Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 13 March 2026
Pronounced on: 01 July 2026
+
W.P.(C) 13600/2019
SHRI KANT AND ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Ankur Chhibber, Mr.
Anshuman Mehrotra, Mr. Nikunj Arora, Ms.
Muskan Dutta and Mr. Amrit Koul, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Ripudaman Bhardwaj,
CGSC with Mr. Amit Kumar Rana, Advs.
Mr. Vinod Sawant, Law Officer CRPF and
INSP Athurv and Mr. Ramniwas Yadav,
CRPF
Ms. Pratima N. Lakra, CGSC along with Mr.
Vinod Sawant, law officer CRPF Mr. Atharv
Midda, Law Officer
+
W.P.(C) 13607/2019
SYED MOHD ZAKI RIZVI AND ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Ankur Chhibber, Mr.
Anshuman Mehrotra, Mr. Nikunj Arora, Ms.
Muskan Dutta and Mr. Amrit Koul, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Ripudaman Bhardwaj,
CGSC with Mr. Amit Kumar Rana, Advs.
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
Mr. Vinod Sawant, Law Officer CRPF and
INSP Athurv and Mr. Ramniwas Yadav,
CRPF
+
W.P.(C) 1945/2020
GURDEEP SINGH MASTANA AND ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Ankur Chhibber, Mr.
Anshuman Mehrotra, Mr. Nikunj Arora, Ms.
Muskan Dutta and Mr. Amrit Koul, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Ripudaman Bhardwaj,
CGSC with Mr. Amit Kumar Rana, Advs.
Mr. Vinod Sawant, Law Officer CRPF and
INSP Athurv and Mr. Ramniwas Yadav,
CRPF
+
W.P.(C) 2612/2020
RAJ KRISHAN GAUR & ORS
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Ankur Chhibber, Mr.
Anshuman Mehrotra, Mr. Nikunj Arora, Ms.
Muskan Dutta and Mr. Amrit Koul, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Vivek Goyal, CGSPC, Mr.
Gokul Sharma, Advs.
Mr. Vinod Sawant, Law Officer CRPF and
INSP Athurv and Mr. Ramniwas Yadav,
CRPF
+
W.P.(C) 767/2020
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
DEVENDRA KUMAR SHARMA
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ankur Chhibber, Mr.
Anshuman Mehrotra, Mr. Nikunj Arora, Ms.
Muskan Dutta and Mr. Amrit Koul, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Vikram Jetly, CGSC with
Ms. Shreya Jetly, Adv.
+
W.P.(C) 912/2020
RAM KANWAR SAINI AND ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Ankur Chhibber, Mr.
Anshuman Mehrotra, Mr. Nikunj Arora, Ms.
Muskan Dutta and Mr. Amrit Koul, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Avshreya Pratap Singh
Rudy, CGSC with Mr. Ankit Khatri, Ms.
Usha Jamnal and Ms. Nyasa Sharma, Advs.
Mr. Nishant Gautam, CGSC with Ms. Kavya
Shukla Adv. Mr. Vineet Negi, Mr. Naman
Sharma, Ms. Theresa, Advs.
+
W.P.(C) 660/2022
RAZA HAIDER AND ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Ankur Chhibber, Mr.
Anshuman Mehrotra, Mr. Nikunj Arora, Ms.
Muskan Dutta and Mr. Amrit Koul, Advs.
versus
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Arti Bansal, CGSC with
Ms. Shruti Goel, Adv.
Mr. Vinod Sawant, Law Officer CRPF and
INSP Athurv and Mr. Ramniwas Yadav,
CRPF
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE OM PRAKASH SHUKLA
%
JUDGMENT
01.07.2026
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1.
These writ petitions involve a similar controversy. They are,
therefore, being decided by this common judgment. For the sake of
convenience, we would refer to the facts and render our decision
treating WP (C) 13600/2019 as the lead case, and would thereafter
apply the principles that we lay down to other writ petitions.
WP (C) 13600/2019 [Shri Kant & ors v. Union of India & Ors.]
A.
The lis and the issues involved
2.
The petitioners seek Non-Functional Financial Upgradation1 in
terms of Office Memorandum2 dated 24 April 2009 issued by the
Department of Personal and Training3. Petitioner 1 claims entitlement
1 "NFFU" hereinafter
2 “OM” hereinafter
3 "DOPT" hereinafter
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
to NFFU with effect from 10 July 2009; Petitioner 2 Dulal Chandra
Dey with effect from 8 July 2007; Petitioner 3 Rizwan Rasul with
effect from 21 June 2007 and Petitioner 4 B.D.S. Chauhan with effect
from 1 January 2006. Petitioners 1 to 3 claim NFFU in the Higher
Administrative Grade4 whereas Petitioner 4 claims NFFU in the
Senior Administrative Grade5. The respondents, on the other hand,
contend that Petitioner 1 was entitled to NFFU with effect from 1
April 2011 and Petitioner 2 with effect from 1 April 2009, and that
they have been granted NFFU from the said dates. Petitioners 3 and 4,
according to the respondents, are not entitled to NFFU.
3.
Though arguments in these writ petitions were heard on
multiple occasions, and we have been taken through a plenitude of
OMs and other executive instructions, at the end of the day, the
controversy has narrowed down to a very limited compass.
4.
The respondents contend that grant of NFFU to any grade,
under the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009, is conditional on that grade
forming part of the promotional hierarchy in the service of the
petitioners. Petitioners 1 to 3 were already in the grade of Inspector
General6 in the CRPF when they staked their claim for NFFU in terms
of the OM dated 24 April 2009. The post of IG was in the SAG.
NFFU was sought, by the said petitioners, in the HAG. The post of
Additional Director General7 was introduced as a HAG-level post in
the promotional hierarchy in the CRPF only on 7 October 2008, and
4 "HAG"
5 "SAG"
6 “IG" hereinafter
7 "ADG" hereinafter
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
the applicable Recruitment Rules8 were amended to that effect only in
July 2009. The respondents’ contention is therefore that, prior to 7
October 2008, none of the first three petitioners could seek NFFU
under the OM dated 24 April 2009.
5.
The RRs, as amended with effect from 7 October 2008, required
30 years’ regular service in Group A with three years’ regular service
as IG for eligibility to promotion as ADG. One year’s relaxation in the
requisite residency period in the feeder grade was allowed by DOPT
OM dated 30 September 2019. The requisite regular service as IG,
which was ordinarily of three years as per the RRs was, therefore,
reduced to two years by application of the OM dated 30 September
2019. Petitioners 1 to 3 were, therefore, according to the respondents,
eligible for NFFU in the HAG, in terms of the OM dated 24 April
2009, only on completion of two years’ regular service in the grade of
IG (apart from 30 years’ regular service in Group A, which, it is not
disputed, all three petitioners possessed). In as much as two years’
regular service as IG in the case of Petitioner 1 expired on 10 July
2010, he was given NFFU in the HAG with effect from 1 April 2011
and, as 2 years regular service as IG in the case of Petitioner 2 expired
on 8 July 2008, he was given NFFU in the HAG with effect from 1
April 2009.
6.
Petitioner 3 superannuated on 30 November 2007, before the
post of ADG, in the HAG, was introduced as a promotional post in the
8 "the RRs" hereinafter
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
RRs. The respondents contend that, therefore, Petitioner 3 would not
be entitled to NFFU in terms of the OM dated 24 April 2009.
7.
Petitioner 4 has been denied NFFU in the SAG on the ground
that he had not undergone the requisite promotional course for
eligibility for promotion as IG till the date of his retirement from
service, as was required by the OM dated 24 April 2009.
8.
The petitioners contend, per contra, that the requirement of the
post, to the scale of which the petitioners were seeking upgradation,
being in the promotional hierarchy in the service, was not envisaged
by the OM dated 24 April 2009, and had been artificially inserted in
para 3(iii)(b) of a subsequent OM dated 30 September 2019 issued by
the Ministry of Home Affairs9. The insertion of this condition, which
was not envisaged in the OM dated 24 April 2009 has, therefore, been
challenged, and quashing of the said para 3(iii)(b) of the MFA OM
dated 30 September 2019 has been sought in the writ petition.
