Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
#
$%& $ '
()
&$
(
)*
#
#
+,
)
*
RAMESH
MATHAPATI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!"!
#
$
%
!"! &'
-2-
(
)
!"!
&
#
$
*
&)
& !
$
%
! "
%
"
$
%
+
$
&
& & $
&'
& "
%
'
) $ % $ %
,""
)$ %
(
)
*
&
)-
! "
+
(
!-& &
$
%
!"!
&'
%
-3-
-'
!"! &
$
*
%
"
! "
$
$
%
+
+
! "
'
& , $
'
&)
& "
%
)$ %
)$ %$.%
,""
(
+, )
*
((
!"! &
$
%
!"! &'
%
-4-
)'
(
!"! ) &
$
%
"
! "
$
%
+
! "
+
$
&
& " $
&)
%
& '
%
'
)$ %$.%
,""
)$ %
(
/
/
123.
(
412351.
&&!&
& ! 25.
(
6785914
:<13 23>8=5> 97?1<=?1
:73
&&-!!
;23<=19
=5
& !
412351. 6785914 :73 <@1
;23<=19 98A?=< <@2< <@191 ;1<=<=759 ?2B A1 .=9?=991. 29 57<
;31991.
)
25.
5 C=1D 7: <@1 98A?=99=759
&&-!!
& ! 231
&&!&
& !
-5-
+, )
@=9 ;1<=<=75 =9 :=41. 85.13
2>23=E
832E9@2
2>2=59<
<@1
&
25@=<2
242A832>=
16<=75 ! " 7:
@232<=B2
7 &)
=5
;4
$ 7338;<=75%
& '% 31>=9<131. AB
74=61
:73 <@1 7::15619 ;85=9@2A41 85.13 916<=759 '
)$ %$.% 3 D
16<=75
)$ % 7:
,," $ :73 A31C=<B G
25.
#
& ) 911E=5> <7 F829@ ;37611.=5>9
;1<=<=7513 266891.
& " $ 3=?1
!
6<H%
199=759 (8.>1
!
31C15<=75 7:
7338;<=75
15.=5> 75 <@1 :=41
=9<3=6<
242A832>=
@1 2A3=.>1. :26<9 7: <@1 6291 231 <@2<
;1<=<=7513 266891. A1=5> 2 ;8A=6 913C25< D73E=5> 29
66785<25< =5
6<
2<<=
25>C=
=441>24 >32<=:=62<=75 7:
=442>1 75 &' &
! &&&
<@1
=442>1
& ' .1?25.1.
:37? 319;75.15<
67?;42=525< <7 9@7D 7::=6=24 :2C783 =5 319;16< 7: .141<=5> <@1
15.7391?15< 7: <@1
7:
1673. 7:
99=9<25<
7??=99=7513 :37?
=>@<9 =5 319;16< 7: 425. A123=5>
?12983=5> - 26319 ! >85<29 7:
2<<=
25>C=
B
748?5
=442>1
!
;83982561 7: 986@ .1?25. <@1 ;1<=<=7513 3161=C1. 25 2?785<
7:
9 - &&&
?=5=
=.@252
78.@2
(1D23>=
@1
-6-
67?;42=525<
2:<13 31673.=5> <@1 92=. .1?25. 25. ;2B?15<
47.>1. <@1 67?;42=5< A1:731 <@1 319;75.15<
3=?1
7 &)
85.13
& ' .2<1.
&&
74=61 =5
& ' :73 <@1 7::1561 ;85=9@2A41
16<=75 ' 7: <@1
6<
675.86<1. 2 <32; 7: <@1 ;1<=<=7513 D@=41 @1
&&
>32<=:=62<=75
& ' 2< 2A78< & / & ; ? 5123
D=<@=5 <@1 ;31?=919 7: ?=5=
<32;
;256@252?2
9 , &&&
D29
7:
15<389<?15<
9 , &&&
25.=5= 12
=.@252
.32D5
<@1
& '
;256@252?2
=441>24
675.86<=5>
&&
31?2=5=5>
2:<13
@1312:<13 75
319;75.15<
3161=C=5>
74=61
<244 9=<82<1.
