Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
:--
[ 33021
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR T'HE STATE OF
TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE SEVENTEENTH DAY
OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SX
'-""
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SR! .IT'STICE K.
Syed Riyasath pasha.
SARATH
F
S/o.
pc No 1e2, R/o H No l;r, p;''i;iilii;A'B#,b:,y;:J,f.l;3,:&#r,;S,:.rl!iars,
I
AND
' *:;8,"'"?ili513::f,'r53*#rits Principar Secretary, Home Department,
2. The Director General of police, Government
of Telangana, Hyderabad.
3. The Deputy lnspector General of police, Karimnagar.
4. The Commissioner of police, Siddipet.
'irghffa[:Blil:,::siI"",.[i?ffi li:xru:H,.?mll:,T5j,ld*epbyts
RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Articre 226 0f the constitution
circumstances stated in the affidavit
pleased to issue a writ, order
of lndia praying that in the
fired therewith, the High court may be
or direction more particurarry one in
of Mandamus, declaring the impugned
extending the same benefit
the nature of writ
action of the respondents 2 to
4, in not
as extended to other simirarry situated
persons,
petitioners in W.p.No.3091l
ot .2O22, dt 26tO3t2O24 and further
amended rure issued vide G'o.Ms.No.19,
though petitioner was serected
transfer vide proceedin gs dt
applying the
dt o6to2t2o18,to the case of petitioner
as per the notification issued for
14t1112016 i.e. much prior
further appointment by transfer
appointment by
to the amended rure and
of petitioner against vaerncy of porice
I
constabre('civir) in paner year 2014 - 2015 and
seniority ard promotion of petitioner as illegat,
2o1s - 2016, thereby depriving
arbitrary and further action in not
slating the petitioner for Pre-promotional rraining,
0911212024, or any other as highly illegal,
scheduled to commence from
arbitrary and violative of Artictes 14 and
16 of the cr>nstitution of tndia, consequently
direct the respondents to consider the
case of pelitioner for promotion to the post of Head
inspector(civil) in A.P Police(Civil) Sub-ordinate
constable/Assistant sub-
Seryice, by extending the same
benefit as extended to other similarly situated persons,
W.P. No.309't 7 of 2022, dt Z6tO3t2O24.
petitioners in
|.A.NO:1 OF 2024
Petitiorr Under section 151 cPC p;aying
that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support cf the petition, the High
court may be pleased to direct
the responderts to allow the petitioner for Pre-promotional
scheduled on 09/12t2024 to 19t01t2025, or any
rraining which is
other dates for police constables
(civil) fit to ar:t as Head constables(civil) for G
weeks, communicated through
Radio Messiage/Fax f\ressage issued vide proceedings
course/1 02112024, dt 20t11t2024, pending disposar
No.A1lppr
of the writ petition.
Counsel for ther petitioner : SRI G.V.SHIVAJI
counsel for the Respondents : AGp FoR SERVTCES (HOME)
The Court mader the foltowing ORDER
I
I
I
t
I
I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SARATH
WRIT PETITION No.3471O OF 2024
Datez L7.O2.2O26
Between:
Syed Riyasath Pasha.
Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangar.a, Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Home Department & (4) others.
...Respondents
ORDER:
Heard Sri G.V.Shivaji, learned Counsel for the petitioner and
learned Assistant Government Pleader for Sen'ices-Home appearing
for the respondents. Perused the material available on record.
2.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that the issue
involved in this Writ Petition is squarely covered by the common
order passed by this Court in W.P.Nos.30917 and 31353 of 2022
dated 26.03.2024 artd requested to follow the sarrre order for giving
bene{it to the petitioner for appointment by transfer, for the
vacancies of the years 2ol4-15 and 2oL5-16 and granting seniority
and prornotion of Head constable/Assistant Sub-lnspector
Telanganer police (civil) Sub-ordinate Service
by giving benefits as to
tlre similar persons in w.p.Nos.3o917 and 31353
3'
of 2022.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits
that the
said comrnon order passed by this court has attained
finarity and
the respordent authorities arso implemented the said
ordei.s and
requested this Court to pass a similar order in this
4.
Writ petition also.
on the other hand, lear-ned Assistant Government pleader
services-Home did not dispute the submission
.
