Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
Reserved on 29.04.2026
Delivered on 18.06.2026
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Criminal Misc Application No. 1667 of 2025
(under Section 528 of B.N.S.S.)
Swami Keshwanand
Versus
State Of Uttarakhand and Another
……….Applicant
………Respondent
---------------------------------------------------------------------Presence:-
Mr. A.K. Shukla, Mr. Kundan Rai, Mr. Mohd. Umar and Mr. Zakir Ali,
learned counsel for the applicant.
Mr. Prabhat Kandpal, learned A.G.A. for the State.
Mr. Siddhartha Singh, learned counsel for respondent no.2.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Per: Hon’ble Mr. Alok Mahra, J.
The C-528 Application No.1667 of 2025 has
been filed seeking quashing of the judgment/order dated
14.05.2024 passed by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge, Kotdwar in Criminal Revision No.03 of 2024 and
the order dated 19.07.2024 passed by the learned SubDivisional Magistrate, Yamkeshwar/Kotdwar, District
Pauri Garhwal under Section 145 Cr.P.C., along with the
entire proceedings of Case No.01 of 2022-23 initiated on
the basis of challani report dated 17.12.2022 submitted
by the Station House Officer, Police Station Laxman
Jhoola under Section 145 Cr.P.C. The applicant has also
prayed for stay of the effect and operation of the order
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
dated 19.07.2024 passed by the learned Sub-Divisional
Magistrate.
2.
Learned counsel for the applicant would
submit that the applicant had earlier filed C-528
Application No.77 of 2024 challenging the order dated
14.05.2024 passed by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge, Kotdwar in Criminal Revision No.03 of 2024,
whereby the revisional court remanded the matter to the
Sub-Divisional
Magistrate,
Yamkeshwar
for
fresh
adjudication of proceedings under Section 145 Cr.P.C. It
is submitted that despite having knowledge of pendency
of the said application before this Court, the learned
Sub-Divisional Magistrate proceeded to pass the order
dated 19.07.2024 directing delivery of possession of the
disputed property to respondent no.2. Consequently, the
earlier application was withdrawn with liberty to file a
fresh application challenging both the orders.
3.
Learned counsel for the applicant would
further submit that the applicant is the General
Secretary of Bharat Sadhu Samaj, a society registered
under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. According to
the applicant, he was appointed to the said post in the
year 2019 and has since been managing the ministerial
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
and administrative affairs of the Society; that, the
Bharat Sadhu Samaj was registered on 04.02.1957 and
its principal office is situated at Delhi; that, the Society
was constituted with the object of promoting cultural,
spiritual and social welfare activities across the country;
that, Bharat Sadhu Samaj owns various properties
across India, including land situated at Village Jok,
Tehsil Yamkeshwar, District Pauri Garhwal; that, the
land was leased by the Government of Uttar Pradesh to
Bharat Sadhu Samaj on 23.03.1960 for a period of
thirty years; that, initially, the leased land measured 42
Nali 11 Mutthi comprising Khasra Nos.34, 35 and 36;
that, subsequently, in the year 1978, the lease area was
reduced to 32 Nali 8 Mutthi; that, Bharat Sadhu Samaj
Adhyatmik Yoga Ashram was established on the said
land on 29.06.1962 for promoting the objects of the
Society.
4.
Learned counsel for the applicant would
further submit that there exists a permanent structure
over the leased property consisting of seventeen rooms
along with shops and open land; that, four shops were
allegedly entrusted to Swami Krishnanand and his
disciples for management purposes during their lifetime
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
under a document dated 29.06.1962; that, from time to
time, caretakers and managers were appointed for
supervision and maintenance of the Ashram and
adjoining
properties;
Rishiwaranand,
father
that,
of
Swami
respondent
Mahant
no.2,
was
appointed merely as a caretaker/manager by the then
General
Secretary,
Swami
Harinarayanand;
that,
according to the applicant, respondent no.2’s father was
a married person and, therefore, was not eligible to hold
office in the Society in view of the by-laws of Bharat
Sadhu Samaj, which provide that only persons free from
family ties may become members; that, respondent
no.2’s father had no authority to appoint respondent
no.2 as Treasurer of the Ashram and any such
appointment is illegal; that, after renewal of the lease for
another period of thirty years by the District Magistrate,
Pauri Garhwal, respondent no.2 and his father started
treating the Ashram property as their personal property;
that,
they
attempted
to
raise
a
multi-storeyed
commercial construction over the leased property by
obtaining approvals and sanctions in their personal
capacity and not in the name of the Society; that, such
acts were done with an intention to illegally grab the
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
property belonging to Bharat Sadhu Samaj.
5.
