Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
Serial No. 01
Daily List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 14 of 2023
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Date of order: 24.10.2025
Smti. Surmamon Nongbri
Smti. Esbian Nongkhlaw
Smti. Billo Mylliempdah
Smti. Nehkynti Syiem
Smti. Olika Lyngdoh
Smti. Brissila Pyngrope
Smti, Binaris Pyngrope
Smti. Bitiful Kharmudai
Smti. Riti Kharmudai
- versus -
…Appellants
1.
State of Meghalaya represented by the Chief Secretary,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong, Meghalaya.
2.
The Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of
Meghalaya, Land and Revenue Department, Shillong.
3.
The Under Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya, Revenue
and Disaster Management Department, Government of
Meghalaya, Shillong.
4.
The Commissioner and Secretary, Public and Health Engineering,
Shillong.
5.
The Deputy Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya, Public
Health Engineering Department, Shillong.
6.
The Under Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya, Public
Health Engineering Department, Shillong.
7.
The Chief Engineer (PHE) Government of Meghalaya, Shillong.
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
8.
9.
The Additional Chief Engineer (PHE), Zone-1, Government of
Meghalaya, Shillong.
The Chief Engineer (PHE), Electrical Division, Mawphlang, East
Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
10.
The Superintendent of Engineer (PHE), Electrical Circle, Shillong.
11.
The Executive Engineer (PHE), Electrical Division, Mawphlang,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
12.
The Additional Director of Survey, Government of Meghalaya,
Shillong.
13.
The Collector, East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya, Shillong.
14.
Headman of Jalynteng, Nongkynrih, Khyrim Syiemship,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
15.
Headman Madan Lyngdoh, Nongkynrih Khyrim Syiemship,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
16.
Headman Wahtyngngai, Nongkynrih Khyrim Syiemship,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
17.
Headman Madan Phutbol, Nongkynrih Khyrim Syiemship,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya
….Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Soumen Sen, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellants
: Mr H.L. Shangreiso, Sr Adv. with
Ms M. Hajong, Adv.
For the Respondents : Mr A. Kumar, Advocate General with
Ms R. Colney, GA
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The affidavit of service filed on behalf of the appellants is taken
on record.
2.
The appellants claiming to be the landowners whose land had
submerged during the construction of the dam across the River Umiew at
Dkong Nongkynrih during the implementation of the Wahtyngngai
Combined Water Supply Scheme. It appears that an administrative
approval was received on March, 2007 for an amount of ₹10,90,08,500/towards construction of the said dam. The villages upstream of the dam
raised their concern during the rainy season on flooding of cultivable land
and it appears that the Executive Engineer, PHE Electrical Division,
Mawphlang in his report prepared in February, 2020 has given an opinion
that the construction of the dam across the river Umiew at Dkong was
taken up at the sloping portion of the river for possible avoidance of the
inundation of areas upstream of the dam but on account of heavy rain
there was backlash of water impounded against the dam. However, no
inundation of cultivable land after 2011 had been reported.
3.
The writ petitioners did not accept the said report and have
claimed that due to the construction of the said dam, there has been
inundation of cultivable land and they have lost their land forever.
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
4.
It was in the conspectus of such facts and conflicting stand taken
by the parties, the learned single judge disposed of the writ petition with
the directions contained in paragraph 15 of the impugned judgment. For
convenience paragraph 15 is reproduced below:“15. In this backdrop of events and circumstances, where nothing
is clear to facilitate conclusive adjudication, this Court in the
absence of any due process being adopted by the respondents, and
looking into the plight of the land owners, who may, or may not
have been affected after 2011, but, however, have been pursuing
this litigation, deems it fit, inspite of the presence of disputed
facts, to direct as follows:i)
the respondent in the PHE department shall
from available records, such as, the details contained
in the affidavit filed by the State respondents in
WP(C) No. 117 of 2016, which is annexed to the writ
petition, as well as, by fresh survey identify and
establish as to whether lands of the petitioners
remain submerged after 2011, till date.
ii) if the same after survey and examination is
found to be true as alleged by the petitioners, the
respondents shall initiate the process for acquisition
of the said portions of land that have remained
submerged till date.
iii) if it is found otherwise, that after only one
instance in 2011, portions of land had been
submerged, which has not occurred since, after due
identification of the owners and the plots that were
affected in 2011, the Collector shall from the amount
of Rs.6,64,51,581.00/- (Rupees Six Crores Sixty
Four Lakhs Fifty One Thousand Five Hundred and
Eighty-One) only deposited by the PHE, since
20.09.2018, apportion the said amount as
compensation to the land owners, after due
assessment and examination of their respective
plots.”
