Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 19.08.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010878882025
+
CM(M) 2147/2025 & CM APPL. 70221/2025 (Stay)
SWAPNIL
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Saurabh Mishra, Senior
Advocate along with Mr. Lave
Kumar
Sharma,
Ms.
Deepshikha, Ms. Yashi Porwal
and Ms. Aarushi, Advocates.
versus
SAU NAMITA
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Rajat Kapoor, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
%
1.
JUDGEMENT (Oral)
The present Petition has been filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 seeking quashing/setting aside of the
Order dated 06.09.20251 passed by the learned Principal Judge,
Family Court, East District, Karkardooma, Delhi in S.M.A Case
No. 13/2022.
2.
The Impugned Order dated 06.09.2025 allows the Application
filed by the respondent under Order IX Rule 7 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 [“CPC”] read with Section 151 of the CPC and,
consequently, sets aside the Order dated 22.03.2023 whereby the
Impugned Order
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
respondent had been proceeded ex-parte.
3.
Mr. Saurabh Mishra, learned Senior Counsel appearing on
behalf of the Petitioner assails the Impugned Order primarily on the
ground that the application under Order IX Rule 7 CPC was not
maintainable at the stage at which it came to be filed.
4.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioner
submits that the hearing of the matter had already concluded and the
matter had been reserved for pronouncement of judgment. Reliance is
placed, in this regard, upon the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Arjun Singh v. Mohindra Kumar2, Rasikalal Manikchand
Dhariwal and Anr v. MSS Food Products3 and Bhanu Kumar Jain
v. Archana Kumar & Anr.4, wherein it has been held that an
Application under Order IX Rule 7 for setting aside an ex-parte order
is not maintainable after a matter is reserved for judgment.
5.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioner
submits that the order-sheets of the proceedings demonstrate that the
Respondent was proceeded ex parte on 22.03.2023 and that the matter
thereafter proceeded further. The matter was thereafter put up on
24.05.2023 and subsequently on 22.07.2023 and finally on 21.08.2023
on which date final arguments were heard and the matter was directed
to be put up for judgments on 15.09.2023.
6.
The Order dated 21.08.2023 reads as follows:“Present: Sh. L.K. Sharma, Ld. Counsel for the
petitioner with petitioner in person.
None for respondent. Respondent is already ex -parte.
Written arguments has already been filed. Final
arguments heard.
Put up for judgment on 15.09.2023.”
AIR 1964 SC 993
(2012) 2 SCC 196
(2005) 1 SCC 787
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
7.
It is further submitted that, thereafter, on 25.08.2023, i.e. after
the matter had been heard and reserved for pronouncement of
judgment, the Respondent instituted the application under Order IX
Rule 7 read with Section 151 CPC. The said application was taken up
on 28.08.2023. The learned Trial Court, while noticing the question
concerning the maintainability of the application, observed that the
same involved a mixed question of law and fact, permitted the parties
to file their respective responses and referred the matter to mediation.
8.
The matter could not be resolved through mediation. The
question concerning the maintainability of the application under Order
IX Rule 7 CPC was thereafter heard by the learned Trial Court on
17.09.2024 and on subsequent dates. The Impugned Order came to be
passed on 06.09.2025, whereby the learned Trial Court allowed the
application principally on the ground that the Respondent had engaged
an Advocate, who had allegedly failed to inform her of the progress of
the proceedings. The learned Trial Court also took into consideration
the fact that the Respondent had earlier approached the Hon'ble
Supreme Court for transfer of the proceedings and, consequently,
found that she deserved indulgence in the interests of justice.
The relevant portion of the Impugned Order reads as under:“7. 1 have heard the submissions and carefully perused the record.
8. It is a settled principle of law that if a party shows sufficient
cause for non-appearance, the Court may set aside the ex-parte
proceedings.
9. In the present case, the stand of the respondent/applicant/wife
is that though she had engaged an Advocate, he failed to defend
her case and also did not inform her about the progress of the
matter.
