Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010840922017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3206]
WEDNESDAY, THE EIGHTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE R RAGHUNANDAN RAO
WRIT PETITION Nos.36069, 33944 & 34043 /2017
WRIT PETITION NO: 36069/2017
Between:
1. T.A.P KASTURI RANGAN, S/O. LATE KRISHNAMACHARI, AGED- 58
YEARS, OCC- SENIOR ASSISTANT, R/O. 401, SAI NIKITHA
RESIDENCY, SHANTI NAGAR, KHADI COLONY, TIRUPATHI- 517
...PETITIONER
AND
1. PRL SECY REV DEPT
5 ORS, REVENUE DEPARTMENT,
AMARAVATHI, GUNTUR DISTRICT. A.P
2. THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR CHITTOOR CHITTOOR DISTRICT A P,
3. THE SUB COLLECTORCUMLAO, TIRUPATHI, CHITTOR. CHITTOR
DISTRICT.
4. THE REVENUE
DISTRICT, -
DIVISIONAL
OFFICER
TIRUPATI
CHITTOR
5. UNION OF INDIA REP BY ITS GENERAL MANAGER, SOUTH
CENTRAL RAILWAYS, RAIL NILAYAM, SECUNDERABAD.
6. SENIOR DIVISIONAL ENGINEER, SOUTH CENTRAL RAILWAY,
DIVISION OFFICE, WORKS BRANCH, GUNTAKAL, CHITTOOR
DISTRICT. AP
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased topleased to issue a writ, order or direction preferably a writ in the
nature of Mandamus to declare the action of the respondents in awarding
compensation to the petitioner on reduced market value of his acquired land
admeasuring 129.228 Sq.yards in Sy. No. 207/1 an extent of Ac. 0.56.00, Sy.
No. 207/2 an extent of Ac. 0.01.00 and in Sy. No. 207/3B an extent Ac. 0.34,
situated at Rayala cheruvu Road, Gopalraju colony, Tirupathi in Ward No.19
Block No.7 after issue of Preliminary Notification No.62/2015 dated
20.07.2015 despite Petitioner's objections to the acquisition dated 20.11.2015
and insertion of including all benefits in the enquiry statement by the
respondents without his knowledge is illegal and consequently direct the
respondents to pay 100% solatium on the compensation paid under Section
30 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 with interest from the date of
acquisition of the land
IA NO: 1 OF 2017(WPMP 44815 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the respondents to award the compensation with 100% solatium on the
market price of Rupees 30,000/- as per provisions of The Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013 which was prevailing on the date of issuance of
Preliminary Notification No.62/2015 Form-VI (A) dated. 20-07-2015 with
interest from the date of acquisition of the land, pending disposal of the above
writ petition
IA NO: 4 OF 2017(WPMP 207522 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to grant leave to the petitioner herein / Respondent No.4 in WP
No.36069/2017 to file counter affidavit
IA NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
Pleased to grant leave to the petitioner herein to file and to receive reply to
counter affidavit and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. T L KRISHNA PRASAD
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR REVENUE (AP)
2. GP FOR LAND ACQUISITION
3. DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA
4. .
Date of Reserved
: 27.02.2026
Date of Pronouncement
: 08.04.2026
Date of Upload
: 08.04.2026
The Court made the following Common Order:
As the three Writ Petitions arise out of the same requisition
proceedings and raise the same issue, they are being disposed of by way of
this common order.
2.
Heard Sri T.L. Prasad, learned counsel for the petitioner and the
learned Assistant Government Pleader for Land Acquisition for the
respondents.
3.
The Indian Railways had sought, as part of the expansion and
modernization of the Tirupati Railway Station, to acquire certain extents of
land situated in Sy.No.190/1A1B2; Sy.No.190/1A1C as well as Sy.Nos.207/1,
207/2, 207/3B of Tirupati.
4.
Upon a requisition being made, to that effect, by the Indian
Railways, the
3rd
respondent, initiated acquisition proceedings. The
preliminary notification, under Section 11(1) of the Act 30 of 2013 was
published in the Gazette on 20.07.2015. Under this notification, Ac.0-48 cents
in Sy.No.190/1A1C and Ac.0-267 cents in Sy.No.190/1A1B2 belonging to the
writ petitioner in W.P.No.34043 of 2017; Ac.0-56 cents in Sy.No.207/1; Ac.001 cent in Sy.No.270/2 and Ac.0-34 cents in Sy.No.207/3B belonging to the
writ petitioner in W.P.No.36069 of 2017 were included in this notification. In
the course of the said acquisition, the respondent authorities, on the ground
that the petitioners in W.P.No.34043 of 2017 and 36069 of 2017, had given
consent for passing consent Award, were awarded compensation, in relation
to these lands at the rate of Rs.30,000/- per square yard.