9.
Alternatively, the petitioners contend that the prescribed
eligibility for promotion to the post of ADG in the CRPF was not 30
years’ regular service in Group A with at least three years’ regular
service as IG, as the respondents would contend, but 25 years’ regular
service in Group A with at least one year’s regular service as IG, for
which purpose the petitioners rely on DOPT OMs dated 15 December
2009 and 18 January 2011. There is no dispute that all four petitioners
fulfil the requirement of 25 years’ regular service in Group A. One
9 "MHA" hereinafter
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
year’s regular service as IG was completed by Petitioner 1 on 10 July
2009, by Petitioner 2 on 8 July 2007 and by Petitioner 3 on 21 June
2007 with effect from which dates, according to the petitioners,
Petitioners 1 to 3 would therefore be entitled to grant of NFFU in the
HAG.
10.
In so far as Petitioner 4 is concerned, the petitioners contend
that the DOPT OMs dated 15 December 2009 and 18 January 2011
required the RRs to be amended to provide for Junior Administrative
Grade10 officers with 17 years’ regular service in Group A, of which at
least four years’ regular service had to be in the JAG, as the eligibility
criterion for promotion to the SAG. It is contended that Petitioner 4
had, by 31 March 2006, completed 17 years in Group A, out of which
four years’ regular service was in the JAG and that, therefore,
Petitioner 4 was entitled to NFFU, in terms of the OM dated 24 April
2009, with effect from 31 March 2006.
11.
Thus, only two issues primarily arise for consideration in the
present petitions, viz.,
(i)
whether it was a prerequisite, for being entitled to NFFU
in a particular grade in terms of the DOPT OM dated 24 April
2009, that the said grade had to form part of the promotional
hierarchy in the service; in other words, whether para 3(iii)(b)
of the MHA OM dated 30 September 2019 was legal and valid,
and
10 "JAG" hereinafter
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
(ii)
whether the petitioners are entitled to NFFU, as claimed
by them, in terms of the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009.
B.
Rival Pleadings
I.
Case of the petitioners in the writ petition
12.
Of the four petitioners in this writ petition,
(i)
Petitioner 1 enrolled on 1 December 1971, was promoted
to the rank of IG on 10 July 2008 and to the rank of ADG on 1
April 2011, and superannuated on 30 September 2011,
(ii)
Petitioner 2 enrolled on 15 December 1971, was
promoted as IG on 8 July 2006, as ADG on 7 September 2009
and superannuated on 30 June 2010,
(iii)
Petitioner 3 enrolled on 1 December 1971, was promoted
as IG on 21 June 2006 and superannuated on 30 November
2007 and
(iv)
Petitioner 4 was enrolled on 6 December 1971, was
promoted as DIG on 17 May 2005 and superannuated on 31
December 2007.
13.
Pursuant to the recommendations of the 6th Central Pay
Commission11, the DOPT issued OM dated 24 April 2009, the
entitlement of the petitioners to the benefit of which constitutes the
controversy in this writ petition. The following clauses of the OM are
relevant:
11 "CPC" hereinafter
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
New Delhi, the 24th April, 2009
Office Memorandum
Subject:-
Non-Functional upgradation for Officers of
Organised Group ‘A’ Services in PB-3 and PB-4
***
Consequent on the acceptance of the recommendations of
the 6 Central Pay Commission, the following orders are issued:th
(i)
Whenever an Indian Administrative Services
Officer of the State of Joint Cadre is posted at the Centre to
a particular grade carrying a specific great way in Pay band
3 or Pay Band 4, the officers belonging to backers of
Organised Group A Services that are senior by 2 years or
more and have not so far been promoted to that particular
grade would be granted the same grade on non-functional
basis from the date of posting of the Indian Administrative
Service Officers in that particular grade at the Centre.
(ii)
Grant of higher scale would be governed by the
terms and conditions given in Annex-I.
(iii) Appropriate amendments in the Service Rules may
also be carried out.
*****
2.
Grant of higher scale (i.e. pay band and/or grade pay) under
these instructions would be with effect from 1.1.2006, wherever
due and admissible.
*****
ANNEX I
TERMS AND CONDITIONS FOR GRANT OF HIGHER
PAY SCALE ON NON-FUNCTIONAL BASIS TO
OFFICERS OF ORGANISED GR ‘A’ SERVICES
*****
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
3.
All the prescribed eligibility criteria and promotional norms
including ‘benchmark’ for upgradation to a particular grade pay
would have to be met at the time of screening for grant of higher
pay scale under these orders.
*****
6.
Orders will be issued with the approval of the competent
authority. Grant of higher pay scale on the non-functional basis
would be from the date of posting of the 1st officer belonging to the
particular batch of IAS officer at the Centre.
In case of any delay in the issue of order, financial benefits under
these orders will be given from the due date.
*****
8.
As and when the normal vacancies in the grade arise, the
officer will be considered for regular promotions as per the normal
DPC guidelines, based on the provisions of the recruitment rules.
UPSC will be conducted wherever the rules provide for the same.
However, at the time of promotion, the pay in the grade will not be
fixed again for officers who have been granted upgradation under
these orders.”
14.
Certain officers of the CRPF approached the respondents for
being granted NFFU with effect from the dates when Joint Cadre IAS
officers two batches junior to them were posted at the Centre. The
DIG (Personnel) in the CRPF, vide communication dated 27
September 2012, addressed to one such officer, rejected the request on
the ground that the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009 applied only to
officers of Organized Group A services, appointed under the Central
Staffing Scheme12, and CRPF cadre officers neither belong to an
Organized Group A service, nor were they appointed under the CSS.
Nonetheless, the matter was referred to the MHA for comments.
12 "CSS" hereinafter
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
15.
This led to some of the officers approaching this Court in a
batch of writ petitions, headed by WP (C) 153/201313. These writ
petitions were disposed of, by a Division Bench of this Court, on 3
September 2015, from which we deem it appropriate to reproduce the
following paragraphs:
“2.
During the pendency of these proceedings, vide an order
dated 26.09.2013, the Court directed the respondents to re-examine
the issue regarding grant of NFFU to Group ‘A’ officers of the
Central Reserve Police Force, Border Security Force and IndoTibetan Border Police. However, vide an Office Memorandum (for
short OM) No. F. No. P.I.1/21022-Pers.DA-Pay dated 28.10.2013
issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs, the issue was decided
against the petitioners. Accordingly, the petitioners were given
leave to file amended writ petitions to incorporate these subsequent
events.
3.
Hence, the petitioners seek a writ of mandamus to grant
them, i.e., Executive Group-A officers of CAPFs, the benefit of
NFFU with effect from 01.06.2006, as given to other Officers of
Group-A Service under PB-3 & PB-4, as issued vide Office
Memorandum (OM) dated 24th April, 2009.
4.
The petitioners further pray that they be formally declared
as an Organized Group ‘A’ Service with effect from 01.01.2006
with all consequential benefits. Finally, some of the petitioners
also seek directions for amendment of the Recruitment Rules, i.e.,
CRPF Group-A (General Cadre Officers) Recruitment Rules, 2008
as notified on 10.08.2010 vide Notification No. GSR 679(E) issued
by the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India.
*****
72.
In this case, the Court has been called upon to decide if the
impugned letter dated 31st May 2012 rejecting the grant of NFFU
is arbitrary. Consequently, it has to be decided if the petitioners
would be entitled to NFFU w.e.f 1.1.2006 as has been granted to
Group A Officers in PB-3 and PB-4 vide OM dated 24.04.2009.
*****
13 G.J. Singh v. Union of India
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
84.
