Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:22752
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
F.A. No. 34 of 2025
Rajendra Ram @ Rajendra Ravidas, age about 52 years, son of Late
Mangal Ram, resident of Village- Pochra, P.O.- Barkakana, P.S.Patratu, District-Ramgarh
…
… Appellant
Versus
1. The Deputy Commissioner Ramgarh, P.O.- Chattermandu, P.S.Ramgarh, District- Ramgarh
2. Executive, Engineer, Road Construction Department, Road Division
Ramgarh, P.O.+ P.S.- Ramgarh, District- Ramgarh
… … Respondents
With
F.A. No. 60 of 2025
Jagdish Ram, age about 52 Years, son of Late Sahdeo Ram, resident of
Village- Pochra, P.O.- Barkakana P.S.- Patratu, District – Ramgarh
…
…
Appellant
Versus
1. The Deputy Commissioner Ramgarh, P.O.+ P.S.+ District- Ramgarh
2. Executive, Engineer, Road Construction Department, Road Division
Ramgarh, P.O.+ P.S. + District- Ramgarh
… …
Respondents
With
F.A. No. 231 of 2025
Sweta Kumari, age about 36 years, wife of Arjun Ram, resident of
Village- Pochra, P.O.- Barkakana, P.S.- Ramgarh, District- Ramgarh
…
…
Appellant
Versus
1. The Deputy Commissioner Ramgarh, P.O.& P.S.- Ramgarh, DistrictRamgarh
2. Executive Engineer, Road Construction Department, Road Division
Ramgarh, P.O.& P.S. -Ramgarh, District- Ramgarh.
…
Respondents
With
F.A. No. 232 of 2025
Ramesh Gope, age about 44 years, Son of Ramdeo Gope, resident of
Village- Bujurg Jamira, P.O.- Barkakana, P.S.- Patratu, DistrictRamgarh
…
…
Appellant
Versus
1. The Deputy Commissioner Ramgarh, P.O. & P.S.- Ramgarh, DistrictRamgarh
2. Executive Engineer, Road Construction Department, Road Division
Ramgarh, P.O. & P.S.- Ramgarh, District- Ramgarh.
…
… Respondents
With
F.A. No. 66 of 2025
Meena Biswash, age about 55 years, W/o Shashankar Biswash, resident
of Nehru Road, Ramgarh Cantt., P.O. & P.S.- Ramgarh, DistrictRamgarh
…
… Appellant
2026:JHHC:22752
Versus
1. The Deputy Commissioner Ramgarh, P.O.- Chattermandu, P.S.Ramgarh, District- Ramgarh
2. Executive, Engineer, Road Construction Department, Road Division
Ramgarh, P.O.+ P.S.- Ramgarh, District- Ramgarh
…. …
Respondents
With
F.A. No. 67 of 2025
Bhuneshwar Ram, aged about 66 years, son of Late Mangal Ram,
resident of Village- Pochara, P.O.- Barkakana P.S.- Patratu, DistrictRamgarh
…
… Appellant
Versus
1. The Deputy Commissioner Ramgarh, P.O.- Chhattermandu, P.S.
Ramgarh, District- Ramgarh
2. Executive Engineer, Road Construction Department, Road Division,
Ramgarh, P.O.+ P.S.- Ramgarh, District- Ramgarh
… …
Respondents
With
F.A. No. 68 of 2025
Fagan Devi, age about 65 years, Wife of Late Chhatu Saw Ram, resident
of Village- Pochara, P.O.- Barkakana, P.S.- Patratu, District- Ramgarh
… … Appellant
Versus
1. The Deputy Commissioner Ramgarh, P.O. + P.S. + District- Ramgarh
2. Executive, Engineer, Road Construction Department, Road Division
Ramgarh, P.O.+ P.S. + District- Ramgarh
…
…
Respondents
With
F.A. No. 109 of 2026
Arun Saw, age about 59 years, S/o Fudan Saw, resident of VillageRamgarh Sahu Colony, Gola Road, Ramgarh, P.O. & P.S.- Ramgarh,
District- Ramgarh
…
…
Appellant
Versus
1. The Deputy Commissioner, Ramgarh, P.O. + P.S. + DistrictRamgarh
2. Executive Engineer, Road Construction Department, Road Division,
Ramgarh, P.O. + P.S. + District- Ramgarh
…
… Respondents
--CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Appellants
: Mr. Himansu Kumar Mehta, Advocate
: Mr. Ranjan Prasad Sinha, Advocate
: Mr. Sanjeev Thakur, Advocate (In all cases)
For the Respondents
: Mr. Sanjay Kumar Tiwari, SC-I
: Mr. Mrinal Kanti Roy, GA-I
: Mr. Krishna Kumar Bhatt, AC to SC-I
2026:JHHC:22752
: Mr. Kanishka Deo, AC to GP-IV
: Mr. Arun Kumar Dubey, AC to GP-III
(In F.A. No.67/2025 and F.A. No.68/2025)
--CAV on 30.04.2026
1.
Pronounced on 31.07.2026
All these first appeals have been filed under Section 74 of the
Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 against the common
Judgement dated 29.04.2024 and the respective awards dated 10.05.2024
passed by the learned Principal District Judge-cum-L.A.R.R.A.,
Hazaribag in Land Reference Case Nos. 83/2021, 82/2021, 87/2021,
86/2021, 81/2021, 80/2021, 84/2021 and 85/2021 respectively, arising
out of L.A. Case No.05/2018-19 in connection with acquisition of lands
for the purpose of construction of 4-lane road from Patratu to Ramgarh
vide Notification No.378/L.A., Ramgarh dated 20.08.2018 and
Declaration No.140/L.A. dated 06.03.2020 whereby and whereunder the
learned Principal District Judge-cum-L.A.R.R.A., Hazaribag has
enhanced the rate of compensation to Rs.1,00,000/- (Rs. One Crore) per
acre from Rs.88,69,400/- per acre as determined by the learned District
Land Acquisition Officer, Ramgarh.
