Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
Date of Decision: 2nd September, 2026
Uploaded on: 10th September, 2026
CNR No. DLHC010482352025
+
CRL.A. 1032/2025 & CRL.M.(BAIL) 1572/2025
SURESH
Through:
versus
STATE, NCT OF DELHI
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Avneesh Saran, Adv.
.....Respondent
Mr. Ritesh Kumar Bahri, APP for
State with Mr. Lalit Luthra, Mr.
Randeep Kumar, Mr. Rishabh and
Ms. Divya Yadav, Advs. with SI N.K.
Patil, P.S. Gazipur (M. 9766981530)
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE VIKAS MAHAJAN
VIKAS MAHAJAN, J. (ORAL)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present criminal appeal under Section 415(2) read with Section
528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (B.N.S.S.) has been
preferred by the Appellant assailing the impugned Judgment of conviction
dated 25th March, 2025 and the Order on sentence dated 16th April, 2025
passed by the Ld. Additional Sessions Judge (FTC), East District,
Karkardooma Courts, Delhi, in Sessions Case No. 2650/2019.
3.
Vide the impugned Judgment dated 25th March, 2025, the Appellant
was convicted for the offences punishable under Section 302 of the Indian
Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as ‘IPC’) and Section 174-A IPC,
arising out of FIR No. 96/2019, registered at Police Station Gazipur.
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
4.
Vide the Order on sentence dated 16th April, 2025, the Trial Court
sentenced the Appellant to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life for the
offence under Section 302 IPC, and simple imprisonment for a period of
one year for the offence punishable under Section 174-A IPC, with a
direction that both sentences shall run concurrently. The relevant portion of
the said order is reproduced hereunder:
“13. Thus, considering the overall facts and
circumstances of the case including the gravity of
offence committed by the convict and the young age of
deceased victim, the convict Suresh is sentenced to
undergo life imprisonment and to pay fine of
Rs.10,000/-for commission of offence punishable
under Section 302 IPC. In default of payment of fine,
he shall undergo simple imprisonment of six months.
Further the convict is also sentenced to undergo
simple imprisonment for period of one year and to pay
fine of Rs. 2000/- for commission of offence u/s 174-A
of IPC. In default of payment of fine of Rs. 2,000/-, he
shall undergo simple imprisonment for 15 days. The
sentences of convict shall run concurrently. The
benefit of Section 428 Cr.P.C. be given to the convict.
Fine amount realized shall be disbursed to the LRs of
deceased as compensation.”
5.
Briefly stated, the case of the prosecution, as culled out from the
record, is that on 6th April, 2019, at about 8:40 AM, information was
received at Police Station Gazipur, vide DD No. 14A, regarding an incident
in front of Shop No. C-265, Paper Market, Gazipur, Delhi, in which a
person had sustained a head injury. The said DD entry was entrusted to SI
Amit Bhardwaj (PW-23), who along with Ct. Dinesh (PW-15) reached the
spot, where bloodstains were found on the road. Upon inquiry, it transpired
that the injured person namely, Mahajan had already been taken to Lal
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
Bahadur Shastri (LBS) Hospital. Due to his critical condition, the patient
was in turn referred by LBS Hospital to GTB Hospital, where he was
subsequently declared unfit to make a statement.
6.
SI Amit Bhardwaj, however, met Smt. Krishna Wati, wife of the
injured, and recorded her statement. In her statement, she stated that she
resided with her family in a jhuggi situated opposite C-265, Paper Market,
Gazipur, Delhi. On 6th April, 2019, at about 8:00 AM, Smt. Nankarna,
mother of appellant Suresh started abusing them on the allegation that they
had hit their dog. An altercation ensued between Bifai Lal, father of the
Appellant, and Krishna Wati’s husband namely, Mahajan, whereafter both
retreated to their respective jhuggis.
7.
Shortly thereafter, while Mahajan was standing outside, the Appellant
Suresh came there and uttered that he would teach Mahajan a lesson for
insulting his father ("abhi maja chakhata hoon"), went inside his jhuggi,
brought an axe (kulhari), and struck a single blow on the head of Mahajan,
who fell to the ground bleeding, and the accused fled with the axe.
8.
On the basis of Smt. Krishna Wati's statement, a rukka was prepared
and FIR No. 96/2019 was registered under Section 307 IPC. The custody of
the Appellant was handed over to SI Amit Bhardwaj by Ct. Prem at the
police station, whereupon the Appellant was arrested vide arrest memo, Ex.
PW-13/D. Pursuant to his disclosure statement, Ex. PW-13/F, the accused
led the police team behind his jhuggi and facilitated the recovery of an iron
axe (kulhari) Ex. P2.
9.
