Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
$
%
!
$
&
"#
% &''''
(#
$
)
#
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
#
*
))
*
#
)
)"
*
"
* "
"
*
& '''
+
*
#
))
& & '
"!
)
#
#
#
%
-2-
,
))
"!
#
-
(
#
& & '
$
*
#
#
*
#
"
)
*
#
)
++
)
)
-
%
)
)
#
.
)
,
++
)
+.
#
#
##
*
+
#
) )
#
#
)
#
'
)
)
*
#
)
/
,
#
#
#
0123 4012503 6785904 :72 ;<0 =0;>;>7502
012503
33>;>7514
7?025@05;
;7 1660=; 57;>60 :72 209=75305;
3?761;0 >9 3>206;03
012503 6785904
-3-
2>
515;<
209=75305;
+
,1<1A>2312 >9 3>206;03 ;7 1660=; 57;>60 :72
<0 =20905; =0;>;>75 >9 :>403 BC ;<0 =0;>;>7502
900D>5A ;<0 :7447E>5A 204>0:9
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
*
!
,
()
+
; >9 ;<0 6190 7: 4012503 6785904 :72 ;<0
=0;>;>7502 ;<1; ;<0 4153 B012>5A
1?04>
C
' 7: *>441A0
84412
>312 >9 ;<0 15609;214 =27=02;C 7: =0;>;>7502 ;7;144C
@01982>5A
16209
' A85;19 153 >5 ;<0 91>3 4153 ;<0
-4-
"1251;1D1
789>5A
16F8>203
7123 16F8>203 +
'
'
16209
A85;19
A85;19.
>312
#74C;06<5>6
7440A0 16F8>203 '
16F8>9>;>759
;7;14 4153 E<>6< 20@1>503 >5 ;<0 91>3
58@B02 >9 '+ 16209 '
A85;19
16209 153 1:;02 144 ;<790
C
; >9 :82;<02 675;05303 ;<1;
>5 ;<0 :1@>4C =12;>;>75 ;<0 91>3 20@1>5>5A 4153 7: '+ 16209
'
A85;19 <19 67@0 ;7 ;<0 9<120 7: =0;>;>7502 153 )72@
' 153 =<73> 9D0;6< >99803 >9 >5 ;<0 51@0 7: ;<0
=0;>;>7502 153 166723>5A4C
;<0 51@0 7: =0;>;>7502 E19
05;0203 >5 ;<0 206723 7: 2>A<;9
; >9 :82;<02 675;05303 BC 4012503 6785904 :72
;<0 =0;>;>7502 ;<1; 41539 >5
<>6D=0;
148D
C
'
7: *>441A0
>312 120 144 >5 ;<0 51@09 7: 209=75305;
; >9 ;<0 675;05;>75 7: 4012503 6785904 :72 ;<0
=0;>;>7502 ;<1; 4153 @01982>5A '+ 16209 '
84412
1?04> ?>441A0 >5
7:
C
A85;19 7:
' >9 13G1605; ;7
C
<>6D=0; ?>441A0 B0475A>5A ;7 209=75305;
; >9 :82;<02 9;1;03 ;<1; 209=75305;
9156;>75 7: 41C78; >5 ;<0 4153 B012>5A
C
1==4>03 :72
'
-5-
7: *>441A0
209=75305;
<>6D=0;
>312 ;7 209=75305;
<19 98B@>;;03 1 @1= :72 1==27?14 7: ;<0
41C78; ;7 209=75305;
7 + BC >56483>5A =72;>75 7: ;<0 4153
7: =0;>;>7502 @01982>5A '
13G1605; ;7 4153 >5
&
7 + 153
C
A85;19 >5
C
7 '