2.
The learned Principal District Judge-cum-L.A.R.R.A., Hazaribag
framed the following point for determination: “Whether the compensation awarded to the petitioners should be
enhanced?”
3.
The applicants/awardees/appellants examined two witnesses in
support of their claims. P.W.-1 is Bhuneshwar Ram and P.W.-2 is
Meena Bishwash.
4.
P.W.-1 (Bhuneshwar Ram) filed his examination-in-chief on
affidavit stating that the Government has acquired 0.02 acres of land of
Khata No.01 alongwith the lands of other raiyats situated in Mouza
Pochra, Thana No. 80, Thana- Patratu, District Ramgarh vide Land
Acquisition Case No.05/2018-2019 for the purpose of strengthening and
widening the road from Patratu Dam to Ramgarh. The Opposite Party
has determined the compensation for his acquired land at a lower rate
than the prevailing market value at the time of acquisition and he and the
2026:JHHC:22752
other raiyats have objections, therefore, all the affected raiyats have filed
the case in the court for enhancement of the compensation amount. He
further stated that Mouza- Pochra is situated adjacent to Ramgarh and
their acquired lands are identical to the acquired lands in Ramgarh and
there is no distinction absolutely between their acquired lands and the
land acquired in Ramgarh, as Ramgarh Town has expanded at both
Ramgarh and Pochra. Pochra lies under Ward No.7 of Ramgarh
Cantonment and development of Ramgarh Town has progressed
considerably towards their area in course of many years. Pochra is also a
part of Ramgarh Town and is situated within the Ramgarh Cantonment.
A significant portion of the Punjab Regiment Centre of Ramgarh is
situated over the land located within Mauza Pochra. Their acquired land
is situated adjacently to the south of the Punjab Regiment. He further
stated that they have access of all the amenities and facilities under the
Ramgarh Cantonment and all types of taxes are being levied upon and
collected from them by the Ramgarh Cantonment. He further stated that
the land measuring 14 decimals bearing Plot No.1005, Khata No.150,
Mauza- Ramgarh has also been acquired vide Land Acquisition Case
No.03/2018-2019 for the same project and a compensation amount of
Rs.80,69,712/- has been determined and paid for the same. The acquired
lands in Ramgarh and their acquired lands are identical in nature without
any difference whatsoever and both the lands have been acquired in the
same year and at the same time. He further stated that Plot No.1005 of
Mauza Ramgarh has been acquired vide Land Acquisition Case
No.03/2018-19 and a drain (nala) of 20 to 25 feet in width lies in the
west of this plot and after the drain, Plot No.1529 of Mauza Pochra is
situated which has been acquired by the Government vide Land
Acquisition Case No.04/2018-19. Accordingly, the distance between
Plot No.1005 of Mouza- Ramgarh and Plot No.1529 of Mauza- Pochra is
merely 20 to 25 feet. The nature of both the lands is identical and
without any difference and both the lands have been acquired in the
same year and at the same time and for the same project. He further
stated that all the lands situated on the side of the Ramgarh Road are
commercial lands and their market value was not less than Rs.8,00,000/4
2026:JHHC:22752
to Rs.10,00,000/- at the time of acquisition. All the lands of Pochra
situated on the side of road are commercial lands. He further stated that
considering their lands as urban area, the doubled compensation amount
has been paid, which proves that the government has also considered
their lands as urban area, but the assessment has been done considering it
as rural area, which is incorrect. He further stated that the acquired lands
are their purchased lands and the same has been their source of
livelihood since the time of their ancestors and they have faith and
identification with the acquired lands, but the government did not take it
into account while determining the compensation amount, which is
unfair. All the raiyats are demanding compensation for their respective
lands at a flat rate of Rs.5 crore per acre. The government has
determined the compensation for their lands unfairly by classifying it as
undeveloped and rural area. He further stated that their village is located
in the most developed Patratu Circle of Ramgarh district and the village
as well as the surrounding area are quite developed. Their village is
situated on the side of the Bhurkunda to Ormanjhi Road and all the
amenities of urbanization i.e. electricity, water, roads, medical center,
school, college, hospital, banks, markets, shopping centers, post office,
residential colony of CCL, Jindal Steel Power Plant, railway station,
Barkakana Junction, glass factory, several sponge iron factories and
Patratu Thermal Power Plant are available in their village. Being
dissatisfied with the compensation amount, all the land owners of
Pochra, Ramgarh and Balkudra have filed the case for enhancement of
the compensation amount and the type of their lands is same. All the
acquired lands are situated within Patratu Circle which is a developed
area since many years and the Patratu Circle is considered as an
industrial area in Ramgarh district where several mills, collieries,
factories, etc. are located since before independence. He further stated
that at the time of acquisition, the sale and purchase of the lands adjacent
to their acquired lands used to take place between Rs.6,00,000/- to
Rs.8,00,000/-. Their lands have been acquired after creation of Ramgarh
district in the year 2007 and thereafter, the price of their lands has
increased more rapidly. He identified his signature on the affidavit and
2026:JHHC:22752
stated that he had signed the affidavit after reading it. During crossexamination, he admitted that the type of his land which has been
acquired by the government was Tand. He also admitted that he has no
knowledge about the government registration value of Tand land in the
year 2018-19. Children from his Village- Pochra attend the school at
Cantonment Board and thereafter, they attend Ramgarh High School and
Ramgarh College. Their Circle Office is at Patratu and they travel by
road and rail. He further admitted that he had an asbestos house built on
his land, for which he used to pay rent @ Rs.220/- per year to the
Cantonment Board, but they have not filed the rent receipts. He further
admitted that when people from his village fall sick, they go to Pochra
for treatment and then to Ramgarh. He has bank account in Ramgarh. He
also admitted that he has not filed any document related to purchase of
land in the year 2018-19. There were facilities in their village even
before the road was widened by the government. The grocery store is
located in Pochra from where they get kerosene, rice and salt. He denied
the suggestion that the compensation paid to them for their lands by the
government is appropriate and they have filed the case for unfair
advantage.