78.@2 (1D23>=
25.
<2=5<1.
2<13
6833156B
7:
D29 3167C131. 2< <@1 =59<2561 7: <@1 ;1<=<=7513 25.
2:<13 67?;41<=5> <@1 =5C19<=>2<=75 319;75.15<
74=61 42=.
6@23>1 9@11< 2>2=59< <@1 ;1<=<=7513 :73 <@1 7::15619 ;85=9@2A41
85.13
16<=759 '
)$ %$.% 3 D 916<=75
)$ % 7:
6<
3161=;< 7: <@1 6@23>1 9@11<
412351.
67>5=I2561 7: <@1 7::15619
>>3=1C1. AB <@1 92?1
;16=24 (8.>1 <77E
<@1
;1<=<=7513 ;31:1331. <@=9 ;1<=<=75
-
123. 412351. 6785914 :73 <@1 ;1<=<=7513 25. 412351.
;16=24 6785914 :73 319;75.15<
<2<1
-7-
'
;23< :37? 83>=5> 91C1324 675<15<=759
412351.
6785914 :73 <@1 ;1<=<=7513 ;3=?23=4B 675<15.1. <@2<
=5 <@1
1;23<?15<24
5F8=3B <@1
5F8=3B
6479831 31;73< .2<1. )
&' &
&
& ! ?2.1 AB <@1
;2
::=613 @29 98A?=<<1. <@1
25. 3167??15.2<=75 .2<1.
7E2B8E<2 25. <@1
8<@73=<B @29 2661;<1. <@1 :=5.=5>9 7: <@1
=96=;4=523B
5F8=3B
::=613 25.
64791. <@1 ;37611.=5>9 AB 1J75132<=5> <@1 ;1<=<=7513 75
"&
& ! 29 <@1 6@23>19 231 57< ;37C1.
412351. 6785914
6673.=5> <7 <@1
<@1 63=?=524 ;37611.=5>9 A1=5> =5=<=2<1. 75
:2491 266892<=75 25. 29 <@1 6@23>19 41C141. 2>2=59< <@1
;1<=<=7513
=5
<@1
1;23<?15<24
5F8=3B
25.
63=?=524
;37611.=5>9 231 A1=5> 751 25. <@1 92?1 25. <@1 6@23>19
A1:731 <@1
1;23<?15<24
5F8=3B @29 57< ;37C1.
5 986@
6=368?9<2561 675<=582<=75 7: 63=?=524 ;37611.=5>9 2>2=59< <@1
;1<=<=7513 =9 2A891 7: ;376199 7:
"
B 314B=5> 75 <@1 K8.>?15< 7: <@1
783< =5
=5 "
783< 25. 4=2A41 <7 A1 F829@1.
&
!
'(
& ( )))
"
*))) )
#
$
75LA41
;1J
%
+ @1 675<15.1. <@2<
=5 2 6291 D@131 <@1 D=<5199 <8351. @79<=41 A1:731 <@1
1;23<?15<24
5F8=3B ;37611.=5>9
<@78>@ <@1 266891. =9
1J75132<1. <@1 63=?=524 6@23>19 62557< A1 F829@1. 29 @14. AB
-8-
<@1
75LA41
;1J
783< =5 <@1 2A7C1 6291
=59<25< 6291 =5 <@1
1;23<?15<24
@2C1 98;;73<1. <@1 6291
:37?
<@1
1;23<?15<24
7D1C13 =5 <@1
5F8=3B
244 <@1 D=<519919
.19;=<1 <@1 ;1<=<=7513 1J75132<1.
5F8=3B
;37611.=5>9
986@
6=368?9<2561 A7<@ <@1 ;37611.=5>9 A123 3191?A42561 25. <@1
675<=582<=75 7: 63=?=524 ;37611.=5>9 2>2=59< <@1 ;1<=<=7513 =9
57<@=5> A8< 2A891 7: ;376199 7:
783<
6673.=5>4B @1 ;32B9 <7
2447D <@1 ;1<=<=75
412351.
