Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3383 ]
IN THE HIGH,COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE FIFTEENTH DAY OF SEPTEMBER
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENIY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY
WRIT PETITION NO: 35945 OF 2025
Between:
1. Syeda Ghousiya Sultana, D/o. Syed Siddique Ahmed, Wo. late Mohammed
Aslam, Aged about 49 years, Occ. Housewife, H No 17-1-1371218, Rain
Bazar, Yakutpura, Charminar, Hyderabad - 500 023.
2. Tashfeen Fatima, D/o. late Mohammed Aslam, Aged about 21 years, Occ.
Student,
3. Nikhath Fatima Tazeen, D/o. late [Vohammed Aslam, Aged about 20 years,
Occ. Student,
4. Mohammed Ghouseuddin, S/o. late Mohammed Aslam, Aged about 18 years,
Occ. Student,
5. Tabasum Fatima, D/o. late Mohammed Aslam, Aged about 17 years, Occ.
Student,
Rep. by her natural guardian and mother, Syeda Ghousiya Sultana
Fl/o. H No 17-1-1371218, Rain Bazar, Yakutpura, Charminar, Hyderabad - 500
o23.
6. Kouser Ruqia Khanam, W/o. late Mohammed Zaheeruddin, Aged about 56
years, Occ. Housewife, Rt/o. H.No.17-1 -175165, Nehru Nagar, Rain Bazar,
Charminar, Hyderabad 500023.
7. Md. Zameeruddin, S/o. late Md. Zaheeruddin, Aged about 35 years, Occ.
Business, R/o. H.No.10-3-671E11, 2nd Floor, Humayun Nagar, Asif Nagar,
Hyderabad - 500023.
8. Mohammed Basheer Ahmed, S/o. late Mohammed Khaja, Aged about 59
years, Occ. Business, Fl/o. H.No.20-25lC, Mohammadia Colony, Khanapur,
Adilabad, Telangana State.
9. Nazeer Ahmed, S/o. late Mohammed Khaja, Aged about 53 years, Occ.
Business, Fi,/o. H.No.20-25lC, Mohammadia Colony, Khanapur, Adilabad,
Telangana State.
l0.Mohammed Zaheer Ahmed, S/o. late Mohammed Khaja, Aged about 51
years, Occ. Business, Rl/o. H.No.20-25/C, Mohammadia Colony, Khanapur,
Adilabad, Telangana State.
11. Rodda Rajeshwari, W/o. late R. Yada Goud, Aged about 57 years, Occ.
Housewife,
'12. Rodda Madhu Goud, S/o. late R. Yada Goud, Aged about
35 years, Occ.
Business,
13. Rodda Nagesh Goud, S/o. late R. Rama Goud, Aged about 62 years, Occ.
Business,
'14.
R. Kapil Gcud, Sio Rodda Nagesh Goud, Aged about 39 years, Occ.
B usiness,
15.R. Pradeep Goud, S/o. Rodda Nagesh Goud, Aged about 35 years, Occ.
Business,
16.R. Pawan C,oud, S/o. Rodda Nagesh Goud, Aged about 37 years, Occ.
Business,
17. R. Manjula tloud, W/o. late R. Sidda Goud, Aged about 5'l years, Occ.
Housewife,
'18. Rodda Sairam Goud, S/o. late Sidda Goud, Aged
about 28 years, Occ.
Business,
19. R. Satyanarayana Goud, S/o. late Rama Goud, Aged about 52 years, Occ.
Business,
20.Jangamma Akhila. D/o. R. Satyanarayana Goud, Aged about 27 years, Occ.
Housewife, P1'1 to
P20 all are
FJo.H.No.14-52, Ward No.14,
Thatha papan pa lly, Toopran Village and Mandal, lVledak District - b02334.
21 . Qazi Mohamrned Abdul Raheem Rizwan, S/o. late Qazi Fateh Mohammed,
Aged about 40 years, Occ. Business, Rl/o.H.No.1 1-43-2, f oopran Village and
lMandal. Medak District.
22. Mohammed hbdul Qayyum, S/o. late Qazi Fateh Mohammed, Aged about 44
years, Occ. Business,
23, Mohammed hbdul lt4annan, S/o. late Qazi Fateh [\,4ohammed, Aged about 42
years, Occ. B;siness,
24. [\4ohammed Nlomaan, S/o. late Qazi Fateh l\,4ohammed, Aged about 36 years,
Occ. Business,
25.Amtul Aleem Atiya, D/o. late Qazi Fateh Mohammed. Aged about 45 years,
Occ. Housewife,
P22 lo P25 all are RJo H.No 1 1-4-3-2, Toopran Village and Mandal, IVledak
District
26. Mahammad Afzal Bee, W/o.
late Mahammad Mahinoddin, Aged about 74
years, Occ. llousewife, Rl/o H.No.1-85, Maqdumpur, Shivampet Mandal,
Medak Districl 502334.
27. lvlahammad Ciousoddin, S/o.
late Mahammad Mahinoddin, Aged about 62
years, Occ. 13usiness, Rt/o. H.No.1-85, Maqdumpur, Shivampet Mandal,
Medak District - 502334.
28. Nooruddin, S/o. late Mahammad Mahinoddin, Aged about 47 years, Occ
Business, Rt/o.H.No.7-8-166/5, Goutham Nagar, Ferozguda, Balanagar,
Hyderabad - 50001 1.
2g.Mahammad Nazeeruddin, S/o. late Mahammad Mahinoddin, Aged about 38
years, Occ. Business, R/o. H.No.'1-85, Maqdumpur, Shivampet [V1andal,
Medak District - 502334.
30. Mohammad Sharfuddin, S/o. late Mohammed Yousufuddin, Aged about 41
years, Occ. Business, Rl/o.H.No.13-3-866/8, Jiyaguda, Karwan, Asif Nagar'
Hyderabad 500006.
31. Mohammad Shaboddin, S/o. late Mohammed Yousufuddin' Aged about 39
years, Occ. Business, FVo.H.No.13-3-866/8, Jiyaguda, Kanruan, Asif Nagar'
Hyderabad - 500006.
32.lr,4ohd. Aslamuddin, S/o. late Yousufuddin, Aged about 38 years, Occ.
Business, R/o.H.No.'l 3-3-866/8, Jiyaguda, Karwan, Asif Nagar, Hyderabad
500006.
33. Mohammed Akramuddin, S/o. late Yousufuddin, Aged about 36 years, Occ.
Business, R/o.H.No.13-3-866/8, Jiyaguda, Karwan, Asif Nagar, Hyderabad
500006.
34.Mohammed Salman Ahmed, S/o. late Qazi Gulam Ahmed, Aged about 40
years, Occ. Business, R/o.H.No.12-2-422194, 1sl Floor, Priya Colony,
Guddimalkapur, Mehdipatnam, Telangana State.
35.I\/ohammed lftekaruddin, S/o. late Qazi Maqdoom Bahauddin, Aged about 40
years, Occ. Business, No. 17-1-21016/6/1 , Santosh Nagar, Beside Bharat
Petrol Pump, Saidabad, Hyderabad.
36. Mohammed Ghulam Mustafa, S/o. late Qazi Maqdoom Bahauddin, Aged
about 40 years, Occ. Business, No. 17-1-21016/6/1 , Santosh Nagar, Beside
Bharat Petrol Pump, Saidabad, Hyderabad.
37. Khaja Moinuddin, S/o. Mohammed Sultan, Aged about 62 years, Occ.
Business, PJo. H.No.1 1 -3-357 I 161812, Shabazguda, Srinivas Nagar Colony,
Secunderabad, Hyderabad.
38. Khaja Qutubuddin, S/o. Mohammed Sultan, Aged about 60 years, Occ.
Business, R/o. H.No.7-7'1160, tVaheshwari Nagar, St. No.B, Habsiguda,
Hyderabad.