; >9 ;<0 675;05;>75 7: 4012503 6785904 ;<1;
209=75305;
>9 57; 675602503 E>;< ;<0 4153 B0475A>5A
;7 ;<0 =0;>;>7502 >5
C
' B8; <19 >5648303 1 =72;>75 7:
;<0 4153 :72 1==27?14 7: ;<0 41C78;
;<1; 209=75305;
7+
; >9 :82;<02 675;05303
E>;<78; ?02>:C>5A ;<0 672206;5099
153 ;28;<:845099 7: ;<0 @1= 98B@>;;03 :72 1==27?14 7: ;<0
41C78; 1==27?03 ;<0 41C78; 153 209=75305;
<19 57E
67@@05603 3>AA>5A @83 ;7E1239 978;<025 9>30 7: ;<0
@1= 153 <19 1;;0@=;03 ;7 0562716<
=0;>;>7502
C
' 7: ;<0
0560 380 ;7 ;<0 315A02 618903 ;7 ;<0 4>:0 7:
;<0 209>305;9
0=8;C
7@@>99>7502 BC ;1D>5A 57;0 7: ;<>9
3>206;03 1 982?0C ;7 B0 675386;03 153 20=72; ;7 B0
98B@>;;03 E<>6< E19 98B@>;;03 166723>5A4C 19 =02 ;<0
@1= E<>6< 9<7E9 ;<1; ;<020 >9 15 0562716<@05; 7: '
-6-
A85;19 7: 4153 > 0 +& A85;19 7: 4153 13G1605; ;7
;<0 4153 >5
C
7: 209=75305;
4153 13G1605; ;7 ;<0 4153 >5
C
A85;19 7:
; >9 ;<0 A2>0?1560 7: =0;>;>7502 ;<1; 209=75305;
7 + <19 1==27?03 ;<0 41C78; @1= 7: 209=75305;
209=75305;
7:
<19 9;12;03 :056>5A E72D >5 ;<0 419; E00D
6;7B02 +'+& >5 ;<0 4153 >5
C
' 7: ;<0 =0;>;>7502
<020:720
;<0 =0;>;>7502 <19 @130 15 1==4>61;>75 ;7
209=75305;
7 + :72 6156044>5A ;<0 41C78; @1= >5 :1?782 7:
209=75305;
@05;>75>5A 144 ;<0 >440A14>;>09 153 ;<0
0562716<@05; @130 BC 209=75305;
09=>;0 E<>6< 209=75305;
>5 ;<0 91>3 4153
7 + <19 57; ;1D05 15C 16;>75
75 ;<0 1==4>61;>75 :>403 BC ;<0 =0;>;>7502
0560 =0;>;>7502
B0>5A 1AA2>0?03 BC ;<0 >516;>75 7: 209=75305;
7 + <19
1==2716<03 ;<>9
782;
.
"8@12
2>
782; 900D>5A >5384A0560 7: ;<>9
4012503
05>72
785904
2>
@00;
09<=1530 1==012>5A 75 B0<14: 7: 4012503 6785904
515;<
,1<1A>2312 :72 209=75305;
?0<0@05;4C
675;0539 ;<1; ;<0 =20905; =0;>;>75 >9 57; @1>5;1>51B40 >5
-7-
41E 72 75 :16;9 :72 ;<0 201975 ;<1; 0?05 166723>5A ;7 ;<0
=0;>;>7502
*>441A0
;<0 4153 B012>5A
<>6D=0;
148D
C
79 '
7:
>312 >9 >5 ;<0 51@0 7: 209=75305;
153 ;<0 91@0 >9 57; 3>9=8;03
; >9 754C ;<0 A2>0?1560
7: ;<0 =0;>;>7502 ;<1; >5 4153 B012>5A
C
' =72;>75 7:
>; <19 B005 0562716<03 BC 209=75305;
:72 E<>6< 1
20=20905;1;>75 >9 A>?05 BC ;<0 =0;>;>7502 ;7 ;<0 675602503
