Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 16.01.2026
+
ARB.P. 1301/2025
SWADESHI CIVIL INFRASTRUCTURE PVT LTD
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Dinkar Singh and Mr Rohit
Singh, Advocates.
versus
RITES LIMITED & ANR.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. G. S. Chaturvedi, Advocate
for Respondent No-1.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
%
JUDGEMENT (ORAL)
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
1.
The present petition has been filed under Section 11(6) of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 19961, for the appointment of an
Arbitrator to adjudicate upon a commercial dispute between the
parties.
2.
Learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner contends that the
Arbitration clause is set out at Clause 25 of the Agreement dated
22.08.2017, and which clause reads as under:
Act
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
14:30:47
ARB.P. 1301/2025
“CLAUSE 25
Settlement of Disputes & Arbitration
Except where otherwise provided in the Contract all questions and
disputes relating to the meaning of the specifications, design,
drawings and instructions herein before mentioned and as to the
quality of workmanship or materials used on the work or as to any
other question, claim, right, matter or thing whatsoever in any way
arising out of or relating to the Contract, designs, drawings,
specifications, estimates, instructions, orders or these conditions or
otherwise concerning the works or the execution or failure to
execute the same whether arising during the progress of the work
or after the cancellation, termination, completion or abandonment
thereof shall be dealt with as mentioned hereinafter:
1)
If the Contractor considers any work demanded of him to
be outside the requirements of the Contract, or disputes any
drawings, record or decision given in writing by the Engineer on
any matter in connection with or arising out of the Contract or
carrying out of the work, to be unacceptable, he shall promptly
within 15 days request the Engineer-in-Charge in writing for
written instruction or decision. Thereupon, the Engineer-in-Charge
shall give his written instructions or decision within a period of one
month from the receipt of the Contractor's letter.
If the Engineer-in-Charge fails to give his instructions or decision
in writing within the aforesaid period or if the Contractor is
dissatisfied with the instructions or decision of the Engineer-inCharge, the Contractor may, within 15 days of the receipt of the
Engineer-in-Charge decision, appeal to the Appellate Authority
specified in Schedule 'F' who shall afford an opportunity to the
Contractor to be heard, if the latter so desires, and to offer evidence
in support of his appeal. The Appellate Authority shall give his
decision within 30 days of receipt of Contractor's appeal. If the
Contractor is dissatisfied with this decision, the Contractor shall
within a period of 30 days from receipt of the decision, give notice
to the Appointing Authority specified in Schedule 'F' for
appointment of arbitratorfailing which the said decision shall be
final binding and conclusive and not referable to adjudication by
the arbitrator.
2)
Except where the decision has become final, binding and
conclusive in terms of Sub Para (1) above, disputes or difference
shall be referred for adjudication through arbitration by a sole
arbitrator appointed by the Appointing Authority. The selection of
Arbitrator by the Appointing Authority will be governed by the
fact whether the dispute is (i) between two Public Sector
Enterprises or (ii) between a Public Sector Enterprise and a
Government Department or (iii) Otherwise.
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
14:30:47
ARB.P. 1301/2025
In case the dispute does not fall under item (i) or (ii) of this Para
the Appointing Authority, shall appoint the sole Arbitrator. Within
30 days of receipt of notice from the Contractor to refer the dispute
for Arbitration, the Appointing Authority stipulated in Schedule F
shall send to the Contractor a list of three serving officers of
RITES of appropriate status depending on the total value of claim,
who have not been connected with the work under the Contract.
The Contractor shall, within 15 days of receipt of this list select
and communicate to the Appointing Authority, the name of one
officer from the list who shall then be appointed as the Sole
Arbitrator. the Contractor fails to communicate his selection of
name within the stipulated period, the Appointing Authority shall
without delay, select one officer from the list and appoint him as
the Sole Arbitrator.
3) In case the dispute falls under item (i) or (ii) of Sub Para (2)
above, the Appointing Authority shall refer the dispute for
Arbitration by one of the Arbitrators in the Department of Public
Enterprises to be nominated by the Secretary to the Govt. of India
in charge of the Department of Public Enterprises. The Arbitration
& Conciliation Act 1996 shall not be applicable to the Arbitration
in such a case. The Award of the Arbitrator shall be binding upon
the parties to the dispute, provided however that any party
aggrieved by such award may make a further reference for setting
aside or revision of the Award to the Law Secretary, Department of
Legal Affairs, Ministry of Law & Justice, Govt. of India. Upon
such reference, the dispute shall be decided by the Law Secretary
or the Special Secretary/Additional Secretary when so authorized
by the Law Secretary, whose decision shall bind the parties finally
and conclusively. The Parties to the dispute will share equally the
cost of Arbitration as intimated by the Arbitrator. The Arbitrator
shall make a speaking Award and the Award may be published on
plain paper. In the event of the Sole Arbitrator dying, neglecting or
refusing to act or being unable to act for any reason, it shall be
lawful for the Secretary to the Govt. of India in charge of the
Department of Public Enterprises to nominate another person in
place of the outgoing Arbitrator to act as Sole Arbitrator. The new
Arbitrator as appointed shall as far as practicable proceed from the
stage where it was left by the outgoing Arbitrator.