(civil) in
made by the lear,ed
counsel fclr the petitioner with regard to disposal
of w.p.Nos. 3ogr1
and 31353 of 202'2 and reouested to pass appropriate
5.
for
orders.
Iir vie'*' of the submissions made by both sides, this writ
Petition is rellow'ed b-v clirecting the respondents
to foilow the common
<rrder passed by this court in w.p.Nos.3o9rr
and,31353 of 2022
dated 26.02.2024 and the respondents are further
directed to grant
seniority a,d prclmotio' to the petitioner by considering
the case of
the petiti'rner for thc promotion to the post of
Head
constable/Assistant Sub-Inspector (civil) in Terangana police
Sub-ordine.te Service. ,.vithout taking into acc.unt
dated O6.Oi,,.2AIg.
(civil)
of G.o.Ms.No.19
6.
The Registry is directed to annex copy of the common order
w.P.Nos.30917 and 313s3 of 2022 dated 26.03.2024 arongwith
in
this
order.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this writ petition
shall stand closed. There shall be no order as to costs.
//TRUE COPYII
SD/.A. SREE NIVASA REDDY
STANT RE
SECTION OFFICER
To
The Principal Secretary Home Department,
Buildings, State of
Telangana at Hyderabad
2. The Director Genera! of Police, Government of Tela
3. The Deputy lnspector General of potice , Karim nagar.ngana, Hyderabad
4. The Commissioner of police, Sidd ipet
5. The Chairman, Te langa na State Level Police Recruitment Board (rsLPRB),
O/o. Director G eneral of Police, Government of Tela ngana, Hyde rabad.
6. Two CC's to G P FOR HOME, High Court for the State of Telangana
at
Hyderabad .(o UT)
7. One CC to SRI G.V.SHIVAJI, Advocate [OpUC]
8. Two CD Copies
SA
BS
q
HIGH C}OURT
DATEDIlT 10212026
.-t
i',..8
: i;3I5
ORDER
WP.No.il4710 of 2024
l
I
ALLOWING THE W.P
'
i
I
:
i
I
I
:
I
WITHOUT COSTS.
L:)
..{.
0 J i,ifii 202[
i:)
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI
[I.P.Nos. gO9L7
31353 of 20t22
COMMON ORDER:
In both these writ petitions, the petitioners are seeking a
writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in
applying the amended Rule 10(ii) of Telangana Police (Civil)
Subordinate Service Rules issued vide G.O.Ms.No.19, dated
O6.O2.2OL8 to the petitioners though their appointment by
transfer is within 10% quota against the vacancies of the year
2OL4 to 2018 i.e., prior to amendment, as illegal, arbitrar5r, as
they are depriving seniority and promotions to the petitioners
and consequently to declare that the petitioners seniority
cannot be effected by virhre of Amendment issued in
G.O.Ms.No.19, dated 06.02.2018 and to grant all consequential
benefits and to pass such other order or orders in the interest of
justice.
2.
Brief facts leading to the filing of the present writ
petition are that some of the petitioners were initially appointed
as Police Constables (A.P.Special Police Battalion) and thereafter
appointed by transfer as Police Constables (Armed Reserve) and
further by transfer as Police Constables (Civil) and some of them
TrD,,
W.P.Ilor-3O9r7 & 3r3ig olt 2U2Z
were initially appointed as Police Constable in Armed Reserve of
Andhnr Pradesh Police Subordinate Service and thereafter
appointed by transfer/conversion as Police Constables (Civil). It
is subrnitted that there is another police service called Andhra
Prades h Special Police Battalions (APSp) governed by the
A.P.Police (Special Police battalions) vide G.O.Ms.No.69 Home
(Police-D), dated O7.04. 1997. Tlne police constables of ApSp
have <:hannel of appointment by transfer into A.p.police
Subordinate Service Rules, 1959, upto 4Oo/o of the cadre
strength in constable (Armed Reserve/SpL/CAR) under Rules of
1959. It is submitted that petitioners herein were called to
submit their willingness for appointment by transfer as police
Constables (CMl) within 10% quota meant for Armed Reserve
categoq/ in the State of Telangana. The petitioners have
submitted their willingness and they were appointed by transfer
as Police Constables (Civil) on various dates during the months
of Junr:, July, August and October, 2018 and have been
working as Police Constables (Civil) ever since. It is submitted
that in,:he meantime, the G.O.Ms.No.19, dated 06.O2.201g has
been issued amending the Rule 10(ii) of Telangana (Civil)
Subordi:nate Rule-1999, by way of substitution, substituting the
earlier llule with the amendment as extracted below i.e., the
TMD,J
W.P.Nos.3O977 & 31353 ot2Ut2
seniority in respect of the Police Constable (Civil) (Men)
appointed by transfer (conversion) from Police Constable's
(AR/SAR CPL) (Men) shall be fixed as follows:
"shall be given a weightage of one year for every completed
two years of service rendered as PC(AR/SAR CPL) (Men), subject
to a maximum of seven years."