It is further submitted that upon learning
about these activities, a meeting of the Central Working
Committee of Bharat Sadhu Samaj was convened at
Haridwar on 05.06.2019 under the chairmanship of
Shankaracharya Swami Swaroopanand Saraswati; that,
in the said meeting, the applicant was appointed as
Acting
General
Secretary
in
place
of
Swami
Harinarayanand on account of his ill health; that, in the
said
meeting,
Swami
Mahant
Rishiwaranand
was
directed to hand over documents relating to the Ashram
and submit accounts regarding income and expenditure;
that, the Working Committee also allegedly resolved that
any authority earlier granted to him stood withdrawn;
that, thereafter, in a meeting of the National Working
Committee
held
on
12.12.2022
at
Haridwar,
the
applicant was appointed as National General Secretary
of Bharat Sadhu Samaj and was authorised to take
steps for removal of unauthorised occupants from the
Society
properties;
that,
pursuant
thereto,
by
authorization letter dated 13.12.2022, one Manoj Rajput
was temporarily authorised to manage the Ashram and
adjoining properties and to represent the Society in legal
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
proceedings.
6.
It
is
submitted
that
on
13.12.2022,
respondent no.2 lodged a complaint before Police Station
Laxman Jhoola alleging that the applicant along with
several persons forcibly entered the Ashram premises,
assaulted the staff, damaged property and removed
documents and valuables, however, according to learned
counsel, upon inquiry the police found the allegations to
be
false
and
17.12.2022
submitted
stating
a
that
challani
there
report
existed
a
dated
dispute
regarding possession and management of the property
and there was likelihood of breach of peace; that, on the
basis of the said report, proceedings under Section 145
Cr.P.C.
were
initiated;
that,
the
Sub-Divisional
Magistrate, Yamkeshwar/Kotdwar initiated proceedings
under Section 145 Cr.P.C. on 07.02.2023; that, both
parties filed written statements and led evidence; that,
respondent no.2 admitted in his cross-examination that
he was not present at the Ashram on the date of the
alleged
incident
and
also
failed
to
produce
any
documentary proof of his appointment as Treasurer of
the Society; that, despite the evidence on record, the
learned
Sub-Divisional
Magistrate
by
order
dated
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
06.04.2023 attached the disputed property in favour of
the State Government and appointed the Station House
Officer, Laxman Jhoola as Receiver; that, the said order
was challenged by respondent no.2 in Criminal Revision
No.03 of 2024, which was allowed by the revisional
court on 14.05.2024 and the matter was remanded for
fresh consideration.
7.
Learned counsel submits that the applicant
thereafter challenged the revisional order before this
Court. However, during pendency of the proceedings,
the Sub-Divisional Magistrate passed the impugned
order dated 19.07.2024 holding respondent no.2 to be in
possession of the disputed property and directing
restoration of possession in his favour; that, the dispute
between the parties essentially relates to management
and administration of a registered society and not to
possession of immovable property, therefore, according
to him, proceedings under Section 145 Cr.P.C. were
wholly misconceived and without jurisdiction; that, the
Assistant Registrar under the Societies Registration Act
is the competent authority to adjudicate disputes
relating to office bearers and management of the Society;
that, the Magistrate while exercising powers under
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
Section 145 Cr.P.C. cannot adjudicate questions of title
or ownership and is only required to ascertain actual
possession for the limited purpose of maintaining peace.
Reliance has been placed upon the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ashok Kumar vs. State of
Uttarakhand and Others, (2013) 3 SCC 366, wherein it
has been held that proceedings under Section 145
Cr.P.C. are preventive in nature and are intended only to
prevent breach of peace.
8.
Learned counsel submits that the entire
proceedings under Section 145 Cr.P.C. have been
initiated on incorrect assumptions and without there
being any genuine dispute regarding possession of land;
that, the property admittedly belongs to Bharat Sadhu
Samaj
and
the
dispute
merely
concerns
internal
management of the Society, therefore, the impugned
orders dated 14.05.2024 and 19.07.2024 are illegal,
arbitrary and liable to be quashed.
9.
Learned counsel for the State submits that
upon inquiry into the complaint dated 13.12.2022, the
police found that a serious dispute existed between the
rival parties regarding possession and management of
the Ashram property situated over Khasra Nos.65, 66,
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
67 and 68; that. considering the likelihood of breach of
peace, proceedings under Section 145 Cr.P.C. were
rightly initiated by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate; that.
that pursuant to the order dated 06.04.2023, the
disputed property was attached and possession was
taken by the Station House Officer, Laxman Jhoola on
13.04.2023, thereafter, the revisional court remanded
the matter and ultimately the Sub-Divisional Magistrate
by order dated 19.07.2024 held respondent no.2 to be in
possession and directed restoration thereof. However,
pursuant to interim orders passed by this Court,
possession presently remains with the police authorities.
10.