5.
The petitioners in these writ petitions being aggrieved by the said
compensation have approached this Court, by way of these writ petitions. The
contention of the writ petitioners, in all these cases, is that the market value of
the land, in the above survey numbers, according to the Basic Value Register
is Rs.30,000/- per square yard and consequently, compensation that should
have been paid to the petitioners should have been calculated on the basis of
the above market value. However, the total compensation payable to the
petitioners was fixed at the rate of Rs.30,000/- per Sq. yard, which is clearly
impermissible.
6.
It appears that during pendency of W.P.No.34043 of 2017, the
writ petitioner therein had passed away and his wife and daughter have been
brought on record as his legal representatives. Apart from this, the wife and
the daughter of the deceased writ petitioner in W.P.No.34043 of 2017 have
filed a separate writ petition in W.P.No.33944 of 2017.
7.
The respondents have filed their counter-affidavits. In the
counter-affidavit, the stand taken by the respondents is that the value of the
land, which was sought to be acquired from the petitioners, as per the Basic
Value Register was only Rs.10,000/- per square yard and the comparable sale
deeds also did not show any great variation from this figure, consequently,
compensation paid out to the petitioners was a fair and reasonable
compensation. Apart from this, the petitioners in W.P.Nos.34043 & 36069 of
2017 are said to have consented for passing of such awards by way of signing
the necessary consent forms.
8.
The petitioners in the above two Writ Petitions disputed this
contention. The contention of the petitioners is that the signatures on the
consent forms are their signatures. However, these signatures were obtained,
under a false pretence, by assuring the petitioners that compensation would
be paid to them by taking the market value of the land, i.e., Rs. 30,000/- per
sq. yard. However, the respondent authorities after giving such assurance had
gone back on that assurance and had fixed compensation itself as
Rs.30,000/- per Sq. yard and the same is a clear case of fraud perpetrated on
the petitioners therein.
9.
The petitioners in W.P.No.33944 of 2017 on the other hand would
contend that, they had a share in the land shown in the name of Sri T. Krishna
Reddy, and the consent given by Sri T. Krishna Reddy, even it was treated as
proper consent, would not in any manner bind the petitioners in W.P.No.33944
of 2017.
10.
The petitioners to demonstrate that the value of the land, in
question was Rs.30,000/- per Sq. yard at the relevant point of time had relied
upon the minutes of the Market Value Revision Committee and the revised
values fixed under the Market Value guidelines with effect from 01.08.2015. In
the table set out in the said guidelines, Ward No.19, Block No.7 which had the
original market value of Rs.30,000/- per Sq. Yard of “commercial land” was
reduced to Rs.15,000/- with effect from 01.08.2015 and the value of
“residential land” was maintained at Rs.10,000/- per square yard. The
petitioners contend that the reduction of market value for this block is not only
unreasonable but unrealistic and done primarily to ensure that the petitioners
do not get proper value for their land. The petitioners point out that the market
value of all the other wards and blocks were increased and it is only Ward
No.19, Block No.7 where the market value is reduced. The petitioners would
also contend that the reduction also would not have any effect on the
compensation payable to them as the preliminary notification was issued on
20.07.2015 when the market value for this area was Rs.30,000/- per Sq. yard
and the valuation was only changed from 01.08.2015. It is contended that it is
the market value available on the date on which preliminary notification is
issued that would be relevant for the calculation of compensation.
11.
The respondents while reiterating the aforesaid contention of
consent being given by the petitioners, also contend that the land of the
petitioners does not fall under Ward No.19, Block No.7. To counter this
contention, the petitioners have applied to the Deputy City Planner, Tirupati
Municipality, for correlation of the Ward and Block numbers with the revenue
and town survey numbers. The Deputy City Planner has furnished necessary
information, by proceedings, dated 06.01.2026. In these proceedings, the
Deputy City Planner states that there is no Town Survey number available in
relation to Ward No.19, Block no.7. However, the revenue survey number
corresponding to this Ward and Block are Sy.Nos.190, 195 to 198, 200, 201,
208 and 209.
12.
The petitioners in W.P.No.34043 of 2017 contend that the land of
the petitioners, even according to the preliminary notification falls in Sy.No.190
which falls within the Ward No.19, Block No.7 and the market rate would have
to be taken at the rate of Rs.30,000/- per Sq. yard. As far as the petitioner in
W.P.No.36069 of 2017 is concerned, it is contended that the market value in
relation to all the other areas in different wards and blocks is comparable and
the same rate would have to be paid to the petitioners in W.P.No.36069 of
2017.
13.