39. Mohammed Badroddin, S/o. Mohammed Sultan, Aged about 49 years, Occ
Business, Rl/o. H.No. 1 1 -3 -357 l2l 4, Shabazguda, Parsigutta, Secunderabad
Rep. by their General Power of Attorney holder, Pedapudi Venkaja Shrinagu,
S/o. P. Venkata Mohan Rao, Aged about 40 years, Occ. Business, Rl/o. Flat
No.101 , Plot No.24, Laxmi Ganapathi Apartment, Road No.2, RTC Colony'
Medchal, Ranga Reddy District - 501404.
...PETITIONERS
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Revenue
Department, Telangana Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. Telangana Sltate Waqf Board, Rep. by its Chief Executive Officer, Razak
Manzil, Opp. Public Gardens, Nampally, Hyderabad
3. The District Oollector, Medak District.
4. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Toopran Revenue Division, Medak District.
5. The Tahsildar, Toopran Mandal, IVedak District
...RESPONDENTS
Petition unde' Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased
to issue a writ, ord 3r or direction more particularly one in the nature of wRlr oF
MANDAI\ilus to der;lare the action of the 2nd respondent in including the lands of
petitioners 1to 5 in Sy.Nos.893, 894 and 897 admeasuring Ac.O.20 gts and in
Sy.Nos.432, 433 ard 434 admeasuring Ac.0.05 gts, lands of petitioners 6 and 7 in
Sy.Nos.893, 894 and Bg7 admeasunng Ac 0.20 gts and in Sy.Nos.432, 433 and 434
admeasurrng Ac.0.C3 gts, lands of petitioners 8, 9 and .10 in Sy.Nos.Bg3, g94, g95
and 897 admeasurirrg Ac.o.1325 gts and in sy.Nos.432, 433 and 434 admeasuring
Ac.0.03 gts, lands of petitioners 11 to 20 in Sy.No.103i/EE admeasuring Ac.1.0950
gts and land in Sy.lrlo.1031/AA admeasuring Ac.0.2475 gts, land of petitioners 21 to
25 in Sy,Nos.B93, €i94,895 and 897 admeasuring Ac.1.02 gts and in Sy.Nos.432,
433 and 434 adrneasuring Ac.0.06 gts, land of petitioners 26 to 29 in
Sy.Nos.893/AA3, 8rl4/AA3 and 897/AA3 admeasuring Ac.O.1325 gts, tands of
petitroners 30 to 33 in Sy.Nos.893, 894. 895 and 897 admeasuring Ac.O.1325 gts
and in Sy.Nos.432, ,133 and 434 admeasurrng Ac.0.O3 gts, tands of petitioner No.34
in Sy Nos.893, 894, 895, 896 and 897 admeasuring Ac.1 .22 gts and in Sy.Nos.432,
433 and 434 admea;uring Ac.0.03 gts, lands of petitroners 35 and 36 in Sy.Nos.g93,
894, 895 and Bg7 admeasuring Aci.02 gts and in Sy.Nos.432, 433 and 434
admeasuring Ac.0.0ll gts, lands of petitioners 37, 38 and 39 in Sy.Nos.B93, 894, g95
and 897 admeasurirrg Ac.0.1325 gts and in sy.Nos.432, 433 and 434 admeasuring
Ac.0.03 gts situatecl at roopran Village and tVlandal, I\,4edak District in Gazette
Notification No.46-A daled 20.12.200 1 treating the lands of the petitioners belongs
to waqf properties, as illegal, improper, null, void and unjust and consequently to
delete the lands of the petitroners from the prohibitory list furnished by the 2nd
respondent
l.A. NO: 1OF 202
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
respondents to delete the lands of petitioners 1 to 5 in Sy.Nos.893,894 and 897
admeasuring Ac.0.20 gts and in Sy.Nos.432,433 and 434 admeasuring Ac.O.05 gts,
lands of petitioners 6 and 7 in Sy.Nos.893, 894 and 897 admeasuring Ac.0.20 gts
and in Sy.Nos.432, 433 and 434 admeasuring Ac.0.03 gts, lands of petitioners 8, 9
and 1 0 in Sy.Nos.893, 894, 895 and 897 admeasuring Ac.o.1 325 gts and in
Sy.Nos.432, 433 and 434 admeasuring Ac.0.03 gts, lands of petitioners 11 to 20 in
Sy.No.1031/EE admeasuring Ac.1.0950 gts and land in Sy.No.1031/AA
admeasuring 4c.0.2475 gts, land of petitioners 21 to 25 in Sy.Nos.893, 894, 895 and
897 admeasuring Ac.'1 .02 gts and in Sy.Nos.432, 433 and 434 admeasuring Ac.0.06
gts, land of petitioners 26 to 29 in Sy.Nos.893/AA3, 894/AA3 and 897/AA3
admeasuring Ac.0.1325 gts, lands of petitioners 30 to 33 in Sy.Nos.893, 894, 895
and 897 admeasuring Ac.O.1325 gts and in Sy.Nos.432,433 and 434 admeasuring
Ac.0.03 gts, lands of Petitioner No.34 in Sy.Nos.B93, 894, 895, 896 and 897
admeasuring Ac.1 .22 gts and in Sy.Nos.432, 433 and 434 admeasuring Ac.0.03 gts,
lands of petitioners 35 and 36 in Sy.Nos.893, 894, 895 and 897 admeasuring
Ac.1 .02 gts and in Sy.Nos.432, 433 and 434 admeasuring Ac.0.03 gts, lands of
petitioners 37,38 and 39 in Sy.Nos.Bg3,894,895 and 897 admeasuring Ac.O.'1325
gts and in Sy.Nos.432, 433 and 434 admeasuring Ac.0.03 gts situated at Toopran
Village & Mandal, Medak District in Gazette Notification No.46-A, daled 20.12.2001
treating the lands of the petitioners belongs as Waqf properties, pending disposal of
the Writ Petition
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI JALLI KANAKAIAH, REPRESENTING FOR
SRI JALLI NARENDAR
Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 't, 3 to 5: GP FOR REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondent No.2 : SRI FARHAN AZAM KHAN, SC FOR
TELANGANA STATE WAQF BOARD
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THt] HIGII CO[,IR'I' FOR-tHF] S]'ATE OF'I'EI'AN(;ANA
AT I{YDERABAD
IIONOURABI,T] SRI .IUSTICE I,,\XMI NARAYANA AI-ISHETTY
WR IT PETII'IO\ \ o i59 45 o12025
rC \R \o t lBtl( 011)7 175ll0l5)
Pronouncc-d or) 15 09'2026
UPloaded on 15 09 2026
Reserved on 0 L07 1016
Between:
Syeda Ghous ivo Stituna
and 38
other's'
' "Petitioners
And'.