Learned counsel appearing for respondent
no.2 submits that Bharat Sadhu Samaj Adhyatmik Yoga
Ashram, Rishikesh has been functioning independently
since
and
regular
meetings
of
its
working
committee have been held from time to time; that,
various resolutions and minutes of meetings were relied
upon to show that Swami Rishiwaranand and thereafter
respondent no.2 had been managing the affairs of the
Ashram for several years; that, respondent no.2 and the
working committee have been regularly maintaining
accounts, conducting audits and carrying on the objects
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
of the Ashram; that, the lease of the property was
renewed in the name of Bharat Sadhu Samaj itself and
not in the individual name of any person; that the
resolutions dated 05.06.2019 and 12.12.2022 relied
upon by the applicant are forged and fabricated
documents. It is argued that the impugned orders have
already been acted upon and, therefore, the challenge to
the earlier orders has become infructuous.
11.
Learned counsel appearing for respondent
no.2 further submitted that the applicant himself has, in
several paragraphs of the affidavit filed in support of the
present
application,
admitted
the
possession
and
management of respondent no.2 and his father over the
property in dispute. The relevant admissions may be
summarised as follows:
(i) The applicant has admitted that the father of
respondent
no.2
was
functioning
as
the
caretaker/manager of Bharat Sadhui Samaj
Adhyatmik Yog Ashram, Rishikesh.
(ii) It has been admitted that the father of
respondent no.2 got the lease renewed pertaining
to the land, upon which the Ashram and its
appurtenant properties exist, renewed in his
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
favour. Significantly, the said renewal of lease
was never challenged by the applicant before
any competent forum.
(iii) The applicant has further admitted that
possession of the property was entrusted to
the father of respondent no.2 and thereafter
to
respondent
no.2
for
promoting
and
carrying forward the objects and activities of
the Ashram. Such admission unequivocally
demonstrates that respondent no.2 and his
father were in actual and physical possession
and control of the Ashram property.
(iv) The affidavit also contains an averment
that the applicant had subsequently taken
back the documents relating to the Ashram,
shops
and
market
from
the
father
of
respondent no.2. This statement itself accepts
that the respondent no.2 and his father were
in
possession
and
management
of
the
property and its records.
(v) It has further been averred that one Shri
Manoj Rajput was authorised by letter dated
13.12.2022 to look after the Ashram and its
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
properties. Learned counsel submits that Shri
Manoj Rajput is one of the tenants occupying
shops situated in the Ashram market and
that the eviction proceedings against him
have been upheld up to the Hon'ble Supreme
Court. It is further contended that the
incident relating to the alleged dispossession
of respondent no.2 and the complaint lodged
by him are also of 13.12.2022 itself, which
prima facie indicates that Shri Manoj Rajput,
acting under the purported authorization
dated 13.12.2022, along with his associates
and
musclemen,
entered
the
Ashram
premises without recourse to due process of
law and attempted to interfere with the
settled possession of respondent no.2.
12.
Learned counsel for respondent no.2 further
submitted that the applicant has sought to contend that
respondent no.2 has neither lawful ownership nor legal
possession over the Ashram property and that the
dispute pertains to rival claims regarding management
of
societies
and
allegations
of
forged
documents.
According to the learned counsel, all such questions
UKHC010147462025
involve
adjudication
of
2026:UHC:5023
disputed
rights,
title
and
management, which can only be determined in properly
instituted civil proceedings. These issues lie wholly
outside
the
limited
and
preventive
jurisdiction
exercisable under Section 145 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure.
13.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused the material available on record.
14.
The moot question that falls for determination
is whether respondent no.2 and his father were in actual
possession of the Ashram property on 13.12.2022 or
whether
they
had
been
forcibly
and
wrongfully
dispossessed within two months preceding the said
date.
15.
Section 145 of the Code forms part of the
preventive jurisdiction conferred upon an Executive
Magistrate
for
preservation
of
public
peace
and
tranquillity. The jurisdiction can be invoked only when
the Magistrate is satisfied from a police report or other
information that a dispute concerning land, water or
boundaries thereof exists and is likely to occasion a
breach of peace. The object of the provision is not to
adjudicate questions of ownership or proprietary rights
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
but merely to ascertain which of the rival parties was in
actual possession on the relevant date and to preserve
such possession until the rights of the parties are
determined by a competent civil court.
16.
The section contemplates a summary inquiry.
Upon recording satisfaction under sub-section (1), the
Magistrate is required to call upon the parties to put
forth
their
respective
claims
regarding
actual
possession. After considering the written statements,
documents and other materials produced by the parties,
the
Magistrate
has
to
determine
the
factum
of
possession without entering into the merits of competing
claims of title. The proviso to sub-section (4) specifically
empowers the Magistrate, where it appears that a party
has been forcibly and wrongfully dispossessed within
two months immediately preceding the date of receipt of
information or thereafter but prior to the preliminary
order, to treat such party as being in possession on the
date of the preliminary order. In cases of emergency,
Section 146 empowers the Magistrate to attach the
property and appoint a receiver until completion of the
proceedings. The orders passed under Sections 145 and
146 are temporary, preventive and provisional in nature
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
and continue to operate only until the rights of the
parties are finally adjudicated by a competent civil
court. Thus, the proceedings under Section 145 cannot
be converted into an adjudication of title, nor can they
be employed as a substitute for ordinary civil remedies.