The issue of acknowledging the petitioners as OGAS has
been pending for some time like a festering wound. From the
preceding discussion, the Court would note although from the
government records it can clearly be seen that the Petitioners have
over and over again been recognised as OGAS, an element of
obfuscation has been kept alive. It cannot be overemphasised that
in matters relating to the armed forces and the paramilitary/CAPFs
there ought to be clarity and certainty apropos the service benefits
which the forces would be entitled to. An element of greater
dispatch in taking decisions governing their service conditions
would always be requisite. Therefore, to the extent that the OM
dated 19/20.11.2009 and OM dated 28.10.2010 themselves leave
scope for interpretation, it could well be said that there is a level of
arbitrariness in them. The government having repeatedly
acknowledged the Petitioners in their various communications as
belonging to OGAS cannot be allowed to reprobate there from.
85.
In view of the above, the Court is of the view that the
petitioners, i.e., officers in PB-3 and PB-4 in the CAPFs (CRPF in
the present instance) have been categorised under Organised Group
‘A’ Service ever since the year 1986. Hence, the benefits
contemplated by the 6th CPC by way of NFFU to remove disparity
between All India Services and other Organised Central Group ‘A’
Services, ought to be granted to them. Accordingly, the impugned
OM dated 28.10.2010 and all other letters whereby the petitioners'
request for the grant of NFFU was rejected, cannot be sustained
and are hereby quashed.”
Thus, the Division Bench of this Court held the CRPF to be an
Organised Group A service and also held the petitioners before it to
be entitled to NFFU in terms of the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009.
16.
The Union of India challenged the aforesaid judgment dated 3
September 2015 of this Court before the Supreme Court. The
Supreme Court consolidated several writ petitions involving the
issues of entitlement of various services to be treated as Organised
Group A Services and the consequent entitlement of officers in the
said services to the benefit of NFFU in terms of the DOPT OM dated
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
24 April 2009, which came to be decided in Union of India v. Sri
Harananda14. The judgment independently deals with the batches of
Civil Appeals dealing with various services.
17.
The first Civil Appeal decided by the said judgment arose out
of SLP (C) 12393/2013, and dealt with the Railway Protection
Force15. The second batch of appeals decided in the said judgment
included the Civil Appeal arising out of the judgment of the Division
Bench of this Court in G.J. Singh. The following passages from the
judgment of the Supreme Court merit reproduction:
“23.1. At the outset, it is required to be noted that the issue in the
present appeals is non-grant of NFFU to the officers/employees
like the original writ petitioners serving in CRPF. CRPF in the
present case is denied NFFU solely on the ground that CRPF is not
an Organised Group A Service and, therefore, they are denied the
benefits of NFFU as recommended by the 6th Pay Commission as
granted to other services.
*****
23.3. As observed hereinabove, CMPFs are not granted the
benefit of NFFU on the ground that they are not categorised as
Organised Group A Services. As noted hereinabove, it is the case
on behalf of the appellants that, out of six attributes which are
required to be considered for treating and/or considering an
organisation as an Organised Group A Services, CRPF does not
satisfy Attributes (iv) and (vi) and also on the ground that the 6th
Pay Commission did not recommend grant of NFFU to CAPFs.
23.4. Considering the material on record, more particularly, the
Monographs published by the DoPT right from 1986 till date,
CAPFs have been shown to be a part of the Central Group A
Services. CAPFs have been shown as a part of the Central Group
A Services after conducting the exercise of cadre review, etc. by
the DoPT. Therefore, all throughout from 1986 till date, in the
Monographs published by the DoPT, CAPFs have been shown to
14 (2019) 14 SCC 126
15 "RPF" hereinafter
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
be a part of Central Group A Services. Therefore, thereafter it
would not be open for the DoPT not to consider and/or treat the
CAPFs as an Organised Group A Services.
*****
24.
Now, so far as another ground on which CRPF are denied
NFFU that the 6th Central Pay Commission did not grant NFFU to
CAPFs is concerned, it is required to be borne in mind that the
Central Pay Commission, as such, is not authorised to define
“Organised Services” or to grant such status to any service. The
recommendations would be made by the Central Pay Commission
on the basis of the information submitted to it by the various
Departments. It appears from the material on record that right from
1986 onwards, in various Monographs CAPFs were included in the
list of Group A Central Civil Services. The Government took “U”
turn and a stand was taken that CAPFs are not Organised Group A
Central Services and, therefore, on the basis of such a stand, the
Department must have given the information to the Central Pay
Commission and, therefore, the 6th Pay Commission did not
recommend NFFU to CAPFs. Therefore, merely because the 6th
Pay Commission did not recommend to grant NFFU to CAPFs —
Group A Officers in PB-III and PB-IV, the Group A Officers in
PB-III and PB-IV cannot be denied NFFU, which otherwise is
granted to all the Officers of Group A Central Civil Services.
*****
24.2. Considering the aforesaid facts and circumstances and the
objects and reasons of the grant of NFFU as recommended by the
6th Pay Commission, when the High Court has observed and
consequently directed that the officers in PB-III and PB-IV in the
CAPFs are Organised Group A Service and, therefore, entitled to
the benefits recommended by the 6th Pay Commission by way of
NFFU and thereby has directed the appellants to issue a requisite
notification granting the benefits of NFFU as recommended by the
6th Central Pay Commission, it cannot be said that the High Court
has committed any error which calls for the interference by this
Court. We are in complete agreement with the view taken by the
High Court.
25.
In view of the facts and circumstances, the present appeals
arising out of SLPs (Civil) Nos. 35548-554 of 2015 and 13937 of
2016 deserve to be dismissed and are accordingly dismissed. In the
facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to
costs.”
(Emphasis supplied)
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
The Supreme Court, therefore, upheld the entitlement of the CRPF
officers who had initially petitioned this Court and, thereafter, were
respondents before the Supreme Court, both to be entitled to be
regarded as members of an Organised Group A Service as well as to
the benefit of NFFU in terms of the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009.
18.
In compliance with the judgment of the Supreme Court, in so
far as it dealt with members of the RPF, the Ministry of Railways,
vide OM dated 8 April 2019, notified the RPF as an Organised Group
A Service. The Notification also received the concurrence of the
DOPT on 12 April 2019. Following this, the draft RRs of the RPF
were also circulated amongst stakeholders, inviting comments.
19.
On 12 July 2019, the DOPT issued the following OM, also a
consequence of the judgment of the Supreme Court in Harananda:
“Dated 12 July 2019
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject:
Grant of Organised Status of Railway Protection
Force (RPF) and Group ‘A’ Executive Cadres of Central
Armed Police Force (CAPFs)16
*****
The undersigned is directed to refer to the Hon’ble
Supreme Court’s judgement dated 05.02.2019 given in SLP (C)
35545-35554/2015 and SLP (C) No. 12393 of 2013 Re: Organised
Group ‘A’ status to CAPF’s hand RPF.
2.
In compliance of the above mentioned judgement dated
05.02.2019 of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the Ministry of Home
Affairs and Ministry of Railways vide the references cited above,
16 It is not in dispute that the CRPF is also a CAPF.
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
have conveyed the approval of the competent authority to grant of
OGAS status to RPF and 2 Group ‘A’ Executive Cadre Officers of
CAPFs and consequential benefits of NFFU with effect from
01.01.2006 and NFS the at 30% of Senior Duty Post (SDP) with
effect from 06.06.2000 respectively.
3.
The RPF and Group ‘A’ Executive Cadres of the following
CAPFs having been treated as Organised Group ‘A’ Service
(OGAS) by this Department for Cadre review and other related
matters accordingly.
(i)
Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF)
*****”
20.
Despite this, the MHA proceeded to issue, on 30 September
2019, an OM, which contains, inter alia, para 3(iii)(b), with which the
petitioners are aggrieved. The relevant paragraphs of the said OM may
be reproduced as under:
North Block, New Delhi
Dated, the 30th September, 2019
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject:
Grant of Benefits of Non-Functional Financial
Upgradation (NFFU) and Non-Functional Selection Grade (NFSG)
to Group ‘A’ Executive Cadre Officers of CAPFs considered by
the Hon’ble Quotes as belonging to Organised Group ‘A’ Services
(OGAS) – Reg.
*****
2.
The matter has been further examined on the advice of
DOPT was talked seeking relaxation in the residency requirement
by one year, so as to benefit more officers.
3.