5.
P.W.-2 (Meena Bishwash) filed her examination-in-chief on
affidavit stating that the Government has acquired 24½ decimals of land
bearing Plot No.1157, Khata No.01 alongwith the lands of other raiyats
situated in Mouza- Pochra, Thana No.80, Thana- Patratu, District
Ramgarh vide Land Acquisition Case No.05/2018-2019 for the purpose
of strengthening and widening the road from Patratu Dam to Ramgarh.
The sale-purchase of the land measuring 04 decimals bearing Plot
No.1538, Mauza- Pochra has been executed vide Deed No.773 dated
26.02.2018 for Rs.10,95,000/-. This sold land and her acquired land are
identical and both are adjacent to the road on the eastern side. She
exhibited the certified copy of Deed No.773 dated 26.02.2018 in support
of her claim, which is a public document. She also exhibited the certified
copies of two more sale deeds of her village i.e. Deed No.1635 dated
08.08.2016 and Deed No.1593 dated 21.12.2017, which are public
documents. All the aforesaid three plots are situated adjacent to the road
2026:JHHC:22752
and their acquired lands are already situated adjacent to the main road,
which have been acquired by the government for road widening and
therefore, have demanded compensation as per the above sale deeds. She
further stated that she has demanded payment of compensation for the
acquired lands at the rate of Rs.2,60,000/- (two lakh sixty thousand) per
decimal as per the sale and purchase of lands taken place in her village at
the time of acquisition. She further stated that the land measuring 14
decimals bearing Plot No.1005, Khata No.150, Mauza- Ramgarh
adjacent to her acquired lands has also been acquired vide Land
Acquisition Case No.03/2018-2019 for the same project and a
compensation amount of Rs.80,69,712/- has been paid for the same @
Rs.2,88,000/- per decimal and the acquired lands in Ramgarh and their
acquired lands are identical in nature and contiguous. She further stated
that Mouza- Pochra lies under Ward No.7 of Ramgarh Cantonment and
development of Ramgarh Town has progressed considerably towards
Mouza- Pochra from before, which has developed and urbanized and all
the amenities and facilities are available. Mouza- Ramgarh and MouzaPochra are adjacent to each other. The Sikh Regiment Centre and Punjab
Regiment Centre are situated in Mouza Pochra and Mouza Ramgarh in
Ramgarh district since the year 1940-41 and the acquired land is
adjacent to the State Road passing through the two regiments. The
acquired plots under Mouza- Ramgarh and Mouza- Pochra for the same
project are situated adjacent to each other. She identified her signature
on her affidavit and she had signed on it after reading the same. During
cross-examination, she admitted that the acquired land measuring 24.5
decimals, Plot No.1157, Khata No.01 is her Khatiani land, but she had
not made the sale-purchase transaction and it was done by her relatives
@ Rs.2,50,000/- per decimal approximately. She further admitted that
the sale deed filed by her is not the sale deed of the land sold by her
relatives. She has not filed, nor she can file any proof of sale @ Rs. 2.5
lac per decimal. She also admitted that she has no knowledge about the
government rate or market value for the year in which her land was
acquired by the government. 24.5 decimals of her lands has been
acquired, which was tand and parti land. Pochra, Cantonment lies under
2026:JHHC:22752
Ward No.7 and children from Pochra Mouza attend the Pochra
government school. They attend the government college in Ramgarh for
higher education. The district headquarters of Pochra is situated at
Ramgarh. People from Pochra get their treatment at Cantonment
Hospital, Ramgarh and they travel from Pochra to Ramgarh on foot or
by vehicles. She denied the suggestion that the distance from Pochra to
Ramgarh is very long. She also admitted that it takes half an hour to go
from Pochra to Patratu by bike. She also admitted that she has received
compensation for the acquired land from the government and the
government officials, land surveyors and other officials had visited at the
time of acquisition process, but they had not raised any objection at that
time. She denied the suggestion that the compensation determined for
them by the government is correct and the case filed by them for
enhancement of the compensation amount is improper.
6.
The Opposite Parties examined one witness on their behalves i.e.
O.P.W.-1 Baij Nath Yadav who filed his examination-in-chief stating
that he is currently posted as Correspondence Clerk in Road
Construction Department, Ramgarh Office and he was also posted in the
same office at the time of acquisition of lands for construction of 4-lane
road and he has been authorized to give evidence in the present case. He
further stated that the land of Village- Pochra has been acquired for
construction and widening of 4-lane road from Ramgarh to Patratu Dam.
The land has been acquired for widening the already constructed road in
village Pochra, in which the work of labelling and soil filling has been
done. There is no basic facility in village Pochra. The compensation
amount determined by the Collector is legally correct and on the basis of
the prevailing market rate at that time. The compensation was awarded
according to the nature of the land. The acquired land is not situated in
the developed area and the government has spent a lot in expanding the
road. The land has been acquired for public purpose. The claim of the
applicants for enhancement of compensation for the acquired lands is
incorrect and baseless. It is not true that Pochra is a developed village.