(emphasis supplied)
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
5.
The appellants are aggrieved by the said order in so far as it
directed the PHE to conduct the survey as the appellants/writ petitioners
were of the view that there is very likelihood of bias as the PHE is the
requiring body and there may not be any fair assessment with regard to
the extent of the land submerged due to inundation at the time of
construction of the dam and accordingly they prayed for modification of
the impugned order dated 02.05.2023 to the extent that the learned
District and Sessions Judge or Collector, Shillong or Central Water
Commission is directed to conduct fresh enquiry/survey to identify and
find out whether the appellants’ agricultural land measuring about 30.29
acres situated at Umiew River is affected or submerged by water from
RCC dam till date.
6.
However, during the pendency of the appeal, the Additional
Director of Survey, Government of Meghalaya has filed a report dated
14.08.2023. The learned senior counsel for the appellants has submitted
that the report filed by the Additional Director of Survey in compliance
with the orders dated 06.06.2023, 28.06.2023 and 24.07.2023 passed in
this appeal [WA No.14 of 2023] is acceptable to the appellants and hence,
the prayer for modification of the direction with regard to survey is not
necessary. In view of that we do not find any reason to interfere with the
order passed by the learned single judge although prayer has been made
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
on behalf of the appellants for implementation of the impugned order. In
the event, the State does not implement the said order, it will be open for
the appellants to take appropriate steps in this regard.
7.
We also record that in the appeal, the headmen of the communities
have been impleaded as respondent Nos.14 to 17 on a plea taken by the
State that the appellants have donated the said lands to the community
head and the community head had allowed the State to utilise the said
land free of costs and hence, even if it is found that the said land was
submerged due to the construction of the dam, the State is not liable to
pay any compensation notwithstanding that the PHE has assessed the
compensation a little over of ₹6 crores and a sum of ₹5 crores admittedly
has been deposited with the Collector.
8.
In our view that the said issue is not required to be gone into in
this appeal as it relates to the executability or implementation of the
direction passed by the learned single judge. Moreover, it is apposite to
mention here that the Additional Director of Survey, Government of
Meghalaya filed the report on 14.08.2023 in compliance with the orders
dated 06.06.2023, 28.06.2023 and 24.07.2023 passed in the appeal. It is
necessary to refer to the orders dated 06.06.2023, 28.06.2023 and
24.07.2023 that had culminated in the report filed by the Additional
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
Director of Survey on 14.08.2023 for proper appreciation of the said
report.
9.
On 06.06.2023, the coordinate bench, inter alia, had observed:“What the appellants insinuate is that in view of the Act of 2013,
the mode of assessing compensation stood altered and the
methodology adopted by the Chief Secretary in his report of
March 13, 2017 would not pass muster under the provisions for
larger compensation introduced by the Act of 2013. The
appellants claim that the PHE apparently requested the LA
Collector to waive the provisions of the 2013 Act so that the
compensation as indicated in the Chief Secretary’s report could
be disbursed, whereupon the LA Collector, quite appropriately,
responded that he had no authority to waive the applicability of
any provision of law.
What also remains the undisputed position is that no notification
was issued under the Act of 1894 despite a draft notification in
such regard having been prepared by the State. The real
controversy is as to whether parcels of land belonging to the
appellants herein have been lost to the appellants forever or they
only remained submerged for some period of time in 2011. If such
lands continue to remain submerged periodically ever since the
construction of the dam, it would tantamount to the appellants
having lost their land and the State having, de facto, taken
possession thereof otherwise than by the procedure established by
law.