DOPT has conveyed as under:*****
(ii)
CAPFs may release payment on grant of NFFU to
all those officers who meet the eligibility norms prescribed
in the RRs in compliance of court orders, except in respect
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
of NFFU to Level-13A, for the reason explained in (i)
above.
(iii) One year relaxation in the residency period,
prescribed under the Recruitment Rules, to the Group A
Executive Cadre is agreed to, subject to the following
conditions:a)
This is a one-time relaxation in respect of
CAPF officers who are otherwise due for NFFU
during the period 01.01.2006 to 31.12.2019.
b)
As per guidelines, NFFU is to be allowed in
HAG level, provided it is a level in the promotion
hierarchy of the CAPF concerned.
c)
The officers fulfil all other terms and
conditions laid down in DOPT OM dated
24.04.2009 for grant of NFU and other instructions
issued from time to time.”
21.
Even while objecting to the introduction, in para 3(iii)(b) of the
MHA OM dated 30 September 2019, of the additional requirement of
the post, the grade of which was being sought on NFFU basis under
DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009, being part of the promotional
hierarchy in the service, the petitioners contend that, in fact, in the
CRPF, the post of ADG was already in existence since 1987, for
which purpose they rely on the following order dated 25 May 1987:
No. II. 27012/32/86/FP.II
Government of India/Bharat Sarkar
Ministry of Home Affairs/Grih Mantralaya
….
New Delhi, Dated: 25.5.1987
To
1.
The Director General,
Border Security Force,
New Delhi
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
2.
The Director General,
Central Reserve Police Force,
New Delhi.
Subject:
Creation of a post each of Additional DG in BSF
and CRPF
Sir,
I am directed to convey herewith the sanction of the Pres to
the creation of one post each of Additional Dir General in the scale
of the of ₹ 7300-100-7600 in the BSF and CRPF with effect from
the date these posts are filled in and up to 29.2.1988 for the
present.
2.
The above sanction is subject to the condition that you
posts of Assistant Commandant in BSF and 2 posts of Dy. SPs in
CRPF will be kept in abeyance till the posts of Additional DG
continue and the supporting staff for the post of Additional DG in
BSF and CRPF should be made available by the Organisation
concerned by internal adjustment.
3.
The expenditure involved in the creation of the posts will
be debitable to the budget head of BSF and CRPF respectively
under Demand No. 41 of the Ministry of Home Affairs for 198788.
4.
This issues with the concurrence of Integrated Finance
Division vide their Dy. No. 1811/87-Fin. III (D.I) dated 20 May
1987.
Yours faithfully,
(P. Vijayaraghavan)
Under Sec to the Government of India
Dated: 21.5.1987.”
22.
The DG, CRPF issued, on 1 November 2019, an Order granting
NFFU in the HAG, in terms of DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009, to
various officers in the CRPF. Petitioner 1 was granted NFFU with
effect from 1 April 2011 and Petitioner 2 was granted NFFU with
effect from 1 April 2009. The name of Petitioner 3 was absent.
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
23.
This was followed by Order dated 13 December 2019, also
issued by the DG, CRPF, granting NFFU in the SAG, in terms of
DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009, to officers of the CRPF. The list did
not include Petitioner 4.
24.
According to the petitioners, Petitioners 1 and 2 were entitled to
NFFU with effect from 10 July 2009 and 8 July 2007 respectively,
Petitioner 3 was entitled to NFFU with effect from 21 June 2007 in
the HAG and Petitioner 4 was entitled to NFFU in the SAG with
effect from 31 March 2006.
25.
It is in the above circumstances that the petitioners approached
this Court by means of the present writ petition, praying that
(i)
DOPT OM dated 30 September 2019 be quashed and set
aside to the extent it requires, in para 3(iii)(b) thereof, inclusion
of the post, the scale of which was being sought on NFFU basis
under DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009, in the promotional
hierarchy of the service,
(ii)
Orders dated 1 November 2019 and 13 December 2019,
issued by the DG, CRPF be quashed and set aside to the extent
they do not grant NFFU to the petitioners with effect from the
dates from which they were entitled thereto, in terms of DOPT
OM dated 24 April 2009, and
(iii)
a writ of mandamus be issued to the respondents to grant
NFFU to the petitioners with effect from the dates indicated in
para 24 supra.
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
26.
The petitioners have, in the writ petition, submitted that the
MHA could not, in the OM dated 30 September 2019, include, in para
3(iii)(b) thereof, an additional requirement of the post, for which
NFFU was being sought, having to be in the promotional hierarchy of
the concerned CAPF.
27.
That apart, the writ petition relies on the following OMs issued
by the DOPT, which repeatedly called upon the respondents to amend
the Service Rules/RRs of the CAPFs to bring the promotional
avenues, and eligibility thereto, in line with the recommendations of
the 6th CPC:
DOPT OM dated 15 December 2009
Dated 15th December, 2009
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject:-
6th Central Pay Commission’s recommendations –
amendment of Service Rules – regarding
***
This Department in OM No. AB 14017/61/2008-Estt ®
dated 24.3.2009 issued the guidelines for amendment of Service
Rules/Recruitment Rules for incorporating the changes arising out
of 6th CPC recommendations.
2.
The 6th CPC have also recommended for bringing
uniformity in eligibility criteria across various organised Group A
Services for promotions. The issue has been examined and in the
light of these, it has been decided that the following steps to amend
the existing Service Rules shall be undertaken on priority basis:
(i)
For promotion to SAG level, the eligibility
requirement shall be
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
“Officers in the JAG with 8 years regular service in
the grade including NFSG OR Officers with 17
years regular service in Group ‘A’ posts in the
service out of which at least 4 years regular service
should be in the JAG (including service rendered in
the NFSG of the JAG).”
(ii)
For promotion to HAG level, the eligibility
requirement shall be
“Officers in the SAG with 3 years regular service in
the grade OR Officers with 25 years regular service
in Group ‘A’ posts in the service out of which at
least 1 year’s regular service should be in the SAG.”
3.
The cadre controlling authorities of the various Organised
Group A Services may initiate action for appropriate amendments
in the Service Rules.”
DOPT OM dated 18 January 2011
Dated 18th January, 2011
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject:-
Qualifying service for promotion to SAG/HAG
Grades in Organised Group ‘A’ Engineering
Services – regarding
***
This Department vide OM of even No. dated 15.12.2009
had issued guidelines for amendment of Service Rules for
incorporating the eligibility requirements for promotion to SAG
and HAG level in Organised Group A Services.
2.
The matter has been examined in respect of the Organised
Engineering Services where the functional JAG is at Grade Pay of
₹ 8700/– and the eligibility requirement for SAG level is 3 years in
the JAG grade. Accordingly for promotion to SAG (PB 4 Grade
Pay ₹ 10,000/-) level in Organised Engineering Services, the
eligibility requirement shall be
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
“Officers in the grade of Superintending Engineer and
equivalent (PB 4 Grade Pay of ₹ 8700/–) with 3 years
regular service in the grade or officers in the grade of
Superintending Engineer/equivalent with 17 years regular
service in Group A posts in the service out of which at least
one year of regular service should be in the PB-4 Grade
Pay of ₹ 8700.”
For promotion to HAG (₹ 67,000-79,000/-) level, the eligibility
requirement shall be
“Officers in the SAG (PB-4 Grade Pay ₹ 10,000/-) with
with 3 years regular service in the grade OR Officers with
25 years regular service in Group ‘A’ posts in the service
out of which at least 1 year’s regular service should be in
the SAG.”
3.
The cadre controlling authorities of the various Organised
Group A Engineering Services may initiate action for appropriate
amendments in the Service Rules.”
DOPT OM dated 8 July 2011
Dated 8th July, 2011
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject:-
6th Central Pay Commission’s recommendations –
amendment of Service Rules – regarding
***
This Department in OM No. AB 14017/61/2008-Estt (RR)
dated 24.3.2009 issued the guidelines for amendment of Service
Rules/Recruitment Rules for incorporating the changes arising out
of 6th CPC recommendations. Separately the revised eligibility
conditions for SAG & HAG level for members of Organised
Group A Services have been issued in this Department OMs dated
15.12.09 (Non-Technical) and 18.01.2011 (Engineering Services).