During the course of treatment at GTB Hospital, the injured Mahajan
succumbed to his injuries on 8th April 2019, consequent upon which
Section 302 IPC was added to the case, and further investigation was
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
entrusted to Inspector Rajiv Kumar Vats. Post-mortem was conducted by
Dr. Shilpa Singh [PW-10] vide PM Report No. 600/19, Ex. PW-10/A,
which opined the cause of death to be shock, consequent upon an antemortem head injury caused by a sharp-edged weapon, sufficient to cause
death in the ordinary course of nature.
10.
Upon completion of investigation, a charge sheet under Section 302
IPC was filed against the Appellant, and vide order dated 26th August, 2019,
the Ld. Trial Court framed charge under the said Section against Appellant,
to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
11.
During the pendency of trial, the Appellant, who had been released
on interim bail during the COVID-19 pandemic, failed to appear,
whereupon process under Section 82 Cr.P.C. was executed against him and
was declared a Proclaimed Offender vide order dated 1st September, 2022.
He was subsequently re-arrested on 14th December, 2022 from Dehradun,
Uttarakhand. Thereafter, an additional charge for the offence punishable
under Section 174-A IPC was framed against him on 21st February, 2023, to
which he pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
12.
To establish its case, the prosecution examined 26 witnesses in all.
After the conclusion of prosecution evidence, the statement of the Appellant
was recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C., wherein he denied the allegations
and pleaded false implication on account of prior enmity, asserting that the
complainant party wanted to evict him and his family from their jhuggi. He
stated that the axe had been planted on him and opted not to lead any
evidence in defence.
13.
The Ld. Trial Court, upon appreciation of the evidence on record,
concluded that the prosecution had successfully proved beyond reasonable
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
doubt that the Appellant had committed the murder of the deceased
Mahajan, and that he had deliberately evaded his appearance before the
Court despite issuance of process under Section 82 Cr.P.C. The Appellant
was accordingly convicted for the offences punishable under Sections 302
and 174-A IPC. The relevant extract of the impugned Judgment is
reproduced hereinbelow:
“68……Therefore, from all the angles, the prosecution
has successfully proved that PW-2 Krishna Wati was
present at the scene of crime at the time of incident and
she had witnessed the incident. In view of the oral
deposition of prosecution witnesses including Smt.
Krishna Wati and the documentary evidence including
medical evidence such as the MLC and PMR of deceased,
the prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that
accused Suresh had caused injury on the head of Mahajan
with an axe which resulted into his death. Thus,
prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that
accused Suresh had committed murder of Mahajan.
“74. Thus, in view of the aforementioned discussion, it has
to be concluded that the prosecution has successfully
proved beyond reasonable doubt that the accused Suresh
had committed murder of deceased Mahajan and he
deliberately evaded his appearance and did not appear
before the court despite issuance of process u/s 82 Cr. PC.
Accordingly, accused Suresh is convicted for commission
of offences u/s 302 IPC 174-A IPC respectively.”
14.
Mr. Avneesh Saran, Ld. counsel for the Appellant has argued that on
the basis of evidence on record, only an offence of culpable homicide not
amounting to murder punishable under section 304 Part II IPC is made out
as there was no premeditation and the entire incident happened in 2-3
minutes.
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
15.
Per contra, Mr. Ritesh Bahri, learned APP submits that in view of the
nature of weapon used and the situs of the injury, the Appellant is not
entitled to the benefit of Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC.
16.
We have heard Mr. Saran, as well as, Mr. Bahri and have gone
through the impugned Judgment, as well as, the records of the case.
17.
The case of the prosecution hinges on the ocular version given by the
sole eyewitness examined by the prosecution, namely, PW-2 Smt. Krishna
Wati, wife of the deceased, therefore, it is imperative to examine the same
for ascertaining the criminal liability of the Appellant. PW-2 Smt. Krishna
Wati deposed as under in her examination-in-chief recorded on 25th
November, 2019:
“On 06.04.2019 at about 8 am, I along with my
husband/deceased Mahajan were present in my
aforesaid jhuggi along with our children. In the
meantime, Smt. Nankarna, mother of accused Suresh
started abusing to us on the issue of dog and saying that
we had beaten her dog. On the issue, an altercation also
took place between my husband and father of the
accused namely Bifai Lal. After sometime, while my
husband Mahajan (deceased) was standing outside our
jhuggi, accused Suresh present in the court today, came
there and stated that 'abhi maja chakhata hoon' (I will
teach a lesson to you as you have insulted my father).
After saying this, Suresh went to his jhuggi and his
mother Nankarna gave a kulhari (axe) to him and
thereafter, accused reached the spot and hit kulhari on
the head of my husband to kill him. Blood started oozing
out from the head of my husband. Accused ran away
from the spot with kulhari. One person namely Kamal
chased the accused and apprehended him at some
distance and axe was seized from the accused. At the time
of incident, one Suraj, Lal Babu and Kamal were also
present near the spot beside other public persons.