He further stated that the claim of the applicants is incorrect. He
identified his signature on the affidavit and said that he has signed on the
2026:JHHC:22752
affidavit after reading it. During cross-examination, he admitted that he
is working in the Road Construction Department since January 2009. He
was posted in Hazaribagh from 2009 to 2011 and is posted in Ramgarh
since 2011. He further admitted that he sometimes looks at the
documents of the land acquired by his department and this case is related
to Village- Pochra in connection with Ramgarh-Bhurkunda 4-lane in
which the land was acquired around the year 2017. He further admitted
that Village- Pochra falls under the Cantonment Board and the acquired
land is situated at a distance of about 2 - 2½ kilometers from Subhash
Chowk, Ramgarh. Apart from Village- Pochra, the land of VillageRamgarh has also been acquired for construction of the said 4-lane.
Village-Pochara is situated adjacent to Village- Ramgarh and the
distance of Ramgarh Army School from the acquired land is about one
kilometer. Both the regiments of the security department, Punjab
Regiment and Sikh Regiment are located in Ramgarh and Punjab
Regiment Centre is situated adjacent to the acquired land. He could not
say that Punjab Regiment Centre is situated over the lands of VillagePochra and Village- Ramgarh. He further admitted that he has never got
a chance to visit Village- Pochra, but he has gone on the road from
Village Ramgarh to Patratu dam. Village Pochra comes after Village
Ramgarh, but he has no knowledge that the road from Village Ramgarh
to Village Pochra passes through Village Pochra. He also admitted that
every village falling under the Ramgarh Cantonment Board has school,
hospital and post office. The Cantonment Board provides drainage, roads
and electricity to all villages. Toll tax and other taxes are collected by
the government on the roads constructed by the Housing. He knows that
the land has been acquired by the Land Acquisition Officer, but he does
not know about determination of the market value of the land acquired in
Village Pochra. He also does not know as to why the DLO did not
include three deeds i.e. Deed No.1635 dated 08.08.2016, Deed No.773
dated 26.02.2018 and Deed No.1593 dated 21.12.2017 while
determining the market value. The DLO of Village- Pochra has fixed
double of the market price. When a photocopy of the map of VillageRamgarh was shown to him and was asked as to whether the land under
2026:JHHC:22752
Plot No.1005, Ramgarh- Mouza has been acquired under this project or
not, he replied that he does not remember. He admitted that there is a
small river between Ramgarh Village and Pochra Village. He denied to
have knowledge that Plot No.1529 of Village Pochra is situated adjacent
to the river. He denied the suggestion that the claim of the applicant is
correct. He further admitted that the process of acquisition of the lands
was started from the year 2018. He also admitted that big houses and
shops have been built on both sides of the road constructed by the
department and large buildings have been built adjacent to the acquired
land. He also admitted that the existing road is more than 50 years old.
7.
Learned counsel for the appellants in all these cases submitted
that these cases arise from Land Acquisition Case No.05 of 2018-19 and
the lands were acquired under the Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013 (hereinafter referred to as Act of 2013). He has
submitted that different awards were prepared and the matter was
referred to the Principal District Judge-cum-L.A.R.R.A, Hazaribag for
determination of fair compensation for the acquired land. He has further
submitted that corresponding reference cases and the first appeals are as
under:-
8.
Sl. No.
First Appeal
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
F.A. No. 34 of 2025
F.A. No. 60 of 2025
F.A. No.231 of 2025
F.A. No.232 of 2025
F.A. No. 66 of 2025
F.A. No. 67 of 2025
F.A. No. 68 of 2025
F.A. No.109 of 2026
Corresponding Land
Reference Case
L.R. No.83 of 2021
L.R. No.82 of 2021
L.R. No.87 of 2021
L.R. No.86 of 2021
L.R. No.81 of 2021
L.R. No.80 of 2021
L.R. No.84 of 2021
L.R. No.85 of 2021
Learned counsel for the appellants has referred to the impugned
judgment and has submitted that the area acquired with respect to the
various persons have been mentioned therein and all the lands are of the
same village namely, Pochra.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that since all the
cases were adjudicated by common judgment and common evidences
have been placed on record, therefore, he has referred to the records
2026:JHHC:22752
relating to L.R Case No.82 of 2021 and has submitted that the same
would be sufficient for the purpose of other cases as well in view of the
fact that identical pleadings are there in all the cases.
10.
Learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that as per the
petition which was filed before the District Land Acquisition Officer,
Ramgarh on 17.07.2020, it was specifically mentioned therein that the
opposite party served notice under Section 37(2) of the aforesaid Act of
2013 and the claimant/awardee being the interested person filed their
claim under Section 64 of the aforesaid Act seeking higher
compensation. The notice issued under Section 37(2) has been annexed
alongwith the said petition filed before the District Land Acquisition
Officer. However, the said notice is undated, but it was mentioned in the
said notice that the claimant should appear on 25.06.2020 to accept the
awarded amount, failing which no further interest will be paid.
11.
He has further submitted that the records reveal that the payment
was accepted by the claimants on 03.10.2020 vide D.D. dated
17.09.2020 and the petition seeking higher amount of compensation has
been filed vide petition dated 17.07.2020 before District Land
Acquisition Officer. Learned counsel has referred to the impugned
judgment and has submitted that the parties participated in the
proceedings and the point for determination was whether the
compensation awarded to the petitioners should be enhanced. He has
submitted that two witnesses were examined on behalf of the claimants
namely Bhuneshwar Ram and Meena Bishwash and three sale deeds
were exhibited which are as follows:Exhibit-1
Exhibit-1/1
Exhibit-1/2
12.