The provisions with regard to grant of functional scale of ₹ 14,30018,300 (pre-revised) to the SEs and equivalent in respect of
Engineering Services prescribed in OM dated 29.12.2010 also
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
refers. Instructions for grant of NFU as per 6th CPC
recommendations have been issued in OM dated 24.4.09.
2.
As the Recruitment Rules/Service Rules are required to be
amended after incorporating the above instructions, all the
Ministry/Departments/Cadre Controlling Authorities of Organised
Group ‘A’ Services may take immediate necessary action for
notification of Service Rules positively by 31.3.2012 in
consultation with DOPT/UPSC & Ministry of Law.”
28.
The petitioners contend, in the writ petition, that the applicable
eligibility qualifications for promotion to the HAG in the CRPF had
to abide by the stipulations contained in DOPT OM dated 15
December 2009. Reckoned thus, it was submitted that all petitioners
qualified for grant of NFFU in terms of the DOPT OM dated 24 April
2009 with effect from the date mentioned in the prayer clause in the
writ petition.
II.
Counter-affidavit
29.
The CRPF has filed a counter-affidavit by way of response to
the writ petition. In the counter-affidavit, the CRPF has placed
reliance on Clause 3 of the Annexure to the DOPT OM dated 24 April
2009, which required fulfilment, by the officer seeking NFFU in terms
of the OM, of the prescribed eligibility criteria and promotional
norms, including benchmark, for upgradation to the post carrying the
grade pay of which NFFU was being sought, to be met at the time of
screening while considering the case for grant of NFFU.
30.
The counter-affidavit points out that, following the OM dated
24 April 2009, the DOPT issued a further OM dated 25 September
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
2009, providing clarifications to the earlier OM dated 24 April 2009,
para 2 of which read as under:
“2.
The new HAG scale of ₹ 67,000-79,000 has been
introduced in replacement of the pre-revised S-30 scale. It is
clarified that consequent upon the carving out of the new HAG
scale, non-functional upgradation under the scheme will be
available to particular Grade Pays in PB-3 and PB-4 and also to the
HAG scale.
SAG officers can be allowed Non-functional
upgradation to the HAG Grade only where there is such a Grade
in the service.”
31.
Promotional avenues, and eligibility thereto, it is pointed out,
are specified in the RRs. The post of ADG, in the HAG, was created
in the CAPF for the first time on 7 October 2008, following which, in
July 2009, provision was made in the RRs for promotion of cadre
officers in the CAPFs to the post of ADG. The first promotions to the
post of ADG in the CRPF followed, in September 2009. As such,
prior to 7 October 2008, there was no HAG post in the promotional
hierarchy in the CAPFs. There could be no question, therefore, of the
benefit of NFFU in the HAG scale, in terms of the DOPT OM dated
24 April 2009, being extended prior to 7 October 2008.
32.
The MHA OM dated 30 September 2019 provided a one-time
one year relaxation in the residency period for grant of NFFU under
the OM dated 24 April 2009.
33.
On this basis, the CRPF has sought to justify the grant of NFFU
in the HAG to Petitioners 1 and 2 in the Order dated 1 November
2019 issued by the DG, CRPF, and the refusal of NFFU to Petitioners
3 and 4 on the following basis:
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
(i)
Petitioner 1 was promoted to the SAG, as IG, on 10 July
2008. The RRs stipulated 30 years’ regular service in Group A
with at least three years’ service in the SAG, as the eligibility
for promotion to the HAG. The requirement of three years in
the SAG stood reduced to two years’ by virtue of the one year
relaxation extended by MHA OM dated 30 September 2019.
Thus, Petitioner 1 became eligible for grant of NFFU under the
DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009 on the expiry of two years from
10 July 2008, i.e. on 10 July 2010. He was, therefore, granted
NFFU with effect from the beginning of the next financial year,
i.e. with effect from 1 April 2011.
(ii)
By the same token, Petitioner 2 having been promoted to
the SAG on 8 July 2006, became eligible for NFFU in the HAG
scale on expiry of two years therefrom, i.e. on 8 July 2008. He
was, therefore, granted NFFU with effect from 1 April 2009.
(iii)
Petitioner 3 had not completed the requisite two years’
residency period in the SAG, after promotion as IG on 1 June
2006, before he superannuated on 30 November 2007. He could
not, therefore, be granted NFFU in terms of the DOPT OM
dated 24 April 2009.
(iv)
Petitioner 4 had not undergone the requisite promotional
course as stipulated in the RRs till his superannuation, after
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
promotion as DIG, in the JAG scale on 17 May 2005. He was,
therefore, not eligible for grant of NFFU.
34.
The CRPF has, therefore, prayed that the writ petition be
dismissed.
C.
Rival Contentions
35.
We have heard Mr. Ankur Chhibber, learned Counsel for the
petitioners and Mr. Ripudaman Bharadwaj, learned CGSC for the
respondents, at length.
36.
Mr. Chhibber reiterates the contentions advanced by the
petitioners in the writ petition. Additionally, Mr. Chhibber places
reliance on the following OM issued by the DOPT on 26 March 2019,
mandating expeditous implementation of the judgment of the Supreme
Court in Harananda:
“No.I-11011/2/2013-CDR (Vol.II)
Government of India
Department of Personnel & Training
(Cadre Review Division)
Lok Nayak Bhawan, New Delhi
Dated, the 26th March, 2019
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Sub: Implementation of Hon'ble Supreme Court's judgment
dated 05.02.2019 in SLP No. 12393 of 2013 and SLP No.3554835554 of 2015 in the matter of Organised Status and consequential
benefit of NFU to RPF and CAPFs.
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
The undersigned is directed to refer to MHA's OM No.I21023/08/2013-IPS.III dated 22.03.2019 on the subject mentioned
above.
2.
Being Cadre Controlling Authority for the RPF and CAPFs,
M/o Railways and Ministry of Home Affairs (respectively) are
requested to send detailed modalities-on all issues/directions
covered in the Orders of the Hon'ble Court for enabling
implementation at the earliest.
3.
This may be accorded TOP PRIORITY.
Sd/(M S Subramanya Rao)
Director (CRD)
Shri Amitabh Kharkwal
Joint Secretary (Police)
Ministry of Home Affairs
North Block, New Delhi.”
37.
Mr Chhibber submits that, while the RPF had, in due earnest,
taken steps to comply with the judgment of the Supreme Court and
had also framed draft amended RRs, the CRPF, despite repeated
missives from the DOPT, had still not amended its RRs in tune with
DOPT OM dated 15 December 2009. The petitioners, it is submitted,
could not be prejudiced as a reason of the inaction on the part of the
respondents.
38.
Mr. Chhibber further placed reliance on the judgment of a
Division Bench of this Court in Arun Chhibber v. Union of India17.
He has drawn our attention to paras, 1, 6 and 7 of the said decision
which read thus thus:
17 2022 SCC OnLine Del 2697
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
“1.
The two petitioners, having retired from the rank of
Inspector General in the respondents No. 2 and 3 Central Reserve
Police Force (CRPF) on 30th June, 2007 and 30th August, 2008
respectively, have filed this petition, (i) impugning the order dated
1st November, 2019 of the respondents CRPF, to the extent
excluding the names of the petitioners from the list of those
granted the benefit of the Non-functional Financial Upgradation
(NFFU) for the Higher Administrative Grade (HAG) level; (ii)
impugning the order/Office Memorandum (OM) dated
30th September, 2019, to the extent it states that NFFU is to be
allowed in HAG, provided it is a level in the promotional hierarchy
of the Central Armed Police Force (CAPF) concerned; (iii) seeking
mandamus, directing the respondents to amend the Recruitment
Rules/Service Rules for Group ‘A’ officers of CRPF and to make it
in line with the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT)
OMs dated 24th April, 2009, 15th December, 2009, 18th January,
2011 and 8th July, 2011; (iv) in the alternative, pending the
amendment of the Recruitment Rules, consider the petitioners for
grant of benefit of NFFU with effect from 31st March, 2006 in
HAG, by following the eligibility criteria provided in OM dated
15th December, 2009 and as has been done with respect to
personnel in the Ministry of Mines, vide letter dated 2nd December,
2010; and, (v) seeking mandamus, directing the respondents to
grant the benefit of NFFU to the petitioners with effect from
31st March, 2006, along with arrears, interest and all consequential
benefits.