10. The record shows that the case was transferred to this Court
on 05.05.2022 pursuant to the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s order
dated 27.01.2022. Thereafter, notice was issued to the
respondent’s Counsel, and Sh. Sambhav Shekhar entered
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
appearance on 09.01.2023 by filing vakalatnama. However, on
17.02.2023 and 22.03.2023, there was no appearance on behalf of
the respondent, and consequently she was proceeded ex-parte.
The case then proceeded to ex-parte evidence, and ultimately, on
28.08.2023, the present application for setting aside ex-parte order
was filed. During this time, the matter was also referred to
mediation, which, however, not settled.
11. Considering the averments in the application, particularly that
the applicant/respondent/wife had indeed engaged an Advocate
who has not informed her about the proceedings, I do not find any
strong ground to disbelieve her version. More so, as she had
herself taken steps earlier by approaching the Hon’ble Supreme
Court for transfer of the case, which indicates her intent to contest
the proceedings. Although it is true that a litigant must be vigilant
and cannot completely abdicate responsibility to the Advocate,
keeping in view that the respondent is a layperson and a destitute
woman, she deserves some indulgence of this Court. In the
interest of justice, therefore, the application merits acceptance.
12. In view of the above, the application for setting aside the exparte order dated 22.03.2023 is allowed, subject to costs of
Rs.10,000/- (Rs.5,000/- to be deposited with DLSA by the
respondent/applicant/wife and Rs.5,000/- to be paid by her to the
petitioner/non-applicant/husband).
13. Accordingly, the application under Order IX Rule 7 read with
Section 151 CPC filed by the respondent/applicant/wife stands
disposed of in the above terms.”
9.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
Respondent relies upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Lal Devi & Anr. vs Vaneeta Jain & Ors.5, particularly paragraph nos.
14, 15 and 16, to submit that the Hon’ble High Court has the power to
set aside ex-parte decree in an Appeal preferred against the decree.
ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION:
10.
This Court has heard learned counsel for the parties and, with
their able assistance, perused the relevant order-sheets as also the
Impugned Order.
11.
At the outset, it would be apposite to examine the statutory
scheme governing an application under Order IX Rule 7 of the CPC.
2007 (7) SCC 200
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
Order IX of the CPC deals with the consequences flowing from the
non-appearance of parties on the date fixed for hearing and provides
distinct remedies depending upon the stage at which such nonappearance occurs.
12.
Order IX Rule 6 CPC contemplates a situation where, upon the
matter being called for hearing, the Plaintiff appears but the Defendant
does not appear. Depending upon the circumstances relating to the
service of summons, the Court may either proceed ex parte against the
Defendant, direct issuance of fresh summons or postpone the hearing.
Where the Court proceeds ex parte against the Defendant, the
proceedings do not, by themselves, come to an end. The suit may
thereafter continue ex parte, with the Plaintiff being permitted to lead
evidence and address arguments in support of the relief sought.
13.
It is at this stage that Order IX Rule 7 CPC becomes relevant.
The Rule contemplates a situation where the Court has adjourned the
hearing of the suit ex parte and the Defendant appears at or before
such hearing and assigns good cause for his previous non-appearance.
Upon the Court being satisfied as to the existence of such good cause,
the Defendant may be permitted to participate in the proceedings and
be heard in answer to the suit, subject to such terms as to costs or
otherwise as the Court may deem appropriate.
14.
The language of Order IX Rule 7 CPC is significant. The Rule
proceeds on the premise that, notwithstanding the order directing the
suit to proceed ex parte, the hearing of the suit is still continuing and
has been adjourned to a subsequent date for further hearing. Thus, the
jurisdiction under Order IX Rule 7 CPC is essentially remedial in
nature and enables a Defendant, who had initially remained absent and
against whom ex parte proceedings had been directed, to re-enter the
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
proceedings before the hearing has concluded, provided sufficient
cause is shown for the earlier non-appearance. Order IX Rule 7 of the
CPC reads as under:
“7. Procedure where defendant appears on day of adjourned
hearing and assigns good cause for previous nonappearance.—Where the Court has adjourned the hearing of the
suit, ex parte, and the defendant, at or before such hearing appears
and assigns good cause for his previous non-appearance, he may,
upon such terms as the Court directs as to costs or otherwise, be
heard in answer to the suit as if he had appeared on the day fixed
for his appearance.”