'l
!'he State oJ' elon.grttttr
teptd bt :: [)rint ipLtl Se(retan '
.Nlinorit.,'w'ellilr( I-), [)Ltt nl e nl
Ilt,derabud and Ictti, othe'rs
Respondents
ORDER:
-l
his Writ t.etition is tiled sceking issuance of a writ o1' Mandamus
declaring the action of respondent No 2 in issuing Gazette
Notification
No.46-A. dated 110.12.2001, under Section 52 of the Waql
Act' 1954'
*'hereby thc lancls of petitioner Nos l to 5 in 51 Nos 89i' 89'+
admeasuring ,\c 0.10 gts: in S\ '\os l3l'
:l3l and 13-l aclncasuring
,\c.0.05 gts: lirncl; o1'petitioner Nos 6 and 7 in S1 Nos 89l
adrneasut ing .Ac 0 20 gts and in S1 Nos '132'
894 and 897
431 and 43'1 aclncasuring
Ac.0.0l gts: lands of pcritioner Nos 8' 9 and I0 in Sy Nos
and 897 admeasuring Ac 0 1325 gts and in Sy'Nos
adrreasitr it.llL \t 0.03 qts: lailds 'rl
and 897
893' 894' 895
432' 433 and 434
pctitioner \os lI
to 2'J in
t\|
t
tl I,\..1jql-. ol :tt: )
Sy.No. 103 l/E[-- admeasuring Ac.1.0950 _srs and in Sy.No.l03 llAA
admeasuring Ac.0.2475 gts; lands of petitioner Nos.2l to 25 in
Sy.Nos.893, 894, 895 and 897 admeasuring Ac.l.02 gts and in Sy.Nos.432,
433 and 434 adrneasuring Ac.0.06 gts; lands of petitioner Nos.26 to 29 in
Sy.Nos.893/AA3, 894/AA3 and 897/AA3 admeasuring Ac.O. 1325 gts;
lands of petitioner Nos.30 to 33 in Sy.Nos.g93, g94, g9-5 and g97
admeasuring Ac.0.1325 gts and in Sy.Nos.432. 433 and 434 admeasuring
Ac.0.03 gts; lands ol Petitioner No.j4 in Sy.Nos.g93, g94, g!)-s, g96 and
897 admeasuring Ac. 1.22 gts and in Sy.Nos.432, 433 and 434 admeasr-ri-ing
Ac.0.03 gts; lands of petirioner Nos.35 and 36 in Sy.Nos.g93, g94, g95 and
897 admeasuring Ac.l.02 gts and in Sy.Nos.432, 433 and 434 ad,reasuring
Ac.0.03 gts; lands olpetitioner Nos.37, 38 and 39 in Sy.Nos.g93, g94, g95
and 897 adrreasuring Ac.0. 1325 grs and in Sy.Nos.432,433 and 434
admeasuring Ac.0.03 gts situated at '[oopran Vi age and Mandar Medak
District, (hereinalter referred to as the ,.subject properri,,.), *,erc notified
as 'waqf lands' without issuing any notice to the petitioners, as illegal,
improper, null, void and unjust and consequently to derete the aforesaid
lands of the petitioners from the prohibitory list fumished by respondent
No.2.
LNA, J
WPNa 35915 of2025
2.
Heard Sri .lalli Kanakaiah, leamed senior counsel appearing for Sri
Jalli Narendar, learned counsel-on-record for the petitioners, Sri Farhan
Azam K.han, learned Standing Counsel for Telangana State Waqf Board
and learned Assistant Covemment Pleader lor Revenue
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that petitioner Nos.2l
to 25, 34, 35 and 16 are the absolute owners and possessors of the land in
Sy.Nos.893 to 897. having derived title to the same by' way of inheritance
from ancestors; tlrat the competent revenue authorities granted Occupancy
Rights Certificates (ORC), dated 05.06.1990, to the lbrefathers of
petitioner Nos.2 I to 25,34,35 and 36: and that pursuant thereto, petitioner
Nos.2l to 25. 31. 35 and 36 were issued Pattadar Passbooks and Title
Deeds in their favour; that petitioner Nos.21 to 25, 34, 35 and 36 have
been in peaceflrl and unintenupted possession and enjoyment of the
subject propert), irnd their names have consistently reflected in the revenue
records as pattadars. owners and possessors
3.I
.
He further submitted that when the petitioners approached the
registering authorities tbr execution and registration of sale deeds in favour
of prospective prrrchasers, they were shocked to learn that the subject
property is included in the prohibited propefties list, vide Gazette
Notification No..1ri-A at Sl.No.l9509. dated 20.11.200 I.
LNA. J
tt/PNo 35915 of 2025
3.2. Leamed counsel further submitted that immediately upon coming to
know of the inclusion of the subject property in the impugned Gazette
Notification, the petitioners approached respondent No.2 requesting for
deletion of the subject property from the prohibited properties list, but
respondent No.2 rejected their request claiming that the subject property is
waqf property; and as such, the petitioners' subject property continues to
remain in the prohibited properties list, causing grave prejudice and
preventing the petitioners from exercising their lawful proprietary rights.
3.3. Leamed counsel further submitted that respondent No.2 has not
asserted any lawful title or possession over the subject property; that at no
point of time, any notice was issued to the petitioners calling upon them to
show their title over the subject properry before publication of the Gazette
Notification; and that no enquiry was conducted, no opportunity of hearing
was afforded to the petitioners and no proceedings were initiated
questioning the petitioners title or possession, and thus, the respondents
acted in violation of the principles of natura I j ustice and fair procedure.
3.4. Learned counsel further submitted that respondent No.2, without
foltowing the mandatory procedure contemplated under the provisions of
the Waqf Act, 1954, included the subject property in the impugned Gazette
LNA J
t!/PNo.35915 of2025
Notification atlegedly issued under Section 5(2) thereof, which is wholly
illegal, arbitrary and \^'ithout j urisdiction
3.5. Leamed ,:ounsel further subrnitted that the subject property IS
private patta lanc which devolved Llpon the petitioners through ancestral
succession and family partition. The petitioners and their predecessors-in-
interest have been in lawful possession and enjoyment o1'the land for
several decades.
-l-he
land has always been recognized as private patta land
in all revenue records. and at no point of time. has it ever been dedicated
for any religious. charitable or pious purpose so as to constitute Waqf
property
3.6. Leamed ccunsel further submitted that the ORCs granted in favour
of forefathers of the petitioners have attained finaliry. since the same have
not been cancelled, modified or challenged befbre any competent lorum
As the revenue entries standing in the name of the petitioners have
remained intact tirr several decades. there is a presumption cf correctness
until rebutted in lccordance u'ith law. Therefore, respondent No.2 could
not have unilaterally treated the subject property as Waqf properry
3.7
.
Leamed counsel further submitted that the action of respondent
No.2 in illegally including the subject propefiy in the prohibited properties
list has seriously affected the petitioners' constitutional and statutory
LNA, J
WPNo 35915 o12025
rights, and the petitioners have been deprived of their right to alienate,
mortgage or otherwise enj oy the subject property despite possessing valid
title. Such action of respondent No.2 is withotrt authority of law and in
violative of Articles 14 and 300-A ofthe Constitution of India and hence,
the same cannot be sustained.
3.8. Leamed counsel further submitted that the administrative action
affecting valuable property rights of persons must satisfu the test of
fairness, hansparency and reasonableness. The impugned action of the
respondents fails to meet any ofthese constitutional requirements; that the
action of respondent No.2 in including the subject property of the
petitioners in the impugned Gazette notification is arbitrary and reflects
failure on the part of the respondent-authorities to discharge their statutory
duties, which resulted in irreparable hardship and financial loss to the
petitioners.
4.
By contending as above, leamed counsel for petitioners prayed to
allow the Writ Petition.
5.
On the other hand, leamed Standing Counsel for Waqf Board
submitted that in the year 1960, the then Govemment of Andhra Pradesh
appointed a Survey Commissioner ol Waqfs for survey and demarcation of
the Waqf properties in the State, as provided under Section 4 of the Waqf
LNA, J
IYP No 3594 5 of 2025
Act. 1954. Accor,Jingly, the Surver Commissioner of Waqfs, through his
survey officials and b1 issuing noticc through tom-tom beat in rural areas,
conducted survey and demarcated all the Waqf properties, by preparing
survey forms as prescribed; that the survey conducted by the Survey
Commissioner of Waqls in respect ol'subject propefi) was also to the
knowledge of the general public and the said tom-tom beat was got done
through the village servants, village patu,aris, village revenue officers and
revenue inspector:;, etc.. and as such. thc petitioners cannot contend that no
notice was issueci to them before publication of the impugned Gazette
notification and due process of law was not followed.