*****
6.
The counsel for the respondents has however also drawn
attention to the OM dated 24th April, 2009 issued consequent upon
the acceptance of the recommendations of the 6th Pay Commission
qua grant of NFFU, inter-alia providing that the grant of higher
scale would be governed by the terms and conditions given in
annexure thereto and to the clause in the annexure thereto, interalia providing that “all the prescribed eligibility criteria and
promotional norms including “benchmark” for up-gradation to a
particular grade pay would have to be met at the time of screening
for grant of higher pay scale under these orders.”. It is contended
that since till October, 2008, there was no eligibility criteria for
promotion of the cadre officers to the rank of Additional Director
General, the petitioners cannot be said to have met the eligibility
criteria and norms for promotion to the HAG level of Additional
Director General.
7.
However, it is not the argument of the respondents that the
petitioners did not meet any of the eligibility criteria laid down in
the Recruitment Rules amended in October, 2008 or that the
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
eligibility criteria for deputationists to be appointed as Additional
Director General in CRPF were not met by the petitioners. Once it
is so and the petitioners are found to meet the eligibility criteria of
three years regular service in the SAG or 25 years regular service
in group ‘A’ post and of which at least one year regular service
should be in SAG, as found in OM dated 15th December, 2009 for
promotion to HAG level, and both of which criteria, it is not the
case of the respondents that the petitioners did not satisfy, we are
of the view that the petitioners are entitled to the benefit of NFFU
with effect from 31st March, 2006 in accordance with OM dated
21st May, 2009 inter-alia providing that since the 1975 batch of
IAS officers had been posted/empaneled as Additional Secretary
with effect from 31st March, 2006 and thus batch of 1973 and
earlier of organized Group ‘A’ service are to be considered for
NFFU; it is contended that thus the petitioners who are of 1971
batch, would be entitled to the NFFU benefit from 31st March,
2006 in the HAG grade.”
39.
During the course of arguments, Mr. Chhibber sought to
contend that the petitioners were seeking the benefit of NFFU, as per
the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009, with effect from 31 March 2006.
He sought to place reliance, for this purpose, on OM dated 21 May
2009 issued by the DOPT, which reads thus:
“No. AB. 14017/64/2008-Estt.(RR)
Government of India
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions
Department of Personnel and Training
New Delhi, the 21st May, 2009
Office Memorandum
Subject:-
Non-Functional upgradation for Officers of
Organized Group 'A' Services in PB-3 and PB-4
***
A reference is invited to this Department OM of even No.
dated 24.04.09 on the above subject. As indicated at point (v) of
para 1, the details of batch of the officers belonging to the Indian
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
Administrative Service who have been posted at the Centre in the
various grades of PB-3 and PB-4 with effect from 01.01.2006 as
well as the date of posting of the first officer belonging to the batch
is annexed. Necessary action may be taken for grant of higher scale
for the Officers belonging to batches of Organized Group A
Services that are senior by two year or more and have not so far
been promoted to that particular grade.
2.
Hindi version will follow.
Sd/(S. J. Kumar)
Deputy secretary to the Government of India
Tel. 2309 2112”
40.
Mr. Chhibber submits that the Annexure to the aforesaid OM
specifies the dates with effect from which various batches of officers
of Organised Group A services were to be considered for NFFU, on
batches of officers in the IAS, two years’ junior, being posted as
Additional Secretary, Joint Secretary etc. Mr. Chhibber’s contention
is that, as per the said OM, Organised Group A service officers of
batches of 1973 or earlier were required to be considered for grant of
NFFU in terms of DOPT OM dated 24 Apirl 2009, with effect from
31 March 2006.
41.
Inasmuch as the petitioners are officers of the 1971 batch, he
submits that they would be entitled to NFFU with effect from 31
March 2006.
42.
We may note, here itself, that the above submission of Mr.
Chhibber cannot be permitted to be countenanced, as it is contrary to
the prayers in the writ petition, which specify the dates with effect
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
from which the petitioners are seeking grant of NFFU. These prayers
were never amended. We cannot, therefore, permit the petitioners, at
the stage of arguments, to change the case set out in the writ petition
and seek NFFU with effect from 31 March 2006.
43.
Mr. Chhibber also places reliance on the judgment of the
Supreme Court in State of Mizoram v. Mizoram Enigeering Service
Association18. However, as this decision deals only with the issue of
whether the Mizoram Engineering Service could be treated as an
Organised Group-A service, and as this issue, so far as the CRPF is
concerned, stands concluded by the judgment of the Supreme Court in
Harananda, we do not intend to advert further to this judgment.
44.
Responding to Mr. Chhibber’s submission, Mr. Bhardwaj,
learned CGSC, submits that the decision in Arun Chhibber was
rendered in the peculiar facts of that case, in which there was no
dispute that the officers concerned satisfied the residency period
requirement for promotion to the grade in which they were seeking
NFFU. He submits that, on the date of superannuation of Petitioners 1
and 2, 3 years in the SAG was the essential requirement to entitle an
officer to promotion in the HAG. One year’s relaxation to this
reqruiement of three years’ service in the SAG was available in view
of MHA OM dated 30 September 2019. The RRs for the post of ADG
came to be amended later on 10 August 2010, after the Petitioner 2
had superannuated. In any event, as the RRs were amended on 10
18 (2004) 6 SCC 218
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
August 2010, Petitioner 2 could not seek grant of NFFU from 8 July
2007.
D.
Analysis
45.
Having heard learned Counsel for the parties and perused the
material on record, the only relief which, to our mind, can be granted
in the present case is advancing the date with effect from which
Petitioners 1 and 2 would be entiled to NFFU to 10 July 2010 and 8
July 2008 respectively. No further relief can be granted to the
petitioners in this petition.
46.
The challenge, in the writ petition, to para 3(iii)(b) of MHA
OM dated 30 September 2019 is, to our mind, without substance. As
has been pointed out by the respondents in the counter affidavit, this
requirement was contained in OM dated 25 September 2009 issued by
the DOPT. It is not, therefore, as though the MHA introduced this
requirement for the first time in the impugned OM dated 30
September 2019.
47.
The requirement, to our mind, does not travel beyond the limits
of DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009. Clause 3 in Annexure I to the OM
clearly required satisfaction of the prescribed eligibility criteria and
promotional norms for upgradation to a particular grade pay to be met
by an officer seeking NFFU in that grade pay under the OM. It is but
obvious that, if NFFU was sought, under the OM, to a post which was
not in the promotional hierarchy of the service concerned, there could
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
be no question of satisfaction, by the officer, of the prescribed
eligibility criteria and promotional norms applicable for promotion to
that post. There was, therefore, nothing illegal or irregular in the
DOPT and, later, the MHA, clarifying that NFFU in the HAG would
be available only if a post in the HAG was part of the promotional
hiearchy in the service. Else, compliance with Clause 3 of Annexure I
to the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009 could not be ensured.
48.
We, therefore, reject the challenge to para 3(iii)(b) of MHA OM
dated 30 September 2019.
49.
Once we have upheld the requirement of the grade, to which
NFFU was sought, being one which was in the promotional hiearchy
of the service concerned, all that remains is to decide whether,
applying the concerned RRs, the decision of the respondents, in so far
as the petitioners’ entitlement to NFFU was concerned, is correct, or
whether the petitioners are entitled to NFFU from the dates claimed in
the writ petition.
50.
We have already noted, earlier in this judgment, the contention,
advanced by Mr. Chhibber, to the effect that the post of ADG, in the
HAG, was part of the CRPF since 1987.
51.