18;<72>;>09 ;7 ;1D0 16;>75 :72 20@7?14 7: ;<0 0562716<@05;
E<>6< >9 57; 16;03 8=75
91@0 <0 >9 B0:720 ;<>9
<020:720 B0>5A 1AA2>0?03 BC ;<0
782;
==1205;4C >; >9 675;05303 BC 4012503
6785904 :72 209=75305;
05>72
;<1; >5 986< 61909 E<020 ;<0
=0;>;>7502 >9 @1D>5A 15 1;;0@=; ;7 9<7E ;<1; ;<020 >9 15
1440A03 0562716<@05; 1 =0;>;>75 85302
++
7: ;<0
2;>6409 ++
759;>;8;>75 7: 53>1 E7843 57; B0 989;1>51B40
153 @1>5;1>51B40
; >9 :72 ;<0 =0;>;>7502 ;7 1==2716< ;<0
G82>93>6;>7514
782; ;7 >5?7D0 ;<0
>?>4
>?>4 20@03C ;7 ;1D0
50609912C 16;>75 72 7B;1>5 50609912C 723029 :27@ ;<0
>?>4
782; 1:;02 =27?>5A ;<0 :16; ;<1; 15C 0562716<@05; @130
-8-
BC 209=75305;
<020:720 4012503
>5 ;<0 4153 B0475A>5A ;7 <>@
05>72
785904 :82;<02 675;0539 ;<1; 144
;<090 F809;>759 120 3>9=8;03 F809;>759 7: :16;
E>44 <1?0 ;7 B0 306>303 >5 1 6>?>4
<0 91@0
782; BC 1 =27=02 ;2>14
0204C :72 ;<0 201975 ;<1; ;<0 =0;>;>7502 <19 67@0 B0:720
;<>9
782; ;7 91C ;<1; 209=75305;
<19 0562716<03
8=75 ;<0 =0;>;>7502/9 4153 61557; B0 989;1>503 19 57
@1;02>14 >9 =41603 B0:720 ;<0
782; ;7 9<7E ;<1; ;<0 4153
7: =0;>;>7502 >9 0562716<03 BC 209=75305;
; >9 :82;<02
675;05303 BC 4012503
05>72
785904 ;<1; >; >9 1497 57; 640124C 9;1;03 >5 ;<0 =0;>;>75 19
;7 E<05 209=75305;
>: 1; 144 <19 0562716<03 15C
=72;>75 7: ;<0 4153 7: =0;>;>7502 >5
C
;<0 =0;>;>7502 >9 57; 675602503 E>;<
<020:720 4012503
05>72
C
' 19 13@>;;034C
79 '
785904 :82;<02 675;0539 ;<1;
@0204C >5?7D>5A ;<0 E2>; G82>93>6;>75 >5 ;<090 D>539 7: 6>?>4
@1;;029
;<>9
782; 5003 57;
1; ;<0 >59;1560 7: ;<0
=0;>;>7502
=199 15 72302 :72 1 E2>; 7: @1531@89 72 1
3>206;>75
;7
;<0
18;<72>;>09
;7
6759>302
;<0>2
-9-
20=20905;1;>75
<020:720
<0 900D9 3>9@>9914 7: ;<>9
=0;>;>75 19 >; >9 57; @1>5;1>51B40 B0:720 ;<>9
'
012503
33>;>7514
7?025@05;
98==72;9 ;<0 12A8@05; 7: 4012503
05>72
782;
3?761;0 1497
785904
0 1497
98B@>;9 ;<1; E<05 ;<020 >9 3>9=8;03 F809;>75 7: :16; ;<0
=0;>;>7502 E>44 <1?0 ;7 1==2716< ;<0
09;1B4>9< <>9 2>A<; B0:720 ;<0
9866099:84 05:7260 >;
>?>4
>?>4
782; 153
782; 153 >: <0 >9
; >9 1497 675;05303 ;<1; 57 @1;02>14