15.
The statutory scheme, however, draws a clear distinction
between a proceeding which is continuing ex parte and one in which
the hearing itself has already concluded. Order IX Rule 7 CPC
operates in the former situation. Once the evidence has been
concluded, arguments have been heard and nothing remains to be done
except the pronouncement of judgment, the hearing of the suit comes
to an end and the stage contemplated under Order IX Rule 7 CPC no
longer survives.
16.
The distinction, therefore, is between a matter which has been
“adjourned for hearing” and a matter in which the “hearing has
concluded” and the matter has merely been kept for pronouncement of
judgment. In the former situation, the Defendant may, subject to the
requirements of the Rule, invoke Order IX Rule 7 CPC by appearing
at or before the next date of hearing and showing good cause for the
previous non-appearance. In the latter situation, however, there is no
further hearing of the suit to which the Defendant can seek entry under
Order IX Rule 7 CPC.
17.
An adjournment for the purposes of pronouncement of
judgment is, therefore, fundamentally distinct from an adjournment
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
for hearing of the suit. The expression “Where the Court has
adjourned the hearing of the suit, ex parte”, occurring in Order IX
Rule 7 CPC, cannot be construed to include every adjournment
occurring after a party has been proceeded ex parte. The adjournment
contemplated by the Rule must be an adjournment of the hearing
itself. Where the hearing has concluded and the matter is adjourned
merely for pronouncement of judgment, there remains nothing further
to be heard in the suit and, consequently, Order IX Rule 7 CPC has no
application.
18.
The remedies available under Order IX are, thus, dependent
upon the procedural stage reached in the proceedings. Prior to the
conclusion of the hearing, a Defendant who has been proceeded ex
parte may appear and seek to participate in the proceedings by
invoking Order IX Rule 7 CPC and demonstrating good cause for the
previous non-appearance. However, once an ex parte decree has been
passed, the CPC provides a separate and distinct remedy under Order
IX Rule 13 CPC for setting aside such decree, subject to the fulfilment
of the conditions stipulated therein.
19.
Order IX Rule 7 CPC and Order IX Rule 13 CPC, therefore,
operate in distinct fields and at different procedural stages. While
Order IX Rule 7 CPC is concerned with restoring the Defendant's
participation during the pendency of the hearing of the suit, Order IX
Rule 13 CPC comes into operation after an ex parte decree has been
passed. The statutory scheme does not contemplate an intermediate
stage, after the conclusion of the hearing but before the
pronouncement of judgment, at which stage an application under
Order IX Rule 7 CPC can be maintained.
20.
The legal position in this regard stands authoritatively settled by
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Arjun Singh (supra). The Hon'ble
Supreme Court, while examining the scheme of Order IX Rule 7, held
that once the hearing of the suit has been completed, the Code
contemplates no intervening stage between completion of hearing and
pronouncement of judgment at which an application under Order IX
Rule 7 can be maintained. The Court specifically observed that, after
completion of hearing, the matter stands at the stage of
pronouncement of judgment and the remedy under Order IX Rule 7 is
no longer available. The relevant finding of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court reads as under:“18. So far as the case before us is concerned the order under appeal
cannot be sustained even on the basis that the finding recorded in
disposing of an application under O. IX Rule 7 would, operate as res
judicata when the same question of fact is raised in a subsequent
application to set aside an exparte decree under Order IX, Rule 13.
This is because it is not disputed that in order to operate as res
judicata, the court dealing with the first matter must have had
jurisdiction and competency to entertain and decide the issue.