3.
It is submitted that though the above amendment
was issued after submission of willingness by the petitioners
herein, none of the petitioners were put on notice or informed
about the amendment of the Rule and without even mentioning
the said G.O.Ms.No.19, dated 06.02.2018, conversion orders
were issued appointing the petitioners as Police Constables
(Civil) and since they were not aware that the seniority will be
counted only from the date of appointment by transfer as Police
Constables (Civil), they have joined the post of Police Constables
(Civil) and. have been working for the past four years. It is
submitted that the petitioners came to know only when the
provisional seniority list was issued by the respondents that
they are getting the weightage as per the G.O.Ms.No.19, dated
06.02.2018 and not the seniority from the date of their initial
appointment as Police Constables (APSP) or Armed Resenre,
TX4,'
W.P.t{o..3O9r7 & SrZSg of ZOlr2
therefo re, they have made representations to the respondents
on 09.03.2022, but the same has been rejected on the ground
that tht: appointment of petitioners by transfer have taken place
after the issuance of G.O.Ms.No.l9, dated 06.02.2O18 and
therefore, they are covered by its provisions.
4.
[rarned counsel for the petitioners submitted that
the amendment made to G.O.Ms.No.19, dated 06.02.2018, was
challenged before this Court in W.P.No.4636 of 2O18 and batch
and vide judgment dated 25.01.2022 this Court was pleased to
hold th,rt the vested right of seniority from the date of
appointnlent in the Armed Reserve Police Constables cannot be
taken arvay vide the amendment and therefore, the Armed
Reserve l?olice Constables, after being appointed by transfer as
Police Cc,nstables (Civil), shall be conferred seniority from the
date of i:nitial appointment in the Armed Reserve. The Court
further held that the said amendment was effective only
prospectirrely.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioners, while
reiteratinSl the above submissions, submitted that the issue is
squarely c overed by the various judgments of this Court as well
as the Andhra Pradesh High Court and that the Hon,ble
Tf
r]
TAD,J
w.P.I{os.3Og77
supreme court has repeatedly held that the rules
& 31353 oti2(n2
of the game
Since the
cannot be changed after the game has begun'
of the petitioners has been obtained prior to the
willingness
amendment of Rule 10 (ii), but the appointments
were made
subsequenttotheamendments,thesaidRulescannotbe
appliedtothepetitionershereinwithoutputtingthepetitioners
on notice of the same.
6.
Learned Special Government Pleader for the
respondents relied' upon' the averments made
in the counter
affidavit and submitted that since the petitioners
have been
appointedtothepostofPoliceConstable(Civil)bytransferafter
the amendment of Rule 10 (ii), the said Rule would
be applicable
andthepetitioners,seniorit5rwasconferredaccordingly.
T.Havingregard'totherivalcontentionsandthe
material on record, this Court finds that the
amendment of the
Rulelo(ii)hasbeenmadeon06'02'2018'Therefore'
to the
undisputedly that can only be made applicable
subsequenttransfers.However,inthiscase,itisseenthatthe
but the willingness
transfers were made after the amendment,
wasobtained.muchpriortotheamendment.Admittedly,the
petitionerswerenotputonnoticeabouttheG.o.Ms.No.19.As
a
L.l
W.P,Nos.BO9I Z& Cr g5g
held by the Honbre supreme court in civil
Appeal No. 9746 of
2071, the rule of the game cannot be changed
after the game
has begun. Having received the options or willingness
petitioners for transfer to the post of police
of the
constable (civil) in
the yea:' 2016, their seniority cannot be changed
consent or without putting them on notice.