It is a term of this Contract that the party invoking arbitration shall
give a list of disputes with amount claimed in respect of each such
dispute along with the notice for appointment of arbitrator and
giving reference, to the rejection by the Appellate Authority of the
appeal in the form at Annexure 'F'. It is a term of this Contract that
"Excepted matters" or matters where the decision of the Engineerin-Charge or any higher authority has been stipulated as "Final and
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
14:30:47
ARB.P. 1301/2025
Binding" in various Clauses of Contract, stand specifically
excluded from the purview of Arbitration Clause.
It is also a term of this Contract that no person other than a person
appointed by such Appointing Authority as aforesaid should act as
arbitrator and if for any reason that is not possible, the matter shall
not be referred to arbitration at all. It is also a term of this Contract
that if the Contractor does not make any demand for appointment
of arbitrator in respect of any claims in writing as aforesaid within
120 days of receiving the intimation from the Engineer-in-Charge
that the final bill is ready for payment, the claim of the Contractor
shall be deemed to have been waived and absolutely barred and the
Employer shall be discharged and released of all liabilities under
the Contract in respect of these claims.
4) Obligation during pendency of arbitration
Work under the Contract shall unless otherwise directed by the
Engineer-in-Charge continue during the Arbitration proceeding and
no payment due or payable by the Employer shall be withheld on
account of such proceedings, provided however, it shall be open
for the Arbitrator to consider and decide whether or not such work
should continue during arbitration proceedings.
5) Signing of "No Claim" certificate
The Contractor shall not be entitled to make any claim whatsoever
against the Employer under or by virtue of or arising out of the
Contract, nor shall the Employer entertain or consider any such
claim if made by the Contractor after he shall have signed a "No
Claim Certificate" in favour of the Employer in such form as
stipulated by the Employer, after the works are finally measured
up. The Contractor shall be debarred from disputing the correctness
of any item covered by the "No Claim Certificate" or demanding a
reference to arbitration in respect thereof.
6) Parties to be impleaded in the arbitration proceedings
In case of any claims by the Contractor, the Employer as well as
RITES Ltd acting as
Agent to the Employer will implead themselves as parties to the
Arbitration Proceedings.
7) The arbitration shall be conducted in accordance with the
provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of
1996) or any statutory modifications or reenactment thereof and the
rules made there under and for the time being in force shall apply
to the arbitration proceeding under this clause, except for cases
falling under para 2 (i) or (ii).
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
14:30:47
ARB.P. 1301/2025
8) It is also a term of this Contract that the arbitrator shall
adjudicate on only such disputes as are referred to him by the
appointing authority and give separate award against each dispute
and claim referred to him and in all cases where the total amount of
the claims by any party exceeds Rs.1,00,000/- the arbitrator shall
give reasons for the award.
9) It is also a term of the Contract that where the arbitral award is
for the payment of money, no interest shall be payable on whole or
any part of the money for any period till the date on which the
award is made.
10) It is also a term of this Contract that the arbitrator shall indicate
i) the Award amount payable on the date of award
ii) the period within which it is to be paid and
iii) Simple rate of interest applicable beyond the stipulated free
period for making payment of Award amount.
11) It is also a term of the Contract that if any fees are payable to
the arbitrator these shall be paid equally by both the parties.
12) It is also a term of the Contract that the arbitrator shall be
deemed to have entered on the reference on the date he issues
notice to both the parties calling them to submit their statement of
claims and counter statement of claims. The venue of the
arbitration shall be such place as may be fixed by the arbitrator in
his sole discretion. The fees, if any, of the arbitrator shall, if
required to be paid before the award is made and published, be paid
half and half by each of the parties. The cost of the reference and of
the award (including the fees, if any, of the arbitrator) shall be in
the discretion of the arbitrator who may direct to any by whom and
in what manner, such costs or any part thereof shall be paid and fix
or settle the amount of costs to be so paid.”
3.
Learned counsel appearing for the Respondent submits that the
arbitration clause prescribes certain mandatory pre-conditions which
are required to be satisfied before a dispute can be referred to
arbitration. It is contended that the said pre-conditions have admittedly
not been complied with and, therefore, the present petition is
premature. In this regard, learned counsel specifically draws attention
to Clause 25(1) of the arbitration clause, submitting that the clause
contemplates a detailed two-tier mechanism, whereby, in the first
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
14:30:47
ARB.P. 1301/2025
instance, the dispute is required to be referred to the Engineer-inCharge, and upon failure thereof, an appeal is required to be preferred
before the designated Appellate Authority. It is urged that only upon
exhaustion of the said two-step process can recourse to arbitration be
taken.
