than 14 years from the date of publication of Gazette
on the ground of alleged violation of principles of natural
justice which is hit by delay and latches, as such it is not
open to the petitioner to invoke the extraordinary special
original jurisdiction of this Honble Court under Article
226 of the Constitution of India after more than 14 years
from the date of publication of Gazette, further the issues
involved in the present case are disputed question of fact
to be decided and proved at the appropriate forum, the
Wakf Tribunal. As such, the petitioner has got alternative
22 (202212 SCC 25
rer.edy under Section 83 of the Wakf Act, 1995, as held by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Board of Wakf, West Bengal
vs. Anis Fatima Begum [(2010) t4 SCC Sgg], as such the
above writ petition is liable to be dismissed.
22. The company had purchased the subject lands in an
auction held on 26.12.2or3 and 13.0g.2014. The sale
certificates were also issued in favour of the company.
Thereupon, it initiated attempts to seek mutation of its name
in the rev,--nue records and learnt about the notification dated
15. 1 1 .2oo7. Thereafter, the writ
petition was fited on
05.11.2074. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the
case, we kLold that the writ petition does not suffer from delay
and lacher; disentitling the petitioner to invoke the jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the constitution of India. Accordingly, the
third issue is answered.
(ia) whet:her the wakf rribunal is the onlg authoritg und.er
section 6(-l) of the wakf Act, r99s to exannine the aalid.itg of
the impugned notifico;tion dated ls.ll.2ool and the sa.me
cantnot be examined in a proceeding und.er Article 226 of the
Constitutic, n of India?
23. Before proceeding further, it is apposite to take note of
Section 6 of the 1995 Act as'it stood.'ftio, to Amendment by
Amendment Act No.27 of 2013 dated"O 1: 1 1.2O 13.
:
':''';'-'
'I
''
6. Disputes regarding Wakfs:- 1t1'1{'any question arises
whether a particular propert5r specified as Wakf property
in the list of Wakfs is wakf propeft5r or not or whether a
Wakq specified in such list is a Shia Wakf or Sunni Wakf,
the Board or the Mutawalli of the Wakf or any person
interested therein may institute a suit in a Tribunal for the
decision of the question and the decision of the Tribunal in
respect of such matter shall be final;
Provided that no such suit shall be entertained by
the Tribunal after the expiry of one year from the date of
the publication of the list of Wakfs:
Explanation:- For the purposes of this section and
section 7, the expression "any person interested therein",
shall, in relation to any property specified as wakf property
in the list of wakfs published after the commencement of
this Act, shatl include also every person who, though not
interested in the wakf concerned, is interested in such
property and to whom a reasonable opportunity had been
afforded to represent his case by notice served on him in
that behalf during the course of the relevant inquiry under
Section 4.
(2) Not withstanding anything contained in subsection (l), no proceeding under this Act in respect of any
wakf shall be stayed by reason only of the pendency of any
such suit or of any appeal or other proceeding arising out
of such suit.
(3) The Survey Commissioner sha-ll not be made a
party to any suit under sub-section (1) and no suit,
prosecution or other legal proceeding shall lie against him
in ::espect of anything which is in good faith done or
intended to be done in pursuance of this Act or any rules
macle thereunder.
(a) The list of Wakfs shall, unless it is modified in
purrsuance of a decision or the Tribunal under sub-section
(1), be final and conclusive.
(5) On and from the commencement of this Act in a
state, no suit or other legal proceeding shall be instituted
or commenced in a court in that State in relation to any
question referred to in sub-section (l).
24. Thusi, it is evident that dispute whether or not property is
a wakf property in the list of wakfs and whether the same
belongs to shia or sunni wakf, the Board or the Mutawalli of
the wakf or any person interested therein may institute a suit
in a Tribunal for adjudication of the aforesaid question.
Section 6 has to be read with section 3(k) of the Act which
defines thr: expression 'person interested in a wakf and reads
as under:
3 (k) "person interested in a wakf,means any person
who is entitled to receive any pecuniary or other benefit
from the wakf and includes-
(i) any person who has a right to workship or to
perform any religious rite in a mosque, idgah, imambara,
dargerh, khanqah, peerkhana and karbala, maqbara,
graveyard or any other religious institution connected with
the vrakf or to participate in any religious or charitable
institution under the walf;
(ii) the wakif and any descendant of the wakf and the
Mutawalli;
25. Thus, if provisions of Section 6 and 3(k) of the Wakf Act,
,,
1995, prior to its Aminament, are read in conjunction, it is
t
.
t-
'
evident that a person interested in the wakf alone could have
resorted to the remedy under Section 6 of the 1995 Act.