5.1.
Learned Standing Counsel lurther submitted that though the
exercise of surver and demarcation of all the Waqf properties by making
tom-tom beat ann,runcement for the local public was taken up in the early
1960s itself, the conlenls of the sun, ey fbrms were published in the year
I in the impugned Gazette Notification, which has become final as
provided under thr'Section-6 of the Waqf Act, 1955.
5.2.
Learned Standing Counsel vehemently submitted that the present
Writ Petition fllecl challenging the C;azette Notification issued under the
WaqlAct, 1954. after repeal of the WaqlAct, 1954. is not maintainable.
He further submi[ed that the changes under Sections 4 and 5 which are
LNA, J
WPNo.35945 of2025
germane to the instant /ls stands altered by the Unified Waqf Management,
Empowerment, Efficiency and Development Act, 1995 (for brevity
'UWMEED') as amended by the Waqf Amendment (Act No.14 of 2025)
having come into force w.e.f. 08.04.2025 and that prior to that also, the
Waqf Act, 1995 had been amended by the Amendment Act No.27 of 2013,
w.e.f 01.11.2013. The Waqf Act, 2025, provides for registration of all
waqf properties, with the introduction of UWMEED Portal on 06.06.2025,
to digitalize and streamline Auquaf registration in line with the Waqf
Amendment Act 14 of 2025, however, the procedure has not been
completed.
5.3.
Learned Standing Counsel further submitted that the UWMEED,
1995 being procedural law, stands as an exception and is retroactive and in
support of his submission, he relied upon the judgment rendered in Shyam
Sunder and others vs Ram Kumar and anothert, which had been
reiterated in Zile Singh vs State of Haryana2.
5.4. Leamed Standing Counsel has placed reliance on the judgment
rendered in Shiv Sagar Tiwari vs Union of Intlia3, wherein the Hon'ble
Supreme Court observed that publication in news papers is sufficient
' AtR 2oo t sc 2472
'?
zooa 1ay scc r
' 1997 (1) SCC 444
I
LA'A, J
ll'PNc.35945 of2025
notice to the local populace
who were affected and were non-local
residents.
5.5.
He further submitted that the every
given
number; that notices have been
separate survey; that aboul
waqf institution has serial
to each institution betbre conducting
92'000 institutions were surveyed
Commissioner'
first Survey conducted by the Sur.''ey
during the
who submitted his
report to the Goverrment'
5.6.
Learned Strrnding Counsel further
by writ petitioner: in the present
submined that the relief sought
vn'rit petition tantamounts to virtual
at the outset' the
perpetuation of illcgality' since
b1' delal and
maintainable and is being hit
judgments of this '- our-t and the Hon'ble
he relied on thc iudgment of the
Behera vs Pravati Parida and
present writ petition is not
laches' as held in catena of
Apex Court' ln support thereof'
I lon'bte Apex Court
in Charulatha
othersl '
5.T.LeamedlitandingCounsellorWaqfBoardfinallysubmittedthat
counsel fbr
the judgments reli:d br learned
law and further, r'rhen the Parliarrent
the petitioners is no more good
in its wisdom has enacted the Waqf
the proccdure
Act, 2025, theret';- changing
into effect frorn 08'04 2025' the
'20l5 (4) sc( lo
to be followed' which came
s'rit petitioners cannot contend non-
l0
Li\'A J
WPNo..l5915 of2025
compliance of the procedure which is not in force as on date and
accordingly, prayed to dismiss the Writ Petition.
6.
Learned counse! for petitioners, in reply to submissions made by
leamed Standing Counsel for Waqf Board, submitted that the contention of
the Waqf Board that survey was conducted under Section 4 of Waqf Act,
1954, is unsupported by production of the original survey report. Under
Sections 4 and 5 of the Waqf A ct, 1954 (and similarty under the 1 995 Act),
the Suivey Commissioner must conduct a quasi-judicial enquiry, issue
notices to persons interested, invite objections, examine revenue records
and submit a detailed report. Publication under Section 5 of the Waqf Act,
1954 must be based on such lawful enquiry. However, in the instant case,
the Waqf Board has not placed on record any survey proceedings, enquiry
file, objection register and the notice acknowledgments
6.1
.
Learned counsel further submitted that the subject property was
recorded as patta land along with the name of pattadar in the revenue
records, therefore, when the vested proprietary rights are affected,
individual notice is mandatory. In such an event, the specific case of Waqf
Board about issuance ofnotice by beat of tom tom in the Village is legally
insufficient. Public announcement without proof, cannot substitute service
of notice on affected land owners.
LN'A, J
tt'P\a.J5945 oI2025
6.2.
Learned counsel further submitted that the contention of the Waqf
Board that the im;;ugned Gazette publication attained finaliq,and as such,
the petitioners ouglht to havc approached the Waqf 1'ribunal under Section
83 of Waqf Act i-s misconceived. The challenge in the present Writ Petition
is to the very validity and legalitt, of the notification. When mandatory
statutory provisions of law are not complied with and the action of the
Waqf Board is vc,id aD initio, writ jurisdiction can be invoked and Writ
Petition is maintair-rable.
6.3.
Leamed counsel further subntitted that admittedly, the Waqf Act,
954 stood repeal,:d w ith the enactment of Waqf Act 1 995. After repeal,
no notification coL.ld be issued under the repealed Act. 1954. l-lowever, the
action of the resr,ondents in issuing the notification, dated 14.08.2003,
under the repealed Waqf Act, 1954, declaring vast extent of properties as
waqf properties. has, in lact, driven a large number ofpersons to approach
this Court by filing, Writ Petitions challeneing the said notification. Section
I l2 of Waqf Act, 995. saves onlr completed actions; it does not authorize
fresh publication under a dead statute.
6.4.
Learned c,)unsel further submitted that the Waqf Board relies on
the doctrine "Once ll/aql, always Waql[." Ihe doctrine applies only where
waqf character is lirst laq,fullv established. In the present cases, there is no
LN',4, J
LfP\o 35915 ol2D5
proof of rvakif, no deed of dedication, no evidence of permanent charitable
or religious endowment, and no statutory adjudication establishing Waqf
status, hence, the said doctrine has no application to the present case.
6.5.
Learned counsel further submitted that even assuming existence
of graves or religious structures in the subject property, as contended in the
counter, mere physical existence does not establish legal Waqf dedication
Dedication must be proved in accordance with law. In this regard, leamed
counsel for petitioners relied on the order passed by a leamed single Judge
of this Court in W.P.No.33133 of 2014, wherein it is held that mere
inclusion of a particular property in Gazette notification without statutory
compliance of the mandatory procedure under the Act does not create title
on the Waqf Board over the said property.
6.6.
Leamed counsel further submitted that the contention of the Waqf
Board that delay defeats the petitioners' claim is untenable, since a void
action can be chailenged at any time. A notification issued without
jurisdiction is a nullity in the eye of law; that the long inaction on the part
of the Waqf Board, failure to exercise possession, manage the property'
collect rent, or assert rights for decades, all put together belies the claim of
Waqf character and demonstrates absence of effective control or
recognition.
L]'iA, J
IYPNo 35915 of2025
7.
On careful ,lonsideration of the submissions advanced by the leamed
counsel appearingi on either side and on perusal of the relevant material
available on record, the following issues emerge for adjudication:-
(I) Whether llr.e petitioners have locus standi to maintain the Wril
Pelition?
(2) ll/hether tlrere is delal' and laches on the pdrl of the petitioners?
(3) Whether the ll/rit Petition is maintainable inspite of availabilily of
alternative remedy of approuching lhe Waqlf Tribunal?
(4) Whether the procedure conlemplated under the ll/aqlf Act, 1954,
has been followed prior to issuance of the impugned Gazette
NotiJicatiotr?