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
I alongwith my relative Raju took my husband to LBS
Hospital in an auto. After providing treatment, my
husband was sent to GTB Hospital...”
(emphasis supplied)
18.
When recalled for cross-examination on 26th November, 2019, PW-2
Smt. Krishna Wati, further deposed as follows:
"We were residing at the above mentioned address for the
last about four years prior to the date of incident. The
jhuggi of accused persons is situated at a distance of 1015 meters from our jhuggi. We had not beaten the dog of
accused persons. We had slightly pushed the dog with
hands in the morning on the day of incident just before 8
am. No call at 100 number was made regarding the issue
of dog. No one came there to pacify the matter of dog.
No quarrel took place prior to the incident of pushing
the dog. There is only one room in my jhuggi. The quarrel
regarding pushing the dog took place in middle of road
between two jhuggis. My jhuggi is surrounded by other
jhuggis approximately 150.
xxx
xxx
xxx
My husband was standing at the distance of about 6-7
feet from our jhuggi gate. I was present outside my
jhuggi when accused was causing injury to my husband.
I tried to intervene but father of the accused pushed me
aside. I raised alarm to save my husband. No public
person saved my husband from the accused. The
occurrence of hitting of kulhari (axe) by the accused had
happened within 2-3 minutes. Accused had brought the
axe (kulhari) within one minute of threatening my
husband. Smt. Nankarna, mother of the accused was
also present outside her jhuggi but she had gone inside
jhuggi to giving the kulhari to accused Suresh. I did not
go anywhere when accused Suresh went to bring the
kulhari (axe)...."
(emphasis supplied)
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
19.
Dr. G.K. Himanshu (Junior Resident, LBS Hospital) who prepared
the MLC, Ex. PW-5/A, deposed as under:
"On 06.04.2019, I was on duty in casualty of LBS
Hospital. On that day at about 9 am, patient Mahajan
was brought in the casualty with alleged history of
assault. The patient was in drowsy condition and patient
was not maintaining SPO2 (oxygen level). The patient
was given oxygen to the patient. On local examination, I
found the following injuries: 1.
Lacerated wound over parietal area
size approx. 7x2x2 cm.
2.
20.
Active bleeding present in the wound.
I provided initial treatment to the patient and referred to
SR (Surgery) for further management and treatment. I
prepared the MLC of the patient bearing
No.003575/2019 which bears my signature at point A.
The MLC is Ex.PW5/A."
PW-10 Dr. Shilpa Singh, Senior Resident, GTB Hospital, who
conducted the post-mortem examination, proved the Post-Mortem Report,
Ex. PW-10/A, and testified as follows:
"In external injury no.1: On removal of bandage
mentioned above, a sutured wound with 14 sutured
present on the head measuring 9.5 cm x 0.7 cm. On
removal of sutur margins not approximated. Upper end
of wound 1 cm away from mid-line towards right side
and 10 cm above right side of eyebrow. Lower end of
the wound is 0.5 cm away from mid-line on the right
and 10 cm above occipital protuberance. Margins are
clean-cut and well defined. Wound is bone deep and the
surgical bandage is blood soaked.
Internal examination: Skull depressed fracture with
radiating fissured margins present on the right frontal
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
and parietal temporal bone. Fracture at the base of
skull was also present.
Scalp. Subscalp hematoma present on bilateral frontal
and right parietal region.
Brain: Weighs 1340 grams edematous, pale. Dura is
torn with brain matter protruding out at right frontal
region and right parietal region. Brain lacerated and
contusion present over right parietal region. Subdural
hemorrhage present over right frontal, temporal, partial
region. Subarachonoid hemorrhage present over
bilateral frontal and right partial region...
Time since death: About half a day.
21.
Cause of death: Shock as a result of ante-mortem head
injury produced by a sharp edged weapon. Injury
mentioned in external injury is sufficient to cause
death in ordinary course of nature. My detailed report
is Ex.PW10/A which bears my signatures at Point A."
The seized axe [kulhari], Ex. P2, was subjected to examination at
FSL Rohini. The FSL Report dated 31st July, 2019, Ex. PA, reveals that
blood could not be detected on the axe.
22.
From a reading of testimony of PW-2 Smt. Krishna Wati, which
appears to be credible, the factum of the Appellant having dealt a single
blow on the head of the deceased with an axe which resulted in his demise
two days later, stands established on record. The post-mortem report [Ex.
PW-10/A] as well as testimony of PW-10 Dr. Shilpa Singh reveals that
external injury no.1 present on the head of the deceased was sufficient to
cause death in ordinary course of nature. This clearly brings the case within
the ambit of clause (3) of Section 300 IPC.
23.