However, subsequently by Amendment Act No.27 of 2073
dated 01.11.2073, the words 'any person interested'had been
substituted by 'any person aggrieved'. The Supreme Court in
Rashid Wali Beg (supra) dealt with the issue whether suit
seeking the relief of perpetrral and mandatory injunction in
respect of a property admitted to be the wakf property before
the civii court is maintainable. The aforesaid issue was
answered in the negative and in paragraph 47 and 68, it was
held as under:
47.The upshot of the above discussion is that the basis
of Ramesh GobindramlRamesh Gobindramv- Sugra
Humayun Mirza Wakf, (2O1O) 8 SCC 726 : (2Oi0) 3 SCC
(Civ) 553] now stands removed through Amendment Act
27 of 2013. In fact, when Ramesh GobindramlRamesh
Gobindramv. Sugra Humagun Mirza Wakf, (2010) 8 SCC
726 : (2010) 3 SCC (Civ) 5531 was decided, Sections 6(1)
and 7(1) enabled only three categories of persons to
approach the Waqf Tribunal for relief. They are, (0 the
Board; (ir) the mutawalli of the waqf; or (rrr) any person
intt:rested therein. However, the Explanation under
Section 6(1) clarified that the expression ,,ang person
inte'rested. therein" shall include every person, who, though
not interested in the waqf, is interested in the property.
But by Act 27 of 2013 the words, ,,anA person interested,
were substituted by the words, ,,ang person aggieueil,
meeming thereby that even a non-Muslim is entitled to
invc,ke the jurisdiction of the Tribunal. Due to the
substitution of the words "ang person aggrieued,, Act 2T orf
201.3 has deleted the Explanation under 6(t). This
amendment has also addressed the concern expressed
in Ramesh Gobindram [Ramesh Gobindram v. Sugra
Huntagun Mirua Wakf, (2010) B SCC 726 : (2010) 3 SCC
(Civ) 5531 (in para 27 of the SCC report) whether a non_
Muslim could be put to jeopardy by the bar of jurisdiction,
mer:ly because the property is included in the list of
waqls. We must point out at this stage that the
Explanation under sub-section (1) of Section 6, as it stood
at
the time
when Ramesh Gobind.ram lRamesh
Gobindramv. Sugra Humagun Mirza Wakf, (2010) B SCC
726 : (2010) 3 SCC (Civ) SS3l was decided, already took
care of this contingency, but was omitted to be brought to
the notice of this Court.
68. The dichotomy created in some decisions of this
Cour'-, between the properties which are admitted to. be
waqf properties and properties which are disputed to be
so, is on account of the misapplication of the two limited
questions in Sections 6(1) and 7(1) to the whole of the Act
inclurling section 83. At the cost of repetition we should
point out that section 83(1) provides for the determination
of anl' dispute, question or any other matter, (r) relating to
a waqf and (ir) relating to a waqf property. This
t:. .
j:il
prescrirption cannot be taken to have been curtailed or
circumscribed
Sections 6(1) and 7(1), to come to the
conclusion that the Tribunal will assume
,,':. when a
26. ,The decision in Rashid
only
tobea
(supra) was considered
by the Supreme Court in State of Andhra Pradesh (Now
State of Telangana vs. Andhra Pradesh State Wakf Board23.
The relevant extract of paragraph 105 reads as under:
1O5. In Rashid Wali Beg, this Court examined all the
previous judgments on the question as to whether any
propert5r is a wakf property or not is triable exclusively by
the Wakf Tribunal but the judgments discussed therein
pertained to the invocation of the jurisdiction of the Civil
Court or of the Wakf Tribunal. None of the judgments
dealt with the invocation of the jurisdiction of the writ
court. Board of Wakf, West Bengal vs. Anis Fatma Begum
((2010) 14 SCC 588) is again not a judgment arising out of
a writ petition filed before the High Court. It was a case of
a suit liled before the Civil Court, though in para 7, there
is an observation that all matters pertaining to wakf
should be filed in the first instance before the Tribunal
and should not be entertained by the Civil Court or by the
High Court straightaway under Article . 226 of the
Constitution. The observation made by this Court in
respect of invocation of the jurisdiction of the writ court is
clearly obiter as that was not the question arising for
consideration.