>9 =41603 ;7 9<7E 15C 4153 7: =0;>;>7502 >9 0562716<03
<>9
782; 85302
2;>6409 ++
153 ++
7: ;<0
759;>;8;>75
7: 53>1 E7843 57; <1?0 ;<0 =7E02 ;7 3014 E>;< 3>9=8;03
F809;>759 7: :16; 0?05 >: 9;1;0 19 1 =12;C >9 1440A03 ;7 B0
>5?74?03
<1?0 <0123 4012503 6785904 :72 ;<0 =0;>;>7502
4012503
05>72
33>;>7514
7?025@05;
3?761;0 :72 209=75305;
4012503 6785904 :72 209=75305;
785904
2>
@00; "8@12
4012503 6785904 :72 209=75305;
7 + 153 4012503
09<=1530 75 B0<14: 7:
- 10 -
+
; >9 9005 ;<1; 0?05 166723>5A ;7 ;<0 =0;>;>7502
<0 <19 13@>;;03 ;<1; ;<0 4153 B012>5A
B0475A ;7 209=75305;
E>;< 4153 B012>5A
C
C
79 '
<0 =0;>;>7502 >9 675602503
' 7:
84412
1?04>
E<020 <0
1440A09 ;<1; ;<020 >9 15 0562716<@05; 7: 1 602;1>5 0H;05;
7: 4153 BC 209=75305;
E<>6< <0 641>@9 ;7 <1?0
9068203 BC E1C 7: 1 :1@>4C =12;>;>75 ;7 15 0H;05; 7: '+
16209 '
A85;19 78; 7: E<>6< '
;7 <1?0 B005 0562716<03
A85;19 >9 1440A03
5 ;<0 20@1>5>5A =72;>75 ;<0
=0;>;>7502 >9 641>@>5A ;7 <1?0 =799099>75
==1205;4C 0?05
>5 ;<0 20=20905;1;>75 @130 BC ;<0 =0;>;>7502 1;
550H820
) E<>6< >9 15 1==4>61;>75 A>?05 :72 61560441;>75 7: 41C78;
1==27?14 7: 4153 >5
C
148D 153
>312 ;<020 >9 57 @05;>75 7: <7E 153
>9;2>6;
79 '
7: *>441A0
<>6D=0;
E<05 ;<0 1440A03 =72;>75 7: 4153 >9 0562716<03
<0 =0;>;>7502 >5 ;<0 91>3 20=20905;1;>75 <19
1497 57; 3>9=8;03 ;<0 7E5029<>= E>;< 20A123 ;7
7: 209=75305;
C
79 '
<020 1497 <0 <19
@05;>7503 E>;< 20A123 ;7 <>@ B0>5A 7E502 7:
C
7 '
- 11 -
@01982>5A ;7 15 0H;05; 7: '+ 16209 '
A85;19
>9 754C
A2>0?1560 >9 E>;< 20A123 ;7 ;<0 @1=
>5 E<>6< ;<020 >9
602;1>5 0562716<@05; 20:406;03 BC ;<0 18;<72>;>09 E<>40
A215;>5A 9156;>75 ;7 209=75305;
A2>0?1560 ;<1; 209=75305;
>5 ;<0 A8>90 7: A21BB>5A
<020:720 >; >9 ;<0
;<0 4153 7: ;<0 =0;>;>7502 <19 0562716<03 1 =72;>75 7: ;<0
4153 >5
C
>312
7 3768@05;9 120 =2738603 BC ;<0 =0;>;>7502 >5 ;<>9
782; ;7
' 153
7:
84412
1?04>
148D 153
>9;2>6;
9<7E ;<1; ;<020 >9 15C 0562716<@05; BC
209=75305;
>5 ;<0 =72;>75 7:
C
' B0475A>5A ;7
;<0 =0;>;>7502
<0 =0;>;>7502 <19 57; 305>03 ;<0 7E5029<>=
7: ;<0 4153 7:
C
'
7: 209=75305;
>5