Adverting to the facts of the present appeal, this would primarily turn
upon the proper construction of the terms of Order IX. Rule 7. The
opening words of that rule are, as already seen, Where the Court has
adjourned the hearing of the suit exparte. Now, what do these words
mean? Obviously they assume that there is to be a hearing on the date
to which the suit stands adjourned. If the entirety of the "hearing" of
the suit has been completed and the Court being competent to
pronounce the judgment then and there, adjourns the suit merely for
the purpose of pronouncing judgment under Order XX. Rule 1, there
is clearly no adjournment of "the hearing" of the suit, for there is
nothing more to be heard in the suit. It was precisely this idea that was
expressed by the learned Civil Judge when he stated that having
regard to the stage which the suit had reached the only proceeding in
which the appellant could participate was to hear the judgment
pronounced and that on the terms of Rules 6 and 7 he would permit
him to do that. If, therefore the hearing Was completed and the suit
was not "adjourned for hearing", Order IX. Rule 7 could have no
application and the matter would stand at the stage of Order IX. Rule
6 to be followed up by the passing of an exparte decree making Rule
13 the only provision in order IX applicable. If this were the correct
position, it would automatically follow that the learned Civil Judge
would have no jurisdiction to entertain the application dated May 31,
1958 purporting to be under Order IX. Rule 7, or pass any order
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
thereon on the merits. This in its turn would lead to the result that the
application under Order IX, Rule 13 was not only Competent but had
to be heard on the merits without reference to the findings contained
in the previous order.”
(emphasis supplied)
21.
The aforesaid principle was thereafter reiterated by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Rasiklal Manikchand Dhariwal (supra) whereby
the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that once the hearing of the suit is
concluded and the suit is closed for judgment, Order IX Rule 7 has no
application. The Court further clarified that the adjournment of a
matter for purposes of pronouncement of judgment is not an
adjournment of the hearing of the suit within the contemplation of
Order IX Rule 7. The relevant finding of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
reads as under:“41. The contention, at the first blush, appears to be attractive but
has no substance at all. In the first place, once the hearing of the suit
is concluded, and the suit is closed for judgment, Order 9 Rule 7 of
the Code has no application at all. The very language of Order 9
Rule 7 makes this clear. This provision presupposes the suit having
been adjourned for hearing. The courts, time out of number, have
said that adjournment for the purposes of pronouncing judgment is
no adjournment of the "hearing of the suit". On 17-3-2005, the trial
court in the present case did four things, namely, (1) closed the
evidence of the plaintiff as was requested by the plaintiff; (ii)
ordered the suit to proceed ex parte as the defendants failed to appear
on that date; (il) heard the arguments of the advocate for the
plaintiff; and (iv) kept the matter for pronouncement of judgment on
28-3-2005. In view of the above, Order 9 Rule 7 of the Code has no
application at all and it is for this reason that the application made by
the defendants under this provision was rejected by the trial court.
42. Secondly, once the suit is closed for pronouncement of judgment,
there is no question of further proceedings in the suit. Merely
because the defendants continued to make application after
application and the trial court heard those applications, it cannot be
said that such appearance by the defendants is covered by the
expression "appeared on the day fixed for his appearance" occurring
in Order 9 Rule 7 of the Code and thereby entitling them to address
the court on the merits of the case.”
(emphasis supplied)
22.
The distinction is, therefore, between a matter which has been
adjourned for hearing and a matter in which the hearing itself has
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
concluded and the matter has merely been kept for pronouncement of
judgment. In the former situation, an application under Order IX Rule
7 may be maintainable subject to the requirements of the Rule. In the
latter, the stage contemplated by Order IX Rule 7 has already passed.
23.
The statutory scheme, when read in conjunction with the
aforesaid decisions, thus envisages distinct stages. First, where a
Defendant fails to appear and the Court directs the matter to proceed
ex parte under Order IX Rule 6 CPC. Secondly, where the ex parte
proceedings are still continuing and the hearing of the suit has been
adjourned for hearing, the Defendant may invoke Order IX Rule 7
CPC by appearing at or before such hearing and assigning good cause
for the previous non-appearance. Thirdly, where the hearing has
concluded, and the matter has been reserved for pronouncement of
judgment, the jurisdiction under Order IX Rule 7 CPC is no longer
available. Upon the passing of an ex parte decree, the Defendant may
avail such remedies as are available under law.
24.