Certified copy of deed No. 1635 dated
08.08.2016
Certified copy of deed No. 773 dated
26.02.2018
Certified copy of deed No. 1593 dated
21.12.2017
All the sale deeds were within three years prior to the date of
notification under Section 11 of the Act of 2013 and were with respect to
the same village. He has prepared a chart with respect to calculation per
decimal of land with respect to each of the exhibits which is as follows:11
2026:JHHC:22752
Exhibit
Deed No.
Exhibit-1
1635 dated Pochara
24.07.2016
773 dated Pochara
01.06.2018
1593 dated Pochara
21.12.2017
Exhibit 1/1
Exhibit 1/2
13.
Village
Amount
(Rs.)
10,12,000/-
1 decimal
(Rs.)
2,53,000/-
1 Acre
(Rs.)
2,53,00,000/-
10,95,000/-
2,73,750/-
2,73,75,000/-
6,75,000/-
2,25,000/-
2,25,00,000/-
Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the respondent
also produced both oral and documentary evidence before the court.
Only one witness namely Baij Nath Yadav was examined and following
documents were exhibited:Exhibit-A
Exhibit-B
Exhibit-C
Exhibit-D
14.
Attested copies of award received from District
Land Acquisition Officer, Ramgarh.
Attested copy of notification No. 378/LA dated
20.08.2018 which is the notification under Section
11.
Attested copy of declaration No.140/L.A. dated
06.03.2020 which is the declaration under Section
19.
Attested copy of the map received from District
Land Acquisition Officer, Ramgarh.
The learned counsel has submitted that the learned court while
passing the impugned judgment has mentioned the case of the respective
parties as per their claim & show cause and mentioned the oral evidence
/documentary evidence placed on record. However, the finding has been
recorded only in Paragraphs 11 and 12 which does not discuss either oral
or documentary evidences placed on record by the either party. He has
submitted that though the learned court has enhanced the compensation
from Rs.88,69,400/- per acre to Rs.1 crore per acre, but there is no
discussion of any oral and documentary evidence and if the sale deeds
which were placed on record by the claimants were taken into
consideration, the compensation amount would be much higher.
Paragraphs 11 and 12 of the impugned judgment are quoted as under:“11. I find that, the claimants have claimed compensation at
enhanced rate i.e. @ Rs. Two crore, sixty lacs per acre for the
acquired land. I find that, the State has paid the compensation @
Rs.88,69,400/- per acre. The claimants have claimed enhanced
compensation on the ground of proximity to connecting roads,
2026:JHHC:22752
school etc., potentiality of the land for future use, nature of land
and other sale deeds. Certain sale-deeds have also been proved
on behalf of the claimants. It has been submitted on behalf of the
Opp. Parties that, the compensation has been decided in
accordance with law, taking in view of all the relevant
consideration and the claimants do not deserve to be granted
compensation at an enhanced rate.
12. On the basis of above discussion, considering all the facts and
taking into consideration, the statutory provisions, as well as,
settled law and the fact that, no straitjacket formula can be
applied to determine the value of the acquired land, I come to the
conclusion that, the average rate of the land in the said locality
for determination of the compensation should be enhanced to
Rs.1,00,00,000/- (Rs. One crore) per acre, from Rs.88,69,400/per acre, as determined by the Land Acquisition Officer.
Office is directed to prepare the Award accordingly.”
15.
Learned counsel has referred to Section 26 of the aforesaid Act of
2013 and has submitted that there are three modes for determination of
compensation which includes:a) Circle rate; or
b) the average sale price for similar type of land
situated in the nearest village or nearest vicinity
area; or
c) consented amount of compensation as agreed
upon.
whichever is higher:
16.
Learned counsel has submitted that the sale deeds which were
produced by the claimants before the learned court were not taken care
of by the collector and having been exhibited before the court the same
ought to have been taken into consideration for the purpose of
determination of market value of land. He has further submitted that as
per explanation 2 of the Section 26, it has been provided that for
determining the average sale price referred to in Explanation 1, one-half
of the total number of sale deeds or the agreements to sell in which the
highest sale price has been mentioned shall be taken into account. He has
submitted that out of three sale deeds which were produced, if half is to
be taken into consideration, then two of the sale deeds of the highest
value should be taken into consideration and the average of the same
2026:JHHC:22752
should be considered for determining the market value. He submits that
this exercise has not been undertaken by the learned court and the
learned court has enhanced the compensation to Rs. 1 crore on adhoc
basis and there is no adjudication by the learned court.
17.
Learned counsel has also submitted that since the first appeal is a
continuation of the suit and the materials are already before this Court,
therefore, appropriate judgment be passed so that the market value of the
land is ultimately determined on the basis of materials which were
produced before the learned court.
18.
Learned counsel for the State has submitted that so far as the
impugned judgment is concerned, it is not in dispute that there is no
adjudication as such. The entire discussion in paragraph 11 and 12 does
not refer to any oral or documentary evidence. He has also submitted
that under such circumstances, the matter be remanded to the court
concerned for fresh consideration and this Court may not enter into the
merits of the case.
19.
Learned counsel has also submitted that the compensation amount
was accepted by the claimants without any protest, but such plea has not
been considered by the learned court and therefore, it requires fresh
adjudication.
20.