(5) To what reliel?
Issue No.1'.-
8.
The petitioners have prodr-rced ORC, vide D.Dis.No.Al427l90l,
dated 05.06.1990. Pattadar Passbooks. Title Deeds and revenue records
reflecting their names as pattadars. owners and possessors of the subject
lands. It is not th: case of the respondents that the ORC or the revenue
entries standing ir the names of the petitioners have been cancelled or
l4
LNA, J
lrPNo.j5945 oJ )02.5
declared invalid by any competent forum. Thus, the petitioners continue to
enjoy primafacie Lrtle and lawful possession over the subject property.
9.
The grievance of the petitioners is that their subject property has
been included in the impugned Gazette Notification, dated 20.12.2001, and
is brought under the prohibited properties list, thereby preventing them
from alienating or otherwise dealing with the subject property.
Undoubtedly, by such action of the Waqf Board, the petitioners are
subjected to civil consequences and it also directly affects their
constitutional and proprietary rights guaranteed under Article 300-A ofthe
Constitution of India. Therefore, the petitioners are persons directly
aggrieved by the impugned action and possess sufficient legal interest to
invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution.
10. The expression "person aggrieved" has consistently received liberal
interpretation by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. In Calcutta Gas Company
(Proprietary) Ltd. v, State of West Bengaf , the Constitution Bench of
Hon'ble Supreme Court held that a person who has suffered a legal injury
or whose legal rights are directly affected by administrative action has the
' alK i96z sc r o++
l5
LT|A. J
lltP.\o.35915 of2025
necessary locus :;tandi to maintain a writ petition. Similarly. in State of
Orissa v. Madan Gopal Rungtat', it *as held that the existence of an
enforceable legal right is the loundation for invoking jurisdiction under
Article 226.
1I
. Likewise. in Ayaaubkhan Noorkhan Pathan v. Stale of
Maharashtrul, the Hon'ble Supreme Court explained the concept of an
"aggrieved person" and held that a person can maintain a writ petition
when he suffers a legal grievance by' reason of deprivation ol something to
which he is legalll'entitled. The Coun observed that only a person'*'ho has
suffered legal inlury by reason ol r iolation ol his legal or constitutional
right has the locus to maintain proceedings.
12. In the present case. the petitioners have demonstrated that the
impugned notification has directly in.rpaired their right to en-loy, alienate
and deal with the subject propern.. Therefore, they clearly answer the
description of "pt:rsons aggrieved"
13.
Furthsrmore, the petitioners being recorded as pattadars and
possessors of the subject property and whose proprietarl rights stand
directly affected lrir the impugned notification, have a clear legal interest in
" AIR 1952 SC 12
20 r 3 (1) SCC 165
l6
LIA, J
tt'Plio 35945 oJ 202 5
the subject matter. They satisry the requirement
aggrieved" and are fully competent
of being "persons
to invoke the jurisdiction of this Court
under Article 226 of the Constitutton'
t4.
In the light of the above, this Court holds
that the petitioners have
locus standi to maintain the present
writ petition' The preliminary
objection raised by the respondent-Waqf
Board regarding maintainability
of the Writ Petition due to lack of locus standi
of the Petitioners is,
therefore, rejected.
15.
Accordingly, this issue is answered in favour
of the petitioners'
Iss ue No.2'.-
16. As regards the contention of the respondents
is liable to be dismissed on the grounds
that the Writ Petition
of detay and laches, it is pertinent
to note that the petitioners have specifically
know of the inclusion of their lands in the
when they approached the registering
pteaded that they came to
prohibited properties list only
authoriry for registration of sale
deeds and immediately, they approached
respondent No 2 seeking deletion
of their lands from the prohibited properties
the petitioners cannot defeat their right
list Mere delay on the part of
to challenge an action allegedly
l7
Lj\A J
W P.\'o.35945
affecting their. r,ested proprietar)- rights. The
of2025
issue of delay cannot be
decided as an inclependenr issue. where
the substantial rights of the parties
are to be decided based on the merits of
the case.
17. Therelor.e. this issue is answered accordingly
Issue No.3:-
lS
As regards the objection raised bl learned Standing
waqf Board w th regard to maintainability of
the writ petition in view of
availability of arternative remedy of approaching
Section 83 of the Waqf Act, ir is ro be
questioned the
counsel for the
the waqf Tribunar under
seen rhar the petitioners have
',er) iurisdiction of the respondents to include their lands in
the Gazette Notification without complying
with the mandatory provisions
of Sections 4 and 5 or the waqf Act. 1954,
principles of natural justice. 'rhe challenge
of the notification bur to the legality of the
and also in l.iolation of the
is not merely to the correctness
decision_making process itself.
19. It is a scttled principle thar the existence ofan alternative
does not bar the :xercise or writ jurisdiction.
where the impugned action is
without jurisdicrion or in violation of principles
llthirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of
Supreme court I'eld that a writ perition
' tqgt (8) scc I
remedy
of narural justice. In
Tratle Markss, the Hon,ble
is maintainable, notwithstanding
l8
LN'A, J
WPn"o.35945 of 2025
the availability of an alternative remedy to the petitioner, to seek
enforcement of fundamental rights when there has been violation of
principles of natural justice; or the impugned proceedings are wholly
without jurisdiction or the vires of an Act is under challenge.
20. The said principle has been reiterated in Harbanslal Sahnia v'
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd., and Radha Krishan Industries v. State of
Himachal Pradesht|, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court summarized the
exceptions to the rule of altemative remedy and held that where an order is
passed without jurisdiction or in breach of natural justice' the High Court
can entertain a writ petition under Article 226 of Constitution of India'
.
In this regard, it is trite to refer to judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in RaJique Bibi (Dead) by LRs v. Sayed ll/aliuddin (Dead)
by LRsrt , wherein it is held that an order which is a nullity for want of
jurisdiction can be challenged whenever and wherever it is sought to be
enforced. Similarty, in Kiran Singh v. Chaman PaswantT, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court held that a decree or order passed without jurisdiction is a
nullity and its invatidity can be set up whenever it is sought to be enforced.
'rozoo: (z) scc I oz
2o2t (6) scc 771
" 2oo4 (1) scc 287
'' ntR ii54 sc l+o
t9
LNA, J
tl/PNo.35945 of2025
22. In the context of Waqf disputes, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Board of Muslin llaqfs, Rajaslhan v. Radha Kishantr, hetd that where
persons claiming independent title are affected by inclusion of their
properry as Waq 1' property, they are entitled to challenge such inclusion
before the coml)etent forum. -fhc decision recognizes that private
landholders whos: rights are prej udicially allected by Waqf notifications
are the 'persons arggrieved' and thel have the requisite standing to question
such action.
23.
Thereforc, when the petitioners allege that the impugned
notification is void ab initio for want of jurisdiction and non-compliance of
mandatory statut(,r) requirements. the) arc entitled to invoke the writ
jurisdiction of this Court.
24. This issue ir; accordingly answered.
Issue No,4:-
25. The challe nge in the Writ Petition to the impugned gazetre
notification dated 20.12.2001 is primarily on the ground that the procedure
prescribed under S ection 4 of the Waclf Act. I 954. which is pari materia to
Sections 4 and 5 of the Waqf Act. 1995 has not been followed while
' 1t ol9; : scc +os
L!\',1 J
tl'PNo.35945 of2a25
issuing the impugned notification, thereby showing the subject property as
waqf property.
26. A perusal of the impugned notification reveals that the same has
been issued on 20.12.2001, by claiming that the subject lands have been
surveyed under Section 4(3) of the Waqf Act, 1957 (wrongly noted instead
of the Waqf Act, 1954) and published irnder Section 5(2) of the Waqf Act,
1954.
27.