The core issue that, however, survives for our determination lies
within a narrow compass viz. whether the case warrants the invocation of
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC, thereby constituting ‘culpable homicide not
amounting to murder’ punishable under Section 304 Part II IPC.
24.
In Sita Ram Kuchhbedia v. Vimal Rana & Ors., 2026 SCC
OnLine SC 293, following its earlier decision in Virsa Singh v. State of
Punjab, 1958 SCC OnLine SC 37, the Supreme Court reiterated the
structured three-stage inquiry required to be undertaken by courts while
delineating between ‘murder’ and ‘culpable homicide not amounting to
murder’:
“47. At the first stage, the Court must determine whether
the accused has committed an act which has caused the
death of another, that is to say, whether the case involves
a homicide. If such causal connection between the act of
the accused and the death is established, the enquiry then
proceeds to the second stage, that is to say, whether the
act so committed amounts to 'culpable homicide' within
the meaning of Section 299 IPC.
48. If the answer to this question is prima facie in the
affirmative, the Court must then enter upon the third stage
of enquiry, viz., whether the facts proved by the
prosecution bring the case within the ambit of any of the
four clauses of Section 300 IPC, which define murder. If
the case does not fall within any of the four clauses of
Section 300, the offence would be culpable homicide not
amounting to murder, punishable under either Part I or
Part II of Section 304 IPC, depending upon whether the
case attracts the second or the third clause of Section 299
IPC.
49. Even if the case falls within the four clauses of
Section 300 IPC, the Court must further examine
whether any of the Exceptions to Section 300 IPC are
attracted. If the case is covered by any such Exception,
the offence would fall back to Section 299, that is,
culpable homicide not amounting to murder.”
(emphasis supplied)
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
25.
As exposited in Sita Ram Kuchhbedia (supra) even where a
homicidal act ostensibly satisfies the objective criteria of Section 300
IPC, the inquiry does not terminate there; the court is duty-bound to
further examine whether the act is mitigated by any of the statutory
Exceptions to Section 300 IPC. Incidentally, the Trial Court did not
delve into this aspect of the matter.
26.
In the present case, the learned counsel for the Appellant has invoked
Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC, which reads as under:
"Exception 4.—Culpable homicide is not murder if it is
committed without premeditation in a sudden fight in the
heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel and without the
offender's having taken undue advantage or acted in a
cruel or unusual manner.
Explanation.—It is immaterial in such cases which party
offers the provocation or commits the first assault."
27.
Section 304 IPC deals with cases not covered by Section 302 IPC
and it divides the offence into two distinct classes, i.e., (i) those in which the
death is intentionally caused; and (ii) those in which death is caused
unintentionally but knowingly. The cases of the first category are
punishable under Section 304 Part I, whereas the cases under the second
category are punishable under Section 304 Part II of the IPC.
28.
The intention being the state of mind, is to be gathered from a
cumulative effect of the circumstances proved on record. As laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Pulicherla Nagaraju v. State of A.P., (2006)
11 SCC 444, either few or several of the factors in combination will be
decisive for ascertaining whether there was any intention to cause death.
The Supreme Court delineated the relevant factors as under:
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
"29. Therefore, the court should proceed to decide the
pivotal question of intention, with care and caution, as
that will decide whether the case falls under Section 302
or 304 Part I or 304 Part II. Many petty or insignificant
matters—plucking of a fruit, straying of cattle, quarrel of
children, utterance of a rude word or even an
objectionable glance, may lead to altercations and group
clashes culminating in deaths. Usual motives like
revenge, greed, jealousy or suspicion may be totally
absent in such cases. There may be no intention. There
may be no premeditation. In fact, there may not even be
criminality. At the other end of the spectrum, there may be
cases of murder where the accused attempts to avoid the
penalty for murder by attempting to put forth a case that
there was no intention to cause death. It is for the courts
to ensure that the cases of murder punishable under
Section 302, are not converted into offences punishable
under Section 304 Part I/II, or cases of culpable homicide
not amounting to murder, are treated as murder
punishable under Section 302. The intention to cause
death can be gathered generally from a combination of a
few or several of the following, among other,
circumstances: (i) nature of the weapon used; (ii)
whether the weapon was carried by the accused or was
picked up from the spot; (iii) whether the blow is aimed
at a vital part of the body; (iv) the amount of force
employed in causing injury; (v) whether the act was in
the course of sudden quarrel or sudden fight or free for
all fight; (vi) whether the incident occurs by chance or
whether there was any premeditation; (vii) whether there
was any prior enmity or whether the deceased was a
stranger; (viii) whether there was any grave and sudden
provocation, and if so, the cause for such provocation;
(ix) whether it was in the heat of passion; (x) whether
the person inflicting the injury has taken undue
advantage or has acted in a cruel and unusual manner;
(xi) whether the accused dealt a single blow or several
blows. The above list of circumstances is, of course, not
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
exhaustive and there may be several other special
circumstances with reference to individual cases which
may throw light on the question of intention. Be that as it
may.”