This submission was sought to be justified on the basis of order
dated 25 May 1987 issued by the MHA, reproduced in para 21 supra.
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
52.
We have seen the said order. The order conveys the sanction of
the President to the creation of two posts of ADG for a limited period,
till 29 February 1988. In the interregnum, two posts of Deputy SP
were to be kept in abeyance.
53.
No order or other document, extending this arrangement
beyond 29 Febraury 1988, has been placed on record. In the absence
thereof, it appears, from a reading of the order dated 25 May 1987,
that the arrangement envisaged therein was a mere ad hoc arrangment
for a limited period of time.
54.
In any event, what is required is that the grade to which NFFU
is sought under the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009, is part of the
promotional hierarchy in the service. The respondents are correct in
their contention that a post becomes part of the promotional hierarchy
in an organised service only when it is so specified in the applicable
RRs. The submission of the respondents that the post of ADG, in the
HAG, was made part of promotional hierarchy in the CRPF only with
effect from 7 October 2008 and that the applicable RRs were
accordingly amended only in July 2009, has not been disputed by the
petitioners.
55.
Petitioner 3, having superannuated prior to 7 Octobr 2008,
could not be entitled to NFFU in the HAG, as the HAG was not part
of the promotional hierarchy in the CRPF till the date of
superannuation of Petitioner 3. There is, therefore, no illegality in the
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
respondents’ decision to deny NFFU to Petitioner 3 in terms of DOPT
OM dated 24 April 2009.
56.
Insofar as Petitioners 1 and 2 are concerned, we cannot agree
with Mr. Chhibber that the eligibility criteria for promotion to the
HAG (i.e. the post of ADG) was to be adopted from the DOPT OM
dated 15 December 2009. That OM merely calls upon the various
organized Group A Services to amend their RRs to incorporate the
eligibility qualifications contained in the said OM, both for promotion
to the SAG as well as for promotion to the HAG. Till the date of
superannuation of Petitioners 1 and 2, it is not in dispute that the
applicable RRs for the post of ADG in the CRPF were not amended in
line with DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009.
57.
In the absence of any such amendment, the entitlement of
Petitioners 1 and 2 to NFFU in terms of the DOPT OM dated 24 April
2009 has to be decided on the basis of the RRs as they existed on the
date when the said petitioners superannuated. On that date, the RRs
for the post of ADG (in the HAG) required 30 years’ service in Group
A with at least three years’ regular service in the SAG. This
requirement of three years stands reduced to two years in view of the
one year relaxation granted by MHA OM dated 30 September 2019.
Even so, the officer was required to have 30 years’ service in Group A
with at least two years’ regular service in the SAG.
58.
While there is no dispute about the fact that Petitioners 1 and 2
possessed 30 years’ service in Group A, the requirement of two years’
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
regular service in the SAG was completed by Petitioner 1 only on 10
July 2010 and by Petitioner 2 only on 8 July 2008. They could not,
therefore, be entitled to NFFU in terms of the DOPT OM dated 24
April 2009 prior to the said dates.
59.
Accordingly, the prayer of Petitioner 1 for grant of NFFU with
effect from 10 July 2009 and of Petitioner 2 for grant of NFFU with
effect from 8 July 2007 is without merit and has to be rejected.
60.
That said, however, we see no justification for the respondents
granting NFFU to Petitioner 1 and Petitioner 2 only from the first day
of April of the year following the year in which they satisfied the
requirement of two years’ residency in the SAG. There is nothing in
the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009 which justifies postponement of
the date from which NFFU would be granted to the first day of April
of the year following the year in which the officer was entitled thereto.
In fact, Clause (i) of the OM specifically states that the grade would
be granted “on non-functional basis from the date of posting of the
Indian Administrative Service Officers in that particular grade at the
Centre”. The entitlement would be, therefore, from the date when the
Joint Cadre IAS officers, two batches junior, were posted at the
centre, subject, of course, to satisfaction of the terms and conditions
enumerated in Annexure-I to the OM.
61.
Clause 3 of Annexure-I of the OM required the officers to
fulfill the prescribed eligibility criteria and promotional norms for
promotion to the grade in which NFFU was sought. That requirement
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
was satisfied in the case of Petitioner 1 on 10 July 2010 and in the
case of Petitioner 2 on 8 July 2008. The said petitioners, therefore,
became ipso facto entitled to NFFU in the HAG scale from those
dates.
62.
We cannot, therefore, sustain the decision of the respondents to
grant NFFU to Petitioner 1 only with effect from 1 April 2011 and to
Petitioner 2 with effect from 1 April 2009. We hold that Petitioners 1
and 2 would be entitled to NFFU under the DOPT OM dated 24 April
2009 with effect from 10 July 2010 and 8 July 2008, respectively.
63.
In so far as Petitioner 4 is concerned, there is no dispute that he
had not undergone the requisite ISSMC for promotion to the SAG.
Respondents are correct in their submission that Clause 3 of
Annexure-I to the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009 would require the
officer to satisfy all promotional norms stipulated for promotion to the
grade in which NFFU is sought. Inter alia, in the case of post of IG,
this would have required Petitioner 4 to undergo the ISSMC, which he
had not undergone till the date of his superannuation.
64.
We, therefore, do not find any error or infirmity in the
respondents’ decision to deny, to Petitioner 4, the benefit of NFFU in
terms of the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009.
65.
Insofar as the case of Arun Chhibber is concerned, a bare
reading of para 7 thereof reveals that the court ruled as it did because
there was no dispute that the petitioners before it satisfied the
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
residency period requirement for the purpose of promotion to the
grade in which NFFU was sought. In the case of the petitioners, this
requirement, as we have noted, was not satisfied in the case of
Petitioner 3 and, in the case of Petitioners 1 and 2, they have been
granted NFFU with effect from the date on which they satisfied the
said requirements.
66.
The decision in Arun Chhibber, therefore, would in fact
validate the act of the respondents, rather than otherwise.
67.
The petitioners have also prayed for a direction to the
respondents to amend the RRs in terms of the DOPT OM dated 15
December 2009. It is trite that a writ court cannot direct the executive
to frame, or amend, Rules19. Even were such a direction to be issued,
it would be of no avail to the petitioners, as any amendment could not
have retrospective effect.
Conclusion
68.
For the aforesaid reasons, we are of the opinion that, except for
advancing the date of grant of NFFU of Petitioner 1 to 10 July 2010
and of Petitioner 2 to 8 July 2008, no other relief can be granted to the
petitioners in this writ petition.
69.
The petition is accordingly disposed of.
19 Refer Union of India v. K. Pushpavanam (2023) 20 SCC 736, State of J & K v. A R Zakki 1992 Supp
(1) SCC 548 and Supreme Court Employees’ Welfare Association v. Union of India (1989) 4 SCC 187.
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
WP (C) 13607/2019 [Syed Mohd Zaki Rizvi and Anr v. Union of
India and Ors]
70.
There are two petitioners in this writ petition. Both the
petitioners seek grant of NFFU in the SAG.
71.
Petitioner 1 was promoted to the JAG in the rank of DIG with
effect from 30 May 2005 and Petitioner 2 was promoted as DIG with
effect from 24 May 2005. However, both the petitioners underwent
the ISSMC between 10 and 15 November 2008. They were granted
SAG with effect from 1 April 2009.
72.
As in the case of Petitioners 1 and 2 in WP (C) 13600/2019, this
writ petition would liable to be allowed to the limited extent of
advancing the date of grant of NFFU to the petitioners with effect
from the dates when they underwent the ISSMC.
73.
As the exact dates are not forthcoming, the writ petition is
disposed of in these terms.
WP (C) 1945/2020 [Gurdeep Singh Mastana and Anr v. Union of
India and Ors]
74.
There are two petitioners in this writ petition. Both claim NFFU
to the SAG grade.
75.
Petitioner 1 G.S. Mastana was promoted as DIG, in the JAG
grade, on 30 September 2005. His case is, however, similar to
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
Petitioner 4 in WP (C) 13600/2019, as he had not undergone the
requisite ISSMC for promotion as IG till the date of his
superannuation on 31 January 2008. He was not, therefore, entitled to
NFFU in terms of the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009.
