Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial Nos.01 & 02
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No.27/2023 with
WA No.28/2023
Date of order: 29.08.2023
Mithu B. Marak & ors
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & ors
Sympahunlang Syiemlieh & ors Vs.
State of Meghalaya & ors
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellants
: Mr. V.K. Jindal, Sr.Adv with
Mr. S Rana, Adv
For the Respondents : Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
These two appeals are directed against a common judgment and
order of August 14, 2023 passed on two sets of petitions under Article
226 of the Constitution.
2.
The grievance carried by both sets of petitioners – the appellants
herein – was two-fold. They claimed that by virtue of their long service,
albeit as temporary peons in the Meghalaya (Civil) Secretariat, Shillong,
they were entitled to be regularised under the Service Rules, 1986 rather
than be considered under the Regular Casual Workers Scheme, 1996.
The second limb of complaint was that the appellants herein had been
exploited by the State in the sense that the appellants were required to
do all duties as regular peons but were discriminated against and were
not afforded either equal pay or equal benefits though doing the same
work.
3.
Pursuant to an advertisement issued on January 20, 2012,
seeking applications for temporary engagement as peons in the
Meghalaya (Civil) Secretariat on payment of daily wages at rates fixed
by the State government under the Minimum Wages Act from time to
time for unskilled labour, the appellants applied. It is the case of the
appellants that a proper examination was held following which the
successful candidates were called for interviews. The appellants seek to
establish that a thorough recruitment exercise, as in the usual course
under the service rules, was conducted before the selection process to
the temporary post was completed and no appointment was given
without obtaining a police verification report.
4.
However, what cannot be missed is that the advertisement was
for temporary engagement as peons, the letter of appointment also
provided that the appellants were temporarily engaged as peons and a
lump-sum monthly amount was indicated as the pay.
5.
The initial appointment was for a period of a year, but the
appellants claim that the State continued to obtain the services of the
appellants without issuing any subsequent letter or indicating the tenure
or terms of the appellants’ further engagement. It is, however, the
undeniable position that from a monthly payment of Rs.4000/- in the
year 2012, the appellants received a payment of about Rs.15,000/- per
month in the year 2022 when the appellants approached this Court.
6.
The two immediate reasons for approaching this Court were the
issuance of a circular or letter of January 5, 2021 to the effect that the
appellants’ cases would be considered under the Regular Casual
Workers Scheme, 1996, despite the appellants insisting that the
appellants had made several representations for regularisation of their
services and some kind of assurance may have been given by the
appellants’ seniors that their cases would be considered favourably in
such regard. The other matter that triggered off the appellants’ ire was
the issuance of an advertisement on February 9, 2022 calling for
applications for filling up different categories of Grade-IV posts in the
Department.
7.
According to the appellants, since the recruitment process in the
appellants’ case was done as in any regular recruitment exercise by
conducting a written examination and thereafter an interview and finally
causing a police verification to be made before offering appointment to
a person, there could be no doubt as to the integrity of the process.
Thus, according to the appellants, their recruitment has to be seen to
have been above board and in accordance with any regular recruitment
exercise. Next, the appellants say that they were required to do the same
work as the regular appointees or as would be expected of the regular
appointees who may be engaged pursuant to the advertisement of
February 9, 2022. In such regard, the appellants have produced some
details of the nature of duties that the appellants had to discharge and
the duties and work requirements of regular appointees in the same post.
8.
The Single Bench held that since the appellants accepted their
appointments with their eyes wide open in temporary posts and the
advertisement of January 20, 2012 clearly indicated the nature of the
engagement to be temporary, merely because such temporary
engagement continued for a period of nine or ten years, would give no
right to the appellants to assert a claim for regularisation. The writ court
noticed that a consolidated lump-sum monthly amount was regularly
paid to the appellants herein instead of the graded manner of payment of
regular employees. Though certain other benefits, such as some leave,
were extended to the appellants, the appellants did not have any further
rights as regular appointees.
9.
Under the Scheme of 1996, casual workers who have worked for
a certain period of time or who possesses the qualifications necessary
for regular appointment to the similar posts are considered, subject to
the age relaxation which is provided in the scheme itself. Of course, the
scheme recognises instructions and orders to be issued by the State
government to provide for further relaxation to absorb persons who
have worked in casual posts into the regular posts.