The learned counsel for the petitioner would also contend that the
market value of the very same land which had been reduced to Rs.15,000/per Sq. yard with effect from 01.08.2015 was increased to Rs.33,000/- per Sq.
yard on 28.02.2017 which shows that the reduction of Rs.15,000/- was an
artificial reduction.
CONSIDERATION OF THE COURT:14.
The land acquisition proceedings, for acquisition of the lands in
question commenced on 20.07.2015 with a notification under Section 11(1) of
the Act 30 of 2013. The compensation, payable under such acquisition, would
be calculated either on the basis of the value of these lands, on 20.07.2015,
under the basic value register maintained by the registration authority or by
looking at the comparable sales, in the area, whichever is higher.
15.
In the present case, the petitioners in W.P.Nos.33944 & 36069 of
2017, had given their consent for acquisition of the land and payment of
compensation. The petitioners in W.P.No.33944 of 2017, who are the wife and
daughter of the petitioner, in W.P.No.34043 of 2017, contend that their
consent was not taken. The record does not show that such consent was
obtained from these two petitioners. However, their names along with their
bank account details, were included in the consent forms, signed by the
petitioner in W.P.No.34043 of 2017. Further, they had also received
compensation, apportioned between the petitioner in W.P.No.34043 of 2017
and themselves.
16.
The basic contention of the petitioners is that the market value of
the land, in question in the Basic Value Register was Rs.30,000/- per Sq. yard
and the question of the petitioners agreeing for a compensation of Rs.30,000/per Sq. yard is incomprehensible as the minimum compensation that would
have to be awarded to the petitioners would be in excess of Rs.60,000/- per
Sq. yard.
17.
The petitioners, with view to demonstrate this contention, had
placed before this Court the minutes of the meeting of the market value
revision committee, in which the values fixed under the market value
guidelines, had been revised, with effect from 01.08.2015. The petitioners
would draw the attention of this Court to the market value fixed for Ward
No.19, Block No.7. The said minutes shows that the market value revision
committee while either, maintaining the same rates or increasing the rates for
all other locations, had reduced the market value, in relation to this area, from
Rs.30,000/- per Sq. yard to Rs.15,000/- per Sq. yard for commercial land
while, retaining the market value of residential land at Rs.10,000/- per Sq.
yard. This rate was to come into effect from 01.08.2015.
18.
The petitioners contend that the authorities being aware of the
huge amount of compensation they would have to pay out, had deliberately
reduced the value of the land, in the basic value register, only for this area
with effect from 01.08.2015. The petitioners would also point out that the value
of this area was increased to Rs.33,000/- per Sq. yard, as on 28.02.2017
which fortifies their case that the value was deliberately reduced in order to
deprive the petitioners of their just compensation.
19.
The Counter affidavit filed by the respondents, is silent and does
not deny the allegations of the petitioners. The respondents, while not
answering these contentions took the stand that the value of the land in
question was Rs.10,000/- per Sq. yard as per the Basic Value Register. It is
further contended that the land in question does not fall under the Ward
No.19, Block No.7. Though, the respondents had made this specific
contention, they have not stated as to where the land in question would be
located in terms of Wards and Blocks. This issue has become relevant as the
acquisition proceedings refer to revenue survey numbers, while the Basic
Value Register refers to Wards and Blocks.
20.
The acquisition notifications were issued in terms of the revenue
survey numbers, mentioned above. As the correlation between the revenue
survey numbers and Ward & Blocks numbers was not available, the petitioner
had filed an application on the Right to Information Act, for such information.
The Deputy City Planner, Tirupati by proceedings, dated 06.01.2026, had
replied to the Right to Information query. In this reply, it was stated that the
land in ward No.19, block No.7 would correspond to the land in Sy.Nos.190,
195 to 198, 200, 201, 208 & 209. The land in question, in W.P. No. 36069 of
2017, falls in Sy.Nos.207/1, 270/2 & 207/3B. The respondents have not
produced any documents or correlation to show where the land is located, in
terms of the Ward and Block numbers are concerned.
21.
As noted above, the value of the land in Ward No.19, Block No.7,
which corresponds to Sy.No.190, as on 20.07.2015, was fixed at Rs.30,000/per Sq. yard, The respondents while contending that the value of the land in
the Basic Value Register, was Rs.10,000/- per square yard, have not
submitted any document, including the relevant extracts of the basic value
register of the area. There are no details available as to the ward and block
corresponding to Sy.Nos.207/1, 270/2 & 207/3B. The respondents have not
chosen to place any material before this Court as to the basis for taking the
value of the land to be Rs.10,000/- per square yard, in the Basic Value
Register. In the counter affidavit filed by the 4th respondent, a table setting out
the value of land, according to the 4th respondent, as per the Basic Value
register has been set out. In this table, it is stated that the value of land
categorized as “Railway quarters” and “Ellappareddy Quarters” is Rs.10,000/per square yard, if it is residential and Rs.15,000/- per square yard, if it is
Commercial. It is not stated anywhere, if the land in question is residential or
commercial. From the valuation adopted, the respondents have treated the
land to be residential. However, this is in direct contrast to the communication
between Sub-Registrar Tirupati, and the Senior Section Engineer (works)
South Central Railway. The Senior Section Engineer, by letter, dated
08.06.2013, had requested the Sub-Registrar to set out the value of the land,
proposed to be acquired. In reply, the Sub-Registrar, by his letter dated
11.06.2013, had stated as follows:
“REGISTRATION AND STAMPS DEPARTMENT
From,
K. Mohan Babu,
Sub Registrar,
Tirupati.