In response, the learned counsel for the appellants has submitted
that records of the case itself reveal that prior to accepting the awarded
amount, the petition seeking enhancement of compensation was filed
before the Land Acquisition Officer raising protest with respect to the
quantum of compensation and the sale deeds which have been exhibited
were also mentioned in the petition seeking enhancement. He has also
submitted that the Land Acquisition Officer was satisfied that the award
was received under protest and therefore, in exercise of statutory powers
under the Act of 2013 he referred the matter to the learned court for
adjudication and it was for the learned court to adjudicate the matter on
merits after appreciating the materials on record.
21.
Learned counsel for the State has submitted that though the
petition seeking enhancement of compensation was filed prior to
2026:JHHC:22752
accepting the amount of compensation, but the records do not reveal that
at the time of receiving payment, the protest was mentioned.
22.
At this, the learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that
protest is recorded while receiving the payment and he has produced
certified copies to show that even at the time of receiving the amount,
protest was registered. However, it is not in dispute that prior to
receiving the amount, the petition seeking enhancement of compensation
was already filed.
23.
On merits, the learned counsel for the State has insisted that
since the impugned judgment is a cryptic judgment and compensation
has been enhanced on ad-hoc basis, the matters be remanded.
24.
To this, the learned counsel for the appellants has reiterated that
materials are before this court and it is not in dispute that prior to
receiving compensation, the petition seeking enhancement was already
filed and what is required to be considered is only three sale deeds which
have been produced by the appellants before the learned court as the
respondents herein did not produce any deed to substantiate the market
value of the acquired land or to justify the compensation paid by them
and the compensation is to be assessed in terms of Section 26 of the Act
of 2013 read with its explanations. It is submitted that the amount of
compensation be quantified by this court and the case be decided on
merits. He has given a chart whose details have been mentioned in the
order dated 23.04.2026 and submits that out of 3 sale deeds which have
been exhibited, 50% of amongst them having highest value is to be taken
into consideration and therefore exhibit 1 and 1/1 would be relevant for
consideration and the average rate would come to Rs. 2,63,375/- per
decimal.
25.
Learned counsel for the appellants submits that apart from the
aforesaid amount, the statutory amount which has been included in the
Awards are also required to be re-calculated.
Findings of this Court
26.
The foundational facts are that the lands were acquired for
widening of road (four lane construction) from Ramgarh to Patratu dam
and the notification under section 11 of the aforesaid Act of 2013 was
2026:JHHC:22752
issued on 20.08.2018. The District Land Acquisition Officer fixed the
compensation at Rs. 88,69,400/- per acre or Rs.88,694/- per decimal and
by the impugned judgment, the compensation has been enhanced to Rs.
1,00,00,000/- per acre or Rs.1,00,000/- per decimal.
27.
The core issue to be decided in this case is –
Whether the determination of compensation by the
learned court of the Principal District Judge -cumL.A.R.R.A., Hazaribag is in conformity with the
provisions of section 26 of the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013?
28.
The acquisition of land in the present case is admittedly governed
by the provisions of the aforesaid Act of 2013 and the compensation has
to be determined under the aforesaid Act of 2013 in terms of section 26
of the Act. The sections relevant for the present case are sections 11, 26
and 27 of the Act of 2013.
The impugned judgement
29.
The learned court, while enhancing the compensation from
Rs.88,69,400/- per acre to Rs.1 crore per acre, has simply stated that the
claimants are entitled to enhanced compensation on the ground of
proximity to connecting roads, school etc., potentiality of the land for
future use, nature of land and other sale deeds. The learned court further
noted that certain sale-deeds were proved on behalf of the claimants and
came to the conclusion that the average rate of land in the said locality
for determination of the compensation should be enhanced to
Rs.1,00,00,000/- (Rs. One crore) per acre, from Rs.88,69,400/- per acre.
The learned court has enhanced the compensation on ad-hoc basis
without referring to the rate at which the exemplar and comparable saledeeds i.e., the aforesaid three sale-deeds exhibited by P.W. 2, were
executed. There is no discussion in the impugned judgment as to what
was the rate at which the land covered by the aforesaid sale-deeds of the
same village and also adjoining to the road were sold. This court is of
the considered view that the impugned judgement passed by the
learned court is perverse on account of incomplete appreciation of
materials on record and non-consideration of the sale value of the land
2026:JHHC:22752
covered by the sale deeds exhibited by the claimants for the purposes of
coming to the market value of the acquired lands.
Considerations of the materials on record.
30.
From the side of the claimants, two witnesses have been
examined. So far as P.W. 1 is concerned, he has stated that the
government has acquired 0.02 acre of land along with land of other
raiyats situated in Mouza Pochra for the purpose of strengthening and
widening the road from Patratu Dam to Ramgarh. He stated that
compensation was fixed at lower rate than the prevailing market rate and
he and other raiyats had objected. He has further stated that the property
lies under Ward No.7 of Ramgarh Cantonment. There has been
considerable development and progress in Ramgarh town and the land is
situated adjacent to Punjab Regiment having all amenities and facilities.
This witness has further stated that adjoining land was acquired at higher
rate of compensation. He has also stated that the land situated on the side
of Ramgarh road are commercial land and their market value is very
high to the extent of Rs.8,00,000/- to Rs.10,00,000/- per decimal at the
time of acquisition. The raiyats were demanding compensation @ Rs. 5
crore per acre. The government determined the compensation by treating
the same as underdeveloped and rural area, although the location of the
property is surrounded by developed area and all amenities of
urbanization like electricity, water, roads, medical center, school,
college, hospital, banks, markets, shopping centers, post office,
residential colony of CCL, Jindal Steel Power Plant, railway station,
Barkakana Junction, glass factory, several sponge iron factories and
Patratu Thermal Power Plant are available in their village.