Thus, it is evident that the decision of Supreme Court in
23 2022 SCC Online SC 159
Rashid wali Beg (supra) does not deal with the invocation of
jurisdiction of a writ court.
27. Hou,ever, the alternative remedy has been held by
supreme court not to operate as a bar in at least three
contingencies, namely (4 where the writ petition seeks
enforcemr:nt of any of the fundamental rights; (iz) where there
is failure of principles of natural justice; or (iil where the
orders or proceedings are wholly without jurisdiction or the
vires of arr Act is challenged (see r[hirlpool, corporation vs.
Registrar of rrade Marks, Mumbaiza and Harbanslal sahnia
vs. Indian oil corporation2s). The Supreme court in Radha
Krishan Industries vs. state of Himachal pradesh26, while
dealing wlth exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
constitution, when an alternative remedy is available to a
party, hel<l as under:
2.,7. The principles of law which emerge are that:
t27.1. The power under Article 226 of the Constitution
to issue writs can be exercised not only for the
enforcement of fundamental rights, but for any other
purtr)ose as well.
z+ (7998) 8 SCC 1
2s (2003) 2 sCC 107
zo
6 scc 771
l2o2i)
27.2.The High Court has the discretion not to
where:'l '(a) the' writ petition has been filed for the
enforcement of a fundamental right protected by Part III of
the Constitution; (b) there has been a violation of the
principles of natura-l justice; (c) the order or proceedings
are wtrolly without jurisdiction; or (d) the vires of a
legislation is challenged.
27.4. An alternate remedy by itself does not divest the
High Court of its powers under Article 226 of the
Constitution in an appropriate case though ordinarily, a
writ petition should not be entertained when an efficacious
alternate remedy is provided by law.
27.5. When a right is created by a statute, which itself
prescribes the remedy or procedure for enforcing the right
or liability, resort must be had to that particular statutory
remedy before invoking the discretionary remedy under
Article 226 of the Constitution. This rule of exhaustion of
statutory remedies is a rule of policy, convenience and
discretion.
27.6.In cases where there are disputed questions of
fact, the High Court may decide to decline jurisdiction in a
writ petition. However, if the High Court is objectively of
the view that the nature of the controversy requires the
exercise of its writ jurisdiction, such a view would not
readily be interfered with.
The aforesaid view was reiterated with approval in
Maharashtra State Board of Wakfs (supra).
27. In the case in hand, the impugned notification dated
15.1 1 .2OCt 1 is void as the same has been issued under the
provisions; of the repealed Act. Therefore, the instant case falls
within th,: exceptions carved out by the Supreme Court in
\llhirlpool. Corporation (supra) and Harbanslal Sahnia
(supra) ared the writ petition has rightly been entertained,
notwithstanding the availabilit5r of an alternative remedy.
Therefore, in the facts of the case, it is not necessary to
relegate the petitioner to alternative remedy. Accordingly, the
fourth issue is answered in the affirmative by stating that
notwithstzrnding the alternative remedy, the writ petition can
be entertained.
28. Even otherwise, the scope of an intra-court appeal is well
defined. 'l'his Court in appeal against an order of learned
Single Juclge does not act as Court of regular appeal.
29. For ':he aforementioned reasons, the finding recorded by
learned single Judge that survey conducted under Section 4 of
the 1954 t\ct is not saved under Section rr2 ofthe 1995 Act is
:
:i.l
::
, ,j:,
set aside. However, we agree with the conclusion of the learned
Single Judge. The , notification dated 15.11.2001 assailed in
W.P.No.
B and'W.P.No. L92OS of 2019 insofar aS it
The Inam Tribunal cum Revenue Divisional Officer, Med.ak
shall decide File No.H /5652/98 in accordance with law.
(viii! coNcLUSIoN:
30. In the result, W.A.No.7432 of 2016 is dismissed, whereas
W.P.Nos .23242 of 2OO8 and 1 92OS of 2a19 are allowed.
Pending miscellaneou.s applications, if dfly, shall
stand closed. There shall be no order as to costs.
ALOK ARADHE, C,.'
N.V.SHRAVAN KUMAR, J
04.12.2023
Note: LR copy be marked.
(By order)
Pln
til
:
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review