(emphasis supplied)
29.
The legal requirements for invoking Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC
were authoritatively summarized by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Surinder Kumar v. UT, Chandigarh, (1989) 2 SCC 217, and reaffirmed in
Arjun v. State of Chhattisgarh, (2017) 3 SCC 247, in the following terms:
“20. To invoke this Exception 4, the requirements that
are to be fulfilled have been laid down by this Court
in Surinder
Kumar v. UT,
Chandigarh [Surinder
Kumar v. UT, Chandigarh, (1989) 2 SCC 217 : 1989
SCC (Cri) 348], it has been explained as under: (SCC p.
220, para 7)
“7. To invoke this exception four requirements
must be satisfied, namely, (i) it was a sudden
fight; (ii) there was no premeditation; (iii) the act
was done in a heat of passion; and (iv) the
assailant had not taken any undue advantage or
acted in a cruel manner. The cause of the quarrel
is not relevant nor is it relevant who offered the
provocation or started the assault. The number of
wounds caused during the occurrence is not a
decisive factor but what is important is that the
occurrence must have been sudden and
unpremeditated and the offender must have acted
in a fit of anger. Of course, the offender must not
have taken any undue advantage or acted in a
cruel manner. Where, on a sudden quarrel, a
person in the heat of the moment picks up a
weapon which is handy and causes injuries, one
of which proves fatal, he would be entitled to the
benefit of this exception provided he has not acted
cruelly.”
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
30.
(emphasis supplied)
A Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Sanjay Singh v. State (NCT of
Delhi), 2026 SCC OnLine Del 4184, noting the circumstances, where two
men, who were friends, were drinking together and had a fight over a trivial
issue of payment for a bottle of liquor, which led to a sudden rage in a state
of intoxication, leading to the Appellant therein picking up a brick that was
lying outside and striking the deceased, opined that there was no intention to
cause death, and accordingly, the offence under Section 302 was altered to
one under Section 304 Part II of the IPC. The relevant extract from the said
decision reads thus:
“45. The circumstances of the case in hand fit
squarely within this well-settled principle. The two
men were friends. They were drinking together. The
quarrel arose without warning over something as
trivial as payment for a bottle of liquor. The deceased
slapped the Appellant. The Appellant, in a state of
intoxication and sudden rage, picked up a brick that
was lying outside and struck the deceased. There was
no prior plan. The Appellant was not carrying any
weapon. There was no motive to kill. There was no
intention, in the legal sense of the term, to cause death,
but there was knowledge, that striking a person
repeatedly on the head with a brick is likely to cause
death.
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
49. Having considered the entire evidence on record,
this Court is of the view that though the Appellant had
the knowledge that repeated blows with a brick on the
head could likely cause death, the material on record
does not establish a deliberate intention to commit
murder within the meaning of Section 300 IPC. The
present case would therefore fall within the ambit of
Section 304 Part II IPC.
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
52. Accordingly, the conviction of the Appellant under
Section 302 IPC is altered to one under Section 304
Part II of the IPC. The sentence of rigorous
imprisonment for life awarded by the Ld. trial court is
modified and reduced to rigorous imprisonment for a
period of eight years. The fine imposed by the Ld. trial
court shall remain undisturbed.”
(emphasis supplied)
31.
The aforementioned principle was recently reaffirmed by this Court in
Mukesh v. State (NCT of Delhi), 2026 SCC OnLine Del 5961. In that case,
the Appellant and the deceased, who were co-workers sharing a room,
engaged in a sudden scuffle over a trivial issue of not opening a door by the
Appellant therein when the deceased knocked the same. During the
altercation, the Appellant inflicted a single fatal stab wound using a pair of
scissors. Noting the absence of prior animosity, the Court held that the use
of a readily available tool negated any inference of premeditation, and
thereby altered the conviction to Section 304 Part II IPC. The Court
observed:
“30. The offence weapon i.e. scissors, which is stated to
have been used, was, readily available at the site of the
crime since both the Appellant and deceased were tailors
and were staying in the tailoring shop. It is not a situation
where the Appellant had specially brought any offence
weapon to execute the crime, in a pre-meditated manner.
31. Further, PW 1 had not seen the Appellant giving any
blow to the deceased, much less with a force which in all
probability would have caused a fatal injury. The injuries
were suffered by the deceased during scuffle, and the
same was noticed by PW 1 when he separated them. The
entire incident happened in a short span of time or at the
spur of the moment, in a sudden fight when both Appellant
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
32.
and deceased where under the influence of liquor. It is
thus, clear that there was no intention on part of the
appellant to kill the deceased, nor he had committed the
crime with any pre-planning or premeditation.”