At this juncture, it is relevant to refer to vociferous contention of
the learned Standing Counsel for the Waqf Board that in view of the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rashid ll/ali Begv' Farid
Pindarila, and Section 83(l) of the Waqf Act, 1995, the dispute at hand
about the nature and character of the property being waclf can be dealt with
only by the Waqf Tribunal and neither the Writ Court nor the State
Govemment is competent to decide such issues.
28. The High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is
always empowered to examine whether essential attributes for declaration
of waqf have been made out or not; whether the procedure of survey and
conducting quasi-judicial inquiry prior to declaration of any property as
waqf has been diligently and sincerely followed by the authorities as it has
" (zoi) q scc qt q
).1
LNA, J
tt'P\o 35915 of2025
the draconian cor sequence of deprir ing a large number of cltizens of their
fundamental and ronstitutional rights. and if this Court finds that a specific
properry- has been published in the official gazette declaring the same as
waqf property \ thout fbllowing the mandatory procedure contemplated
under the Act in ,'ogue. it can alwa-vs intervene or decline tc acknowledge
the character of uaqfto such property
29.
At this st:Lge, it is apposite to refer ro the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Madanuri Sri Ramachandra Murthy v. Syed
Jalalts , wherein while dealing with a case where the waqf authorities had
staked claim to r propert\ /landr structure as rvaql propert), in a similar
fashion abridging the fundamental rights of large number of adversely
affected citizens or have acted arbitrarily. the Hon'ble Supreme Court
clearly held that t:onducting of surve)'by the Survey Commissioner prior
to notification o I an."., property as a u,aqf is an indispensable statutory
procedure and surve;- contemplates a quasi-judicial inquiry at the grass
root level as to u hcther thc propen\ is actualll a w,aqf propeny or not; that
the inclusion of any propertv as a waqf property must be with due
application of mind; that only thereafter, it can be sent to the Govemment
for notification ir, the olficial gazetre: and that if the above mandatory
t (:o n) 13 scc rz+
LNA, J
WPNo.35945 of2025
procedure has not been followed before issuing publication in the official
gazette, then such property cannot be assumed as a waqf property.
30. For better appreciation of the case, the relevant provisions of the
Waqf Act, 1954, are extracted hereunder:"Section 4 empowered the State Government to appoint a State
Commissioner, and as many Additional and Assistant Survey
Commissioners of Waqif as mav be necessary, by a noiiJication in
the fficial gazette for the purpose of making survey of waqlf
properties existing within the State. The Survey Commissioner,
after making a survey of waqf properties, would submit his report
to the State Goyernment contoining various particulars as
mentioned in sub-sections (3) and (4) ofSection 4 of the Act.
Section 5 mandated that on receipt of such report from the
Surtey Commissioner made under sub-section (3) ofSection 4, the
State Government should forward a copy of the same to the Waqlf
Board. The Ll/aq;[ Board would examine the report forwarded to it
and publish in official gazette, the list of waq)li in the State.
For resolving the disputes regarding waqlfs, Section 6 of
the 1954 Act, provided jttisdictional civil Court as a forum and
decision of civil Court in respect of such matters should be final. It
was also clartfied that no such suit should be entertained by the
civil Court, after the expiry ofone year from the date of publication
of the list of waqt's as per sub-section (2) ofSection 5.
ll
LNA, J
WPNo.35915 of 2A25
Sut'-section (4) of Section 6 stated that the list of waqlfs
published under sub-section (2) ofSection 5 shall be final and
conclusie unles,s such list is modified on the direction of the civil
Court.
The prr-visions found in Sections 5 and 6 of the |Vaqf Act,
1995 ana the 1954 Act ar€ almost akin to each other. However, the
change htought in bt Parliantent under the 1995 Act is that. m the
case of Tispute regardin.q wac1l.s. the aggrteved part.r' needs to
approacl the lt'aql Tribunol constituted under Seclion 83 of
the Waql .4c1, 1995 and con.sequently. the jurisdiction of the civil
Court i.s raken awal. Ercept the aforesaid change. no olher
substantttl modification is lbtrncl in those provisions.'
1.
It is reler ant to refer to the judgment of Division Bench of the High
Court of Kerala in Ezhome Sunni Valfi'a Juma v. Kerala llaqf Boardt6
wherein it is held that inquirl to be conducted by Waqf Board before
declaring an) propert) as a \4,aq1 is a 'quasi-judicial /hnction', and
therefore. no uniiateral decision cor"rld have been taken without recording
any reason as to hou,. ivhen and uhr the propert) came 10 be included as a
waqf property.
32. It is relevant to refer to the judgmenr in Salem Muslim Burial
Grounri Proteclion Committee v. Stute o.f Tamil Nadut', wherein the
" 20 r9 (3) KLT 1064
'' lzozly ro scc:o+
LNA, J
tt'P,Yo.35943 oJ2025
Hon'ble Supreme Court had an occasion to consider the challenge to the
conversion of private property as a waqf property, on the ground of noncompliance of statutory procedure prescribed under the Waqf Act of 1954
or 1995, and the Hon'ble Supreme Court, after comprehensively examining
the scheme of both the Acts of 1954 and 1995, categorically held that mere
notification in the offrcial gazette is not enough, but the notification must
be preceded by a preliminary survey followed by submission of report to
the State Government about the exact status of the land proposed to be
notified as waqf. Conducting of survey and quasi-judicial inquiry before
declaring any property as a waqf property is slne qua non before declaring
any property as waqf property, in the absence of which, notification
under Section 5 of the Waqf Act stands vitiated and would carry no legal
recognition. The Supreme Court further held that such a notification
published in the officiat gazetle at the instance of Waqf Board sha1l not
bind the State Government at all, especially when the mandatory procedure
preceding inclusion of property as a waqf under Sections 4 and 5 of
the Act of 1954 has not been followed.
.5
LNA, J
llP\o 3 5915 of 202 5
33. The above principles have been reiterated in State of Andhra
Pradesh v. A.P. Slate Wad BoortltE. wherein it is observed thus:
"A plain reading of the provisions of the above two Acts would
reveal tlttt the notification under Seclion 5 of both the Acts
declaring the gist o,l rhe u aclis slrull only be published after
complenon of the process as laid down under Sectiort 4 of the
above Acts. which provides.for ht:o surteys. settlement of disputes
arising tlrcreto and the submission of the report to the State
Governmtnt and to the Board. Therefore, conducliag elf the
surveys before decla nE a propertv a waaf propertv is u sine qua
non. In the case at han
there is no material or evidence on
record tltal before issuing nolification under Seclion 5 of
lhe ll/aqf Act, 1954, anv p rocedure or lhe survev b,as conducled
as contenryloted bl, Section 4 of the Act. In the absence of such a
material, lhe mere issuance of the nolification under Section 5
of the Acr would not constitule a valid waof in resDect ofthe suit
land, Th,erefore, lhe Notification dated 29-4-1959 is not a
conclusiv,g proof of the fa ct thdt the suit land is a waaf orooertv.