10.
The writ court found that for a claim of equal pay for equal work
to be established, the equivalence had to be demonstrated on all counts.
The writ court referred to the principle enunciated by the Supreme
Court in such regard and found that the material presented fell woefully
short of what was required in such regard.
11.
The essential feature of the matter, as the writ court noticed by
referring to a Supreme Court judgment, was that the appellants herein
were aware that they were being temporarily engaged and that their
services could be terminated at short notice. The only basis for the
appellants’ assertion that the appellants should be considered for regular
appointment appears to be the length of time that the appellants spent in
the temporary engagement. Rather than looking at such aspect of the
matter from the point of view of how long the appellants served, the
appellants should view it as to how lucky the appellants were that their
temporary engagement lasted for a period of 10 years or more.
12.
At the end of the day, considering the strict rules that are now in
place for regularisation of casual employees, there is no right that the
appellants have been able to demonstrate for the appellants to be given a
chance under the service rules to obtain regularisation. It will be open to
the appellants to accept the benefits that may be conferred to all or some
of them in terms of the Scheme of 1996.
13.
There is a further aspect to the matter. Upon the casual peons’
representations for regularisation of their services, the Personnel and
Administrative Reforms Department of the State issued an order on
January 5, 2021 to the effect that casual employees who were appointed
on daily wages may be regularised under the RCW Scheme after
completion of 10 years’ service. There does not appear to have been any
immediate protest to such order though representations continued to be
made for regularisation by the casual employees and also seeking higher
pay.
14.
The RCW Scheme defines a regular casual worker to be a casual
worker who has been working as such for a continuous period of not
less than 10 years. The conferment of RCW status on a casual worker
would entitle such casual worker to obtain earned leave on prorata
basis, casual leave, festival advance and children education advance. In
addition when vacancies in Group-D posts arise in the relevant
Department, 50 per cent of such posts, subject to the rules, orders and
instructions as may be issued by the State government, would be filled
up from amongst the RCWs working in that Department. In such a
scenario, the maximum age limit is relaxed by the total number of years
served continuously as a casual worker. Further, if an RCW is selected
to a regular Group-D post, half of the length of service rendered as an
RCW would be added to the length of service rendered in the Group-D
post for the purpose of retirement benefits.
15.
Thus, it is evident that casual workers who have been engaged
for a continuous period of 10 years are conferred certain benefits which
may even extend to regular appointment if they are otherwise found
suitable. The RCW Scheme appears to be benevolent and even if every
casual worker who attains the status of RCW does not get selected to
the regular post, such casual worker obtains certain other benefits that
ordinarily casual workers cannot expect to enjoy.
16.
The RCW Scheme was in place at the time that the appellants
were recruited in 2012 and the appellants are deemed to have been
aware of such scheme, if not at the time of their recruitment, at least
after having been temporarily engaged for some period of time. Once it
is found that casual workers with long period of engagement are
conferred certain benefits, such casual workers would be confined to the
benefits under the scheme and not permitted to jump to any regular post.
17.
In a sense, since the writ petition was not filed immediately
upon issuance of the letter of January 5, 2021 but it was filed only after
the advertisement of February 9, 2022 was published, it would appear
that the pretended dissatisfaction with the decision contained in the
letter of January 5, 2021 was an afterthought and the only object of the
appellants’ exercise was to scuttle the recruitment process of 2022 and
jump into the regular posts by only citing the length of service rendered
in the casual post.
18.
Since there was no specific right that could be demonstrated
before the writ court, such Court was perfectly justified in rejecting the
petitions by taking relevant considerations into account as evident from
the judgment and order impugned. The order impugned calls for no
interference.
19.
Accordingly, WA No.27 of 2023 and WA No.28 of 2023 are
dismissed. There will, however, be no order as to costs.
20.
Despite there being no room for sympathy in this jurisdiction,
considering the fact that the appellants have been used to a certain way
of life for over 10 years, the State will do well to consider the
appellants’ case sympathetically under the relevant Scheme of 1996.
(B. Bhattacharjee)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
29.08.2023
“Lam DR-PS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review