Reference may also be had to the decision of Atul Thakur v. State of
Himachal Pradesh, (2018) 2 SCC 496 : (2018) 1 SCC (Cri) 743, wherein
there was sudden fight between friends who had gathered for a drink party in
which appellant gave six knife blows to the deceased in the heat of passion
on different parts of the his body, causing serious bodily injuries to which he
succumbed, the Supreme Court held that the facts of the case warrant the
invocation of Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC, as it is a case of culpable
homicide not amounting to murder since it was found that there was no
shred of evidence that the appellant had assaulted the deceased with an
intention to cause his death, and that the act was done without the appellant
taking any undue advantage or acting in a cruel manner. The Court also
concluded that the number of wounds caused cannot be a decisive factor,
and neither the use of a knife nor the factum of multiple injuries given by the
appellant would deny him the benefit of Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC.
The relevant extract from the said decision reads thus:
“7. We have carefully considered the oral evidence
adduced by the prosecution, in particular the evidence
of PW 11 and PW 12 who were the eyewitnesses to the
incident during which Hitesh Thakur was assaulted by
the appellant with knife causing serious bodily injuries
to which he finally succumbed. In addition to the said
oral evidence, the other circumstances also point
towards the complicity of the appellant in the
commission of crime such as recovery of the knife at his
instance and the nature of injuries suffered by the
deceased attributable to the assault by the same knife by
the appellant. We find that the trial court has justly
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
analysed the evidence to record a finding about the
complicity of the appellant in the commission of crime.
That has been affirmed by the High Court after
reappreciation of the relevant evidence. We are in
agreement with the view so taken by the two courts
below. In other words, we are inclined to uphold the
concurrent finding recorded by the courts below that the
appellant caused six injuries to deceased Hitesh Thakur
by attacking him with a knife on the night of 27-7-2011
in the presence of their friends (including PW 11 and
PW 12) who had gathered at the house of Mukesh
Thakur for celebrating a drink party arranged at the
behest of Hitesh Thakur. Further, Hitesh Thakur
succumbed to the injuries caused by the appellant.
Thus, it is a case of homicidal death.
8. Notably, the evidence on record plainly establishes
that a sudden fight took place between the appellant
and Hitesh Thakur and in the heat of passion, the
appellant assaulted Hitesh Thakur causing serious
bodily injuries. There is no shred of evidence, much
less even a remote suggestion that the appellant had
assaulted Hitesh Thakur with an intention to cause his
death. Though the High Court found the appellant
guilty, it has not held that the bodily injuries caused by
the appellant were with an intention to cause the death
of Hitesh Thakur. The High Court overturned the
finding recorded by the trial court regarding the nature
of offence, principally on the ground that the appellant
gave repeated knife-blows to Hitesh Thakur and Hitesh
Thakur could not defend himself as he was unarmed.
Thus, the appellant was found guilty of offence
punishable under Section 302 IPC.
9. In other words, the controversy in these appeals boils
down to the nature of offence and the sentence to be
awarded in that behalf. As aforesaid, the evidence on
record, as held by the two courts below and with which
finding we are in full agreement, is that the appellant
gave six knife-blows to Hitesh Thakur on the fateful
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
night to which he succumbed. Thus, it is a case of
homicidal death. However, there is no evidence that the
injuries inflicted by the appellant were with an
intention to cause the murder of Hitesh Thakur. On
the other hand, the evidence clearly establishes that
the appellant assaulted Hitesh Thakur without any
premeditation. The whole incident took place suddenly
and, in the heat of passion a sudden quarrel started as
Hitesh Thakur, while smoking, blew smoke on the face
of the appellant. Resultantly, the appellant got
enraged. He told him that he was senior in age and
thus should not smoke in his presence much less blow
the smoke towards him. Then a sudden physical fight
started between them, in which the appellant, in heat
of passion, gave six knife-blows to Hitesh Thakur on
different parts of his body.
10. The evidence of PW 11 and PW 12 (eyewitnesses)
would establish that the appellant and others including
deceased Hitesh Thakur had gathered at the spot for a
drink party arranged at the instance of Hitesh Thakur.
They had consumed drinks when the incident took
place. Soon after assaulting Hitesh Thakur by knife,
when the appellant realised that Hitesh has been badly
injured, he offered him water and took him to the
hospital along with his other friends. He was in the
hospital till Hitesh Thakur succumbed to the
injuries. He had also informed the father of Hitesh on
telephone and called him to the hospital. Further, when
Hitesh was taken to the hospital, the doctors did not
provide him immediate treatment but insisted on calling
his father. This can be culled out from the evidence of
PW 11 and PW 12, who were eyewitnesses and also
present throughout and until the last rites of Hitesh
Thakur were performed.