In 7..);. Waq;f Boardv Hathi.ja Ammal /2001) 8 SCC 528, it
was obsetred that the lltaq/ Board should follow the procedure as
required under Seclions 4, 5 and 6 or Seclion 27 of the llaq;f
Act befort' notirt'ing the wtulfs under Section 5 of the Act.
ln lvladanuri Srr
Rama Chandra Murthl'v. Syed
Jalal (sryt,a). ir was observed as under. (SCC p. 185. Para l6)
' (2022) (zo) scc l8-:
L\A, J
tvPNo.J5945 of2A25
" Thus, tt is amply clear tlat the conducting of survey by the
Survey Commissioner dnd preparing a report and forwarding the
same to the State or the Waqf Board precedes the final act of
notifying such list in the fficial gazette by the State under
the 1995 Act (it was by the Board under the 1954 Act). As
mentioned supra, the list would be prepared by the Suntey
Commissioner after making due enquiry and after valid survey as
well as after due application of mind. The enquiry contemplated
under sub-section (3) ofSection 4 is not merely an informal
enquiry but a formal enquiry to find out al the grass loot level, as
to whether the property is a wakt' property or nol. Thereafter the
waqf board will once again examine the list sent lo it with due
application of its mind and only thereafter the same will be sent ttt
the Government for notifying the same in the gazette. "
It may be noted that lYaqf Board is a statutory authority
under the llad Act. Therefore, the official eazette is bound to
carry anv notilicalion al lhe ins tance of the lltasf Board bul
nonetheless, the State Governmenl k nol bou nd bv such a
Dublication of the notifrcdtion published in the offic ial saz.ette
merelv for lh e reason that il has b een so Dublishetl. In State of
Andhra Pradesh v. Andhra Pradesh Waq[ Board (supra), this
Court consisting of one of us (V. Ramasubramanian, J. as a
Member) held that the publication of a notification in the fficial
gazette has a presumption of knowledge to the general public just
like an advertisement published in the newspaper, but such a
notiJ)cation published at the instance of the llrod' Board in the
State gazette is not binding upon the State Government. Il means
thal the notilication
f
t an t). D ublished in lhe o tctal eazetle al
LNA. J
tttP\o.35945 of2025
the behest of the ll/aqf Act Riving the lists of lhe waqls is not a
conclusive proof lhat a particular propertv is a h)aql' Dropertv
especiallt
,
b)hen no Drocedure 4S DTescribed under Section 4 of
the Waq[ 4ct hqs been followed in is,suins the sam4
In vnt' oJ the aJbresaid iacts and crcumstances, ve do not
find am substance in the argument that the suit land was a waq[
propertr c,nd as such would continue to be a waq;[ alwa.ys. In lhe
dbsence of ant: evidence of valid creation of a waaf in resDect of
lhe suil DroDeny*, it cannot be rec' opnised as a waqf so as lo allow
il to be continued as a wuqf oro'Dertv irresDective of ils use or
disuse as o burial round,"
[emphasis supplied by ils]
34.
In the present case. the Waqf Board was required to establish that
the statutory procedure prescribed under Sections 4 and 5 ofthe Waqf Act,
1954. had been dt.ly followed before the subject properties '*,ere included
in the impugned Cazette notification
5.
Section 4 o ' the I 954 Act contemplated survey of waqf properties
by the Survey Commissioner appointed by the State Govemment. The
Survey Commissioner, after conducting survey and requisite enquiry and
on due applicatior of mind, was required to submit a repon. to the State
Govemment containing the parliculars prescribed under Section 4(3) of the
Act. Thereafter. Llrrder Section 5, rhe report was required to be lorwarded
LNA. J
trPNo.35945 o!2025
to the Waqf Board, which was required to examine the same and publish
the list of waqfs in the Official Gazette.
36. The statutory scheme clearly indicates that the survey and enquiry
under Section 4 constitute the foundation for the subsequent publication of
the properties under Section 5. The requirement of conducting a proper
survey and enquiry cannot be treated as an empty formality' The enquiry
contemplated under Section 4 is a substantive enquiry for determining
whether the properties in question constitute waqf properties, and the
authorities are required to apply their mind to the relevant material before
the properties are included in the final list.
37. As stated supra, in Salem Muslim Burial Ground Protection
Committee's case (cited supra) and in State of Andhra Pradesh's case
(19th cited supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that survey under
Section 4 is not merely an administrative exercise, but involves a quasi-
judicial enquiry; and that the survey, inquiry and the report must precede
the publication of the Gazette notification.
38.
In the case on hand, though on behalf of the respondents, it has
been contended that the respondents-authorities have followed the due
process of law before issuing the impugned notification, no material is
LNA, J
WPNo.35945 of2025
placed before this Court as to when and hou, the respondents have
conducted preliminary survey of the waqf properties as contemplated
under Sections 4 and 5 of the 1954 Act.
39.
Therefore. from the above, it is obvious that the Waqf Board has to
establish compliance of
the following steps/foundational
requirements/proc r:dure, before declaring a property as waqf property in
the official gazette:-
(i) that a Survey Oommissioner was appointed in accordance with Section
4 of the Waqf Act. 1954;
(ii) that a prelimirary survey of the subject propenies was conducted by
the competent Surr e1 (srnrnissioner:
(iii) that a fbrmal enquiry was conducted with respect to the nature,
character, origin and alleged dedication of the subject properties as waqf
properties;
(iv) that the Survev commissioner prepared and submitted a report under
Section 4(3) containing the particulars prescribed under the Act;
(v) that the said r()port was forwarded by the State Govemment to the
Waqf Board in accc,rdance with Section 5(l) of the Act;
LNA, J
WPNo.35945 of2025
(vi) that the Waqf Board independently examined the said report and
applied its mind to the material before including the subject properties in
the list of waqfs;
(vii) that the persons having an interest in or possession of the subject
properties were afforded an effective opportunity to place their objections
before the competent authority during the course of the enquiry;
(viii) that a notice of the survey or enquiry was issued to the affected
persons and that their objections, if any, were considered;
(ix) that the alleged survey particulars, including the survey report, local
inspection report, revenue records and other foundational matedal, were
prepared and maintained by the competent authority;
(x) that the proclamation of the survey proceedings by way of tom-torrl/
beat of drum was in fact undertaken, and no contemporaneous record
evidencing such publication in newspapers has been placed before this
Court,' and
(xi) that the properties were identified with sufficient particulars, including
survey numbers, extent, boundaries and the basis upon which each
individual property was treated as waqf property.
3l
LNA, J
WPN1.35945 of2025
40.
Significant. to note that the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the
Waqf Board is cornpletely silent rn,ith regard to compliance of the aforesaid
foundational requ rements. The Waqf Board has not produced the survey
report, the procee,lings of the Survey Commissioner, the material relating
to the enquiry. the objections, if any, allegedly received and considered. or
any record evidencing compliance with the procedure preceding the
impugned notification. Mere assertion in the counter-affidavit that the
notihcation was issued in accordance with law cannot supersede the
production of the' statutory record demonstrating compliance with the
mandatory procedure.
41. Once a pr(rpefty is included in the statutory list of waqfs, serious
civil consequence:; follow. Therefore, the authority exercising the statutory
power was requir',:d to strictly adhere to the procedure prescribed by the
Act and could not dispense with the loundational survey and enquiry
contemplated undcr Section 4 thereof
42. It is also perlinent to refer to the judgment of a Co-ordinate Bench
of this Court in (.-herukuri Proveena and others v. Slate of Telanganate,
wherein, while cor.rsidering a similar challenge under the Waqf Act, it was
'n zoz+ 1+1
l'tt aee
LNA, J
WPNo.35945 0f2025
held that where the procedure prescribed under Sections 4 and 5 of the
Waqf Act had not been followed before publication of the Gazette
notification, mere issuance of the Gazette notification would not, by itself,
validate inclusion of the property as waqf property. The Gazette
notification cannot be treated as an independent or self-proving source of
title or character of the property as waqf when the foundational statutory
proceedings/requirements/steps leading to such notification are not
established.