";y:;l
without their
The G.o.Ms.No.1g,
is dated 06.02.201g i.e., much rater to the options
exercised. by
the petitioners. Therefore, the amended rule
cannot be made
applicable to the petitioners herein as held
by the Division
Bench of this court in w.p.No.4636 of 2o1g
25.oL-2022. For the sake of ready reference
and batch, dated
relevant paras are
reproduced hereunder:
2' The petitioners before this court who are seruing
in the posts of constabres und.er the Terangana porice
(Chil) are aggrieued. bg the G.O.Ms.No.79,
Ao*. (Legat)
Detrtartment, dated 06.02.201g, issued
bg the State
Gouerrtment bg which the recruitment tales,
known as the
spe'ciat Rules for tLrc Terangana porice (ciuit)
subordinate
Serfice Rules issued. in G.O.Ms.No.S74, Home
(pol.C)
Dep'qfi*.n| dated 14.12.1ggg, rwue been amend.ed..
49. In the considered opinion of this Court,
as the
Recruitment Rures prouid.ed
transfer
onrg to the extent of
for
looti posts, the petitioners at th.e rereuait point
of time
opted for transfer to ciuil police and. they
utouti haue
certainlg receiued promotions bg now in the
parent
orga:'nization. The Amendment in the
Recntitment'Rtres,
i'e., G.O.Ms.No.7g, d.ated. 06.0g.201g has been
introduced.
and for the ftrst time, a uteightage
formula has been
introduced bg the state Gouernment under
the Recruitment
Rules gouerning the
meaning
therebg,
field.,
wipirry the past
-7
TMD,J
W.P.Nos.3O977 & 31353 oJ2O!t2
senioritA and therefore, once a right uthich has accrued in
fauour of the petitioners, cannot be utiped out bg tlrc
impugned Amendment and the Amendment is certainlg not
at all applicable with retrospectiue effect. Tle Etestion of
depriuing the petitioners bg making the Amendment
applicabte with retrospectiue effect does not arise.
Therefore, this Court is of the considered opinion that alt
those constables uho haue come prior to 06.02.2078 are
certainlg entitled for grant of senioritg and all tlwse
corxtables uho haue come on transfer after 06.02.2018
shallbe gouernedbg t?rc Amended Recruitment Rules.
7l\. Further in the case of P.Brahma Sai vs. The State
of Andhra Pradesh in W.P.No.45816 of 2018, the Division
Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in paras 11 & 12 are
held as under:
11. h is settled principle of laut, as laid doutn in tlrc aboue
refened judgments, cited bg the learned counsel for the
petitioners, that the rules of tlrc game cannot be changed in the
middle and, in the instant case, the respondent authoities
follouted the said rule in breach. It is also pertinent to note, in
this contert, that in th.e letter, dated 20.01.2017, addressed bg
the second respondent herein to the State Gouernment, in
unnumbered. paragraph No.3 of ttrc last page of the said letter,
tlle second respondent expressed his opinion that it is
desirable to entrust all future recruitments of Hortiadture
Officers to the APPSC but euentuallg recommended for
entrustment of 36 Horticalture Offrcer posts, including tlrc
posfs notified uide notification, dated 01.09.2016, to t?rc
APPSC and all future recruitmenls also to tlrc APPSC. In this
context, it utould be appropriate to refer to certain paragraph's
in the said letter of tlrc second respondent, uthich utould read
as under:
"As could be seen from the aboue, the 15 marks
being autarded for the expeience has become a crucial
factor and mag change tlrc forfimes of the candidates
for the post of Hortianlture Officers. Moreouer, this is an
E
TAD,J
W.P.Nos.3O977 & AI353 of 2O22
appointment in the department on perrnanent basis.
l"herefore, the selection slnuld be based on merit of the
candidates.
In the present sAstem, the candidate utith lesser
nrerit, ofien getting an edge of aduantage ouer the
candidates with higher mertt because of the weightage
a.llouted for experience and senioritg. The candidates
t,tith higher meit are lefi out due to lack of uteightage
ntarks. Further, the expeience so rendered is either
p'urelg on outsourcing basis of contract basis and for
such appointments, no rational selection procedure or
nterit is follouted. Therefore, merit candidates should
not be depriued of the benefit of a fair chance of
selectionfor utant of experience.