Accordingly, the State is directed to immediately ensure that
photographs of the entire area, including of the parcels of land
claimed by the appellants, are immediately taken by drones to
establish the present position. Such drone photography must be
conducted upon notice to the appellants herein. If reasonable
notice of at least two days is given to the appellants, it will be
open to the appellants to depute one or more representatives to be
present at the time that the photographs are taken.
It is also necessary that the survey directed to be conducted by the
order impugned should be completed as expeditiously as possible
and, preferably, within six weeks from date. The completion of
the survey in terms of the order impugned will be without
prejudice to the rights and contentions of the appellants.
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
The matter will appear a fortnight hence for the photographs to be
received; whereupon, if immediate further directions are not
required to be issued, it will appear seven weeks hence, after the
completion of the survey. The revenue records revealing the plots
must be produced at the final hearing.
(emphasis supplied)
10.
On 28.06.2023, the appellants alleging that the State conducted
the survey on 22.06.2023 on a State holiday in the absence of the
appellants, the following order was passed:“The matter will appear a fortnight hence. A fresh drone survey
will be conducted upon giving due notice to the appellants. If any
digital photography is undertaken, the State should forward a
copy of the entire set in digital form to the appellants and ensure
that the Court can see the digital photography when the matter
appears next.”
11.
Thereafter on 24.07.2023 after recording the submissions of the
State and the appellants, the matter was adjourned till 16.08.2023, inter
alia, with the following direction:“Let the matter appear three weeks hence. A report pertaining to
the ground and aerial survey should be filed within a fortnight
from date with a copy immediately made over to Advocate for the
appellants herein.”
12.
Pursuant to the aforesaid orders, a survey report was filed by the
Additional Director of Survey, Government of Meghalaya on 14.08.2023
and the said report was taken on record.
13.
Thereafter, on 16.08.2023, the State contended that the entirety of
such land is covered by an agreement of 05.05.2007 by which the Khyrim
Syiemship donated the land for the purpose of the dam upon obtaining
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
the same from one Smti. Sumarmon Lyngdoh Nongbri. The Hon’ble
Division Bench in its order dated 16.08.2023 did not accept the said
submission as would appear from the following observations:
“However, the agreement of May 5, 2007 does not indicate the
extent of the land. Instead, the agreement refers to a map
appended thereto to cover the extent of the land donated thereby.
The physical survey that has been conducted refers to 24 plots in
all, about 11 of them belonging to Sumarmon Nongbri. However,
the map at the last page of the survey report indicates areas which
do not appear to be covered by the area indicated in the map
appended to the agreement of May 5, 2007. Indeed, in the survey
map, the land of Sumarmon Nongbri has been indicated beyond
the 24 plots which have been surveyed and which are said to be
submerged as a result of the construction of the dam.
A second report has been filed appending drone photographs of
the area. If there is any future dispute, since the photographs have
been taken during peak monsoon season, such photographs along
with the survey map would indicate the extent of the land which
has been submerged upon the construction of the dam.
What is evident is that the petitioners other than Sumarmon
Nongbri may not have donated any land for the purpose of the
construction of the dam; while it is the admitted position, on the
basis of the survey report, that at least 13 plots not belonging to
Sumarmon Nongbri remain submerged. That would imply that
the relevant plot-owners have lost use of the land covered by the
submerged area. Even Sumarmon Nongbri may be entitled to
compensation for the area of land belonging to her which has now
been submerged other than the area indicated in the map
appended to the agreement of May 5, 2007.
Prima facie, the petitioners or a substantial number of them
appear to be justified in their claim and the State appears to be
liable to compensate the petitioners for their plots of land having
been lost to them as a result of the construction of the dam and
such plots going under water.
Since the State seeks a fortnight’s time to report, let the matter
appear three weeks hence when the State should indicate the
mode and manner of compensation that the petitioners would be
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
entitled to and the time-frame within which the exercise would be
completed.”
(emphasis supplied)
14.
The State has accepted the said order.
15.
On 19.09.2023, the Hon’ble Division Bench after recording the
submission of the appellants that they are being pressurised to accept a
much lesser sum than what would be due, inter alia, passed the following
directions:“There is little to adjudicate in this matter, particularly after the
surveys have been conducted pursuant to the orders of this Court.