4.
On these contentions, learned counsel for the Petitioner, after
placing reliance upon the letter dated 07.11.2024, which is annexed as
Document 14 along with the Petition, submits that the pre-arbitration
procedure had been complied with and that the letter had been sent to
Mr. Kailash Chand, Joint General Manager[“JGM”], RITES Ltd.
5.
He further relies upon the letter dated 30.12.2024, which is
annexed as Document No. 15 along with the Petition, and contends
that since the Engineer-in-Charge failed to respond, the Petitioner
thereafter invoked the Appellate mechanism in terms of the
Arbitration clause.
6.
Learned counsel for the Respondent, however, submits that the
definition of the Engineer-in-charge, which is set out in Clause 25 of
the conditions of the contract, provides for the General Manager
[“GM”] or the Group General Manager [“GGM”] as being the
necessary officers. He also submits that the Engineer-in-charge is the
General Manager, which he submits is on the basis of the specified
proforma, which is made under the heading of conditions of the
contract, wherein a tick mark is placed against the GM in clause 2(v).
7.
Learned counsel for the Respondent further submits that the
Appellate Authority, as prescribed under the applicable framework, is
the GGM. He then submits that neither the letter dated 07.11.2024 nor
the letter dated 30.12.2024 is addressed to the authorities as set out in
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
14:30:47
ARB.P. 1301/2025
the Arbitration clause, namely, the Engineer-in-Charge and the
Appellate Authority, and resultantly, the present petition is premature.
8.
This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties at
length and has carefully perused the contractual clauses relied upon by
them. Upon such consideration, this Court is of the considered view
that the present petition is premature.
9.
The reliance placed by the learned counsel for the Petitioner on
the
letter
dated
07.11.2024
is
misconceived,
as
the
said
communication was addressed to the JGM, who is not designated as
the Engineer-in-Charge under the terms of the Agreement. Similarly,
the letter dated 30.12.2024 was also addressed to the JGM and,
therefore, does not satisfy the contractual requirement stipulated under
the Agreement.
10.
In view thereof, it is evident that the Petitioner has failed to
comply with the mandatory pre-conditions prescribed under the
Agreement. Consequently, the present petition is liable to be
dismissed as premature, on account of non-compliance with the
contractual stipulations.
11.
As regards the contention of the learned counsel for the
Petitioner that the stipulated pre-condition is merely directory and not
mandatory, this Court finds the said submission to be misconceived.
12.
In the present case, the arbitration clause unequivocally
contemplates a two-step procedure, which has admittedly not been
complied with. The judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for
the Petitioner, Sri Ganesh Engineering Works v. Northern Railway
& Anr.2, particularly paragraph no. 12 thereof, in fact reinforces the
2024 SCC OnLine Del 8985
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
14:30:47
ARB.P. 1301/2025
prescribed procedure rather than supporting the Petitioner’s case.
13.
It is further contended on behalf of the Petitioner that, as is
evident from a reading of the aforesaid judgment, the conciliation
clause has been held to be largely directory and not mandatory, and
that non-invocation thereof would not disentitle the Petitioner from
preferring an application under Section 11(6) of the Act for
appointment of an Arbitrator.
14.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner also places reliance on the
judgment of this Court in Jhajharia Nirman Ltd. v. South Western
Railways, through Dy. Chief Engineer/IV Construction3, which
holds as follows:
“18. In numerous judicial precedents, this Court has taken the view
that any pre-condition in an arbitration agreement obliging one of
the contracting parties to either exhaust the pre-arbitral amicable
resolution avenues or to take recourse to Conciliation are directory
and not mandatory.”
15.
Upon a careful examination, it is evident that the aforesaid
judgments have no applicability to the present case. The decisions
relied upon by the Petitioner pertain to the pre-arbitral amicable or
conciliatory mechanisms, whereas, in the present matter, the
Agreement prescribes a specific and structured pre-arbitral procedure
for dispute resolution, which is neither conciliatory in nature nor
intended for amicable settlement.
16.
The said two-step pre-arbitration procedure, as stipulated under
the Agreement, is, in the considered view of this Court, mandatory
and not merely directory, and therefore cannot be waived or dispensed
with.
2024 SCC OnLine Del 7133
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
14:30:47
ARB.P. 1301/2025
17.
In light of the above, the objections raised by the learned
counsel for the Respondent are found to be well-founded and are
accordingly upheld. Consequently, the present petition is dismissed.
18.
No Order as to costs.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
JANUARY 16, 2026/v/kr/jk
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
14:30:47
ARB.P. 1301/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review