Accordinglg, through uaious notifications (91)
posfs of Hortianlture Olficers were alreadg filled in the
Ltepartment. At present, qut of the total sanctioned
posts of (territoial) posts of Horticulture Officers in the
Ltepartment, 36 posts are uacant.
Therefore, fiUing up of (3Q Homculhre Officer
posfs uacant as on date mag be entntsted to APPSC
and all fuhre recnitments shall be done by the
APPSC'.
12. It is uery much obuious from a reading of the aboue
portion of the letter of the second respondent that he expressed
cert,tin possibilities of change of fortunes because of
stipiiation of certain Etalifications in the notification. In the
con:;idered opinion of this Court, tlrc said assumptions and
pres;umptions cannot be the basis and foundation for the
respsnQsllts herein to change the rules of the game in the
mid,Tle of th.e process of selection.
7121. Further in W.P.NI.L129I of 2021 and batch, the
Andhra Pradesh High court has also considered the case of the
persons who have given options prior to the amendment and
TM4,'
w.P.NoE.3O977 & 31353 of 2(n2
were appointed subsequent to amendment and has held as
under
34. In uieut of the law laid down in the judgments
cited bg the learned counsel for the utrit petitioners,
refened to supra, in the preceding paragraphs, the said
contention of the learned Special Gouernment Pleader and
thp leamed counsel for the unofficial respondents in
W.P.No.1O593 of 2022 is liable to be rejected. The fact
remains that, except the issuance of the appointment
orders, the rest of the process came to an end by the time
the amendment came into force. It is a settled and utell
established principle of laut that th.e rules of the game
cannot be changed in the middle of the game. In this
context, it mag also be pertinent to note that, uhen a
similar amendment utas made bg the State of Telangana
uide G.O.Ms.No.19 dated 06.02.2018, the aggrieued filed a
batch of Writ Petitions uide W.P.No.4636 of 2O18 and batch
before the High Court for the State of Telangana. A Diuision
Bench of the High Court for t?rc State of Telangana, while
categoicallg lwlding that a ight, uthich has accrued,
cannot be utiped out bg amending the stahtte when tlrc
applicabilitA of th.e stafiite is not in retrospectiue effect and
thgt the State Gouernment u.tas not able to point out the
public interest inuolued in the matter, held that tl13
constables, utlrc came on transfer afier 06.02.2018, utere
required to be gouerned bg the amended recruitment Rules.
In the case on hand, the realitg remains that, as mentioned
supra, the process of recruitment, by transfer of the utrit
petitioners started anterior to the impugned amendment. It
is eEnllg true that the wit petitioners submitted th.eir
willingness for being posted as Police Constables (Ciuil)
much anteior to the impugned amendment.
35. Since the utrit petitioners, admittedlg, applied in
terms of the notiftcation issued under the unamended R:.tle
and as th.eg etqressed willingness for being appointed as
Police Constables (Auil) in terms of the unamended Rtie, in
tlrc considered opinion of this Court, the action of the
respondent authorities in denying the benefit/right accrued
to th.e utrit petitioner under tlrc unamended Rtle, cannot
T4J
W.P.Ib..3O9r7 &, 3r35A or 2O2!,
stand for judicial scrutiny and the said action is a clear
infraction of the Fundamental Rights guaranteed under
Chapter 3 of the Constitution of India. Admittedlg, the
impugned. amendment came to be canied out bg placing
reliance on the judgment of the Composite High Court of
An:lhra Pradesh in W.P.No.26765 of 2O11 and batcly
d.ai:ed O8.1O.2O13. In the ansidered opinion of this Court,
the respondents grosslg ened in making the said judgment
as the basis as fhe issues in the said batch of Writ
Petitions would not relate to the subjec.t category of posts.
In the considered opinion of this Court, the impugned
anr'.end.ed Rule cannot be made applicable to the cases of
the petitioners.
8.
In view of the above, both the writ petitions are
allowed. There shall be no order as to costs.
9.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in these
writ petitions, shall stand closed.
Date: 126.o8.2o24
bak
JUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review