The land which now remains submerged as a result of the dam
being constructed has to be regarded as the land which has been
de facto acquired, though a substantial part thereof may not have
been compensated for. The law has to take its own course and fair
compensation for the additional land which has, in fact, been
acquired but has not been paid for, has to be paid. It is a matter of
simple arithmetic.
It is hoped that the State will indicate how and in what manner
the payment will be made when the matter appears next a week
hence. There is no doubt that the State can persuade the appellants
to accept a little less than what may be due, but that does not mean
that the State has a right to ride roughshod over citizens or coerce
them into parting with land at an inequitable price.”
16.
Subsequently on 04.10.2023, the Division Bench while deciding
the issue after taking into consideration the submissions made on behalf
of the State that on the basis of a cost-benefit analysis, the Government
has decided to dismantle the existing project and has proposed a
greenfield project amounting to approximately ₹32.95 crore to cover the
3295 households has some merit. The State’s assertion that a project
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
which ultimately is so costly may not be viable and it may be inequitable
to hold the State to ransom to expend more than Rs.100 crore, after taking
into account the money already spent, to cater to the water needs of
slightly over 3000 households needs consideration and the appellants
were granted leave to use an affidavit in response to the report filed by
the State. However, the State was restrained from indulging any action to
dismantle the project.
17.
In response to the aforesaid, an additional affidavit was filed by
the appellants on 03.10.2023.
18.
Thereafter, the matter was attempted to be settled between the
parties which, however, failed as would appear from the orders dated
01.12.2023 and 15.12.2023.
19.
It was at this stage an application was filed by the State
respondents for impleading the respondent Nos.14 to 17 and the said
prayer was ultimately allowed on 29.02.2024 and the said order was not
interfered with by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Special Leave to Appeal
(C) No.9866 of 2024 preferred by the appellants.
20.
The issue that ultimately remains to be decided is that what would
be the amount of compensation payable to the appellants upon taking into
consideration the observations of the Hon’ble Division Bench in
paragraph 6 of the order dated 04.10.2023. The issue with regard to the
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
land being donated and hence the State would not be liable to pay
compensation did not find favour with the earlier Division Bench.
Moreover, the State respondent did not prefer any cross appeal against
the direction passed by the learned single judge.
21.
In determining the amount of compensation that may be payable
to the appellants, the observations of the Hon’ble Division Bench in
paragraph 6 of the order dated 04.10.2023 is relevant and the State must
decide on the amount of compensation payable to the appellants taking
into consideration the observations made in paragraph 6 of the said order
which is stated below:“The appellants assert that once land has been acquired, it cannot
be returned and that there is a bar in such regard under the
applicable laws. At the same time, there is some merit in the
State’s assertion that a project which ultimately is so costly may
not be viable and it may be inequitable to hold the State to ransom
to expend more than Rs.100 crore, after taking into account the
money already spent, to cater to the water needs of slightly over
3000 households.”
22.
In our view, the Collector would have been the appropriate
authority to decide the amount of compensation. However, it appears that
the Deputy Commissioner then made an assessment with the old probable
cost of ₹6,64,51,580/- as compared to the new estimated probable cost of
₹78,87,43,573/- for compensation based on the Right to Fair
2025:MLHC:1013-DB
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013.
23.
Upon the survey report being accepted by the appellants, the
direction in paragraph 15(iii) of the impugned order is now required to be
given effect to by the State respondents. The compensation amount is
restricted to the aforesaid sum of ₹6,64,51,580/- having regard to the
observation made in paragraphs 6 of the order dated 04.10.2023.
Moreover, the respondent Nos.14 to 17 have not come forward to support
the stand of the State that no compensation would be payable to the writ
appellants.
24.
In view of the aforesaid, we do not find any reason to interfere
with the order passed by the learned single judge. We make it clear that
if any issue arises with regard to the implementation of the order passed
by the learned single judge, the parties shall be at liberty to approach the
learned single judge for any clarification or direction upon prior notice to
the parties.
25.
Accordingly, the appeal is disposed of.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
Meghalaya
24.10.2025
(Soumen Sen)
Chief Justice
“Sylvana PS”
LIZ KHARBHIH
Date: 2025.10.26 16:27:16 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review