To
The Senior Section Engineer(Works)
South Central Railways,
Tirupati.
Letter No Nil Date 11-6-2013
Sir.
Sub: Land value particulars foracquisition of 1.83 acares of land at
Southern side of Rallway Station-furnished-Regarding.
Ref: letter No. Nil dated 8-6-2013 of Sr.Section engineer (Works),
Tiruputi.
I invite your kind attention to the reference cited I am herewith furnishing the basic value as
th
per M.V. Revision 1-4-2013 for the given locality Gopal Raju colony 19 ward nearby door No
19/7/110/Al as mentioned below.
Sl.No.
Survey No.
Extent of
land
190/1A1B2
0.0267
cents
2.
190/1A1C
0.48
Value of land at
19 ward near
bydoor
No.19/7/110/A1
per sq yards Rs.
30,000/-
Total value
3.
203/1B
0.11
4.
203/1C
0.09
5.
203/2
0.21
6.
207/1
0.56
7.
207/2
0.01
8.
207/3B
0.34
Total
1.8267
Or
Sqyds.8841.22
Rs.265236600/-
(Rupees Twenty Six crores Fifty two laksh thirty six thousand and six hundred only). Further I
submit that this is not for Registration purpose.
Yours faithfully
Sd/Joint Sub Registrar I
Tirupati.”
22.
The silence of the respondents, in responding to the specific
allegations of the petitioners, regarding the change in the land values, in the
Basic Value Register, read with the aforesaid correspondence, requires this
Court to accept the contentions of the petitioners, that the market value of the
lands in question was fixed at Rs.30,000/- in the Basic Value Register.
23.
In this backdrop, this Court would have to consider the
contentions of the petitioners that they had signed the consent forms with the
understanding that they were consenting to payment of compensation by
taking the market value at Rs.30,000/- per square yard and the consent was
not for accepting a lump sum compensation of Rs.30,000/- per square yard.
24.
Another aspect which would have a bearing on this issue has to
be noticed. The same land was sought to be acquired under a preliminary
notification,
No.73
of
2013,
dated
04.11.2013.
The
petitioner,
in
W.P.No.34043 of 2017, had filed W.P.No.35639 of 2013 challenging the said
preliminary notification. Thereafter, the present notification was issued on
20.07.2015. It is the averment of the Petitioner, that upon publication of this
notification, the petitioner in W.P.No.34043 of 2017 had filed objections, on
14.09.2015, raising the issue of reduction of value under the Basic Value
Register and that such reduction had been made only to defeat the legitimate
right of the petitioners to receive fair compensation. This contention has not
been denied by the respondents. In such circumstances, it would be highly
doubtful that a person who has been constantly litigating, to protect his
property, would accept a reduced rate, especially after he had raised the very
same issue before the authorities, by way of his objections.
25.
In such circumstances, this Court believes that the consent given
by the petitioners in W.P.No.34043 of 2017 as well as the consent given by
the petitioner in W.P.No.36069 of 2017 cannot be treated as informed
consents accepting the total compensation of Rs.30,000/- per square yard.
Another aspect to the matter is the fact that the allegation of the petitioners
that he had not received a copy of the award has not been disputed by the 4 th
respondent, in the counter affidavit filed by the 4th respondent. In the absence
of such an award, it would also not be possible for the petitioners to seek
enhancement of compensation.
26.
For all the aforesaid reasons, these Writ Petitions are allowed
setting aside the award passed by the 4th respondent on 01.12.2015, to the
extent of the lands of the petitioners herein, with a further direction to the
Respondents to complete the process of passing a fresh award, in relation to
the land of the petitioners, in accordance with law, and without reference to
the consent forms said to have been signed by the petitioners.There shall be
no order as to costs.
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand
closed.
________________________
R. RAGHUNANDAN RAO, J
Date:-08.04.2026
BSM
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE R RAGHUNANDAN RAO
WRIT PETITION Nos.36069, 33944 & 34043 /2017
Date:- 08.04.2026
BSM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review