During cross-examination, P.W. 1 admitted that the acquired land was
Tand and he stated that children from his village attend school at
Cantonment board and they attend Ramgarh High School and Ramgarh
College and they travel by road and rail. In case they fall sick, they go to
Pochra for treatment and then to Ramgarh. He also stated during crossexamination that there were facilities in their village even before the road
was widened by the government.
2026:JHHC:22752
31.
So far as P.W. 2 is concerned, she has also stated that her land was
acquired for the purpose of strengthening and widening the road from
Patratu Dam to Ramgarh. She exhibited sale-purchase document of land
of village- Pochra vide sale deed No.773 dated 26.02.2018 and stated
that the acquired land was identical to the said land being adjacent to the
road on the eastern side. She also cited two more sale-deeds of the same
village bearing Deed No.1635 dated 08.08.2016 and Deed No.1593
dated 21.12.2017 and stated that all the aforesaid properties sold through
the deeds are adjacent to the road and the land acquired is also situated
adjacent to the main road. She stated that the rate of compensation for
the acquired land should be at Rs. 2,60,000/- per decimal. She also stated
that for the land acquired vide another Land Acquisition Case
No.03/2018-2019, compensation was paid @ Rs. 2,88,000/- per decimal.
Mouza – Pochra lies in ward no. 7 of Ramgarh cantonment and Ramgarh
town has progressed considerably towards Mouza Pochra from before
and has developed, urbanized and has all amenities and facilities. The
Sikh Regiment Centre and Punjab Regiment Centre are situated in
Mouza Pochra and Mouza Ramgarh in Ramgarh district since the year
1940-41.
During cross-examination, P.W. 2 stated that the sale-purchase of land
was not made by her, but it was done by her relatives. The land which
was acquired was Tand and Parti land. Children from Pochra Mouza
attend the Pochra government school and they attend the government
college in Ramgarh for higher education. She further admitted that they
get treatment from cantonment hospital at Ramgarh and they travel from
Pochra to Ramgarh on foot or by vehicle. She denied the suggestion that
the distance from Pochra to Ramgarh was very long.
32.
So far as opposite parties are concerned, only one witness was
examined on their behalf who also stated that the acquisition was
relating to construction of four lane road and the land of village Pochra
has been acquired for construction and widening of four lane road from
Ramgarh to Patratu dam. He asserted that there is no basic facility in
village Pochra and the collector has rightly determined the compensation
on the basis of prevailing market rate and the government had spent a lot
2026:JHHC:22752
in expanding the road which has been acquired for public purpose. This
witness admitted during his cross-examination that village Pochra falls
under the cantonment board and the acquired land is situated at a
distance of 2 - 2½ kilometers from Subhash Chowk, Ramgarh and
village Pochra is adjacent to village Ramgarh. He further admitted that
distance of Ramgarh Army School from the acquired land is just 1 KM.
Further, the Punjab Regiment and Sikh Regiment are located in Ramgarh
and Punjab Regiment Centre is situated adjacent to the acquired land. He
further admitted that he never got a chance to visit the village Pochra but
he had gone on the road from Village Ramgarh to Patratu dam and the
cantonment board provides drainage, roads and electricity to all villages.
In his cross-examination, the sole witness from the side of opposite
parties stated that he did not know as to why the District Land
Acquisition Officer did not take into consideration the three sale-deeds
which were exhibited by the P.W. 2 while determining the market value
of land. He also admitted that big houses and shops have been built on
both sides of the road constructed by the department and large buildings
have been built adjacent to the acquired land. He also admitted that
existing road was more than 50 years old.
33.
The evidence of the claimants reveal that the acquired property
is in ward no. 7 of village Pochra and they were acquired for widening
of road, meaning thereby that the acquired property was itself adjacent
to the existing road. They have also produced three sale-deeds with
respect to the same locality which were also said to be adjacent to the
road. They have also stated that Mouza Pochra is adjoining to
Ramgarh cantonment and is near Sikh Regiment Centre and Punjab
Regiment Centre. These evidences remained uncontroverted during
their cross-examination. Thus, the witnesses of the claimants have
proved the location of the land being adjacent to the road and have
also proved the sale deeds which were also adjoining to the existing
road.
34.
The evidence of the aforesaid witness on the behalf of the
opposite parties reveals that the acquired land was adjacent to the
existing road and was acquired for the purpose of widening of road.
2026:JHHC:22752
The location of the land was quite close to Ramgarh town and it was in
the vicinity of the cantonment area. The cantonment board provided
drainage, road and electricity to all the villages. The witness, during
his cross-examination, could not explain as to why the District Land
Acquisition Officer did not take into consideration the three deeds
exhibited by P.W. 2 while determining the market value of the land.
35.
In view of the aforesaid evidences placed on record, this Court
finds that the location of the acquired land was adjacent to the existing
road and the same was acquired for the purpose of widening of the road;
three deeds which were exhibited by P.W. 2 were apparently not
considered while fixing the compensation and the sole witness on behalf
of the opposite parties had no answer as to why these deeds were not
considered which were also belonging to village Pochra and were also
adjacent to the road. The claimants have successfully demonstrated that
the compensation as fixed by the District Land Acquisition Officer was
not as per the prevailing market value, inasmuch as, even the three deeds
of the same village which were admittedly executed within 3 years prior
to issuance of notification under section 11 of the aforesaid Act of 2013
were not taken into consideration while fixing the compensation.
36.