43. There is yet another important aspect which requires consideration.
The impugned notification dated 20.12.2001 was admittedly issued under
the provisions of the Waqf Act, 1954. The repealing of Waqf Act, l954,by
the Waqf Act, 1995 and the amendments introduced thereafter, cannot
retrospectively cure the non-compliance with the mandatory procedure
prescribed under the statute which govemed the issuance of the impugned
notification. In other words, the validity of the notification dated
20.12.2001 has to be tested with reference to the statutory requirements
applicable to the enactment under which the notification was issued and it
cannot be sustained merely by relying upon subsequent amendments or
subsequent statutory mechanisms.
i3
LNA, J
WPNo.35945 of 2025
44. It is also pertinent to note that the subsequent Unified Waqf
Management, EmDowerment, Efficiency and Development Act, 1995, as
amended by the Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025, does not contain any
provision which retrospectively validates a Gazette notification issued
under the repealecl Waqf Act, 1954, without proof of compliance with the
mandatory survey and enquiry contemplated under Sections 4 and 5 of the
1954 Act. The subsequent statutory regime cannot be invoked to cure a
foundational def-err which existed at the very inception of the impugned
notification.
45.
More importantly, the question in the present case is not mereiy
whether an aggrie'red person has a statutory remedy against an entry in the
list of auqaf. The primary question is whether the very notification dated
20.12.2001 was validly issued in accordance with the mandarory procedure
prescribed under the Aot
46.
Section 6 of the Waqf Act, 1995 provides a mechanism for
determination of a dispute as to n.hether a particular property specified in
the list of auqaf is waqf propefy or not. However, such provision cannot
be construed as dispensing with the mandatory statutory requirements
which precedes th: publication of the original notification. l-he existence
LNA, J
WPNo 35915 of2025
of an altemative remedy cannot retrospectively validate an otherwise
defective exercise of statutory power.
47.
Thus, the Waqf Board cannot contend that avaitability of a remedy
under the subsequent statutory regime renders the challenge to the validity
of the notification dated 14.08.2003 to be impermissible.
48.
The subsequent statutory provisions cannot be relied upon either to
validate the impugned notification or to shift the burden upon the
petitioners to establish the invalidity of the impugned notification, whose
statutory foundation has itself not been demonstrated by the Waqf Board.
49. There is distinction between (i) a challenge to the correctness ofan
entry validly made after following the statutory procedure, and
(ii) a challenge to the very jurisdictional and procedural foundation upon
which the notification was issued, are required to be maintained. In the
former case, the statutory remedy prescribed under the Act may have
relevance. In the latter case, where the competent authority has failed to
establish compliance of the mandatory conditions precedent for exercise of
statutory power, the Court is empowered to examine whether the impugned
notification itself was lawfully issued.
LNA, J
n/Pi'io.35915 of2025
50. Therefore. mere existence ofa subsequent statutory mechanism for
adjudication of disputes relating to waqf properties cannot, by itself,
validate the impugned Gazette notification dated 14.08.2003, particularly
when the Waqf Board has failed to place before this Court the any material
or records demonstrating compliance of Sections 4 and 5 of the Waqf Act,
.
It is true t rat a waqf validly registered under the earlier law may
not require fresh legistration under the 1995 Act by virtue of the saving
provision contained in Section 43. However, in the absence of any material
showing that the s;ubject properties were duly registered under the earlier
law or that the statutory requirements for their recognition as waqf
properties were otherwise satisfied. the mere asseftion that the properties
were included in an old Gazette notification cannot, by itself, cure the
absence of the forurdational statutory requirement
52. Further. rnere production of the Gazette notification dated
20.12.2001 does not establish that the notification was preceded by a valid
survey, enquiry and consideration of the relevant material. A Gazette
notification is the r:ulmination of the statutory process and it cannot replace
the process itselI Where the very tbundation upon which the notification
LNA, J
WPNo.35945 of2025
rests is not produced or absent, the notification cannot be sustained merely
on the ground that it was published in the Official Gazette.
53.
In the present case, the Waqf Board has failed to produce any
material demonstrating that the statutory process contemplated under
Sections 4 and 5 of the Waqf Act, 1954 was completed before the Gazette
notification dated 20.12.2001 was issued. Mere assertion of the contention
of the Waqf Board that prescribed procedure has been followed prior to
issuance of the impugned Gazetle notification is untenable and
unacceptable in the light of the fact that the Waqf Board failed to place
before this Court the sun,ey repolt of the Commissioner, forwarding of
such reporl to the Waqf Board, consideration of the report by the Board,
any proof of the alleged proclamation/beat of tom tom, the consideration of
objections, if any, received, or the registration particulars of the subject
waqf properties, nor any contemporaneous material evidencing compliance
with the statutory procedure. The silence of the Waqf Board on these
material aspects assumes significance, particularly when the entire
statutory basis for treating the subject properlies as waqf properties is
under chalienge.
54.
A Co-ordinate Bench of this Courl has also taken a similar view in
WPNo.447 of 2007, by order dated 18.09'2024, wherein the requirement
LNA, J
tYPNo.35945 of 202 5
of compliance of the statutory procedure preceding the Gazette notification
was considered.
55.
All the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court referred to supra
reinforce the principle that the statutory procedure prescribed under
the
WaqfActcannotL,ebypassedandthatmerepublicationofanotification'
without establish ing compliance ol the mandatory procedural
requirements, cannot confer validity upon the same'
56.Thus,ithastobeconcludedthatthemandatoryprocedureunderthe
provisions of the \ilaqf Act, 1954, before issuance of the notification has
not been comPlied with.
"
Accordingll , this issue is answered'
Issue No.5:-
58.Inviewc,ftheaforesaiddiscussion,therelianceplacedbythe
leamed Standing rlounsel for the Waqf Board on various
judgments does
not advance the czLse of the waqf Board. None of the decisions relied
upon
by leamed Stan ling Counsel for Waqf Board dispensed with the
requirement of establishing that the statutory procedure preceding
the
impugned notificlrtion was actuall.v followed The burden was upon the
Waqf Board, beirg the authorit-',- seeking to sustain the notification, to
place the relevant records/material papers before this Court evidencing that
i8
LNA, J
fi/PNo.35945 of2025
there is compliance of the procedure contemplated under the Act, but, it
failed to do so, thereby, rendering the impugned notification unsustainable.
59.
For the aforesaid reasons and discussion, and in the light of the
judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court referred to supra, and further,
having regard to the failure of the Waqf Board to establish compiiance
with the mandatory statutory procedure preceding the impugned
notification, this Writ Petition deserves to be allowed.
60.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is allowed and the impugned
Gazelte Notification No.46-A, daled 20.12.2001, insofar as it relates to the
subject properlies of the petitioners, is hereby set aside.
61.
Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed. No
costs
//TRUE COPY//
essrsrflr?n?'3':=rtJffi
\
\
seefioNr oFFtcER
One Fair Copy to the Hon,ble Sri Justice LAXMI NARAYANA ALTSHETW
(For His Lordships kind perusal)
To,
1. 4 LR Copies
The Under Spc1e,tary, Union of lndia, Ministry of Law, Justice and Company
Affairs, New Delhi.
3. The Secretar)', 1",rnnrna Advocates Association, Library, High Court
Buildings, HYdt;rabad.
4. The Principal Secretary, Revenue Department, Telangana Secretariat, The
State of Telang;ana, HYderabad.
5. The Executive officer, Telangana state waqf Board, Razak ltzlanzil, opp.
Public Gardenr;, Nampally, Hyderabad
6. The District Ccllector, Medak District
7. The Revenue l)ivisional officer, Toopran Revenue Division, Medak District.
8. The Tahsildar, Toopran l\/andal, lVledak District
9. One CC to SRI JALLI NARENDAR, Advocate IOPUCI
10,One CC to SRI FARHAN AZAI/ KHAN, SC FOR TELANGANA STATE
WAQF BOARD, Advocate [OPUC]
11.TWo CCs to CiP FoR REVENUE, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad [OJT]
1 2. Two CD CoPie,s
Ay PVL
TKS
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1ilA912026
1 H E STA
ORDER
WP.No.35945 of 2025
o
L,
1B SEP zffi
D;SPAT
ALLOWINGTHE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
$ 4
C
tS
$b
o
.\,
t'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review