E<>6< ;<0 9156;>75 =415 <19 B005 >99803 BC ;<0 675602503
18;<72>;>09 1;
550H820
; >9 B1903 75 ;<0 91>3
9156;>75 =415 ;<1; ;<0 =0;>;>7502 <19 21>903 ;<0 >9980 7:
0562716<@05;
5 A7>5A ;<278A< ;<0 @1;02>149 =41603 153 ;<0
A2>0?1560 7: ;<0 =0;>;>7502 1==1205;4C >; >9 0?>305; ;<1;
;<0
=0;>;>7502
>9
641>@>5A
1440A03
0562716<@05;
BC
- 12 -
209=75305;
>5 =72;>75 7: ;<0 4153 >5
C
' B1903
75 ;<0 982?0C 20=72; 153 ;<0 @1= 98B@>;;03 BC
82?0C72
<020:720 144 ;<090 19=06;9 120 3>9=8;03 F809;>759 7: :16;
E<>6< 61557; B0 A750 >5;7 BC ;<>9
782; >5 ;<0 E2>;
G82>93>6;>75 85302
7: ;<0
7: 53>1
2;>6409 ++
153 ++
759;>;8;>75
<05 ;<020 >9 1 =2>?1;0 3>9=8;0 7: 6>?>4 >5 51;820
B0;E005 ;E7 =12;>09 7?02 1 =12604 7: 4153 153 ;<0 91@0 >9
57; 13@>;;03 >; >9 1 3>9=8;03 F809;>75 7: :16; E<>6< E>44
<1?0 ;7 B0 13?02;03 >5 1 =27=02 6>?>4 3>9=8;0 ;2>14
=12;>09 E>44 <1?0 ;7 1==2716< ;<0
>?>4
<0
782; ;7 09;1B4>9<
153 =27?0 ;<0 91@0 >5 ;<0 @15502 D57E5 ;7 41E
; >9 1497
57; :72;<67@>5A 153 64012 19 ;7 E<05 ;<0 0562716<@05;
<19
;1D05
=4160
E<0;<02
1;
;<020
>9
15C
0562716<@05; 153 >: 97 E<0;<02 ;<0 4153 B0475A9 ;7
=0;>;>7502
7 ;<0 F809;>75 E>;< 20A123 ;7 4>@>;1;>75 E>44
1497 <1?0 ;7 B0 A750 >5;7 BC ;<0
B0 05;02;1>503 BC ;<>9
&
<0
75/B40
>?>4
782; E<>6< 61557;
782; >5 ;<0 E2>; G82>93>6;>75
=0H
782; >5 ;<0 6190 7:
- 13 -
>5
'(')
**+,)
% '(')&
4 4
%-& .
,/'-'01
<19 <043 1; =121A21=<
19 85302
/
#
!
#
,
'
!
!
!
(
3 .
!
!
(
!
!
!
!
!
!
-
5 ;<0 =20905; 6190 75 <153 ;<0 =0;>;>7502 >9
900D>5A 1 E2>; 7: @1531@89 1A1>59; 1 =2>?1;0 209=75305;
>5 E<790 :1?782 1 =415 <19 B005 9156;>7503 E<>6<
- 14 -
0?05 166723>5A ;7 =0;>;>7502
13@>;;034C
B0475A9 ;7
=2>?1;0 209=75305;
>9 57; @1>5;1>51B40
5 ?>0E 7: ;<0 1:72091>3 G83A@05; 7:
;<0
75/B40
=0H
1==2716<03 ;<0 6>?>4
782;
<020:720 ;<0 =20905; =0;>;>75
;<0 20@03C E7843 B0 ;7 <1?0
782;
5302 ;<0 6>268@9;15609
=199 ;<0 :7447E>5A
>
<0 E2>; =0;>;>75 >9
ix.
; >9 50034099 ;7 @05;>75 ;<1; ;<>9
782; <19 57; 0H=209903 15C 7=>5>75
75 ;<0 @02>;9 7: ;<0 @1;;02
%
&
$
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review