,
<@=9
;16=24 6785914 :73 319;75.15<
7E2B8E<2 675<15.1. <@2< =< =9 91<<41. ;79=<=75 7: 42D AB
783< 25. <@1
;1J
783< =5 62<152 7: K8.>?15<9
<@2< 1J75132<=75 7: .14=5F815<
7C135?15< 1?;47B11 =5 <@1
1;23<?15<24
75LA41
5F8=3B ;37611.=5>9 62557< AB =<914: :835=9@ 2
>3785. <7 F829@ <@1 63=?=524 ;37611.=5>9 1C15 =: A7<@ <@1
;37611.=5>9 231 :785.1. 75 <@1 92?1 91< 7: :26<9
6673.=5> <7
@=? =5 <@1 =59<25< 6291 244 <@1 D=<519919 @2C1 98;;73<1. =5 <@1
1;23<?15<24
29 @14. AB <@1
98;32
5F8=3B ;37611.=5>9 25. =5 986@ 6=368?9<2561
75LA41
;1J
1J75132<=75 =5 <@1
.719 57<
783< =5 <@1 6291 7:
1;23<?15<24
5F8=3B ;37611.=5>9
:835=9@ 2 >3785. :73 .37;;=5> 63=?=524
;37611.=5>9 ?731 ;23<=684234B =5 <32; 62919
6673.=5> <7 <@1
-9-
412351.
785914
<@1
75LA41
;1J
783< =5 <@1 6291 7:
98;32 @14. <@2< 1C15 <@78>@ =5 <@1
5F8=3B ;37611.=5>9 <@1 .14=5F815<
1;23<?15<24
7C135?15< 1?;47B11 =9
1J75132<1. :73 D=<5199 57< @2C=5> 98;;73<1. 25. <@1 92?1
D=<5199 D131 6@23>1 9@11<1. =5 <@1 63=?=524 ;37611.=5>9 <@1
63=?=524 ;37611.=5>9 62557< A1 F829@1. .37;;1. 2>2=59< <@1
266891.
7D1C13 =5 <@1 =59<25< 6291 244 <@1 D=<519919 @2C1
98;;73<1. =5 <@1
1C13B
1;23<?15<24
5F8=3B ;37611.=5>9 25. <@131
;799=A=4=<B 7: <@1B 98;;73<=5> =5 <@1 63=?=524
;37611.=5>9
5 986@ 6=368?9<2561
@1 ;32B9 <7 .=9?=99 <@1
;1<=<=75
&
5 ;138924 7: <@1 67?;42=5< 25. 6@23>1 9@11<
?2<13=249 =< =9 57< =5 .=9;8<1 <@1 ;1<=<=7513 1J75132<1. =5 <@1
1;23<?15<24
5F8=3B ;37611.=5>9
.19;=<1 244 <@1 D=<519919
@2C1 98;;73<1.
7D1C13 <@1 92=. 73.13 @29 A115 6@24415>1.
AB 319;75.15<
D=<519919 =5 <@1
1;23<?15<24 5F8=3B ;37611.=5>9 231 2497 <@1
7E2B8E<2
< =9 57< =5 .=9;8<1
<@1
D=<519919 =5 <@1 63=?=524 ;37611.=5>9
< =9 91<<41. ;79=<=75 7: 42D AB <@1
783< =5 <@1 6291 7:
,
#
- '!
"
75LA41
;1J
- 10 -
.
/ '
%
31;73<1. =5
)) & ( "
0) <@2< <@1
2.K8.=62<=75 ;37611.=5>9 25. <@1 63=?=524 ;37611.=5>9 231
=5.1;15.15< =5 52<831 <7 126@ 7<@13 25. <@1 :=5.=5> 2>2=59< <@1
;13975 :26=5> ;379168<=75 =5 <@1 2.K8.=62<=75 ;37611.=5>9 =9 57<
A=5.=5> 75 <@1 ;37611.=5>9 :73 63=?=524 ;379168<=75
=59<25< 6291
5 <@1
9=561 244 <@1 D=<519919 @2C1 98;;73<1. =5 <@1
1;23<?15<24
5F8=3B
;37611.=5>9
F829@=5>
7:
63=?=524
;37611.=5>9 .719 57< 23=91 <@78>@ <@1 ;1<=<=7513 1J75132<1. =5
<@1
1;23<?15<24 ;37611.=5>9
@1
.