In connection with the mode and manner of computation of
market value of the acquired lands, it would be relevant to refer to
section 26 of the aforesaid Act of 2013 wherein three modes for
determination of compensation have been provided which are –
d) Circle rate; or
e) the average sale price for similar type of land
situated in the nearest village or nearest vicinity
area; or
f) consented amount of compensation as agreed
upon.
whichever is higher.
For the purpose of determination of compensation in terms of Section 26
of the aforesaid Act of 2013, three modes, as explained above, under
Section 26(1)(a), 26 (1)(b) and 26(1)(c) have been prescribed and
2026:JHHC:22752
whichever is of higher value amongst them, is to be taken into
consideration.
As per explanation 1 to section 26 of the Act of 2013, the average sale
price referred to in clause (b) shall be determined taking into account the
sale deeds or the agreement of sale registered for similar type of area in
the nearby village or near vicinity area during immediately preceding
three years.
As per explanation 2, for determining the average sale price referred to
in explanation 1, half of the total number of sale deeds or the agreements
of sale, in which highest sale price has been mentioned, shall be taken
into account.
37.
The circle rate of the area has not been brought on record and
three sale-deeds have been brought on record by the claimants, but the
learned court has not taken care to calculate the average sale-price with
respect to the deeds which were exhibited. As per explanation -1 to
section 26 of the aforesaid act of 2013, it has been provided that one-half
of the total number of sale deeds or the agreements to sell in which the
highest sale price has been mentioned shall be taken into account for the
purposes of fixation of compensation. Since, three sale-deeds have been
produced by the claimants which remained undisputed and no sale-deeds
have been brought on record by the opposite parties nor they have
demonstrated as to how the compensation was fixed and which all saledeeds were taken into consideration for that purpose and the sole witness
of the respondents could not explain as to why the District Land
Acquisition Officer did not take into consideration the aforesaid three
sale-deeds which were exhibited by the P.W. 2 while determining the
market value of land, the learned court ought to have taken the three
sale-deeds into consideration and 50% of the three sale-deeds amongst
them having highest value was required to be taken into consideration
for arriving at the market value of the acquired land.
Computation of rate of compensation of the acquired land
38.
Apart from the aforesaid, it is also required to be seen as to which
of the sale deeds, amongst the 3 sale deeds exhibited by the claimants,
fall within the relevant period i.e. 3 years prior to notification dated
2026:JHHC:22752
20.08.2018 issued under section 11 of the aforesaid Act of 2013 i.e., the
period between 20.08.2015 to 19.08.2018 to be eligible for consideration
for the purpose of taking average rate of ½ of such eligible sale deeds.
The competent authority had fixed compensation at flat rate for the
entire village and the trial court has also fixed compensation at flat rate
but the rate has been enhanced.
39.
The aforesaid chart regarding the three sale deeds exhibited by the
claimants reveals that they all fall within the period of 3 years prior to
the date of notification under section 11 of the aforesaid Act of 2013.
This Court finds that all the aforesaid sale deeds are related to village
Pochra , which is the village involved in the present case, and are falling
within the period from 20.08.2015 to 19.08.2018 and therefore, are
within the zone of consideration for calculating the average rate for the
acquired land.
Half of such eligible sale deeds would be 1 and ½ and therefore 2 sale
deeds having higher value per decimal are to be taken into consideration
for computing the compensation. They would be exhibit-1 and 1/1.
40.
In view of the materials placed on record, the market value to find
the compensation of the acquired land is fixed in the following manner:
Exhibit
Deed No.
Exhibit-1
1635 dated Pochara
24.07.2016
773 dated Pochara
01.06.2018
1593 dated Pochara
21.12.2017
Exhibit
1/1
Exhibit
1/2
Village
Amount
(Rs.)
10,12,000/-
1 decimal
(Rs.)
2,53,000/-
1 Acre
(Rs.)
2,53,00,000/-
10,95,000/-
2,73,750/-
2,73,75,000/-
6,75,000/-
2,25,000/-
2,25,00,000/-
Out of the aforesaid three sale-deeds, 50% of them of the highest value is
to be taken into consideration and therefore, exhibit- 1 and 1/1 are
required to be taken into consideration. The average sale-price per
decimal by considering exhibit- 1 and 1/1 would come to Rs. 2,63,375/-,
calculation of which is as under:
Rs. 2,53,000/- + Rs. 2,73,750/- = Rs.5,26,750/Rs. 5,26,750/- ÷2 = Rs. 2,63,375/-.
Accordingly, the rate of compensation, as fixed by the learned court, is
further enhanced to Rs. 2,63,375/- per decimal.
2026:JHHC:22752
41.
The appeals filed by the claimants are allowed by enhancing the
rate of compensation with respect to the acquired land from
Rs. 1,00,000/- per decimal to Rs. 2,63,275/- per decimal. The claimants
would be entitled to all statutory benefits provided under the provisions
of the aforesaid Act of 2013 as granted in the impugned awards at the
enhanced rate of compensation with respect to the acquired land in
connection with which there is no dispute.
42.
Office to prepare decree.
43.
This court has adopted the same mode and manner of calculation
under the aforesaid Act of 2013 as has been interpreted and adopted by
this court in F.A. No. 52 of 2026 and analogous cases vide judgment
dated 30.03.2026 against which the Special Leave Petition being SLP
(C) No. 15181 of 2026 has been dismissed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court vide order dated 18.05.2026.
44.
Pending interlocutory application, if any, is closed.
45.
Let the records received from the learned court concerned be sent
back.
46.
Let this Judgment be communicated to the concerned court
through “Fax/E-mail”.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Date of Judgment: 31.07.2026
Pankaj/
Date of Uploading:01.08.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review