The maintainability of an application under Order IX Rule 7
CPC is, therefore, not merely dependent upon whether the Defendant
has shown sufficient cause for the previous non-appearance. The
threshold requirement is that the application itself must be filed at a
stage contemplated by the Rule. Unless the hearing of the suit remains
pending and the matter has been adjourned for hearing, the jurisdiction
under Order IX Rule 7 CPC cannot be invoked. Consequently, before
examining whether sufficient cause has been made out, the Court must
first determine whether it retains the jurisdiction to entertain an
application under the said provision.
25.
It is in the aforesaid statutory and legal framework that the facts
of the present case are required to be examined.
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
26.
The order-sheet dated 21.08.2023 leaves little scope for doubt
as to the stage at which the matter stood when the application under
Order IX Rule 7 came to be filed. The order records that written
arguments had already been filed, final arguments had been heard and
the matter was directed to be put up for judgment on 15.09.2023.
Thus, by 21.08.2023, the hearing of the matter stood concluded.
27.
The application under Order IX Rule 7 was thereafter filed on
25.08.2023. The application was, therefore, not filed at a stage when
the hearing of the matter was still pending. It was filed after final
arguments had been heard and after the matter had been expressly
reserved for pronouncement of judgment.
28.
The learned Trial Court, while passing the Impugned Order, has
principally considered whether the Respondent had shown sufficient
cause for her previous non-appearance. The Impugned Order records
that the Respondent had engaged an Advocate, that the Advocate had
allegedly failed to defend her case or inform her about the progress of
the proceedings and that the Respondent had herself earlier
approached the Hon'ble Supreme Court for transfer of the
proceedings. On that basis, the learned Trial Court proceeded to
exercise discretion in her favour.
29.
The difficulty, however, is not with the manner in which the
learned Trial Court appreciated the explanation furnished by the
Respondent. The difficulty lies at a more anterior stage. Before
examining whether sufficient cause had been shown, the learned Trial
Court was required to consider whether an application under Order IX
Rule 7 was maintainable at all at the stage at which it had been filed.
30.
Once the hearing had concluded and the matter had been
reserved for judgment, the jurisdiction under Order IX Rule 7 was no
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
longer available. The question of whether the Respondent had
sufficient cause for her previous non-appearance consequently did not
arise for consideration under that provision.
31.
In this regard, the reliance placed by learned counsel for the
Respondent upon Lal Devi (supra) does not advance her case. In Lal
Devi, the Hon'ble Supreme Court was concerned with the power of the
High Court, while exercising appellate jurisdiction against an ex-parte
decree, to set aside such decree in the interests of justice. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court itself noticed that the learned District Judge could not
entertain an application under Order IX Rule 7, but held that this did
not prevent the High Court, in an appeal against the ex-parte decree,
from setting aside the decree.
32.
The power of the High Court, in an appeal against a decree
cannot be equated with the jurisdiction of the learned Trial Court to
entertain an application under Order IX Rule 7 after the hearing of the
matter had concluded. The two situations operate at different stages
and under different jurisdictional parameters. Admittedly, the order
under challenge is not the final decree.
33.
It is, therefore, not necessary for this Court to enter into the
merits of the explanation furnished by the Respondent for her previous
non-appearance. The issue before this Court is whether the learned
Trial Court could have exercised jurisdiction under Order IX Rule 7
on 06.09.2025 in respect of an application which had been filed after
final arguments had been heard and the matter had been reserved for
pronouncement of judgment.
34.
In view of the aforesaid position, this Court is of the view that
the learned Trial Court fell in error in entertaining and allowing the
application under Order IX Rule 7 CPC after reserving the matter for
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
pronouncement of Judgement. The Impugned Order, therefore, cannot
be sustained.
35.
In view thereof, the present Petition is required to be allowed.
36.
Accordingly, the Impugned Order dated 06.09.2025 is set aside.
The application filed by the Respondent under Order IX Rule 7 read
with Section 151 CPC shall stand dismissed as not maintainable at
that stage.
37.
The present Petition, along with all pending application(s), if
any, stands disposed of.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
AUGUST 19, 2026/nd/va
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
12:30:12
CM(M) 2147/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review