!
75LA41
' ' 1
;1J
%
"
!
'
)
783< =5 <@1 6291 7: %
'
"
!
&
'(
)
@14. <@2< =5 2 6291 31>=9<131. 85.13 <@1
9;16=24 9<2<8<1 = 1
6< 2 F829@=5> 7: <@1 7::15619 85.13
<@1 92=. 26< D784. @2C1 2 >32C1 25. 98A9<25<=24 =?;26< 57< K89<
75 <@1 ;23<=19 =5C74C1. A8< 2497 75 <@1 976=1<B 2< 423>1
)
"
83<@13
<@1
31;73<1. =5 &
, 29 :7447D9/
750A41
%
( )
"
+
8;31?1
783< =5 6291 7:
#
"
@14. =5 ;232>32;@
"
79 " 25.
- 11 -
!
"
#
$
"
$
$
%
&'
& '
& '
!
#
$
"
"
#
%
#
!
#
#
"
%
(
"
$
"
$
#
"
$
"
$
$ #
$
)
"
*
"
$
"
$
#
%
+,
,
,
"
"
+ &
"
$
' "
!
%
#
%
#
!
#
#
#
%
%
$
*
"
$
%
- 12 -
$
#
$
%
#
"
!
#
%
#
"
$
%
# %
!
,
.
$
,
#
"
%
-
#
$
$
#
$
,
#
/
$
$
,
"
*
# "
#
"
"
,
$
#
#
#
$
#
$
$
"
$
"
$
)
$
#
#
" "
$
#
"
$
#
%
,
- 13 -
&
2 3
5066 7
&4 ' "
0' !
"
89:
<
#
;
#
*!; &06= '
$
# #
$
"
#
#
#
"
$
,
!
$
#
#
$
#
-
$
$
$
!
"
$
#
$
"
$
$
,
#
#
,
#
$
"
&
2 4
/ $ " ;
> $
506697
= =
<
"
$
*!;
&066='
896 ;
< % % "
>
?
5066:7 =
>
" 1
>
*!;
&0666'
@
" 1
$
5066=7 A
A9: ;
$
> $
" B
> $
<
5066A7
86A
"
>
"
&? "
(
*!; &066='
6 8
; %
< % % "
(
506667 8
:6'
!
#
"
$
/
$
$
#
$
- 14 -
#
$
%
$
#
"
$
$
#
#
C
$
"
$
#
$
"
,
"
$
"
& $ ' " 3
5066 7 8
80A
$
,
#
$
$
#
!
D
#
"
#
#
"
#
#
#
"
$
#
"
+& $
$
'
# "
$ /
#
E#
#
#
"
$
#
F
5 <@1 =59<25< 6291 29 .=968991. 98;32 <@1 ;3=?23B
=5>31.=15<9 7: <@1 7::15619 ;85=9@2A41 85.13
16<=759 '$2%
- 15 -
)$ %$.% 3 D
16<=75
)$ % 7:
6< 231 ?2.1 78< AB <@1
;379168<=75 25. <@1 92?1 @29 <7 A1 <19<1. =5 2 .1<2=41. <3=24
@=9
783< 62557< 675.86< 2 ?=5= <3=24 2< <@=9 9<2>1 <7 @74.
<@2< D@1<@13 <@1 266892<=75 ?2.1 2>2=59< <@1 ;1<=<=7513 D=44
;37C1 73 57<
5 25 15<=31 ;138924 7: 6@23>1 9@11< ?2<13=249
2? 7: <@1 C=1D <@2<
675<=582<=75 7: 63=?=524 ;37611.=5>9
2>2=59< <@1 ;1<=<=7513 D=44 57< 2?785< <7 2A891 7: ;376199 7:
783<
1561 ;1<=<=75 426E9 ?13=< 25. <@1 92?1 =9
-)
$
=9<
7/
7/ "
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review