17.
The inquiry under Section 145 is necessarily
summary and pragmatic. The Magistrate is required to
act expeditiously on the basis of available materials and
arrive
at
a
practical
conclusion
regarding
actual
possession. Strict rules of evidence applicable to regular
civil or criminal trials do not govern such proceedings.
The Magistrate may take into consideration affidavits,
contemporaneous
documents,
oral
statements
and
surrounding circumstances having probative value. The
consistent view of the Supreme Court is that the
determinative
factor
under
Section
is
actual
physical possession and not legal or constructive
possession arising merely from title documents. A
person may possess ownership papers, yet if another
person is in settled physical possession of the property,
the latter's possession deserves protection under the
provision. Even a person in settled possession cannot be
dispossessed except by due process of law. Overt acts
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
evidencing possession, such as management and control
of the property, erection of structures, payment of
charges and taxes, maintenance of accounts and
records,
employment
of
security
personnel
and
regulation of ingress and egress, constitute relevant
circumstances for determining actual possession. The
legislative intent underlying Section 145 is to ensure
that disputes relating to immovable property do not
degenerate into breaches of peace and public disorder.
18.
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Shanti Kumar Panda v. Shakuntala Devi, (2004) 1 SCC
438 has held that in proceedings under Section 145
Cr.P.C., the Magistrate is concerned solely with the
question of actual possession and is not required to
enter upon disputed questions of title or ownership. The
Hon’ble Court further held that possession may be
established not merely through title documents but also
through overt acts and conduct indicating control and
dominion over the property. Likewise, in M. Siddiq (D)
Thr. Lrs. v. Mahant Suresh Das & Ors., (2020) 1 SCC 1,
the
Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
reiterated
that
the
jurisdiction under Section 145 is founded upon the
existence of a dispute likely to occasion a breach of
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
peace and that the Magistrate's function is limited to
taking immediate preventive measures for preserving
public tranquillity and protecting the party shown to be
in actual possession.
19.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts
of the present case, the inquiry before the Magistrate
was confined to determining whether respondent no.2
and his father were in possession of the Ashram
property on 13.12.2022 or whether they had been
forcibly dispossessed within the preceding period of two
months. The contemporaneous materials, admissions
made by the applicant in his own affidavit, the conduct
of the parties and the sequence of events placed on
record disclose a continuous and consistent chain of
circumstances indicating that respondent no.2 and his
father were in settled possession and management of the
Ashram property. Their possession is reflected not only
from documentary material but also from acts of
management and control exercised over the property
and its affairs. Conversely, the applicant has failed to
place any convincing material demonstrating his own
actual and physical possession of the property on the
relevant date or any overt acts indicating exercise of
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
dominion and control over the same.
20.
Upon perusal of the impugned orders, this
Court finds that the learned Magistrate meticulously
examined the material placed on record and considered
the
contemporaneous
documents
and
surrounding
circumstances bearing upon the issue of possession.
Upon appreciation of the evidence, the Magistrate
recorded a finding that respondent no.2 was in settled
possession of the property on the relevant date. The
finding is based upon relevant material, is neither
arbitrary nor perverse, and accords with the settled
principles governing proceedings under Section 145
Cr.P.C.
21.
This Court, therefore, finds no illegality,
jurisdictional error or perversity in the impugned orders
warranting interference in exercise of powers under
Section 482 of the Code. The application being devoid of
merit deserves dismissal.
22.
Accordingly,
the
C-528
application
is
dismissed. No order as to costs.
23.
Consequently, the order dated 19.07.2024
passed by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Yamkeshwar,
shall be complied with forthwith. The Station House
UKHC010147462025
2026:UHC:5023
Officer, who has been appointed as Receiver in respect
of the property in question, is directed to hand over
possession of the property to respondent no.2 in terms
of the directions contained in the order passed by the
Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Yamkeshwar.
24.
Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
25.
Pending
applications,
if
any,
also
disposed of.
Mamta
(ALOK MAHRA,J.)
18.06.2026
MAMTA
RANI
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=6a812005bebfcf46f244f3e584af1449e430ef90
0bf09a6d67ebbd642671329b, postalCode=263001,
st=Uttarakhand,
serialNumber=5de1751a4f1d9cabfd54852c9e68911ca
8b66dd26690a191648ab5d8dd004ef0, cn=MAMTA
RANI
Date: 2026.06.18 15:48:19 +05'30'
stand
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review