11. Taking into account the events as unfolded, it
leaves no manner of doubt that the appellant had no
intention to cause the death of Hitesh Thakur. The
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
incident happened without any premeditation in a
sudden fight between Hitesh Thakur and the appellant
and in heat of passion the appellant inflicted six knifeblows on Hitesh Thakur. On the contrary, after
realising his mistake, he immediately offered water to
Hitesh Thakur and also took him to hospital and stayed
there till his last rites were performed. PW 2, father of
deceased Hitesh Thakur also corroborates the position
that the appellant had contacted him to inform that
Hitesh had been brought to the hospital in serious
condition.
12. Taking overall view of the matter, the facts of the
present case warrant invocation of Exception 4 to
Section 300 IPC. For, it is a case of culpable homicide
not amounting to murder inasmuch as the incident
happened on account of sudden fight between the
friends who had gathered for a drink party arranged at
the behest of Hitesh Thakur. There was no
premeditation and the act done by the appellant was in
the heat of passion without the appellant taking any
undue advantage or acted in a cruel manner. The
number of wounds caused by the appellant, it is a wellestablished position, by itself cannot be a decisive
factor. The High Court committed manifest error in
being influenced by the said fact. What is relevant is
that the occurrence was sudden and not premeditated
and the offender acted in the heat of passion. The
evidence supports the case of the appellant in this
behalf. The fact that the appellant used weapon such
as knife, is also not a decisive factor to attract
Section 302 IPC. Neither the use of a knife in the
commission of offence nor the factum of multiple
injuries given by the appellant would deny the
appellant of the benefit of Exception 4.
13. Dealing with a somewhat similar situation, in Surain
Singh v. State of Punjab [Surain Singh v. State of
Punjab, (2017) 5 SCC 796 : (2017) 3 SCC (Cri) 461],
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
this Court has restated the settled legal position about
the purport of Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC. Even in
that case, the accused had repeatedly assaulted the
deceased with a kirpan and caused injuries resulting
into death. After restating the legal position, the Court
converted the offence to one under Section 304 Part II
instead of Section 302 IPC. Following the same legal
principle and keeping in mind the factual position as
unfolded, the view taken by the trial court of convicting
the appellant for the offence punishable under Section
304 Part II, is unexceptionable.
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
15. As aforesaid, the High Court overturned this finding
of the trial court on the question of nature of offence, by
mainly observing that the appellant had caused
repeated blows with a weapon like knife, causing six
serious injuries to Hitesh Thakur to which he
succumbed. We are of the opinion that neither the
factum of use of knife by the appellant during the
assault nor the multiple blows (six) given by the
appellant can be the sole basis to deny the appellant of
the benefit available under Exception 4 to
Section 300 IPC. The Court is obliged to take an
overall view of the matter on the basis of the
established facts. This principle is restated in Surain
Singh case [Surain Singh v. State of Punjab, (2017) 5
SCC 796 : (2017) 3 SCC (Cri) 461].
33.
(emphasis supplied)
When the evidence in the present case is evaluated on the touchstone
of above noted settled principles, several significant features emerge:
(a)
The entire genesis of the incident was an exceedingly trivial dispute
concerning the pushing of a pet dog, which took place in a congested
jhuggi cluster where the parties were immediate neighbour residing
merely 10 to 15 meters apart;
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
(b)
There was no history of prior enmity or animosity between the
Appellant and the deceased, inasmuch as in her cross-examination
PW-2 Smt. Krishna Wati candidly admitted that no quarrel had ever
taken place prior to that morning;
(c)
The initial altercation occurred between the elderly parents of the
Appellant and the deceased, and the Appellant was not even an initial
participant in the dispute;
(d)
The entire incident from the exchange of words to the assault
transpired in a rapid sequence within 2-3 minutes;
(e)
It seems upon hearing his father being insulted in the course of the
quarrel, the Appellant reacted impulsively in a fit of anger, uttering
"abhi maja chakhata hoon", went into his adjacent jhuggi, brought out
a domestic axe, and inflicted a single blow on the deceased;
(f)
Significantly, the Appellant inflicted only one single blow, he did not
attempt to repeat the strike, nor did he persist in assaulting the
deceased after the latter fell to the ground; and thereafter he
immediately fled from the spot; and
(g)
The weapon was a domestic tool readily accessible in the household
of a jhuggi dweller. Moreover, the deceased did not die
instantaneously, but survived for nearly two days and succumbed in
the hospital on 08th April, 2019.
34.
The above enumerated circumstances demonstrate that the occurrence
was sudden and not premeditated, arising out of a sudden quarrel in the heat
of passion. A single blow and the immediate cessation of the assault repels
the inference of a deliberate intention to cause death or of causing such
bodily injury as is likely to cause death. However, in the opinion of this
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
Court, the Appellant acted with a knowledge that striking the deceased on
the head with an axe was likely to cause death. Clearly, the Appellant did
not even take undue advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner.