76.
Petitioner 2 retired from service in the rank of ADIG. It was
only thereafter that his post of ADIG was upgraded as DIG, in the
JAG grade, in situ, with effect from 23 October 2008. Petitioner 2,
therefore, was promoted to the JAG scale only after he had
superannuated, he was also not entitled to the benefit of NFFU in
terms of the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009.
77.
The respondents, therefore, correctly denied NFFU to the
petitioners as sought in this writ petition.
78.
The writ petition is, therefore, dismissed.
WP (C) 2612/2020 [Raj Krishna Gaur & Ors v. Union of India &
Ors.]
79.
There are nine petitioners in this writ petition. All the
petitioners seek grant of NFFU in the HAG grade.
80.
Petitioners 1, 2 and 3 were promoted to the rank of IG, in the
SAG, with effect from 24 July 2009. Thus, for grant of NFFU in the
HAG, they were required to have two years in the SAG. However,
they superannuated on 31 July 2009, 31 August 2009 and 31 October
2009 and could not, therefore, be granted NFFU in the HAG.
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
81.
Petitioner 9 was promoted to the rank of IG with effect from 9
January 2012. He, too, superannuated on 31 January 2012, before
completing two years in the SAG and was not, therefore, eligible for
NFFU in the HAG.
82.
Petitioners 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 were promoted to the rank of DIG
with effect from 29 November 2005, 7 February 2007, 9 February
2005, 5 April 2005 and 22 September 2008 respectively. Their case is,
however, similar to Petitioner 4 in WP (C) 13600/2019, as they had
not undergone the requisite ISSMC for promotion as IG till the date of
superannuation of Petitioners 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 on 31 January 2007, 31
July 2007, 31 August 2008, 30 September 2006 and 31 January 2009
respectively. They were not, therefore, entitled to NFFU in terms of
the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009.
83.
The respondents, therefore, correctly denied NFFU to the
petitioners as sought in this writ petition.
84.
The writ petition is, therefore, dismissed.
WP (C) 767/2020 [Devendra Kumar Sharma v. Union of India &
Ors.]
85.
The petitioner, Devendra Kumar Sharma, in this writ petition
seeks grant of NFFU in the HAG grade. He is a Group A General
Duty Cadre retired officer of the ITBPF20.
20 Indo Tibetan Border Police Force
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
86.
The petitioner was not considered for grant of NFFU to the
grade of HAG as neither was the HAG level post available in the
promotion hierarchy before 14 November 2019, nor were any service
Rules available in ITBPF till date. The MHA vide OM dated 30
September 2019 granted a one-time relaxation of one year in the
residency period prescribed under Recruitment Rules to Group A
Executive Cadre Officers as a special dispensation.
87.
Since there were no service Rules available in ITBPF and,
therefore, no HAG post available in the promotional hierarchy of the
ITBPF, in view of the MHA OMs dated 24 April 2009 and 30
September 2019, the respondents denied NFFU to petitioner as sought
in this writ petition.
88.
We find no infirmity with the decision.
89.
The writ petition is, therefore, dismissed.
WP (C) 912/2020 [Ram Kanwar Saini & Ors v. Union of India &
Ors.]
90.
There are 11 petitioners in this writ petition. All the petitioners
have claimed NFFU to the SAG and HAG grade.
91.
Petitioners 1, 10 and 11 were promoted to the rank of DIG on
21 April 2008, 18 May 2007 and 12 August 2008 respectively and to
the rank of IG, in the SAG grade, on 1 January 2012, 24 August 2011
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
and 1 March 2014 respectively. Subsequently they superannuated on
31 July 2015, 31 August 2013 and 29 February 2016 respectively.
They were granted NFFU in the SAG grade with effect from 1 April
2011. They would be entitled to NFFU in the SAG with effect from
the actual date of completion of one year service as DIG (as the
prescribed residency period in the RRs for the post of IG was two
years as DIG, with one year relaxation), which would advance their
entitlement to NFFU in the SAG to 21 April 2010, 18 May 2009 and
12 August 2010 respectively.
92.
Petitioners 2, 6 and 7 were promoted to the rank of DIG on 1
January 2006. Petitioners 2 and 6 were promoted to the rank of IG on
31 December 2015 and Petitioner 7 on 15 September 2013. Petitioners
2 and 6 superannuated on 28 February 2017 and 31 March 2019
respectively and Petitioner 7 superannuated on 31 August 2015.
Petitioners 2 and 6 were granted NFFU in SAG grade with effect from
1 April 2013 and Petitioner 7 was granted NFFU in SAG garde with
effect from 1 April 2011.
93.
Petitioners 3, 4 and 8 were promoted to the rank of DIG in the
year 2003, 1 March 2004 and 1 February 2002 respectively and to the
rank of IG on 25 March 2010, 5 August 2010 and 26 September 2008
respectively. Petitioner 3 superannuated on 31 December 2011,
Petitioner 4 superannuated on 28 February 2014 and Petitioner 8
superannuated on 31 July 2010. They were granted NFFU in SAG
grade with effect from 3 January 2006. Their claim for SAG NFFU
from 1 January 2006 is therefore effectively met. As regards NFFU in
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
HAG grade, Petitioner 3 was promoted to the rank of IG only on 25
March 2010 and superannuated on 31 December 2011 and Petitioner 8
superannuated on 31 July 2010 before completing two years’
residency period as IG. They were not, therefore, entitled to NFFU in
the HAG.
94.
No NFFU to the HAG could, however, be granted as the post of
ADG, in the HAG, was created in the ITBPF only on 14 November
2019.
95.
Petitioners 5 and 9 were promoted to the rank of DIG on 21
April 1998 and 27 February 2003 respectively and to the rank of IG
on 1 August 2012 and 24 June 2009 respectively. They superannuated
on 30 September 2015and 31 July 2012 and Petitioner 5 and 9 were
granted NFFU in SAG grade with effect from 1 April 2011 and 3
January 2006 respectively being the date on which they met the
eligibility norms under the existing RRs. Their claim that NFFU in
SAG grade ought to have been granted from 1 January 2006 is not
sustainable, as the eligibility norms prescribed under the existing RRs
were not met by them as of that date.
96.
We, therefore, find no infirmity in the decision of the
respondents.
97.
The writ petition is, therefore, dismissed.
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
WP (C) 660/2022 [Raza Haider & Anr v. Union of India & Ors.]
98.
There are two petitioners in this writ petition. Both claimed
NFFU to the JAG grade.
99.
Petitioner 1, Shri Raza Haider was promoted to the rank of Dy.
Commandant on 31 July 2006. On completion of the ISSMC and he
was granted NFFU in the JAG grade with effect from 1 April 2012.
He was subsequently promoted to the rank of Commandant on 1
January 2014.
100. Petitioner 1 has claimed NFFU in the JAG grade with effect
from 28 September 2010 on the basis of his batch entitlement under
DOPT OM dated 4 January 2011.
101. As the ISSMC and other eligibility conditions had not been
fulfilled as on 28 September 2010, therefore he was not entitled to
NFFU in terms of the DOPT OM dated 24 April 2009.
102. Petitioner 2 was promoted to the rank of Deputy Commandant
on 16 July 2003. He remained posted at Central Police Canteen till 14
May 2008 and had not completed two years' mandatory Duty
Battalion field service as prescribed under the statutory RRs, which
was one of the essential eligibility conditions for grant of NFFU in the
JAG grade.
103. Petitioner 2 was promoted to the rank of 2-IC with effect from
18 April 2008, i.e., prior to fulfilling the eligibility criteria for grant of
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
NFFU in the JAG grade. Therefore, the respondents denied grant of
NFFU to the JAG grade to Petitioner 2.
104. The respondents, therefore, correctly denied NFFU to
petitioners, as sought in this writ petition.
105. The writ petition is, therefore, dismissed.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J.
JULY 01, 2026
dsn/AR
W.P.(C) 13600/2019 & other connected matters
KUMAR
17:59:04
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review