35.
The mere utterance of words such as "abhi maja chakhata hoon" in
the heat of an ongoing altercation cannot be elevated to an intention to
commit murder. Reference in this regard may be had to the decision of a Coordinate Bench of this Court in Jagraj Singh v. State of Delhi, 2019 SCC
OnLine Del 7922, which dealt with an identical utterance made during a
sudden quarrel. Extending the benefit of Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC, the
Division Bench observed as follows:
"31. The above circumstances demonstrate that the
appellant had not taken undue advantage of the
situation or acted in a cruel or an unusual manner for
being deprived of the benefit available under Exception
4 to Section 300 IPC. It was an unpremeditated incident
arising from a sudden accident. The use of the words
"Mein tumhein abhi maja chakhata hun" by the
appellant at the time of the incident also goes to show
that he did not have any intention to kill the deceased,
but to assault him. We are therefore of the opinion that
considering the totality of the circumstances, the benefit
of Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC ought to be extended
to the appellant. Our view is also fortified by a string of
decisions of the Supreme Court in circumstances where
Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC has been applied and
the offence against the appellant in the said case, was
converted from capital offence to a lesser offence i.e.,
culpable homicide not amounting to murder, as noted
above."
(emphasis supplied)
36.
The case thus, squarely satisfies all the requirements of Exception 4 to
Section 300 IPC, thereby reducing the gravity of offence from ‘murder’ to
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
‘culpable homicide not amounting to murder’ punishable under Section 304
Part II IPC.
37.
Insofar as the conviction under Section 174-A IPC is concerned, no
argument was put forth on behalf of the Appellant.
The punishment
awarded for the same was for one year, which the Appellant has already
served.
38.
The next question that arises for consideration is the quantum of
sentence to be awarded to the Appellant under Section 304 Part II IPC. The
maximum sentence prescribed under Section 304 Part II IPC is
imprisonment for a term which may extend to ten years, but no minimum
sentence is stipulated therefor.
39.
A perusal of the latest Nominal Roll indicates that as on 21st October,
2025, the Appellant has undergone an actual sentence of 5 years and 17 days
besides earning remission of 3 months and 25 days. Thus, as on date, taking
into account the time that has elapsed since the issuance of the Nominal
Roll, the Appellant has undergone nearly 06 years of actual incarceration,
besides remission.
40.
The nominal Roll further depicts that the Appellant is not involved in
any other criminal case, his jail conduct has been satisfactory, and he has
been working as a “Sahayak” in jail.
41.
In Sanjay Singh (supra), where the appellant had similarly inflicted
fatal blows in a sudden quarrel without premeditation and had undergone
actual incarceration for over 5 years and 6 months, a Co-ordinate Bench of
this Court deemed it fit to modify the sentence to rigorous imprisonment for
a period of 8 years. While in Mukesh (supra) this Court restricted the
sentence to the period already undergone. The said sentence was granted
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
specifically because the Appellant therein had already served more than 10
years, which constitutes the maximum punishment prescribed under Section
304 Part II IPC.
42.
Having regard to the totality of facts and circumstances, the nature of
the weapon used, the single blow delivered in a sudden heat of passion over
a trivial dispute, the clean antecedents of the Appellant, we are of the view
that the ends of justice would be adequately met by modifying the sentence
from imprisonment for life to rigorous imprisonment for a period of 08
years.
43.
Consequently, the appeal is partly allowed in the following terms:
(i)
The conviction of the Appellant under Section 302 IPC is
altered to a conviction under Section 304 Part II IPC.
(ii)
The sentence of rigorous imprisonment for life awarded
by the Ld. Trial Court under Section 302 IPC is modified
and reduced to the period of 08 years.
(iii)
The fine of Rs. 10,000/- imposed under Section 302 IPC is
maintained under Section 304 Part II IPC, and in default
of payment of fine, the Appellant shall undergo simple
imprisonment for one month.
(iv)
The conviction and sentence of simple imprisonment for
one year along with a fine of Rs. 2,000/- under Section
174-A IPC stands affirmed, and having been directed to
run concurrently, stands already served.
(v)
The direction issued by the Ld. Trial Court referring the
matter to DLSA (East) for grant of suitable compensation
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
to the legal heirs of the deceased under the Delhi Victim
Compensation Scheme, 2018 shall remain undisturbed.
44.
The appeal, along with any pending applications, stands disposed of
accordingly.
45.
A copy of this judgment be transmitted forthwith to the
Superintendent of Prison, for necessary information and immediate
compliance.
46.
The judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court forthwith.
VIKAS MAHAJAN
JUDGE
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER 2, 2026
nsa
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
20:41:14
CRL.A. 1032/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review